Extrusion of an imperfect palindrome to a cruciform in superhelical DNA: complete determination of energetics using a statistical mechanical model

We present a detailed study of the extrusion of an imperfect palindrome, derived from the terminal regions of vaccinia virus DNA and contained in a superhelical plasmid, into a cruciform containing bulged bases. We monitor the course of extrusion by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis experiments as a function of temperature and linking number. We find that extrusion pauses at partially extruded states as negative superhelicity increases. To understand the course of extrusion with changes in linking number, DeltaLk, we present a rigorous semiempirical statistical mechanical analysis that includes complete coupling between DeltaLk, cruciform extrusion, formation of extrahelical bases, and temperature-dependent denaturation. The imperfections in the palindrome are sequentially incorporated into the cruciform arms as hairpin loops, single unpaired bases, and complex local regions containing several unpaired bases. We analyze the results to determine the free energies, enthalpies and entropies of formation of all local structures involved in extrusion. We find that, for each unpaired structure, the DeltaG, DeltaH and DeltaS of formation are all approximately proportional to the number of unpaired bases contained therein. This surprising result holds regardless of the arrangement or composition of unpaired bases within a particular structure. Imperfections have major effects on the overall energetics of cruciform extrusion and on the course of this transition. In particular, the extent of the DeltaLk change necessary to extrude an imperfect palindrome is considerably greater than that required for extrusion of the underlying perfect palindrome. Our analysis also suggests that, at higher temperatures, significant denaturation at the base of an imperfect cruciform can successfully compete with extension of the cruciform arms.     

The effect of supercoil and temperature on the recognition of palindromic and non-palindromic regions in phi X174 replicative form DNA by S1 and Bal31

The effect of supercoil and temperature on the topology of phi X174 replicative form (RF) DNA was studied using single-strand specific endonucleases S1 and Bal31 as probes for cruciform extrusion and other structural perturbations of the B-helix. Both enzymes were found to recognize specifically and reproducibly over 30 sites, most of which were cleaved by both enzymes independent of the superhelicity of the genome. A negative superhelical density exceeding 0.06 stabilized a transition in the DNA conformation that generated several new cleavage sites for Bal31. The underlying structures appeared to be only transiently stable and were lost from in vitro supercoiled DNA during brief incubation at 65 degrees C. They were generally absent from in vivo supercoiled RF DNA of equal superhelicity as a consequence of the extraction and storage procedure. Mapping of the cleavage sites suggested that they were preferentially located near the beginnings and ends of genes and that the structural basis for at least some of them was the extrusion of relatively small palindromes into the cruciform state. Insertion of a short synthetic palindromic sequence into the phi X174 genome generated a supercoil-dependent, temperature-sensitive secondary structure that was cleaved in the Bal31 but not the S1 reaction, further supporting the hypothesis that even small cruciforms with stem size of 7 or less base pairs may be transiently stable. Subjecting supercoiled RF DNA to the typical S1 reaction conditions induced a topological shift that diminished all but one of the supercoil-induced Bal31 recognition sites and promoted the formation of one major new site.     

Effect of magnesium on cruciform extrusion in supercoiled DNA.

Recently, it was reported that Mg2+greatly facilitates cruciform extrusion in the short palindromes of supercoiled DNA, thereby allowing the formation of cruciform structures in vivo. Because of the potential biological importance of this phenomenon, we undertook a broader study of the effect of Mg2+on a cruciform extrusion in supercoiled DNA. The method of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis was used to detect the cruciform extrusion both in the absence and in the presence of these ions. Our results show that Mg2+shifts the cruciform extrusion in the d(CCC(AT)16GGG) palindrome to a higher, rather than to a lower level of supercoiling. In order to study possible sequence-specific properties of the short palindromes for which the unusual cruciform extrusion in the presence Mg2+was reported, we constructed a plasmid with a longer palindromic region. This region bears the same sequences in the hairpin loops and four-arm junction as the short palindrome, except that the short stems of the hairpins are extended. The extension allowed us to overcome the limitation of our experimental approach which cannot be used for very short palindromes. Our results show that Mg2+also shifts the cruciform extrusion in this palindrome to a higher level of supercoiling. These data suggest that cruciform extrusion in the short palindromes at low supercoiling is highly improbable. We performed a thermodynamic analysis of the effect of Mg2+on cruciform extrusion. The treatment accounted for the effect of Mg2+on both free energy of supercoiling and the free energy of cruciform structure per se. Our analysis showed that although the level of supercoiling required for the cruciform extrusion is not reduced by Mg2+, the ions reduce the free energy of the cruciform structure.     

