Chromosomal damage induced in human lymphocytes by low doses of D-T neutrons

Unstable chromosome aberrations induced by in vitro irradiation with zero plus seven low doses of 14.8 MeV D-T neutrons in the range 3.55-244 mGy have been analysed in human peripheral blood lymphocytes. In order to obtain the required large numbers of scored cells for such low doses, fourteen laboratories participated in the experiment. The dose responses for dicentrics, excess acentrics and total aberrations, fitted well to the Y = alpha D model. The alpha coefficient of yield for dicentrics, 1.60 +/- 0.07 X 10(-2) Gy-1, compares well with the values obtained in previous studies with D-T neutrons at somewhat higher doses. Results from a previous collaborative study using 250 kVp X-rays over a comparable dose range indicated the possible existence of a threshold below 50 mGy. In the present study there is no clear evidence for neutrons for such a threshold. However, the data were insufficient to permit the rejection of a possible threshold below approximately 10 mGy.     

The low dose and low dose rate cytogenetic effects induced by gamma-radiation in human blood lymphocytes in vitro. II. the results of cytogenetic study

The yield of chromosome aberrations induced by gamma-radiation of 60Co in human blood lymphocytes in vitro at low doses (30 divided by 600 mGy) and low dose rates (0.70, 5.05, 59.2 mGy/min) was investigated. It was found that the observed level of chromosomal aberrations induced by gamma-irradiation was unaffected by the value of the dose rate when using constant dose rate and obtaining different doses by altering the exposure time. However, a relatively enhanced level of chromatid aberrations was found at 5.05 and 59.2 mGy/min dose rates in the dose range less than 250 mGy. We have found that the observed level of the sum of chromosomal aberrations induced by gamma-irradiation at doses less than 250 mGy and a dose rate of 59.2 mGy/min was essentially larger compared with the level extrapolated from high doses (above 300 mGy) using a linear-quadratic dose curve. This complied with our previous finding in 1976, 1977 when the enhanced level of dicentrics was only found at a high dose rate approximately 500 mGy/min. Such a non-linear cytogenetic effect does not manifest itself statistically significantly at dose rates of 0.70 and 5.05 mGy/min for the sum of chromosomal aberrations and does not manifest itself at all for dicentrics at all the examined dose rates.     

Mutation induction by very low dose rate gamma rays in cultured mouse leukemia cells L5178Y

Induction of cell killing and mutation to 6-thioguanine resistance was studied in growing mouse leukemia cells in culture following gamma rays at dose rates of 30 Gy/h, 20 cGy/h, and 6.3 mGy/h, i.e., acute, low dose rate, and very low dose rate irradiation. A marked increase was observed in the cell survival with decreasing dose rate; no reduction in the surviving fraction was detected after irradiation at 6.3 mGy/h until a total dose of 4 Gy. Similarly, the induced mutation frequency decreased after low dose rate irradiation compared to acute irradiation. However, the frequency after irradiation at 6.3 mGy/h was unexpectedly high and remained at a level which was intermediate between acute and low dose rate irradiation. No appreciable changes were observed in the responses to acute gamma rays (in terms of cell killing and mutation induction) in the cells which had experienced very low dose rate irradiation.     

Simulation of neutron interactions at the single-cell level

We recently reported that the exposure of cancer cells to 14 MeV neutrons at a very low dose rate (0.8 mGy min(-1)) produced a marked increase in cell killing at 5 cGy, followed by a plateau in survival and chromosomal damage. Simulation of the energy deposition events in irradiated cells may help to explain these unusual cell responses. We describe here a Monte Carlo simulation code, Energy Deposition in Cells Irradiated by Neutrons (EDCIN). The procedure considered the experimental setup and a hemispheric cell model. The simulation data fitted the dosimetric measurements performed using tissue-equivalent ionization chambers, Geiger-Müller counters, fission chambers, and silicon diodes. The simulation showed that 80% of the energy deposited in a single cell came from the interactions of neutrons outside the cell and only 20% came from neutron interactions inside the cell. Thus the "external" interactions that result in the production of recoil protons and secondary electrons may induce most of the biological damage, which may be repaired efficiently at low dose rate. The repair process may be triggered from a threshold level of damage, which would explain an initial increase cell death due to unrepaired sublethal damage, and then may compensate for induced damage, resulting in the plateaus.     

