Optimizing recombinant antibody function in SPR immunosensing. The influence of antibody structural format and chip surface chemistry on assay sensitivity

BACKGROUND: Recombinant antibody fragments are valuable tools for SPR-based detection of small molecules such as illicit drugs. However, the multiple structural formats of recombinant antibody fragments are largely uncharacterised with respect to their respective performance in SPR sensing. We have expressed a model anti-M3G antibody in both scFv and chimeric Fab formats to examine its sensitivity and binding profiles in a microplate immunoassay format and Biacore. We have further examined the influence of scFv multimerisation, Fab constant region stability and SPR chip surface coating chemistry, on anti-hapten SPR assay development. RESULTS: Under optimised competition ELISA conditions, the anti-M3G scFv was found to have an IC(50) value of 30 ng/ml, while the most stable Fab construct exhibited an IC(50) value of 2.4 ng/ml. In SPR competition assay on an M3G-OVA-coated SPR chip surface, the two constructs again differed in sensitivity, with IC(50) values of 117 and 19 ng/ml for the scFv and Fab, respectively (the scFv also exhibiting poor linearity of response). However, when the SPR chip surface was directly coated with M3G, both antibody constructs exhibited good linearity of response, similar high sensitivity IC(50) values (scFv 30 ng/ml, Fab 14 ng/ml) and high reproducibility (50 effective regenerations for M3G-OVA, 200 for M3G direct). During SPR assay development it was noticed that scFv and Fab constructs gave differing off-rate profiles. Subsequent HPLC, ELISA and electrophoretic analyses then confirmed that a portion of the scFv population multimerises. Bivalent scFv was found to profoundly affect the dissociation curve for scFv in stringent SPR kinetic analyses, leading to a 40-fold difference in calculated off-rate values (Fab off rate 4.7 x 10(-3)S(-1), scFv off rate 1.03 x 10(-2)S(-1)). CONCLUSION: The structural format of recombinant antibody fragments and chip functionalisation methodology can both profoundly affect the function of anti-M3G SPR assay, with direct coating and Fab format proving to be optimal. The confirmation of scFv multimerisation and resulting changes in SPR kinetics profile, in comparison with a Fab, further suggest that caution must be taken in the interpretation of SPR sensorgrams, which are commonly used in the 'affinity ranking' of scFv panels in which the extent of dimerisation in each sample is unknown.     

Thermodynamic basis for antibody binding to Z-DNA: comparison of a monoclonal antibody and its recombinant derivatives

Antibody engineering represents a promising area in biotechnology. Recombinant antibodies can be easily manipulated generating new ligand and effector activities that can be used as prototype magic bullets. On the other hand, an extensive knowledge of recombinant antibody binding and stability features are essential for an efficient substitution. In this study, we compared the stability and protein binding properties of two recombinant antibody fragments with their parental monoclonal antibody. The recombinant fragments were a monomeric scFv and a dimeric one, harboring human IgG1 CH2-CH3 domains. We have used fluorescence titration quenching to determine the thermodynamics of the interaction between an anti-Z-DNA monoclonal antibody and its recombinant antibody fragments with Z-DNA. All the antibody fragments seemed to bind DNA similarly, in peculiar two-affinity states. Enthalpy-entropy compensation was observed for both affinity states, but a marked entropy difference was observed for the monomeric scFv antibody fragment, mainly for the high affinity binding. In addition, we compared the stability of the dimeric antibody fragment and found differences favoring the monoclonal antibody. These differences seem to derive from the heterologous expression system used.     

