Sources of variability in foot and mouth disease vaccine potency estimates based on serum neutralizing antibody assay

Some vaccines can be assayed for potency by measuring the serum antibody response they produce in vaccinated test animals. Using data obtained from potency assays on batches of foot and mouth disease vaccine, the sources of variability in such a method were examined. A linear model is proposed for the analysis of replicate serum neutralizing antibody assays, which represents an improvement on the usual approach of working with only a mean serum assay value for each test animal. Components of variance were calculated, allowing the relative importance of the numbers of test animals, or the numbers of serum assays per test animal, to be estimated in terms of the variability of the overall group mean antibody response. A method is described for calculating fiducial intervals for the serological potency estimates, and it is shown that these intervals are no larger than, and are in fact probably smaller than, those obtained from quantal challenge tests. The results have important implications for the design and analysis of similar biological tests used for other products.     

Report on the international workshop on alternative methods for human and veterinary rabies vaccine testing: State of the science and planning the way forward

Potency testing of most human and veterinary rabies vaccines requires vaccination of mice followed by a challenge test using an intracerebral injection of live rabies virus. NICEATM, ICCVAM, and their international partners organized a workshop to review the availability and validation status of alternative methods that might reduce, refine, or replace the use of animals for rabies vaccine potency testing, and to identify research and development efforts to further advance alternative methods. Workshop participants agreed that general anesthesia should be used for intracerebral virus injections and that humane endpoints should be used routinely as the basis for euthanizing animals when conducting the mouse rabies challenge test. Workshop participants recommended as a near-term priority replacement of the mouse challenge with a test validated to ensure potency, such as the mouse antibody serum neutralization test for adjuvanted veterinary rabies vaccines for which an international collaborative study was recently completed. The workshop recommended that an in vitro antigen quantification test should be a high priority for product-specific validation of human and non-adjuvanted veterinary rabies vaccines. Finally, workshop participants recommended greater international cooperation to expedite development, validation, regulatory acceptance, and implementation of alternative test methods for rabies vaccine potency testing.     

Report on the international workshop on alternative methods for Leptospira vaccine potency testing: State of the science and the way forward

Routine potency testing of Leptospira vaccines is mostly conducted using a vaccination–challenge test that involves large numbers of hamsters and unrelieved pain and distress. NICEATM, ICCVAM, and their international partners organized a workshop to review the state of the science of alternative methods that might replace, reduce, and refine the use of animals for veterinary Leptospira vaccine potency testing and to identify ways to advance improved alternative methods. Vaccine manufacturers were encouraged to initiate or continue product-specific validation using in vitro enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays as replacements for potency testing of four common Leptospira serogroups. Participants discussed the potential for eliminating the back-titration procedure in the hamster challenge assay, which could reduce animal use by 50% for each individual potency test. Further animal reduction may also be possible by using cryopreserved Leptospira stock to replace continual passaging through hamsters. Serology assays were identified as a way to further reduce and refine animal use but should be considered only after attempting in vitro assays. Workshop participants encouraged consideration of analgesics and use of earlier humane endpoints when the hamster vaccination–challenge potency assay is used. International harmonization of alternative potency methods was recommended to avoid duplicative potency testing to meet regionally different requirements.     

A multi-dose serological assay suitable to quantify the potency of inactivated rabies vaccines for veterinary use

The mouse vaccination-challenge test, which is the most widely used method for determining the potency of inactivated rabies vaccines, is imprecise, time-consuming, and causes severe distress to the test animals. An alternative single-dose serological method has been implemented in the European Pharmacopoeia Monograph 0451 to replace the mouse challenge test for batch release. This single-dose limit method provides semi-quantitative results, but is not suitable for quantifying potency. We have now extended this serological method to a multi-dose format which allows a quantification of vaccine potency. In studies including all rabies vaccine strains relevant for Europe, we found dose-dependency for all vaccines and standard preparations. We have demonstrated that the multi-dose serological approach provides reliable quantitative potency results and is more precise than the mouse vaccination-challenge test. We have shown that adjuvanted vaccines can be calibrated against non-adjuvanted material, and that reference material can be calibrated against the International Standard. The method is therefore capable of assigning potency with the additional advantage of requiring fewer animals and reducing distress. Once the applicability of the method has been further verified in a collaborative study, it can complement the single-dose assay and eventually eliminate the need for the mouse challenge test.     