Mutation induction by different dose rates of gamma rays in radiation-sensitive mutants of mouse leukemia cells

Induction of cell killing and mutation to 6-thioguanine resistance was examined in a radiation-sensitive mutant strain LX830 of mouse leukemia cells following gamma irradiation at dose rates of 30 Gy/h (acute), 20 cGy/h (low dose rate), and 6.2 mGy/h (very low dose rate). LX830 cells were hypersensitive to killing by acute gamma rays. A slight but significant increase was observed in cell survival with decreasing dose rate down to 6.2 mGy/h, where the survival leveled off above certain total doses. The cells were also hypersensitive to mutation induction compared to the wild type. The mutation frequency increased linearly with increasing dose for all dose rates. No significant difference was observed in the frequency of induced mutations versus total dose at the three different dose rates so that the mutation frequency in LX830 cells at 6.2 mGy/h was not significantly different from that for moderate or acute irradiation.     

Response of X-ray-sensitive CHO mutant cells (xrs-6c) to radiation. II. Relationship between cell survival and the induction of chromosomal damage with low doses of alpha particles

The induction of cytotoxicity, chromosomal aberrations, and sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) was measured in CHO K-1c cells and in isogenic X-ray-sensitive mutant xrs-6c cells that had been irradiated with X rays and alpha particles in isoleucine-deficient alpha-minimal essential medium in G1 phase of the cell cycle. There was a noticeable shoulder region on the survival curve for CHO K-1c cells irradiated with very low doses of alpha particles, whereas this feature was absent for xrs-6c cells with alpha-particle doses as low as 0.5 cGy. Higher frequencies of chromatid-type aberrations were induced in G1-phase xrs-6c cells than in G1-phase CHO K-1c cells by both gamma- and alpha-particle irradiation. Induction of nonlethal chromosomal aberrations was observed following exposure to 2-6 cGy of alpha particles, doses yielding 97-100% cell survival. Irradiation with 0.5 cGy of alpha particles induced SCE; nearly 60% of irradiated cells contained significantly increased levels of SCE. However, only 3% of the nuclei of cells exposed to 0.5 cGy of alpha-particle radiation were actually traversed by an alpha particle. The observation that a large fraction of cells apparently survive exposure to very low doses of alpha-particle radiation with persistent genetic damage manifested by both chromosomal aberrations and SCEs may have important implications for the carcinogenic hazards of high-LET radiation.     

Chromosome aberration frequencies and chromosome instability in mice after long-term exposure to low-dose-rate gamma-irradiation

Chronological changes of chromosome aberration rates related to accumulated doses in chronically exposed humans and animals at a low-dose-rate have not been well studied. C3H female specific pathogen-free mice (8 weeks of age) were chronically irradiated. Chromosome aberration rate in mouse splenocytes after long-term exposure to low-dose-rate (LDR) gamma-rays was serially determined by conventional Giemsa method. Incidence of dicentrics and centric rings increased almost linearly up to 8000 mGy following irradiation for about 400 days at a LDR of 20 mGy/day. Clear dose-rate effects were observed in the chromosome aberration frequencies between dose rates of 20 mGy/day and 200 Gy/day. Furthermore, the frequencies of complex aberrations increased as accumulated doses increased in LDR irradiation. This trend was also observed for the incidences of micronuclei and trisomies of chromosomes 5, 13 and 18 in splenocytes, detected by micronucleus assay and metaphase fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) method, respectively. Incidences of 2-4 micronuclei and trisomy increased in mouse splenocytes after irradiation of 8000 mGy at a LDR of 20 mGy/day. These complex chromosome aberrations and numerical chromosome aberrations seem to be induced indirectly after radiation exposure and thus the results indicate that continuous gamma-ray irradiation for 400 days at LDR of 20 mGy/day induced chromosomal instability in mice. These results are important to evaluate the biological effects of long-term exposure to LDR radiation in humans.     

