Structural energetics of the molten globule state

Certain partly ordered protein conformations, commonly called “moltenglobule states,” are widely believed to represent protein folding intermediates. Recentstructural studies of molten globule states ofdifferent proteins have revealed features whichappear to be general in scope. The emergingconsensus is that these partly ordered forms exhibit a high content of secondary structure, considerable compactness, nonspecific tertiary structure, and significant structural flexibility. These characteristics may be used to define ageneral state of protein folding called “the molten globule state,” which is structurally andthermodynamically distinct from both the native state and the denatured state. Despite exaatensive knowledge of structural features of afew molten globule states, a cogent thermodynamic argument for their stability has not yetbeen advanced. The prevailing opinion of thelast decade was that there is little or no enthalpy difference or heat capacity differencebetween the molten globule state and the unfolded state. This view, however, appears to beat variance with the existing database of protein structural energetics and with recent estimates of the energetics of denaturation of α-lactalbumin, cytochrome c, apomyoglobin, and T4 lysozyme. We discuss these four proteins at length. The results of structural studies, together with the existing thermodynamic values for fundamental interactions in proteins, provide the foundation for a structural thermodynamic framework which can account for the observed behavior of molten globule states. Within this framework, we analyze the physical basis for both the high stability of several molten globule states and the low probability of other protential folding intermediates. Additionally, we consider, in terms of reduced enthalpy changes and disrupted cooperative interactions, the thermodynamic basis for the apparent absence of a thermally induced, cooperative unfolding transition for some molten globule states. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Energetic basis of structural stability in the molten globule state: alpha-lactalbumin

The denatured states of alpha-lactalbumin, which have features of a molten globule state, have been studied to elucidate the energetics of the molten globule state and its contribution to the stability of the native conformation. Analysis of calorimetric and CD data shows that the heat capacity increment of alpha-lactalbumin denaturation highly correlates with the degree of disorder of the residual structure of the state. As a result, the denaturational transition of alpha-lactalbumin from the native to a highly ordered compact denatured state, and from the native to the disordered unfolded state are described by different thermodynamic functions. The enthalpy and entropy of the denaturation of alpha-lactalbumin to compact denatured state are always greater than the enthalpy and entropy of its unfolding. This difference represents the unfolding of the molten globule state. Calorimetric measurements of the heat effect associated with the unfolding of the molten globule state reveal that it is negative in sign over the temperature range of molten globule stability. This observation demonstrates the energetic specificity of the molten globule state, which, in contrast to a protein with unique tertiary structure, is stabilized by the dominance of negative entropy and enthalpy of hydration over the positive conformational entropy and enthalpy of internal interactions. It is concluded that at physiological temperatures the entropy of dehydration is the dominant factor providing stability for the compact intermediate state on the folding pathway, while for the stability of the native state, the conformational enthalpy is the dominant factor.     

Equilibrium titrations of acid-induced unfolding-refolding and salt-induced molten globule of cytochrome c by FT-IR spectroscopy

Despite extensive investigations on the acid-unfolded and acid/salt-induced molten globule(-like) states of cytochrome c using variety of techniques, structural features of the acid-unfolded state in terms of residual secondary structures and the structural transition between the acid-unfolded and acid/salt-refolded states have not been fully characterized beyond the circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. It is unusual that secondary structure(s) of the unfolded state leading to the molten globule state, an important protein folding intermediate, as determined by CD was not fully corroborated by independent experimental method(s). In this study, we carried out an equilibrium titration of acid-induced unfolding and subsequent acid- and salt-induced refolding of cytochrome c using Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. The spectral profiles of the equilibrium titration reveal new structural details about the acid-unfolded state and the structural transition associated with the acid/salt-refolded molten globule(-like) states of cytochrome c.     

Formation of the molten globule-like state of cytochrome c induced by n-alkyl sulfates at low concentrations

