Functional analysis of the ffh-trmD region of the Escherichia coli chromosome by using reverse genetics.

We have analyzed the essentiality or contribution to growth of each of four genes in the Escherichia coli trmD operon (rpsP, 21K, trmD, and rplS) and of the flanking genes ffh and 16K by a reverse genetic method. Mutant alleles were constructed in vitro on plasmids and transferred by recombination to the corresponding lambda phage clone (lambda 439) and from the phage clone to the E. coli chromosome. An ability to obtain recombinants only in cells carrying a complementing plasmid indicated that the mutated gene was essential, while an ability to obtain recombinants in plasmid-free cells indicated nonessentiality. In this way, Ffh, the E. coli homolog to the 54-kDa protein of the signal recognition particle of mammalian cells, and ribosomal proteins S16 and L19 were shown to be essential for viability. A deletion of the second gene, 21K, of the trmD operon reduced the growth rate of the cells fivefold, indicating that the wild-type 21-kDa protein is important for viability. A deletion-insertion in the same gene resulted in the accumulation of an assembly intermediate of the 50S ribosomal subunit, as a result of polar effects on the expression of a downstream gene, rplS, which encodes ribosomal protein L19. This finding suggests that L19, previously not considered to be an assembly protein, contributes to the assembly of the 50S ribosomal subunits. Strains deleted for the trmD gene, the third gene of the operon, encoding the tRNA (m1G37)methyltransferase (or TrmD) showed a severalfold reduced growth rate. Since such a strain grew much slower than a strain lacking the tRNA(m(1)G37) methyltransferase activity because of a point mutation, the TrmD protein might have a second function in the cell. Finally, a 16-kDa protein encoded by the gene located downstream of, and convergently transcribed to, the trmD operon was found to be nonessential and not to contribute to growth.     

Distinct origins of tRNA(m1G37) methyltransferase

The enzyme tRNA(m1G37) methyltransferase catalyzes the transfer of a methyl group from S-adenosyl-l-methionine (AdoMet) to the N1 position of G37 in the anticodon loop of a subset of tRNA. The modified guanosine is 3' to the anticodon and is important for maintenance of reading frame during decoding of genetic information. While the methyltransferase is well conserved in bacteria and is easily identified (encoded by the trmD gene), the identity of the enzyme in eukarya and archaea is less clear. Here, we report that the enzyme encoded by Mj0883 of Methanocaldococcus jannaschii is the archaeal counterpart of the bacterial TrmD. However, despite catalyzing the same reaction and displaying similar enzymatic properties, MJ0883 and bacterial TrmD are completely unrelated in sequence. The catalytic domain of MJ0883, when aligned with the five known structural folds (I-V) that have been described to bind AdoMet, is of the class I fold, similar to the ancient Rossmann fold that binds nucleotides. In contrast, the catalytic domain of the bacterial TrmD has the unusual class IV fold of a trefoil knot structure. Thus, both the sequence and structural arrangements of tRNA(m1G37) methyltransferase have distinct evolutionary origins among primary kingdoms, revealing an unexpected but remarkable non-orthologous gene displacement to achieve an important tRNA modification.     

Structural alterations of the tRNA(m1G37)methyltransferase from Salmonella typhimurium affect tRNA substrate specificity

In Salmonella typhimurium, the tRNA(m1G37)methyltransferase (the product of the trmD gene) catalyzes the formation of m1G37, which is present adjacent and 3' of the anticodon (position 37) in seven tRNA species, two of which are tRNA(Pro)CGG and tRN(Pro)GGG. These two tRNA species also exist as +1 frameshift suppressor sufA6 and sufB2, respectively, both having an extra G in the anticodon loop next to and 3' of m1G37. The wild-type form of the tRNA(m1G37)methyltransferase efficiently methylates these mutant tRNAs. We have characterized one class of mutant forms of the tRNA(m1G37)methyltransferase that does not methylate the sufA6 tRNA and thereby induce extensive frameshifting resulting in a nonviable cell. Accordingly, pseudorevertants of strains containing such a mutated trmD allele in conjunction with the sufA6 allele had reduced frameshifting activity caused by either a 9-nt duplication in the sufA6tRNA or a deletion of its structural gene, or by an increased level of m1G37 in the sufA6tRNA. However, the sufB2 tRNA as well as the wild-type counterparts of these two tRNAs are efficiently methylated by this class of structural altered tRNA(m1G37)methyltransferase. Two other mutations (trmD3, trmD10) were found to reduce the methylation of all potential tRNA substrates and therefore primarily affect the catalytic activity of the enzyme. We conclude that all mutations except two (trmD3 and trmD10) do not primarily affect the catalytic activity, but rather the substrate specificity of the tRNA, because, unlike the wild-type form of the enzyme, they recognize and methylate the wild-type but not an altered form of a tRNA. Moreover, we show that the TrmD peptide is present in catalytic excess in the cell.     

