Natural variation among Arabidopsis accessions reveals malic acid as a key mediator of Nickel (Ni) tolerance

Plants have evolved various mechanisms for detoxification that are specific to the plant species as well as the metal ion chemical properties. Malic acid, which is commonly found in plants, participates in a number of physiological processes including metal chelation. Using natural variation among Arabidopsis accessions, we investigated the function of malic acid in Nickel (Ni) tolerance and detoxification. The Ni-induced production of reactive oxygen species was found to be modulated by intracellular malic acid, indicating its crucial role in Ni detoxification. Ni tolerance in Arabidopsis may actively involve malic acid and/or complexes of Ni and malic acid. Investigation of malic acid content in roots among tolerant ecotypes suggested that a complex of Ni and malic acid may be involved in translocation of Ni from roots to leaves. The exudation of malic acid from roots in response to Ni treatment in either susceptible or tolerant plant species was found to be partially dependent on AtALMT1 expression. A lower concentration of Ni (10?μM) treatment induced AtALMT1 expression in the Ni-tolerant Arabidopsis ecotypes. We found that the ecotype Santa Clara (S.C.) not only tolerated Ni but also accumulated more Ni in leaves compared to other ecotypes. Thus, the ecotype S.C. can be used as a model system to delineate the biochemical and genetic basis of Ni tolerance, accumulation, and detoxification in plants. The evolution of Ni hyperaccumulators, which are found in serpentine soils, is an interesting corollary to the fact that S.C. is also native to serpentine soils.     

Integrated tolerance mechanisms: constitutive and adaptive plant responses to elevated metal concentrations in the environment

Isolation and study of metal tolerant and hypersensitive strains of higher plant (and yeast) species has greatly increased our knowledge of the individual pathways that are involved in tolerance. Plants have both constitutive (present in most phenotypes) and adaptive (present only in tolerant phenotypes) mechanisms for coping with elevated metal concentrations. Where studies on the mechanisms of tolerance fall down is in their failure to integrate tolerance mechanisms within cell or whole-plant function by not relating adaptive mechanisms to constitutive mechanisms. This failure often distorts the relative importance of a proposed tolerance mechanism, and indeed has confused the search for adaptive mechanisms. The fundamental goal of both constitutive and adaptive mechanisms is to limit the perturbation of cell homeostasis after exposure to metals so that normal or near-normal physiological function may take place. Consideration of the response to metals at a cellular rather than a biochemical level will lead to a greater understanding of mechanisms to withstand elevated levels of metals in both contaminated and uncontaminated environments. Recent advances in the study of Al, As, Cd, and Cu tolerance and hypersensitivity are reported with respect to the cellular response to toxic metals. The role of genetics in unravelling tolerance mechanisms is also considered.     

Nickel and zinc accumulation capacities and tolerance to these metals in the excluder Thlaspi arvense and the hyperaccumulator Noccaea caerulescens

