The Bacillus subtilis conjugative transposon ICEBs1 mobilizes plasmids lacking dedicated mobilization functions

Integrative and conjugative elements (ICEs, also known as conjugative transposons) are mobile elements that are found integrated in a host genome and can excise and transfer to recipient cells via conjugation. ICEs and conjugative plasmids are found in many bacteria and are important agents of horizontal gene transfer and microbial evolution. Conjugative elements are capable of self-transfer and also capable of mobilizing other DNA elements that are not able to self-transfer. Plasmids that can be mobilized by conjugative elements are generally thought to contain an origin of transfer (oriT), from which mobilization initiates, and to encode a mobilization protein (Mob, a relaxase) that nicks a site in oriT and covalently attaches to the DNA to be transferred. Plasmids that do not have both an oriT and a cognate mob are thought to be nonmobilizable. We found that Bacillus subtilis carrying the integrative and conjugative element ICEBs1 can transfer three different plasmids to recipient bacteria at high frequencies. Strikingly, these plasmids do not have dedicated mobilization-oriT functions. Plasmid mobilization required conjugation proteins of ICEBs1, including the putative coupling protein. In contrast, plasmid mobilization did not require the ICEBs1 conjugative relaxase or cotransfer of ICEBs1, indicating that the putative coupling protein likely interacts with the plasmid replicative relaxase and directly targets the plasmid DNA to the ICEBs1 conjugation apparatus. These results blur the current categorization of mobilizable and nonmobilizable plasmids and indicate that conjugative elements play a role in horizontal gene transfer even more significant than previously recognized.     

A Conserved Helicase Processivity Factor Is Needed for Conjugation and Replication of an Integrative and Conjugative Element

Integrative and conjugative elements (ICEs) are agents of horizontal gene transfer and have major roles in evolution and acquisition of new traits, including antibiotic resistances. ICEs are found integrated in a host chromosome and can excise and transfer to recipient bacteria via conjugation. Conjugation involves nicking of the ICE origin of transfer (oriT) by the ICE–encoded relaxase and transfer of the nicked single strand of ICE DNA. For ICEBs1 of Bacillus subtilis, nicking of oriT by the ICEBs1 relaxase NicK also initiates rolling circle replication. This autonomous replication of ICEBs1 is critical for stability of the excised element in growing cells. We found a conserved and previously uncharacterized ICE gene that is required for conjugation and replication of ICEBs1. Our results indicate that this gene, helP (formerly ydcP), encodes a helicase processivity factor that enables the host-encoded helicase PcrA to unwind the double-stranded ICEBs1 DNA. HelP was required for both conjugation and replication of ICEBs1, and HelP and NicK were the only ICEBs1 proteins needed for replication from ICEBs1 oriT. Using chromatin immunoprecipitation, we measured association of HelP, NicK, PcrA, and the host-encoded single-strand DNA binding protein Ssb with ICEBs1. We found that NicK was required for association of HelP and PcrA with ICEBs1 DNA. HelP was required for association of PcrA and Ssb with ICEBs1 regions distal, but not proximal, to oriT, indicating that PcrA needs HelP to progress beyond nicked oriT and unwind ICEBs1. In vitro, HelP directly stimulated the helicase activity of the PcrA homologue UvrD. Our findings demonstrate that HelP is a helicase processivity factor needed for efficient unwinding of ICEBs1 for conjugation and replication. Homologues of HelP and PcrA-type helicases are encoded on many known and putative ICEs. We propose that these factors are essential for ICE conjugation, replication, and genetic stability.     

A conserved anti-repressor controls horizontal gene transfer by proteolysis

The mobile genetic element ICEBs1 is an integrative and conjugative element (a conjugative transposon) found in the Bacillus subtilis chromosome. The SOS response and the RapI-PhrI sensory system activate ICEBs1 gene expression, excision and transfer by inactivating the ICEBs1 repressor protein ImmR. Although ImmR is similar to many characterized phage repressors, we found that, unlike these repressors, inactivation of ImmR requires an ICEBs1-encoded anti-repressor ImmA (YdcM). ImmA was needed for the degradation of ImmR in B. subtilis. Coexpression of ImmA and ImmR in Escherichia coli or co-incubation of purified ImmA and ImmR resulted in site-specific cleavage of ImmR. Homologues of immR and immA are found in many mobile genetic elements. We found that the ImmA homologue encoded by B. subtilis phage phi105 is required for inactivation of the phi105 repressor (an ImmR homologue). ImmA-dependent proteolysis of ImmR repressors may be a conserved mechanism for regulating horizontal gene transfer.     

