An evolutionary conserved pattern of 18S rRNA sequence complementarity to mRNA 5′ UTRs and its implications for eukaryotic gene translation regulation

There are several key mechanisms regulating eukaryotic gene expression at the level of protein synthesis. Interestingly, the least explored mechanisms of translational control are those that involve the translating ribosome per se, mediated for example via predicted interactions between the ribosomal RNAs (rRNAs) and mRNAs. Here, we took advantage of robustly growing large-scale data sets of mRNA sequences for numerous organisms, solved ribosomal structures and computational power to computationally explore the mRNA–rRNA complementarity that is statistically significant across the species. Our predictions reveal highly specific sequence complementarity of 18S rRNA sequences with mRNA 5′ untranslated regions (UTRs) forming a well-defined 3D pattern on the rRNA sequence of the 40S subunit. Broader evolutionary conservation of this pattern may imply that 5′ UTRs of eukaryotic mRNAs, which have already emerged from the mRNA-binding channel, may contact several complementary spots on 18S rRNA situated near the exit of the mRNA binding channel and on the middle-to-lower body of the solvent-exposed 40S ribosome including its left foot. We discuss physiological significance of this structurally conserved pattern and, in the context of previously published experimental results, propose that it modulates scanning of the 40S subunit through 5′ UTRs of mRNAs.     

Putative implication of 3′-terminal segment of 18S rRNA in translation initiation of uncapped mRNAs in plants

A putative implication 3′-terminal 18S rRNA segment in the cap-independent initiation of translation on plant ribosomes was studied. It was shown that 3′-terminal segment (nucleotides 1777–1811) of 18S rRNA including the last hairpin 45 was accessible for complementary interactions within 40S ribosomal subunits. Oligonucleotides complementary to this segment of rRNA, when added to wheat germ cell-free protein synthesizing system, specifically inhibited translation of uncapped reporter mRNA encoding β-glucuronidase. In the 5′-untranslated region (UTR), the reporter mRNA contained a leader sequence of potato virus Y (PVY) genomic RNA with fragments complementary to the region 1777–1811. A sequence corresponding to nucleotides 291–316 of PVY, which was complementary to most of the 3′-terminal 18S rRNA segment 1777–1808, was shown to enhance translational efficiency of the reporter mRNAs when placed into 5′-UTR. The obtained results suggest that complementary interactions between 5′-UTR of mRNA and 3′-terminal segment of 18S rRNA can take place during cap-independent translation initiation.     

Probable involvement of 3'-terminal segment of 18S rRNA in translation initiation of uncapped mRNAs in plants

A possibility of involvement of 3'-terminal 18S rRNA segment in the cap-independent initiation of translation on plant ribosomes was studied. It was shown that 3-terminal segment (nucleotides 1777-1811) of 18S rRNA including the last hairpin 45 is accessible for complementary interactions in 40S ribosomal subunits. Oligonucleotides complementary to this segment of rRNA when added to wheat germ cell-free protein synthesizing system were found to specifically inhibit translation of uncapped reporter mRNA coding for beta-glucuronidase, which bears in the 5'-untranslated region (UTR) a leader sequence of potato virus Y (PVY) genomic RNA possessing fragments complementary to the region 1777-1811. It was shown that a sequence corresponding to nucleotides 291-316 of PVY, which is complementary to a major portion of the 3-terminal 18S rRNA segment 1777-1808, when placed into 5'-UTR, is able to enhance translational efficiency of the reporter mRNAs. The results obtained suggest that complementary interactions between mRNA 5'-UTR and 18S rRNA 3'-terminal segment can take place in the course of cap-independent translation initiation.     

Escherichia coli mRNAs with strong Shine/Dalgarno sequences also contain 5' end sequences complementary to domain # 17 on the 16S ribosomal RNA

A well-established feature of the translation initiation region, which attracts the ribosomes to the prokaryotic mRNAs, is a purine rich area called Shine/Dalgarno sequence (SD). There are examples of various other sequences, which despite having no similarity to an SD sequence are capable of enhancing and/or initiating translation. The mechanisms by which these sequences affect translation remain unclear, but a base pairing between mRNA and 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) is proposed to be the likely mechanism. In this study, using a computational approach, we identified a non-SD signal found specifically in the translation initiation regions of Escherichia coli mRNAs, which contain super strong SD sequences. Nine of the 11 E. coli translation initiation regions, which were previously identified for having super strong SD sequences, also contained six or more nucleotides complementary to box-17 on the 16S rRNA (nucleotides 418-554). Mutational analyses of those initiation sequences indicated that when complementarity to box-17 was eliminated, the efficiency of the examined sequences to mediate the translation of chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) mRNA was reduced. The results suggest that mRNA sequences with complementarity to box-17 of 16S rRNA may function as enhancers for translation in E. coli.     