Influence of cation size and charge on the extrusion of a salt-dependent cruciform

We have made a comparative study of the kinetics of cruciform extrusion by a salt-dependent (S-type) cruciform in the presence of a variety of metal ions and related species. We find that the nature of the cation present has a marked effect on the observed kinetics, and that different cations differ greatly in the efficiency with which they promote the extrusion process. We can divide the ions into four classes according to the optimal ionic concentration required for maximal extrusion rate. Group Ia cations and tetramethyl ammonium are most effective in promoting extrusion at 50 to 60 mM. Group IIa and selected transition metal ions (notably manganese) are effective over a wide range, extending down to 200 microM. Hexaminecobalt(III) and the polyamines promote extrusion at concentrations as low as 15 to 40 microM. Most remaining ions examined, including trivalent ions such as Al(III) and many transition metal ions are totally ineffective. Within the first two groups, we observe a marked correlation between the rate of cruciform extrusion promoted and ionic radius, the larger ions giving faster extrusion rates. We interpret this to indicate specific ion binding occurring in the transition state of the extrusion process. We may rationalize all the data in terms of a model for salt-dependent cruciform extrusion, in which the transition state resembles a partially extruded protocruciform. This creates an anionic "cavity" with selective ion binding properties, and its stabilization is therefore ion size-dependent.     

Cellular pathways controlling integron cassette site folding

By mobilizing small DNA units, integrons have a major function in the dissemination of antibiotic resistance among bacteria. The acquisition of gene cassettes occurs by recombination between the attI and attC sites catalysed by the IntI1 integron integrase. These recombination reactions use an unconventional mechanism involving a folded single‐stranded attC site. We show that cellular bacterial processes delivering ssDNA, such as conjugation and replication, favour proper folding of the attC site. By developing a very sensitive in vivo assay, we also provide evidence that attC sites can recombine as cruciform structures by extrusion from double‐stranded DNA. Moreover, we show an influence of DNA superhelicity on attC site extrusion in vitro and in vivo. We show that the proper folding of the attC site depends on both the propensity to form non‐recombinogenic structures and the length of their variable terminal structures. These results draw the network of cell processes that regulate integron recombination.     

The physical chemistry of cruciform structures in supercoiled DNA molecules

Inverted repeat DNA sequences extrude cruciform structures when present in negatively supercoiled molecules, stabilised by the release of torsional stress brought about by the negative twist change. We have revealed the presence of cruciform structures by means of enzyme and chemical probing experiments and topological band shift methods. The geometry of cruciform structures has been studied from two points of view. The unpairing of bases in the loop region has been investigated using bisulphite modification, with the result that the central four nucleotides have single-stranded character, and the next pair have only partially single-stranded nature. Gel electrophoretic studies of a pseudo-cruciform structure indicate that the cruciform junction introduces a pronounced bend into the molecule. The dependence of the formation of the ColE1 cruciform upon DNA supercoiling shows that it has a free energy of formation of 18.4 +/- 0.5 kcal mole-1. The kinetics of the extrusion process are complex. Most sequences extrude slowly with considerable temperature coefficients, but the detailed properties are strongly sequence-dependent. One synthetic inverted repeat sequence which we have studied in detail has an Arrhenius activation energy of 42.4 +/- 3.2 kcal mole-1. We discuss possible mechanistic pathways for the extrusion process.     