The molten globule state of cytochrome c is the major intermediate of protein folding. Elucidation of the thermodynamic mechanism of conformational stability of the molten globule state would enhance our understanding of protein folding. The formation of the molten globule state of cytochrome c was induced by n-alkyl sulfates including sodium octyl sulfate, SOS; sodium decyl sulfate, SDeS; sodium dodecyl sulfate, SDS; and sodium tetradecyl sulfate, STS, at low concentrations. The refolding states of the protein were monitored by spectroscopic techniques including circular dichroism (CD), visible absorbance and fluorescence. The effect of n-alkyl sulfates on the structure of acid-unfolded horse cytochrome c at pH 2 was utilized to investigate the contribution of hydrophobic interactions to the stability of the molten globule state. The addition of n-alkyl sulfates to the unfolded state of cytochrome c appears to support the stabilized form of the molten globule. The m-values of the refolded state of cytochrome c by SOS, SDeS, SDS, and STS showed substantial variation. The enhancement of m-values as the stability criterion of the molten globule state corresponded with increasing chain length of the cited n-alkyl sulfates. The compaction of the molten globule state induced by SDS, as a prototype for other n-alkyl sulfates, relative to the unfolded state of cytochrome c was confirmed by Stokes radius and thermal transition point (T(m)) measured by microviscometry and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), respectively. Thus, hydrophobic interactions play an important role in stabilizing the molten globule state.     

1,1,1,3,3,3-hexafluoroisopropanol induced thermal unfolding and molten globule state of bovine alpha-lactalbumin: calorimetric and spectroscopic studies

The thermal denaturation of alpha-lactalbumin was studied at pH 7.0 and 9.0 in aqueous 1,1,1,3,3,3-hexafluoroisopropanol (HFIP) by high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry. The conformation of the protein was analyzed by a combination of fluorescence and circular dichroism measurements. The most obvious effect of HFIP was lowering of the transition temperature with an increase in the concentration of the alcohol up to 0.30M, beyond which no calorimetric transition was observed. Up to 0.30M HFIP the calorimetric and van't Hoff enthalpy remained the same, indicating the validity of the two-state approximation for the thermal unfolding of alpha-lactalbumin. The quantitative thermodynamic parameters accompanying the thermal transitions have been evaluated. Spectroscopic observations confirm that alpha-lactalbumin is in the molten globule state in the presence of 0.50M HFIP at pH 7.0 and 0.75M HFIP at pH 9.0. The results also demonstrate that alpha-lactalbumin in the molten globule state undergoes a noncooperative thermal transition to the denatured state. It is observed that two of four tryptophans are exposed to the solvent in the HFIP induced molten globule state of alpha-lactalbumin compared to four in the 8.5M urea induced denatured state of the protein. It is also observed that the HFIP induced molten globule states at the two pH values are different from the acid induced molten globule state (A state) of alpha-lactalbumin.     

Thermodynamic and structural properties of the acid molten globule state of horse cytochrome C

To understand the stabilization, folding, and functional mechanisms of proteins, it is very important to understand the structural and thermodynamic properties of the molten globule state. In this study, the global structure of the acid molten globule state, which we call MG1, of horse cytochrome c at low pH and high salt concentrations was evaluated by solution X-ray scattering (SXS), dynamic light scattering, and circular dichroism measurements. MG1 was globular and slightly (3%) larger than the native state, N. Calorimetric methods, such as differential scanning calorimetry and isothermal acid-titration calorimetry, were used to evaluate the thermodynamic parameters in the transitions of N to MG1 and MG1 to denatured state D of horse cytochrome c. The heat capacity change, ΔC(p), in the N-to-MG1 transition was determined to be 2.56 kJ K(-1) mol(-1), indicating the increase in the level of hydration in the MG1 state. Moreover, the intermediate state on the thermal N-to-D transition of horse cytochrome c at pH 4 under low-salt conditions showed the same structural and thermodynamic properties of the MG1 state in both SXS and calorimetric measurements. The Gibbs free energy changes (ΔG) for the N-to-MG1 and N-to-D transitions at 15 °C were 10.9 and 42.2 kJ mol(-1), respectively.     

Compactness of the kinetic molten globule of bovine alpha-lactalbumin: a dynamic light scattering study.

During folding of globular proteins, the molten globule state was observed as an equilibrium intermediate under mildly denaturing conditions as well as a transient intermediate in kinetic refolding experiments. While the high compactness of the equilibrium intermediate of alpha-lactalbumin has been verified, direct measurements of the compactness of the kinetic intermediate have not been reported until now. Our dynamic light scattering measurements provide a complete set of the hydrodynamic dimensions of bovine alpha-lactalbumin in different conformational states, particularly in the kinetic molten globule state. The Stokes radii for the native, kinetic molten globule, equilibrium molten globule, and unfolded states are 1.91, 1.99, 2.08, and 2.46 nm, respectively. Therefore, the kinetic intermediate appears to be even more compact than its equilibrium counterpart. Remarkable differences in the concentration dependence of the Stokes radius exist revealing strong attractive but repulsive intermolecular interactions in the kinetic and equilibrium molten globule states, respectively. This underlines the importance of extrapolation to zero protein concentration in measurements of the molecular compactness.     