Fragment of mRNA coding part complementary to region 1638–1650 of wheat 18S RNA functions as a translational enhancer

The possible involvement of 18S rRNA fragment 1638–1650, including basements of the helices h44 and h28, as well as nucleotides of the ribosomal decoding site in the cap-independent mode of the initiation of the translation of plant ribosomes is studied. This rRNA fragment is shown to be accessible for complementary interactions in the 40S ribosomal subunit. It is found that the sequence that is complementary to the 18S rRNA fragment 1638–1650 is able to enhance the efficiency of the reporter mRNA translation when placed just after the initiation codon. The obtained results indicate that, in the course of the cap-independent mode of the initiation of translation, complementary interactions can occur between the mRNA coding sequence and 18S rRNA fragment in the region of the ribosomal decoding site.     

Evidence for a Competitive-Displacement Model for the initiation of protein synthesis involving the intermolecular hybridization of 5 S rRNA, 18 S rRNA and mRNA.

We have previously shown that a 5'-terminal region of mouse 5 S rRNA can base-pair in vitro with two distinct regions of 18 S rRNA. Further analysis reveals that these 5 S rRNA-complementary sequences in 18 S rRNA also exhibit complementarity to the Kozak consensus sequence surrounding the mRNA translational start site. To test the possibility that these 2 regions in 18 S rRNA may be involved in mRNA binding and translational initiation, we have tested, using an in vitro translation system, the effects of DNA oligonucleotides complementary to these 18 S rRNA sequences on protein synthesis. Results show that an oligonucleotide complementary to one 18 S rRNA region does inhibit translation at the step of initiation. We propose a Competitive-Displacement Model for the initiation of translation involving the intermolecular base-pairing of 5 S rRNA, 18 S rRNA and mRNA.     

Complementarity between the mRNA 5' untranslated region and 18S ribosomal RNA can inhibit translation

In eubacteria, base pairing between the 3' end of 16S rRNA and the ribosome-binding site of mRNA is required for efficient initiation of translation. An interaction between the 18S rRNA and the mRNA was also proposed for translation initiation in eukaryotes. Here, we used an antisense RNA approach in vivo to identify the regions of 18S rRNA that might interact with the mRNA 5' untranslated region (5' UTR). Various fragments covering the entire mouse 18S rRNA gene were cloned 5' of a cat reporter gene in a eukaryotic vector, and translation products were analyzed after transient expression in human cells. For the largest part of 18S rRNA, we show that the insertion of complementary fragments in the mRNA 5' UTR do not impair translation of the downstream open reading frame (ORF). When translation inhibition is observed, reduction of the size of the complementary sequence to less than 200 nt alleviates the inhibitory effect. A single fragment complementary to the 18S rRNA 3' domain retains its inhibitory potential when reduced to 100 nt. Deletion analyses show that two distinct sequences of approximately 25 nt separated by a spacer sequence of 50 nt are required for the inhibitory effect. Sucrose gradient fractionation of polysomes reveals that mRNAs containing the inhibitory sequences accumulate in the fractions with 40S ribosomal subunits, suggesting that translation is blocked due to stalling of initiation complexes. Our results support an mRNA-rRNA base pairing to explain the translation inhibition observed and suggest that this region of 18S rRNA is properly located for interacting with mRNA.     

An mRNA-rRNA base-pairing mechanism for translation initiation in eukaryotes

Base-pairing of messenger RNA to ribosomal RNA is a mechanism of translation initiation in prokaryotes. Although analogous base-pairing has been suggested to affect the translation of various eukaryotic mRNAs, direct evidence has been lacking. To test such base-pairing, we developed a yeast system that uses ribosomes containing a mouse-yeast hybrid 18S rRNA. Using this system, we demonstrate that a 9-nucleotide element found in the mouse Gtx homeodomain mRNA facilitates translation initiation by base-pairing to 18S rRNA. Various point mutations in the Gtx element and in either the hybrid or wild-type yeast 18S rRNAs confirmed the requirement for an intact complementary match. The presence of the Gtx element in various mRNAs suggests that this element affects the translation of groups of mRNAs. We discuss the possibility that other mRNA elements affect translation by base-pairing to different sites in the 18S rRNA.     

