Relationship between enantioselectivity of alternative molecularly imprinted polymeric membranes and species of amino acid residues composing chiral recognition sites

Molecularly imprinted polymeric membranes with tetrapeptide residue H-Asp(OcHex)-Asp(OcHex)-Asp(OcHex)-Asp(OcHex)-CH₂- (DDDD) or H-Glu(OBzl)-Glu(OBzl)-Glu(OBzl)-Glu(OBzl)-C H₂- (EEEE) were prepared during membrane preparation (casting) processing in the presence of print molecules. The Boc-L-Trp imprinted polymeric membranes thus obtained showed adsorption selectivity toward Ac-L-Trp from its racemic mixtures. From adsorption isotherms of Ac-Trp, the chiral recognition site, that had been formed by the presence of print molecules in the membrane preparation process, exclusively recognized Ac-L-Trp that possessed the same configuration of the print molecule. The affinity constants between chiral recognition sites in the membrane and Ac-L-Trp was determined to be 1.00 × 10⁴ mol^–1 dm³ and 1.08 × 10⁴ mol^–1 dm³ for the DDDD and EEEE membranes, respectively. Enantioselective electrodialysis could be attained by applying an optimum potential difference to give permselectivity, with a value close to its adsorption selectivity.     

Synthesis of molecularly imprinted polymers using a functionalized initiator for chiral-selective recognition of propranolol

We present a new concept of synthesis for preparation of molecularly imprinted polymers using a functionalized initiator to replace the traditional functional monomer. Using propranolol as a model template, a carboxyl-functionalized radical initiator was demonstrated to lead to high-selectivity polymer particles prepared in a standard precipitation polymerization system. When a single enantiomer of propranolol was used as template, the imprinted polymer particles exhibited clear chiral selectivity in an equilibrium binding experiment. Unlike the previous molecular imprinting systems where the active free radicals can be distant from the template-functional monomer complex, the method reported in this work makes sure that the actual radical polymerization takes place in the vicinity of the template-associated functional groups. The success of using functional initiator to synthesize molecularly imprinted polymers brings in new possibilities to improve the functional performance of molecularly imprinted synthetic receptors.     

Molecularly imprinted polymeric membranes

Molecularly imprinted polymeric membranes have been emerged since 1990. Among various kinds of molecular imprinting studies, the application of molecular imprinting to membrane separation is still a novel investigation. In the present review paper, molecularly imprinted polymeric membranes are summarized and examined. The application of molecular imprinting to membrane separation shortly leads to high performance separation membranes.     

HPLC-based bioseparations using molecularly imprinted polymers

HPLC-based separations of amino acids and peptides, nucleotide bases, drugs, sugars and steroids using molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) have been reviewed in this article. The molecular recognition mechanisms of the template molecules on the MIPs in organic and aqueous eluents were discussed. Furthermore, new polymerization methods suitable for preparations of HPLC columns and packing materials using molecular imprinting techniques, and their applications to HPLC-based separations are also dealt with.     

Mobile phase effects on enantiomer resolution using molecularly imprinted polymers

The aim of this study was to rationalise retention behaviour of a chiral solute on molecularly imprinted polymer (MIP) HPLC stationary phases in terms of variation of the mobile phase. It is generally held that the most important interaction governing the separation of enantiomers on such materials is H-bonding, and that retention times increase with decreasing H-bonding potential of the mobile phase. Previous studies have largely concerned mobile phases containing chloroform with acetic acid as a polar modifier. Boc-L-Phenylalanine (Boc-L-Phe-OH) MIPs were prepared, processed, and packed into HPLC columns, which were then used to investigate the retention characteristics of Boc-L-Phe-OH and Boc-D-Phe-OH with a range of mobile phases. The main observations were as follows: (1) in chloroform-based mobile phases there was generally a linear relationship between the H-bond donator factor of the polar modifier and capacity (K′). Results also indicated a hydrogen bond donor parameter value for a polar modifier at which retention became concentration independent; (2) For given values of K′_L, K′_D varied depending on the polar modifier, indicating that enantiomer resolution was solvent dependent; (3) Using mobile phases based on solvents of lower polarity/H-bonding potential than chloroform, substantial increases in K′ were observed, although enantioselectivity was greatly reduced. Chirality 9:238–242, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Highly selective recognition of L‐phenylalanine with molecularly imprinted polymers based on imidazolyl amino acid chiral ionic liquid

