Peripheral regions of natural hammerhead ribozymes greatly increase their self-cleavage activity

Natural hammerhead ribozymes are mostly found in some viroid and viroid-like RNAs and catalyze their cis cleavage during replication. Hammerheads have been manipulated to act in trans and assumed to have a similar catalytic behavior in this artificial context. However, we show here that two natural cis-acting hammerheads self-cleave much faster than trans-acting derivatives and other reported artificial hammerheads. Moreover, modifications of the peripheral loops 1 and 2 of one of these natural hammerheads induced a >100-fold reduction of the self-cleavage constant, whereas engineering a trans-acting artificial hammerhead into a cis derivative by introducing a loop 1 had no effect. These data show that regions external to the central conserved core of natural hammerheads play a role in catalysis, and suggest the existence of tertiary interactions between these peripheral regions. The interactions, determined by the sequence and size of loops 1 and 2 and most likely of helices I and II, must result from natural selection and should be studied in order to better understand the hammerhead requirements in vivo.     

Hammerheads derived from sTRSV show enhanced cleavage and ligation rate constants

The catalytic properties of the hammerhead ribozyme embedded in the (+) strand of the satellite tobacco ringspot viral genome are analyzed with the goal of obtaining the elemental rate constants of the cleavage (k(2)) and ligation (k(-)(2)) steps. Two different chimeras combining the sTRSV (+) hammerhead and the well-characterized hammerhead 16 were used to measure the cleavage rate constant (k(2)), the rate of approach to equilibrium (k(obs) = k(2) + k(-)(2)), and the fraction of full-length hammerhead at equilibrium (k(-)(2)/k(2) + k(-)(2)). When compared to minimal hammerheads that lack the recently discovered loop I-loop II interaction, an extended format hammerhead derived from sTRSV studied here shows at least a 20-fold faster k(2) and a 1300-fold faster k(-)(2) at 10 mM MgCl(2). However, the magnesium dependence of the cleavage rate is not significantly changed. Thus, the enhanced cleavage of this hammerhead observed in vivo is due to its higher intrinsic rate and not due to its tighter binding of magnesium ions. The faster k(-)(2) of this hammerhead suggests that ligation may be used to form circular RNA genomes. This in vitro system will be valuable for experiments directed at understanding the hammerhead mechanism and the role of the loop I-loop II interaction.     

Characterization of a native hammerhead ribozyme derived from schistosomes

A recent re-examination of the role of the helices surrounding the conserved core of the hammerhead ribozyme has identified putative loop-loop interactions between stems I and II in native hammerhead sequences. These extended hammerhead sequences are more active at low concentrations of divalent cations than are minimal hammerheads. The loop-loop interactions are proposed to stabilize a more active conformation of the conserved core. Here, a kinetic and thermodynamic characterization of an extended hammerhead sequence derived from Schistosoma mansoni is performed. Biphasic kinetics are observed, suggesting the presence of at least two conformers, one cleaving with a fast rate and the other with a slow rate. Replacing loop II with a poly(U) sequence designed to eliminate the interaction between the two loops results in greatly diminished activity, suggesting that the loop-loop interactions do aid in forming a more active conformation. Previous studies with minimal hammerheads have shown deleterious effects of Rp-phosphorothioate substitutions at the cleavage site and 5' to A9, both of which could be rescued with Cd2+. Here, phosphorothioate modifications at the cleavage site and 5' to A9 were made in the schistosome-derived sequence. In Mg2+, both phosphorothioate substitutions decreased the overall fraction cleaved without significantly affecting the observed rate of cleavage. The addition of Cd2+ rescued cleavage in both cases, suggesting that these are still putative metal binding sites in this native sequence.     

Sequence requirements of the hammerhead RNA self-cleavage reaction.

A previously well-characterized hammerhead catalytic RNA consisting of a 24-nucleotide substrate and a 19-nucleotide ribozyme was used to perform an extensive mutagenesis study. The cleavage rates of 21 different substrate mutations and 24 different ribozyme mutations were determined. Only one of the three phylogenetically conserved base pairs but all nine of the conserved single-stranded residues in the central core are needed for self cleavage. In most cases the mutations did not alter the ability of the hammerhead to assemble into a bimolecular complex. In the few cases where mutant hammerheads did not assemble, it appeared to be the result of the mutation stabilizing an alternate substrate or ribozyme secondary structure. All combinations of mutant substrate and mutant ribozyme were less active than the corresponding single mutations, suggesting that the hammerhead contains few, if any, replaceable tertiary interactions as are found in tRNA. The refined consensus hammerhead resulting from this work was used to identify potential hammerheads present in a variety of Escherichia coli gene sequences.     