Role of electrostatic repulsion in the acidic molten globule of cytochrome c.

The molten globule has been assumed to be a major intermediate state of protein folding. To extend our understanding of protein folding it is important to elucidate the thermodynamic mechanism of conformational stability of the molten globule. To clarify the role of electrostatic charge repulsion in the stability of the acidic molten globule state, we prepared a series of acetylated horse ferricytochrome c species with various degrees of charge repulsion. On the basis of circular dichroism measurement, we show that the stability of the acidic molten globule is determined by a balance of electrostatic repulsions between positive residues, which favor the extended conformation, and the opposing forces, which stabilize the molten globule. These results provide a clear example of charge repulsions producing unfolding of the compact protein structure, and suggest that the reversibly denatured conformation of ferricytochrome c under physiological conditions (i.e. neutral pH, ambient temperature and no denaturant) is the molten globule.     

Molecular basis of cooperativity in protein folding. V. Thermodynamic and structural conditions for the stabilization of compact denatured states

The heat-denatured state of proteins has been usually assumed to be a fully hydrated random coil. It is now evident that under certain solvent conditions or after chemical or genetic modifications, the protein molecule may exhibit a hydrophobic core and residual secondary structure after thermal denaturation. This state of the protein has been called the “compact denatured” or “molten globule” state. Recently is has been shown that α-lactalbumin at pH < 5 denatures into a molten globule state upon increasing the temperature (Griko, Y., Freire, E., Privalov, P. L. Biochemistry 33:1889–1899, 1994). This state has a lower heat capacity and a higher enthalpy at low temperatures than the unfolded state. At those temperatures the stabilization of the molten globule state is of an entropic origin since the enthalpy contributes unfavorably to the Gibbs free energy. Since the molten globule is more structured than the unfolded state and, therefore, is expected to have a lower configurational entropy, the net entropic gain must originate primarily from solvent related entropy arising from the hydrophobic effect, and to a lesser extent from protonation or electrostatic effects. In this work, we have examined a large ensemble of partly folded states derived from the native structure of α-lactalbumin in order to identify those states that satisfy the energetic criteria of the molten globule. It was found that only few states satisfied the experimental constraints and that, furthermore, those states were part of the same structural family. In particular, the regions corresponding to the A, B, and C helices were found to be folded, while the β sheet and the D helix were found to be unfolded. At temperatures below 45°C the states exhibiting those structural characteristics are enthalpically higher than the unfolded state in agreement with the experimental data. Interestingly, those states have a heat capacity close to that observed for the acid pH compact denatured state of α-lactalbumin [980 cal (mol.K)^?l]. In addition, the folded regions of these states include those residues found to be highly protected by NMR hydrogen exchange experiments. This work represents an initial attempt to model the structural origin of the thermodynamic properties of partly folded states. The results suggest a number of structural features that are consistent with experimental data. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Calorimetric determination of the energetics of the molten globule intermediate in protein folding: apo-alpha-lactalbumin

High-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry has been used to characterize the energetics of the molten globule state of apo-alpha-lactalbumin. This characterization has been possible by performing temperature scans at different guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) concentrations in order to experimentally define the temperature-GuHCl stability surface of the protein. Multidimensional analysis of the heat capacity surface has allowed simultaneous resolution of the energetics of the unfolded and molten globule states. These experiments indicate that the intrinsic enthalpy difference (i.e., excluding additional contributions such as those arising from differential GuHCl binding) between the unfolded and native states is 31.8 kcal/mol at 25 degrees C whereas that of the molten globule and native states is only 7.7 kcal/mol. At the same temperature, the entropy changes are 99.2 and 23.7 cal/K.mol and the heat capacity changes are 1821 and 326 cal/K.mol, respectively. Analysis of the thermodynamic data indicates that in passing from the native to the molten globule state only approximately 19% of the hydrogen bonds are broken. In addition, the magnitude of delta Cp for the molten globule suggests that water does not largely penetrate into the interior of the molten globule, implying that significant hydrophobic interactions are still present in this state. These parameters provide precise energetic constraints to the allowed structural conformations of the molten globule.     

