Unusual thermal and conformational properties of the rhodopsin congenital night blindness mutant Thr-94 --> Ile

Naturally occurring point mutations in the opsin gene cause the retinal diseases retinitis pigmentosa and congenital night blindness. Although these diseases involve similar mutations in very close locations in rhodopsin, their progression is very different, with retinitis pigmentosa being severe and causing retinal degeneration. We report on the expression and characterization of the recently found T94I mutation associated with congenital night blindness, in the second transmembrane helix or rhodopsin, and mutations at the same site. T94I mutant rhodopsin folded properly and was able to bind 11-cis-retinal to form chromophore, but it showed a blue-shifted visible band at 478 nm and reduced molar extinction coefficient. Furthermore, T94I showed dramatically reduced thermal stability, extremely long lived metarhodopsin II intermediate, and highly increased reactivity toward hydroxylamine in the dark, when compared with wild type rhodopsin. The results are consistent with the location of Thr-94 in close proximity to Glu-113 counterion in the vicinity of the Schiff base linkage and suggest a role for this residue in maintaining the correct dark inactive conformation of the receptor. The reported results, together with previously published data on the other two known congenital night blindness mutants, suggest that the molecular mechanism underlying this disease may not be structural misfolding, as proposed for retinitis pigmentosa mutants, but abnormal functioning of the receptor by decreased thermal stability and/or constitutive activity.     

Crystal structure of a thermally stable rhodopsin mutant

We determined the structure of the rhodopsin mutant N2C/D282C expressed in mammalian cells; the first structure of a recombinantly produced G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR). The mutant was designed to form a disulfide bond between the N terminus and loop E3, which allows handling of opsin in detergent solution and increases thermal stability of rhodopsin by 10 deg.C. It allowed us to crystallize a fully deglycosylated rhodopsin (N2C/N15D/D282C). N15 mutations are normally misfolding and cause retinitis pigmentosa in humans. Microcrystallographic techniques and a 5 microm X-ray beam were used to collect data along a single needle measuring 5 microm x 5 microm x 90 microm. The disulfide introduces only minor changes but fixes the N-terminal cap over the beta-sheet lid covering the ligand-binding site, a likely explanation for the increased stability. This work allows structural investigation of rhodopsin mutants and shows the problems encountered during structure determination of GPCRs and other mammalian membrane proteins.     

Retinitis Pigmentosa Mutants Provide Insight into the Role of the N-terminal Cap in Rhodopsin Folding,Structure, and Function

Autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa (ADRP) mutants (T4K, N15S, T17M, V20G, P23A/H/L, and Q28H) in the N-terminal cap of rhodopsin misfold when expressed in mammalian cells. To gain insight into the causes of misfolding and to define the contributions of specific residues to receptor stability and function, we evaluated the responses of these mutants to 11-cis-retinal pharmacological chaperone rescue or disulfide bond-mediated repair. Pharmacological rescue restored folding in all mutants, but the purified mutant pigments in all cases were thermo-unstable and exhibited abnormal photobleaching, metarhodopsin II decay, and G protein activation. As a complementary approach, we superimposed this panel of ADRP mutants onto a rhodopsin background containing a juxtaposed cysteine pair (N2C/D282C) that forms a disulfide bond. This approach restored folding in T4K, N15S, V20G, P23A, and Q28H but not T17M, P23H, or P23L. ADRP mutant pigments obtained by disulfide bond repair exhibited enhanced stability, and some also displayed markedly improved photobleaching and signal transduction properties. Our major conclusion is that the N-terminal cap stabilizes opsin during biosynthesis and contributes to the dark-state stability of rhodopsin. Comparison of these two restorative approaches revealed that the correct position of the cap relative to the extracellular loops is also required for optimal photochemistry and efficient G protein activation.     