Alternative tertiary structure attenuates self-cleavage of the ribozyme in the satellite RNA of barley yellow dwarf virus.

A self-cleaving satellite RNA associated with barley yellow dwarf virus (sBYDV) contains a sequence predicted to form a secondary structure similar to catalytic RNA molecules (ribozymes) of the 'hammerhead' class (Miller et al., 1991, Virology 183, 711-720). However, this RNA differs from other naturally occurring hammerheads both in its very slow cleavage rate, and in some aspects of its structure. One striking structural difference is that an additional helix is predicted that may be part of an unusual pseudoknot containing three stacked helices. Nucleotide substitutions that prevent formation of the additional helix and favor the hammerhead increased the self-cleavage rate up to 400-fold. Compensatory substitutions, predicted to restore the additional helix, reduced the self-cleavage rate by an extent proportional to the calculated stability of the helix. Partial digestion of the RNA with structure-sensitive nucleases supported the existence of the proposed alternative structure in the wildtype sequence, and formation of the hammerhead in the rapidly-cleaving mutants. This tertiary interaction may serve as a molecular switch that controls the rate of self-cleavage and possibly other functions of the satellite RNA.     

Catalytic diversity of extended hammerhead ribozymes

Chimeras of the well-characterized minimal hammerhead 16 and nine extended hammerheads derived from natural viroids and satellite RNAs were constructed with the goal of assessing whether their very different peripheral tertiary interactions modulate their catalytic properties. For each chimera, three different assays were used to determine the rate of cleavage and the fraction of full-length hammerhead at equilibrium and thereby deduce the elemental cleavage ( k 2) and ligation ( k -2) rate constants. The nine chimeras were all more active than minimal hammerheads and exhibited a very broad range of catalytic properties, with values of k 2 varying by 750-fold and k -2 by 100-fold. At least two of the hammerheads exhibited an altered dependence of k obs on magnesium concentration. Since much less catalytic diversity is observed among minimal hammerheads that lack the tertiary interactions, a possible role for the different tertiary interaction is to modulate the hammerhead cleavage properties in viroids. For example, differing hammerhead cleavage and ligation rates could affect the steady state concentrations of linear, circular, and polymeric genomes in infected cells.     

Comparative analysis of cleavage rates after systematic permutation of the NUX consensus target motif for hammerhead ribozymes.

A trans-cleaving asymmetric hammerhead ribozyme directed against an AUC decreases target motif within an RNA specific for human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) was generated. The AUC decreases motif of the target RNA was permutated in order to generate all 12 variants of an NUX decreases consensus target motif, wherein N = A, C, G or U and X = A, C or U. Four asymmetric hammerhead ribozymes differing in the nucleotide that is complementary to N were generated, of which each was specific for three of the 12 target motifs. The residual sequence context within helices I and III remained unchanged. All 12 combinations resulted in cleavage of the target RNA. Using single-turnover conditions, the detectable cleavage rate constants at 37 degrees C were determined, which varied considerably depending on the NUX decreases motif. The NUC decreases motifs were cleaved more efficiently, with AUC decreases being cleaved best. Comparison with previous studies indicates that the sequence context of the NUX decreases motif plays a major role for the detectable cleavage activity.     

Probing RNA tertiary structure: interhelical crosslinking of the hammerhead ribozyme.

Distinct structural models for the hammerhead ribozyme derived from single-crystal X-ray diffraction and fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements have been compared. Both models predict the same overall geometry, a wishbone shape with helices II and III nearly colinear and helix I positioned close to helix II. However, the relative orientations of helices I and II are different. To establish whether one of the models represents a kinetically active structure, a new crosslinking procedure was developed in which helices I and II of hammerhead ribozymes were disulfide-crosslinked via the 2' positions of specific sugar residues. Crosslinking residues on helices I and II that are close according to the X-ray structure did not appreciably reduce the catalytic efficiency. In contrast, crosslinking residues closely situated according to the FRET model dramatically reduced the cleavage rate by at least three orders of magnitude. These correlations between catalytic efficiencies and spatial proximities are consistent with the X-ray structure.     

