Paclitaxel resistance in cells with reduced beta-tubulin

We previously described the isolation of colcemid resistant Chinese hamster ovary cell lines containing alpha- and beta-tubulin mutations that increase microtubule assembly and stability. By analyzing colcemid sensitive revertants from one of the beta-tubulin mutants, we now find that loss or inactivation of the mutant allele represents the most common mechanism of reversion. Consistent with this loss, the revertants have 35% less tubulin at steady state, no evidence for the presence of a mutant polypeptide, and a normal extent of tubulin polymerization. In addition to the loss of colcemid resistance, the revertant cells exhibit increased resistance to paclitaxel relative to wild-type cells. This paclitaxel resistance can be suppressed by transfecting the revertant cells with a cDNA for wild-type beta-tubulin, indicating that the reduction in tubulin in the revertant cells is responsible for the resistance phenotype. We propose that reducing tubulin levels may represent a novel mechanism of paclitaxel resistance.     

Mutations affecting beta-tubulin folding and degradation

Revertants of a colcemid-resistant Chinese hamster ovary cell line with an altered (D45Y) beta-tubulin have allowed the identification of four cis-acting mutations (L187R, Y398C, a 12-amino acid in-frame deletion, and a C-terminal truncation) that act by destabilizing the mutant tubulin and preventing it from incorporating into microtubules. These unstable beta-tubulins fail to form heterodimers and are predominantly found in association with the chaperonin CCT, suggesting that they cannot undergo productive folding. In agreement with these in vivo observations, we show that the defective beta-tubulins do not stably interact with cofactors involved in the tubulin folding pathway and, hence, fail to exchange with beta-tubulin in purified alphabeta heterodimers. Treatment of cells with MG132 causes an accumulation of the aberrant tubulins, indicating that improperly folded beta-tubulin is degraded by the proteasome. Rapid degradation of the mutant tubulin does not elicit compensatory changes in wild-type tubulin synthesis or assembly. Instead, loss of beta-tubulin from the mutant allele causes a 30-40% decrease in cellular tubulin content with no obvious effect on cell growth or survival.     

Tubulin composition and microtubule nucleation of a griseofulvin-resistant Chinese hamster ovary cell mutant with abnormal spindles

A griseofulvin-resistant Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) mutant (Grs-2) which has an altered beta-tubulin subunit as well as wild-type beta-tubulin is temperature-sensitive (ts) for growth at 40.5 degrees C. This growth defect appears to result from the formation of abnormal mitotic spindles at the non-permissive temperature (Abraham, I et al., J cell biol 97 (1983) 1055) [19]. Light microscopy of spindles isolated from mutant cells cultured at the permissive temperature showed a typical bipolar morphology, whereas spindles isolated at the non-permissive temperature were multipolar. In order to study the role of tubulin in spindle formation, we analyzed the tubulin composition of the multipolar spindles. Two-dimensional gels and immunoblotting analysis of one-dimensional electrophoretic gels stained with monoclonal anti-Chinese hamster brain beta-tubulin antibody revealed that both mutant and wild-type beta-tubulins were present in similar proportions in both bipolar spindles at 37 degrees C and multipolar spindles at 40.5 degrees C. The ratio between wild-type and mutant tubulin in spindles was also found to be the same as in the cytoplasmic microtubule network in interphase cells, providing evidence that the mutant beta-tubulin appeared to be incorporated in a similar manner into both interphase and mitotic microtubule structures. In vitro microtubule polymerization onto centrosomes prepared from mutant Grs-2 demonstrated that 80% of the sites for microtubule nucleation were without centrioles, suggesting fragmentation of pericentriolar material away from centrioles. This may be one of the causes of multipolar spindle formation in the mutant cells. These results, therefore, suggest that abnormal formation of spindles in mutant cells is due not to the presence of the mutant tubulin per se, but to the abnormal behavior of this mutant tubulin in the cellular environment during mitosis or abnormal interaction with other components in the spindle at 40.5 degrees C.     