Representatives of Brassicaceae species—the hyperaccumulator Noccaea caerulescens F.K. Mey and the metal excluder Thlaspi arvense L.—were compared in terms of their ability to accumulate nickel (Ni) and zinc (Zn) and their tolerance to these metals. Four ecotypes of N. caerulescens were used: the ecotypes La Calamine (LC, Belgium) and Saint Felix de Palliéres (SF, France) grow naturally on calamine soils rich in Zn, Cd, and Pb; the ecotype Monte Prinzera (MP, Italy) originates from serpentine soils rich in Ni, Co, and Cr; and the ecotype Lellingen (LE, Luxembourg) inhabits non-metalliferous soils. The plants of N. caerulescens were grown for 8 weeks in a half-strength Hoagland solution supplemented with 25, 100, 200, 300, and 400 μM Ni(NO₃)₂ (ecotypes LC, SF, MP, LE) or 100, 200, 400, 800, and 1000 μM Zn(NO₃)₂ (ecotypes LC, SF, LE); the plants of T. arvense were grown in the presence of 10, 20, 25, and 30 μM Ni(NO₃)₂ or 40, 50, 60, 70, 80 μM Zn(NO₃)₂. The toxic effect of Ni and Zn was assessed from changes in dry matter of roots and shoots of treated plants compared to untreated. The content of metals in roots and shoots was determined by means of atomic absorption spectrophotometry. The Ni-accumulating capacity of N. caerulescens ecotypes increased in the order: LC < SF < LE < MP, and the Zn-accumulating capacity increased in the row: LC < SF < LE. In the hyperaccumulating plant N. caerulescens, the increments of biomass started to decrease at a lower metal content in roots than in shoots, whereas the opposite pattern was observed in the metal excluder T. arvense. Since T. arvense plants accumulated Ni and Zn in roots, whereas N. caerulescens accumulated these metals in shoots, one may assume that the greater sensitivity of root growth compared with shoots in N. caerulescens was determined by more effective mechanisms of metal detoxification in shoots. Conversely, the higher sensitivity of shoot growth compared to root growth in T. arvense was determined by more effective mechanisms of metal detoxification in roots. Being more tolerant to Ni and Zn than T. arvense plants, the N. caerulescens ecotypes differed substantially in terms of metal-accumulating capacity and their tolerance to heavy metals. The ecotype originating from non-metalliferous soils (LE) accumulated larger amounts of Zn, but was less tolerant compared with ecotypes growing naturally on calamine soils (SF and LC), whereas the ecotype occurring on serpentine soils (MP) exhibited a markedly greater tolerance to Ni, compared with other ecotypes examined, as well as the largest accumulation of this metal. The results indicate the existence of different mechanisms responsible for plant tolerance to Ni and Zn; the study of these mechanisms is a promising direction for future research.     

Physiological and biochemical traits of drought tolerance in Argania spinosa

The objective of this study was to understand and characterize the physiological and biochemical tolerance mechanisms of Argania spinosa under drought stress for selection tolerant ecotypes. Significant differences were observed among ecotypes in indices of leaf water status studied: stomatal conductance (g_s), predawn leaf water potential (Ψ_pd) and leaf relative water content. There was a significant decrease in these physiological traits with increasing degree of drought stress in all ecotypes. Drought stress significantly increased endogenous H₂O₂ and lipid peroxidation. Moderate and severe drought stress increased significantly the catalase, superoxide dismutase, peroxidase, polyphenoloxidase and lipoxygenase activities, depending on time. Their constitutive activities were higher in inland ecotypes than in coastal ecotypes. According to canonical discriminant analysis, the inland ecotypes were essentially distinguished from the coastal ecotypes by the following physiological and biochemical traits: Ψ_pd, g_s, polyphenol oxidase, superoxide dismutase and malonyldialdehyde. Inland ecotypes seem to be more tolerant to drought stress than coastal ecotypes.     

Ecotypes of Holcus lanatus Tolerant to Zinc Toxicity also Tolerate Zinc Deficiency

Genotypes tolerant to zinc (Zn) toxicity, if they accumulateZn in their roots, may grow better than Zn-sensitive genotypes,even in Zn-deficient soil. In the present study, Holcus lanatusL. ecotypes differing in tolerance to Zn toxicity were grownin Zn-deficient Laffer soil which was amended with Zn to createa range of conditions from Zn deficiency to Zn toxicity. IncreasingZn additions to the soil, up to the sufficiency level, improvedgrowth of all ecotypes. At toxic levels of added Zn, the Zn-sensitiveecotype suffered a greater decrease in growth than the Zn-tolerantecotypes. All ecotypes accumulated more Zn in roots than inshoots, with root concentrations exceeding 8 g Zn kg^-1dry weightin extreme cases. When grown in Zn-deficient or Zn-sufficientsoil (up to 0.5 mg Zn kg^-1soil added), ecotypes tolerant toZn toxicity took up more Zn, grew better and had greater rootand shoot Zn concentration than the control (Zn-sensitive ecotype).Zn-tolerant ecotypes transported more Zn, copper (Cu) and iron(Fe) from roots to shoots in comparison with the Zn-sensitiveecotype. The average Zn uptake rate from Zn-deficient soil (noZn added) was greater in the Zn-tolerant ecotypes than in theZn-sensitive ecotype. In conclusion, ecotypes of H. lanatusthat are tolerant to Zn toxicity also tolerate Zn deficiencybetter than the Zn-sensitive ecotype because of their greatercapacity for taking up Zn from Zn-deficient soil. This is thefirst report of the coexistence of traits for tolerance to Zntoxicity and Zn deficiency in a single plant genotype. Copyright2000 Annals of Botany Company Copper, heavy metal, Holcus lanatus, iron, zinc deficiency, zinc toxicity     

