Murine T-cell-mediated cytotoxicity against syngeneic and allogeneic cell lines induced by fetal calf serum

Mouse spleen cells from normal animals developed easily measurable cytotoxicity against various cell lines when cultured in vitro without deliberate sensitization. Cytotoxicity, measured by a 3-hr ⁵¹Cr-release assay, was maximum on Days 3 and 4 of culture and was dependent on the presence of fetal calf serum. Neither cell recovery nor blastogenesis, however, invariably correlated with the amount of cytotoxicity generated. Nylon wool adsorption of effector cells cultured 3 days had only a marginal effect on cytotoxicity, whereas cytolysis was markedly reduced (but not totally eliminated) by treatment with anti-T-cell serum and complement. When target cells were in relative excess to effector cells, ⁵¹Cr release was proportional to effector cell number and proceeded for at least 22 hr. The cytotoxicity was not tumor or H-2 specific, and targets without known C-type viral antigens (gp71) were killed as readily as those with easily measurable viral antigens. Nontumorigenic fibroblasts were lysed, but concanavalin A-induced blast cells were not. Cytotoxicity was not augmented in cultures of spleen cells from mice injected with fetal calf serum or with tumor fragments exposed to fetal calf serum. Mercaptoethanol was not necessary for the generation of cytotoxic activity, but T cells and Sephadex G-10 or nylon wool-adherent cells were necessary and the function of the adherent cell could not be replaced by mercaptoethanol. Removal of plastic adherent cells had no effect. Fetal calf serum retained its activity when heated for 45 min at 56 °C or when dialyzed. Dilution and reconcentration by Amicon filtration revealed that the mass of the active material was between 30,000 and 100,000 daltons.The early appearance, transient nature, and nonspecificity of this cytotoxicity distinguish it from antigen-specific reactions. The effector's stability at 37 °C and its relatively easily detectable T-cell markers distinguish it from natural killer and cytotoxic cells. This activity is like lectin-induced cytotoxicity but differs because allogeneic blast cells are not lysed. The observed cytotoxic activity may be of in vivo relevance (vis-à-vis natural killer cells) or, more likely, an in vitro expression of a stage of cell differentiation that T cells may normally pass through during their response to antigen.     

In vitro expression of cytotoxicity by macrophages is independent of the actual serum concentration.

In utilizing the same effector and target cells, similar arrangement and population density of cells but varying the actual serum concentration in the range between 1 and 50% fetal calf serum, it was attempted to accurately assess the dependence of in vitro cytolysis expressed by adherent, predominantly phagocytic mononuclear cells ('macrophages') on the actual serum concentration. The results show that the extent to which cytotoxicity by activated macrophages against a given target cell type was expressed, was within a comparable range independent of the actual serum concentration. This holds true for each of the 9 target cell lines examined although with some of the cell lines there was a certain tendency towards high cytotoxicity in the range between 5 and 20% serum.     

Characterization of culture-induced cytotoxicity from human peripheral lymphocyte subpopulations

Cultured human lymphocyte subpopulations can generate cytotoxicity against K562 leukemia target cells under certain conditions. Such cytotoxicity arises during mixed leukocyte culture or in medium containing fetal calf serum (FCS), mitogenic factors, or interleukin 2. We cultured peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) in FCS-containing medium after fractionation of these cells on a Percoll discontinuous density gradient. Higher density cell fractions generated culture-induced spontaneous cytotoxicity (CIC) after 2-3 days in culture. CIC was not due to a loss of suppressor cells during fractionation since culture of PBL prior to fractionation yielded the same results. At least some CIC was associated with the differentiation of higher density cells to newly appearing lower density cells during culture. Most CIC required cells with the HNK-1- OKT3- OKM1+ phenotype. Culture-induced cytotoxicity has some similarities to the previously described lymphokine-activated killing but some important differences are also discussed.     

