Gene expression profiles of vitrified in vitro- and in vivo-derived bovine blastocysts

Vitrification is becoming a preferred method for pre‐implantation embryo cryopreservation. The objective of this study was to determine the differentially expressed genes of in vivo‐ and in vitro‐produced bovine embryos after vitrification. In vitro‐ (IVF) and in vivo‐derived (IVV) bovine blastocysts were identified as follows: in vitro‐produced fresh (IVF‐F), in vitro‐produced vitrified (IVF‐V), in vivo‐derived fresh (IVV‐F), in vivo‐derived vitrified (IVV‐V). The microarray results showed that 53 genes were differentially regulated between IVF and IVV, and 121 genes were differentially regulated between fresh and vitrified blastocysts (P < 0.05). There were 6, 268, 962, and 17 differentially regulated genes between IVF‐F × IVV‐F, IVF‐V × IVV‐V, IVF‐F × IVF‐V, and IVV‐F × IVV‐V, respectively (P < 0.05). While gene expression was significantly different between fresh and vitrified IVF blastocysts (P < 0.05), it was similar between fresh and vitrified IVV blastocysts. Significantly up‐regulated KEGG pathways included ribosome, oxidative phosphorylation, spliceosome, and oocyte meiosis in the fresh IVF blastocyst samples, while sphingolipid and purine metabolisms were up‐regulated in the vitrified IVF blastocyst. The results showed that in vitro bovine blastocyst production protocols used in this study caused no major gene expression differences compared to those of in vivo‐produced blastocysts. After vitrification, however, in vitro‐produced blastocysts showed major gene expression differences compared to in vivo blastocysts. This study suggests that in vitro‐produced embryos are of comparable quality to their in vivo counterparts. Vitrification of in vitro blastocysts, on the other hand, causes significant up‐regulation of genes that are involved in stress responses. Mol. Reprod. Dev. 79: 613–625, 2012. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Formation of extracellular and intracellular ice during warming of vitrified mouse morulae and its effect on embryo survival

In vitrified solutions, ice can form during warming if the concentration of the cryoprotectant is insufficient. For the cryopreservation of cells, ice is innocuous when it remains outside the cell, but intracellular ice (ICI) is lethal. We tried to estimate the conditions in which ICI forms in vitrified mouse morulae during warming. The solutions for the experiments (EFS10–EFS50) contained 10–50% ethylene glycol plus Ficoll plus sucrose. When vitrified EFS20, EFS30, and EFS40 were kept at −80 °C, they remained transparent after 3 min, but turned opaque after 60 min (EFS20, EFS30) or 24 h (EFS40). Morulae were vitrified with EFS solutions after exposure for 30–120 s at 25 °C. They were warmed by various methods and survival was assessed in culture. After rapid warming (control), survival was high with EFS30 (79–93%) and EFS40 (96–99%). After slow warming, survival decreased with both EFS30 (48–62%) and EFS40 (44–64%). This must be from the formation of ICI. To examine the temperature at which ICI formed during slow warming, vitrified embryos were kept at various sub-zero temperatures during warming. Survival with EFS30 and EFS40 decreased on keeping samples for 3 min at −80 (25–75%), −60 (7–49%), −40 (0–41%), or −20 °C (26–60%). When samples were kept at −80 °C for 24 h, the survival decreased to 0–14%. These results suggest that ICI forms at a wide range of temperatures including −80 and −20 °C, more likely between −60 and −40 °C, and the ice forms not only quickly but also slowly.     

Comparison of two methods for one-step in-straw thawing and direct transfer of cattle blastocysts

The aim of this experiment was to evaluate the feasibility of dilution of the cryoprotectant by a sucrose solution in the straw followed by direct transfer without any selection of the embryos. A comparison was made between the method described by Renard et al. (7) and a method slightly modified from that published by Leibo (8). The feasibility is proved by a mean pregnancy rate of 41.4%. Although the difference was not statistically significant, the method described by Renard et al. (7) led to a higher pregnancy rate (44.7%) than that of Leibo (8) (38.5%).     