Comparative analysis of the contribution of phytochelatins to cadmium and arsenic tolerance in soybean and white lupin

The biosynthesis of phytochelatins (PCs) plays a crucial role in the detoxification and homeostasis of heavy metals and metalloids in plants. However, in an increasing number of plant species metal(loid) tolerance is not well correlated with the accumulation of PCs: tolerant ecotypes frequently contain lower levels of PCs than non-tolerant ecotypes. In this study we have compared the responses of soybean (Glycine max L. cv. Resnik) and white lupin (Lupinus albus L. cv. Marta) to cadmium and arsenate in order to assess the role of homophytochelatins (hPCs) in the tolerance of soybean to these toxic elements. Soybean plants treated with Cd and As showed a high contribution of homo-glutathione (hGSH) to the pool of thiols in shoots in comparison to white lupin. Higher levels of hPCs in Cd-treated soybeans compared to PCs in lupins did not prevent growth inhibition. In contrast, the role of hPCs in the detoxification mechanism to arsenate in soybean seems to be clearer, showing higher thiol concentrations and lower growth reductions than those present in lupin plants.     

Distribution of cadmium in leaves of cadmium tolerant and sensitive ecotypes of Silene vulgaris

It has been postulated that vacuolar compartmentation might play an important role in naturally selected cadmium tolerance in Silene vulgaris (Moench.) Garcke (Bladder campion). Additionally, a tendency of heavy metals to accumulate in the epidermis has been reported. Since these factors would affect the distribution of cadmium in leaves, we determined the distribution of cadmium in leaves of cadmium tolerant and sensitive ecotypes of Silene vulgaris at different levels of exposure and at different time intervals. Cadmium concentrations were higher in leaves of sensitive plants than in those of cadmium tolerant ones after identical exposure to cadmium for a period of 8 days. The highest cadmium concentrations were found in the lower epidermis of plants of both ecotypes. The amount of cadmium located at the lower epidermis was highest for sensitive plants, although the stomatal density was lower in the sensitive ecotype than in the tolerant one. A possible explanation for this phenomenon is the weak relationship between transpiration (water flow) and element allocation. Our results support the hypothesis that vacuolar storage of cadmium plays an important role in the mechanism of cadmium tolerance in Silene vulgaris .     

Cadmium tolerance plasticity in Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae: glutathione as a detoxifying agent

Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae strains expressing different degrees of tolerance to metal stress were used in this work to study the basic mechanisms underlying heavy metal tolerance. We used various parameters to evaluate this response. The strains' growth responses under different Cd2+ concentrations were determined and we reported variation in Cd2+ tolerance. Total soluble protein content decreased drastically, revealing the toxic effects that intracellular Cd2+ imposes on cellular metabolism, but this decrease in protein content was particularly evident in sensitive and moderately tolerant strains. Tolerant strains presented the highest intracellular and wall-bound Cd2+ concentrations. Cd2+ induced increases in the expression of some specific proteins, which were identical in all tolerant strains. Glutathione levels remained unaltered in the sensitive strain and increased significantly in tolerant and moderately tolerant strains, suggesting the importance of glutathione in coping with metal stress. This work suggests that efflux mechanisms may not be the only system responsible for dealing with heavy metal tolerance. A clear correlation between glutathione levels and Cd2+ tolerance is reported, thus adding a novel aspect in bacteria protection against heavy metal deleterious effects.     