Regions of Intermolecular Complementarity in Escherichia coli 16S rRNA,mRNA, and tRNA Molecules

The results of computer analysis of complementarity regions in the sequences of E. coli 16S rRNA, mRNAs and tRNAs are reported in this article. The potential regions of intermolecular RNA–RNA hybridization, or clinger fragments, in 16S rRNA, which are complementary to the sites frequently occurring in mRNAs and tRNAs, were found. Major clinger fragments on 16S rRNA are universal for genes that belong to different functional groups. Our results show there are adaptations of the structural organization of the 16S rRNA molecule to messenger and transport RNA sequences. RNA interaction with clinger fragments may contribute to upregulation of the translation process through increasing the local concentration of mRNAs and tRNAs in the vicinity of the ribosome and their proper positioning, as well as decrease the efficiency of translation through nonspecific mRNA–16SrRNA interactions.     

Ribosomal Pausing and Scanning Arrest as Mechanisms of Translational Regulation from Cap-Distal Iron-Responsive Elements

Iron regulatory protein 1 (IRP-1) binding to an iron-responsive element (IRE) located close to the cap structure of mRNAs represses translation by precluding the recruitment of the small ribosomal subunit to these mRNAs. This mechanism is position dependent; reporter mRNAs bearing IREs located further downstream exhibit diminished translational control in transfected mammalian cells. To investigate the underlying mechanism, we have recapitulated this position effect in a rabbit reticulocyte cell-free translation system. We show that the recruitment of the 43S preinitiation complex to the mRNA is unaffected when IRP-1 is bound to a cap-distal IRE. Following 43S complex recruitment, the translation initiation apparatus appears to stall, before linearly progressing to the initiation codon. The slow passive dissociation rate of IRP-1 from the cap-distal IRE suggests that the mammalian translation apparatus plays an active role in overcoming the cap-distal IRE–IRP-1 complex. In contrast, cap-distal IRE–IRP-1 complexes efficiently repress translation in wheat germ and yeast translation extracts. Since inhibition occurs subsequent to 43S complex recruitment, an efficient arrest of productive scanning may represent a second mechanism by which RNA-protein interactions within the 5′ untranslated region of an mRNA can regulate translation. In contrast to initiating ribosomes, elongating ribosomes from mammal, plant, and yeast cells are unaffected by IRE–IRP-1 complexes positioned within the open reading frame. These data shed light on a characteristic aspect of the IRE-IRP regulatory system and uncover properties of the initiation and elongation translation apparatus of eukaryotic cells.     

Escherichia coli Ribosomal Protein S1 Unfolds Structured mRNAs Onto the Ribosome for Active Translation Initiation

Regulation of translation initiation is well appropriate to adapt cell growth in response to stress and environmental changes. Many bacterial mRNAs adopt structures in their 5′ untranslated regions that modulate the accessibility of the 30S ribosomal subunit. Structured mRNAs interact with the 30S in a two-step process where the docking of a folded mRNA precedes an accommodation step. Here, we used a combination of experimental approaches in vitro (kinetic of mRNA unfolding and binding experiments to analyze mRNA–protein or mRNA–ribosome complexes, toeprinting assays to follow the formation of ribosomal initiation complexes) and in vivo (genetic) to monitor the action of ribosomal protein S1 on the initiation of structured and regulated mRNAs. We demonstrate that r-protein S1 endows the 30S with an RNA chaperone activity that is essential for the docking and the unfolding of structured mRNAs, and for the correct positioning of the initiation codon inside the decoding channel. The first three OB-fold domains of S1 retain all its activities (mRNA and 30S binding, RNA melting activity) on the 30S subunit. S1 is not required for all mRNAs and acts differently on mRNAs according to the signals present at their 5′ ends. This work shows that S1 confers to the ribosome dynamic properties to initiate translation of a large set of mRNAs with diverse structural features.     

Complementarity of the 16S rRNA penultimate stem with sequences downstream of the AUG destabilizes the plastid mRNAs

