Flow kinetics of nylon open-tubular and beaded immobilized glucose oxidase reactors

Equations describing the flow kinetics of immobilized glucose oxidase in open nylon tubes and in tubes filled with solid glass spheres were experimentally determined. Reactors of three different tube (dt) and bead (db) diameters were tested using various linear flow rates (vf) and glucose concentrations ([S]). The kinetics of the open-tubular reactors were described by [P] = 1.5.10(-3) [S] L0.86 vf-0.78 dt-0.9 and the kinetics of the beaded-tubular reactors by [P] = 5.10(-3) [S] L0.98 vf-0.75 dt-1.0 (db/dt)2.7, where [P] equals the concentration of H2O2 formed. The aspect ratio, db/dt, is the critical design factor for beaded reactors.     

Phe5(4-nitro)-bradykinin: a chromogenic substrate for assay and kinetics of the metalloendopeptidase meprin

Phe5(4-nitro)-bradykinin has been identified as a good synthetic substrate to study the kinetics and mechanism of action of the metalloendopeptidase meprin. No convenient substrate for kinetic analysis of the enzyme had been previously described. HPLC analyses indicated that meprin cleaved bradykinin and nitrobradykinin between Phe5 (or Phe5(NO2)) and Ser6. Reaction rates for bradykinin were determined by quantitative HPLC analyses, whereas rates for nitrobradykinin were measured by continuous monitoring of the spectral change that occurs at 310 nm when the Phe(NO2)-Ser bond is hydrolyzed. For nitrobradykinin and unmodified bradykinin, respectively, Km values were 281 and 425 microM, kcat values were 28 and 22 s-1, and kcat/Km values were 9.7 x 10(4) and 5.1 x 10(4)M-1. The two products of bradykinin hydrolysis were not substrates for the enzyme, but they were inhibitors. The initial rates of hydrolysis of nitrobradykinin increased linearly with enzyme concentration (0.09-2.2 micrograms/ml), and increased linearly with temperature in the range from 15 to 55 degrees C. Hydrolysis of the substrate was optimal at alkaline pH values. The cysteine endopeptidases papain and cathepsin L and the metalloproteases thermolysin, angiotensin-converting enzyme, and neutral endopeptidase (EC 3.4.24.11) also cleaved nitrobradykinin, but at different peptide bonds than meprin. The single cleavage of nitrobradykinin at the Phe(NO2)-Ser bond and the concomitant spectral shift that occurs at alkaline pH makes this a particularly suitable substrate for meprin.     

Improved methodology for intracellular enzyme reaction and inhibition kinetics by flow cytometry

Flow cytoenzymology is the determination of enzyme activities or concentrations in single intact cells. Using the flow cytometer built and designed in our laboratory and recent modifications to hardware and software, we have developed an improved dynamic flow cytoenzymological procedure for the assay of cellular enzyme kinetics. The reaction mixture is sampled continuously, and the computer clock incorporates time as a parameter for kinetic determinations. Conditions for cellular esterase analysis were optimized and the rates of hydrolysis of two fluorogenic substrates, fluorescein diacetate (FDA) and 4-methylumbelliferone acetate (MUA), by esterases in EMT6 mouse mammary tumor cells were studied. Reaction kinetics were characterized, and Km values of 19 and 72 microM were obtained for the hydrolysis of FDA and MUA respectively. The kinetics of the cellular efflux of fluorescein were investigated, and a half-life of 7.5 min obtained. Enzyme inhibition kinetics were investigated using the competitive substrates p-nitrophenyl acetate and phenyl acetate, and the carbamoylating agents physostigmine and n-butyl isocyanate. The latter was particularly potent with an I50 of 4.8 X 10(-5) M for FDA hydrolysis compared with 6.5 X 10(-3) M for physostigmine. The I50 of 8.8 X 10(-5) M for n-butyl isocyanate inhibition of MUA hydrolysis was similar to that obtained with FDA as substrate. By monitoring FDA and MUA reactions separately and simultaneously, we showed them to act as competitive substrates. A comparison of flow cytoenzymological and conventional spectrofluorimetric analysis was also made, and differences identified in some cases.     