Different molten globule-like folding intermediates of hen egg white lysozyme induced by high pH and tertiary butanol

We have provided evidence that hen egg white lysozyme (HEWL) existed in alpha helical and beta structure dominated molten globule (MG) states at high pH and in the presence of tertiary butanol, respectively. Circular dichroism (CD), intrinsic fluorescence, ANS binding and acrylamide-induced fluorescence quenching techniques have been used to investigate alkali-induced unfolding of HEWL and the effect of tertiary butanol on the alkaline-induced state. At pH 12.75, HEWL existed as molten globule like intermediate. The observed MG-like intermediate was characterized by (i) retention of 77% of the native secondary structure, (ii) enhanced binding of ANS (approximately 5 times) compared to native and completely unfolded state, (iii) loss of the tertiary structure as indicated by the tertiary structural probes (near-UV, CD and Intrinsic fluorescence) and (iv) acrylamide quenching studies showed that MG state has compactness intermediate between native and completely unfolded states. Moreover, structural properties of the protein at isoelectric point (pI) and denatured states have also been described. We have also shown that in the presence of 45% tertiary butanol (t-butanol), HEWL at pH 7.0 and 11.0 (pI 11.0) existed in helical structure without much affecting tertiary structure. Interestingly, MG state of HEWL at pH 12.7 transformed into another MG state (MG2) at 20% t-butanol (v/v), in which secondary structure is mainly beta sheets. On further increasing the t-butanol concentration alpha helix was found to reform. We have proposed that formation of both alpha helical and beta sheet dominated intermediate may be possible in the folding pathway of alpha + beta protein.     

Urea-induced denaturation of beta-trypsin: an evidence for a molten globule state

The denaturation of beta-trypsin induced by urea was investigated by fluorescence and circular dichroism. A transient denatured state was found at 2 M urea in both intrinsic fluorescence spectrum and bis-(8-anilino-1-naphtalene sulfonate) (bis-ANS) binding. In addition, the absence of tertiary contacts and presence of secondary structure for this state, are consistent with an intermediate equilibrium state having features of molten globule.     

An evidence for the equilibrium unfolding intermediates of ribonuclease A by tritium labeling method

A formation of a molten globule in the unfolding of ribonuclease A could be considered as an evidence supporting a hypothesis on the existence of such intermediates on the pathway of a protein folding. Using a novel technique (tritium labeling method) we have showed that the ribonuclease A equilibrium unfolding in urea and guanidinium chloride (GuCl) solutions proceeds through a formation of intermediates whose properties (compactness, retention of the larger part hydrophobic core, secondary structure, and native-like folding pattern) correspond to the fundamental characteristics of the molten globule state. The both intermediates are the “wet” molten globules (the globule interior contains the water molecules). The results reveal the noticeable distinctions in intermediates structure, first of all, in the extent of their compactness. The urea intermediate is less compact than that in GuCl. It is shown that the refolding of the protein denatured by GuCl results in the formation of the intermediate which enzyme activity is virtually the same as the activity of the native protein.     

Thermodynamic analysis of three state denaturation of Peanut Agglutinin

Peanut Agglutinin (PNA) is a homotetrameric protein with a very unusual open quaternary structure. During denaturation, it first dissociates into a molten globule like state, which subsequently undergoes complete denaturation. Urea denaturation of PNA at neutral pH has been studied by intrinsic fluorescence spectroscopy and has been fitted to a three state model, A4 <=> 4I <=> 4U, to get all the relevant thermodynamic parameters. Urea denaturation leads to continuous red shift of wavelength maxima. The molten globule like state is formed in a short range of urea concentration. Refolding of the denatured PNA has been attempted by intrinsic fluorescence study. Refolding by instantaneous dilution shows the occurrence of the formation of an intermediate at a relatively rapid rate, within few seconds. The transition from PNA tetramer to molten globule like state is found to have a DeltaG value of approximately 33 kcal/mole while it is approximately 8 kcal/mole for the transition from molten globule like state to a completely denatured state. This in turn indicates that the tetramerization in PNA contributes significantly to the stability of the oligomer.     

Transient dimer in the refolding kinetics of cytochrome c characterized by small-angle X-ray scattering

The equilibrium unfolding and the kinetic refolding of cytochrome c (Cyt c) in the presence of imidazole were studied with small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). The equilibrium unfolding experiments showed the radius of gyration, R(g), of native Cyt c to swell approximately 1 A with the addition of imidazole. The thermodynamic parameter m also reflects an expansion of the protein as its lower value demonstrates an increase in solvent-accessible surface area over that of native Cyt c in the absence of imidazole. Refolding was studied in the presence of imidazole as it prevents misligated intermediate states from forming during the refolding process, simplifying the kinetics, and making them easier to resolve. Time-resolved decreases in the forward scattering amplitude, I(0), demonstrated the transient formation of an aggregated intermediate. Final protein and denaturant concentrations were varied in the refolding kinetics, and the singular value decomposition (SVD) method was employed to characterize the associated state. This state was determined to be a dimer, with properties consistent with a molten globule.     