Several amino acid chiral ionic liquids were introduced as functional monomers to prepare molecularly imprinted polymers for specific recognition of L‐phenylalanine. Among them, the imprinted polymers L‐Phe@MIPs based on [ViImC3][L‐Pro] showed the best selective recognition ability for L‐phenylalanine. A series of experiments such as dynamic adsorption, static adsorption, and competitive adsorption were conducted to investigate the specific recognition ability and adsorption capacity of the L‐Phe@MIPs. It is found that the adsorption efficiency to L‐phenylalanine on L‐Phe@MIPs was 3.11 times higher than that to D‐phenylalanine. All the results demonstrated that the L‐Phe@MIPs possessed good recognition and relatively high adsorption efficiency for L‐phenylalanine. Besides, the recovery of L‐phenylalanine was above 98%, and the L‐Phe@MIPs exhibited good reusability.     

Investigation of disaccharide recognition by molecularly imprinted polymers

The selectivity of carbohydrate-imprinted polymers for several disaccharides, namely cellobiose, maltose, lactose and gentiobiose, is investigated. An ternary ligand–Cu(II)–carbohydrate complex was formed in alkaline solution and captured afterwards in the polymer. The accessibility of the polymer matrix for disaccharides was investigated by HPLC analysis, refractometry and ¹H NMR spectroscopy applying excess of the original template during rebinding experiments under saturation conditions in unbuffered, aqueous solution at neutral pH and 20°C. The selective discrimination of the - and -glycosidic linkage of cellobiose and maltose is demonstrated. It is further shown, that the disaccharide-imprinted polymers slightly distinguish between the 1,4-- and the 1,6--glycosidic linkage of cellobiose and gentiobiose, while cellobiose and lactose are not selectively recognized. Due to the weak apparent binding constant of the functional Cu(II) monomers with the targeted disaccharides at physiological pH, the recognition process is dominated by the shape of the created imprinted cavity under the applied conditions.     

Electrochromatographic separation of hydrophobic amino acid enantiomers by molecularly imprinted capillary columns

In the present study, the enantiomeric forms of hydrophobic amino acids (l-tryptophan, l-tyrosine, and l-phenylalanine) were separated by molecularly imprinted capillary columns (MICC) via Capillary Electrochromatography (CEC) for the first time. The monomer ratio, crosslinker ratio, template molecule ratio, the porogen ratio and type, polymerization time, and also the effect of temperature were examined to increase the permeability properties of MICC. FTIR, SEM and BET analyses were realized for the characterization of MICC. The effect of the electric field, organic solvent ratio, and pressure were carried out experimentally to determine the optimum conditions. The separation performances of MICC and the non-imprinted capillary columns (NICC) were compared electrochromatographically.     

Chiral determination of cinchonine using an electrochemiluminescent sensor with molecularly imprinted membrane on the surfaces of magnetic particles

A novel molecular imprinting electrochemiluminescence sensor for detecting chiral cinchonine molecules was developed with a molecularly imprinted polymer membrane on the surfaces of magnetic microspheres. Fe₃O₄@Au nanoparticles modified with 6‐mercapto‐beta‐cyclodextrin were used as a carrier, cinchonine as a template molecule, methacrylic acid as a functional monomer and N ,N ′‐methylenebisacrylamide as a cross‐linking agent. Cinchonine was specifically recognized by the 6‐mercapto‐beta‐cyclodextrin functional molecularly imprinted polymer and detected based on enhancement of the electrochemiluminescence intensity caused by the reaction of tertiary amino structures of cinchonine molecules with Ru(bpy)₃²⁺. Cinchonine concentrations of 1 × 10^?10 to 4 × 10^?7 mol/L showed a good linear relationship with changes of the electrochemiluminescence intensity, and the detection limit of the sensor was 3.13 × 10^?11 mol/L. The sensor has high sensitivity and selectivity, and is easy to renew. It was designed for detecting serum samples, with recovery rates of 98.2% to 107.6%.     