Escherichia coli mRNA translation is facilitated by sequences upstream and downstream of the initiation codon, called Shine–Dalgarno (SD) and downstream box (DB) sequences, respectively. In E.coli enhancing the complementarity between the DB sequences and the 16S rRNA penultimate stem resulted in increased protein accumulation without a significant affect on mRNA stability. The objective of this study was to test whether enhancing the complementarity of plastid mRNAs downstream of the AUG (downstream sequence or DS) with the 16S rRNA penultimate stem (anti-DS or ADS region) enhances protein accumulation. The test system was the tobacco plastid rRNA operon promoter fused with the E.coli phage T7 gene 10 (T7g10) 5′-untranslated region (5′-UTR) and DB region. Translation efficiency was tested by measuring neomycin phosphotransferase (NPTII) accumulation in tobacco chloroplasts. We report here that the phage T7g10 5′-UTR and DB region promotes accumulation of NPTII up to ~16% of total soluble leaf protein (TSP). Enhanced mRNA stability and an improved NPTII yield (~23% of TSP) was obtained from a construct in which the T7g10 5′-UTR was linked with the NPTII coding region via a NheI site. However, replacing the T7g10 DB region with the plastid DS sequence reduced NPTII and mRNA levels to 0.16 and 28%, respectively. Reduced NPTII accumulation is in part due to accelerated mRNA turnover.     

Genetic analysis of the Shine-Dalgarno interaction: selection of alternative functional mRNA-rRNA combinations.

The interaction of bacterial mRNAs with the small ribosomal subunit is strongly promoted by Watson-Crick base pairing between a purine-rich consensus ribosomal RNA-binding sequence (RBS) on mRNA and its complementary message-binding sequence (MBS) on rRNA known as the Shine-Dalgarno interaction. To identify and characterize components of the Shine-Dalgarno interaction that contribute to translation initiation, we simultaneously and randomly mutated both the MBS of the 16S rRNA gene from Escherichia coli and the RBS of the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) gene and selected chloramphenicol-resistant mutant combinations. Nucleotide distribution in both mutated sequences of the survivors was nonrandom and the MBSs of the surviving clones showed a preference for purines. In addition, strong interactions between specific nucleotide pairs within each of the mutated sequences were indicated. Although the contribution of free energy of duplex formation between rRNA and mRNA was highly significant (P < 0.001), only 23% of the observed activity in all of the mutants could be attributed to this variable. MBSs that were lethal upon expression were also isolated. These sequences may cause overtranslation of specific messages in the cell. These data indicate that specific sequence constraints exist (primarily within the MBS) that are necessary to establish a functional threshold for translation and that only after establishment of this threshold is the level of expression significantly affected by the free energy of MBS-RBS duplex formation.     

Region of intermolecular complementarity in Escherichia coli 16S rRNA,mRNA, and tRNA molecules

The results of computer analysis of complementarity regions in the sequences of E. coli 16S rRNA, mRNAs and tRNAs are reported in this article. The potential regions of intermolecular RNA-RNA hybridization, or clinger fragments, in 16S rRNA, which are complementary to the sites frequently occurring in mRNAs and tRNAs, were found. Major clinger fragments on 16S rRNA are universal for genes that belong to different functional groups. Our results show there are adaptations of the structural organization of the 16S rRNA molecule to messenger and transport RNA sequences. RNA interaction with clinger fragments may contribute to upregulation of translation process through increasing the local concentration of mRNAs and tRNAs in the vicinity of the ribosome and their proper positioning, as well as decrease the efficiency of translation through non-specific mRNA-16SrRNA interactions.     

5' untranslated leader sequences of eukaryotic mRNAs encoding heat shock induced proteins.

5' untranslated leaders (5' UTLs) are suggested to play a crucial role in the selective translation of their eukaryotic mRNAs encoding heat shock proteins (HSP) during heat stress conditions. However, the structural features of the HSP mRNAs which cause this effect are mostly unknown. We have compiled the 5' UTLs from about 140 eukaryotic HSP mRNAs including vertebrates, invertebrates, higher and lower plants. A detailed analysis of these sequences according to length, A+T content, context of functional ATGs and presence of upstream non-functional ATGs was made. We observed that all these features were similar to the earlier studies in the literature based on data from HSP as well as non-HSP mRNAs. These observations were reconfirmed by intra-specific comparison of 5' UTLs from HSP and non-HSP genes. Similar to the translation element involved in the selective translation of mRNAs in polioviruses, a search for a short sequence motif complementary to highly conserved 18S rRNA was performed using a HSP mRNA database. The majority of the HSP mRNA sequences (77%) contained one or more small sequence motifs suggesting that they may function as internal ribosome entry sites for selective initiation of translation during heat stress.     