Revertants of a Chinese hamster ovary cell mutant with an altered beta-tubulin: evidence that the altered tubulin confers both colcemid resistance and temperature sensitivity on the cell

We recently described the isolation of a mutant Chinese hamster ovary cell (Cmd 4) resistant to the cytotoxic effects of colcemid (Cabral et al., Cell 20:29-36, 1980). This mutant carries an altered beta-tubulin but still grows normally at 37 degrees C. In the present study we found that Cmd 4 is temperature sensitive for growth at 40.3 degrees C. A class of revertants selected for temperature resistance had simultaneously lost colcemid resistance and the altered beta-tubulin. In addition, we isolated a temperature-resistant revertant which carries a further alteration in the mutant beta-tubulin polypeptide. This second alteration appears to make the mutant beta-tubulin incompetent to assemble into microtubules, resulting in a strain which is again colcemid sensitive. These revertant cell lines provide strong evidence that a mutation in beta-tubulin can confer both colcemid resistance and temperature sensitivity on a mammalian cell line. Cellular microtubules studied by indirect immunofluorescence in both mutant and revertant cell lines had an apparently normal distribution at permissive and nonpermissive temperatures, yet mitosis appears to be abnormal in the mutant cell line. We conclude from these studies that incorporation of the altered beta-tubulin into microtubules does not affect their distribution but may affect their function during mitosis.     

Mutations affecting assembly and stability of tubulin: evidence for a nonessential beta-tubulin in CHO cells.

Eight strains of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells having an assembly-defective beta-tubulin were found among revertants of strain Cmd 4, a mutant with a conditional lethal mutation in a beta-tubulin gene (F. Cabral, M. E. Sobel, and M. M. Gottesman, Cell 20:29-36, 1980). The altered beta-tubulins in these strains have electrophoretically silent alterations or, in some cases, an increase or a decrease in apparent molecular weight based on their migration in two-dimensional gels. The identity of these variant proteins as beta-tubulin was confirmed by peptide mapping, which also revealed the loss of distinct methionine-containing peptides in the assembly-defective beta-tubulins of lower apparent molecular weight. The altered mobility of these beta-tubulin polypeptides was not the result of a posttranslational modification, since the altered species could be labeled in very short incubations with [35S]methionine and were found among in vitro-translated polypeptides by using purified mRNA. In at least one strain, an altered DNA restriction fragment could be demonstrated, suggesting that an alteration occurred in one of the structural genes for beta-tubulin. Assembly-defective beta-tubulin was unstable and turned over with a half-life of only 1 to 2 h in exponentially growing cells. This rapid degradation of a tubulin gene product resulted in approximately 30% lower steady-state levels of both alpha- and beta-tubulin yet did not affect the growth rate of the cells or the distribution of the microtubules as judged by immunofluorescence microscopy. These results argue that CHO cells possess a beta-tubulin gene product that is not essential for survival.     

A mutant beta-tubulin confers resistance to the action of benzimidazole-carbamate microtubule inhibitors both in vivo and in vitro

The mutant BEN210 of Physarum polycephalum is highly resistant to a number of benzimidazole carbamate agents, including methylbenzimidazole-2-yl-carbamate and parbendazole. The resistance is conferred by the benD210 mutation in a structural gene for beta-tubulin. This mutant allele encodes a beta-tubulin with novel electrophoretic mobility. We have used this strain to determine whether the mutant beta-tubulin is used in microtubules and whether this usage permits microtubule polymerisation in the presence of drugs both in vivo and in vitro. In vitro assembly studies of tubulin purified from the mutant strain have shown that microtubules are formed both in the absence of drugs and in all drug concentrations tested (up to 50 microM parbendazole). In contrast, the assembly of microtubules from wild-type tubulin in vitro is totally inhibited by 2-5 microM parbendazole. Thus the resistance of BEN210 to parbendazole observed in vivo has been reproduced in vitro using tubulin purified from the mutant strain. Electrophoretic analysis of the microtubules formed in vitro has shown that both the wild-type and the mutant beta-tubulin are incorporated into the microtubules and that the proportion of mutant to wild-type beta-tubulin appears to remain constant with increasing drug concentration. This is the first demonstration of a single mutation in a tubulin structural gene causing an altered function of the gene product in vitro.     