A molecular imprinted polymer with recognition properties towards the carcinogenic mycotoxin ochratoxin A

A molecularly imprinted polymer which recognises the mycotoxin ochratoxin A was prepared using the mimic N-(4-chloro-1-hydroxy-2-naphthoylamido)-(L) -phenylalanine as a template. The polymer was obtained by dissolving the template, methacrylic acid and ethylendimethacrylate in chloroform and polymerising the mixture by thermal treatment at 60°C. The monolith obtained was crushed, sieved to 30–90 m and extensively washed till the template could no longer be found in the washing solution. The binding properties towards the template, ochratoxin A and several related molecules were measured by eluting with acetonitrile and chloroform a HPLC column packed with the imprinted polymer. The experimental results show that the polymer recognises not only the template well, but also the ochratoxin A. The specific molecular recognition effect is due to hydrogen bond interactions but in order to assure the full recognition effect adjunctive steric factors are necessary. The magnitude of these interactions can be controlled by the use of limited amounts of acetic acid in the mobile phase.From the measurement of the relative selectivity it was found that only the simultaneous presence of the carboxyl, the phenolic hydroxyl and certain peculiar substructures such as the chlorine atom assures the whole recognition of the template.     

Binding cross-reactivity of Boc-phenylalanine enantiomers on molecularly imprinted polymers

A potential problem associated with molecularly imprinted polymer (MIP) sorbents is that of cross-reactivity. In this study three MIPs (imprinted with Boc-L-phenylalanine, Boc-L-alanine, Boc-L-glutamic acid) plus a non-imprinted control were prepared and examined for their ability to bind differentially the enantiomers of boc-protected phenylalanine in an effort to quantify cross-reactivity and to develop a predictive model. Batch rebinding studies showed a degree of predictability for a number of MIP-ligand pairs, but other combinations showed unexpectedly high levels of cross-reactivity. Despite the general acceptance of heterogeneity of MIP binding sites, many previous studies report linear Scatchard plots, which is indicative of binding site homogeneity. The data from this study produced curves, clearly demonstrating heterogeneity. The theoretical and practical implications of this heterogeneity are discussed. Chirality 9:233–237, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

New biomedical devices with selective peptide recognition properties. Part 1: Characterization and cytotoxicity of molecularly imprinted polymers

Molecular imprinting is a technique for the synthesis of polymers capable to bind target molecules selectively. The imprinting of large proteins, such as cell adhesion proteins or cell receptors, opens the way to important and innovative biomedical applications. However, such molecules can incur into important conformational changes during the preparation of the imprinted polymer impairing the specificity of the recognition cavities. The "epitope approach" can overcome this limit by adopting, as template, a short peptide sequence representative of an accessible fragment of a larger protein. The resulting imprinted polymer can recognize both the template and the whole molecule thanks to the specific cavities for the epitope. In this work two molecularly imprinted polymer formulations (a macroporous monolith and nanospheres) were obtained using the protected peptide Z-Thr-Ala-Ala-OMe, as template, and Z-Thr-Ile-Leu-OMe, as analogue for the selectivity evaluation, methacrylic acid, as functional monomer, and trimethylolpropane trimethacrylate and pentaerythritol triacrylate (PETRA), as cross-linkers. Polymers were synthesized by precipitation polymerization and characterized by standard techniques. Polymerization and rebinding solutions were analyzed by high performance liquid chromatography. The highly cross-linked polymers retained about 70% of the total template amount, against (20% for the less cross-linked ones). The extracted template amount and the rebinding capacity decreased with the cross-linking degree, while the selectivity showed the opposite behaviour. The PETRA cross-linked polymers showed the best recognition (MIP 2-, alpha=1.71) and selectivity (MIP 2+, alpha'=5.58) capabilities. The cytotoxicity tests showed normal adhesion and proliferation of fibroblasts cultured in the medium that was put in contact with the imprinted polymers.     