Chronic irradiation with low doses can be characterized by significant biological efficacy

Chromosomal aberrations (ChA) level was analyzed in the onion root meristem after the chronic irradiation with different dose capacities. It was shown that after the chronic irradiation with doses of 0.87 cGy, 2.61 cGy and 4.35 cGy the level of chromosomal aberrations depended on the dose capacity. Its value may also correspond to those which have been induced with accute irradiation. Biological efficacy of chronic irradiation may be from 20 to 1000 time folder in order to compare it with accute irradiation and this value depends on the irradiation regime.     

Cytogenetic effects of low-dose radiation with different LET in human peripheral blood lymphocytes

Chromosome damage and the spectrum of aberrations induced by low doses of γ-irradiation, X-rays and accelerated carbon ions (195 MeV/u, LET 16.6 keV/μm) in peripheral blood lymphocytes of four donors were studied. G₀-lymphocytes were exposed to 1–100 cGy, stimulated by PHA, and analyzed for chromosome aberrations at 48 h post-irradiation by the metaphase method. A complex nonlinear dose–effect dependence was observed over the range of 1 to 50 cGy. At 1–7 cGy, the cells showed the highest radiosensitivity per unit dose (hypersensitivity, HRS), which was mainly due to chromatid-type aberration. According to the classical theory of aberration formation, chromatid-type aberrations should not be induced by irradiation of unstimulated lymphocytes. With increasing dose, the frequency of aberrations decreased significantly, and in some cases it even reached the control level. At above 50 cGy the dose–effect curves became linear. In this dose range, the frequency of chromatid aberrations remained at a low constant level, while the chromosome-type aberrations increased linearly with dose. The high yield of chromatid-type aberrations observed in our experiments at low doses confirms the idea that the molecular mechanisms which underlie the HRS phenotype may differ from the classical mechanisms of radiation-induced aberration formation. The data presented, as well as recent literature data on bystander effects and genetic instability expressed as chromatid-type aberrations on a chromosomal level, are discussed with respect to possible common mechanisms underlying all low-dose phenomena.     

Carcinogenesis in laboratory mice after low doses of ionizing radiation

Experimental data on the incidence of solid tumors from various long-term mouse studies performed at the Casaccia laboratories over several years were reconsidered, limiting the analysis to the results available for doses equal to or less than 17 cGy of neutrons and 32 cGy of X rays since these dose limits are reasonably close to the generally accepted low-dose levels for high- and low-LET radiation (i.e. D(high-LET) < 5 cGy and D(low-LET) < 20 cGy, respectively). The following long-term experiments with BC3F1 mice were reviewed: (a) females treated with single doses of 1.5 MeV neutrons or 250 kVp X rays, (b) males treated with fractionated doses of fission neutrons, and (c) mice of both sexes irradiated in utero 17.5 days post coitus with single doses of fission neutrons or X rays. An experiment with CBA mice of both sexes treated with single doses of fission neutrons was also included in this study. Analysis was done on animals at risk; thus all incidences of tumor-bearing animals were expressed as the percentage excess incidence with respect to the controls. Ovarian tumors and other solid neoplasms were considered. The percentage frequencies and mean survival times of tumor-free mice were also recalculated. The results indicate the existence of a region at low doses where the final incidence of solid neoplasms is indistinguishable from the background incidence. These data reinforce the idea that at low doses the effectiveness of ionizing radiation in inducing solid neoplasms in laboratory mice is very low.     

