GENE FLOW IN CAVE ARTHROPODS: A QUALITATIVE AND QUANTITATIVE APPROACH

Slatkin's method (1981) for analyzing gene flow levels is applied to eleven species of cave arthropods. This provides insights into the strength of gene flow as a force affecting the evolution of cave organisms, while serving as a test of Slatkin's method. The results show that patterns of gene flow are consistent with the dispersal abilities and the ecological requirements of each species. Troglobites in general have lower gene flow values than troglophiles or trogloxenes. However, the geology of the area, its vegetation profile, and the geographic distance among the populations considered are also important in determining the gene flow levels. Gene flow patterns in three cave species, Ptomaphagus hirtus, Neaphaenops tellkampfii tellkampfii and Hadenoecus subterraneus, are compared in detail. These species inhabit the same highly interconnected karst area in south-central Kentucky but differ in their ecological requirements. The results suggest that gene flow levels are more dependent upon the intrinsic characteristics of each species than upon the availability of routes for dispersal. Overall estimates of gene flow were coupled with a more detailed population-structure analysis in four terrestrial cave arthropods: Speonomus delarouzeei, Hadenoecus cumberlandicus, Hadenoecus subterraneus and Euhadenoecus puteanus. The results stress the need for this type of analysis for subdivided species, in which estimates of the average gene flow can produce misleading results. Moreover, they show how these types of measures are more relevant in describing historical patterns of gene exchange than in indicating current levels of gene flow.     

Genetic Diversity of the Small Characid Fish Astyanax sp., and its Significance for Conservation

Genetic variations in Astyanax sp. fish from Vila Velha State Park and Tibagi river (Paraná, Brazil) were analyzed by RAPD. Intrapopulational genetic similarity was analyzed at three collection sites. The higher RAPD polymorphism observed at site 3 (Tibagi river) suggests either an overlapping of structured populations or the presence of coexisting morphotypes at this site. Significant p values obtained by homogeneity tests revealed an unequal loci proportion among populations. The significance of similarity coefficients indicated that the differences observed among populations are relevant. These findings provide important information for the management and conservation of the species analyzed and for genetic variability maintenance programs.     

Genetic variability and divergence between populations and species of Nesticus cave spiders

Genetic variability and divergence at 21 enzyme loci were studied in and between Italian populations of the cave spiders Nesticus eremita (13 populations), N. menozzii and N. sbordonii (one population each). The three species differ with respect to the degree of specialization to cave life, dispersion ability, isolation of populations, abundancy, extent of the distribution area, and range from the troglophilic and widespread N. eremita to the troglobitic N. sbordonii, endemic to a single cave in the Central Appennines.Heterozygosity ranges from 0.05 to 0.15 in N. eremita populations and appears to be largely controlled by the occurrence and the extent of gene flow among populations. The relatively low polymorphism levels of N. menozzii (H=0.081) and N. sbordonii (H=0.106) are also associated with reduced gene flow and small population sizes.Genetic distances between N. eremita populations vary considerably and are strictly related to the geographical distances involved, again indicating a major role of gene flow in determining the patterns of genetic differentiation between populations. This view is strongly supported by the results of a principal component analysis applied to the gene-frequency data. Estimates of genetic divergence between species suggest that the major cladogenetic events leading to complete separation of these three Nesticus species occurred in the Middle-late Pliocene.     