Stability of dark state rhodopsin is mediated by a conserved ion pair in intradiscal loop E-2

The rhodopsin crystal structure reveals that intradiscal loop E-2 covers the 11-cis-retinal, creating a "retinal plug." Recently, we noticed the ends of loop E-2 are linked by an ion pair between residues Arg-177 and Asp-190, near the highly conserved disulfide bond. This ion pair appears biologically significant; it is conserved in almost all vertebrate opsins and may occur in other G-protein-coupled receptors. We report here that the Arg-177/Asp-190 ion pair is critical for the folding and stability of dark state rhodopsin. We find ion pair mutants that regenerate with retinal are functionally and spectrally wild-type-like yet thermally unstable in their dark state because of rapid hydrolysis of the retinal Schiff base linkage. Surprisingly, Arrhenius analysis indicates that the activation energies for the hydrolysis process are similar between the ion pair mutants and wild-type rhodopsin. Furthermore, the ion pair mutants do not show increased reactivity toward hydroxylamine, suggesting that their instability is not caused by an increased exposure to bulk solvent. Our results indicate that the loop E-2 ion pair is important for rhodopsin stability and thus suggest that retinitis pigmentosa observed in patients with Asp-190 mutations may in part be the result of thermally unstable rhodopsin proteins.     

Thermal Stability of Rhodopsin and Progression of Retinitis Pigmentosa: COMPARISON OF S186W AND D190N RHODOPSIN MUTANTS

Over 100 point mutations in the rhodopsin gene have been associated with retinitis pigmentosa (RP), a family of inherited visual disorders. Among these, we focused on characterizing the S186W mutation. We compared the thermal properties of the S186W mutant with another RP-causing mutant, D190N, and with WT rhodopsin. To assess thermal stability, we measured the rate of two thermal reactions contributing to the thermal decay of rhodopsin as follows: thermal isomerization of 11-cis-retinal and hydrolysis of the protonated Schiff base linkage between the 11-cis-retinal chromophore and opsin protein. We used UV-visible spectroscopy and HPLC to examine the kinetics of these reactions at 37 and 55 °C for WT and mutant rhodopsin purified from HEK293 cells. Compared with WT rhodopsin and the D190N mutant, the S186W mutation dramatically increases the rates of both thermal isomerization and dark state hydrolysis of the Schiff base by 1–2 orders of magnitude. The results suggest that the S186W mutant thermally destabilizes rhodopsin by disrupting a hydrogen bond network at the receptor''s active site. The decrease in the thermal stability of dark state rhodopsin is likely to be associated with higher levels of dark noise that undermine the sensitivity of rhodopsin, potentially accounting for night blindness in the early stages of RP. Further studies of the thermal stability of additional pathogenic rhodopsin mutations in conjunction with clinical studies are expected to provide insight into the molecular mechanism of RP and test the correlation between rhodopsin''s thermal stability and RP progression in patients.     

Characterization of rhodopsin congenital night blindness mutant T94I

The Thr94 --> Ile mutation in the second transmembrane segment of rhodopsin has been reported to be associated with a congenital night blindness phenotype in a large Irish pedigree. Previously, two other known rhodopsin mutants that cause congenital night blindness, A292E and G90D, have been shown in vitro to constitutively activate the G protein transducin in the absence of a chromophore. The proposed mechanism of constitutive activation of these two mutants is an electrostatic disruption of the active site salt bridge between Glu113 and Lys296 that contributes to stabilization of the protein in the inactive state. Here, the T94I rhodopsin mutant is characterized and compared to the two other known rhodopsin night blindness mutants. The T94I mutant opsin is shown also to constitutively activate transducin. The T94I mutant pigment (with a bound 11-cis-retinal chromophore), like the other known rhodopsin night blindness mutants, is not active in the dark and has wild-type activity upon exposure to light. Similar to the Gly90 --> Asp substitution, position 94 is close enough to the Schiff base nitrogen that an Asp at this position can functionally substitute for the Glu113 counterion. However, in contrast to the other night blindness mutants, the T94I MII intermediate decays with a half-life that is approximately 8-fold slower than in the wild-type MII intermediate. Thus, the one phenotype shared by all congenital night blindness mutants that is different from the wild-type protein is constitutive activation of the apoprotein.     

Mutations at position 125 in transmembrane helix III of rhodopsin affect the structure and signalling of the receptor.