Antibody fragments: Hope and hype

The antibody molecule is modular and separate domains can be extracted through biochemical or genetic means. It is clear from review of the literature that a wave of novel, antigen-specific molecular forms may soon enter clinical evaluation. This report examines the developmental histories of therapeutics derived from antigen-specific fragments of antibodies produced by recombinant processes. Three general types of fragments were observed, antigen-binding fragments (Fab), single chain variable fragments (scFv) and “third generation” (3G), each representing a successive wave of antibody fragment technology. In parallel, drug developers have explored multi-specificity and conjugation with exogenous functional moieties in all three fragment types. Despite high hopes and an active pipeline, enthusiasm for differentiating performance of fragments should, perhaps, be tempered as there are yet few data that suggest these molecules have distinct clinical properties due only to their size.Key words: antibody fragments, scFv, Fab, technology development, antibody-drug conjugate     

Generation of functional scFv intrabodies for triggering anti-tumor immunity

Intracellular expression of recombinant antibodies (intrabodies) allows to interfere with the functions of oncogenic or viral molecules expressed in different cell compartments and has therefore a vast clinical potential in therapy. Although the use of phage-display libraries has made it possible to select Fab or single chain Fv (scFv) antibody fragments usable for intracellular targeting, a major source of recombinant antibodies for therapeutic use still remains hybridoma B cells producing well-characterized monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). However, the cloning and the intracellular expression of antibody fragments derived from mAbs can be markedly hampered by a number of technical difficulties that include failure of cloning functional variable regions as well as lack of binding of the antibody fragments to the targeted molecule in an intracellular environment. We discuss herein various molecular methods that have been developed to generate functional recombinant antibody fragments usable as anti-tumor triggering agents when expressed in tumor cells. Such antibodies can neutralize or modify the activity of oncogenic molecules when addressed in specific subcellular compartments and/or they can be used to trigger anti-tumor immunity when expressed on tumor cell surface.     

Engineering stable cytoplasmic intrabodies with designed specificity

Many attempts have been made to develop antibody fragments that can be expressed in the cytoplasm ("intrabodies") in a stable and functional form. The recombinant antibody fragment scFv(F8) is characterised by peculiarly high in vitro stability and functional folding in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic cytoplasm. To dissect the relative contribution of different scFv(F8) regions to cytoplasmic stability and specificity we designed and constructed five chimeric molecules (scFv-P1 to P5) in which several groups of residues important for antigen binding in the poorly stable anti-hen egg lysozyme (HEL) scFv(D1.3) were progressively grafted onto the scFv(F8) scaffold. All five chimeric scFvs were expressed in a soluble form in the periplasm and cytoplasm of Escherichia coli. All the periplasmic oxidised forms and the scFv(P3) extracted from the cytoplasm in reducing conditions had HEL binding affinities essentially identical (K(d)=15nM) to that of the cognate scFv(D1.3) fragment (K(d)=16nM). The successful grafting of the antigen binding properties of D1.3 onto the scFv(F8) opens the road to the exploitation of this molecule as a scaffold for the reshaping of intrabodies with desired specificities to be targeted to the cytoplasm.     

Grafting of protein L-binding activity onto recombinant antibody fragments

Recombinant antibody fragments consisting of variable domains can be easily produced in various host cells, but there is no universal system that can be used to purify and detect them in the free form or complexed with their antigen. Protein L (PpL) is a cell wall protein isolated from Peptostreptococcus magnus, which has been reported to interact with the V-KAPPA chain of some, but not all, antibodies. Here we grafted the V-KAPPA framework region 1 (FR1) sequence of a high-affinity PpL-binding antibody onto single-chain antibody fragments (scFvs), which have no reactivity with PpL. This substitution made it possible to purify and detect scFvs using PpL conjugates. It did not hinder scFv folding and expression in recombinant bacteria, and it did not interfere with their antigen-binding function. We also identified residue 12 as being potentially able to alter PpL binding. This study, therefore, suggests a way of engineering a PpL-binding site on any scFv without interfering with its function. This could provide a universally applicable method both for the rapid purification of functional recombinant antibody fragments and for their detection even when complexed with their antigen without requiring fusion to an epitope Flag.     

