Kinetic computational alanine scanning: application to p53 oligomerization

We have developed a novel computational alanine scanning approach that involves analysis of ensemble unfolding kinetics at high temperature to identify residues that are critical for the stability of a given protein. This approach has been applied to dimerization of the oligomerization domain (residues 326-355) of tumor suppressor p53. As validated by experimental results, our approach has reasonable success in identifying deleterious mutations, including mutations that have been linked to cancer. We discuss a method for determining the effect of mutations on the location of the dimerization transition state.     

Hydrophobic side-chain size is a determinant of the three-dimensional structure of the p53 oligomerization domain.

The p53 tumor suppressor oligomerization domain, a dimer of two primary dimers, is an independently folding domain whose subunits consist of a beta-strand, a tight turn and an alpha-helix. To evaluate the effect of hydrophobic side-chains on three-dimensional structure, we substituted residues Phe341 and Leu344 in the alpha-helix with other hydrophobic amino acids. Substitutions that resulted in residue 341 having a smaller side-chain than residue 344 switched the stoichiometry of the domain from tetrameric to dimeric. The three-dimensional structure of one such dimer was determined by multidimensional NMR spectroscopy. When compared with the primary dimer of the wild-type p53 oligomerization domain, the mutant dimer showed a switch in alpha-helical packing from anti-parallel to parallel and rotation of the alpha-helices relative to the beta-strands. Hydrophobic side-chain size is therefore an important determinant of a protein fold.     

Tight DNA binding and oligomerization are dispensable for the ability of p53 to transactivate target genes and suppress transformation.

The p53 tumor suppressor protein can bind tightly to specific sequence elements in the DNA and induce the transactivation of genes harboring such p53 binding sites. Various lines of evidence suggest that p53 binds to its target site as an oligomer. To test whether oligomerization is essential for the biological and biochemical activities of p53, we deleted a major part of the dimerization domain of mouse wild-type p53. The resultant protein, termed p53wt delta SS, was shown to be incapable of forming detectable homo-oligomers in vitro and is, therefore, likely to be predominantly if not exclusively monomeric. In agreement with the accepted model, p53wt delta SS indeed failed to exhibit measurable DNA binding in vitro. Surprisingly, though, it was still capable of suppressing oncogene-mediated transformation and of transactivating in vivo a target gene containing p53 binding sites. These findings indicate that dimerization-defective p53 is biologically active and may engage in productive sequence-specific DNA interactions in vivo. Furthermore, p53 dimerization probably leads to cooperative binding to specific DNA sequences.     

Crystal structure of human 53BP1 BRCT domains bound to p53 tumour suppressor

The BRCT (BRCA1 C-terminus) is an evolutionary conserved protein-protein interacting module found as single, tandem or multiple repeats in a diverse range of proteins known to play roles in the DNA-damage response. The BRCT domains of 53BP1 bind to the tumour suppressor p53. To investigate the nature of this interaction, we have determined the crystal structure of the 53BP1 BRCT tandem repeat in complex with the DNA-binding domain of p53. The structure of the 53BP1-p53 complex shows that the BRCT tandem repeats pack together through a conserved interface that also involves the inter-domain linker. A comparison of the structure of the BRCT region of 53BP1 with the BRCA1 BRCT tandem repeat reveals that the interdomain interface and linker regions are remarkably well conserved. 53BP1 binds to p53 through contacts with the N-terminal BRCT repeat and the inter-BRCT linker. The p53 residues involved in this binding are mutated in cancer and are also important for DNA binding. We propose that BRCT domains bind to cellular target proteins through a conserved structural element termed the 'BRCT recognition motif'.     

Function, oligomerization, and conformation of tumor-associated p53 proteins with mutated C-terminus

Mutations that affect the oligomerization domain (OD) of the p53 tumor suppressor may be of particular interest because of the remarkable contradiction between the conservation of the OD and its relative functional resistance to amino acid substitutions, and because of recent hints that cellular protein factors may interact with the OD. Both point to the possibility that this domain fulfills tasks beyond oligomerization. We report that the tumor-associated mutants 330H, 334V, and 337C are defective for homo-oligomerization by three criteria. Accordingly, 330H and 337C failed to bind to a p53 recognition motif in gel-shift assays and to stimulate reporter genes efficiently in transient transfections. 334V retained some activity in both assays despite being oligomerization-defective. The ability of the mutants to induce apoptosis correlated with their performance in the DNA binding and transactivation assays. However, mutants 330H and 337C were able to provoke cell death when overexpressed, which in combination with their failure to transactivate genes suggests competence for the induction of transactivation-independent apoptosis at high protein levels. Although 334V and 337C failed to homo-oligomerize, they were able to hetero-oligomerize with a p53 with wild-type OD, and 334V was able to interfere with transactivation by wt p53. All mutants showed a reduced reactivity with antibody PAb421 and a distinct calpain cleavage pattern indicative of conformational alterations. In conclusion, tumor-associated OD mutants of p53 can be functionally competent to different degrees despite of being oligomerization defective.     

