Deciphering how the chromatin factor RCC1 recognizes the nucleosome: the importance of individuals in the scientific discovery process

The nucleosome repeating unit of chromatin is the target of chromatin enzymes and factors that regulate gene activity in a eukaryotic cell. How the nucleosome is recognized by chromatin enzymes and factors is poorly understood, even though such interaction is fundamental to gene regulation and chromatin biology. My laboratory recently determined the structural basis for how the RCC1 (regulator of chromosome condensation 1) chromatin factor binds to the nucleosome, including the first atomic crystal structure of a chromatin protein complexed with the nucleosome core particle. I describe here how we developed and investigated structural models for RCC1 binding to the nucleosome using biochemical methods and how we crystallized the 300?kDa complex of RCC1 with the nucleosome core particle. This article highlights the contributions made by key laboratory members and explains our thinking and rationale during the discovery process.     

人源HDAC1/2-RbAp46/48核心复合物三维空间构象的电子显微分析

HDAC1、HDAC2和RbAp46、RbAp48是许多重要功能复合物(如NuRD、Sin3等)的核心亚基.这4个亚基在空间上相互作用,形成一个具有去乙酰化酶活性的核心复合物.但该核心复合物的三维空间构象及其对去乙酰化、染色质重塑等功能的可能影响还所知甚少.本研究中,我们包装了含4个亚基的杆状病毒,利用昆虫细胞表达、纯化了HDAC1/2-RbAp46/48核心复合物.在此基础上,利用电子显微镜单颗粒分析方法对该去乙酰化酶核心复合物的三维结构进行了初步解析.结果表明,HDAC1、HDAC2、RbAp46和RbAp48可以形成一个较为稳定均一的复合物,但该复合物中各个亚基并不是以单拷贝、等比例形式存在的.该核心复合物呈现一个非对称的鞍型结构,其背部隆起,大致形成一个三角形,两边分别有一大一小的两翼,两翼中间有个凹槽,直径大约为6 nm,推测为该核心复合物与核小体的结合位置.本研究结果为了解HDAC1/2-RbAp46/48去乙酰化酶复合物各亚基的空间结构组成、与核小体和染色质的可能相互作用以及研究去乙酰化酶活性的作用机理等提供了有益的信息.     

The helical model of the nucleosome core.

A model of the nucleosome core is proposed based on a topologically linear array of histones attached sequentially to DNA. The linear complex folds helically forming a spring-like particle. Different variants of the particle are discussed (cylindrical springs with and without histone-histone contacts between turns of the helix, solenoidal spring). The model is consistent with known data about the nucleosome structure. Histones H3 and H4 have a special role in the model which is related also to the superstructure of chromatin.     

Simulations of SIN mutations and histone variants in human nucleosomes reveal altered protein-DNA and core histone interactions

Alterations in the stability of a nucleosome exert predominant influence on chromatin structure and eukaryotic gene expression. In an attempt to investigate the mononucleosome stability using computational approaches, we have simulated the structure of a human mononucleosome and have compared their energies under the influence of core mutations, tail substitutions, variant histones, and orthologs. We observe that mutant nucleosomes carrying SIN (SWI Independent) mutations do not alter the overall nucleosomal structure but cause local structural changes leading to significant changes in energy and hence the stability. We observe that the nucleosome stability is altered by the substitution of only certain critical lysine residues on the H3 tails. Interestingly, the incorporation of variants H2A.Z and H3.3 lower nucleosome stability as evidenced by small energy changes. However, the substitution of histone orthologs did not alter structural stability. Our simulations to determine the nucleosome stability using energy trends emphasize the role of mutations, variants, and orthologs as determinants of chromatin structure at the nucleosome core particle level. The destabilization we observe on the human nucleosome with core mutations show similar trends of instability as validated experimentally in yeast.     