Real-time detection of cruciform extrusion by single-molecule DNA nanomanipulation

During cruciform extrusion, a DNA inverted repeat unwinds and forms a four-way junction in which two of the branches consist of hairpin structures obtained by self-pairing of the inverted repeats. Here, we use single-molecule DNA nanomanipulation to monitor in real-time cruciform extrusion and rewinding. This allows us to determine the size of the cruciform to nearly base pair accuracy and its kinetics with second-scale time resolution. We present data obtained with two different inverted repeats, one perfect and one imperfect, and extend single-molecule force spectroscopy to measure the torque dependence of cruciform extrusion and rewinding kinetics. Using mutational analysis and a simple two-state model, we find that in the transition state intermediate only the B-DNA located between the inverted repeats (and corresponding to the unpaired apical loop) is unwound, implying that initial stabilization of the four-way (or Holliday) junction is rate-limiting. We thus find that cruciform extrusion is kinetically regulated by features of the hairpin loop, while rewinding is kinetically regulated by features of the stem. These results provide mechanistic insight into cruciform extrusion and help understand the structural features that determine the relative stability of the cruciform and B-form states.     

Large-scale stable opening of supercoiled DNA in response to temperature and supercoiling in (A + T)-rich regions that promote low-salt cruciform extrusion.

We have studied the properties of (A + T)-rich sequences derived from ColE1 that promote cruciform extrusion at low ionic strength in supercoiled plasmids. We compared the chemical reactivity of the sequences in negatively supercoiled DNA (using osmium tetroxide and bromoacetaldehyde) with the results of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis performed under the same conditions. Taken together, the results indicate the occurrence of cooperative helix-coil transitions in the (A + T)-rich DNA at low ionic strength, to form stable, denatured regions. The extent of the open region is a function of temperature and superhelix density, with an additional local destabilization brought about by the presence of cruciform structures. We present a simple statistical mechanical model of the helix-coil transition in the (A + T)-rich DNA, from which we have obtained estimates of the free energy for average base-pair opening of 0.31 kcal mol-1 and that for the formation of a helix-coil junction of 4.9 kcal mol-1, in 45 mM Tris-borate, pH 8.3, 0.5 mM EDTA. The results offer a model for the C-type mechanism of cruciform extrusion. Inverted repeats that are incorporated into the melted region undergo hairpin loop formation below 50 degrees C, and upon closure of the melted region, by reduction of temperature or increased ionic strength, they remain as a fully extruded cruciform structure.     

Influence of DNA sequence and supercoiling on the process of cruciform formation

We have studied some of the effects of DNA sequence and negative superhelicity on the rate of cruciform formation. Replacing the sequence AATT at the center of a perfect 68 base-pair palindromic sequence with the sequence CCCGGG decreases the rate of cruciform formation by a factor of at least 100. The logarithm of the rate constant of cruciform formation was found to increase linearly with linking difference. For the 68 base-pair perfect palindrome in a 4400 base-pair plasmid, each additional negative superhelical turn increased the rate of cruciform formation by a factor of 1.6. These results are consistent with a mechanism in which cruciform formation is initiated by the formation of a single-stranded bubble, 10 base-pairs in length, near the center of the palindromic sequence. In addition, we have examined the effect of introducing an asymmetric insertion into the palindromic sequence.     

Comparison of physical and genetic properties of palindromic DNA sequences.

Some viable palindromic DNA sequences were found to cause an increase in the recovery of genetic recombinants. Although these palindromes contained no Chi sites, their presence in cis caused apparent recA+-dependent recombination to increase severalfold. This biological property did not correlate with the physical properties of the palindromes' extrusion of cruciform structures in vitro. Thus, two unrelated palindromes with similar effects on recombination in both Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas syringae displayed quite different kinetics of cruciform formation. In plasmids of native superhelical density, one palindrome underwent rapid cruciform formation at 55 degrees C, whereas the other did not form detectable cruciforms at any temperature. A shorter palindrome with similarly rapid kinetics of cruciform formation did not affect recombination detectably. The lack of a clear relationship between physical and genetic properties was also demonstrated in the case of longer, inviable palindromes. Here we found that the degree of asymmetry required in vivo to rescue a long palindrome from inviability far exceeded that required to kinetically prohibit cruciform extrusion in vitro.     

