Structural differences between the repertoires of mouse and human germline genes and their evolutionary implications

 Although human and mouse antibodies are similar when one considers their diversification strategies, they differ in the extent to which kappa and lambda light chains are present in their respective variable light chain repertoires. While the Igk-V germline genes are preponderant in mice (95% or more), they comprise only 60% in humans. This may account for differences in the structural repertoire encoded in the Igk-V germline genes of these species. However, this subject has not been properly investigated, partially because a systematic structural characterization of the mouse Igk-V germline genes has not been undertaken. In the present study we compiled all available information on mouse Igk-V germline genes to characterize their structural repertoire. As expected, comparison with the structural repertoire of human Igk-V germline genes indicates differences. The most interesting is that the mouse Igk-V germline gene repertoire is more diverse in structural terms than its human counterpart: the mouse encodes seven canonical structure classes (combination of canonical structures in L1 and L3). In contrast, the human encodes only four. Analysis of the evolutionary relationships of human and mouse Igk-V germline genes led us to propose that the difference reflects a strategy of mice to compensate for the small lambda chain contribution to the repertoire of their variable light chains. Received: 1 June 1997 / Revised: 6 October 1997     

Analysis of the expressed heavy chain variable-region genes of Macaca fascicularis and isolation of monoclonal antibodies specific for the Ebola virus' soluble glycoprotein

The cynomolgus macaque, Macaca fascicularis, is frequently used in immunological and other biomedical research as a model for man; understanding it's antibody repertoire is, therefore, of fundamental interest. The expressed variable-region gene repertoire of a single M. fascicularis, which was immune to the Ebola virus, was studied. Using 5′ rapid amplification of cDNA ends with immunoglobulin (Ig)G-specific primers, we obtained 30 clones encoding full-length variable, diversity, and joining domains. Similar to the human V_H repertoire, the M. fascicularis repertoire utilized numerous immunoglobulin heavy variable (IGHV) gene fragments, with the V_H3 (41%), V_H4 (39%), and V_H1 (14%) subgroups used more frequently than the V_H5 (3.9%) or V_H7 (1.7%) subgroups. Diverse immunoglobulin heavy joining (IGHJ) fragments also appeared to be utilized, including a putative homolog of JH5β gene segment identified in the related species Macaca mulatta, Rhesus macaque, but not in humans. Although the diverse V region genes in the IgG antibody repertoire of M. fascicularis had likely undergone somatic hypermutations (SHMs), they nevertheless showed high nucleotide identity with the corresponding human germline genes, 80–89% for IGHV and 72–92% for IGHJ. M. fascicularis and human V_H genes were also similar in other aspects: length of complementarity-determining regions and framework regions, and distribution of consensus sites for SHMs. Finally, we demonstrated that monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) specific for an Ebola protein could be obtained from M. fascicularis tissue samples by phage display technology. In summary, the study provides new insight into the M. fascicularis V region gene repertoire and further supports the idea that macaque-derived mAbs may be of therapeutic value to humans.     

Vκ polymorphisms in NOD mice are spread throughout the entire immunoglobulin kappa locus and are shared by other autoimmune strains

The diversity of immunoglobulin (Ig) and T cell receptor (TCR) genes available to form the lymphocyte repertoire has the capacity to produce a broad array of both protective and harmful specificities. In type 1 diabetes (T1D), the presence of antibodies to insulin and other islet antigens predicts disease development in both mice and humans, and demonstrate that immune tolerance is lost early in the disease process. Anti-insulin T cells isolated from T1D-prone non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice use polymorphic TCRα chains, suggesting that the available T cell repertoire is altered in these autoimmune mice. To probe whether insulin-binding B cells also possess polymorphic V genes, Ig light chains were isolated and sequenced from NOD mice that harbor an Ig heavy chain transgene. Three insulin-binding Vκ genes were identified, all of which were polymorphic to the closest germline sequence matches present in the GenBank database. Additional analysis of over 300 light chain sequences from multiple sources, including germline DNA, shows that polymorphisms are spread throughout the entire NOD Igκ locus, as these polymorphic sequences represent 43 distinct Vκ genes which belong to 14 Vκ families. Database searches reveal that a majority of polymorphic Vκ genes identified in NOD are identical to Vκ genes isolated from SLE-prone NZBxNZW F1 or MRL strains of mice, suggesting that a shared Igκ haplotype may be present. Predicted amino acid changes preferentially occur in CDR, and thus could alter antigen recognition by the germline B cell repertoire of autoimmune versus non-autoimmune mouse strains.     