Induction of lymphokine-activated killer cells from rat thymocytes using recombinant human interleukin-2

Summary Using a 4-h ⁵¹Cr release assay, we observed that thymocytes from Fischer strain rats incubated with recombinant human interleukin-2 (rhIL-2) developed cytotoxicity to YAC-1 lymphoma, 9L-glioma, and B-16 melanoma cells (effector/target ratio =25/1). Induction of the lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells was as follows: (1) when 5×10⁶/ml thymocytes were cultured with various concentrations of rhIL-2 (50, 125, 250, 500, or 1,000 units/ml) for 4 days, no cell proliferation was observed at any concentration. However, the LAK cells showed significant cytotoxicity toward all tumor cells at more than 50 units/ml. (2) When 5×10⁶/ml thymocytes were cultured for 1 to 6 days with 250 units/ml of rhIL-2, the harvested cell count decreased markedly after the 2nd day. The cytotoxicity of all the tumor cells became significant after the 2nd day, with peak activity on the 4th day. In rat splenocytes, on the other hand, the LAK cells could not be identified because rat splenocytes developed nonspecific cytotoxicity in medium containing fetal calf serum without adding rhIL-2.     

Cell spreading factor. Occurrence and specificity of action.

A factor required for spreading of substratum-attached baby hamster kidney cells (BHK), Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells, HeLa cells, and L cells has been isolated and purified from fetal calf serum. A similar factor has also been found in calf, porcine, human, rabbit, and chicken sera. The spreading factor was active when adsorbed to the substratum and prior adsorption of other proteins prevented cell spreading, regardless of the addition of spreading factor or unfractionated serum to the incubation medium. Antibody against the fetal calf spreading factor inhibited the spreading activity associated with unfractionated fetal calf serum and also the spreading activity associated with calf serum and porcine serum. In model system studies it was found that antibody against BHK cell surfaces induced cell spreading when the antibody was adsorbed to the substratum; when it was present in the incubation medium as well as on the substratum, cell spreading was not observed. The data are discussed in terms of the hypothesis that there is a specific serum factor which adsorbs to the substratum surface and is thereby activated, and which then forms the target for certain cell surface receptors. Interaction between adsorbed-activated factor and cell surface receptors leads to cell spreading.     

The use of cryopreserved lymphocytes for measuring cell-mediated immunity to allo-antigens in dogs by a microcytotoxicity assay

Lymphocyte — mediated cytotoxicity of frozen stored cells against target allogeneic fibroblasts was compared to that of freshly prepared lymphocytes in a microcytotoxicity assay. Peripheral blood lymphocytes obtained from alloimmune dogs were suspended in cold pooled dog serum containing 10% dimethyl sulfoxide, slowly cooled in a GV Planer R 201 programmed freezer and stored in liquid nitrogen vapor. On the day of testing, cell suspensions were rapidly thawed, dimethyl sulfoxide was diluted out of the sample, and the cells were suspended in culture medium containing 20% fetal calf serum. Cytotoxic activity of cryopreserved lymphocytes was only slightly affected by the freezing procedure.     

A study on the blunted natural killer cell activity in severely depressed patients.

Recently, some investigators have established a blunted natural killer cell activity (NKCA) in severely depressed patients. In order to replicate these findings NKC cytotoxicity assays--on fresh cell suspensions in human plasma and fetal calf serum--were performed in healthy controls and depressed inpatients. Instead of the commonly used 51Cr-release assay we have used a fluorescent NKC cytotoxicity assay, which allows a greater sensitivity. We observed a significantly blunted NKCA in melancholic patients as compared with healthy controls and minor depressives, whilst simple major depressives exhibited an intermediate position. NKC cytotoxicity assays in fetal calf serum were significantly and negatively correlated with the severity of illness. We were unable to establish any relationship between NKCA and measures of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal-axis function, such as baseline, postdexamethasone plasma cortisol and 24 hr urinary cortisol secretion. In addition, we did not find any effects of dexamethasone administration (1 mg orally) on NKCA.     

Serum effects on the response of mammalian cells to the exotoxins of Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Corynebacterium diphtheriae.

The response of mammalian cells to Pseudomonas and diphtheria exotoxins was studied. A method was developed whereby the sensitivity of cells to these two toxins could be quantitated. The method is versatile and can be used to study the effects of toxins on many cellular metabolic or transport processes. The type of serum used in the culture medium significantly influenced the response of cells to the toxins. Calf, horse, and human sera protected cells while fetal calf serum did not. Precipitation with (NH4)2SO4 demonstrated the probable presence of toxin-specific antibody in the protective calf serum while none was detected in the nonprotective fetal calf serum. The level of antibody in calf serum, as titrated by hemagglutination, was sufficient to account for all the observed protection. It is suggested that fetal calf serum be used for all future cell culture studies of bacterial toxins.     