Mutation of L125R in trasmembrane helix III of rhodopsin, associated with the retinal degenerative disease retinitis pigmentosa, was previously shown to cause structural misfolding of the mutant protein. Also, conservative mutations at this position were found to cause partial misfolding of the mutant receptors. We report here on a series of mutations at position 125 to further investigate the role of Leu125 in the correct folding and function of rhodopsin. In particular, the effect of the size of the substituted amino-acid side chain in the functionality of the receptor, measured as the ability of the mutant rhodopsins to activate the G protein transducin, has been analysed. The following mutations have been studied: L125G, L125N, L125I, L125H, L125P, L125T, L125D, L125E, L125Y and L125W. Most of the mutant proteins, expressed in COS-1 cells, showed reduced 11-cis-retinal binding, red-shifts in the wavelength of the visible absorbance maximum, and increased reactivity towards hydroxylamine in the dark. Thermal stability in the dark was reduced, particularly for L125P, L125Y and L125W mutants. The ability of the mutant rhodopsins to activate the G protein transducin was significantly reduced in a size dependent manner, especially in the case of the bulkier L125Y and L125W substitutions, suggesting a steric effect of the substituted amino acid. On the basis of the present and previous results, Leu125 in transmembrane helix III of rhodopsin, in the vicinity of the beta-ionone ring of 11-cis-retinal, is proposed to be an important residue in maintaining the correct structure of the chromophore binding pocket. Thus, bulky substitutions at this position may affect the structure and signallling of the receptor by altering the optimal conformation of the retinal binding pocket, rather than by direct interaction with the chromophore, as seen from the recent crystallographic structure of rhodopsin.     

Critical role of transmembrane segment zinc binding in the structure and function of rhodopsin

Zinc deficiency and retinitis pigmentosa are both important factors resulting in retinal dysfunction and night blindness. In this study, we address the critical biochemical and structural relevance of zinc ions in rhodopsin and examine whether zinc deficiency can lead to rhodopsin dysfunction. We report the identification of a high-affinity zinc coordination site within the transmembrane domain of rhodopsin, coordinated by the side chains of two highly conserved residues, Glu(122) in transmembrane helix III and His(211) in transmembrane helix V. We also demonstrate that this zinc coordination is critical for rhodopsin folding, 11-cis-retinal binding, and the stability of the chromophore-receptor interaction, defects of which are observed in retinitis pigmentosa. Furthermore, a cluster of retinitis pigmentosa mutations is localized within and around this zinc binding site. Based on these studies, we believe that improvement in zinc binding to rhodopsin at this site within the transmembrane domain may be a pharmacological approach for the treatment of select retinitis pigmentosa mutations. Transmembrane coordination of zinc may also be an important common principle across G-protein-coupled receptors.     

Altered functionality in rhodopsin point mutants associated with retinitis pigmentosa

Point mutations found in rhodopsin associated with the retinal degenerative disease retinitis pigmentosa have been expressed in mammalian COS-1 cells, purified, and characterised. The mutations characterised-most of them for the first time-have been Met44Thr, Gly114Asp, Arg135Leu, Val137Met, and Pro171Leu in the transmembrane domain; Leu328Pro and Ala346Pro in the C-terminal tail of the cytoplasmic domain; and Gly106Trp in the intradiscal domain. Several of these mutations cause misfolding which results in impaired 11-cis-retinal binding. Two of them, Met44Thr and Val137Met, show spectral and structural features similar to those of wild type rhodopsin (Type I mutants) but significantly increased transducin initial activation rates. We propose that, in the case of these mutants, abnormal functioning resulting in faster activation kinetics could also play a role in retinitis pigmentosa by altering the stoichiometric balance of the different proteins involved in the phototransduction biochemical reactions.     

Structural, energetic, and mechanical perturbations in rhodopsin mutant that causes congenital stationary night blindness

Several point mutations in rhodopsin cause retinal diseases including congenital stationary night blindness and retinitis pigmentosa. The mechanism by which a single amino acid residue substitution leads to dysfunction is poorly understood at the molecular level. A G90D point mutation in rhodopsin causes constitutive activity and leads to congenital stationary night blindness. It is unclear which perturbations the mutation introduces and how they can cause the receptor to be constitutively active. To reveal insight into these mechanisms, we characterized the perturbations introduced into dark state G90D rhodopsin from a transgenic mouse model expressing exclusively the mutant rhodopsin in rod photoreceptor cells. UV-visible absorbance spectroscopy revealed hydroxylamine accessibility to the chromophore-binding pocket of dark state G90D rhodopsin, which is not detected in dark state wild-type rhodopsin but is detected in light-activated wild-type rhodopsin. Single-molecule force spectroscopy suggested that the structural changes introduced by the mutation are small. Dynamic single-molecule force spectroscopy revealed that, compared with dark state wild-type rhodopsin, the G90D mutation decreased energetic stability and increased mechanical rigidity of most structural regions in the dark state mutant receptor. The observed structural, energetic, and mechanical changes in dark state G90D rhodopsin provide insights into the nature of perturbations caused by a pathological point mutation. Moreover, these changed properties observed for dark state G90D rhodopsin are consistent with properties expected for an active state.     