The relative biological effectiveness of low doses of 14 MeV neutrons in steady-state murine spermatogenesis as determined by flow cytometry

The relative biological effectiveness of 14 MeV neutrons in the low-dose range < or =1 Gy has been determined in differentiating and differentiated spermatogonia. Male NMRI mice were exposed to single doses of 2 cGy to 3 Gy of (60)Co gamma rays or neutrons. The ratios of testicular S-phase cells, 4c primary spermatocytes, and elongated spermatids were quantified by DNA flow cytometry 2 to 70 days after irradiation and were found to decrease. Histological samples and testis weight were analyzed in parallel. Doses of 2-5 cGy neutrons and 10-50 cGy gamma rays significantly (P<0.05) decreased the proportions of S-phase cells, spermatocytes and elongated spermatids at 4, 14 and 28 days postirradiation. For S-phase cells, the biphasic shape of the cell survival curves was described with a D(50) of 5 cGy neutrons. The D(50) for (60)Co gamma rays and the relative biological effectiveness could not be determined. The relative biological effectiveness of neutrons at 50% reductions of testis weight, primary spermatocytes, and elongated spermatids were 2.5, 10.0 and 6.1, respectively. This in vivo assay is interesting because of its sensitivity at dose ranges that are relevant for exposures in the environment, the workplace and radiotherapy.     

Cytogenetic effect of low dose γ-radiation in Hordeum vulgare seedlings: non-linear dose–effect relationship

The induction of chromosome aberrations in Hordeum vulgare germinated seeds was studied after ionizing irradiation with doses in the range of 10–1,000 mGy. The relationship between the frequency of aberrant cells and the absorbed dose was found to be nonlinear. A dose-independent plateau in the dose range from about 50 to 500 mGy was observed, where the level of cytogenetic damage was significantly different from the spontaneous level. The comparison of the goodness of the experimental data fitting with mathematical models of different complexity, using the most common quantitative criteria, demonstrated the advantage of a piecewise linear model over linear and polynomial models in approximating the frequency of cytogenetical disturbances. The results of the study support the hypothesis of indirect mechanisms of mutagenesis induced by low doses. Fundamental and applied implications of these findings are discussed. An erratum to this article can be found at     

Effect of low-dose radiation on repair of DNA and chromosome damage

In this report results of studies on the effect of different doses of low LET (linear energy transfer) radiations on the unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) and DNA polymerase activity as well as the induction of adaptive response in bone marrow cells (BMC) by low dose radiation were presented. It was found that whole-body irradiation (WBI) with X-ray doses above 0.5 Gy caused a dose-dependent depression of both UD5 and DNA polymerase activity, while low dose radiation below 250 mGy could stimulate the DNA repair synthesis and the enzyme activity. WBI of mice with low doses of X-rays in the range of 2-100 mGy at a dose rate of 57.3 mGy per minute induced an adaptive response in the BMC expressed as a reduction of chromosome aberrations following a second exposure to a larger dose (0.65 mGy). It was demonstrated that the magnitude of the adaptive response seemed to be inversely related to the induction dose. The possibility of induction of adaptive response in GO phase of the cell cycle and the possibility of a second induction of the adaptive response were discussed.     

Transformation of C3H 10T1/2 cells with 4.3 MeV alpha particles at low doses: effects of single and fractionated doses.

Oncogenic transformation of C3H 10T1/2 cells was determined after exposure to graded doses of 4.3-MeV alpha particles LET = 101 keV/microns. The source of alpha particles was 244Cm and the irradiation was done in an irradiation chamber built for the purpose. Graded doses in the range of 0.2 to 300 cGy were studied with special emphasis on the low-dose region, with as many as seven points in the interval up to 10 cGy. The dose-effect relationship was a complex function. Transformation frequency increased with dose up to 2 cGy; it seemed to flatten at doses between 2 and 20 cGy but increased again at higher doses. A total of 21 cGy was delivered in a single dose or in 3 or 10 equal fractions at an interval of 1.5 h. An inverse dose-protraction effect of 1.4 was found with both fractionation schemes. Measurements of the mitotic index of the population immediately before the various fractions revealed a strong effect on the rate of cell division even after very low doses of radiation. Mitotic yield decreased markedly with the total dose delivered, and it was as low as 50% of the control value after 4.2 cGy and 20% after 14 cGy with both fractionation schemes.     