Reactivity of sarcoplasmic reticulum adenosinetriphosphatase with iodoacetamide spin-label: evidence for two conformational states of the substrate binding sites

The labeling kinetics of sarcoplasmic reticulum ATPase with the iodoacetamide spin probe N-(1-oxy-2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-4-piperidinyl)iodoacetamide were followed under conditions designed to selectively label all reactive groups. Approximately 1 mol of spin-label reacted per one 100 000-dalton ATPase chain, indicating only one residue on the enzyme had been labeled. One uniform rate of labeling was observed in the presence of Ca2+. When substrate was then added, approximately one-half of the residues showed a 10-fold increase in labeling rate while the remaining residues reacted at the initial, slower rate. Sequential labeling experiments further established that the two labeling rates correspond to the coexistence of two conformational state of the enzyme. Both Ca2+ and substrate are required to obtain an equal distribution between states, and the effect is completely reversed when substrate is removed. The iodoacetamide spin probe is known to be highly sensitive to the conformation of the ATPase binding pocket, and the residue labeled here is the one which generates broadening in the electron paramagnetic resonance spectrum on substrate binding. Due to the unique selectively of the labeling reaction, it is suggested that when both substrate and Ca2+ are bound to the enzyme, conditions which are precursory to enzyme phosphorylation, two specific conformations of the binding pocket exist in approximately at 50:50 ratio.     

Kinetcs and decay of fumarase activity of immobilized Brevibacterium ammoniagenes cells for continuous production of L-malic acid

The kinetics of the reversible fumarase reaction of immobilized Brevibacterium ammoniagenes cells and the decay behavior of enzyme activity were investigated in a plug flow system. The time course of the reaction in the immobilized cell column was well explained by the time-conversion equation including the apparent kinetic constants of the immobilized cell enzyme. The decay rate of fumarase activity was faster in the upper sections of the column (inlet side of the substrate solution) compared with the lower sections when 1M sodium fumarate (pH 7.0) was continuously passed through the column at 37°C. It was shown that the decay rate of the fumarase activity in the immobilized cell column depends on the flow rate of the substrate solution. The effect of flow rate on the decay rate of enzyme activity was considered to be related to the rate of contamination of enzyme with poisonous substances derived from the substrate solution or to the rate of leakage of enzyme stabilizers and/or enzyme itself from the immobilized cells.     

Guanine deaminase in rat liver and mouse liver and brain

1. The guanine deaminase in rat liver supernatant preparations was resolved into two fractions, A and B, on DEAE-cellulose columns. The two differed in electrophoretic mobility and in various properties. The most noteworthy distinction between A and B components was that the enzyme A activity showed a sigmoid dependence on substrate concentration whereas the enzyme B showed classical Michaelis-Menten kinetics. The K(m) value of enzyme A for guanine was 5.3mum and that of enzyme B 20mum. 2. The entire guanine deaminase activity of mouse liver was contained in the 15000g supernatant of iso-osmotic homogenates. 3. A reinvestigation of the behaviour of rat brain 15000g supernatant guanine deaminase isoenzymes revealed that one enzyme had sigmoidal kinetics and the other enzyme showed a hyperbolic response. 4. Of the guanine deaminase in mouse brain iso-osmotic sucrose homogenate 80% was recovered in the 15000g supernatant and the rest from the particles. The supernatant guanine deaminase was resolvable into two fractions on DEAE-cellulose columns. One enzyme showed sigmoidal kinetics whereas the other showed a hyperbolic response to increasing substrate concentration; the K(m) values for the reaction with guanine were respectively 5 and 66mum. 5. The particulate fractions of mouse liver and brain were devoid of any overt inhibitory activity.     

Real-time measurements of dark substrate catalysis

We have developed a novel procedure to monitor the real-time cleavage of natural unmodified peptides (dark substrates). In the competition-based assay, the initial cleavage rate of a fluorogenic peptide substrate is measured in the presence of a second substrate that is not required to exhibit any optical property change upon cleavage. Using a unique experimental design and steady-state enzyme kinetics for a two-substrate system, we were able to determine both Km and k(cat) values for cleavage of the dark substrate. The method was applied to HIV-1 protease and to the V82F/I84V drug resistant mutant enzyme. Using two different substrates, we showed that the kinetic parameters derived from the competition assay are in good agreement with those determined independently using standard direct assay. This method can be applied to other enzyme systems as long as they have one substrate for which catalysis can be conveniently monitored in real time.     