Demonstration of the specificity of a monkey antiserum against human melanoma

Summary The reactivity spectrum of a monkey antiserum raised against in vitro-cultured human melanoma cells was compared by means of three different assays: complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC), antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) and mixed hemadsorption (MHA). After absorption with a pool of cells from T- and B-lymphoid cell lines the antiserum was specifically cytotoxic in CDC for cultured melanoma cells. The melanoma specificity of the antiserum was confirmed by quantitative absorption experiments with cultured melanoma and nonmelanoma cells. When the lymphoid cell-absorbed antiserum was assayed by MHA, however, a high reactivity against both melanoma and nonmelanoma cells was observed. Further absorption with nonmelanoma tumor cells removed the reactivity of the antiserum with different nonmelanoma cell lines, but did not abolish its reactivity with melanoma cells. After this second absorption, the antiserum remained cytolytic against melanoma cells in CDC. In ADCC experiments this antiserum was not able to induce any cytotoxicity even before absorption.Analysis of Sephadex G 200 fractions of the antiserum revealed that the melanoma-specific antibodies cytotoxic in CDC were localized exclusively in the IgM peak. This finding was confirmed in similar studies with four other nonhuman primate melanoma antisera. Abbreviations used in this paper: CDC, complement dependent cytotoxicity: ADCC, antibody dependent cell mediated cytotoxicity; MHA, mixed hemadsorption; FCS, fetal calf serum.     

Polyamine cytotoxicity in the presence of bovine serum amine oxidase

The toxicity of extracellular spermine, determined in the presence of fetal calf serum, was studied using three cell lines: FM3A, L1210, and NIH3T3 cells. Amine oxidase in fetal calf serum produces aminodialdehyde generating acrolein spontaneously, H(2)O(2), and ammonia from spermine. Spermine toxicity was prevented by aldehyde dehydrogenase, but not by catalase. Similar concentrations of spermine and acrolein were needed to produce toxicity. Other aldehydes (formaldehyde, acetaldehyde, and propionaldehyde) and hydrogen peroxide were less toxic than acrolein. Spermidine and 3-aminopropanal, which produces acrolein, also exhibited severe cytotoxicity. The degree of cytotoxicity of spermine, spermidine, and 3-aminopropanal was nearly parallel with the amount of acrolein produced from each compound. Thus, it was deduced that acrolein is a major toxic compound produced from polyamines (spermine and spermidine) by amine oxidase.     

Suppression of cell-mediated tumor cell lysis and complement-induced cytotoxicity by trypan blue.

Different forms of cell-mediated cytotoxicity were suppressed in the presence of trypan blue. The systems affected included lysis of antibody-coated tumor cells by normal and C. parvum-stimulated mouse peritoneal cells and lysis of allogeneic targets by immune effector cells. The inhibition, measured in a 4-hr 51Cr release assay, was reversible and did not occur in the presence of 30% fetal calf serum or albumin. Binding between effector and target cells through Fc receptors was not affected, and lysis of allogeneic cells was inhibited at the lytic step rather than at the binding step. In contrast, lysis of sensitized erythrocytes was not inhibited by trypan blue, suggesting that lysis of these targets may not involve the steps required in tumor cell lysis. Trypan blue blocked the function of antibody before binding to target cells and also suppressed complement-induced cytolysis. Most individual complement components were susceptible to the inhibitory action of trypan blue. These results reveal an affinity of trypan blue for proteins in general that may be responsible for many of its biologic actions.     