Fluctuations in superhelical DNA.

The effect of superhelicity on the base-pair opening probability and on the probability of occurrence of cruciform states in palindromic regions is theoretically treated. The calculations show that below the superhelix density value of -sigma=0.05 superhelicity does not appreciably affect the characteristics of DNA secondary structure fluctuations. In the range of physiological superhelix densities sigma (-sigma=0.05-0.09) the base-pair opening probability markedly increases. However, within this range of sigma the base-pairs are opened only transiently and permanently open regions are not formed. Permanently opened regions appear at higher negative superhelix densities (-sigma greater than 0.10). At the values of -sigma higher than 0.06 a cruciform structure in the palindromic region centred in position 3965 proves to be the most probable fluctuational disturbance in the 0x174 duplex DNA. Different experimental approaches used for probing the fluctuations in superhelical DNA have been analysed. The results suggest that most direct quantitative information can be derived from data on the nicking of closed DNA by single strand-specific endonucleases. Such data (Wang, 1974) accord with the results of theoretical calculations. Calculations show that, due to base-pair opening, the total free energy of superhelical DNA should depend parabolically on sigma only up to some critical value of sigma=sigmac. If negative superhelicity exceeds this critical value, which under physiological conditions proves to be -sigma=0.085, the free energy should increase linearly with -sigma. The biological role of supercoiling is discussed in the light of obtained results.     

Formation of (dA-dT)n cruciforms in Escherichia coli cells under different environmental conditions.

We have detected cruciform formation of (dA-dT)n inserts in Escherichia coli cells by analyzing the superhelical density of isolated plasmid DNA samples and by probing intracellular DNA with chloroacetaldehyde. The plasmids we used were pUC19 containing inserts of (dA-dT)n. The cruciforms appeared after cells underwent different stresses: inhibition of protein synthesis, anaerbiosis, and osmotic shock. At the same time, all these stimuli led to an increase in superhelical density of the control pUC19 plasmid DNA. Therefore, we suggest that the increase in plasmid superhelicity in response to different environmental stimuli entails the appearance of cruciform structures. The use of the (dA-dT)n units of various lengths made it possible to estimate the superhelical density of the plasmid DNA in vivo.     

Kinetics of cruciform formation and stability of cruciform structure in superhelical DNA

This is a study of the kinetics of formation of a cruciform structure from the longest palindromic sequence in plasmid pAO3 DNA. DNA was prepared so as to be free of cruciforms even in topoisomers whose negative superhelicity was great enough to induce cruciform formation. Samples of such DNA were incubated at various temperatures, the incubation time varying over a wide range. Then the state was frozen by chilling. Two-dimensional electrophoretic analysis made it possible to estimate the fraction of molecules that got the cruciform structure during incubation. Precautions were taken for electrophoresis conditions to rule out any spontaneous conformational changes within the palindromic region. The relaxation time at the midpoint of the transition ranged from 30 min at 30 C to 50 hrs at 20 C, both in 0.1SSC. An increase in the negative superhelical density by 0.01 led to a 500-fold reduction of the relaxation time at 30 C but had little effect at 20 C. The probability of cruciform formation has been examined as a function of temperature. It has been shown that the cruciform state is no longer the predominant one at elevated temperatures: the cruciformation probability drops to an insignificant value for all of the topoisomers involved. Data have been obtained suggesting that the cruciform formation at the major palindromic site is not the only structural transition possible in pAO3 DNA.     

Large-scale opening of A + T rich regions within supercoiled DNA molecules is suppressed by salt.