Antigen-independent selection of intracellular stable antibody frameworks

The intracellular expression of highly specific antibody fragments ("intrabodies") in eukaryotes has a great potential in functional genomics and therapeutics. However, since the intracellular reducing environment prevents formation of the conserved intrachain disulfide bonds, most antibodies do not fold properly and are therefore inactive inside cells. The few antibodies that have been found to function in an intracellular environment and that have been characterized for their biophysical properties have generally shown a high degree of stability and solubility. Thus, for intracellular expression and application, very stable antibody frameworks are needed that can correctly fold even in the absence of disulfide bonds and that do not aggregate. Here, we present and discuss a novel method, named "Quality Control," which allows selection of stable and soluble antibody frameworks in vivo without the requirement or knowledge of antigens. This system is based on the expression of single-chain antibody fragments (scFvs) fused to a selectable marker that can control gene expression and cell growth. The activity of such a selectable marker fused to various scFvs that have been biophysically characterized correlated with the solubility and stability of the scFv moieties. This antigen-independent intrabody selection system was applied to screen scFv libraries for identifying stable and soluble frameworks, which subsequently served as acceptor backbones to construct intrabody libraries by randomization of hypervariable loops.     

Single chain Fab (scFab) fragment

Background  

The connection of the variable part of the heavy chain (VH) and and the variable part of the light chain (VL) by a peptide linker to form a consecutive polypeptide chain (single chain antibody, scFv) was a breakthrough for the functional production of antibody fragments in Escherichia coli. Being double the size of fragment variable (Fv) fragments and requiring assembly of two independent polypeptide chains, functional Fab fragments are usually produced with significantly lower yields in E. coli. An antibody design combining stability and assay compatibility of the fragment antigen binding (Fab) with high level bacterial expression of single chain Fv fragments would be desirable. The desired antibody fragment should be both suitable for expression as soluble antibody in E. coli and antibody phage display.     

Comprehensive optimization of a single-chain variable domain antibody fragment as a targeting ligand for a cytotoxic nanoparticle

Antibody-targeted nanoparticles have the potential to significantly increase the therapeutic index of cytotoxic anti-cancer therapies by directing them to tumor cells. Using antibodies or their fragments requires careful engineering because multiple parameters, including affinity, internalization rate and stability, all need to be optimized. Here, we present a case study of the iterative engineering of a single chain variable fragment (scFv) for use as a targeting arm of a liposomal cytotoxic nanoparticle. We describe the effect of the orientation of variable domains, the length and composition of the interdomain protein linker that connects VH and VL, and stabilizing mutations in both the framework and complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) on the molecular properties of the scFv. We show that variable domain orientation can alter cross-reactivity to murine antigen while maintaining affinity to the human antigen. We demonstrate that tyrosine residues in the CDRs make diverse contributions to the binding affinity and biophysical properties, and that replacement of non-essential tyrosines can improve the stability and bioactivity of the scFv. Our studies demonstrate that a comprehensive engineering strategy may be required to identify a scFv with optimal characteristics for nanoparticle targeting.     

Comprehensive optimization of a single-chain variable domain antibody fragment as a targeting ligand for a cytotoxic nanoparticle

Antibody-targeted nanoparticles have the potential to significantly increase the therapeutic index of cytotoxic anti-cancer therapies by directing them to tumor cells. Using antibodies or their fragments requires careful engineering because multiple parameters, including affinity, internalization rate and stability, all need to be optimized. Here, we present a case study of the iterative engineering of a single chain variable fragment (scFv) for use as a targeting arm of a liposomal cytotoxic nanoparticle. We describe the effect of the orientation of variable domains, the length and composition of the interdomain protein linker that connects VH and VL, and stabilizing mutations in both the framework and complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) on the molecular properties of the scFv. We show that variable domain orientation can alter cross-reactivity to murine antigen while maintaining affinity to the human antigen. We demonstrate that tyrosine residues in the CDRs make diverse contributions to the binding affinity and biophysical properties, and that replacement of non-essential tyrosines can improve the stability and bioactivity of the scFv. Our studies demonstrate that a comprehensive engineering strategy may be required to identify a scFv with optimal characteristics for nanoparticle targeting.     