Back to the future: the new ICE age

The analysis of bacterial genomes has revealed an extraordinary array of conjugal elements (integrative and conjugative element or ICE) that reside in bacterial chromosomes. These elements contribute to the pan-genomes of individual species and confer a wide variety of properties on their bacterial hosts. ICEBs1 is a conjugal element found in Bacillus subtilis that has a remarkable regulatory mechanism that apparently favours conjugation when there are suitable recipient bacteria at high density or when the bacterial host is facing DNA-damaging stresses. In the current issue, Bose et al. dissect the mechanism of induction of transfer of this element, and reveal a new, apparently widespread repressor anti-repressor system and a new mechanism of repressor destruction by proteolysis.     

Mechanism of retrotransfer in conjugation: prior transfer of the conjugative plasmid is required.

Bacterial conjugation normally involves the unidirectional transfer of DNA from donor to recipient. Occasionally, conjugation results in the transfer of DNA from recipient to donor, a phenomenon known as retrotransfer. Two distinct models have been generally considered for the mechanism of retrotransfer. In the two-way conduction model, no transfer of the conjugative plasmid is required. The establishment of a single conjugation bridge between donor and recipient is sufficient for the transfer of DNA in both directions. In the one-way conduction model, transfer of the conjugative plasmid to the recipient is required to allow the synthesis of a new conjugation bridge for the transfer of DNA from recipient to donor. We have tested these models by the construction of a mutant of the self-transmissible, IncP plasmid RK2lac that allows the establishement of the conjugation bridge but is incapable of self-transfer. Four nucleotides of the nic region of the origin of transfer (oriT) were changed directly in the 67-kb plasmid RK2lac by a simple adaptation of the vector-mediated excision (VEX) strategy for precision mutagenesis of large plasmids (E. K.Ayres, V. J. Thomson, G. Merino, D. Balderes, and D. H. Figurski, J. Mol. Biol. 230:174-185, 1993). The resulting RK2lac oriT1 mutant plasmid mobilizes IncQ or IncP oriT+ plasmids efficiently but transfers itself at a frequency which is 10(4)-fold less than that of the wild type. Whereas the wild-type RK2lac oriT+ plasmid promotes the retrotransfer of an IncQ plasmid from Escherichia coli or Pseudomonas aeruginosa recipients, the RK2lac oriT1 mutant is severely defective in retrotransfer. Therefore, retrotransfer requires prior transfer of the conjugative plasmid to the recipient. The results prove that retrotransfer occurs by two sequential DNA transfer events.     

Evidence that DNA helicase I and oriT site-specific nicking are both functions of the F TraI protein

Site-specific and strand-specific nicking at the origin of transfer (oriT) of the F sex factor is the initial step in conjugal DNA metabolism. Then, DNA helicase I, the product of the traI gene, processively unwinds the plasmid from the nick site to generate the single strand of DNA that is transferred to the recipient. The nick at oriT is produced by the combined action of two Tra proteins, TraY and TraZ. The traZ gene was never precisely mapped, as no available point mutation uniquely affected TraZ-dependent oriT nicking. With several new mutations, we have demonstrated that TraZ activity is dependent upon traI DNA sequences. The simplest interpretation of this finding is that the F TraI protein is bifunctional, with DNA unwinding and site-specific DNA nicking activities.     

Characterization of the reaction product of the oriT nicking reaction catalyzed by Escherichia coli DNA helicase I.

DNA helicase I, encoded on the Escherichia coli F plasmid, catalyzes a site- and strand-specific nicking reaction within the F plasmid origin of transfer (oriT) to initiate conjugative DNA strand transfer. The product of the nicking reaction contains a single phosphodiester bond interruption as determined by single-nucleotide resolution mapping of both sides of the nick site. This analysis has demonstrated that the nick is located at precisely the same site previously shown to be nicked in vivo (T. L. Thompson, M. B. Centola, and R. C. Deonier, J. Mol. Biol. 207:505-512, 1989). In addition, studies with two oriT point mutants have confirmed the specificity of the in vitro reaction. Characterization of the nicked DNA product has revealed a modified 5' end and a 3' OH available for extension by E. coli DNA polymerase I. Precipitation of nicked DNA with cold KCl in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate suggests the existence of protein covalently attached to the nicked DNA molecule. The covalent nature of this interaction has been directly demonstrated by transfer of radiolabeled phosphate from DNA to protein. On the basis of these results, we propose that helicase I becomes covalently bound to the 5' end of the nicked DNA strand as part of the reaction mechanism for phosphodiester bond cleavage. A model is presented to suggest how helicase I could nick the F plasmid at oriT and subsequently unwind the duplex DNA to provide single-stranded DNA for strand transfer during bacterial conjugation.     