Increased resistance to copper-induced damage of the root cell plasmalemma in copper tolerant Silene cucubalus

The relation between copper tolerance and the sensitivity of plants with respect to the effect of copper on the plasmalemma of root cells was studied using plants from one copper sensitive and two copper tolerant populations of Silene cucubalus Wib. In each population, the external copper concentration needed to induce ion leakage (a measure of damage to the permeability barrier) was similar to the highest no-effect-concentration of copper for root growth in that population. At higher concentrations, the degree of root growth inhibition paralleled the rate of ion leakage, the degree of trypan blue staining (a measure of plasmalemma integrity) and the accumulation of lipid peroxidation products. The amount of copper taken up by the plants was inversely related to their level of copper tolerance. Compared to copper sensitive plants, copper tolerant plants showed no increased resistance to either the sulfhydryl reagent N-ethylmaleimide or the free radical-producing compound cumene hydroperoxide.
These results indicate that damage to the permeability barrier of root cells constitutes the primary effect of copper toxicity in both sensitive and tolerant plants, and that copper tolerance is coupled to the ability of the plants to prevent such damage. This ability might depend on exclusion of copper by the root cell plasmalemma.     

Bacterial tolerances to metals and antibiotics in metal-contaminated and reference streams

Anthropogenic-derived sources of selection are typically implicated as mechanisms for maintaining antibiotic resistance in the environment. Here we report an additional mechanism for maintaining antibiotic resistance in the environment through bacterial exposure to metals. Using a culture-independent approach, bacteria sampled along a gradient of metal contamination were more tolerant of antibiotics and metals compared to bacteria from a reference site. This evidence supports the hypothesis that metal contamination directly selects for metal tolerant bacteria while co-selecting for antibiotic tolerant bacteria. Additionally, to assess how antibiotic and metal tolerance may be transported through a stream network, we studied antibiotic and metal tolerance patterns over three months in bacteria collected from multiple stream microhabitats including the water column, biofilm, sediment and Corbicula fluminea (Asiatic clam) digestive tracts. Sediment bacteria were the most tolerant to antibiotics and metals, while bacteria from Corbicula were the least tolerant. Differences between microhabitats may be important for identifying reservoirs of resistance and for predicting how these genes are transferred and transported in metal-contaminated streams. Temporal dynamics were not directly correlated to a suite of physicochemical parameters, suggesting that tolerance patterns within microhabitats are linked to a complex interaction of the physicochemical characteristics of the stream.     

高等植物重金属耐性与超积累特性及其分子机理研究

由于重金属污染日益严重, 重金属在土壤_植物系统中的行为引起了人们的高度重视。高等植物对重金 属的耐性与积累性, 已经成为污染生态学研究的热点。近年来, 由于分子生态学等学科的发展, 有关植物对重金属的解毒和耐性机理、重金属离子富集机制的研究取得了较大进展。高等植物对重金属的耐性和积累在种间和基因型之间存在很大差异。根系是重金 属等土壤污染物进入植物的门户。根系分泌物改变重金属的生物有效性和毒性, 并在植物吸收重金属的过程中发挥重要作用。土壤中的大部分重金属离子都是通过金属转运蛋白进入根细胞, 并在植物体内进一步转运至液泡贮存。在重金属胁迫条件下植物螯合肽 (PC) 的合成是植物对胁迫的一种适应性反应。耐性基因型合成较多的PC, 谷胱甘肽 (GSH) 是合成PC的前体, 重金属与PC螯合并转移至液泡中贮存, 从而达到解毒效果。金属硫蛋白 (MTs) 与PC一样, 可以与重金属离子螯合, 从而降低重金属离子的毒性。该文从分子水平上论述了根系分泌物、金属转运蛋白、MTs、PC、GSH在重金属耐性及超积累性中的作用, 评述了近 10年来这方面的研究进展, 并在此基础上提出存在的问题和今后研究的重点。     

Elevated expression of TcHMA3 plays a key role in the extreme Cd tolerance in a Cd-hyperaccumulating ecotype of Thlaspi caerulescens