Investigation of an Aerosol Challenge Model as Alternative to the Intracerebral Mouse Protection Test for Potency Assay of Whole Cell Pertussis Vaccines

The current potency test for whole cell pertussis vaccines, the intracerebral mouse protection test, is still the only assay which has shown a correlation with protection in children. However, it has considerable disadvantages as it uses a severe challenge procedure and the results tend to show significant intra- and inter-laboratory variation. An alternative assay based on non-lethal aerosol challenge of mice has been investigated as a replacement for the current intracerebral mouse protection test. Evaluation of this indicated that the aerosol system allowed consistent inoculation of bacteria into mice and gave good reproducibility. The protective capacity of different vaccine preparations was distinguished by this assay. Furthermore, the viable counts of Bordetella pertussis in the lungs of challenged mice were immunisation dose-dependent, which allowed the relative potency of vaccines to be calculated. Comparison of potency of five batches of vaccine from different manufacturers assayed by both the intracerebral and the aerosol challenge methods ranked the vaccines in identical order. The results suggest that this method has potential for use as a potency test for whole cell pertussis vaccine which would result in a great reduction in the number of animals used. It would also replace the lethal challenge by a non-lethal procedure and thereby avoid the use of the severe intracerebral challenge procedure.     

An investigation of a mouse model to estimate the potency of the diphtheria component in vaccines

A mouse model to estimate the potency of the diphtheria toxoid components in vaccines using Vero cells to detect the neutralizing antibodies in the sera from immunized mice is described. The results obtained with this mouse model correlated significantly with those obtained in the lethal challenge test in guinea-pigs. For this reason it is suggested that the potency test in guinea-pigs be replaced by this mouse model because a considerable reduction in the number of animals used and costs can be achieved by the introduction of this mouse test for the routine control of the potency of the diphtheria component of vaccines.     

Reduction of numbers of animals used in the quality control of biologicals

Laboratory animals are used for the quality control of vaccines. In particular, the potency testing of batches of inactivated vaccine requires large numbers of animals. The possibilities for reduction have been evaluated, and the results are summarised in this paper. Several approaches were studied, including the retrospective analysis of test data, with the objectives of determining the minimum number of animals required per vaccine dilution group, and evaluating the feasibility of a single-dose potency test. Other studies focused on the development of serology-based models and the use of genetically uniform animals. Based on the outcome of these studies, a substantial reduction in the number of animals used for the potency testing of toxoid vaccines has been achieved or will be achieved in the near future. As reduction alternatives can generally be explored in a relatively simpler and less time-consuming way than replacement alternatives, more emphasis should be placed on reduction strategies than at present.     

The rapid fluorescent focus inhibition test is a suitable method for batch potency testing of inactivated rabies vaccines

The European Pharmacopoeia proposes two methods for potency determination of inactivated rabies vaccines for veterinary use: The first one is a classical mouse challenge test, which is imprecise, time-consuming, and causes severe distress to the test animals. Alternatively, the potency may be determined serologically by measuring the neutralizing antibody titers induced after vaccination of mice by using a rapid fluorescent focus inhibition test (RFFIT). Although this method is faster and less painful for the animals, it is not widely used yet, and only little data exist concerning the comparability of both methods.We have therefore performed a comparative study, in which we demonstrated a good correlation between the challenge test results and the mean titers determined by RFFIT. Furthermore, all vaccine batches failing the challenge test were also recognized as insufficient in the serological assay. This publication further describes the influence of different vaccine administration routes on the resulting antibody titers, and it proposes various modifications to the serological assay protocol which could improve its overall practicability. Finally, we recommend that the serological assay be used for the potency testing of inactivated rabies vaccines.     

Comparision of a serological potency assay for furunculosis vaccines (Aeromonas salmonicida subsp. salmonicida) to intraperitoneal challenge in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.)

Batch potency testing of salmonid vaccines is mainly performed by in vivo challenge, which requires a lot of animals and causes severe pain. Due to the animal welfare concerns associated with in vivo immunization challenge tests, methods which could refine, reduce or replace (3Rs) these tests are needed.The aim of this study was to assess the use of serological assay (immunization & antibody estimation with an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for batch potency testing of oil adjuvanted, inactivated commercial furunculosis vaccines. In total ten vaccines were included in the study: two commercial multi-component vaccines and two experimental single-component furunculosis vaccines with 5% and 20% antigen content (relative to the commercial vaccine), from two manufacturers. In addition two experimental single component vaccines based on A-layer positive and A-layer negative Aeromonas salmonicida respectively were included. Challenge and blood sampling were conducted 9 weeks post vaccination.There was a correlation between antibody response against A. salmonicida as measured by ELISA and protection in i.p. challenge.This study shows that the ELISA assay can be used for testing different vaccine formulations and can potentially replace in vivo challenge tests for batch potency testing of furunculosis vaccines.     