Subsite interactions of ribonuclease T1: viscosity effects indicate that the rate-limiting step of GpN transesterification depends on the nature of N

We report on the effect of the viscogenic agents glycerol and ficoll on the RNase T1 catalyzed turnover of GpA, GpC, GpU, and Torula yeast RNA. For wild-type enzyme, we find that the kcat/Km values for the transesterification of GpC and GpA as well as for the cleavage of RNA are inversely proportional to the relative viscosity of glycerol-containing buffers; no such effect is observed for the conversion of GpU to cGMP and U. The second-order rate constants for His40Ala and Glu46Ala RNase T1, two mutants with a drastically reduced kcat/km ratio, are independent of the microviscosity, indicating that glycerol does not affect the intrinsic kinetic parameters. Consistent with the notion that molecular diffusion rates are unaffected by polymeric viscogens, addition of ficoll has no effect on the kcat/Km for GpC transesterification by wild-type enzyme. The data indicate that the second-order rate constants for GpC, GpA, and Torula yeast RNA are at least partly limited by the diffusion-controlled association rate of substrate and active site; RNase T1 obeys Briggs-Haldane kinetics for these substrates (Km greater than Ks). Calculations suggest that the equilibrium dissociation constants (Ks) for the various GpN-wild-type enzyme complexes are virtually independent of N whereas the measured kcat values follow the order GpC greater than GpA greater than GpU. This is also revealed by the steady-state kinetic parameters of Tyr38Phe and His40Ala RNase T1, two mutants that follow simple Michaelis-Menten kinetics because of a dramatically reduced kcat value (i.e., Km = Ks).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Activity and kinetic characteristics of glutathione reductase in vitro in reverse micellar waterpool

The enzyme activity of glutathione reductase (NAD(P)H:oxidized-glutathione oxidoreductase, EC 1.6.4.2) incorporated in CTAB/H2O/CHCl3-isooctane (1:1, v/v) reverse micelles has been investigated. Enzyme follows the Michaelis-Menten kinetics within a specified concentration range. Effects of pH, waterpool (W0), and surfactant concentration on the activity of glutathione reductase have been studied in detail. Optimum pH for the maximum enzyme activity was found to be dependent on the size of the waterpool. Further, a substrate inhibition was observed when concentration of one of the substrates was present in large excess over the other substrate. Km values for the substrate, oxidized glutathione (GSSG) and NADPH in CTAB/H2O/CHCl3-isooctane (1:1, v/v) were determined at W0 values of 14.4, 20.0, 25.5 and 29.7, at pH 8.0. These values are close to those obtained in aqueous solution, whereas the kcat values vary with W0 values of 8.8 to 32.3. Studies on the storage stability in the reverse micelle at W0 29.7 and pH 8.0 showed that glutathione reductase retained about 80% of its activity even after a month. The enzyme showed a higher stability at high waterpool. Oxidized glutathione (GSSG) provides protection to glutathione reductase against denaturation on storage in reverse micellar solution. Apparently, the enzyme is able to acquire a suitable native conformation at waterpool 29.7 and pH 8.0 and thereby exhibits an activity and stability inside the micellar cavity that are almost equivalent to that in aqueous solution.     

Steady-state kinetic properties of phosphoglycerate kinase of mung beans

Steady-state kinetics of the action of mung bean phosphoglycerate kinase have been investigated using 3-phosphoglycerate and ATP as substrates in the presence of Mg2+ ions. Keeping a constant and high Mg2+ concentration and varying the concentration of one of the substrates (ATP or 3-phosphoglycerates) at several fixed concentrations of the other substrate (3-phosphoglycerate or ATP), the Km values of Mg.ATP2- and 3-phosphoglycerate were found to be 0.42 and 0.60 mM, respectively. These values are independent of the concentration of the other substrate. A limiting value of Vmax, where the enzyme is saturated with both the substrates, was found to be 39.4 mumoles product formed per min per mg enzyme protein. This corresponds to a turnover number equal to 31.5 sec-1 (for molecular weight of the enzyme equal to 48,000). If [Mg2+] and [ATP4-] are held equal and varied together at several fixed concentrations of 3-phosphoglycerate, deviations from Michaelis-Menten kinetics (non-linear Lineweaver-Burk plots) are observed at lower values of ATP4- and Mg2+ (less than 0.1 mM), giving rise to apparent sigmoidicity in the rate versus [ATP4-] plots. It has been suggested that the real substrate for this enzyme is the Mg.ATP2- complex (and not free ATP4-). The complex dissociates at lower values of [Mg2+] and [ATP4-]. The resulting disproportionate decrease in the concentration of the complex brings about a steeper fall in the rate of reaction than is required by the Michaelis-Menten equation, giving rise to an apparent sigmoidicity.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Alternative Substrate Kinetics of Escherichia coli Ribonuclease P: DETERMINATION OF RELATIVE RATE CONSTANTS BY INTERNAL COMPETITION*