Cadmium (Cd) is a highly toxic heavy metal for plants, but several unique Cd-hyperaccumulating plant species are able to accumulate this metal to extraordinary concentrations in the aboveground tissues without showing any toxic symptoms. However, the molecular mechanisms underlying this hypertolerance to Cd are poorly understood. Here we have isolated and functionally characterized an allelic gene, TcHMA3 (heavy metal ATPase 3) from two ecotypes (Ganges and Prayon) of Thlaspi caerulescens contrasting in Cd accumulation and tolerance. The TcHMA3 alleles from the higher (Ganges) and lower Cd-accumulating ecotype (Prayon) share 97.8% identity, and encode a P(1B)-type ATPase. There were no differences in the expression pattern, cell-specificity of protein localization and transport substrate-specificity of TcHMA3 between the two ecotypes. Both alleles were characterized by constitutive expression in the shoot and root, a tonoplast localization of the protein in all leaf cells and specific transport activity for Cd. The only difference between the two ecotypes was the expression level of TcHMA3: Ganges showed a sevenfold higher expression than Prayon, partly caused by a higher copy number. Furthermore, the expression level and localization of TcHMA3 were different from AtHMA3 expression in Arabidopsis. Overexpression of TcHMA3 in Arabidopsis significantly enhanced tolerance to Cd and slightly increased tolerance to Zn, but did not change Co or Pb tolerance. These results indicate that TcHMA3 is a tonoplast-localized transporter highly specific for Cd, which is responsible for sequestration of Cd into the leaf vacuoles, and that a higher expression of this gene is required for Cd hypertolerance in the Cd-hyperaccumulating ecotype of T. caerulescens.     

Cadmium exposure triggers genotype-dependent changes in seed vigor and germination of tomato offspring

Although negative effects on the offspring fitness can be triggered by the mother-plant exposure to environmental stresses, some plants are able to “remember” past incidents and enhance the progeny tolerance. Here, the mineral profile, cytogenetic modifications, and physiological potential of seeds from two tomato cultivars, with contrasting tolerance degrees to cadmium (Cd) toxicity, were evaluated after plant exposure to this metal. Both cultivars exhibited high Cd translocation to the seeds; however, the tolerant tomato accumulated more Cd than did the sensitive one. As a consequence of the Cd accumulation, reductions in the Mn concentration in Cd-challenged plants were detected. Surprisingly, seed germination and vigor were increased in the tolerant tomato cultivar after Cd exposure, despite increases in the chromosomal abnormalities. By contrast, seeds from the sensitive cultivar exhibited no changes in their physiological potential after Cd exposure, despite Cd-induced reductions in the mitotic index. Moreover, bunch position exerted effects on the vigor and type of chromosomal abnormality. The results show that maternal plant exposure to Cd can affect tomato offspring by changing the seed physiological potential, and such effect can be partially explained by alterations in the seed-derived elements (essential and non-essential) and genotype-dependent tolerance mechanisms.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis TTR1</Emphasis> causes LRR-dependent lethal systemic necrosis,rather than systemic acquired resistance,to Tobacco ringspot virus

Most Arabidopsis ecotypes display tolerance to the Tobacco ringspot virus (TRSV), but a subset of Arabidopsis ecotypes, including Estland (Est), develop lethal systemic necrosis (LSN), which differs from the localized hypersensitive responses (HRs) or systemic acquired resistance (SAR) characteristic of incompatible reactions. Neither viral replication nor the systemic movement of TRSV was restricted in tolerant or sensitive Arabidopsis ecotypes; therefore, the LSN phenotype shown in the sensitive ecotypes might not be due to viral accumulation. In the present study, we identified the Est TTR1 gene (tolerance to Tobacco ringspot virus 1) encoding a TIR-NBS-LRR protein that controls the ecotype-dependent tolerant/sensitive phenotypes by a map-based cloning method. The tolerant Col-0 ecotype Arabidopsis transformed with the sensitive Est TTR1 allele developed an LSN phenotype upon TRSV infection, suggesting that the Est TTR1 allele is dominant over the tolerant ttr1 allele of Col-0. Multiple sequence alignments of 10 tolerant ecotypes from those of eight sensitive ecotypes showed that 10 LRR amino acid polymorphisms were consistently distributed across the TTR1/ttr1 alleles. Site-directed mutagenesis of these amino acids in the LRR region revealed that two sites, L956S and K1124Q, completely abolished the LSN phenotype. VIGS study revealed that TTR1 is dependent on SGT1, rather than EDS1. The LSN phenotype by TTR1 was shown to be transferred to Nicotiana benthamiana, demonstrating functional conservation of TTR1 across plant families, which are involved in SGT-dependent defense responses, rather than EDS1-dependent signaling pathways.     