The use of the in vitro toxin binding inhibition (ToBI) test for the estimation of the potency of tetanus toxoid

The in vitro toxin binding inhibition (ToBI) test was used to determine antitoxin responses in mice immunized with tetanus toxoid. The ToBI test showed good correlation with the in vivo toxin neutralization (TN) test in titration of sera of mice immunized with various doses of DPT-Polio, DT-Polio and a tetanus reference preparation. Estimates of potency of tetanus toxoid obtained in mice by ToBI test correlated significantly with those obtained in mice by the lethal challenge test. In addition, potency values of the European reference preparation, succeedingly estimated by ToBI test and lethal challenge test in a single group of guinea-pigs, showed good correlation. From the study it is concluded that the ToBI test is a promising alternative to the toxic challenge procedure in the potency assay of tetanus toxoid vaccines. A substantial refinement and reduction in the use of animals can be achieved. Additional savings can be made by combining diphtheria and tetanus potency testing.     

The development of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for measuring the potency of vaccines containing Clostridium chauvoei antigens

Current standards (British Pharmacopeia (Veterinary) 1985) for vaccines containing Clostridium chauvoei require a potency test based on a challenge assay in guinea-pigs. Animal welfare and cost considerations favour the development of alternatives. Most veterinary clostridial vaccines are multi component, requiring assays in rabbits to test the potency of components other than C. chauvoei. We describe the application of an ELISA to measure the response to C. chauvoei vaccines in rabbits. The antigen is a sonicated extract of C. chauvoei strain CH4, intended to include a mixture of cellular and soluble antigens. The rabbit response to more than 70 vaccines containing C. chauvoei has been assessed against a reference serum which has been assigned an arbitrary potency of 100 units ml-1. The antibody titres of rabbit sera have been compared with the results of guinea-pig challenge potency tests on the same vaccines. The pass level in the guinea-pig potency test is equivalent to a rabbit ELISA titre of 50 units ml-1.     

Comparative efficacy of live replicating sheeppox vaccine strains in Ovines

In the present study, two sheeppox vaccines made from strains [sheeppox virus-Srinagar (SPPV-Srin) and Ranipet (SPPV-R)] indigenous to India and adapted to Vero cells were compared in terms of their safety, potency, efficacy and antigenic value with the commercial in-use Roumanian Fanar (SPPV-RF) vaccine, a foreign strain adapted in primary lamb testes cells. The safety test indicated that the SPPV (Sri and RF) vaccines were safe while SPPV-R was not completely attenuated and caused excessive adverse reactions at the passage level tested. The immunized animals showed DTH reaction and resisted virulent SPPV challenge, while control animals developed disease. Specific virus could be detected in the controls and animals immunized with lower dilutions of vaccines after challenge but not in any of the sheep immunized with 1 and 100 doses of each vaccine. All vaccines were found potent and the PD₅₀ was highest for SPPV (Srin and R) followed by RF. The immunized animals were seroconverted following vaccination with sustained antibody responses after challenge. In conclusion, indigenous SPPV-Srin vaccine was found to be as efficacious as SPPV-R and SPPV-RF vaccines. Thus, there is potential benefit in replacing the currently used commercial vaccine SPPV-RF with indigenous SPPV-Srin vaccine for use in India.     

Potency assays for therapeutic live whole cell cancer vaccines.

Therapeutic cancer vaccines are under development with the goal of enhancing the body's immune response to cancer cells sufficient to arrest cancer cell growth. Among the various approaches being used are those based on whole tumor cells. Developing a suitable measure of the potency of such vaccines presents a significant challenge because neither cellular associated markers nor in vivo biological responses that are correlated with efficacy have been identified; nevertheless, manufacturers and regulatory agencies will need to develop methods to evaluate these products. At this moment, the challenge for manufacturers who are developing whole cell vaccines is to demonstrate batch-to-batch consistency for the vaccine used in clinical studies and to show that comparable vaccine batches have the same capacity to achieve an acceptable level of biological activity that may be related to efficacy. This is particularly challenging in that animal models to test that activity do not exist and direct serological or immunological correlates of clinical protection are not available because protection has not yet been established in clinical trials. In the absence of well-defined biological markers and tests for manufacturing consistency, manufacturers and regulators will need to rely heavily on a highly reproducible manufacturing process--the consistency of the process therefore becomes critical. In developing regulatory approaches to whole cell cancer vaccines, the experience from the field of infectious disease vaccines should be examined for general guidance. A framework that draws heavily on the field of infectious disease vaccines is presented and suggests that at this point in the development of this new class of products, it is reasonable to develop data on quantitative antigen expression as a measure of potency with the expectation that when clinical efficacy has been established it will confirm the appropriateness of this approach. But because this will not be known until the end of a pivotal trial, a bioassay should be considered and run in parallel. Several examples of bioassays are presented along with their advantages and disadvantages. The final selection of a potency assay for use in lot release of a commercializable therapeutic whole cell vaccine ultimately will depend on the totality of the data available at the time of approval by regulatory agencies. Based on information currently available, it is likely that quantitative antigen expression or a bioassay could be used to measure potency. If both are determined to be acceptable, the use of quantitative antigen expression could be considered for routine lot release, while the bioassay could be reserved for use as one of the elements in establishing comparability when manufacturing changes are being considered after approval.     

