Protein�Cprotein binding affinities by pulse proteolysis: Application to TEM-1/BLIP protein complexes

Efficient methods for quantifying dissociation constants have become increasingly important for high‐throughput mutagenesis studies in the postgenomic era. However, experimentally determining binding affinity is often laborious, requires large amounts of purified protein, and utilizes specialized equipment. Recently, pulse proteolysis has been shown to be a robust and simple method to determine the dissociation constants for a protein–ligand pair based on the increase in thermodynamic stability upon ligand binding. Here, we extend this technique to determine binding affinities for a protein–protein complex involving the β‐lactamase TEM‐1 and various β‐lactamase inhibitor protein (BLIP) mutants. Interaction with BLIP results in an increase in the denaturation curve midpoint, C_m, of TEM‐1, which correlates with the rank order of binding affinities for several BLIP mutants. Hence, pulse proteolysis is a simple, effective method to assay for mutations that modulate binding affinity in protein–protein complexes. From a small set (n = 4) of TEM‐1/BLIP mutant complexes, a linear relationship between energy of stabilization (dissociation constant) and ΔC_m was observed. From this “calibration curve,” accurate dissociation constants for two additional BLIP mutants were calculated directly from proteolysis‐derived ΔC_m values. Therefore, in addition to qualitative information, armed with knowledge of the dissociation constants from the WT protein and a limited number of mutants, accurate quantitation of binding affinities can be determined for additional mutants from pulse proteolysis. Minimal sample requirements and the suitability of impure protein preparations are important advantages that make pulse proteolysis a powerful tool for high‐throughput mutagenesis binding studies.     

Membrane lateral phase separation induced by proteins of the prothrombinase complex

Blood coagulation factors X and V, as well as prothrombin fragment 1 caused changes in the observed transition temperature (T_m) of appropriately constituted phospholipid vesicles upon binding to the membrane surface. Factor X- and prothrombin fragment 1-induced T_m shifts were calcium-dependent, while factor V changed the T_m in a calcium-independent manner. The results were consistent with clustering of the acidic phospholipid molecules due to protein binding. In all cases, protein binding to acidic phospholipid-containing vesicles caused the observed T_m to approach that for the neutral phospholipid. This resulted in a T_m increase for phospholipid mixtures containing bovine brain phosphatidylserine (PS) plus dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) and a T_m decrease for mixtures of dipalmitoylphosphatidic acid (DPPA) and dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC). Maximum T_m shifts induced in PS-DPPC (10:90) vesicles were very similar for all the prothrombinase proteins and the extent of the change was proportional to the actual amount of membrane-bound protein as determined by light-scattering techniques. For the vitamin K-dependent proteins, T_m changes were greater in the presence of protein plus calcium than in the presence of calcium alone, indicating that lateral phase separation occurs subsequent to initial protein-membrane contact. Lateral phase separation of acidic phospholipids appears to be an important process in the formation of the prothrombinase complex.     

Sequence- and structural-selective nucleic acid binding revealed by the melting of mixtures

A simple method for the detection of sequence- and structural-selective ligand binding to nucleic acids is described. The method is based on the commonly used thermal denaturation method in which ligand binding is registered as an elevation in the nucleic acid melting temperature (T_m). The method can be extended to yield a new, higher -throughput, assay by the simple expediency of melting designed mixtures of polynucleotides (or oligonucleotides) with different sequences or structures of interest. Upon addition of ligand to such mixtures at low molar ratios, the T_m is shifted only for the nucleic acid containing the preferred sequence or structure. Proof of principle of the assay is provided using first a mixture of polynucleotides with different sequences and, second, with a mixture containing DNA, RNA and two types of DNA:RNA hybrid structures. Netropsin, ethidium, daunorubicin and actinomycin, ligands with known sequence preferences, were used to illustrate the method. The applicability of the approach to oligonucleotide systems is illustrated by the use of simple ternary and binary mixtures of defined sequence deoxyoligonucleotides challenged by the bisanthracycline WP631. The simple mixtures described here provide proof of principle of the assay and pave the way for the development of more sophisticated mixtures for rapidly screening the selectivity of new nucleic acid binding compounds.     