Fractionation, morphological and functional characterization of effector cells responsible for human natural killer activity against cell-line targets

Human natural killer cells cytotoxic against cell-line target cells (NK-CLT) were isolated and characterized by utilizing adsorption-elution of the effector cells from the K-562 target cells. The cell associated with the cytotoxicity was a large lymphocyte with pale and characteristically granular cytoplasm. Thus, its morphology was identical with that of the large granular lymphocyte (LGL) previously shown to be the principal cytotoxic NK cell against fetal fibroblasts (NK-FF). The association of LGL with natural killer activity was verified with contact analysis from mixtures of unfractionated effector cells and target cells, which revealed that the number of contact of LGL with K-562 was correlated to the level of the individually expressed intensity of natural cytotoxicity. The ANAE-staining distribution of LGL was intensively positive with granular or diffuse staining pattern. In direct surface marker analysis LGL were E-rosette forming but, in contrast to NK-FF, heterogenous in regard to the Fc receptors. During in vitro incubation after elution from the target cells, the cytotoxic activity of LGL increased several fold. Also, the presence of K-562 among unfractionated effector cells caused an augmentation of cytotoxicity. This phenomenon was not observed as a result of effector cell-fetal fibroblast coculturing. Evidence from fetal fibroblast adsorption-elution and aggregated IgG blocking experiments suggested that the LGL with strong expression of Fc receptors were initially cytotoxic “mature” NK-cells, whereas the LGL with a weak expression of Fc receptors were initially noncytotoxic, but contact with K-562 “augmented” or “recruited” them to nonselective cytotoxicity.     

The effect of progesterone on hemoglobin synthesis in suspension cultures of fetal erythroid cells from calf liver

When fetal calf liver erythroid cells were incubated in the presence of small amounts of progesterone (10(-7)-10(-8) M), the hemoglobin synthesis in these cells was significantly increased. The increase in the amount of radioactivity in de novo synthesized hemoglobins could be demonstrated when techniques such as isoelectric focusing, chromatography on DEAE-cellulose and gel chromatography on Sephadex G-100 were used to isolate the hemoglobin fraction. Using the latter technique, it was shown that the synthesis of cytoplasmic non-hemoglobin proteins in erythroid-cell lysates was also stimulated by progesterone. The presence of hepatocytes in culture nullified the hormone action. It was necessary that progesterone was present during the first hours of culture. Delayed addition of the steroid to the cells had no effect on hemoglobin synthesis. Erythropoietin was necessary to obtain stimulation by progesterone. These results suggest that the target cell of the hormone is an erythropoietin-sensitive cell. High concentrations of progesterone (10(-4) M) strongly inhibited hemoglobin synthesis in fetal calf erythroid cells. Culture of cells under this condition, however, gives rise to a cell population that preferentially synthesizes adult hemoglobin. Our results suggest that in the erythropoietic calf liver, high concentrations of progesterone may preferentially stimulate adult hemoglobin synthesis, or that those cells which have a high capacity to synthesize adult hemoglobins are less sensitive to toxic concentrations of the hormone. The effects of stimulation of hemoglobin synthesis in fetal calf erythroid cells occur at hormone concentrations that suggest a possible physiological role of progesterone in fetal, and eventually also in maternal, erythropoiesis.     

Differential cytotoxicity of activated lymphocytes on allogeneic and xenogeneic target cells. I. Activation by tuberculin and by Staphylococcus filtrate

Normal lymphocytes activated by mitogens such as phytohemagglutinin (PHA), by Staphylococcus filtrate (SF), or lymphocytes from sensitized individuals stimulated by antigen (PPD, etc.) are cytotoxic to tissue culture cells of different origins. In this and the following paper, the results of a detailed quantitative analysis of the specificity of this cytotoxic reaction are presented. Effector cells were human or mouse lymphocytes, activated by PHA, SF, PPD, or serum factors in the culture medium. Cells from established cell lines of human, mouse, hamster, or rabbit origin, or primary human or rat embryonic fibroblasts were used as target cells. Lysis was quantitated by release of ⁵¹Cr from labeled target cells.Purified human blood lymphocytes, activated by PPD, SF, or otherwise, preferentially damaged allogeneic target cells. Lysis of xenogeneic target cells was weak or did not occur. A close correlation was noted between target cell destruction and blastoid transformation of the lymphocytes, but the slope of the regression lines of xenogeneic cytotoxicity was much smaller than that of allogeneic cytotoxicity when plotted as a function of blastoid transformation.Lymph node or spleen cells from CBA mice were stimulated by PPD to transformation and DNA synthesis. CBA lymphocytes also showed an increased degree of blast transformation in medium containing fetal calf serum or certain batches of fresh human serum. Mouse lymphocytes activated in these ways damaged allogeneic L cells but had no effects on xenogeneic Chang cells.These results indicate that lymphocytes activated by various means preferentially damage target cells from their own species. The recognition mechanisms which determine the specificity of the reactions are not known.     