A single enzyme, ribonuclease P (RNase P), processes the 5′ ends of tRNA precursors (ptRNA) in cells and organelles that carry out tRNA biosynthesis. This substrate population includes over 80 different competing ptRNAs in Escherichia coli. Although the reaction kinetics and molecular recognition of a few individual model substrates of bacterial RNase P have been well described, the competitive substrate kinetics of the enzyme are comparatively unexplored. To understand the factors that determine how different ptRNA substrates compete for processing by E. coli RNase P, we compared the steady state reaction kinetics of two ptRNAs that differ at sequences that are contacted by the enzyme. For both ptRNAs, substrate cleavage is fast relative to dissociation. As a consequence, V/K, the rate constant for the reaction at limiting substrate concentrations, reflects the substrate association step for both ptRNAs. Reactions containing two or more ptRNAs follow simple competitive alternative substrate kinetics in which the relative rates of processing are determined by ptRNA concentration and their V/K. The relative V/K values for eight different ptRNAs, which were selected to represent the range of structure variation at sites contacted by RNase P, were determined by internal competition in reactions in which all eight substrates were present simultaneously. The results reveal a relatively narrow range of V/K values, suggesting that rates of ptRNA processing by RNase P are tuned for uniform specificity and consequently optimal coupling to precursor biosynthesis.     

Kinetics of dithionite-dependent reduction of cytochrome P450 3A4: heterogeneity of the enzyme caused by its oligomerization

To explore the basis of apparent conformational heterogeneity of cytochrome P450 3A4 (CYP3A4), the kinetics of dithionite-dependent reduction was studied in solution, in proteoliposomes, and in Nanodiscs. In CYP3A4 oligomers in solution the kinetics obeys a three-exponential equation with similar amplitudes of each of the phases. Addition of substrate (bromocriptine) displaces the phase distribution toward the slow phase at the expense of the fast one, while the middle phase remains unaffected. The fraction reduced in the fast phase, either with or without substrate, is represented by the low-spin heme protein only, while the slow-reducible fraction is enriched in the high-spin CYP3A4. Upon monomerization by 0.15% Emulgen-913, or by incorporation into Nanodiscs or into large proteoliposomes with a high lipid-to-protein (L/P) ratio (726:1 mol/mol), the kinetics observed in the absence of substrate becomes very rapid and virtually monoexponential. In Nanodiscs and in lipid-rich liposomes bromocriptine decreases the rate of reduction via appearance of the second (slow) phase, the amplitude of which reaches 100% at saturating bromocriptine. In contrast, in P450-rich liposomes (L/P = 112 mol/mol), where the surface molar density of the enzyme is comparable to that observed in liver microsomes, CYP3A4 behaves similarly to that observed in solution. These results suggest that in CYP3A4 oligomers in solution and in the membrane the enzyme is distributed between two persistent conformers with different accessibility of the heme for the reductant (SO*-(2) anion monomer). One of the apparent conformers exists in a substrate-dependent equilibrium between two states with different rate constants of reduction by dithionite, while the second conformer shows no response to substrate binding.     