Simulations of SIN Mutations and Histone Variants in Human Nucleosomes Reveal Altered Protein-DNA and Core Histone Interactions

Abstract Alterations in the stability of a nucleosome exert predominant influence on chromatin structure and eukaryotic gene expression. In an attempt to investigate the mononucleosome stability using computational approaches, we have simulated the structure of a human mononucleosome and have compared their energies under the influence of core mutations, tail substitutions, variant histones, and orthologs. We observe that mutant nucleosomes carrying SIN (SWI Independent) mutations do not alter the overall nucleosomal structure but cause local structural changes leading to significant changes in energy and hence the stability. We observe that the nucleosome stability is altered by the substitution of only certain critical lysine residues on the H3 tails. Interestingly, the incorporation of variants H2A.Z and H3.3 lower nucleosome stability as evidenced by small energy changes. However, the substitution of histone orthologs did not alter structural stability. Our simulations to determine the nucleosome stability using energy trends emphasize the role of mutations, variants, and orthologs as determinants of chromatin structure at the nucleosome core particle level. The de-stabilization we observe on the human nucleosome with core mutations show similar trends of instability as validated experimentally in yeast.     

RCC1 regulates inner centromeric composition in a Ran-independent fashion

RCC1 associates to chromatin dynamically within mitosis and catalyzes Ran-GTP production. Exogenous RCC1 disrupts kinetochore structure in Xenopus egg extracts (XEEs), but the molecular basis of this disruption remains unknown. We have investigated this question, utilizing replicated chromosomes that possess paired sister kinetochores. We find that exogenous RCC1 evicts a specific subset of inner KT proteins including Shugoshin-1 (Sgo1) and the chromosome passenger complex (CPC). We generated RCC1 mutants that separate its enzymatic activity and chromatin binding. Strikingly, Sgo1 and CPC eviction depended only on RCC1's chromatin affinity but not its capacity to produce Ran-GTP. RCC1 similarly released Sgo1 and CPC from synthetic kinetochores assembled on CENP-A nucleosome arrays. Together, our findings indicate RCC1 regulates kinetochores at the metaphase-anaphase transition through Ran-GTP-independent displacement of Sgo1 and CPC.     

RCC1 Uses a Conformationally Diverse Loop Region to Interact with the Nucleosome: A Model for the RCC1-Nucleosome Complex

The binding of RCC1 (regulator of chromosome condensation 1) to chromatin is critical for cellular processes such as mitosis, nucleocytoplasmic transport, and nuclear envelope formation because RCC1 recruits the small GTPase Ran (Ras-related nuclear protein) to chromatin and sets up a Ran-GTP gradient around the chromosomes. However, the molecular mechanism by which RCC1 binds to nucleosomes, the repeating unit of chromatin, is not known. We have used biochemical approaches to test structural models for how the RCC1 β-propeller protein could bind to the nucleosome. In contrast to the prevailing model, RCC1 does not appear to use the β-propeller face opposite to its Ran-binding face to interact with nucleosomes. Instead, we find that RCC1 uses a conformationally flexible loop region we have termed the switchback loop in addition to its N-terminal tail to bind to the nucleosome. The juxtaposition of the RCC1 switchback loop to its Ran binding surface suggests a novel mechanism for how nucleosome-bound RCC1 recruits Ran to chromatin. Furthermore, this model accounts for previously unexplained observations for how Ran can interact with the nucleosome both dependent and independent of RCC1 and how binding of the nucleosome can enhance RCC1's Ran nucleotide exchange activity.     

Structure of the yeast nucleosome core particle reveals fundamental changes in internucleosome interactions

Chromatin is composed of nucleosomes, the universally repeating protein-DNA complex in eukaryotic cells. The crystal structure of the nucleosome core particle from Saccharomyces cerevisiae reveals that the structure and function of this fundamental complex is conserved between single-cell organisms and metazoans. Our results show that yeast nucleosomes are likely to be subtly destabilized as compared with nucleosomes from higher eukaryotes, consistent with the idea that much of the yeast genome remains constitutively open during much of its life cycle. Importantly, minor sequence variations lead to dramatic changes in the way in which nucleosomes pack against each other within the crystal lattice. This has important implications for our understanding of the formation of higher order chromatin structure and its modulation by post-translational modifications. Finally, the yeast nucleosome core particle provides a structural context by which to interpret genetic data obtained from yeast. Coordinates have been deposited with the Protein Data Bank under accession number 1ID3.     