Importance of mRNA folding and start codon accessibility in the expression of genes in a ribosomal protein operon of Escherichia coli.

The trmD operon of Escherichia coli consists of the genes for the ribosomal protein (r-protein) S16, a 21 kilodalton protein (21K) of unknown function, the tRNA(m1G37)methyltransferase (TrmD), and r-protein L19, in that order. The synthesis of the 21K and TrmD proteins is 12 and 40-fold lower, respectively, than that of the two r-proteins, although the corresponding parts of the mRNA are equally abundant. This translational control of expression of at least the 21K protein gene (21K), is mediated by a negative control element located between codons 18 and 50 of 21K. Here, we present evidence for a model in which mRNA sequences up to around 100 nucleotides downstream from the start codon of 21K fold back and base-pair to the 21K translation initiation region, thereby decreasing the translation initiation frequency. Mutations in the internal negative control element of 21K that would prevent the formation of the proposed mRNA secondary structure over both the Shine-Dalgarno (SD) sequence and the start codon increased expression up to about 20-fold, whereas mutations that would disrupt the base-pairing with the SD-sequence had only relatively small effects on expression. In addition, the expression increased 12-fold when the stop codon of the preceding gene, rpsP, was moved next to the SD-sequence of 21K allowing the ribosomes to unfold the postulated mRNA secondary structure. The expression increased up to 150-fold when that stop codon change was combined with the internal negative control element base-substitutions that derepressed translation about 20-fold. The negative control element of 21K does not seem to be responsible for the low expression of the trmD gene located downstream. However, a similar negative control element native to trmD can explain at least partly the low expression of trmD. Possibly, the two mRNA secondary structures function to decouple translation of 21K and trmD from that of the respective upstream cistron in order to achieve their independent regulation.     

The nucleotide sequence of an Escherichia coli operon containing genes for the tRNA(m1G)methyltransferase, the ribosomal proteins S16 and L19 and a 21-K polypeptide.

The nucleotide sequence of a 4.6-kb SalI-EcoRI DNA fragment including the trmD operon, located at min 56 on the Escherichia coli K-12 chromosome, has been determined. The trmD operon encodes four polypeptides: ribosomal protein S16 (rpsP), 21-K polypeptide (unknown function), tRNA-(m1G)methyltransferase (trmD) and ribosomal protein L19 (rplS), in that order. In addition, the 4.6-kb DNA fragment encodes a 48-K and a 16-K polypeptide of unknown functions which are not part of the trmD operon. The mol. wt. of tRNA(m1G)methyltransferase determined from the DNA sequence is 28 424. The probable locations of promoter and terminator of the trmD operon are suggested. The translational start of the trmD gene was deduced from the known NH2-terminal amino acid sequence of the purified enzyme. The intercistronic regions in the operon vary from 9 to 40 nucleotides, supporting the earlier conclusion that the four genes are co-transcribed, starting at the major promoter in front of the rpsP gene. Since it is known that ribosomal proteins are present at 8000 molecules/genome and the tRNA-(m1G)methyltransferase at only approximately 80 molecules/genome in a glucose minimal culture, some powerful regulatory device must exist in this operon to maintain this non-coordinate expression. The codon usage of the two ribosomal protein genes is similar to that of other ribosomal protein genes, i.e., high preference for the most abundant tRNA isoaccepting species. The trmD gene has a codon usage typical for a protein made in low amount in accordance with the low number of tRNA-(m1G)methyltransferase molecules found in the cell.     

1-Methylguanosine deficiency of tRNA influences cognate codon interaction and metabolism in Salmonella typhimurium.

1-Methylguanosine (m1G) is present next to the 3' end of the anticodon (position 37) in tRNA(1,2,3,Leu), tRNA(1,2,3,Pro), and tRNA(3Arg). A mutant of Salmonella typhimurium lacks m1G in these seven tRNAs when grown at or above 37 degrees C, as a result of a mutation (trmD3) in the structural gene (trmD) for the tRNA(m1G37)methyltransferase. The m1G deficiency induced 24 and 26% reductions in the growth rate and polypeptide chain elongation rate, respectively, in morpholinepropanesulfonic acid (MOPS)-glucose minimal medium at 37 degrees C. The expression of the leuABCD operon is controlled by the rate with which tRNA(2Leu) and tRNA(3Leu) read four leucine codons in the leu-leader mRNA. Lack of m1G in these tRNAs did not influence the expression of this operon, suggesting that m1G did not influence the efficiency of tRNA(2,3Leu). Since the average step time of the m1G-deficient tRNAs was increased 3.3-fold, the results suggest that the impact of m1G in decoding cognate codons may be tRNA dependent. The trmD3 mutation rendered the cell more resistant or sensitive to several amino acid analogs. 3-Nitro-L-tyrosine (NT), to which the trmD3 mutant is sensitive, was shown to be transported by the tryptophan-specific permease, and mutations in this gene (mtr) render the cell resistant to NT. Since the trmD3 mutation did not affect the activity of the permease, some internal metabolic step(s), but not the uptake of the analog per se, is affected. We suggest that the trmD3-mediated NT sensitivity is by an abnormal translation of some mRNA(s) whose product(s) is involved in the metabolic reactions affected by the analog. Our results also suggest that tRNA modification may be a regulatory device for gene expression.     