Nature of rate-limiting steps in a compartmentalized enzyme system. Quantitation of dopamine transport and hydroxylation rates in resealed chromaffin granule ghosts

Using isolated chromaffin granule ghosts from bovine adrenal medullae, we have studied the kinetics of dopamine beta-monooxygenase (D beta M) activity as it is linked to dopamine transport. Measurements of the initial rates of transport and of transport-linked norepinephrine formation suggested that enzyme activity may be partially rate-limiting in the coupled carrier/enzyme system. This was confirmed by (i) measurements of initial rates of norepinephrine formation using deuterated substrate, which gave isotope effects greater than 2.0, and (ii) kinetic measurements using ghosts pulsed with varying concentrations of labeled dopamine, which indicated substantial substrate accumulation in the vesicle interior as a function of time. Initial rates of product formation, when combined with approximations of internal substrate concentrations, allowed estimates of Kcat and Km for intravesicular D beta M. Activation by external reductant was apparent in both initial rate parameters and the measurements of transients. Under conditions of optimal D beta M activity, the enzyme rate parameters (kcat = 0.31 nmol/s.mg and Km = 2 mM) indicated partial rate limitation compared to dopamine transport (kcat = 0.38 nmol/s.mg and Km = 32 microM). Compartmental analysis of the time curves, performed using numerical nonlinear least squares methods, gave least squares estimates of rate constants for a simple carrier mechanism and kcat values for D beta M which were consistent with estimates from initial rates.     

Immobilized electric eel acetylcholinesterasemii. II. Flow kinetics of acetylcholinesterase chemically attached to nylon tubing.

Acetylcholinesterase has been attached covalently to the inner surface of nylon tubing. An experimental study has been carried out on the flow kinetics; solutions of acetylthiocholine at various concentrations were passed through tubing at various flow rates, and measurements made of the rates of formation of product. The results were analyzed in the light of the theoretical treatment of Kobayashi and Laidler, four different methods of analysis being employed. It is found that at lower substrate concentrations and flow rates the reactions are largely diffusion controlled. The Km(app) values are substantially higher than the Km value for diffusion-free conditions, but approach it as the flow rate is increased, when the diffusion layer becomes less important. The results are entirely consistent with the Kobayaski-Laidler theory, and provide guidelines for the design of open tubular heterogeneous enzyme reactors, both for industrial and analytic purposes.     

Total Hydrolysis of Xylotetraose and Xylobiose by Soluble and Cross-linked Crystalline Xylanase II from Trichoderma reesei

The ability of Trichoderma reesei xylanase II (EC 3.2.1.8) to hydrolyse the small xylo-oligomer substrates, xylotetraose and xylobiose, was studied. Xylanase was used in both soluble and cross-linked enzyme crystal (CLEC) form. Hydrolysis reactions with crystalline xylanase cross-linked with glutaraldehyde and lysine were performed in a column reactor. By using appropriate combination of column packing length and flow rate, xylotetraose and xylobiose (initial concentrations 10 mg ml &#109 1 ) were hydrolysed completely to xylose in less than 1 h. The observed reaction rate in the column depended substantially on the flow rate of the eluent, probably due to an enhanced mass-transfer with higher flow rates. With soluble xylanase, using extended reaction times of 24 h and extremely high enzyme/substrate ratios of 20 (w/w) or above, the hydrolysis reaction reached completion with both xylotetraose and xylobiose as substrates. Even with the lowest flow rate, the reaction in the column appeared to be faster than soluble enzyme hydrolysis with comparable enzyme/substrate ratios.     

New model for activation of yeast pyruvate decarboxylase by substrate consistent with the alternating sites mechanism: demonstration of the existence of two active forms of the enzyme

Pyruvate decarboxylase from yeast (YPDC, EC 4.1.1.1) exhibits a marked lag phase in the progress curves of product (acetaldehyde) formation. The currently accepted kinetic model for YPDC predicts that, only upon binding of substrate in a regulatory site, a slow activation step converts inactive enzyme into the active form. This allosteric behavior gives rise to sigmoidal steady-state kinetics. The E477Q active site variant of YPDC exhibited hyperbolic initial rate curves at low pH, not consistent with the model. Progress curves of product formation by this variant were S-shaped, consistent with the presence of three interconverting conformations with distinct steady-state rates. Surprisingly, wild-type YPDC at pH < or =5.0 also possessed S-shaped progress curves, with the conformation corresponding to the middle steady state being the most active one. Reexamination of the activation by substrate of wild-type YPDC in the pH range of 4.5-6.5 revealed two characteristic transitions at all pH values. The values of steady-state rates are functions of both pH and substrate concentration, affecting whether the progress curve appears "normal" or S-shaped with an inflection point. The substrate dependence of the apparent rate constants suggested that the first transition corresponded to substrate binding in an active site and a subsequent step responsible for conversion to an asymmetric conformation. Consequently, the second enzyme state may report on "unregulated" enzyme, since the regulatory site does not participate in its generation. This enzyme state utilizes the alternating sites mechanism, resulting in the hyperbolic substrate dependence of initial rate. The second transition corresponds to binding a substrate molecule in the regulatory site and subsequent minor conformational adjustments. The third enzyme state corresponds to the allosterically regulated conformation, previously referred to as activated enzyme. The pH dependence of the Hill coefficient suggests a random binding of pyruvate in a regulatory and an active site of wild-type YPDC. Addition of pyruvamide or acetaldehyde to YPDC results in the appearance of additional conformations of the enzyme.     