MOLECULAR EVOLUTIONARY DIVERGENCE AMONG NORTH AMERICAN CAVE CRICKETS. I. ALLOZYME VARIATION

Forty-nine populations of nine species of North American cave crickets (genera Euhadenoecus and Hadenoecus) have been studied for genetic variation at 41 loci by electrophoresis. Wright's F_ST, Slatkin's Nm^* gene-flow estimator, and Nei's genetic distances (D) have been used to compare closely related species that have different ecological requirements (cave vs. forest species), distribution patterns, and/or different degrees of geographic isolation among populations. Cave and epigean (noncave) species differ greatly in their levels of genetic differentiation. Cave species have lower rates of gene exchange (low Nm, high D, and F_ST) than epigean species. Within cave species the degree of genetic differentiation among populations is correlated with the limestone structure of the area where the species occur. Species or groups of populations inhabiting areas where the limestone is continuous and highly fissured (e.g., H. subterraneus populations in the Mammoth Cave region) are genetically less differentiated than are populations occurring in regions where the limestone distribution is more fragmented, such as the Appalachian Ridge where E. fragilis occurs; this effect is more extreme in Central Tennessee where genetically differentiated E. insolitus populations occur only a few kilometers apart. This suggests that epigean dispersal through forest habitat in cave-dwelling species is negligable. For forest species, the data indicate relatively recent radiation with ongoing gene exchange among populations. For cave species, the distribution of protein polymorphisms is apparently more a function of historical patterns of gene exchange rather than current gene exchange. Phylogenetic relationships were studied using cluster analyses (UPGMA and Wagner algorithms) of Nei's and Edwards' genetic distances and multivariate analysis (correspondence analysis) of the raw allele frequencies. Different algorithms result in branching patterns that are similar but not entirely concordant with one another or with the phylogeny based on morphology.     

A morphometric analysis and taxonomic study of Panax bipinnatifidus Seem. (Araliaceae) species complex from Sikkim Himalaya, India

Cattleya elongata is a rupicolous orchid species spread throughout and endemic to outcrop islands in campo rupestre vegetation of the Chapada Diamantina, northeastern Brazil. We scored nine natural populations of C. elongata for morphological and genetic variability, covering the whole distribution area of the species, using allozymes and ISSR markers and morphometric multivariate analyses. Genetic variability in allozimes was relatively high (H _e?=?0.12?C0.25), and unexpectedly higher than the values based on ISSR (H _e?=?0.16?C0.19). The populations present moderate structuring (allozymes, ??_PT?=?0.14; ISSR, ??_PT?=?0.18) and low inbreeding (allozymes, F _IS?=?0.06). Genetic similarity among the populations was high in both markers, in spite of the discontinuity of the outcrops of the Chapada Diamantina. We found no particular biogeographical pattern to the distribution of the genetic and morphologic similarity among the populations of C. elongata. We found high morphological variability with moderate differentiation among the populations. We did not find any correlation among genetic, morphological, and geographical distances, and among the variability found in the morphological and genetic markers. The differences observed between the two genetic markers and the various morphological markers examined here indicated that the isolated use of any single parameter of these different populations for conservation planning or management would not consider all of the variability to be found in the species, as found in other Brazilian campos rupestres plants.     

Population Genetic Structure of Astyanax scabripinnis (Teleostei, Characidae) from an Urban Stream

Despite the great anthropogenic interference on urban streams, information is still scarce about the genetic variability and structure of native fish populations inhabiting such streams. In the present study, random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers were used to analyze genetic variability and structure of populations assigned to the Neotropical fish species Astyanax scabripinnis from an urban stream located in Londrina, Paraná State, southern Brazil. Thirty individuals of this species were collected from three sites throughout the upper Cambé stream. A total of 10 primers amplified 159 loci, of which 128 (80.5%) were polymorphic. Each of the three populations showed very similar proportions of polymorphic loci, which ranged from 63.5 to 64.8%. Unbiased genetic distances varied from 0.0612 to 0.0646. Theta_p-test values indicated moderate to high genetic differentiation among individuals from different localities. The number of migrants varied from 1.34 to 1.46, suggesting a low gene flow between populations. The genetic similarity among all individuals studied ranged from 0.424 to 0.848. The results suggest that populations of A. scabripinnis in Cambé stream are undergoing genetic differentiation.     

Allozyme variability within and among populations of the epiphytic moss Leucodon (Leucodontaceae: Musci)

Enzyme electrophoresis was used to estimate genetic variability within and among populations of five species of the genus Leucodon (L. atrovirens, L. luteus, L. nipponicus, L. sapporensis, and L. temperatus). All of these perennial, dioecious plants are epiphytic on tree trunks and produce numerous spores that are released in winter. Gene diversity within populations (H_S) was low (0.070) in L. nipponicus, which grows in disturbed habitats, and high (0.169–0.202) in the other four species, which inhabit stable environments. Gene diversity between populations relative to total diversity (G_ST) was low in L. temperatus (0.042) and L. luteus (0.043), suggesting that extensive gene flow occurs among populations. G_ST was moderate in L. sapporensis (0.104) and L. atrovirens (0.114); these values are still less than those previously reported for terrestrial mosses. Since epiphytes could disperse their spores effectively by the wind, low genetic divergence among populations may be related to the epiphytic habit of the species. On the other hand, high G_ST value (0.208) was found in L. nipponicus. It is probably explained by the genetic differentiation of populations by genetic drift, for the species forms geographically and ecologically isolated populations with small number of individuals. We also observed incongruity between morphological and genetic similarity among species.     