Analysis of human V H gene repertoire expression in peripheral CD19+ B cells

Using CD19 B-cell selection and polymerase chain reaction-amplified cDNA libraries, we analyzed the peripheral immunoglobulin heavy chain variable repertoire of three healthy adult donors. Here we report that most of the CD19+ circulating B cells expressed unmutated V _H-D-J_H rearrangements. By specific V _H family hybridization, we show that V _H gene family utilization in the periphery roughly corresponds to the complexity of these families in the germline and appears to be relatively constant among the analyzed subjects. However, sequence data of clones picked at random from one IgM cDNA library reveals that in spite of this random utilization, the V _H gene expression in naive circulating B cells is highly biased towards the expression of a limited set of V _H genes. As previously reported by others, this restricted mechanism is also found for the D and J _H segments.The nucleotide sequence data reported in this paper have been submitted to the GenBank/EMBL nucleotide sequence database and have been assigned the accession numbers Z47213-Z47243 and Z47349     

Efficient amplification of light and heavy chain variable regions and construction of a non-immune phage scFv library

Non-immune phage scFv library is one of the most attractive resources for therapeutics, diagnostics and basic research. As a matter of fact, quality of the library is limited by inefficient PCR cloning of antibody genes using degenerated primers. PCR using this type of primers is difficult to optimize conditions for efficient amplification, and therefore causes loss of antibody diversities. To overcome this problem, we described a novel two-step amplification of V_κ and V_H genes with newly designed primer sets. Initially, we amplified V_κ and V_H genes from their signal sequences to the joining region to keep antibody diversity as large as possible. Thereafter, highly degenerated primers were used to amplify the V_κ and V_H genes from the framework region 1 to the joining region. The V_κ and V_H genes from the second PCR then were linked by PCR overlapping extension to generate the scFv library. Fifteen clones from the library were randomly picked and sequenced, and the diversity of full-length scFvs was confirmed. Expression capability of clones in the library was 80% after confirmation using colony hybridization. The results demonstrated the efficiency of this strategy and the primer sets for construction of the scFv library.     

Human Immunoglobulin Repertoires against Tetanus Toxoid Contain a Large and Diverse Fraction of High-Affinity Promiscuous VH Genes

To study the contribution of antibody light (L) chains to the diversity and binding properties of immune repertoires, a phage display repertoire was constructed from a single human antibody L chain and a large collection of antibody heavy (H) chains harvested from the blood of two human donors immunized with tetanus toxoid (TT) vaccine. After selection for binding to TT, 129 unique antibodies representing 53 variable immunoglobulin H chain (V_H) gene rearrangements were isolated. This panel of anti-TT antibodies restricted to a single variable immunoglobulin L chain (V_L) could be organized into 17 groups binding non-competing epitopes on the TT molecule. Comparison of the V_H regions in this V_L-restricted panel with a previously published repertoire of anti-TT V_H regions with cognate V_H-V_L pairing showed a very similar distribution of V_H, D_H and J_H gene segment utilization and length of the complementarity-determining region 3 of the H chain. Surface plasmon resonance analysis of the single-V_L anti-TT repertoire unveiled a range of affinities, with a median monovalent affinity of 2 nM. When the single-V_L anti-TT V_H repertoire was combined with a collection of naïve V_L regions and again selected for binding to TT, many of the V_H genes were recovered in combination with a diversity of V_L regions. The affinities of a panel of antibodies consisting of a single promiscuous anti-TT V_H combined with 15 diverse V_L chains were determined and found to be identical to each other and to the original isolate restricted to a single-V_L chain. Based on previous estimates of the clonal size of the human anti-TT repertoire, we conclude that up to 25% of human anti-TT-encoding V_H regions from an immunized repertoire have promiscuous features. These V_H regions readily combine with a single antibody L chain to result in a large panel of anti-TT antibodies that conserve the expected epitope diversity, V_H region diversity and affinity of a natural repertoire.     