Expression and function of beta-tubulin isotypes in Chinese hamster ovary cells

The availability of isotype-specific antisera for beta-tubulin, coupled with genetic and biochemical analysis, has allowed the determination of beta-tubulin isotype expression and distribution in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. Using genetic manipulations involving selection for colcemid resistance followed by reversion and reselection for drug resistance, we have succeeded in isolating cell lines that exhibit three major and one minor beta-tubulin spots by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. In concert with isotype-specific antibodies, analysis of these mutants demonstrates that CHO cells express two copies of isotype I, at least one copy of isotype IV, and very small amounts of isotype V. All three isotypes assemble into both cytoplasmic and spindle microtubules and are similar in their responses to cold, colcemid, and calcium-induced depolymerization. They have comparable turnover rates and are equally sensitive to depression of synthesis upon colchicine treatment. These results suggest that beta-tubulin isotypes are used interchangeably to assemble microtubule structures in CHO cells. However, of 18 colcemid-resistant mutants with a demonstrable alteration in beta-tubulin, all were found to have the alteration in isotype I, thus leaving open the possibility that subtle differences in isotype properties may exist.     

Mutation in the beta-tubulin signature motif suppresses microtubule GTPase activity and dynamics, and slows mitosis.

We introduced a threonine-to-glycine point mutation at position 143 in the "tubulin signature motif" 140Gly-Gly-Gly-Thr-Gly-Ser-Gly146 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae beta-tubulin. In an electron diffraction model of the tubulin dimer, this sequence comes close to the phosphates of a guanine nucleotide bound in the beta-tubulin exchangeable E site. Both the GTP-binding affinity and the microtubule (MT)-dependent GTPase activity of tubulin isolated from haploid tub2-T143G mutant cells were reduced by at least 15-fold, compared to tubulin isolated from control wild-type cells. The growing and shortening dynamics of MTs assembled from alphabeta:Thr143Gly-mutated dimers were also strongly suppressed, compared to control MTs. The in vitro properties of the mutated MTs (slower growing and more stable) are consistent with the effects of the tub2-T143G mutation in haploid cells. The average length of MT spindles in large-budded mutant cells was only 3.7 +/- 0.2 microm, approximately half of the size of MT arrays in large-budded wild-type cells (average length = 7.1 +/- 0.4 microm), suggesting that there is a delay in mitosis in the mutant cells. There was also a higher proportion of large-budded cells with unsegregated nuclei in mutant cultures (30% versus 12% for wild-type cells), again suggesting such a delay. The results show that beta:Thr143 of the tubulin signature motif plays an important role in GTP binding and hydrolysis by the beta-tubulin E site and support the idea that tubulins belong to a family of proteins within the GTPase superfamily that are structurally distinct from the classic GTPases, such as EF-Tu and p21(ras). The data also suggest that MT dynamics are critical for MT function in yeast cells and that spindle MT assembly and disassembly could be coordinated with other cell-cycle events by regulating beta-tubulin GTPase activity.     

Increasing tubC beta-tubulin synthesis by placing it under the control of a benA beta-tubulin upstream sequence causes a reduction in benA beta-tubulin level but has no effect on microtubule function

We have constructed a chimeric beta-tubulin gene that places the structural gene for the tubC beta-tubulin of Aspergillus nidulans under the control of the benA beta-tubulin promoter. Introduction of either this chimeric gene or a second wild-type benA gene into a benomyl-resistant benA22 strain causes it to become benomyl sensitive, indicating that the introduced genes are functional. Analysis of the tubulin proteins synthesized in benA22 strains into which a second wild-type benA beta-tubulin gene was transformed showed that the total amount of beta-tubulin protein was the same as in the parental strain with a single benA gene. Thus the level of beta-tubulin must be regulated. This was also true of transformants carrying an extra copy of the chimeric beta-tubulin gene. The total amount of beta-tubulin was the same as in the parental strain. Two-dimensional gel analysis showed that the endogenous benA22 and the introduced chimeric tubC gene contributed equally to the total beta-tubulin pool. The fact that one-half of the benA beta-tubulin could be replaced by tubC beta-tubulin with no effect on the growth of the cells suggests that the benA and tubC beta-tubulins are functionally interchangeable.     