Binucleate cells in mouse morulae

Summary Mouse morulae from two strains were examined in whole mounts after dissociation of embryos into single cells and were analysed in serial sections by light and electron microscopy. One or two binucleate cells per embryo were discovered in a statistically significant number of morulae. The frequency of morulae with binucleate cell(s) was higher in older morulae than in younger ones. Binucleate cells were always the outer cells of the embryo. Their ultrastructure did not differ from the ultrastructure of mononucleate cells. It is suggested that cell binuclearity at the morula stage is a possible way to polyploidization of nuclei, resulting in the formation of primary trophoblast giant cells.     

Superovulation of rabbits with FSH alters in vivo development of vitrified morulae

Morulae were flushed from the oviducts and uteri of New Zealand White (NZW) rabbits superovulated with either 6 (3 d) or 8 (4 d) injections of FSH and from non-superovulated controls. The percentages of embryos recovered from 4 d (100%, n = 8) donors was significantly higher (P < 0.01) than that of 3 d (76%, n = 16) and control (87%, n = 22) donors. Overall, fertilization rates were significantly lower for the 3 d embryos (P < 0.01). Most (86 to 90%) morulae were morphologically suitable for vitrification in an ethylene glycol-based solution. Following storage in liquid nitrogen, morulae were rapidly thawed and transferred to the uteri of pseudopregnant recipients. The total number of kits born for the 3 d, 4 d, and control groups was 40, 61 and 48, respectively. The percentage of live kits from morulae transferred was significantly lower for the 3 d (20%, n = 201) than either the 4 d (36%, n = 169; P < 0.01) or the control (31%, n = 157; P < 0.05) group. The mean number of kits born/recipient for the 3 d (2.4 +/- 2.9), 4 d (4.7 +/- 3.5), and control (3.0 +/- 2.2) protocols did not differ (P > 0.05). The estimated overall efficiency of producing kits based on normal morulae collected for control and 4 d groups, however, was nearly two-fold that for females given 6 FSH treatments. We conclude that the 4 d FSH superovulation regimen enhances the efficiency of rabbit reproductive biotechnology after embryo cryopreservation. These findings have important implications for rabbit colony management using embryo cryopreservation.     

Survival of mouse morulae vitrified in an ethylene glycol-based solution after exposure to the solution at various temperatures.

Mouse morulae were exposed in one step to a vitrification solution (EFS, a modified PBS containing 40% ethylene glycol, 18% Ficoll, and 0.3-M sucrose) at various temperatures, then cooled rapidly in liquid nitrogen, and then warmed rapidly. All of the embryos exposed to the EFS solution for 0.5 min at 25 degrees C before vitrification developed in culture. However, survival rates were lower if the duration of exposure was prolonged to 2, 5, or 10 min. At lower ambient temperatures (20, 10, and 5 degrees C), high survival rates were associated with longer exposure to the EFS solution. The toxicity of the EFS solution was also lower at lower temperatures. The toxic injury of morulae was manifested as decompaction of the blastomeres. Among the three additives in the EFS solution, ethylene glycol, which can cross cell membranes, was responsible for the toxicity. The results show that the optimum time for exposure of the embryos to the EFS solution before rapid cooling varies with the ambient temperature, i.e., 0.5 min at 25 degrees C, 0.5-5 min at 20 degrees C, 2-5 min at 10 degrees C, and 2-10 min at 5 degrees C. If they are exposed for an optimum period, almost all mouse morulae can survive vitrification (94-100%).     