Antisense masking reveals contributions of mRNA-rRNA base pairing to translation of Gtx and FGF2 mRNAs

We previously showed that a 9-nucleotide sequence from the 5' leader of the Gtx homeodomain mRNA facilitates translation initiation by base pairing to 18S rRNA. These earlier studies tested the Gtx element in isolation; we now assess the physiological relevance of this element in the context of two natural mRNAs that contain this sequence in their 5' leaders, Gtx itself and FGF2 (fibroblast growth factor 2). 2'-O-Methyl-modified RNA oligonucleotides were employed to block mRNA-rRNA base pairing by targeting either the Gtx-binding site in 18S rRNA or Gtx elements in recombinant mRNAs containing the Gtx or FGF2 5' leaders linked to a reporter cistron. Studies in cell-free lysates and transfected COS-7 cells showed that translation of mRNAs containing the Gtx or FGF2 5' leaders was decreased by > 50% when oligonucleotides targeting either the rRNA or mRNA were used. Specificity was demonstrated by showing that translation of the recombinant mRNAs was unaffected by control oligonucleotides. In addition, the specific oligonucleotides did not affect the translation of recombinant mRNAs in which the Gtx elements were mutated. Experiments performed using constructs containing Gtx and FGF2 5' leader and coding sequences ruled out possible effects of the reporter cistron. Furthermore, two-dimensional gel electrophoresis revealed that the oligonucleotides used in this study had little overall effect on the proteomes of cells transfected with these oligonucleotides. This study demonstrates that mRNA-rRNA base pairing affects the expression of two cellular mRNAs and describes a new approach for investigating putative mRNA-rRNA base pairing interactions in mammalian cells.     

Cross-linking of tobacco mosaic virus RNA and capped polyribonucleotides to 18S rRNA in wheat germ ribosome-mRNA complexes

Tobacco mosaic virus RNA, forming 40S or 80S initiation complexes with wheat germ ribosomes, was covalently bound to 18S ribosomal RNA by the photoreaction with an RNA cross-linking agent, 4'-aminomethyl-4,5',8-trimethylpsoralen (AMT). Synthetic polyribonucleotide, poly(A, U), with the cap structure m7GpppGmC at the 5'-terminal was also cross-linked to 18S ribosomal RNA in 40S or 80S complexes with ribosomes by the AMT photoreaction. Polyuridylic acid with the same 5'-cap structure, forming 40S complexes but not 80S complexes with ribosomes, was most efficiently cross-linked to 18S ribosomal RNA by the psoralen photoreaction. These results suggest that the interactions between mRNA and 18S rRNA are not necessarily of strict complementarity but occur during formation of the complexes in eukaryotes. The 40S complexes would be then converted to 80S complexes in the presence of the AUG initiation codon or AUG-like triplets containing A and U on the polyribonucleotide chains which interact with 18S ribosomal RNA.     

Free initiation factors eIF4A and eIF4B are dispensable for translation initiation on uncapped mRNAs

The formation of ribosomal 48S initiation complexes at the start AUG codon of uncapped mRNA leader sequences was studied using the methodology of primer extension inhibition (toe-printing). The experiments were performed in the system composed of purified individual components required for translation initiation. The formation of ribosomal 48S initiation complexes at the initiation codon was tested depending on the presence of the initiation factors eIF4F, eIF4A, and eIF4B. Several mRNAs containing short leader sequences lacking the extended secondary structure were studied. It was found that 48S ribosomal complexes at mRNAs with such leaders were not formed in the absence of eIF4F. In contrast, the removal of either eIF4A or eIF4B from the experimental system was found to be dispensable for the formation of the 48S complex.     

Complementarity of sequences in low molecular weight RNAs to regions of messenger and ribosomal RNAs.

Total low molecular weight nuclear RNAs of mouse ascites cells have been labeled in vitro and used as probes to search for complementary sequences contained in nuclear or cytoplasmic RNA. From a subset of hybridizing lmw RNAs, two major species of 58,000 and 35,000 mol. wt. have been identified as mouse 5 and 5.8S ribosomal RNA. Mouse 5 and 5.8S rRNA hybridize not only to 18 and 28S rRNA, respectively, but also to nuclear and cytoplasmic poly(A+) RNA. Northern blot analysis and oligo-dT cellulose chromatography have confirmed the intermolecular base-pairing of these two small rRNA sequences to total poly(A+) RNA as well as to purified rabbit globin mRNA. 5 and 5.8S rRNA also hybridize with positive (coding) but not negative (noncoding) strands of viral RNA. Temperature melting experiments have demonstrated that their hybrid stability with mRNA sequences is comparable to that observed for the 5S:18S and 5.8S:28S hybrids. The functional significance of 5 and 5.8S rRNA base-pairing with mRNAs and larger rRNAs is unknown, but these interactions could play important coordinating roles in ribosome structure, subunit interaction, and mRNA binding during translation.