Translation of beta-tubulin mRNA in vitro generates multiple molecular forms

We describe the in vitro expression and characterization of the isolated beta-tubulin subunit in rabbit reticulocyte lysates and compare its assembly and chromatographic properties with that of the isolated alpha-subunit and the tubulin heterodimer. The beta-tubulin polypeptides, derived from a single chicken beta-tubulin cDNA, were found in three distinct molecular forms: a multimeric or lysate-associated form, beta I (Mr approximately 180,000); the free beta-subunit beta II (Mr approximately 55,000); and the hybrid heterodimer alpha(rabbit) beta(chick), beta III (Mr approximately 80,000-100,000). The hybrid heterodimers were 100% assembly competent, whereas beta-tubulin in the "associated" beta I and the monomeric beta II forms displayed only approximately 70 +/- 15 and 25 +/- 10% competence, respectively, in coassembly assays with bovine brain tubulin. This reduced functionality was not a consequence of diminished beta-subunit stability or protein denaturation. By comparing the elution positions of the three beta forms, the monomeric alpha-subunit, and tubulin dimer purified from bovine brain, we demonstrate that anion-exchange columns (Mono-Q) interact preferentially with the alpha-subunit and chromatograph tubulin dimer on the basis of alpha-subunit isotype. The rate of exchange of the free beta-subunit into bovine tubulin dimer was followed chromatographically. The exchange was slow at 4 degrees C and rapid at 37 degrees C where it is essentially complete in 40 min in the presence of 2.5 mg/ml bovine microtubule protein. Exogenous GTP, a potent effector of microtubule assembly, binds exchangeably to beta II and enhances the recovery of this form from the Mono-Q column, suggesting that GTP binding may occur at identical sites in the isolated beta-subunit and in the tubulin heterodimer.     

Kinetics of beta-tubulin exchange following translation. Evidence for a slow conformational change in beta-tubulin necessary for incorporation into heterodimers

Cell-free translation of beta-tubulin mRNA generates full length beta-tubulin polypeptides distributed in three molecular forms: a high molecular weight lysate-associated form, the free beta-tubulin subunit, and the alpha beta-heterodimer (Yaffe, M.B., Farr, G. W., and Sternlicht, H. (1988) J. Biol. Chem. 263, 16023-16031). A quantitative assay system for these three forms was developed and used to measure the rates of incorporation/exchange of the newly synthesized free beta-subunit and the high molecular weight form into tubulin heterodimers following incubation of the 35S-translation products with unlabeled bovine tubulin dimer. This exchange process was found to be slow and strongly temperature-dependent. The half-lives for exchange ranged from 12.5 min at 37 degrees C to 17.5 h at 0 degree C with a measured activation energy of 22.5 kcal/mol. Microtubule-associated proteins appeared to play no role in the exchange process, since identical exchange rates were observed regardless of whether microtubule protein or phosphocellulose-purified tubulin was used as the source of tubulin dimer. Surprisingly, the exchange rates were found to be independent of dimer concentration. We interpret these results as evidence for a rate-limiting, slow conformational change that occurs within the newly synthesized beta-subunits prior to their association with alpha-tubulin to generate the alpha beta-hetero-dimer.     

Mutagenesis of beta-tubulin cysteine residues in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: mutation of cysteine 354 results in cold-stable microtubules.

Cysteine residues play important roles in the control of tubulin function. To determine which of the six cysteine residues in beta-tubulin are critical to tubulin function, we mutated the cysteines in Saccharomyces cerevisiae beta-tubulin individually to alanine and serine residues. Of the twelve mutations, only three produced significant effects: C12S, C354A, and C354S. The C12S mutation was lethal in the haploid, but the C12A mutation had no observable phenotype. Based on interactive views of the electron crystallographic structure of tubulin, we suggest that substitution of serine for cysteine at this position has a destabilizing effect on the interaction of tubulin with the exchangeable GTP. The two C354 mutations, although not lethal, produced dramatic effects on microtubules and cellular processes that require microtubules. The C354 mutant cells had decreased growth rates, a slowed mitosis, increased resistance to benomyl, and impaired nuclear migration and spindle assembly. The C354A mutation produced a more severe phenotype than the C354S mutation: the haploid cells had chromosome segregation defects, only 50% of cells in a culture were viable, and a significant percentage of the cells were misshapened. Cytoplasmic microtubules in the C354S and C354A cells were longer than in the control strain and spindle structures appeared shorter and thicker. Both cytoplasmic and spindle microtubules in the two C354 mutants were extremely stable to cold temperature. After 24 h at 4 degrees C, the microtubules were still present and, in fact, very long and thick tubulin polymers had formed. Evidence exists to indicate that the C354 residue in mammalian tubulin is near the colchicine binding site and the electron crystal structure of tubulin places the residue at the interface between the alpha- and beta-subunits. The sulfhydryl group is situated in a polar environment, which may explain why the alanine mutation is more severe than the serine mutation. When the C12S and the two C354 mutations were made in a diploid strain, the mutated tubulin was incorporated into microtubules and the resulting heterozygotes had phenotypes that were intermediate between those of the mutated haploids and the wild-type strains. The results suggest that the C12 and C354 residues play important roles in the structure and function of tubulin.     