The remarkable flexibility of the human antibody repertoire; isolation of over one thousand different antibodies to a single protein, BLyS

It is well established that the humoral immune response can generate antibodies to many different antigens. The antibody diversity required to achieve this is believed to be substantial. However, the extent to which the immune repertoire can generate structural diversity against a single target antigen has never been addressed. Here, we have used phage display to demonstrate the extraordinary capacity of the human antibody repertoire. Over 1000 antibodies, all different in amino acid sequence, were generated to a single protein, B-lymphocyte stimulator (BLyS™ protein). This is a highly diverse panel of antibodies as exemplified by the extensive heavy and light chain germline usage: 42/49 functional heavy chain germlines and 19/33 V_λ and 13/35 V_κ light chain germlines were all represented in the panel of antibodies. Moreover, a high level of sequence diversity was observed in the V_H CDR3 domains of these antibodies, with 568 different amino acid sequences identified. Thus we have demonstrated that specific recognition of a single antigen can be achieved from many different VDJ combinations, illustrating the remarkable problem-solving ability of the human immune repertoire. When studied in a biochemical assay, around 500 (40%) of these antibodies inhibited the binding of BLyS to its receptors on B-cell lines. The most potent antibodies inhibited BLyS binding with sub-nanomolar IC₅₀ values and with sub-nanomolar affinities. Such antibodies provide excellent choices as candidates for the treatment of BLyS-associated autoimmune diseases.     

A yeast artificial chromosome contig spanning the mouse immunoglobulin kappa light chain locus

 A single contig spanning the entire mouse immunoglobulin kappa light chain (Igk) locus on chromosome 6 has been established using yeast and bacterial artificial chromosome clones. Detailed mapping of the Igk locus indicates that a member of the Igk-V2 gene family, located about 3.5 megabases upstream of the Igk-J-C complex, is the most distal functional Igk-V gene. Sequence analyses of Igk-V genes and anonymous DNA segments provide indications for internal duplications at the 5′ end of the Igk-V locus and identify the likely origin of Igk-V orphon gene clusters located elsewhere in the mouse genome. Received: 17 July 1996 / Revised: 2 September 1996     

Synthetic antibodies designed on natural sequence landscapes

We present a method for synthetic antibody library generation that combines the use of high-throughput immune repertoire analysis and a novel synthetic technology. The library design recapitulates positional amino acid frequencies observed in natural antibody repertoires. V-segment diversity in four heavy (V_H) and two kappa (V_κ) germlines was introduced based on the analysis of somatically hypermutated donor-derived repertoires. Complementarity-determining region 3 length and amino acid designs were based on aggregate frequencies of all V_H and V_κ sequences in the data set. The designed libraries were constructed through an adaptation of a novel gene synthesis technology that enables precise positional control of amino acid composition and incorporation frequencies. High-throughput pyrosequencing was used to monitor the fidelity of construction and characterize genetic diversity in the final 3.6 × 10¹⁰ transformants. The library exhibited Fab expression superior to currently reported synthetic approaches of equivalent diversity, with greater than 93% of clones observed to successfully display both a correctly folded heavy chain and a correctly folded light chain. Genetic diversity in the library was high, with 95% of 7.0 × 10⁵ clones sequenced observed only once. The obtained library diversity explores a comparable sequence space as the donor-derived natural repertoire and, at the same time, is able to access novel recombined diversity due to lack of segmental linkage. The successful isolation of low- and subnanomolar-affinity antibodies against a diverse panel of receptors, growth factors, enzymes, antigens from infectious reagents, and peptides confirms the functional viability of the design strategy.     

Immunoglobulin heavy chain diversity in Pteropid bats: evidence for a diverse and highly specific antigen binding repertoire

Bats are the natural host reservoir for range of emerging and re-emerging viruses, many of which cause significant morbidity and mortality in other mammals, yet appear to result in no clinical consequences for bats. The ability of bats to coexist with a variety of viruses presents an interesting immunological problem that has not been examined in any detail but which could provide significant insights into the evolution of antiviral mechanisms in mammals. Towards a better understanding of the bat immune system, we analysed the expressed heavy chain variable (VH) regions of antibodies from the black flying fox, Pteropus alecto. The germline repertoire of the closely related Pteropid bat, Pteropus vampyrus, whose genome has been sequenced was also examined for comparative purposes. Representative VH genes were found in all three mammalian VH clans (I, II and III) in both the expressed P. alecto VH repertoire and the germline P. vampyrus VH repertoire. Evidence for the use of multiple heavy chain diversity (DH) and joining (JH) segments for the generation of diverse VDJ rearrangements was also present in the expressed antibody repertoire of P. alecto. The long period of co-evolutionary history of bats with viruses may have resulted in a variety of highly specific VH segments being hardwired into the genomes of bats and may have implications for their ability to successfully cope with a diversity of viral antigens.     