Anion concentration modulates the conformation and stability of the molten globule of cytochrome<Emphasis Type="Italic"> c</Emphasis>

Anions induce collapse of acid-denatured cytochrome c into a compact state, the A-state, showing molten globule character. Since structural information on partially folded forms of proteins is important for a deeper understanding of folding mechanisms and of the factors affecting protein stabilization, in this paper we have investigated in detail the effects of anions on the tertiary conformation of the A-state. We have found that the salt-induced collapse of acid-denatured cytochrome c leads to a number of equilibria between high-spin and low-spin heme states and between two types of low-spin states. The two latter states are characterized by conformations leading to a native-like Met-Fe-His axial coordination and a bis-His configuration. The equilibrium between these two A-states is dependent on the concentration and/or size of the anions (i.e. the bigger the anion, the greater its effect). Further, on the basis of fast kinetic data, a kinetic model of the folding process from the acid-unfolded protein to the A-state (at low and high anion concentration) is described.     

Equilibrium and kinetic studies on folding of the authentic and recombinant forms of human alpha-lactalbumin by circular dichroism spectroscopy

The equilibrium and kinetics of the unfolding and refolding of authentic and recombinant human alpha-lactalbumin, the latter of which had an extra methionine residue at the N-terminus, were studied by circular dichroism spectroscopy, and the results were compared with the results for bovine and goat alpha-lactalbumins obtained in our previous studies. As observed in the bovine and goat proteins, the presence of the extra methionine residue in the recombinant protein remarkably destabilized the native state, and the destabilization was entirely ascribed to an increase in the rate of unfolding. The thermodynamic stability of the native state against the unfolded state was lower, and the thermodynamic stability of the molten globule state against the unfolded state was higher for the human protein than for the other alpha-lactalbumins previously studied. Thus, the population of the molten globule intermediate was higher during the equilibrium unfolding of human alpha-lactalbumin by guanidine hydrochloride. Unlike the molten globule states of the bovine and goat proteins, the human alpha-lactalbumin molten globule showed remarkably more intense circular dichroism ellipticity than the native state in the far-ultraviolet region below 225 nm. During refolding from the unfolded state, human alpha-lactalbumin thus exhibited overshoot kinetics, in which the alpha-helical peptide ellipticity exceeded the native value when the molten globule folding intermediate was formed in the burst phase. The subsequent folding involved reorganization of nonnative secondary structures. It should be noted that the rate constant of the major refolding phase was approximately the same among the three types of alpha-lactalbumin and that the rate constant of unfolding was accelerated 18-600 times in the human protein, and these results interpreted the lower thermodynamic stability of this protein.     

Hydrogen exchange study of canine milk lysozyme: stabilization mechanism of the molten globule

The native state (1)H, (15)N resonance assignment of 123 of the 128 nonproline residues of canine milk lysozyme has enabled measurements of the amide hydrogen exchange of over 70 amide hydrogens in the molten globule state. To elucidate the mechanism of protein folding, the molten globule state has been studied as a model of the folding intermediate state. Lysozyme and alpha-lactalbumin are homologous to each other, but their equilibrium unfolding mechanisms differ. Generally, the folding mechanism of lysozyme obeys a two-state model, whereas that of alpha-lactalbumin follows a three-state model. Exceptions to this rule are equine and canine milk lysozymes, which exhibit a partially unfolded state during the equilibrium unfolding; this state resembles the molten globule state of alpha-lactalbumin but with extreme stability. Study of the molten globules of alpha-lactalbumin and equine milk lysozyme showed that the stabilities of their alpha-helices are similar, despite the differences in the thermodynamic stability of their molten globule states. On the other hand, our hydrogen exchange study of the molten globule of canine milk lysozyme showed that the alpha-helices are more stabilized than in alpha-lactalbumin or equine milk lysozyme and that this enhanced stability is caused by the strengthened cooperative interaction between secondary structure elements. Thus, our results underscore the importance of the cooperative interaction in the stability of the molten globule state.