Structure and dynamics of the anti-AMCV scFv(F8): effects of selected mutations on the antigen combining site

The recombinant antibody fragment scFv(F8), which recognizes the coat protein of the plant virus AMCV, is characterized by peculiar high in vitro stability and functional folding even in reducing environments, making it fit for designing stable antibodies with desired properties. Mutagenesis and functional analysis evidenced two residues, at positions 47 and 58 of the V(H) chain, playing a crucial role in the antigen binding recognition. Here, we used a computational procedure to assess the effects of these mutations on the stability, structure and dynamics of the antigen-binding site. Structural models of the wild type scFv(F8) and of its H47 and H58 mutants were built by homology modelling and assessed by multiple 15.5ns of molecular dynamics simulations. Computational results indicate that the 47H substitution strongly affects the CDR-H(2) conformation, destabilizes the V(H)/V(L) interface and confers high conformational flexibility to the antigen-binding site, leading the mutant to functional loss. The mutation at position H58 strenghtens the binding site, bestowing a high antigen specificity on the mutant. The essential dynamics and the analysis of the protein-solvent interface further corroborate the correspondence between the extent of the structurally-determined flexibility of the binding site with the different functional behaviours proved by the wild-type and its mutants. These results may have useful implications for structure-based design of antibody combining site.     

Nanocell targeting using engineered bispecific antibodies

There are many design formats for bispecific antibodies (BsAbs), and the best design choice is highly dependent on the final application. Our aim was to engineer BsAbs to target a novel nanocell (EnGeneIC Delivery Vehicle or EDV^TMnanocell) to the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). EDV^TMnanocells are coated with lipopolysaccharide (LPS), and BsAb designs incorporated single chain Fv (scFv) fragments derived from an anti-LPS antibody (1H10) and an anti-EGFR antibody, ABX-EGF. We engineered various BsAb formats with monovalent or bivalent binding arms and linked scFv fragments via either glycine-serine (G4S) or Fc-linkers. Binding analyses utilizing ELISA, surface plasmon resonance, bio-layer interferometry, flow cytometry and fluorescence microscopy showed that binding to LPS and to either soluble recombinant EGFR or MDA-MB-468 cells expressing EGFR, was conserved for all construct designs. However, the Fc-linked BsAbs led to nanocell clumping upon binding to EDV^TMnanocells. Clumping was eliminated when additional disulfide bonds were incorporated into the scFv components of the BsAbs, but this resulted in lower BsAb expression. The G4S-linked tandem scFv BsAb format was the optimal design with respect to EDV binding and expression yield. Doxorubicin-loaded EDV^TMnanocells actively targeted with tandem scFv BsAb in vivo to MDA-MB-468-derived tumors in mouse xenograft models enhanced tumor regression by 40% compared to passively targeted EDV^TMnanocells. BsAbs therefore provide a functional means to deliver EDV^TMnanocells to target cells.     

Nanocell targeting using engineered bispecific antibodies

There are many design formats for bispecific antibodies (BsAbs), and the best design choice is highly dependent on the final application. Our aim was to engineer BsAbs to target a novel nanocell (EnGeneIC Delivery Vehicle or EDV^TMnanocell) to the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). EDV^TMnanocells are coated with lipopolysaccharide (LPS), and BsAb designs incorporated single chain Fv (scFv) fragments derived from an anti-LPS antibody (1H10) and an anti-EGFR antibody, ABX-EGF. We engineered various BsAb formats with monovalent or bivalent binding arms and linked scFv fragments via either glycine-serine (G4S) or Fc-linkers. Binding analyses utilizing ELISA, surface plasmon resonance, bio-layer interferometry, flow cytometry and fluorescence microscopy showed that binding to LPS and to either soluble recombinant EGFR or MDA-MB-468 cells expressing EGFR, was conserved for all construct designs. However, the Fc-linked BsAbs led to nanocell clumping upon binding to EDV^TMnanocells. Clumping was eliminated when additional disulfide bonds were incorporated into the scFv components of the BsAbs, but this resulted in lower BsAb expression. The G4S-linked tandem scFv BsAb format was the optimal design with respect to EDV binding and expression yield. Doxorubicin-loaded EDV^TMnanocells actively targeted with tandem scFv BsAb in vivo to MDA-MB-468-derived tumors in mouse xenograft models enhanced tumor regression by 40% compared to passively targeted EDV^TMnanocells. BsAbs therefore provide a functional means to deliver EDV^TMnanocells to target cells.     