The T-cell receptor β chain-encoding gene repertoire of a New World primate species,the cotton-top tamarin

 The New World primate, the cotton-top tamarin (Saguinus oedipus), expresses major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules with limited diversity. The uniqueness of the cotton-top tamarin MHC class I loci may contribute to this species’ unusual susceptibility to viral infections and high incidence of ulcerative colitis. As a prelude to examining the effect of this limited MHC class I diversity on the tamarin CD8⁺ T-cell receptor (TCR) repertoire, we identified expressed tamarin TCR β chain (TCRB) cDNAs by anchored and inverse polymerase chain reaction. Sequence alignments and phylogenetic comparisons with human and rhesus macaque sequences identified homologues of 21 human variable (V) gene families. Only single variable region genes were identified in each of these tamarin VB families, with the exception of the VB 5, 9, and 13 families which were comprised of two or three distinct members. The multiple genes within these three VB families do not appear to have separate human homologues, but rather aligned equally well to a single human gene from their respective VB families. These genes appear to have arisen, therefore, by duplication of certain VB genes in the tamarin ancestors following their divergence from the lineage leading to Old World primates and hominoids. Homologues of 12 of the 13 human joining (J) region genes were also identified in the tamarin. Comparison of the proportion of nonsynonymous (p_N) and synonymous (p_S) substitutions occurring per site within tamarin variable region genes demonstrated a reduction in p_N in the framework regions compared with p_N in the presumed MHC contact regions (CDR1 and CDR2). Taken together, these findings illustrate that the TCR β chain-encoding genes of the cotton-top tamarin are similar in structure and degree of complexity compared with their Old World primate and human counterparts. Received: 19 July 1996 / Revised: 12 August 1996     

Evolutionary relationship between human and mouse immunoglobulin kappa light chain variable region genes

Similar to the Igh-V multigene family, the human or mouse Igk-V repertoirer is a distorted continuum of homologous genes that may be grouped into families displaying >80% nucleic acid sequence similarity among their members. systematic interspecies sequence comparisons reveal that most human Igk-V gene families exhibit clear homology to mouse Ogk-V families (sequence similarity >74%). A hypothetical phylogenetic tree of Igk-V genes predicts that a minimum of seven Igk-V genes/families predate mammalian radiation. In two cases, several interrelated mouse Igk-V families exhibit phylogenetic equidistance with just one human Igk-V family, implying a more pronounced divergence for the elevated number of Igk-V gene families in the mouse. Mouse-human Igk-V comaprisons, moreover, illustrate how expansion, contraction, and perhaps deletion of Igk-V gene families shape the Igk-V repertoire during mammalian evolution.     

Generation and characterization of an immune combinatorial cDNA library of variable genes of mouse immunoglobulins

A combinatorial cDNA library of mouse variable immunoglobulin genes from mice immunized with recombinant human interferon β1b (rhIFN-β1b) has been constructed. For this purpose, cDNA of variable genes of heavy (V _H ) and light (V _L ) immunoglobulin chains amplified from splenocytes were joined by linker DNA to form single-chain antibodies (single-chain Fv-antibodies, or ScFv’s). The ScFv-DNA pool thus obtained was cloned into a phagemid vector and used to transform Escherichia coli. Bacterial clones that produce single-chain antibodies that are specific to rhIFN-β1b ScFv’s were selected using the technique of phage display. Such characteristics of generated library as abundance, functional size, and initial diversity of the ScFv-DNA sequences were established in the study. A high degree of specificity of interaction of selected phage displayed ScFv’s with rhIFN-β1b has been demonstrated. Original Ukrainian Text ? M.V. Pavlova, P.V. Gilchuk, Ia. O. Pokholenko, I.S. Nikolaiev, V.A. Kordium, 2008, published in Tsitologiya i Genetika, 2008, Vol. 42, No. 2, pp. 10–15.     

IgG rheumatoid factors isolated by the surface-displaying phage library technique

 Our analysis of IgG rheumatoid factors (RFs) from three patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) revealed that most contained significant numbers of skewed mutations per V region, suggesting that these RFs arose from antigen-driven responses. To further study IgG RFs in RA, we used pComb3 vector to construct an IgG1,λ combinatorial antibody library from a synovial fluid sample. After panning against human IgG, Fab fragments from 71/96 phage clones bound to Fc-coated wells. Sequence analysis of 20 randomly chosen Fc-binders showed that 17 (85%) clones had identical heavy (H) and light (L) chain V regions, represented by Humha311 and Humla211, respectively. Of the remaining three clones, two had the same Humla211 L chain, but each with a different H chain V region. All the putative germline V genes for these RFs also encode RF in RA patients. However, none of these RF V regions are similar to those of the two IgG RFs derived by the hybridoma technique from the same synovial fluid. The Humha311 H chain has two frameshifts: a one-base insertion upstream of the JH region and a four-base deletion near the end of the CH1 region, resulting in a mainly unconventional amino acid sequence in the CH1 region. In the future, it will be important to study the presence of IgG molecules with such unconventional CH1 amino acid sequences, and the effects of these amino acid sequences on the structures and immunological properties of the IgG molecules. Received: 4 September 1996 / Revised: 22 October 1996     