Patterns of morphological variation among populations of the widespread annual killifish Nothobranchius orthonotus are independent of genetic divergence and biogeography

Populations of annual killifish of the genus Nothobranchius occur in patchily distributed temporary pools in the East African savannah. Their fragmented distribution and low dispersal ability result in highly structured genetic clustering of their populations. In this study, we examined body shape variation in a widely distributed species, Nothobranchius orthonotus with known phylogeographic structure. We tested whether genetic divergence of major mitochondrial lineages forming two candidate species is congruent with phenotypic diversification, using linear and geometric morphometry analyses of body shape in 23 wild populations. We also conducted a common‐garden experiment with two wild‐derived populations to control for the effect of local environmental conditions on body shape. We identified different allometric trajectories for different mitochondrial lineages and candidate species in both sexes. However, in a principal components analysis of population‐level body shape, the separation among mitochondrial lineages was incomplete. Higher similarity of mitochondrial lineages belonging to different candidate species than that of same candidate species prevented distinction of the two candidate species on the basis of body shape. Analysis at the individual level demonstrated that N. orthonotus express high intrapopulation variability, with major overlap among individuals from all populations. In conclusion, we suggest that N. orthonotus be considered as a single species with an extensive geographic range, strong population genetic structure and high morphological variability.     

Variation of the Locomotor Activity Rhythms in Three Species of Talitrid Amphipods,Talitrus saltator,Orchestia montagui,and O. gammarellus,from Various Habitats

The expression of biological rhythms was investigated in five populations of three different species of talitrid amphipods from various habitats in the Maremma Regional Park, Grosseto, Italy: Talitrus saltator (from a sandy beach and a canal), Orchestia montagui (form a Posidonia banquette), and O. gammarellus (from a cave entrance and a river bank). Locomotor activity rhythms were recorded in individual animals over 21 days in constant dark at a temperature of 18°±1°C. A high variability in rhythm expression was evident, not only among species and populations but also within populations and the activity pattern of individuals. Activity rhythms of T. saltator and O. montagui were similar, with a good definition and precise circadian periodicity, whereas O. gammarellus showed a high variability and low definition of the circadian rhythm. Significant differences were also observed between two populations of O. gammarellus and T. saltator from different habitats. Within the O. gammarellus species, a significantly higher percentage of active animals (p<0.001) was observed in the cave than the river‐bank population; within T. saltator, a significantly lower percentage of active animals (p<0.01) and higher percentage of periodic animals (p<0.05) was found in the canal than the sandy beach population. With reference to environmental stability and variability, the differences observed are explained as a need for plasticity to adapt to environmental changes.     

Genetic diversity in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Delphinium staphisagria</Emphasis> (Ranunculaceae), a rare Mediterranean dysploid larkspur with medicinal uses

Delphinium staphisagria is an endemic annual or biennial herb from the Mediterranean Basin, widely distributed in isolated populations of variable size. We evaluated the allozyme diversity of 31 populations along its distribution range via starch gel electrophoresis, assaying 12 enzyme systems and scoring 17 loci. The low levels of genetic variability detected (A = 11.8, A _p = 1.6, H _o = 0.026, H _e = 0.057), are discussed in relation to the life-history traits of the species, such as short life-span, selfing or gravity seed dispersion. Other factors influencing genetic diversity, such as evolutionary history and spreading are also considered. Due to its historical medicinal uses, this plant has probably become widespread in the Mediterranean area. Human-mediated distribution could have promoted few migrant genotypes, recent founder events and long distance dispersal. These events would explain the genetic homogeneity found within and among populations, as well as the absence of a clear biogeographic structure. The limited genetic variability, the high genetic similarity among populations and the dysploidy of this species make it worthy of conservation. Management strategies are proposed mainly to preserve its genetic pool.     