Extension of helix II of an HIV-1-directed hammerhead ribozyme with long antisense flanks does not alter kinetic parameters in vitro but causes loss of the inhibitory potential in living cells.

When designed to cleave a target RNA in trans, the hammerhead ribozyme contains two antisense flanks which form helix I and helix III by pairing with the complementary target RNA. The sequences forming helix II are contained on the ribozyme strand and represent a major structural component of the hammerhead structure. In the case of an inhibitory 429 nucleotides long trans-ribozyme (2as-Rz12) which was directed against the 5'-leader/gag region of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), helix II was not pre-formed in the single-stranded molecule. Thus, major structural changes are necessary before cleavage can occur. To study whether pre-formation of helix II in the non-paired 2as-Rz12 RNA could influence the observed cleavage rate in vitro and its inhibitory activity on HIV-1 replication, we extended the 4 base pair helix II of 2as-Rz12 to 6, 10, 21, and 22 base pairs respectively. Limited RNase cleavage reactions performed in vitro at 37 degrees C and at physiological ion strength indicated that a helix II of the hammerhead domain was pre-formed when its length was at least six base pairs. This modification neither affected the association rate with target RNA nor the cleavage rate in vitro. In contrast to this, extension of helix II led to a significantly decreased inhibition of HIV-1 replication in human cells. Together with the finding of others that shortening of helix II to less than two base pairs reduces the catalytic activity in vitro, this observation indicates that the length of helix II in the naturally occurring RNAs with a hammerhead domain is already close or identical to the optimal length for catalytic activity in vitro and in vivo.     

Length variation of helix III in a hammerhead ribozyme and its influence on cleavage activity

The previously described HIV-1 directed hammerhead ribozyme 2as-Rz12 can form with its target RNA 2s helices I and III of 128 and 278 base pairs (bp). A series of derivatives was made in which helix III was truncated to 8, 5, 4, 3, and 2 nucleotides (nt). These asymmetric hammerhead ribozymes were tested for in vitro cleavage and for inhibition of HIV-1 replication in human cells. Truncation of helix III to 8 bp did not affect the in vitro cleavage potential of the parental catalytic antisense RNA 2as-Rz12. Further truncation of helix III led to decreased cleavage rates, with no measurable cleavage activity for the 2 bp construct. All catalytically active constructs showed complex cleavage kinetics. Three kinetic subpopulations of ribozyme-substrate complexes could be discriminated that were cleaved with fast or slow rates or not at all. Gel purification of preformed ribozyme-substrate complexes led to a significant increase in cleavage rates. However, the complex cleavage pattern remained. In mammalian cells, the helix III-truncated constructs showed the same but no increased inhibitory effect of the comparable antisense RNA on HIV-1 replication.     

A three-nucleotide helix I is sufficient for full activity of a hammerhead ribozyme: advantages of an asymmetric design.

Trans-cleaving hammerhead ribozymes with long target-specific antisense sequences flanking the catalytic domain share some features with conventional antisense RNA and are therefore termed 'catalytic antisense RNAs'. Sequences 5' to the catalytic domain form helix I and sequences 3' to it form helix III when complexed with the target RNA. A catalytic antisense RNA of more than 400 nucleotides, and specific for the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), was systematically truncated within the arm that constituted originally a helix I of 128 base pairs. The resulting ribozymes formed helices I of 13, 8, 5, 3, 2, 1 and 0 nucleotides, respectively, and a helix III of about 280 nucleotides. When their in vitro cleavage activity was compared with the original catalytic antisense RNA, it was found that a helix I of as little as three nucleotides was sufficient for full endonucleolytic activity. The catalytically active constructs inhibited HIV-1 replication about four-fold more effectively than the inactive ones when tested in human cells. A conventional hammerhead ribozyme having helices of just 8 nucleotides on either side failed to cleave the target RNA in vitro when tested under the conditions for catalytic antisense RNA. Cleavage activity could only be detected after heat-treatment of the ribozyme substrate mixture which indicates that hammerhead ribozymes with short arms do not associate as efficiently to the target RNA as catalytic antisense RNA. The requirement of just a three-nucleotide helix I allows simple PCR-based generation strategies for asymmetric hammerhead ribozymes. Advantages of an asymmetric design will be discussed.     