Revertants of a Chinese hamster ovary cell mutant resistant to suppression by an analogue of cholesterol: isolation and partial biochemical characterization

A highly efficient selection procedure was developed for isolating revertants of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell mutants resistant to suppression by 25-hydroxy-cholesterol. The procedure is based on the fact that the specific polyene antibiotic amphotericin B caused a lethal porous complex formation with membrane cholesterol only in cholesterol-rich cells. The wild-type cells and the revertant cells switched to grow from fetal calf serum medium to delipidated fetal calf serum medium for approximately 1 day became deficient in cellular cholesterol content. These cells, unlike the cholesterol-rich mutant cells, became much less sensitive to amphotericin B cytotoxicity. The spontaneous reversion frequency of a previously reported 25-hydroxycholesterol-resistant cell clone, 25-RA [Chang, T.-Y., & Limanek, J.S. (1980) J. Biol. Chem. 255, 7787-7795], was found to be approximately 3 X 10(-6), a frequency comparable to other single gene mutations of CHO cells. Biochemical analyses of three of these revertants showed that all defects manifested in 25-RA cells reverted back in parallel, a result suggesting that these observed defects in 25-RA cells are due to a single mutation event, thus supporting the hypothesis (Chang & Limanek, 1980) that a common controlling factor may be involved in mediating the suppressive action(s) of the cholesterol analogue on various cholesterogenic enzyme activities. The function of this common controlling factor is rendered abnormal in 25-RA cells by mutation.     

Time-dependent differential effects of natural and recombinant murine interferon-gamma on ornithine decarboxylase activity of tumor cells

Incubation of quiescent tumor cells with fetal calf serum induced ornithine decarboxylase (ODCase) activity concomitantly with mitogenic stimulation. Pretreatment of cells with highly purified natural or recombinant murine interferon-gamma (MuIFN-gamma) for 5 h caused a dose-dependent increase of ODCase activity induced by fetal calf serum (FCS). Pretreatment of target cells with IFN-gamma for 5 h in absence of FCS stimulation did not induce ODCase activity. When pretreatment of cells with natural or recombinant MuIFN-gamma was prolonged for 18 h both ODCase activity and DNA synthesis induced by FCS were suppressed. By contrast when a mixture of MuIFN-alpha and -beta was used, ODCase activity was significantly suppressed after 5 h pretreatment compared to untreated controls. These results suggest that IFN-gamma exerts a differential effect on mitogen-stimulated events depending on the dose and the time of addition.     

Announcements

Human peripheral blood monocytes were reproducibly shown to lyse a variety of tumor cells in a 3- to 4-hr ⁵¹Cr release assay. Ficoll-Hypaque-purified mononuclear cells were suspended in medium supplemented with either 10% autologous serum or fetal calf serum (PCS). With either serum, highly purified (97–99%) and viable (>99%) monocyte suspensions were obtained by EDTA-reversible adherence to plastic surfaces which had been precoated with autologous serum. When used as effectors in cytotoxicity assays, the monocytes recovered from mononuclear cells suspended in FCS-supplemented medium exhibited higher cytolytic activity and were therefore used for further studies. Using FCS for both coating the plates and supplementing the suspension medium resulted in monocytes with low cytolytic activity. Tumor cell lysis measured by ⁵¹Cr release was detected within 2 hr of incubation and increased gradually with time. The level of lysis was dependent on the effector/target ratio and the tumor target cell employed. The involvement of natural killer lymphocytes in the observed tumoricidal activity was excluded. Detection of cytotoxic activity in a short-term assay will be very helpful in further studies of the mechanism of tumor cell killing by human monocytes since potential complicating effects of long-term in vitro cultivation will be minimized.     