Lung carcinomas in Sprague-Dawley rats after exposure to low doses of radon daughters, fission neutrons, or gamma rays

The effectiveness of radon-daughter inhalation and irradiation with fission neutrons and gamma rays in the induction of lung carcinomas in Sprague-Dawley rats at low doses is compared. Earlier reports which compared radon-daughter inhalations and neutron irradiations over a wider range of doses were based on dosimetry for the radon-daughter inhalations which has recently been found to be faulty. In the present analysis, low-dose experiments were designed to derive revised equivalence ratios between radon-daughter exposures, and fission neutron or gamma irradiations. The equivalence is approximately 15 working level months (WLM) of radon daughters to 10 mGy of neutrons (the earlier value was 30 WLM to 10 mGy). The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of neutrons is 50 or more at a gamma-ray dose of 1 Gy. In these experiments with low doses and exposures, the lifetime incidences can be estimated from the raw incidences, while the derivation of the time dependence of the prevalence is essential for the estimation of RBE values and equivalence ratios.     

Low-dose irradiation causes rapid alterations to the proteome of the human endothelial cell line EA.hy926

High doses of ionising radiation damage the heart by an as yet unknown mechanism. A concern for radiological protection is the recent epidemiological data indicating that doses as low as 100-500 mGy may induce cardiac damage. The aim of this study was to identify potential molecular targets and/or mechanisms involved in the pathogenesis of low-dose radiation-induced cardiovascular disease. The vascular endothelium plays a pivotal role in the regulation of cardiac function and is therefore a potential target tissue. We report here that low-dose radiation induced rapid and time-dependent changes in the cytoplasmic proteome of the human endothelial cell line EA.hy926. The proteomes were investigated at 4 and 24 h after irradiation at two different dose rates (Co-60 gamma ray total dose 200 mGy; 20 mGy/min and 190 mGy/min) using 2D-DIGE technology. Differentially expressed proteins were identified, after in-gel trypsin digestion, by MALDI-TOF/TOF tandem mass spectrometry, and peptide mass fingerprint analyses. We identified 15 significantly differentially expressed proteins, of which 10 were up-regulated and 5 down-regulated, with more than ±1.5-fold difference compared with unexposed cells. Pathways influenced by the low-dose exposures included the Ran and RhoA pathways, fatty acid metabolism and stress response.     

Immune effects of low-dose radiation: short-term induction of thymocyte apoptosis and long-term augmentation of T-cell-dependent immune responses

We and others have shown that low-dose X or gamma irradiation of mice leads to an increase in their survival after a subsequent lethal high-dose irradiation. The greatest increase in radioresistance appears at a fixed window of dose and time, e.g. 8 weeks after 5-10 cGy or 2 weeks after 50 cGy preirradiation. We show that low-dose irradiation induces thymocyte apoptosis with a maximal level at 6 h postirradiation that returns to background levels after 24 h. At the same time, we observed no morphological alteration of splenocytes and no early modification of the intensity of T-cell-dependent immune responses as measured by plaque-forming cell (PFC) counts. Nevertheless, we found that PFCs were increased 2 weeks after 50 cGy irradiation, which is the same time at which mice expressed the optimal increase in survival after a second lethal irradiation. We also examined thymocyte apoptosis and spleen PFCs in mice subjected to other stress-inducing pretreatments. Our results emphasize the existence of a lag time between the time of low-dose irradiation in vivo and the appearance of radioresistance. A mechanism that interconnects an environmental stimulus with the response of the animal is proposed based on the evidence presented here and reported in the literature.     