Reversible and non-reversible thermal denaturation of lysozyme with varying pH at low ionic strength

DSC analysis has been used to quantify the reversibility of unfolding following thermal denaturation of lysozyme. Since the temperature at which protein unfolding occurs, T_m, varies with different solution conditions, the effect on the melting temperature and the degree of refolding after thermal denaturation in low ionic strength sodium phosphate buffers (5–1000 mM) over a range of pH (5–9) in the presence/absence of disaccharides is examined. This study compares the enthalpies of unfolding during successive heating cycles to quantify reversibility following thermal denaturation. The disaccharides, trehalose and maltose were used to assess if the disaccharide induced increase in T_m is reflected in the reversibility of thermally induced denaturation. There was extensive overlap between the T_m values where non-reversible and reversible thermal denaturation occurred. Indeed, for pH 6, at the highest and lowest T_m, no refolding was observed whereas refolding was observed for intermediate values, but with similar T_m values having different proportions of refolded protein. We established a method to measure the degree of reversible unfolding following thermal denaturation and hence indirectly, the degree to which protein is lost to irreversible aggregation, and show that solution conditions which increase melt transition temperatures do not automatically confer an increase in reversibility. This type of analysis may prove useful in assessing the stability of proteins in both the biopharmaceutical and food industries.     

A combinatorial biophysical approach; FTSA and SPR for identifying small molecule ligands and PAINs

Biophysical methods have emerged as attractive screening techniques in drug discovery both as primary hit finding methodologies, as in the case of weakly active compounds such as fragments, and as orthogonal methods for hit validation for compounds discovered through conventional biochemical or cellular assays. Here we describe a dual method employing fluorescent thermal shift assay (FTSA), also known as differential scanning fluorimetry (DSF) and surface plasmon resonance (SPR), to interrogate ligands of the kinase p38α as well as several known pan-assay interference compounds (PAINs) such as aggregators, redox cyclers, and fluorescence quenchers. This combinatorial approach allows for independent verification of several biophysical parameters such as K_D, k_on, k_off, ΔG, ΔS, and ΔH, which may further guide chemical development of a ligand series. Affinity values obtained from FTSA curves allow for insight into compound binding compared with reporting shifts in melting temperature. Ligand–p38 interaction data were in good agreement with previous literature. Aggregators and fluorescence quenchers appeared to reduce fluorescence signal in the FTSAs, causing artificially high shifts in T_m values, whereas redox compounds caused either shifts in affinity that did not agree between FTSA and SPR or a depression of FTSA signal.     

Single-cell measurements of two-dimensional binding affinity across cell contacts

The two-dimensional (2D) affinity between protein molecules across contacting cells is a key parameter regulating and initiating several cellular processes. However, measuring 2D affinity can be challenging, and experimental data are limited. In addition, the obtained 2D affinities are typically averaged over the cell population. We here present a method to measure 2D affinity on single cells binding to polyhistidine-tagged fluorescent ligands anchored to a supported lipid bilayer (SLB). By decreasing the density of ligands in the SLB using imidazole, a new steady-state accumulation in the contact is obtained, and from this change, both the 2D affinity and the number of receptors on the cell can be determined. The method was validated on an SLB containing rat CD2 binding to the rat CD48 mutant T92A expressed on Jurkat T cells. The addition of imidazole did not influence the average 2D affinity (1/K_d), and the spread in affinities within the cell population was low, K_d = 4.9 ± 0.9 molecules/μm² (mean ± SD), despite an order of magnitude spread in ligand accumulation because of differences in receptor density. It was also found that cell contact size increased both with ligand density and with the number of receptors per cell but that the contact size stayed approximately constant when lowering the ligand density, above a density of around 10 rat CD2 molecules/μm², after the contact first had formed, indicative of a heterogeneous process. In summary, this method not only allows for single-cell affinities to be measured, but it can also reduce measurement and analysis time and improve measurement accuracy. Because of the low spread in 2D K_d within the cell population, the analysis can further be restricted to the cells showing the strongest binding, paving the way for using this method to study weak binding events.     

Ligand-induced conformational changes in a thermophilic ribose-binding protein

Background

Members of the periplasmic binding protein (PBP) superfamily are involved in transport and signaling processes in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Biological responses are typically mediated by ligand-induced conformational changes in which the binding event is coupled to a hinge-bending motion that brings together two domains in a closed form. In all PBP-mediated biological processes, downstream partners recognize the closed form of the protein. This motion has also been exploited in protein engineering experiments to construct biosensors that transduce ligand binding to a variety of physical signals. Understanding the mechanistic details of PBP conformational changes, both global (hinge bending, twisting, shear movements) and local (rotamer changes, backbone motion), therefore is not only important for understanding their biological function but also for protein engineering experiments.