Approaches to the control of acellular pertussis vaccines.

The quality control of acellular pertussis vaccines presents particular problems related to the differences in composition and method of detoxification used in the various type of preparation. These vaccines are not amenable to potency assay by the active mouse protection test used for whole-cell pertussis vaccines and assurance of protective activity is problematic.In contrast, monitoring of these vaccines for safety is relatively straightforward and is centred on assays for the lipooligosaccharide endotoxin, active pertussis toxin and absence of reversion to toxicity of detoxified product. The absence of heat-labile toxin, tracheal cytotoxin and adenyl cyclase toxin is assumed provided that adequate validation of the process has been performed.Confirmation of the antigenic content of the detoxified bulk components is difficult to achieve by conventional binding assays based on monoclonal antibodies because of changes in accessibility of reactive sites post-toxoiding. However, single radial diffusion assay using polyclonal antisera permits estimation of pertussis toxoid (PT), filamentous haemagglutinin (FHA) and pertactin (P69). Dot blot immunoassay can be used for the fimbrial agglutinogens 2 and 3 (Fim 2 and 3) and potentially could also be used to check the composition of final filling lots for PT, FHA, P69 and Fim 2 and 3.Gel electrophoresis and immunoblotting can be applied to monitor purity of purified bulk components and the characteristics of these change after chemical detoxification. Electron microscopy provides a useful semi-quantitative supporting method for checking purity of bulk components. Physico-chemical examination, particularly CD and fluorescence spectroscopy, offer a means of monitoring the consistency of detoxified bulk components.No completely satisfactory method is available for monitoring potency. Immunogenicity assays may be useful for checking consistency but do not necessarily correlate with protection. At present, active protection against aerosol challenge offers the best prospect of a functional assay.     

Feasibility of the use of ELISA in an immunogenicity-based potency test of anthrax vaccines

Complexities of lethal challenge animal models have prompted the investigation of immunogenicity assays as potency tests of anthrax vaccines. An ELISA was used to measure the antibody response to protective antigen (PA) in mice immunized once with a commercially available (AVA) or a recombinant PA vaccine (rPAV) formulated in-house with aluminum hydroxide. Results from the anti-PA ELISA were used to select a single dose appropriate for the development of a potency test. Immunization with 0.2 mL of AVA induced a measurable response in the majority of animals. This dose was located in the linear range of the vaccine dose–antibody response curve. In the case of rPAV, practical limitations prevented the finding of the best single dose for the potency testing of purified vaccines. In additional immunogenicity experiments neither the magnitude of the response to a single dose of vaccine, nor the estimation of the dose necessary to induce a measurable response were able to consistently detect brief exposure of vaccines to potentially damaging temperatures. However, differences detected for rPAV in the proportion of mice responding to the same dose of treated and untreated vaccine suggested that further assay development to increase the sensitivity of the latter design may be warranted.     

增强DNA疫苗免疫应答的新进展

DNA疫苗为编码抗原蛋白的真核表达载体,注入体内后在原位表达所编码的抗原并诱导免疫应答,在预防感染、治疗自身免疫性疾病、过敏性疾病和肿瘤等疫病中有着很好的应用前景。但与灭活疫苗相比,其免疫效价还比较低。有多种策略能够增强或调节DNA疫苗诱导的免疫应答,其中,作为外源基因载体的质粒的组成及插入的有关基因均可直接或间接地影响免疫反应的效果,在构建DNA疫苗质粒时,加入细胞因子、融合信号、泛素等基因以及ISS序列,另外还可以通过设计一些对抗原提成细胞有影响的分子共注射,以及加入转移分子,都可以明显增强DNA疫苗的免疫效果,从而有利于研制更有效的DNA疫苗。     