MouseV k gene classification by nucleic acid sequence similarity

Analyses of immunoglobulin (Ig) variable (V) region gene usage in the immune response, estimates ofV gene germline complexity, and other nucleic acid hybridization-based studies depend on the extent to which such genes are related (i. e., sequence similarity) and their organization in gene families. While mouseIgh heavy chainV region (V _H ) gene families are relatively well-established, a corresponding systematic classification ofIgk light chainV region (V _k ) genes has not been reported. The present analysis, in the course of which we reviewed the known extent of theV _k germline gene repertoire andV _k gene usage in a variety of responses to foreign and self antigens, provides a classification of mouseV _k genes in gene families composed of members with >80% overall nucleic acid sequence similarity. This classification differed in several aspects from that ofV _H genes: only someV _k gene families were as clearly separated (by >25% sequence dissimilarity) as typicalV _H gene families; mostV _k gene families were closely related and, in several instances, members from different families were very similar (>80%) over large sequence portions; frequently, classification by nucleic acid sequence similarity diverged from existing classifications based on amino-terminal protein sequence similarity. Our data have implications forV _k gene analyses by nucleic acid hybridization and describe potentially important differences in sequence organization betweenV _H andV _k genes.     

Idiotypic diversity and variable region gene usage by mouse anti-HLA-DQ3 mAb

The anti-HLA-DQ3 monoclonal antibodies (mAb) KS13, SO1, SO2, SO3, SO4, and SO5 recognize spatially close but distinct antigenic determinants, since they crossinhibit each other in their binding to HLA-DQ3 antigens, but do not share idiotopes recognized in their antigen combining site by syngeneic and anti-id antisera and mAb. Furthermore, mAb SO1, SO3, SO4, and SO5 react also with HLA-DQ allospecificities other than HLA-DQ3. Sequence analysis of the heavy (V _H ) and light (V _L ) chain variable region of the six mAb revealed preferential usage of V _H 36–60 and V _K 12/13 gene families. However, the individual V _H and V _L germline gene usage by the six mAb is diverse and the utilization of D, J _H , and J _L gene segments is heterogeneous. The diverse usage of V _H and V _L gene segments and heterogeneous amino acid sequences of V _H and V _L CDR, together with the heterogeneous idiotypic profile, may reflect the complexity of the determinants recognized by the six mAb on HLA-DQ3 antigens. The results we have presented provide for the first time information about the structural basis of the diversity of antibodies recognizing human histocompatibility antigens.The nucleotide sequence data reported in this Papershave been submitted to the GenBank nucleotide sequence database and have been assigned the accession numbers L20499, L20957, L20961, L24557, L24558 and L20962, respectively, for V _H region genes, and L20956, L20958, L24555, L24556, L20959, and L20960, respectively, for V _L region genes     

Immunoglobulin light chain class multiplicity and alternative organizational forms in early vertebrate phylogeny

The prototypic chondrichthyan immunoglobulin (Ig) light chain type (type I) isolated from Heterodontus francisci (horned shark) has a clustered organization in which variable (V), joining (J), and constant (C) elements are in relatively close linkage (V-J-C). Using a polymerase chain reaction-based approach on a light chain peptide sequence from the holocephalan, Hydrolagus colliei (spotted ratfish), it was possible to isolate members of a second light chain gene family. A probe to this light chain (type II) detects homologs in two orders of elasmobranchs, Heterodontus, a galeomorph and Raja erinacea (little skate), a batoid, suggesting that this light chain type may be present throughout the cartilaginous fishes. In all cases, V, J, and C regions of the type II gene are arranged in closely linked clusters typical of all known Ig genes in cartilaginous fishes. All representatives of this type II gene family are joined in the germline. A third (kappa-like) light chain type from Heterodontus is described. These findings establish that a degree of light chain class complexity comparable to that of the mammals is present in the most phylogenetically distant extant jawed vertebrates and that the phenomenon of germline-joined (pre-rearranged) genes, described originally in the heavy chain genes of cartilaginous fishes, extends to light chain genes.