Site- and strand-specific nicking in vitro at oriT by the traY-traI endonuclease of plasmid R100.

We developed an in vitro system to reproduce a site- and strand-specific nicking at the oriT region of plasmid R100. The nicking reaction was dependent on the purified TraY protein and on the lysate, which was prepared from cells overproducing the TraI protein. This supports the idea that the protein products of two genes, traY and traI, constitute an endonuclease that introduces a specific nick in vivo in the oriT region of the conjugative plasmids related to R100. The products were the "complex" DNA molecules with a protein covalently linked with the 5'-end of the nick. The nick was introduced in the strand, which is supposed to be transferred to recipient cells during conjugation, and was located at the site 59 base pairs upstream of the TraY protein binding site, sbyA.     

Role of sog polypeptides specified by plasmid ColIb-P9 and their transfer between conjugating bacteria.

The sog gene of the conjugative plasmid ColIb-P9 specifies two sequence-related polypeptides with the N-terminal third of the larger product having DNA primase activity. To resolve the function of the C-terminal portion of the polypeptides, we constructed a ColIb mutant containing a Tn5 insertion in the 3' region of sog. The mutation truncated sog gene products without inactivating DNA primase and rendered the plasmid defective in conjugation. Tests for the presence of conjugative pili, for complementation by a sog+ recombinant, and for mobilization of small origin of transfer (oriT) recombinant plasmids indicated that the mutant ColIb allows conjugative aggregation of cells but it is defective in DNA transfer at some stage subsequent to its initiation at oriT. Physical evidence is given that normal sog polypeptides are among a group of proteins transferred selectively from the donor to the recipient cell by a conjugation-specific process. No transfer of the mutant sog proteins was detected. It is proposed that the C-terminal region of sog polypeptides facilitates transfer of single-stranded ColIb DNA between conjugating cells following initiation of transfer at the oriT site, and that in this role the proteins are transmitted to the recipient cell.     

A bacteroides conjugative transposon, CTnERL, can transfer a portion of itself by conjugation without excising from the chromosome

CTnERL, a Bacteroides conjugative transposon, transferred DNA by an Hfr-type mechanism during conjugation when it was excision deficient due to an insertion in the integrase gene. Rescue of the conjugative transposon sequences required the recipient to be RecA proficient and to contain an integrated CTnERL. The transfer efficiency was only 10- to 30-fold lower than the normal element transfer efficiency, and the direction of transfer from the oriT gene showed that the integrase end was transferred first and that the transfer genes were transferred last.     

DNA recognition by F factor TraI36: highly sequence-specific binding of single-stranded DNA

The TraI protein has two essential roles in transfer of conjugative plasmid F Factor. As part of a complex of DNA-binding proteins, TraI introduces a site- and strand-specific nick at the plasmid origin of transfer (oriT), cutting the DNA strand that is transferred to the recipient cell. TraI also acts as a helicase, presumably unwinding the plasmid strands prior to transfer. As an essential feature of its nicking activity, TraI is capable of binding and cleaving single-stranded DNA oligonucleotides containing an oriT sequence. The specificity of TraI DNA recognition was examined by measuring the binding of oriT oligonucleotide variants to TraI36, a 36-kD amino-terminal domain of TraI that retains the sequence-specific nucleolytic activity. TraI36 recognition is highly sequence-specific for an 11-base region of oriT, with single base changes reducing affinity by as much as 8000-fold. The binding data correlate with plasmid mobilization efficiencies: plasmids containing sequences bound with lower affinities by TraI36 are transferred between cells at reduced frequencies. In addition to the requirement for high affinity binding to oriT, efficient in vitro nicking and in vivo plasmid mobilization requires a pyrimidine immediately 5' of the nick site. The high sequence specificity of TraI single-stranded DNA recognition suggests that despite its recognition of single-stranded DNA, TraI is capable of playing a major regulatory role in initiation and/or termination of plasmid transfer.     

Analysis of the sequence and gene products of the transfer region of the F sex factor.