Slow binding of retinal to rhodopsin mutants G90D and T94D

In an examination of the effect of three rhodopsin night blindness mutations on the rate of association of 11-cis-retinal with opsin, one of the mutations (G90D) was found to slow the rate of reaction by more than 80-fold. This effect does not appear to be general to night blindness mutations as the two other mutants (A292E and T94I) were not found to bind retinal with slowed kinetics. However, T94D was similar to G90D in that the rate of retinal binding was dramatically slowed. Gly90 and Thr94 are both located in the active site of the protein close to the Schiff base counterion Glu113. Thus, the slow kinetics of Schiff base formation appear to correlate with the introduction of a negative charge close to the Schiff base counterion, suggesting a possible role for Glu113 as a catalytic base in this reaction. Consistent with this model, the E113Q mutant was also found to bind retinal more slowly than the wild type.     

Alterations in the photoactivation pathway of rhodopsin mutants associated with retinitis pigmentosa

The visual photoreceptor rhodopsin undergoes a series of conformational changes upon light activation, eventually leading to the active metarhodopsin II conformation, which is able to bind and activate the G-protein, transducin. We have previously shown that mutant rhodopsins G51V and G89D, associated with retinitis pigmentosa, present photobleaching patterns characterized by the formation of altered photointermediates whose nature remained obscure. Our current detailed UV-visible spectroscopic analysis, together with functional characterization, indicate that these mutations influence the relative stability of the different metarhodopsin photointermediates by altering their equilibria and maintaining the receptor in a nonfunctional light-induced conformation that may be toxic to photoreceptor cells. We propose that G51V and G89D shift the equilibrium from metarhodopsin I towards an intermediate, recently named as metarhodopsin Ib, proposed to interact with transducin without activating it. This may be one of the causes contributing to the molecular mechanisms underlying cell death associated with some retinitis pigmentosa mutations.     

Insights into congenital stationary night blindness based on the structure of G90D rhodopsin

We present active‐state structures of the G protein‐coupled receptor (GPCRs) rhodopsin carrying the disease‐causing mutation G90D. Mutations of G90 cause either retinitis pigmentosa (RP) or congenital stationary night blindness (CSNB), a milder, non‐progressive form of RP. Our analysis shows that the CSNB‐causing G90D mutation introduces a salt bridge with K296. The mutant thus interferes with the E113Q‐K296 activation switch and the covalent binding of the inverse agonist 11‐cis‐retinal, two interactions that are crucial for the deactivation of rhodopsin. Other mutations, including G90V causing RP, cannot promote similar interactions. We discuss our findings in context of a model in which CSNB is caused by constitutive activation of the visual signalling cascade.     

Retinitis pigmentosa rhodopsin mutations L125R and A164V perturb critical interhelical interactions: new insights through compensatory mutations and crystal structure analysis

L125R, a severe retinitis pigmentosa rhodopsin missense mutation, results in rhodopsin protein misfolding, retinal degeneration, and ultimately blindness. The initiating structural events leading to this protein misfolding are unknown. Through the use of compensatory mutations, in conjunction with crystal structure-based molecular analysis, we established that the larger and positively charged Arg replacing Leu125 sterically hinders both the adjacent Trp126 and a critical interhelical interaction between transmembrane III (TM III) and transmembrane V (TM V; Glu122 and His211 salt bridge). Further, analysis of another retinitis pigmentosa mutation, A164V (TM IV), indicates that the larger Val interferes with residues Leu119 and Ile123 on TM III, leading to the disruption of the same critical Glu122-His211 salt bridge (TM III-TM V interaction). Combined, these localized defects in interhelical interactions cause structural changes that interfere with the ability of opsin to bind 11-cis-retinal. These distortions ultimately lead to the formation of an abnormal disulfide bond, severe protein instability, aggregation, and endoplasmic reticulum retention. In the absence of a crystal or NMR structure of each retinitis pigmentosa mutation, compensatory mutagenesis and crystal structure-based analysis are powerful tools in determining the localized molecular disturbances. A detailed understanding of the initiating local perturbations created by missense mutations such as these, not only identifies critical factors required for correct folding and stability, but additionally opens avenues for rational drug design, mimicking the compensatory mutations and stabilizing the protein.     