Ion-induced folding of the hammerhead ribozyme: a fluorescence resonance energy transfer study.

The ion-induced folding transitions of the hammerhead ribozyme have been analysed by fluorescence resonance energy transfer. The hammerhead ribozyme may be regarded as a special example of a three-way RNA junction, the global structure of which has been studied by comparing the distances (as energy transfer efficiencies) between the ends of pairs of labelled arms for the three possible end-to-end vectors as a function of magnesium ion concentration. The data support two sequential ion-dependent transitions, which can be interpreted in the light of the crystal structures of the hammerhead ribozyme. The first transition corresponds to the formation of a coaxial stacking between helices II and III; the data can be fully explained by a model in which the transition is induced by a single magnesium ion which binds with an apparent association constant of 8000-10 000 M-1. The second structural transition corresponds to the formation of the catalytic domain of the ribozyme, induced by a single magnesium ion with an apparent association constant of approximately 1100 M-1. The hammerhead ribozyme provides a well-defined example of ion-dependent folding in RNA.     

When to believe what you see

The recent X-ray crystal structure of a hammerhead ribozyme derived from Schistosoma mansoni containing the rate-enhancing peripheral domain has a catalytic core that is very different from the catalytic core present in the structure of the "minimal" hammerhead, which lacks a peripheral domain (Martick and Scott, 2006). The new structure reconciles many of the disagreements between the minimal hammerhead structure and the biochemical data on the cleavage properties of chemically modified hammerheads. The new structure also emphasizes the dynamic nature of small RNA domains and provides a cautionary tale for everyone who tries to use structure to understand function.     

The influence of imperfectly paired helices I and III on the catalytic activity of hammerhead ribozymes.

Several catalytic antisense RNAs directed against different regions of the genomic or antigenomic RNA of Sendai virus were constructed. All RNAs contained the same catalytic domain based on hammerhead ribozymes but some had deletions or mutations resulting in imperfect helices I and III. Pre-annealed substrate/ribozyme complexes were used to determine the rates of the cleavage process for the different ribozymes under single-turnover conditions. It was found that the sequence context surrounding the cleavable motif influenced the cleavage efficiencies. Deletions or mutations of nucleotides 2.1 or 15.1 and 15.2 according to the numbering system for hammerhead ribozymes of Hertel et al. destroyed catalytic activity. Deletions of nucleotide 2.2 or additional nucleotides in the helix I-forming region of the ribozyme did not destruct, but only reduced the cleavage efficiencies. Similar results were observed for a deletion of nucleotide 15.3. Simultaneous deletions within helices I and III resulted in alternative cleavage sites. The potential consequences for the specificity of the ribozyme reaction are discussed.     

Unexpected anisotropy in substrate cleavage rates by asymmetric hammerhead ribozymes.

RNA substrates which form relatively short helices I and III with hammerhead ribozymes are generally cleaved more rapidly than substrates which create longer binding helices. We speculated that for optimum cleavage rates, one of the helices needed to be relatively weak. To identify this helix, a series of ribozymes and substrates of varying lengths were made such that in the complex, helices I and III consisted of 5 and 10 bp respectively or vice versa. In two independent systems, substrates in the complexes with the shorter helix I and longer helix III were cleaved one to two orders of magnitude more rapidly than those in the complexes with the longer helix I and shorter helix III. Similar results were obtained whether the numbers of base pairs in helices I and III were limited either by the length of the hybridizing arms of the ribozyme or the length of the substrate. The phenomenon was observed for both all-RNA and DNA armed ribozymes. Thus, a relatively short helix I is required for fast cleavage rates in pre-formed hammer-head ribozyme-substrate complexes. When helix III has 10 bp, the optimum length for helix I is approximately 5 bp.     

An extra nucleotide in the consensus catalytic core of a viroid hammerhead ribozyme: implications for the design of more efficient ribozymes.