Channel-dependent permeation of water and glycerol in mouse morulae

The cryosensitivity of mammalian embryos depends on the stage of development. Because permeability to water and cryoprotectants plays an important role in cryopreservation, it is plausible that the permeability is involved in the difference in the tolerance to cryopreservation among embryos at different developmental stages. In this study, we examined the permeability to water and glycerol of mouse oocytes and embryos, and tried to deduce the pathway for the movement of water and glycerol. The water permeability (L(P), microm min(-1) atm(-1)) of oocytes and four-cell embryos at 25 degrees C was low (0.63-0.70) and its Arrhenius activation energy (E(a), kcal/mol) was high (11.6-12.3), which implies that the water permeates through the plasma membrane by simple diffusion. On the other hand, the L(p) of morulae and blastocysts was quite high (3.6-4.5) and its E(a) was quite low (5.1-6.3), which implies that the water moves through water channels. Aquaporin inhibitors, phloretin and p-(chloromercuri) benzene-sulfonate, reduced the L(p) of morulae significantly but not that of oocytes. By immunocytochemical analysis, aquaporin 3, which transports not only water but also glycerol, was detected in the morulae but not in the oocytes. Accordingly, the glycerol permeability (P(GLY), x 10(-3) cm/min) of oocytes was also low (0.01) and its E(a) was remarkably high (41.6), whereas P(GLY) of morulae was quite high (4.63) and its E(a) was low (10.0). Aquaporin inhibitors reduced the P(GLY) of morulae significantly. In conclusion, water and glycerol appear to move across the plasma membrane mainly by simple diffusion in oocytes but by facilitated diffusion through water channel(s) including aquaporin 3 in morulae.     

Effect of equilibration period on the viability of frozen-thawed mouse morulae after rapid freezing

Mouse morulae were frozen with 1.5-4.0 M glycerol + 0.25 M lactose solution by direct plunging into liquid nitrogen vapor 0.5-30 min after equilibration at room temperature. After thawing, embryos were cultured in vitro, and the highest survival rates were obtained after exposure for 3 min at 3.0 and 4.0 M and for 5 min at 1.5 and 2.0 M glycerol levels. Significant reductions in the survival rates (P less than 0.05) were observed when equilibration periods were extended for 3-5 min at 3.0 and 4.0 M and for 5-10 min at 1.5 and 2.0 M glycerol levels. These results clearly demonstrate that the equilibration time of embryos in glycerol-lactose mixture is one of the most important factors in the present rapid freezing conditions. To clarify the factors that lower embryo viability after prolonged equilibration, we performed further experiments on the effects of exposure to glycerol-lactose mixture on the developmental potential of embryos without freezing and on the volume changes of embryos during the exposure to glycerol solution with or without lactose. It was suggested that the detrimental effects of prolonged equilibration are due not only to the toxicity and osmotic injury of higher concentrations of cryoprotectant solution but also to the influx of water into embryonic cells caused by the hypotonic salt concentration of the extracellular (freezing) solution.     

Successful production of piglets derived from vitrified morulae and early blastocysts using a microdroplet method

This study was conducted to determine the efficiency of vitrification using the microdroplet (MD) method for early stage porcine embryos. Embryos at compacted morulae to early blastocyst stage were vitrified in a vitrification solution containing 40% (v/v) ethylene glycol, 0.6M sucrose and 2% (w/v) polyethylene glycol in M2 (ESP) without any pretreatment. The equilibration and dilution were carried out in third and fourth steps, respectively, at 38 degrees C. The survivability of the cryopreserved embryos was assessed for both in vitro culture (Experiment 1) and by embryo transfer (Experiment 2). In Experiment 1, the embryos were vitrified within a microdroplet or 0.25 ml straw (ST) and fresh embryos were used as a control group. The survival rates after 24h culture in the MD, ST and control groups were 21/23, 14/20 and 20/20, respectively. The hatching rates of the embryos after 48 h incubation were 14/23, 4/20 and 16/20, respectively. In Experiment 2, 171 vitrified embryos were transferred to 5 recipient gilts, and 17 healthy piglets were produced from 2 recipients (3 recipients aborted) in Group 1. In Group 2, 81 vitrified embryos and 16 fresh embryos in total were transferred to 4 recipient gilts, and 10 healthy piglets from the vitrified embryos were produced from 3 recipients. These results indicated that porcine embryos of compacted morulae to early blastocyst stage can survive cryopreservation using the microdroplet method without any special intracellular manipulation or treatment.     