Conversion of olive pomace oil to cocoa butter-like fat in a packed-bed enzyme reactor

Refined olive pomace oil (ROPO) was utilized as a source oil for production of cocoa butter-like fat. Immobilized sn-1,3 specific lipase catalyzed acidolysis of ROPO with palmitic (PA) and stearic (SA) acids was performed in a laboratory scale packed-bed reactor. Effect of reactor conditions on product formation was studied at various substrate mole ratios (ROPO:PA:SA; 1:1:1, 1:1:3, 1:3:3, 1:2:6), enzyme loads (10%, 20%, 40%), substrate flow rates (1.5, 4.5, 7.5, 15 ml/min) and solvent amounts (150, 400 ml). The highest yield (10.9% POP, 19.7% POS and 11.2% SOS) was obtained at 40% enzyme load, 1:2:6 substrate mole ratio, 45 degrees C, 7.5 ml/min substrate flow rate, 150 ml solvent and 3h reaction time. The melting profile and SFC of the product were comparable to those of CB. Polarized light microscope (PLM) images showed no drastic changes in polymorphic behavior between CB and product.     

Spectral and kinetic studies on Pseudomonas L-phenylalanine oxidase (deaminating and decarboxylating)

Pseudomonas L-phenylalanine oxidase (deaminating and decarboxylating) contains two FAD molecules in one molecule of the enzyme (Koyama, H. (1983) J. Biochem. 93, 1313-1319). When the enzyme was mixed anaerobically with L-phenylalanine, beta-2-thienylalanine, L-tyrosine, or L-methionine, a spectral species (purple intermediate) with a broad absorption band around 540 nm was observed with each substrate, and decayed slowly. From the data on the overall reaction kinetics, the rate of the L-phenylalanine oxidase reaction was expressed as follows. e/v = e/Vm + A/[S] + B/[O2] where e represents the concentration of enzyme unit, v the rate of the overall reaction, Vm the maximum velocity, and A and B are constants. Furthermore, the reactions of the enzyme with beta-2-thienylalanine (mostly an oxygenase substrate) and L-methionine (an oxidase substrate) were analyzed by the "stopped flow" method. The following scheme for the mechanism of L-phenylalanine oxidase reaction with both substrates is proposed, based on the data obtained. (formula; see text) Where Eox represents the oxidized form of the enzyme unit, EoxS the enzyme unit (oxidized form)-substrate compound, X the purple intermediate with a characteristic broad absorption band around 540 nm, S the substrate and P the product.     

Total Hydrolysis of Xylotetraose and Xylobiose by Soluble and Cross-linked Crystalline Xylanase II from Trichoderma reesei

The ability of Trichoderma reesei xylanase II (EC 3.2.1.8) to hydrolyse the small xylo-oligomer substrates, xylotetraose and xylobiose, was studied. Xylanase was used in both soluble and cross-linked enzyme crystal (CLEC) form. Hydrolysis reactions with crystalline xylanase cross-linked with glutaraldehyde and lysine were performed in a column reactor. By using appropriate combination of column packing length and flow rate, xylotetraose and xylobiose (initial concentrations 10 mg ml -1 ) were hydrolysed completely to xylose in less than 1 h. The observed reaction rate in the column depended substantially on the flow rate of the eluent, probably due to an enhanced mass-transfer with higher flow rates. With soluble xylanase, using extended reaction times of 24 h and extremely high enzyme/substrate ratios of 20 (w/w) or above, the hydrolysis reaction reached completion with both xylotetraose and xylobiose as substrates. Even with the lowest flow rate, the reaction in the column appeared to be faster than soluble enzyme hydrolysis with comparable enzyme/substrate ratios.