Reconstitution of a functional core polycomb repressive complex

The opposing actions of polycomb (PcG) and trithorax group (trxG) gene products maintain essential gene expression patterns during Drosophila development. PcG proteins are thought to establish repressive chromatin structures, but the mechanisms by which this occurs are not known. Polycomb repressive complex 1 (PRC1) contains several PcG proteins and inhibits chromatin remodeling by trxG-related SWI/SNF complexes. We have defined a functional core of PRC1 by reconstituting a stable complex using four recombinant PcG proteins. One subunit, PSC, can also inhibit chromatin remodeling on its own. These PcG proteins create a chromatin structure that has normal nucleosome organization and is accessible to nucleases but excludes hSWI/SNF.     

Meta analysis of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome through integration of clinical, gene expression, SNP and proteomic data

The histone octamer induced bending of DNA into the super-helix structure in nucleosome core particle, is very unique and vital for DNA packing into chromatin. We collected 48 nucleosome crystal structures from PDB and applied a multivariate analysis on the nucleosome structural data. Based on the anisotropic nature of DNA structure, a principal conformational subspace (PCS) is derived from multiple properties to represent the most significant variances of nucleosome DNA structures. The coupling of base pair-oriented parameters with sugar phosphate backbone parameters presented in principal dimensionalities reveals two main deformation modes that have supplemented the existing physical model. By using sequence alignment-based statistics, a positiondependent conformational map for the super-helical DNA path is established. The result shows that the crystal structures of nucleosome DNA have much consistency in position-specific structural variations and certain periodicity is found to exist in these variations. Thus, the positions with obvious deformation patterns along the DNA path in nucleosome core particle are relatively conservative from the perspective of statistics.     

Bilayers of nucleosome core particles

Among the multiple effects involved in chromatin condensation and decondensation processes, interactions between nucleosome core particles are suspected to play a crucial role. We analyze them in the absence of linker DNA and added proteins, after the self-assembly of isolated nucleosome core particles under controlled ionic conditions. We describe an original lamellar mesophase forming tubules on the mesoscopic scale. High resolution imaging of cryosections of vitrified samples reveals how nucleosome core particles stack on top of one another into columns which themselves align to form bilayers that repel one another through a solvent layer. We deduce from this structural organization how the particles interact through attractive interactions between top and bottom faces and lateral polar interactions that originate in the heterogeneous charge distribution at the surface of the particle. These interactions, at work under conditions comparable with those found in the living cell, should be of importance in the mechanisms governing chromatin compaction in vivo.     

Nucleosome cores reconstituted from poly (dA-dT) and the octamer of histones.

In this paper we describe a detailed investigation of the reconstitution of nucleosome cores from poly (dA-dT) and the octamer of histones. We also attempted the reconstitution from the copolymers poly dA.poly dT, poly dG.poly dC and poly (dG-dC). The repeat of the reconstituted chromatin fibre is discussed. The micrococcal nuclease released poly (dA-dT) core particle is found to contain a considerably narrower DNA size distribution that of the native random DNA nucleosome core (12). In addition we have succeeded in obtaining small crystals of the poly (dA-dT) nucleosome core. The DNAase I digestion pattern of the poly (dA-dT) containing nucleosome core is presented. The periodicity of DNAase I cutting sites is found to be about 10.5 bases and is similar to that of the native nucleosome core (12, 13).     

The crystal structure of nucleoplasmin-core: implications for histone binding and nucleosome assembly.

The efficient assembly of histone complexes and nucleosomes requires the participation of molecular chaperones. Currently, there is a paucity of data on their mechanism of action. We now present the structure of an N-terminal domain of nucleoplasmin (Np-core) at 2.3 A resolution. The Np-core monomer is an eight-stranded beta barrel that fits snugly within a stable pentamer. In the crystal, two pentamers associate to form a decamer. We show that both Np and Np-core are competent to assemble large complexes that contain the four core histones. Further experiments and modeling suggest that these complexes each contain five histone octamers which dock to a central Np decamer. This work has important ramifications for models of histone storage, sperm chromatin decondensation, and nucleosome assembly.