Bacterial conjugation results in the transfer of DNA of either plasmid or chromosomal origin between microorganisms. Transfer begins at a defined point in the DNA sequence, usually called the origin of transfer (oriT). The capacity of conjugative DNA transfer is a property of self-transmissible plasmids and conjugative transposons, which will mobilize other plasmids and DNA sequences that include a compatible oriT locus. This review will concentrate on the genes required for bacterial conjugation that are encoded within the transfer region (or regions) of conjugative plasmids. One of the best-defined conjugation systems is that of the F plasmid, which has been the paradigm for conjugation systems since it was discovered nearly 50 years ago. The F transfer region (over 33 kb) contains about 40 genes, arranged contiguously. These are involved in the synthesis of pili, extracellular filaments which establish contact between donor and recipient cells; mating-pair stabilization; prevention of mating between similar donor cells in a process termed surface exclusions; DNA nicking and transfer during conjugation; and the regulation of expression of these functions. This review is a compendium of the products and other features found in the F transfer region as well as a discussion of their role in conjugation. While the genetics of F transfer have been described extensively, the mechanism of conjugation has proved elusive, in large part because of the low levels of expression of the pilus and the numerous envelope components essential for F plasmid transfer. The advent of molecular genetic techniques has, however, resulted in considerable recent progress. This summary of the known properties of the F transfer region is provided in the hope that it will form a useful basis for future comparison with other conjugation systems.     

Site-specific recombination at oriT of plasmid R1162 in the absence of conjugative transfer.

R1162 is efficiently comobilized during conjugative transfer of the self-transmissible plasmid R751. Bacteriophage M13 derivatives that contain two directly repeated copies of oriT, the site on R1162 DNA required in cis for mobilization, were constructed. Phage DNA molecules underwent recombination during infection of Escherichia coli, with the product retaining a single functional copy of oriT. Recombination was strand specific and depended on R1162 gene products involved in mobilization, but did not require the self-transmissible plasmid vector. Two genes were identified, one essential for recombination and the other affecting the frequency of recombination. Recombination of bacteriophage DNA could form the basis of a simple model for some of the events occurring during conjugation without the complexity of a true mating system.     

Revised genetic map of the distal end of the F transfer operon: implications for DNA helicase I, nicking at oriT, and conjugal DNA transport.

The DNA transfer stage of conjugation requires the products of the F sex factor genes traMYDIZ and the cis-acting site oriT. Previous interpretation of genetic and protein analyses suggested that traD, traI, and traZ mapped as contiguous genes at the distal end of the transfer operon and saturated this portion of the F transfer region (which ends with an IS3 element). Using antibodies prepared against the purified TraD and TraI proteins, we analyzed the products encoded by a collection of chimeric plasmids constructed with various segments of traDIZ DNA. We found the traI gene to be located 1 kilobase to the right of the position suggested on previous maps. This creates an unsaturated space between traD and traI where unidentified tra genes may be located and leaves insufficient space between traI and IS3 for coding the 94-kilodalton protein previously thought to be the product of traZ. We found that the 94-kilodalton protein arose from a translational restart and corresponds to the carboxy terminus of traI; we named it TraI*. The precise physical location of the traZ gene and the identity of its product are unknown. The oriT nicking activity known as TraZ may stem from unassigned regions between traD and traI and between traI and IS3, but a more interesting possibility is that it is actually a function of traI. On our revised map, the position of a previously detected RNA polymerase-binding site corresponds to a site at the amino terminus of traI rather than a location 1 kilobase into the coding region of the gene. Furthermore, the physical and genetic comparison of the F traD and traI genes with those of the closely related F-like conjugative plasmids R1 and R100 is greatly simplified. The translational organization we found for traI, together with its identity as the structural gene for DNA helicase I, suggests a possible functional link to several other genes from which translational restart polypeptides are expressed. These include the primases of the conjugative plasmids ColI and R16, the primase-helicase of bacteriophage T7, and the cisA product (nickase) of phage phi X174.     

Localized denaturation of oriT DNA within relaxosomes of the broad-host-range plasmid R1162

The broad-host-range, multicopy plasmid R1162 is efficiently mobilized during conjugation by the self-transmissible plasmid R751. The relaxosome, a complex of plasmid DNA and R1162-encoded proteins, forms at the origin of transfer ( oriT ) and is required for mobilization. Transfer is initiated by strand- and site-specific nicking of the DNA within this structure. We show by probing with potassium permanganate that oriT DNA is locally melted within the relaxosome, in the region from the inverted repeat to the site that is nicked. Mutations in this region of oriT , and in genes encoding the protein components of the relaxosome, affect both nicking and melting of the DNA. The nicking protein in the relaxosome is MobA, which also ligates the transferred linear, single strand at the termination of a round of transfer. We propose that there is an underlying similarity in the substrates for these two MobA-dependent, DNA-processing reactions. We also show that MobA has an additional role in transfer, beyond the nicking and resealing of oriT DNA.     

Characterization of the Escherichia coli F factor traY gene product and its binding sites.