Morphological variability of Carex spicata Huds. utricles among plant communities

Differentiation in the size and number of seeds among populations or particular individuals of a given species may depend on genetic features and environmental conditions. The objective of our study was to answer two questions: whether any differences exist in the size and shape of utricles among Carex spicata populations growing in several plant communities and whether the hypothesized differences remain constant in ‘common garden’ conditions (i.e. if the sedges grown in different plant communities are evolving distinctly separate ecotypes). We studied utricle morphological traits (projected area, width, length, W/L ratio and projected perimeter) and number of utricles per spike collected from plants grown in five different plant communities (natural sites) and from plants transferred to common garden conditions. C. spicata utricles showed significant variability of morphological traits that depended on the plant community of origin. Among five plant communities, the largest utricles were found in Agropyron repens–Urtica dioica and Convolvulo arvensis–Agropyretum repentis communities, while the smallest ones were in plants from the Lolio-Plantaginetum community. The similarity of the analyzed populations regarding sedge utricle traits corresponded to the similarity of plant communities where the populations had grown. Moreover, the differences in utricle traits collected from natural conditions remained stable in common garden conditions. This indicated that differences in traits among utricles had a physiological dependence on different biotope conditions or different interspecific interactions prevailing in the particular plant communities. The relationship between the similarities in the diaspores of the populations studied and the similarities in the ecological conditions of the communities may also indicate that the variability of utricles is important for evolution and adaptation.The results support the hypothesis that C. spicata populations in different communities are producing separate ecotypes, i.e. specific species forms with genetically fixed traits adapted to narrowly determined habitat conditions.     

The relationship between genetic variability and growth rate among populations of the pocket gopher, Thomomys bottae

Perhaps the oldest unresolved debate inconservation genetics is whether geneticvariability matters – in other words, whetherrelatively low average genetic variationcontributes to deficits in individual andpopulation level vigor and fitness. Using astatistically powerful paired sampling designin which each of three pairs of populationsconsisted of one high genetic variability andone low genetic variability population from aparticular subspecies of the pocket gopher,Thomomys bottae, we tested the hypothesisthat individuals from populations with lowergenetic variability have lower growth rates (acommonly used surrogate for fitness) than thosefrom populations with higher variability. Wemeasured genetic variability using averageallozyme heterozygosity and two measures of DNAfingerprint band sharing (Jeffreys 33.15 andMS1 probes). The population rankings of thelevels of genetic variability among the threemeasures were concordant. The least squaresmean growth rate (controlling for sex,subspecies and initial mass) of gophers fromlow variability populations (0.41 ± 0.06g/day, n = 48) was less than half that ofgophers from high variability populations (1.04± 0.07 g/day, n = 45). This result lendscredence to the premise that differences inpopulation level genetic variability havesignificant fitness consequences andunderscores the importance of maintaininggenetic variability in managed populations.     

Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA Diversity among Surface and Subterranean Populations of Asellus aquaticus (Crustacea: Isopoda)

The ecological and evolutionary processes leading to isolation and adaptation of cave animals compared to their surface ancestors are not yet unequivocally understood. In this study the genetic relations of four cave and three surface population of the freshwater crustacean Asellus aquaticus in the Karst region of SW Slovenia and NE Italy were assessed using RAPDs as genetic markers. The results suggest that specialized populations from two caves invaded their subterranean habitat independently, and that their morphological similarity is a result of convergent evolution. Another, less specialized cave population seems to originate from a later colonization of a cave system already inhabited by a more specialized population, but the two populations do not interbreed. This series of temporally and spatially independent invasions has generated a diversity hotspot of non-interbreeding populations of a ubiquitous freshwatercrustacean, which is uniform over most of its range. Genetic variability estimated by the percentage of polymorphic RAPD fragments was similar (86–91%) in most cave and surface populations. Substantially lower values (as low as 49%) were found in two cave populations affected by heavy pollution. Two a priori groupings of populations, traditional subspecies and hydrologically connected groups, were rejected as not significant by means of nested analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA). On the other hand, groupings revealed by UPGMA clustering displayed a significant component of among-group variance. An analysis of gene flow between populations using estimated migration rates confirmed these findings.     