Constitutively active rhodopsin mutants causing night blindness are effectively phosphorylated by GRKs but differ in arrestin-1 binding

The effects of activating mutations associated with night blindness on the stoichiometry of rhodopsin interactions with G protein-coupled receptor kinase 1 (GRK1) and arrestin-1 have not been reported. Here we show that the monomeric form of WT rhodopsin and its constitutively active mutants M257Y, G90D, and T94I, reconstituted into HDL particles are effectively phosphorylated by GRK1, as well as two more ubiquitously expressed subtypes, GRK2 and GRK5. All versions of arrestin-1 tested (WT, pre-activated, and constitutively monomeric mutants) bind to monomeric rhodopsin and show the same selectivity for different functional forms of rhodopsin as in native disc membranes. Rhodopsin phosphorylation by GRK1 and GRK2 promotes arrestin-1 binding to a comparable extent, whereas similar phosphorylation by GRK5 is less effective, suggesting that not all phosphorylation sites on rhodopsin are equivalent in promoting arrestin-1 binding. The binding of WT arrestin-1 to phospho-opsin is comparable to the binding to its preferred target, P-Rh*, suggesting that in photoreceptors arrestin-1 only dissociates after opsin regeneration with 11-cis-retinal, which converts phospho-opsin into inactive phospho-rhodopsin that has lower affinity for arrestin-1. Reduced binding of arrestin-1 to the phospho-opsin form of G90D mutant likely contributes to night blindness caused by this mutation in humans.     

Structural and functional role of helices I and II in rhodopsin. A novel interplay evidenced by mutations at Gly-51 and Gly-89 in the transmembrane domain

The naturally occurring mutations G51A and G51V in transmembrane helix I and G89D in the transmembrane helix II of rhodopsin are associated with the retinal degenerative disease autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa. To probe the orientation and packing of helices I and II a number of replacements at positions 51 and 89 were prepared by using site-directed mutagenesis, and the corresponding proteins expressed in COS-1 cells were characterized. Mutations at position 51 (G51V and G51L) bound retinal like wild-type rhodopsin but had thermally destabilized structures in the dark, altered photobleaching behavior, destabilized metarhodopsin II active conformations, and were severely defective in signal transduction. The effects observed can be correlated with the size of the mutated side chains that would interfere with specific interhelical interaction with Val-300 in helix VII. Mutations at position 89 had sensitivity to charge, as in G89K and G89D mutants, which showed reduced transducin activation. G89K showed a second absorbing species in the UV region at 350 nm, suggesting a charge effect of the introduced lysine. Increased formation of non-active forms of rhodopsin, like metarhodopsin III, may have some influence in the molecular defect underlying retinitis pigmentosa in the mutants studied. At the structural level, the effect of the mutations analyzed can be rationalized assuming a very specific set of tertiary interactions in the interhelical packing of the transmembrane segments of rhodopsin.     

Electrostatic Compensation Restores Trafficking of the Autosomal Recessive Retinitis Pigmentosa E150K Opsin Mutant to the Plasma Membrane

Rhodopsin is the rod photoreceptor G protein-coupled receptor responsible for capturing light. Mutations in the gene encoding this protein can lead to a blinding disease called retinitis pigmentosa, which is inherited frequently in an autosomal dominant manner. The E150K opsin mutant associated with rarely occurring autosomal recessive retinitis pigmentosa localizes to trans-Golgi network membranes rather than to plasma membranes of rod photoreceptor cells. We investigated the molecular mechanisms underlying opsin retention in the Golgi apparatus. Electrostatic calculations reveal that the E150K mutant features an overall accumulation of positive charges between helices H-IV and H-II. Human E150K and several other closely related opsin mutants were then expressed in HEK-293 cells. Spectral characteristics and functional biochemistry of each mutant were analyzed after reconstitution with the cis-retinoid chromophore. UV-visible spectra and rhodopsin/transducin activation assays revealed only minor differences between the purified wild type control and rhodopsin mutants. However, partial restoration of the surface electrostatic charge in the compensatory R69E/E150K double mutant rescues the plasma membrane localization of opsin. These findings emphasize the fundamental importance of electrostatic interactions for appropriate membrane trafficking of opsin and advance our understanding of the pathophysiology of autosomal recessive retinitis pigmentosa due to the E150K mutation.     