The traY gene product (TraYp) from the Escherichia coli F factor has previously been purified and shown to bind a DNA fragment containing the F plasmid oriT region (E. E. Lahue and S. W. Matson, J. Bacteriol. 172:1385-1391, 1990). To determine the precise nucleotide sequence bound by TraYp, DNase I footprinting was performed. The TraYp-binding site is near, but not coincident with, the site that is nicked to initiate conjugative DNA transfer. In addition, a second TraYp binding site, which is coincident with the mRNA start site at the traYI promoter, is described. The Kd for each binding site was determined by a gel mobility shift assay. TraYp exhibits a fivefold higher affinity for the oriT binding site compared with the traYI promoter binding site. Hydrodynamic studies were performed to show that TraYp is a monomer in solution under the conditions used in DNA binding assays. Early genetic experiments implicated the traY gene product in the site- and strand-specific endonuclease activity that nicks at oriT (R. Everett and N. Willetts, J. Mol. Biol. 136:129-150, 1980; S. McIntire and N. Willetts, Mol. Gen. Genet. 178:165-172, 1980). As this activity has recently been ascribed to helicase I, it was of interest to see whether TraYp had any effect on this reaction. Addition of TraYp to nicking reactions catalyzed by helicase I showed no effect on the rate or efficiency of oriT nicking. Roles for TraYp in conjugative DNA transfer and a possible mode of binding to DNA are discussed.     

The mobilization regions of two integrated Bacteroides elements, NBU1 and NBU2, have only a single mobilization protein and may be on a cassette.

Bacteroides conjugative transposons can act in trans to excise, circularize, and transfer unlinked integrated elements called NBUs (for nonreplicating Bacteroides units). Previously, we localized and sequenced the mobilization region of one NBU, NBU1, and showed that this mobilization region was recognized by the IncP plasmids RP4 and R751, as well as by the Bacteroides conjugative transposons. We report here that the single mobilization protein carried by NBU1 appears to be a bifunctional protein that binds to the oriT region and catalyzes the nicking reaction that initiates the transfer process. We have also localized and sequenced the mobilization region of a second NBU, NBU2. The NBU2 mobilization region was 86 to 90% identical at the DNA sequence to the oriT-mob region of NBU1. The high sequence similarity between NBU1 and NBU2 ended abruptly after the stop codon of the mob gene and about 1 kbp upstream of the oriT region, indicating that the oriT-mob regions of NBU1 and NBU2 may be on some sort of cassette. A region on NBU1 and NBU2 which lies immediately upstream of the oriT region had 66% sequence identity to a region upstream of the oriT region on a mobilizable transposon, Tn4399, an element that had previously appeared to be completely unrelated to the NBUs.     

General requirements for protein secretion by the F-like conjugation system R1

Bacterial conjugation disseminates genes among bacteria via a process requiring direct cell contact. The cell envelope spanning secretion apparatus involved belongs to the type IV family of bacterial secretion systems, which transport protein as well as nucleoprotein substrates. This study aims to understand mechanisms leading to the initiation of type IV secretion using conjugative plasmid paradigm R1. We analyze the general requirements for plasmid encoded conjugation proteins and DNA sequence within the origin of transfer (oriT) for protein secretion activity using a Cre recombinase reporter system. We find that similar to conjugative plasmid DNA strand transfer, activation of the R1 system for protein secretion depends on binding interactions between the multimeric, ATP-binding coupling protein and the R1 relaxosome including an intact oriT. Evidence for DNA independent protein secretion was not found.     

Covalent association of the traI gene product of plasmid RP4 with the 5'-terminal nucleotide at the relaxation nick site

Formation of relaxosomes is the first step in the initiation of transfer DNA replication during bacterial conjugation. This nucleoprotein complex contains all components capable of introducing a site- and strand-specific nick at a cognate transfer origin (oriT) on supercoiled plasmid DNA, thus providing the substrate for generation of the strand to be transferred. Characterization of the terminal nucleotides at the oriT nick site revealed that relaxation occurs by hydrolysis of a single phosphodiester bond between a 2'-deoxyguanosyl and a 2'-deoxycytidyl residue. The relaxation nick site and a 19-base pair invert repeat sequence that is recognized by asymmetric binding of the RP4 TraJ protein are interspaced by 8 base pairs. The nicking reaction results in covalent attachment of the RP4 TraI protein to the 5'-terminal 2'-deoxycytidyl residue of the cleaved strand. The arrangement of the TraJ binding site and the relaxation nick site on the same side of the DNA double helix suggests that protein-protein interactions between TraJ and TraI are a prerequisite for oriT specific nicking. In accordance with the current model of transfer DNA replication, the 3' end remains accessible for primer extension by DNA polymerase I, enabling replacement strand synthesis in the donor cell by a rolling circle-type mechanism.