Application of DNA fingerprinting to population study of chamois (Rupicapra rupicapra)

Hypervariable minisatellite DNA probes 33.15 and 33.6, originally developed for studies in human populations, were used to study genetic variation in chamois (Rupicapra rupicapra). The mean number of bands per individual was 25 for probe 33.15 and 15 for probe 33.6. The average band frequency was 0.33 for both probes. The mean similarity was 0.44, greater than that reported for human and natural populations and close to values found in domestic populations of mammals. This lack of variability could be related to the bottleneck suffered by the population due to large-scale hunting after the Spanish Civil War. Levels of variability are high compared with variability at the level of protein markers, so the use of minisatellite DNA is recommended for future population studies in this species. We did not find large genetic differences between subpopulations, indicating that the population is genetically homogeneous.     

Genetic variation in the soil phthiracarid mite, Steganacarus (S.) magnus (Nicolet, 1855) (Acarida, Oribatida) (Notulae Oribatologicae XL)

Genetic divergence and variability at 14 enzyme loci were examined in and between Italian populations of two edaphic Oribatid (Acarida, Oribatida) species, Steganacarus (Steganacarus) magnus (8 populations) and S. (S.) hirsutus (1 population). The seven populations belonging to S. (S.) magnus can be divided into two groups according to their phenotype, form anomala (A) (MON, ARG, AST, CDO) and form magna (M) (MAL, MAM, RIF) while another can be considered as hybrid between the two preceding groups (ZOC). Genetic identity (I) values between the S. (S.) magnus populations in spite of their morphological differences ranged from 0.977 to 1.000 showing the great genetic similarity of simple local populations while those of S. (S.) hirsutus indicated two distinct morphological species. The genetic distances between all the populations examined were very low despite the ecological differences and geographical distances between the collecting sites. Genetic variability estimates in all the populations of both species were very low when compared to those reported for most arthropods. Some explanatory considerations are suggested.     

Genetic diversity of insular natural populations of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Festuca pratensis</Emphasis> Huds.: RAPD analysis

In natural populations of Festuca pratensis Huds. from the islands of Onega Lake, the level of genetic diversity was evaluated. In three populations variability of 64 RAPD loci was tested. The level of genetic diversity (P _95% = 30.2; H _exp = 0.093) was low for a cross-pollinating plant species. Furthermore, genetic similarity between the plants from insular populations was found to be high (I _N = 0.887). It was demonstrated that genetic variation among the population accounted for at most 5.3% of total genetic diversity, which, however, was higher than the F _ST values for continental populations (F _ST = 0.022). It was suggested that specific features of the genetic structure of insular population, i.e., low gene diversity within the populations along with high differentiation among the populations, were caused by the gene flow attenuation, as a result of isolation, and intensification of inbreeding. These features had negative effect on total population adaptation.     

Genetic variation in small,isolated fern populations

Abstract. Differences in genetic variability of several small, isolated populations of four fern species in a restricted area in the Swiss lowlands reflect differences in breeding system, population size, the degree of population fragmentation, and ecological requirements. The investigated populations of Asplenium septentrionale show only little genetic variability (isozyme variation) without gene flow among populations (based on the banding pattern of multi-locus phenotypes), and they persist for long periods despite the small population sizes. In Asplenium ruta-muraria, genetic variability is correlated with age. Young populations show no genetic variation, while old populations show some. All individuals of Polypodium vulgare investigated, either epiphytic or epilithic, share exactly the same enzyme phenotype. The results for these three species can be related to predominance of inbreeding, lack of inbreeding depression, polyploidy, long-distance dispersal, production of large amounts of diaspores, single-spore colonization, and perennial life cycles. Genetic variability in these three species does not seem to be absolutely necessary for the maintenance of their populations. Ecological and demographic factors are considered to be more important. An isolated, glacial relict population of diploid Asplenium viride shows high variability in two out of eight enzyme systems, which may be due to prevailing outbreeding. We discuss aspects of the importance of genetics and life history for conservation biology.     