A fluorescent chiral chemosensor for the recognition of the two enantiomers of chiral carboxylates

A new 7-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazole (NBD)-based fluorescent chiral chemosensor (NBD-1) was prepared and applied to the recognition of the two enantiomers of the tetrabutylammonium salts of N-t-Boc-α-amino acids and chiral carboxylic acids including naproxen. In particular, the chiral recognition by the new fluorescent chiral chemosensor for the two enantiomers of N-t-Boc-threonine (tetrabutylammonium salt) was quite excellent, the Stern-Volmer constant ratio (K(D)/K(L)) for the two enantiomers being as high as 4.89.     

Study on the recognition of templates and their analogues on molecularly imprinted polymer using computational and conformational analysis approaches

A simplified computational model was proposed to simulate the synthesis of molecularly imprinted polymers (MIP), removal of template and recognition of the template and its analogues by MIP. The MIPs with nicotinamide and iso-nicotinamide as templates were prepared using methacrylic acid as functional monomer. Based on our computational model, the interaction energies between the monomer and the template or its analogues were calculated, which were well correlated with the retention factors and imprinting factors obtained on HPLC columns packed with the corresponding MIP particles. The imprinting effects of the template and its analogues were also investigated from the viewpoint of conformational analysis. The computational data were successfully used to predict the chromatographic behaviour of some chemicals in separation on HPLC columns. We believe that the computational method will find application in designing monomers for MIP synthesis and in studying recognition of templates and their analogues on MIP.     

A general criterion for molecular recognition: implications for chiral interactions

A general criterion is formulated for molecular recognition. The criterion for recognition is the inequality of the distance matrices of complexes of different compounds with a resolving agent under ambient experimental conditions. It is shown how this criterion provides for an objective, well-defined, and simple explanation for recognition of chiral compounds. This approach may be used to explain models (e.g., three-point of attachment) and relationships for chiral recognition. It is also shown how one-, two-, or three-point mechanisms are equivalent in this formalism and could result in chiral recognition. Examples are used to illustrate how the so called one- or two-point mechanisms may be operative in many experimental findings. Symmetry requirements of resolving agents may also be derived from considerations of distance matrices. Finally, the reciprocal relationship of chiral resolving agents is easily derived from the present method of analysis.     

A brief review of coarse-grained and other computational studies of molecularly imprinted polymers

Molecular imprinting is an established method for the creation of artificial recognition sites in synthetic materials through polymerization and cross-linking in the presence of template molecules. Removal of the templates leaves cavities that are complementary to the template molecules in size, shape, and functionality. In recent years, various theoretical and computational models have been developed as tools to aid in the design of molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) or to provide insight into the features that determine MIP performance. These studies can be grouped into two general approaches-screening for possible functional monomers for particular templates and macromolecular models focusing on the structural characterization of the imprinted material. In this review, we pay special attention to coarse-grained models that characterize the functional heterogeneity in imprinted pores, but also cover recent advances in atomistic and first principle studies. We offer a critical assessment of the potential impact of the various models towards improving the state-of-the-art of molecular imprinting.     