Adaptive response of human lymphocytes for the repair of radon-induced chromosomal damage

In human lymphocytes low doses of X-rays can decrease the number of chromatid deletions induced by subsequent high doses of sparsely ionizing X-rays. Because of the concern with the carcinogenic effects of low doses of -particles from radon in homes, experiments were carried out to see if low doses of X-rays could also decrease the yield of chromosomal aberrations induced by subsequent exposure to radon. Human peripheral blood lymphocytes were irradiated with low doses of X-rays (2 cGy) at 48 h of culture, exposed to radon at 72 h of culture, and analyzed for the presence of chromatid aberrations at subsequent intervals. The frequency of chromatid aberrations induced by radon alone increased with time after exposure, indicating exaggerated differences in the stage sensitivity of cell cycle stages to high-LET radiation. Furthermore, the numbers of aberrations per cell did not follow a Poisson distribution but were over dispersed, as might be expected since high-LET radiations have a high relative biological effectiveness compared with low-LET radiations. Nevertheless, lymphocytes exposed to 2 cGy of X-rays before radon exposure contained approximately one-half the number of chromatid deletions compared with lymphocytes treated with radon alone and analzed at the same time. Thus, the putative chromosomal repair mechanism induced by low doses of sparsely ionizing radiation is also effective in reducing chromosomal aberrations induced by radon, which hitherto had been thought to be relatively independent of repair processes.     

Induction of cytogenetic adaptive response in spermatogonia and spermatocytes by pre-exposure of mouse testis to low-dose (12)C(6+) ions

To investigate the effects of pre-exposure of mouse testis to low-dose (12)C(6+) ions on cytogenetics of spermatogonia and spermatocytes induced by subsequent high-dose irradiation, the testes of outbred Kun-Ming strain mice were irradiated with 0.05Gy of (12)C(6+) ions as the pre-exposure dose, and then irradiated with 2Gy as challenging dose at 4h after per-exposure. Poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARPs) activity and PARP-1 protein expression were respectively measured by using the enzymatic and Western blot assays at 4h after irradiation; chromosomal aberrations in spermatogonia and spermatocytes were analyzed by the air-drying method at 8h after irradiation. The results showed that there was a significant increase in the frequency of chromosomal aberrations and significant reductions of PARP activity and PARP-1 expression level in the mouse testes irradiated with 2Gy of (12)C(6+) ions. However, pre-exposure of mouse testes to a low dose of (12)C(6+) ions significantly increased PARPs activity and PARP-1 expression and alleviated the harmful effects induced by a subsequent high-dose irradiation. PARP activity inhibitor 3-aminobenzamide (3-AB) treatment blocked the effects of PARP-1 on cytogenetic adaptive response induced by low-dose (12)C(6+) ion irradiation. The data suggest that pre-exposure of testes to a low dose of heavy ions can induce cytogenetic adaptive response to subsequent high-dose irradiation. The increase of PARP-1 protein induced by the low-dose ionizing irradiation may be involved in the mechanism of these observations.     

Relationship between radiation induced adaptive response in human fibroblasts and changes in chromatin conformation

Chromatin conformation changes in the normal human fibroblasts VH-10 were studied by the method of anomalous viscosity time dependence (AVTD). Gamma-irradiation of cells in a dose range of 0.1–3 Gy caused an increase in maximal viscosity of cell lysates. Conversely, irradiation of cells with low doses of 0.5 or 2 cGy resulted in a decrease in the AVTD peaks with a maximum effect approximately 40 min after irradiation. The same exposure conditions were used to study a possible adaptive effect of low doses, measured by changes in cell survival. A primary dose of 2 cGy caused significant modification of cell response to a challenge dose. Approximately 20% protection to challenge doses of 0.5 Gy (p < 0.003), 2 Gy (p < 0.02) and 2.5 Gy (p < 0.002) was observed. However, the direction of this effect (adaptation or synergism) was found to be dependent on a challenge dose. The combined effect of 2 cGy and 1 Gy was significantly synergistic, while no modification was observed for 1.5 Gy and 3 Gy. A partial correlation was found between the AVTD changes and cell survival when the combined effect of a primary dose of 2 cGy and challenge dose was examined. The dose of 2 cGy alone increased survival by 16% (p < 0.0003). These results suggest that the low-dose induced effects on survival may be related to chromatin reorganization.