LOW GENIC DIFFERENTIATION AMONG ISOLATED POPULATIONS OF THE CALIFORNIA FAN PALM (WASHINGTONIA FILIFERA)

The purpose of this study was to assess the relative roles of population size and geographic isolation in determining population-genetic structure. Using electrophoretic techniques to quantify allozymic variation at 16 genetic loci, we measured genic variation within and among 16 natural populations of the California fan palm (Washingtonia filifera). Genotypes were determined for every individual in each population so that parametric values rather than sample estimates for measures of genic variability were obtained. Palm populations displayed low levels of within-population variability. The proportion of polymorphic loci and observed heterozygosity were 0.098 and 0.009 per population, respectively. Population size displayed a significant positive correlation with proportion of polymorphic loci, but not with observed heterozygosity. Low levels of genetic differentiation among populations were demonstrated by an F-statistic analysis and the computation of genetic similarity values. A hierarchical analysis of gene diversity revealed that only about 2% of the total gene diversity in W. filifera resides as among-population diversity. Climatic and geological changes since the Pliocene have eliminated widespread palm populations, and the species is presently restricted to isolated locations around the Colorado Desert. Existing populations in southern California are either relicts or recent recolonizations resulting from the dispersal of seeds from a refugium population in Baja California, Mexico. The observed patterns of low within- and low among-population genic diversity seem most consistent with a recent colonization by fan palms. It is hypothesized that stochastic processes reduced levels of genic variability in this refugium population during its formation. Dispersal of seeds from this refugium into suitable habitats in the Colorado Desert would produce populations with low variability and high genetic similarity because of their common ancestry. However, low intrapopulation variability and genetic homogeneity across populations could be the product of uniform selection pressures favoring a narrow array of specialized genotypes in either relict or colonizing populations.     

ADAPTIVE RADIATION AND GENETIC DIFFERENTIATION IN HAWAIIAN BIDENS

The genus Bidens (Asteraceae) has undergone extensive adaptive radiation on the Hawaiian Islands. The 19 species and eight subspecies endemic to Hawaii exhibit much more morphological and ecological differentiation than the continental members of the genus. However, the Hawaiian taxa have the same chromosome number and retain the capacity to interbreed in all possible combinations. Twenty-two populations of 15 Hawaiian taxa and four populations of American taxa were compared at 21 loci controlling eight enzyme systems. Populations of Hawaiian taxa are highly polymorphic. However, little genetic differentiation has occurred among taxa in spite of the high levels of genetic variability. Genetic identities calculated for pairs of populations show that populations of the same taxon are genetically more similar than are populations belonging to different taxa, but all values are high. The level of genetic differentiation that has occurred among the species of Hawaiian Bidens is comparable to the level of genetic differences found among populations within single continental plant species. Moreover, there is no correlation between the isozyme data and morphological data. No groups of taxa are evident in the genetic data, although morphological groups exist. Genetic differentiation at isozyme loci has not occurred at the same rate as the acquisition of presumably adaptive morphological and ecological characters in Hawaiian Bidens. Adaptive radiation may be limited to a few genes controlling morphological and ecological characters.     

Unexpected low genetic differentiation among Allopatric species of section Algarobia of Prosopis (Leguminosae)

The Chaqueña Biogeographic Province, in South America, is the main diversity centre of Prosopis. A group of sympatric species of Section Algarobia in this region constitutes a syngameon, characterised by frequent hybridization and introgression. These processes have been postulated as responsible for the low genetic differentiation observed among species within this group. In this study genetic variability and differentiation among geographically isolated species of the same section was analysed through isoenzyme electrophoresis. Variability parameters and fixation indices were estimated to determine the genetic structure of populations. Two Argentinean, P. ruscifolia (‘vinal’) and P. flexuosa (‘algarrobo amarillo’), and one North American species, P. glandulosa (honey mesquite) were studied. All of them showed, similarly to other species of the same section, high genetic variability and exhibit homozygote excess, probably due to population substructure and low rates of selfing. In contrast to our hypothesis, genetic similarity among species is not related to geographic distance. Genetic distances between P. glandulosa and South American species are similar to those observed among species of this subcontinent. The results obtained suggest that the high genetic similarity among the species of the section Algarobia studied is not due to hybridization.