Mechanisms underlying molecularly imprinted polymer molecular memory and the role of crosslinker: resolving debate on the nature of template recognition in phenylalanine anilide imprinted polymers

A series of molecular dynamics simulations of prepolymerization mixtures for phenylalanine anilide imprinted co-(ethylene glycol dimethacrylate-methacrylic acid) molecularly imprinted polymers have been employed to investigate the mechanistic basis for template selective recognition in these systems. This has provided new insights on the mechanisms underlying template recognition, in particular the significant role played by the crosslinking agent. Importantly, the study supports the occurrence of template self-association events that allows us to resolve debate between the two previously proposed models used to explain this system's underlying recognition mechanisms. Moreover, the complexity of the molecular level events underlying template complexation is highlighted by this study, a factor that should be considered in rational molecularly imprinted polymer design, especially with respect to recognition site heterogeneity.     

A molecular dynamics investigation of chiral discrimination complexes as chiral stationary-phase models: Methyl N-(2-naphthyl)alaninate with N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)leucine n-propylamide

Molecular dynamics simulations were performed on complexes of (S)-methyl N-(2-naphthyl)alaninate (NAP) with the enantiomers of N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)leucine n-propylamide (DNB), which are used as models for chiral stationary-phase systems developed by Pirkle and co-workers. These studies were undertaken to qualitatively examine (pictorially) the role of entropic effects in these systems. The results of the dynamics calculations were used to refine the search for low-energy conformers. The structures were refined by the use of BioDesign's molecular mechanics method implemented in Biograf. The results of the structural refinements support our previous observation that the SR complex can achieve the same three primary interactions which are observed in the SS structure (i.e., two intermolecular hydrogen bonds and pi stacking) without a significant increase in energy. In addition, these primary interactions are conserved during molecular dynamics simulations with the occurrence of conformations which differ only in the rotational states of the alkyl side chains and ester group (which bears two potential hydrogen bond acceptors utilized in both the homo- and heterochiral complexes). The major difference in the two complexes is the relative position of the sec-butyl group and hydrogen atom on DNB's chiral center, both of which are outside the primary interaction region. All other local minima which have different relative pi orientations (“front–back,” “back–back,” and “back–front” as defined herein) are not sufficiently populated to make more than a negligible contribution to the statistical (time- or energy-averaged) analysis of the (SS)- and (SR)-NAP–DNB complexes. Thus the entropic effects observed in this study (e.g., alkyl side chain or ester group rotations) do not show evidence of qualitative differential effects on the maintenance of the same three primary interactions by both the homo- and heterochiral complexes. The reliability of the present study, which provides pictorial representations of the entropic effects, is not sufficient to determine whether the entropic effects observed herein are sufficient to achieve enantiomeric discrimination alone or in conjunction with other factors (e.g., conformational strain energy). Thus, all of the computational studies we have performed to date (i.e., our previous studies, which include strain energy and through-space field effects, and the present study, which includes entropic effects) show no evidence of any qualitative difference in the homo- and heterochiral complexes in terms of maintaining the same three “contact points”.     

Influence of polymerization temperature on the molecular recognition of imprinted polymers

This paper aimed at investigating the influence of polymerization temperature on the molecular recognition of molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) based on multiple non-covalent interactions. 3-l-Phenylalanylaminopyridine (3-l-PheNHPy) imprinted polymers were prepared using azobisnitriles as either thermal initiators or photoinitiators at various temperatures of 10, 40 and 60 degrees C, respectively. These polymers were subsequently evaluated in the high-performance liquid chromatographic (HPLC) mode for enantioselectivity. An unexpected result shows that polymer prepared at 40 degrees C has the highest enantioselectivity, but not the polymer prepared at lower temperature of 10 degrees C. Further, the effect of elution temperature and sample load on the selectivity of polymers was investigated in detail. In order to get a better understanding of the "exception", the influence of polymerization temperature on the polymerization extent and polymer morphology was studied by FT-IR spectrum test, cross-polarization magic angle spinning (CP-MAS) (13)NMR spectra experiment and pore analysis. Based on these results we attribute this "exception" to that there is a tradeoff between the extent of polymerization and stabilization of the template-functional monomer complexes. And an optimal polymerization temperature can be found for each combination of template and monomer.