p53 and transformation by SV40

The large T antigen of SV40 is able to immortalize and transform primary and established cells in culture, and can, at least in certain cases, confer a tumorigenic phenotype on the infected cell. T antigen has been shown to induce cellular DNA synthesis in the infected cell and this activity is likely to be instrumental in T antigen mediated oncogenesis. A property of T antigen which may be of paramount importance to its oncogenic and mitogenic activities is its ability to specifically bind and stabilize the cellular protein p53. p53 has been implicated in the control of the passage of the cell from G0 arrest to G1 and S phase. Furthermore, altered p53 expression is strongly associated with various phenotypes of the transformed state, and p53 has been identified as an immortalizing oncogene. Thus it is possible that p53-fixation by T antigen is responsible for its transforming potential. In this article, the transforming activities of T antigen and p53 are reviewed, and the possible relevance of p53-binding to T antigen-induced transformation is discussed.     

AHNAK controls 53BP1-mediated p53 response by restraining 53BP1 oligomerization and phase separation

1. Download : Download high-res image (200KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

Evidence for allosteric effects on p53 oligomerization induced by phosphorylation

p53 is a tetrameric protein with a thermodynamically unstable deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA)‐binding domain flanked by intrinsically disordered regulatory domains that control its activity. The unstable and disordered segments of p53 allow high flexibility as it interacts with binding partners and permits a rapid on/off switch to control its function. The p53 tetramer can exist in multiple conformational states, any of which can be stabilized by a particular modification. Here, we apply the allostery model to p53 to ask whether evidence can be found that the “activating” C‐terminal phosphorylation of p53 stabilizes a specific conformation of the protein in the absence of DNA. We take advantage of monoclonal antibodies for p53 that measure indirectly the following conformations: unfolded, folded, and tetrameric. A double antibody capture enzyme linked‐immunosorbent assay was used to observe evidence of conformational changes of human p53 upon phosphorylation by casein kinase 2 in vitro. It was demonstrated that oligomerization and stabilization of p53 wild‐type conformation results in differential exposure of conformational epitopes PAb1620, PAb240, and DO12 that indicates a reduction in the “unfolded” conformation and increases in the folded conformation coincide with increases in its oligomerization state. These data highlight that the oligomeric conformation of p53 can be stabilized by an activating enzyme and further highlight the utility of the allostery model when applied to understanding the regulation of unstable and intrinsically disordered proteins.     

The transforming and suppressor functions of p53 alleles: effects of mutations that disrupt phosphorylation, oligomerization and nuclear translocation.

Mutant p53 alleles that have a recessive phenotype in human tumors can, in cooperation with an activated H-ras gene, transform rat embryo fibroblasts (REFs). Mutant p53 proteins differ from wild type, and from each other in conformation, localization and transforming potential. Missense mutations in codons 143, 175 and 275 confer strong transforming potential. A serine 135 p53 mutant has an intermediate transforming potential, while the histidine codon 273 allele transforms weakly, if at all. In contrast to the wild type p53 gene, mutant p53 alleles with strong transforming ability cannot suppress the transformation of REFs by other oncogenes. The His273 allele retains partial suppressor function in this assay. The relevance of p53 oligomerization, phosphorylation and nuclear translocation to the transforming potential of mutant p53 and to wild type p53 suppressor function were examined. The inability of mutant p53 polypeptides to form homodimers correlates with loss of transforming function. Monomeric variants of wild type p53 protein, however, retain the ability to suppress focus formation. Phosphorylation of serine residues 315 and 392 is not required for the transforming function of mutant p53, nor is serine 315 required for suppressor function when these alleles are constitutively expressed in REF assays. Nuclear translocation-defective mutant and wild type p53 proteins retain transforming and suppressor function in REF assays.     