Constitutively active mutants of rhodopsin.

Two critical amino acids in the visual pigment rhodopsin are Lys-296, the site of attachment of retinal to the protein through a protonated Schiff base linkage, and Glu-113, the Schiff base counterion. Mutation of Lys-296 or Glu-113 results in constitutive activation of opsin, as assayed by its ability to activate transducin in the absence of added chromophore. We conclude that opsin is constrained to an inactive conformation by a salt bridge between Lys-296 and Glu-113. Recently, one of the mutants, K296E, was found in a family with retinitis pigmentosa, suggesting that degeneration of the photoreceptor cells in individuals with this mutation may result from persistent stimulation of the phototransduction pathway.     

Retinoids assist the cellular folding of the autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa opsin mutant P23H

The clinically common mutant opsin P23H, associated with autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa, yields low levels of rhodopsin when retinal is added following induction of the protein in stably transfected HEK-293 cells. We previously showed that P23H rhodopsin levels could be increased by providing a 7-membered ring, locked analog of 11-cis-retinal during expression of P23H opsin in vivo. Here we demonstrate that the mutant opsin is effectively rescued by 9- or 11-cis-retinal, the native chromophore. When retinal was added during expression, P23H rhodopsin levels were 5-fold (9-cis) and 6-fold (11-cis) higher than when retinal was added after opsin was expressed and cells were harvested. Levels of P23H opsin were increased approximately 3.5-fold with both compounds, but wild-type protein levels were only slightly increased. Addition of retinal during induction promoted the Golgi-specific glycosylation of P23H opsin and transport of the protein to the cell surface. P23H rhodopsins containing 9- or 11-cis-retinal had blue-shifted absorption maxima and altered photo-bleaching properties compared with the corresponding wild-type proteins. Significantly, P23H rhodopsins were more thermally unstable than the wild-type proteins and more rapidly bleached by hydroxylamine in the dark. We suggest that P23H opsin is similarly unstable and that retinal binds and stabilizes the protein early in its biogenesis to promote its cellular folding and trafficking. The implications of this study for treating retinitis pigmentosa and other protein conformational disorders are discussed.     

Chemical kinetic analysis of thermal decay of rhodopsin reveals unusual energetics of thermal isomerization and hydrolysis of Schiff base

The thermal properties of rhodopsin, which set the threshold of our vision, have long been investigated, but the chemical kinetics of the thermal decay of rhodopsin has not been revealed in detail. To understand thermal decay quantitatively, we propose a kinetic model consisting of two pathways: 1) thermal isomerization of 11-cis-retinal followed by hydrolysis of Schiff base (SB) and 2) hydrolysis of SB in dark state rhodopsin followed by opsin-catalyzed isomerization of free 11-cis-retinal. We solve the kinetic model mathematically and use it to analyze kinetic data from four experiments that we designed to assay thermal decay, isomerization, hydrolysis of SB using dark state rhodopsin, and hydrolysis of SB using photoactivated rhodopsin. We apply the model to WT rhodopsin and E181Q and S186A mutants at 55 °C, as well as WT rhodopsin in H(2)O and D(2)O at 59 °C. The results show that the hydrogen-bonding network strongly restrains thermal isomerization but is less important in opsin and activated rhodopsin. Furthermore, the ability to obtain individual rate constants allows comparison of thermal processes under various conditions. Our kinetic model and experiments reveal two unusual energetic properties: the steep temperature dependence of the rates of thermal isomerization and SB hydrolysis in the dark state and a strong deuterium isotope effect on dark state SB hydrolysis. These findings can be applied to study pathogenic rhodopsin mutants and other visual pigments.