Mutations affecting assembly of beta-tubulin localize to a region near the carboxyl terminus

The generation of Chinese hamster ovary cell lines that express assembly defective forms of beta-tubulin were isolated using selections based on reversion of conditional lethal or drug resistance phenotypes. Two such cell lines, D2 and 6H3, were chosen for further characterization because they contain beta-tubulin polypeptides that exhibit decreases in apparent molecular weight on two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Analysis of the nucleic acid from these cell lines using both Southern and Northern procedures suggests a deletion in one of the beta-tubulin genes in each cell line. Localization of the missing sequence in D2 was first determined by tryptic peptide mapping by high performance liquid chromatography. Subsequently, the assignment was confirmed by constructing appropriate subclones of a wild type Chinese hamster ovary beta-tubulin cDNA for Southern analysis to demonstrate a failure to recognize characteristic hybridization patterns of the mutant tubulin gene. In the other revertant, 6H3, the deletion was detected on a Northern blot by differential hybridization of a 3' fragment of the cDNA to the beta-tubulin messages. The results indicate that D2 has an internal deletion whose approximate limits extend from amino acid residues 250 through 345. Cell line 6H3 has a deletion that begins near amino acid residue 330 and extends into the 3'-untranslated region of the gene.     

Taxol-dependent mutants of Chinese hamster ovary cells with alterations in alpha- and beta-tubulin

Chinese hamster ovary cell mutants resistant to the microtubule stabilizing drug taxol were isolated in a single step. Of these 139 drug-resistant mutants, 59 exhibit an absolute requirement for taxol for normal growth and division, 13 have a partial requirement, and 69 grow normally without the drug. Two-dimensional gel analysis of whole cell proteins reveal "extra" spots representing altered tubulins in 13 of the mutants. Six of these have an altered alpha-tubulin and seven have an altered beta-tubulin. Cells with an absolute dependence on taxol become large and multinucleated when deprived of the drug. In contrast, partially dependent cells exhibit some multinucleation, but most cells appear normal. In one mutant that has an absolute dependence on taxol, the cells appear to die more quickly and their nuclei do not increase in size or number. As previously found for another taxol-dependent mutant (Cabral, F., 1983, J. Cell. Biol., 97:22-29), the taxol dependence of the mutants described in this paper behaves recessively in somatic cell hybrids, and the cells are more susceptible to being killed by colcemid than are the wild-type parental cells. When compared with wild-type cells, taxol-dependent mutants have normal arrays of cytoplasmic microtubules but form much smaller mitotic spindles in the presence of taxol. When deprived of the drug, however, these mutants cannot complete assembly of the mitotic spindle apparatus, as judged by tubulin immunofluorescence. Thus, the defects leading to taxol dependence in these mutants with defined alterations in alpha- and beta-tubulin appear to result from the cell's inability to form a functional mitotic spindle. Reversion analysis indicates that the properties of at least one alpha-tubulin mutant are conferred by the altered tubulin seen on two-dimensional gels.     

An X-linked gene affecting mouse cell DNA synthesis also affects production of unintegrated linear and supercoiled DNA of murine leukemia virus.