Large-scale cooperative helix opening has been previously observed in A + T rich sequences contained in supercoiled DNA molecules at elevated temperatures. Since it is well known that helix melting of linear DNA is suppressed by addition of salt, we have investigated the effects of added salts on opening transitions in negatively supercoiled DNA circles. We have found that localised large-scale stable melting in supercoiled DNA is strongly suppressed by modest elevation of salt concentration, in the range 10 to 30 mM sodium. This has been shown in a number of independent ways: 1. The temperature required to promote cruciform extrusion by the pathway that proceeds via the coordinate large-scale opening of an A + T rich region surrounding the inverted repeat (the C-type pathway, first observed in the extrusion of the ColE1 inverted repeat) is elevated by addition of salt. The temperature required for extrusion was increased by about 4 deg for an addition of 10 mM NaCl. 2. A + T rich regions in supercoiled DNA exhibit hyperreactivity towards osmium tetroxide as the temperature is raised; this reactivity is strongly suppressed by the addition of salt. At low salt concentrations of added NaCl (10 mM) we observe that there is an approximate equivalence between reducing the salt concentration, and the elevation of temperature. Above 30 mM NaCl the reactivity of the ColE1 sequences is completely supressed at normal temperatures. 3. Stable helix opening transitions in A + T rich sequences may be observed with elevated temperature, using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis; these transitions become progressively harder to demonstrate with the addition of salt. With the addition of low concentrations of salt, the onset of opening transitions shifts to higher superhelix density, and by 30 mM NaCl or more, no transitions are visible up to a temperature of 50 degrees C. Statistical mechanical simulation of the data indicate that the cooperativity free energy for the transition is unaltered by addition of salt, but that the free energy cost for opening each basepair is increased. These results demonstrate that addition of even relatively low concentrations of salt strongly suppress the large-scale helix opening of A + T rich regions, even at high levels of negative supercoiling. While the opening at low salt concentrations may reveal a propensity for such transitions, spontaneous opening is very unlikely under physiological conditions of salt, temperature and superhelicity, and we conclude that proteins will therefore be required to facilitate opening transitions in cellular DNA.     

Long-range structural effects in supercoiled DNA: statistical thermodynamics reveals a correlation between calculated cooperative melting and contextual influence on cruciform extrusion

We have previously described [K. M. Sullivan and D. M. J. Lilley (1986) Cell 47, 817-827] a set of sequences, called C-type inducing sequences, which cause cruciform extrusion by adjacent inverted repeats to occur by an abnormal kinetic pathway involving a large denatured region of DNA. In this paper we apply statistical thermodynamic DNA helix melting theory to these sequences. We find a marked correlation between the ability of sequences to confer C-type cruciform character experimentally and their calculated propensity to undergo cooperative melting, and no exceptions have been found. The correlations are both qualitative and quantitative. Thus the ColE1 flanking sequences behave as single melting units, while the DNA of the S-type plasmid pIRbke8 exhibits no propensity to melt in the region of the bke cruciform. The results of the calculations are also fully consistent with the following experimental observations: 1. the ability of the isolated colL and colR fragments of the ColE1 flanking sequences, as well as the short sequence col30, to confer C-type character; 2. C-type induction by an A + T rich Drosophila sequence; 3. low-temperature cruciform extrusion by an (AT)34 sequence; 4. the effect of changing sequences at a site 90 base pairs (bp) removed from the inverted repeat; 5. the effects of systematic deletion of the colL sequence; and 6. the effects of insertion of various sequences in between the colL sequence and the xke inverted repeat. These studies show that telestability effects on thermal denaturation as predicted from equilibrium helix melting theory of linear DNA molecules may explain all the features that are revealed by studying the extrusion of cruciforms in circular DNA molecules subjected to superhelical stress.     