Variations in sensitivity to copper and zinc among three isolated populations of the seagrass, Zostera capricorni

Metal accumulation in seagrass is well documented, but toxic impacts and mechanisms of tolerance in seagrass are not well understood. We looked at the impacts of 10 h exposure to copper and zinc for three isolated populations of Zostera capricorni in the Sydney (Australia) region. Photosynthetic efficiency (measured as the effective quantum yield, ΔF/Fm′) and chlorophyll pigment concentrations showed different sensitivities to metal impacts at the three geographically isolated sites. Seagrasses from the least developed estuary were the most sensitive to metals and the two more developed estuaries had more tolerant populations. Determination of metal concentrations in the leaves showed that there was no difference in metal exclusion as the sensitive seagrass accumulated no more metal than the tolerant seagrass. Equally, background levels of copper and zinc in the sediments and seagrass tissue could not explain the differences in tolerance. We discuss some other possible mechanisms of tolerance. The outcomes suggest that assessing metal content in seagrass tissue may not demonstrate degree of photosynthetic impact.     

Screening Possible Mechanisms Mediating Cadmium Resistance in Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae Isolated from Contaminated Portuguese Soils

Environment heavy-metal contamination is now widespread. Soils may become contaminated from a variety of anthropogenic sources, such as smelters, mining, industry, and application of metal-containing pesticides and fertilizers. Soil microorganisms are very sensitive to moderate heavy-metal concentrations. Therefore, the present work was designed to screen possible mechanisms involved in Rhizobium's Cd resistance; with this purpose, we determined the tolerance levels of several isolates originated from sites with different heavy-metal contamination. Whole-cell-soluble proteins and plasmid profiles were analyzed. We also determined Cd cell concentrations and lipopolysaccharide (LPS) amounts. Results showed different tolerances among Rhizobium isolates; according to their maximum resistance level, isolates were divided in four groups: sensitive (0–125 μM CdCl₂), moderately tolerant (125–210 μM CdCl₂), tolerant (250–500 μM CdCl₂), and extremely tolerant (≥750 μM CdCl₂). Intracellular Cd concentrations were lower when compared to wall-bound Cd. Unexpectedly, extremely tolerant isolates accumulated higher levels of metal, suggesting the presence of intracellular agents that prevent metal interfering with important metabolic pathways. The electrophoretic patterns of whole-cell-soluble proteins evidenced cadmium as an inducer of protein metabolism alterations, which were more evident in some polypeptides. Plasmid profiles also showed differences; most tolerant isolates presented two plasmids with molecular weights of 485 and 415 kb, indicating that extrachromosomal DNA may be involved in cadmium resistance. LPS showed to be a common mechanism of resistance. However, the degree of tolerance conferred by LPS is not enough to support tolerance to the higher levels of stress imposed. Presence of other resistance mechanisms is currently being investigated.     

Life history variation in the heavy metal tolerant plant Thlaspi caerulescens growing in a network of contaminated and noncontaminated sites in southern France: role of gene flow, selection and phenotypic plasticity

* Here we explore life history differences in a set of neighbouring metallicolous and nonmetallicolous populations of the heavy metal tolerant plant Thlaspi caerulescens. * We contrasted data from field observations and from a common garden experiment, in which soil zinc (Zn) concentration and light availability were manipulated, and data on microsatellite molecular variation. * The two ecotypes showed few differences in life history in the field, but large differences in their response to Zn concentration in the common garden. Soil toxicity affected most characters in nonmetallicolous plants, while it had no effect on metallicolous plants. The two ecotypes responded similarly to light. Genetic differentiation for quantitative characters between ecotypes contrasted with the absence of differentiation for microsatellites. Conversely, populations of the same ecotype showed similar responses to Zn, despite their high differentiation for molecular markers. * We conclude that divergent selection related to soil toxicity has had a predominant role in shaping life history differences between ecotypes, gene flow weakly opposing local adaptation despite geographical proximity.