Functional expression of a single-chain antibody specific for the HER2 human oncogene in a bacterial reducing environment

Recombinant antibody fragments represent useful tools for cancer diagnosis and therapy. Aberrant expression of the HER2 receptor is implicated in metastatic breast and ovary cancers, two malignancies with a high prevalence in young women. In this study, we focussed on a single-chain fragment of variable antibody regions specific for HER2 (scFv800E6) that can be expressed in a functional form in the cytoplasm of Escherichia coli. ScFv800E6 was extracted from bacterial cultures following induction at different temperatures and purified. The yield of both soluble and insoluble forms was measured. We found that scFv800E6 was functional when expressed in the soluble fraction in the bacteria cytosol. In addition, scFv800E6 extracted from inclusion bodies was easily refolded and largely recovered its functionality. Thus, scFv800E6 is intrinsically capable of efficient and functional folding in a reducing environment and represents one of the few described antibody fragments with a framework well adapted for cytoplasmic expression.     

A generic strategy for subcloning antibody variable regions from the scFv phage display vector pCANTAB 5 E into pASK85 permits the economical production of F(ab) fragments and leads to improved recombinant immunoglobulin stability

Apart from the decisive sensitivity and specificity of immunosensors, the employed antibodies essentially contribute to additional key factors like fabrication costs for sensor chips and sensor stability. A production scheme for recombinant antibody fragments has been optimised with respect to these particular issues of biosensor development. The phagemid vector pCANTAB 5 E is widely used for the selection of antibody fragments from corresponding libraries. However, large-scale production of the selected single-chain F(v) (scFv) fragments is substantially restricted by the high cost for the inducer IPTG and the anti-E-tag antibody. The latter is needed in significant amounts for the purification of the recombinant protein. A generic strategy was established for subcloning scFv variable regions from pCANTAB 5 E into the plasmid pASK85 for the expression of F(ab) fragments. pASK85 bears coding sequences for murine constant domains including a His(6) tag at the carboxyl-terminal end of the constant heavy chain domain. The anti-s-triazine antibody K47H served as a model system in this study. Biosynthesis of the F(ab) fragment in a high cell density fermenter was induced by addition of anhydrotetracycline. The F(ab) fragment was subsequently purified from the periplasmic extract in a single step by immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC). A yield of 100 microg/lxOD(550) purified F(ab) fragment was obtained employing a standard fermentation scheme. The sensitivity and cross-reactivity of the F(ab) was comparable to the parent scFv when assayed by enzyme immunoassay. However, the F(ab) fragment exhibited significantly improved long-term stability.     

High-throughgput phage-display screening in array format

Emerging technologies for the design and generation of human antibodies require improved approaches enabling their screening, characterization and validation. Currently, strategies based on ELISA or western blot are used to that aim. However, the ever increasing number of novel antibodies generated would benefit from the development of new high-throughput (HT) platforms facilitating rapid antibody identification and characterization. Herein, we describe a protein chip bearing recombinant phage particles and based on a large phage antibody library. In this paper we have set forth a novel implementation which provides a powerful and simple methodology enabling the identification of single-chain variable fragments (scFv). As a proof-of-principle of this method, we tested it with recombinant antigen (human recombinant interleukin 8). Additionally, we developed a novel bioinformatics tool that serves to compare this novel strategy with traditional methods. The method described here, together with associated informatics tools, is robust, relatively fast and represents a step-forward in protocols including phage library screenings.     

Helix-stabilized Fv (hsFv) antibody fragments: substituting the constant domains of a Fab fragment for a heterodimeric coiled-coil domain.