Regulation of the cytotoxic effect of human ‘normal killer cells’ on tumor cell lines by neuraminidase-treated T-lymphocytes

Summary Subpopulations of peripheral blood lymhocytes (PBL) from healthy individuals were separated according to their capacity to form various rosettes and tested for their cytotoxic activity on cell lines of urinary bladder and breast carcinomas. The subpopulation exerting the highest natural cytotoxic activity was characterized by the presence of cell surface Fc-receptors and by the lack of receptors for sheep red blood cells and for C'3 on their surface. Treatment with vibrio cholera neuraminidase (VCN) increased the cytotoxicity of unseparated PBL to a level twice as high as that of untreated PBL. The attachment of T-lymphocytes to tumor monolayers was increased several fold after VCN-treatment, while the attachment of other lymphocyte subpopulations was not. Evidence is presented that the augmentation of the cytotoxicity of PBL following VCN-treatment results from the interaction of VCN-treated T-lymphocytes, attached to target cells, with normal killer cells. It is suggested that augmentation of the activity of killer cells by T-lymphocytes may play a role in antitumor defense mechanisms.Abbreviations CMC Cell-mediated cytolysis - E-rosettes Rosettes formed with sheep red blood cells - EA-rosettes Rosettes formed with red blood cells coated with antibody - EAC'-rosettes Rosettes formed with red blood cells coated with antibody and complement - FCS Heat inactivated fetal calf serum - PBL Peripheral blood lymphocytes - RBC Red blood cells - RF-TAL E-rosette forming, target-attached lymphocytes - SRBC Sheep red blood cells - VCN Vibrio cholera neuraminidase     

Modulation of albumin-like protein and lysozyme production by bovine tracheal gland serous cells. Dependence on culture conditions

Bovine tracheal submucosal gland serous cells were cultured in medium supplemented with either 10% fetal calf serum or 2% Ultroser G, a commercial serum substitute for cell culture. The proteins synthesized and secreted into the culture medium during [35S]methionine pulse, chase and isoproterenol-stimulated periods were analyzed. Marked differences in the patterns of secretory radiolabeled proteins with Mr values ranging from 15,000 to 95,000 were observed between pulse and chase media of cells cultured in fetal calf serum and Ultroser G. In the presence of Ultroser G, albumin-like protein production was inhibited 95% as compared to cultures incubated with fetal calf serum. A bovine lysozyme-type enzymatic activity was detected only in medium from stimulated cells cultured in Ultroser G. The results suggest that bovine tracheal serous cells synthesize different proteins according to the composition of culture medium and release certain proteins when adrenergically stimulated.     

Inhibition of cytolytic T lymphocyte maturation with ornithine, arginine, and putrescine

L-Ornithine was shown to inhibit the development of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC). Lymphokines were unable to reverse the suppressive effect, and cytotoxic activity was not revealed by coupling ornithine-inhibited MLC cells to target cells with phytohemagglutinin (PHA). If addition of ornithine to MLC were delayed, sensitivity of CTL to inhibition was reduced after 24 hr and lost by 48 hr. Suppression of CTL development was not due to a toxic effect. MLC washed free of ornithine after 3 days produced detectable cytolytic activity within 24 hr of secondary culture, and to the same degree as the uninhibited MLC control within 48 hr. Cytotoxic cells generated in secondary cultures were Lyt-2+, did not kill the natural killer-sensitive YAC-1 cell line, and were shown to be antigen-specific by virtue of the findings that cytolysis and cold target inhibition were observed only with cells carrying the original, inducing H-2 haplotype. Cytolysis of target cells by normal CTL effector cells was not inhibited by L-ornithine. MLC depleted of accessory cells so that CTL activation was dependent upon addition of lymphokines remained susceptible to inhibition by ornithine. Our findings indicate that in the ornithine-inhibited MLC, CTL precursors undergo clonal expansion, but their maturation is arrested at a precytolytic stage. L-Arginine and putrescine also suppressed generation of CTL in primary MLC, and cells recovered from arginine- and putrescine-inhibited MLC developed control levels of CTL within 48 hr of secondary culture. Inhibition by putrescine was observed in tissue culture medium supplemented with human serum but not with fetal calf serum, presumably due to the presence of diamine oxidase activity in fetal calf serum. Similar to ornithine, the suppressive effects of arginine and putrescine on T lymphocytes were apparently selective for CTL because they did not inhibit mitogen activation with concanavalin A or the production of interleukin 2 and interleukin 3. These findings are consistent with a hypothesis that the inhibitory effects of ornithine, arginine, and putrescine are mediated by polyamines, and exerted on the differentiative stage of CTL development.