Results

Here we present biochemical characterization and crystal structure determination of the periplasmic ribose-binding protein (RBP) from the hyperthermophile Thermotoga maritima in its ribose-bound and unliganded state. The T. maritima RBP (tmRBP) has 39% sequence identity and is considerably more resistant to thermal denaturation ( ^app T _m value is 108°C) than the mesophilic Escherichia coli homolog (ecRBP) ( ^app T _m value is 56°C). Polar ligand interactions and ligand-induced global conformational changes are conserved among ecRBP and tmRBP; however local structural rearrangements involving side-chain motions in the ligand-binding site are not conserved.

Conclusion

Although the large-scale ligand-induced changes are mediated through similar regions, and are produced by similar backbone movements in tmRBP and ecRBP, the small-scale ligand-induced structural rearrangements differentiate the mesophile and thermophile. This suggests there are mechanistic differences in the manner by which these two proteins bind their ligands and are an example of how two structurally similar proteins utilize different mechanisms to form a ligand-bound state.     

LCP-Tm: An Assay to Measure and Understand Stability of Membrane Proteins in a Membrane Environment

Structural and functional studies of membrane proteins are limited by their poor stability outside the native membrane environment. The development of novel methods to efficiently stabilize membrane proteins immediately after purification is important for biophysical studies, and is likely to be critical for studying the more challenging human targets. Lipidic cubic phase (LCP) provides a suitable stabilizing matrix for studying membrane proteins by spectroscopic and other biophysical techniques, including obtaining highly ordered membrane protein crystals for structural studies. We have developed a robust and accurate assay, LCP-T_m, for measuring the thermal stability of membrane proteins embedded in an LCP matrix. In its two implementations, protein denaturation is followed either by a change in the intrinsic protein fluorescence on ligand release, or by an increase in the fluorescence of a thiol-binding reporter dye that measures exposure of cysteines buried in the native structure. Application of the LCP-T_m assay to an engineered human β₂-adrenergic receptor and bacteriorhodopsin revealed a number of factors that increased protein stability in LCP. This assay has the potential to guide protein engineering efforts and identify stabilizing conditions that may improve the chances of obtaining high-resolution structures of intrinsically unstable membrane proteins.     

Thermostabilization of Ovotransferrin by Anions for Pasteurization of Liquid Egg White

The effects of anions on the thermostability of ovotransferrin (oTf) were investigated. The temperature, T_m, causing aggregation of oTf was measured in the presence or absence of anions, and the denaturation temperature, T_m^DSC, was also determined by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) in the presence of the citrate anion. We found that some anions (phosphate, sulfate and citrate) raised temperature T_m of oTf by about 5–7 °C. However, neither sodium chloride nor sodium bicarbonate raised T_m by that much. Temperature T_m was increased by increasing the concentration of the citrate anion, and was in good agreement with denaturation temperature T_m^DSC, suggesting that denaturation of the oTf molecules resulted in aggregation of oTf. We also demonstrated that the anions, especially sulfate, repressed the heat-aggregation of liquid egg white.

The Van’t Hoff plot from the T_m and ΔH_d values revealed that two anion-binding sites were concerned with heat stabilization. These binding sites may have been concerned with sulfate binding (not bicarbonate binding) that is found in the crystal structure of apo-form of oTf, since the bicarbonate anion did not raise T_m.     

Updates to Binding MOAD (Mother of All Databases): Polypharmacology Tools and Their Utility in Drug Repurposing

The goal of Binding MOAD is to provide users with a data set focused on high-quality x-ray crystal structures that have been solved with biologically relevant ligands bound. Where available, experimental binding affinities (K_a, K_d, K_i, IC₅₀) are provided from the primary literature of the crystal structure. The database has been updated regularly since 2005, and this most recent update has added nearly 7000 new structures (growth of 21%). MOAD currently contains 32,747 structures, composed of 9117 protein families and 16,044 unique ligands. The data are freely available on www.BindingMOAD.org. This paper outlines updates to the data in Binding MOAD as well as improvements made to both the website and its contents. The NGL viewer has been added to improve visualization of the ligands and protein structures. MarvinJS has been implemented, over the outdated MarvinView, to work with JChem for small molecule searching in the database. To add tools for predicting polypharmacology, we have added information about sequence, binding-site, and ligand similarity between entries in the database. A main premise behind polypharmacology is that similar binding sites will bind similar ligands. The large amount of protein–ligand information available in Binding MOAD allows us to compute pairwise ligand and binding-site similarities. Lists of similar ligands and similar binding sites have been added to allow users to identify potential polypharmacology pairs. To show the utility of the polypharmacology data, we detail a few examples from Binding MOAD of drug repurposing targets with their respective similarities.     