The effect of temperature on DNA structural transitions under the action of Cu2+ and Ca2+ ions in aqueous solutions

The work examines the structural transitions of DNA under the action of Cu2+ and Ca2+ ions in aqueous solution at temperatures of 29 and 45 degrees C by ir spectroscopy. Upon binding to the divalent ions studied, DNA transits into the compact state both at 29 and 45 degrees C. In the compact state DNA remains in B-form limits. The compaction process is of high positive cooperativity. As temperature increases the divalent metal ion concentration required to induce DNA compaction decreases in the case of Cu(2+)-induced compaction and increases in the case of Ca(2+)-induced compaction. It is suggested that the mechanism of the temperature effect on DNA compaction in the presence of Cu2+ ions possessing higher affinity for DNA bases differs from that of the temperature influence on Ca(2+)-induced DNA compaction. In the case of copper ions the determining factor is the increase of binding constants of the Cu2+ ions interacting with the denatured parts formed on DNA while in the case of calcium ions it is the decreased screening action of counterions upon the increase of their hydration with temperature. The efficiency of divalent metal ions studied in inducing DNA compaction depends on hydration of counterions. DNA compaction occurs in a narrow interval of Cu2+ concentrations. As the Cu2+ ion concentration increases, DNA compaction is replaced with Cu(2+)-induced DNA aggregation. At elevated temperatures Cu(2+)-induced DNA compaction could acquire a phase transition character.     

Cruciform extrusion in plasmids bearing the replicative intermediate configuration of a poxvirus telomere

The transition from lineform DNA to cruciform DNA (cruciformation) within the cloned telomere sequences of the Leporipoxvirus Shope fibroma virus (SFV) has been studied. The viral telomere sequences have been cloned in recombination-deficient Escherichia coli as a 322 base-pair, imperfect palindromic insert in pUC13. The inverted repeat configuration is equivalent to the arrangement of the telomere structures observed within viral DNA replicative intermediates. A major cruciform structure in the purified recombinant plasmid has been identified and mapped using, as probes, the enzymes AflII, nuclease S1 and bacteriophage T7 endonuclease I. It was extruded from the central axis of the cloned viral inverted repeat and, by unrestricted branch migration, attained a size commensurate with the superhelical density of the plasmid molecule at native superhelical densities. This major cruciform extrusion event was the only detectable duplex DNA perturbation, induced by negative superhelical torsion, in the insert viral sequences. No significant steady-state pool of extruded cruciform was identified in E. coli. However, the identification of a major deletion variant generated even in the recombination-deficient E. coli strain DB1256 (recA recBC sbcB) suggested that the cruciform may be extruded transiently in vivo. The lineform to cruciform transition has been further characterized in vitro using two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis. The transition was marked by a high energy of formation (delta Gf = 44 kcal/mol), and an apparently low activation energy that enabled facile transitions at physiological temperatures provided there was sufficient torsional energy. By comparing cruciformation in a series of related bidirectional central axis deletions of the telomeric insert, it has been concluded that the presence of extrahelical bases in the terminal hairpin structures contributes substantially to the high delta Gf value. Also, viral sequences flanking the extruded cruciform were shown to influence the measured delta Gf value. Several general features of poxvirus telomere structure that would be expected to influence the facility of cruciform extrusion are discussed along with the implications of the observed cruciform transition event on the replicative process of poxviruses in vivo.     

Kinetics of Cruciform Formation and Stability of Cruciform Structure in Superhelical DNA

Abstract

This is a study of the kinetics of formation of a cruciform structure from the longest palindromic sequence in plasmid pA03 DNA. DNA was prepared so as to be free of cruciforms even in topoisomers whose negative superhelicity was great enough to induce cruciform formation. Samples of such DNA were incubated at various temperatures, the incubation time varying over a wide range. Then the state was frozen by chilling. Two-dimensional electrophoretic analysis made it possible to estimate the fraction of molecules that got the cruciform structure during incubation. Precautions were taken for electrophoresis conditions to rule out any spontaneous conformational changes within the palindromic region. The relaxation time at the midpoint of the transition ranged from 30 min at 30 C to 50 hrs at 20 C, both in 0.1SSC. An increase in the negative superhelical density by 0.01 led to a 500-fold reduction of the relaxation time at 30 C but had little effect at 20 C. The probability of cruciform formation has been examined as a function of temperature. It has been shown that the cruciform state is no longer the predominant one at elevated temperatures: the cruciformation probability drops to an insignificant value for all of the topoisomers involved. Data have been obtained suggesting that the cruciform formation at the major palindromic site is not the only structural transition possible in pA03 DNA.