Ligand-mediated anticodon conformational changes occur during tRNA methylation by a TrmD methyltransferase

Orthologs of TrmD, G37 tRNA methyltransferases, have been analyzed with regard to post-tRNA binding events required to move the residue G37 in proximity to bound AdoMet for catalysis. This was approached initially by probing tRNA with T2 nuclease or Pb acetate in the presence, then absence, of Escherichia coli TrmD protein. Cleavage patterns clearly show that portions of the anticodon loop phosphodiester backbone are protected from cleavage only in the presence of sinefungin, a potent AdoMet analogue. This demonstrates that there must be considerable movement of the loop region and/or protein as the AdoMet site is occupied. Florescence energy transfer experiments were employed to better assess the movement of the G37 and G36 base residues in response to occupancy of the AdoMet site. When the Streptococcus pneumoniae TrmD protein was bound to synthetic tRNA(1)(Leu) substituted with 2-aminopurine at positions 36 and 37, fluorescence energy transfer analysis showed that a decrease in 2-aminopurine fluorescence occurs only when AdoMet is present. Taken together, these results suggest that the base to be methylated by the TrmD protein is mobilized into the active center after tRNA binding only when the AdoMet site is occupied.     

Catalysis by the second class of tRNA(m1G37) methyl transferase requires a conserved proline

The enzyme tRNA(m1G37) methyl transferase catalyzes the transfer of a methyl group from S-adenosyl methionine (AdoMet) to the N1 position of G37, which is 3' to the anticodon sequence and whose modification is important for maintaining the reading frame fidelity. While the enzyme in bacteria is highly conserved and is encoded by the trmD gene, recent studies show that the counterpart of this enzyme in archaea and eukarya, encoded by the trm5 gene, is unrelated to trmD both in sequence and in structure. To further test this prediction, we seek to identify residues in the second class of tRNA(m1G37) methyl transferase that are required for catalysis. Such residues should provide mechanistic insights into the distinct structural origins of the two classes. Using the Trm5 enzyme of the archaeon Methanocaldococcus jannaschii (previously MJ0883) as an example, we have created mutants to test many conserved residues for their catalytic potential and substrate-binding capabilities with respect to both AdoMet and tRNA. We identified that the proline at position 267 (P267) is a critical residue for catalysis, because substitution of this residue severely decreases the kcat of the methylation reaction in steady-state kinetic analysis, and the k(chem) in single turnover kinetic analysis. However, substitution of P267 has milder effect on the Km and little effect on the Kd of either substrate. Because P267 has no functional side chain that can directly participate in the chemistry of methyl transfer, we suggest that its role in catalysis is to stabilize conformations of enzyme and substrates for proper alignment of reactive groups at the enzyme active site. Sequence analysis shows that P267 is embedded in a peptide motif that is conserved among the Trm5 family, but absent from the TrmD family, supporting the notion that the two families are descendants of unrelated protein structures.     

Control of Catalytic Cycle by a Pair of Analogous tRNA Modification Enzymes

Enzymes that use distinct active site structures to perform identical reactions are known as analogous enzymes. The isolation of analogous enzymes suggests the existence of multiple enzyme structural pathways that can catalyze the same chemical reaction. A fundamental question concerning analogous enzymes is whether their distinct active-site structures would confer the same or different kinetic constraints to the chemical reaction, particularly with respect to the control of enzyme turnover. Here, we address this question with the analogous enzymes of bacterial TrmD and its eukaryotic and archaeal counterpart Trm5. TrmD and Trm5 catalyze methyl transfer to synthesize the m1G37 base at the 3′ position adjacent to the tRNA anticodon, using S-adenosyl methionine (AdoMet) as the methyl donor. TrmD features a trefoil-knot active-site structure whereas Trm5 features the Rossmann fold. Pre-steady-state analysis revealed that product synthesis by TrmD proceeds linearly with time, whereas that by Trm5 exhibits a rapid burst followed by a slower and linear increase with time. The burst kinetics of Trm5 suggests that product release is the rate-limiting step of the catalytic cycle, consistent with the observation of higher enzyme affinity to the products of tRNA and AdoMet. In contrast, the lack of burst kinetics of TrmD suggests that its turnover is controlled by a step required for product synthesis. Although TrmD exists as a homodimer, it showed half-of-the-sites reactivity for tRNA binding and product synthesis. The kinetic differences between TrmD and Trm5 are parallel with those between the two classes of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, which use distinct active site structures to catalyze tRNA aminoacylation. This parallel suggests that the findings have a fundamental importance for enzymes that catalyze both methyl and aminoacyl transfer to tRNA in the decoding process.     