Mouse Potency Assay for Western Equine Encephalomyelitis Vaccines

A potency assay for Western equine encephalomyelitis vaccine was developed which utilized mice as the test animal instead of guinea pigs or hamsters. By immunizing several groups of mice with dilutions of the vaccine and challenging them intracerebrally with virulent virus, it was possible to determine mathematically a dose of vaccine capable of protecting 50% of the animals (ED(50)). When log dilutions of virulent virus were used to challenge mice which were immunized with dilutions of the vaccine, there was no difference among the ED(50) values for the dilutions of challenge virus. In a direct comparison of ED(50) values determined from the immunization of mice and those determined from the immunization of guinea pigs, there were no differences in the rankings of the vaccines.     

炭疽活疫苗家兔免疫力与血清抗芽胞IgG关系的研究

炭疽疫苗是预防炭疽流行和炭疽生物恐怖的重要手段。已有动物实验表明,炭疽活疫苗的保护力优于以保护性抗原为主要成份的无细胞疫苗,但两类现行疫苗都有待重新评价和改进。炭疽疫苗的效力必须用适当的实验室方法进行检测与分析才能了解其性质和细节。试验中力图探寻炭疽活疫苗家兔免疫力与血清抗芽胞抗体水平的关系。用“皮上划痕人用炭疽活疫苗”免疫家兔,以特定制备的炭疽芽胞抗原用ELISA法检测血清抗炭疽芽胞IgG抗体水平,并用强毒炭疽杆菌攻击进行效力试验。免疫家兔血清几何平均抗芽胞IgG滴度在免疫后一个月内持续升高,14d达到206,28d时达到776,这时其抵抗20MLD毒菌攻击的保护率为80％,符合中国生物制品规程要求的保护力。一个月后抗体水平开始下降,42d时滴度降至223。实验所揭示的炭疽减毒活疫苗诱导的家兔抗芽胞IgG抗体与抗炭疽保护力之间的关系,既为评价现行疫苗提供了资料,也为研制新型疫苗建立了参考性指标。     

The influence of the inactivating agent on the antigen content of inactivated Newcastle disease vaccines assessed by the in vitro potency test

An in vitro potency test has recently been included in the European Pharmacopoeia (EP) monograph (01/2007:0870) to assess the potency of inactivated Newcastle disease (ND) vaccines. This enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) is an attractive alternative for the existing in vivo potency tests especially with regard to the objective of the European Authorities to Replace, Reduce and Refine the use of laboratory animals for production and quality control of immunobiologicals.In the present study the influence of the inactivant on the antigen content established by ELISA was evaluated. Therefore, oil based vaccines containing similar concentrations of β-propiolactone (BPL) or formaldehyde inactivated Newcastle disease virus (NDV) were examined by ELISA and in the in vivo potency tests outlined in the EP.The results obtained demonstrate that the use of formaldehyde as inactivant lowered the in vitro potency compared to BPL as inactivant. In contrast, the in vivo potency was not affected. Therefore, the ELISA should not be used to compare the potency of commercial ND vaccines containing formaldehyde inactivated NDV with those containing BPL inactivated NDV. However, the ELISA is considered an attractive alternative for the existing in vivo potency tests since it can be used by vaccine manufacturers for the release of inactivated ND vaccines.     

用概率单位-平行线法和常规法统计分析几种疫苗效力检测结果的比较

本文采用概率转换-平行线法并应用微机程序对乙肝疫苗30批、狂犬疫苗34批双百日咳菌苗30批的效力试验结果进行了统计分析,并与现行常现统计法即Reed-Muench和Wilsonworcester法统计结果作了比较。 1.采用P-P法统计分析乙肝疫苗、狂犬病疫苗及百日咳菌苗效力试验结果,经对回归方程的线性及平行性检验成立的批数分别占83.3％、82.3％和83.3％,结果表明该法可以检查出由于动物差异及实验误差导致结果不成立的批数,应予复试。 2.P-P法与常规法(R-M法及W-W法)统计分析给果对三种制品评价一致的符合率分别为80％、79.4％和76.6％,两会判定结果一致,但前者更有科学性。 3.由P-P法统计分析结果,三种制品都有部分批的95％可信区间上下限值差距较大,该差距来源于动物差异及实验误差,说明在检测试验中,必需按规程要求严格筛选适宜动物和严格试验操作,以减少实验误差。对效力值可信区间应控制何种适宜范围,尚需作进一步探讨。