To identify specific cellular factors which could be required during the synthesis of retroviral DNA, we have studied the replication of murine leukemia virus in mouse cells temperature sensitive for cell DNA synthesis (M. L. Slater and H. L. Ozer, Cell 7:289-295, 1976) and in several of their revertants. This mutation has previously been mapped on the X chromosome. We found that a short incubation of mutant cells at a nonpermissive temperature (39 degrees C) during the early part of the virus cycle (between 0- to 20-h postinfection) greatly inhibited virus production. This effect was not observed in revertant or wild-type cells. Molecular studies by the Southern transfer procedure of the unintegrated viral DNA synthesized in these cells at a permissive (33 degrees C) or nonpermissive temperature revealed that the levels of linear double-stranded viral DNA (8.8 kilobase pairs) were nearly identical in mutant or revertant cells incubated at 33 or 39 degrees C. However, the levels of two species of supercoiled viral DNA (with one or two long terminal repeats) were significantly lower in mutant cells incubated at 39 degrees C than in mutant cells incubated at 33 degrees C or in revertant cells incubated at 39 degrees C. Pulse-chase experiments showed that linear viral DNA made at 39 degrees C could not be converted into supercoiled viral DNA in mutant cells after a shift down to 33 degrees C. In contrast, such conversion was observed in revertant cells. Restriction endonuclease analysis did not detect differences in the structure of linear viral DNA made at 39 degrees C in mutant cells as compared to linear viral DNA isolated from the same cells at 33 degrees C. However, linear viral DNA made at 39 degrees C in mutant cells was poorly infectious in transfection assays. Taken together, these results strongly suggest that this X-linked gene, affecting mouse cell DNA synthesis, is operating in the early phase of murine leukemia virus replication. It seems to affect the level of production of unintegrated linear viral DNA only slightly while greatly reducing the infectivity of these molecules. In contrast, the accumulation of supercoiled viral DNA and subsequent progeny virus production are greatly reduced. Our pulse-chase experiments suggest that the apparent, but not yet identified, defect in linear viral DNA molecules might be responsible for their subsequent impaired circularization.     

A ubiquitous beta-tubulin disrupts microtubule assembly and inhibits cell proliferation

Vertebrate tubulin is encoded by a multigene family that produces distinct gene products, or isotypes, of both the alpha- and beta-tubulin subunits. The isotype sequences are conserved across species supporting the hypothesis that different isotypes subserve different functions. To date, however, most studies have demonstrated that tubulin isotypes are freely interchangeable and coassemble into all classes of microtubules. We now report that, in contrast to other isotypes, overexpression of a mouse class V beta-tubulin cDNA in mammalian cells produces a strong, dose-dependent disruption of microtubule organization, increased microtubule fragmentation, and a concomitant reduction in cellular microtubule polymer levels. These changes also disrupt mitotic spindle assembly and block cell proliferation. Consistent with diminished microtubule assembly, there is an increased tolerance for the microtubule stabilizing drug, paclitaxel, which is able to reverse many of the effects of class V beta-tubulin overexpression. Moreover, transfected cells selected in paclitaxel exhibit increased expression of class V beta-tubulin, indicating that this isotype is responsible for the drug resistance. The results show that class V beta-tubulin is functionally distinct from other tubulin isotypes and imparts unique properties on the microtubules into which it incorporates.     

A novel step in beta-tubulin folding is important for heterodimer formation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Undimerized beta-tubulin is toxic in the yeast S. cerevisiae. It can arise if levels of beta-tubulin and alpha-tubulin are unbalanced or if the tubulin heterodimer dissociates. We are using the toxicity of beta-tubulin to understand early steps in microtubule morphogenesis. We find that deletion of PLP1 suppresses toxic beta-tubulin formed by disparate levels of alpha- and beta-tubulin. That suppression occurs either when alpha-tubulin is modestly underexpressed relative to beta-tubulin or when beta-tubulin is inducibly and strongly overexpressed. Plp1p does not affect tubulin expression. Instead, a significant proportion of the undimerized beta-tubulin in plp1Delta cells is less toxic than that in wild-type cells. It is also less able to combine with alpha-tubulin to form a heterodimer. As a result, plp1Delta cells have lower levels of heterodimer. Importantly, plp1Delta cells that also lack Pac10, a component of the GimC/PFD complex, are even less affected by free beta-tubulin. Our results suggest that Plp1p defines a novel early step in beta-tubulin folding.