Hammerhead ribozymes catalyze self-cleavage of oligomeric RNAs generated in replication of certain viroid and viroid-like RNAs. Previous studies have defined a catalytic core conserved in most natural hammerheads, but it is still unknown why some present deviations from the consensus. We have addressed this issue in chrysanthemum chlorotic mottle viroid (CChMVd), whose (+) hammerhead has an extra A (A10) between the conserved A9 and the quasi-conserved G10.1. Effects of insertions at this position on hammerhead kinetics have not hitherto been examined. A10 caused a moderate decrease of the trans-cleaving rate constant with respect to the CChMVd (+) hammerhead without this residue, whereas A10-->C and A10-->G substitutions had major detrimental effects, likely because they favor catalytically inactive foldings. By contrast, A10-->U substitution induced a 3-4-fold increase of the rate constant, providing an explanation for the extra U10 present in two natural hammerheads. Because A10 also occupies a singular and indispensable position in the global CChMVd conformation, as revealed by bioassays, these results show that some hammerheads deviate from the consensus due to the involvement of certain residues in critical function(s) other than self-cleavage. Incorporation of the extra U10 into a model hammerhead also caused a similar increase in the rate constant, providing data for a deeper understanding of the hammerhead structural requirements and for designing more efficient ribozymes.     

Three conserved guanosines approach the reaction site in native and minimal hammerhead ribozymes

Native hammerhead ribozymes contain RNA domains that enable high catalytic activity under physiological conditions, where minimal hammerheads show little activity. However, little is known about potential differences in native versus minimal ribozyme folding. Here, we present results of photocross-linking analysis of native and minimal hammerheads containing photoreactive nucleobases 6-thioguanosine, 2,6-diaminopurine, 4-thiouridine, and pyrrolocytidine, introduced at specific sites within the catalytic core. Under conditions where catalytic activity is observed, the two substrate nucleobases spanning the cleavage site approach and stack upon G8 and G12 of the native hammerhead, two conserved nucleobases that show similar behavior in minimal constructs, have been implicated in general acid-base catalysis, and are >15 A from the cleavage site in the crystal structures. Pyrrolocytidine at cleavage site position 17 forms an efficient crosslink to G12, and the crosslinked RNA retains catalytic activity. Multiple cross-linked species point to a structural rearrangement within the U-turn, positioning residue G5 in the vicinity of cleavage site position 1.1. Intriguing crosslinks were triggered by nucleotide analogues at positions distal to the crosslinked residues; for example, 6-thioguanosine at position 5 induced a crosslink between G12 and C17, suggesting an intimate functional communication among these three nucleobases. Together, these results support a model in which the native hammerhead folds to an active structure similar to that of the minimal ribozyme, and significantly different from the crystallographic structures.     

Satellite cereal yellow dwarf virus-RPV (satRPV) RNA requires a douXble hammerhead for self-cleavage and an alternative structure for replication.

The 110 nt hammerhead ribozyme in the satellite RNA of cereal yellow dwarf virus-RPV (satRPV RNA) folds into an alternative conformation that inhibits self-cleavage. This alternative structure comprises a pseudoknot with base-pairing between loop (L1) and a single-stranded bulge (L2a), which are located in hammerhead stems I and II, respectively. Mutations that disrupt this base-pairing, or otherwise cause the ribozyme to more closely resemble a canonical hammerhead, greatly increase self-cleavage. In a more natural multimeric sequence context containing the full-length satRPV RNA and two copies of the hammerhead, wild-type RNA cleaves much more efficiently than in the 110 nt context. Mutations in the upstream hammerhead, including a knock-out in the catalytic core, affect cleavage at the downstream cleavage site, indicating that multimers of satRPV RNA cleave via a double hammerhead. The double hammerhead includes base-pairing between two copies of the L1 sequence which extends stem I. Disruption of L1-L1 base-pairing slows cleavage of the multimer. L1-L2a base-pairing is required for efficient replication of satRPV RNA in oat protoplasts. Mutations that affect self-cleavage of the multimer do not correlate with replication efficiency, indicating that the ability to self-cleave is not a primary determinant of replication. We present a replication model in which multimeric satRPV RNA folds into alternative conformations that cannot form in the monomer. One potential metastable intermediate conformation involves L1-L2a base-pairing that may facilitate formation of the double hammerhead. However, we conclude that L1-L2a also performs some other essential function in the satRPV RNA replication cycle, because the L1-L2a base-pairing is more important than efficient self-cleavage for replication.