Correlation of metabolic stability and altered quaternary structure of oncoprotein p53 with cell transformation

The phosphoprotein p53 seems to be implicated in various processes connected with cell transformation and in particular with the regulation of cell cycle and probably DNA replication. In the present paper we have analyzed two sets of closely related cell lines expressing the same p53 which exhibited either a nontransformed or a transformed phenotype. These cell lines were used to study biochemical properties of the p53 protein which might be correlated with cell transformation. We found a positive correlation among an elevated stability of p53, the formation of high-molecular-weight forms of p53, and the transformed phenotype of the corresponding cell lines. Furthermore, these data indicate that self-aggregation prevents p53 from rapid degradation. By a comparative analysis of the stability and oligomerization properties of mutant p53 and wild-type p53, we could demonstrate that elevated stability and self-aggregation of p53 are correlated with the transformed phenotype of the cells and independent of a particular mutation in the p53 gene.     

Synthesis of complex phosphopeptides as mimics of p53 functional domains.

A complete set of mono-, di- and triphosphorylated peptides comprising amino acids 10-27, the Mdm2 and p300 binding site(s) of p53, with and without a fluorescein label at the N-terminus, was synthesized by step-by-step solid phase synthesis. Fluorescence polarization analysis revealed that phosphorylation at Thr18 decreased binding to recombinant Mdm2 protein compared with the unphosphorylated and the two other single phosphorylated analogues. Unlabelled multiply phosphorylated peptides corresponding to this amino-terminal transactivation domain proved to be powerful tools in analysing the phosphate specificity of existing anti-p53 monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies using direct ELISA. The tetramerization domain of human p53 protein was modelled with a 53 residue-long unlabelled unphosphorylated and Ser315-phosphorylated peptide pair. CD analysis showed similar alpha-helical structures for both peptides and no major difference in the secondary structure could be observed upon phosphorylation. Size-exclusion HPLC indicated that these synthetic oligomerization domain mimics underwent a pH-dependent tetramerization process, but the presence of a phosphate group at Ser315 did not modify the oligomeric state of the 308-360 p53 fragments. Nevertheless, the fluorescein-labelled Ser315 phosphorylated peptide bound to the downstream signalling ligand DNA topoisomerase I protein with slightly higher affinity than did the unphosphorylated analogue.     

Single-Molecule characterization of oligomerization kinetics and equilibria of the tumor suppressor p53

The state of oligomerization of the tumor suppressor p53 is an important factor in its various biological functions. It has a well-defined tetramerization domain, and the protein exists as monomers, dimers and tetramers in equilibrium. The dissociation constants between oligomeric forms are so low that they are at the limits of measurement by conventional methods in vitro. Here, we have used the high sensitivity of single-molecule methods to measure the equilibria and kinetics of oligomerization of full-length p53 and its isolated tetramerization domain, p53tet, at physiological temperature, pH and ionic strength using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) in vitro. The dissociation constant at 37 °C for tetramers dissociating into dimers for full-length p53 was 50 ± 7 nM, and the corresponding value for dimers into monomers was 0.55 ± 0.08 nM. The half-lives for the two processes were 20 and 50 min, respectively. The equivalent quantities for p53tet were 150 ± 10 nM, 1.0 ± 0.14 nM, 2.5 ± 0.4 min and 13 ± 2 min. The data suggest that unligated p53 in unstressed cells should be predominantly dimeric. Single-molecule FCS is a useful procedure for measuring dissociation equilibria, kinetics and aggregation at extreme sensitivity.     

ATM activates p53 by regulating MDM2 oligomerization and E3 processivity

Rapid activation of p53 by ionizing irradiation is a classic DNA damage response mediated by the ATM kinase. However, the major signalling target and mechanism that lead to p53 stabilization are unknown. We show in this report that ATM induces p53 accumulation by phosphorylating the ubiquitin E3 ligase MDM2. Multiple ATM target sites near the MDM2 RING domain function in a redundant manner to provide robust DNA damage signalling. In the absence of DNA damage, the MDM2 RING domain forms oligomers that mediate p53 poly ubiquitination and proteasomal degradation. Phosphorylation by ATM inhibits RING domain oligomerization, specifically suppressing p53 poly ubiquitination. Blocking MDM2 phosphorylation by alanine substitution of all six phosphorylation sites results in constitutive degradation of p53 after DNA damage. These observations show that ATM controls p53 stability by regulating MDM2 RING domain oligomerization and E3 ligase processivity. Promoting or disrupting E3 oligomerization may be a general mechanism by which signalling kinases regulate ubiquitination reactions, and a potential target for therapeutic intervention.