Molecular recognition of poly(A) by small ligands: an alternative method of analysis reveals nanomolar, cooperative and shape-selective binding

A few drug-like molecules have recently been found to bind poly(A) and induce a stable secondary structure (T_m ≈ 60°C), even though this RNA homopolymer is single-stranded in the absence of a ligand. Here, we report results from experiments specifically designed to explore the association of small molecules with poly(A). We demonstrate that coralyne, the first small molecule discovered to bind poly(dA), binds with unexpectedly high affinity (K_a >10⁷ M⁻¹), and that the crescent shape of coralyne appears necessary for poly(A) binding. We also show that the binding of similar ligands to poly(A) can be highly cooperative. For one particular ligand, at least six ligand molecules are required to stabilize the poly(A) self-structure at room temperature. This highly cooperative binding produces very sharp transitions between unstructured and structured poly(A) as a function of ligand concentration. Given the fact that junctions between Watson–Crick and A·A duplexes are tolerated, we propose that poly(A) sequence elements and appropriate ligands could be used to reversibly drive transitions in DNA and RNA-based molecular structures by simply diluting/concentrating a sample about the poly(A)-ligand ‘critical concentration’. The ligands described here may also find biological or medicinal applications, owing to the 3′-polyadenylation of mRNA in living cells.     

Exploring the Denatured State Ensemble by Single-Molecule Chemo-Mechanical Unfolding: The Effect of Force,Temperature, and Urea

While it is widely appreciated that the denatured state of a protein is a heterogeneous conformational ensemble, there is still debate over how this ensemble changes with environmental conditions. Here, we use single-molecule chemo-mechanical unfolding, which combines force and urea using the optical tweezers, together with traditional protein unfolding studies to explore how perturbants commonly used to unfold proteins (urea, force, and temperature) affect the denatured-state ensemble. We compare the urea m-values, which report on the change in solvent accessible surface area for unfolding, to probe the denatured state as a function of force, temperature, and urea. We find that while the urea- and force-induced denatured states expose similar amounts of surface area, the denatured state at high temperature and low urea concentration is more compact. To disentangle these two effects, we use destabilizing mutations that shift the T_m and C_m. We find that the compaction of the denatured state is related to changing temperature as the different variants of acyl-coenzyme A binding protein have similar m-values when they are at the same temperature but different urea concentration. These results have important implications for protein folding and stability under different environmental conditions.     

HTSDSF Explorer,A Novel Tool to Analyze High-throughput DSF Screenings

The identification of new drugs for novel therapeutic targets requires the screening of libraries containing tens of thousands of compounds. While experimental screenings are assisted by high-throughput technologies, in target-based biophysical assays, such as differential scanning fluorimetry (DSF), the analysis steps must be calculated manually, often combining several software packages. To simplify the determination of the melting temperature (T_m) of the target and the change induced by ligand binding (ΔT_m), we developed the HTSDSF explorer, a versatile, all-in-one, user-friendly application suite. Implemented as a server-client application, in the primary screenings, HTSDSF explorer pre-analyzes and displays the T_m and ΔT_m results interactively, thereby allowing the user to study hundreds of conditions and select the primary hits in minutes. This application also allows the determination of preliminary binding constants (K_D) through a series of subsequent dose–response assays on the primary hits, thereby facilitating the ranking of validated hits and the advance of drug discovery efforts.     

Isothermal chemical denaturation to determine binding affinity of small molecules to G-protein coupled receptors

The determination of accurate binding affinities is critical in drug discovery and development. Several techniques are available for characterizing the binding of small molecules to soluble proteins. The situation is different for integral membrane proteins. Isothermal chemical denaturation has been shown to be a valuable biophysical method to determine, in a direct and label-free fashion, the binding of ligands to soluble proteins. In this study, the application of isothermal chemical denaturation was applied to an integral membrane protein, the A2a G-protein coupled receptor. Binding affinities for a set of 19 small molecule agonists/antagonists of the A2a receptor were determined and found to be in agreement with data from surface plasmon resonance and radioligand binding assays previously reported in the literature. Therefore, isothermal chemical denaturation expands the available toolkit of biophysical techniques to characterize and study ligand binding to integral membrane proteins, specifically G-protein coupled receptors in vitro.     