Insights into catalysis by a knotted TrmD tRNA methyltransferase

The crystal structure of Escherichia coli tRNA (guanosine-1) methyltransferase (TrmD) complexed with S-adenosyl homocysteine (AdoHcy) has been determined at 2.5A resolution. TrmD, which methylates G37 of tRNAs containing the sequence G36pG37, is a homo-dimer. Each monomer consists of a C-terminal domain connected by a flexible linker to an N-terminal AdoMet-binding domain. The two bound AdoHcy moieties are buried at the bottom of deep clefts. The dimer structure appears integral to the formation of the catalytic center of the enzyme and this arrangement strongly suggests that the anticodon loop of tRNA fits into one of these clefts for methyl transfer to occur. In addition, adjacent hydrophobic sites in the cleft delineate a defined pocket, which may accommodate the GpG sequence during catalysis. The dimer contains two deep trefoil peptide knots and a peptide loop extending from each knot embraces the AdoHcy adenine ring. Mutational analyses demonstrate that the knot is important for AdoMet binding and catalytic activity, and that the C-terminal domain is not only required for tRNA binding but plays a functional role in catalytic activity.     

Evidence that there are only two tRNA(Phe) genes in Escherichia coli.

pheV, one of the genes that code for tRNA(Phe), was deleted from the chromosome of a strain of Escherichia coli K-12. As a consequence of this mutation, expression of pheA, the gene for chorismate mutase P-prephenate dehydratase, the first enzyme in the terminal pathway of phenylalanine biosynthesis, was derepressed. Similar derepression of pheA has been reported in pheR mutants of E. coli K-12 (J. Gowrishankar and J. Pittard, J. Bacteriol. 150:1130-1137, 1982). Attempts to introduce a pheR mutation into the delta pheV strain failed under circumstances suggesting that this combination of mutations is lethal. Southern blot analysis of pheV+ and delta pheV strains indicated that there are only two tRNA(Phe) genes in E. coli. It is recommended that the names pheU and pheV be retained for these genes.     

Distinct determinants of tRNA recognition by the TrmD and Trm5 methyl transferases

TrmD and Trm5 are, respectively, the bacterial and eukarya/archaea methyl transferases that catalyze transfer of the methyl group from S-adenosyl methionine (AdoMet) to the N1 position of G37 in tRNA to synthesize m1G37-tRNA. The m1G37 modification prevents tRNA frameshifts on the ribosome by assuring correct codon-anticodon pairings, and thus is essential for the fidelity of protein synthesis. Although TrmD and Trm5 are derived from unrelated AdoMet families and recognize the cofactor using distinct motifs, the question of whether they select G37 on tRNA by the same, or different, mechanism has not been answered. Here we address this question by kinetic analysis of tRNA truncation mutants that lack domains typically present in the canonical L shaped structure, and by evaluation of the site of modification on tRNA variants with an expanded or contracted anticodon loop. With both experimental approaches, we show that TrmD and Trm5 exhibit separate and distinct mode of tRNA recognition, suggesting that they evolved by independent and non-overlapping pathways from their unrelated AdoMet families. Our results also shed new light onto the significance of the m1G37 modification in the controversial quadruplet-pairing model of tRNA frameshift suppressors.     

Over expression of a tRNA(Leu) isoacceptor changes charging pattern of leucine tRNAs and reveals new codon reading

During mRNA translation, synonymous codons for one amino acid are often read by different isoaccepting tRNAs. The theory of selective tRNA charging predicts greatly varying percentages of aminoacylation among isoacceptors in cells starved for their common amino acid. It also predicts major changes in tRNA charging patterns upon concentration changes of single isoacceptors, which suggests a novel type of translational control of gene expression. We therefore tested the theory by measuring with Northern blots the charging of Leu-tRNAs in Escherichia coli under Leu limitation in response to over expression of tRNA(GAG)(Leu). As predicted, the charged level of tRNA(GAG)(Leu) increased and the charged levels of four other Leu isoacceptors decreased or remained unchanged, but the charged level of tRNA(UAG)(Leu) increased unexpectedly. To remove this apparent inconsistency between theory and experiment we postulated a previously unknown common codon for tRNA(GAG)(Leu) and tRNA(UAG)(Leu). Subsequently, we demonstrated that the tRNA(GAG)(Leu) codon CUU is, in fact, read also by tRNA(UAG)(Leu), due to a uridine-5-oxyacetic acid modification.