Antibody Fv fragments would in principle be useful for a variety of biotechnological applications because of their small size and the possibility to produce them in relatively large amounts in recombinant form; however, their limited stability is a drawback. To solve this problem, both domains are usually fused via a peptide linker to form a single-chain Fv (scFv) fragment, but in some cases this leads to a dimerization. We present an alternative format for stabilizing antibody Fv fragments. The C(H)1 and C(L) domain of the Fab fragment were replaced with a heterodimeric coiled coil (WinZip-A2B1), which had previously been selected using a protein-fragment complementation assay in Escherichia coli. This new antibody format was termed helix-stabilized Fv fragment (hsFv), and was compared to the corresponding Fv, Fab and single-chain Fv format. Bacterial growth and expression of the hsFv was significantly improved compared to the Fab fragment. The hsFv fragment formed a heterodimer of heavy and light chain with the expected molecular mass, also under conditions where the scFv fragment was predominantly dimeric. The hsFv fragment was significantly more stable than the Fv fragment, and nearly as stable as the scFv fragment under the conditions used (80 nM protein concentration). Thus, the format of a helix-stabilized Fv (hsFv) fragment can be a useful alternative to existing recombinant antibody formats, especially in cases where poor expression of Fab fragments or multimerization of scFv fragments is a problem.     

A single-chain antibody fragment is functionally expressed in the cytoplasm of both Escherichia coli and transgenic plants.

Despite the well-known crucial role of intradomain disulfide bridges for immunoglobulin folding and stability, the single-chain variable fragment of the anti-viral antibody F8 is functionally expressed when targeted to the reducing environment of the plant cytoplasm. We show here that this antibody fragment is also functionally expressed in the cytoplasm of Escherichia coli. A gel shift assay revealed that the single-chain variable fragment (scFv) accumulating in the plant and bacterial cytoplasm bears free sulfhydryl groups. Guanidinium chloride denaturation/renaturation studies indicated that refolding occurs even in a reducing environment, producing a functional molecule with the same spectral properties of the native scFv(F8). Taken together, these results suggest that folding and functionality of this antibody fragment are not prevented in a reducing environment. This antibody fragment could therefore represent a suitable framework for engineering recombinant antibodies to be targeted to the cytoplasm.     

Domain interactions in the Fab fragment: a comparative evaluation of the single-chain Fv and Fab format engineered with variable domains of different stability

Recombinant antibody fragments, most notably Fab and scFv, have become important tools in research, diagnostics and therapy. Since different recombinant antibody formats exist, it is crucial to understand the difference in their respective biophysical properties. We assessed the potential stability benefits of changing the scFv into the Fab format, the influence of the variable domains on the stability of the Fab fragment, and the influence of the interchain disulfide bond in the Fab fragment. To analyze domain interactions, the Fab fragment was broken down into its individual domains, several two-domain assemblies and one three-domain assembly. The equilibrium denaturation properties of these constructs were then compared to those of the Fab fragment. It was found that mutual stabilization occurred across the VH/VL and the CH1/CL interface, whereas the direct interaction between the V) and the CL domain had no influence on the stability of either domain. This observation can be explained by the different interfaces used for interaction. In contrast, the whole CH1CL and VHVL unit showed significant mutual stabilization, indicating a high degree of cooperation between the VH/VL and CH1/CL interface. The interchain disulfide bond in the Fab fragment plays an essential role in this stabilization. In addition to the effects of domain association on the thermodynamic (equilibrium) stability, Fab fragments differ from scFv fragments of similar equilibrium stability by having a very slow unfolding rate. This kinetic stabilization may increase significantly the resistance of Fab fragments against short time exposure to adverse conditions.     

Generation of anti-c-met single domain antibody fragment based on human stable frameworks

The size reduction is an important issue in the biomedical application of antibody and single domain antibody fragment is recognized as very attractive tool. However, it is very time-consuming and laborious to generate the fragment antibody with targeted binding function. Here, we investigated the possibility to prepare single domain antibody (sdAb) by a simple grafting method based on stable human consensus framework sequences. The complementarity determining region sequences in V_H domain of anti-c-Met scFv from rabbit were grafted with the human V_H3 consensus framework sequences, which generated the anti-c-Met single domain antibody showing almost same binding activity to its scFv form. The generated single domain antibody could be produced as functional form in oxidizing cytoplasm of E. coli, but produced as inactive form in reducing cytoplasm. The structural analysis of the homology models gave us the insight on the stability of the single domain antibody. In this report, we have demonstrated that the very stable human consensus framework sequence can be used for the generation of active anti-c-Met sdAb via complementarity determining regions grafting. We expect that this kind of grafting method for the generation of sdAb may provide us with the opportunities to prepare sdAbs based on the known antibody sequences.