Protein Structure Validation and Refinement Using Amide Proton Chemical Shifts Derived from Quantum Mechanics

We present the ProCS method for the rapid and accurate prediction of protein backbone amide proton chemical shifts - sensitive probes of the geometry of key hydrogen bonds that determine protein structure. ProCS is parameterized against quantum mechanical (QM) calculations and reproduces high level QM results obtained for a small protein with an RMSD of 0.25 ppm (r = 0.94). ProCS is interfaced with the PHAISTOS protein simulation program and is used to infer statistical protein ensembles that reflect experimentally measured amide proton chemical shift values. Such chemical shift-based structural refinements, starting from high-resolution X-ray structures of Protein G, ubiquitin, and SMN Tudor Domain, result in average chemical shifts, hydrogen bond geometries, and trans-hydrogen bond (^h3 J_NC'') spin-spin coupling constants that are in excellent agreement with experiment. We show that the structural sensitivity of the QM-based amide proton chemical shift predictions is needed to obtain this agreement. The ProCS method thus offers a powerful new tool for refining the structures of hydrogen bonding networks to high accuracy with many potential applications such as protein flexibility in ligand binding.     

Thermal inactivation scaling applied for SARS-CoV-2

Based on a model of protein denaturation rate limited by an entropy-related barrier, we derive a simple formula for virus inactivation time as a function of temperature. Loss of protein structure is described by two reaction coordinates: conformational disorder of the polymer and wetting by the solvent. These establish a competition between conformational entropy and hydrophobic interaction favoring random coil or globular states, respectively. Based on the Landau theory of phase transition, the resulting free energy barrier is found to decrease linearly with the temperature difference T − T_m, and the inactivation rate should scale as U to the power of T − T_m. This form recalls an accepted model of thermal damage to cells in hyperthermia. For SARS-CoV-2 the value of U in Celsius units is found to be 1.32. Although the fitting of the model to measured data is practically indistinguishable from Arrhenius law with an activation energy, the entropy barrier mechanism is more suitable and could explain the pronounced sensitivity of SARS-CoV-2 to thermal damage. Accordingly, we predict the efficacy of mild fever over a period of ∼24 h in inactivating the virus.     

The Use of the Free Metal – Temperature ‘Phase Diagrams’ for Studies of Single Site Metal Binding Proteins

Typical physico-chemical studies of metal binding proteins are usually aimed at determination of the metal binding constant K for a native protein (K _n), while the significance of the K value for the thermally denatured protein (K _u) is usually underestimated. Meanwhile, metal binding induced shift of thermal denaturation transition of a single site metal binding protein is defined by K _n to K _u ratio, implying that knowledge of both K values is required for full characterization of the system. In the present work, the most universal approach to the studies of single site metal binding proteins, namely construction of a protein “phase diagram” in coordinates of free metal ion concentration – temperature, is considered in detail. The detailed algorithm of construction of the phase diagrams along with underlying mathematic procedures developed here may be of use for studies of other simple protein-target type systems, where target represents low molecular weight ligand. Analysis of the simplest protein-ligand system reveals that thermodynamic properties of apo-protein dictate the maximal possible increase of its affinity to any simple ligand upon thermal denaturation of the protein. Experimental and general problems coupled with the use of the phase diagrams are discussed.     

A high-throughput fluorescence chemical denaturation assay as a general screen for protein–ligand binding

Chemical denaturation of ligand–protein complexes can provide the basis of a label-free binding assay. Here, we show how the technique can be used as a sensitive/affordable screen of potential ligands from a pool of lead drug variants. To demonstrate, we characterized the binding of polyketide ligands based on the mTOR inhibitor rapamycin to the cellular immunophilin FKBP12. This used the intrinsic fluorescence of the protein to monitor the chemical denaturation of each FKBP12–ligand complex. The assay was then successfully modified to a 96-well plate-based screen. Both formats were able to differentiate binding affinities across a wide dynamic range.     

Interaction of spermine and DNA

The effect of spermine upon the denaturation temperature (T_m) of DNA's of various base compositions has been found to depend upon both the base composition of the DNA and the pH of the solution. Measurement of the hydrogen ion titration curve of spermine as a function of temperature reveals that the net charge of the spermine molecule is undergoing a rapid change with temperature in the range of temperatures at which DNA denatures. Since the value of T_m depends upon base composition, the correlation of the effect of spermine upon T_m with the base composition of the DNA used may be explainable in terms of the changing degree of ionization of spermine. The binding of spermine to native DNA has also been studied by dialysis equilibrium. There is no significant variation either in the number of strongly binding sites or strength of binding with base composition. It is concluded that there is no evidence of correlation between the binding of spermine and the base composition of DNA.