Reassortment of cells according to position in mouse morulae

Sixteen-cell mouse morulae were disaggregated and blastomeres originally occupying outer or inner positions were separated. Outer, inner, or unsorted populations of blastomeres were labeled with either trinitrobenzene sulphonic acid (TNP) or fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) and individual blastomeres aggregated to unlabelled partially decompact eight- to ten-cell morulae. After up to 6 h in culture, the positions of the labelled blastomeres within the aggregates were examined. The combined results demonstrated that between 86 and 92% of outer cells remained on the surface of the aggregate and flattened into extensive polygonal shapes, whereas 76-77% of the inner cells had become engulfed by the host morula cells and retained their initial spherical shape. Using unsorted cells, 33-37% were internalised, which is compatible with the most recent estimates of the presence of six to eight inner cells at the 16-cell stage. The possibility that differential adhesiveness of the outer and inner cells is involved in the allocation of cells to the trophectoderm and inner cell mass of the blastocyst is discussed.     

Conversion of pregnenolone to progesterone by mouse morulae and blastocysts

When mouse morulae, early blastocysts and implanting blastocysts were cultured with tritiated pregnenolone, tritiated progesterone and its metabolites, 5 alpha-pregnan-3,20-dione and 3 alpha-hydroxy-5 alpha-pregnan-20-one, were isolated from the medium. It appears that mouse embryos can make progesterone from pregnenolone and the progesterone is quickly metabolized into various metabolites. These abilities increase with development. It is suggested that the mouse embryo can make progesterone and may regulate its own progesterone level for optimal development.     

Production of monozygotic mouse twins from microsurgically bisected morulae

Mouse monozygotic twins were produced by bisection of the compacted morulae and transfer of the pairs of half-embryos after culture in vitro. The compacted morulae (about 16 cells) were microsurgically bisected, using a fine glass needle attached to a micromanipulator, without any supporting micro-instruments, after pretreatment for zona-softening and decompaction. About 80% of the morulae were bisected without visible cell damage. After 20 h in culture, the half-embryos were classified morphologically as eu-blastocysts, pseudo-blastocysts, or trophectodermal vesicles or non-integrated forms. After culture of 131 pairs of bisected morulae, 75 (57.3%) pairs of eu-blastocysts, 20 (15.3%) pairs comprising a eu-blastocyst and pseudo-blastocyst, and 9 (6.9%) pairs of pseudo-blastocysts, were obtained. The pseudo-blastocysts were considered to be derived from half-morulae in which some blastomeres were destroyed or dissociated as a result of micromanipulation. From 30 pairs of eu-blastocysts transferred to 21 recipients, 5 twin fetuses on Day 17 (18 pairs/9 recipients) and 3 twin male young (12 pairs/12 recipients) were obtained. Survival rate of the twin-embryo pairs was 27.8% at autopsy and 25.0% at term. None of the 20 pairs of pseudo-blastocysts transferred to 10 recipients gave rise to normal conceptuses.     

Spatial distribution of blastomeres is dependent on cell division order and interactions in mouse morulae

Spatial distribution of blastomeres was examined in 16- to 30-cell morulae obtained from aggregates of 1/2----1/2 and 1/2----2/4 blastomeres. The advanced blastomeres (2/4) contributed disproportionately more inner cells while there was a corresponding decline in the contribution from the delayed blastomere (1/2) so that a balance between the total number of inner and outer cells was retained. There was, however, no marked change in the relative number of outer cells. It is suggested that once formed, the inner more adhesive cells divide relatively faster than the outer cells whose behaviour is dictated by the inner cells. The outer less adhesive cells spread over the inner cells; cell spreading is incompatible with division. The degree to which cell spreading and retardation of division of outer cells occurs may be dictated by the number of inner cells present at any one time and this partly determines the entry of further cells inside. The suggested mechanism for cell allocation is highly flexible and, indeed, essential to encompass the wide variety of patterns of cell interactions and distribution observed in morulae. It is also proposed that the retardation of division of outer cells may trigger differentiation of trophectoderm by inducing endoreduplication and the blastomeres delayed from dividing for the longest period of time may mark down the abembryonic pole and establish the embryonic-abembryonic axis.     

The type and extent of injuries in vitrified mouse oocytes

To improve the vitrification of mouse oocytes using straws, we attempted to estimate the type and extent of injuries during vitrification with a vitrification solution EAFS10/10. Injuries in oocytes were assessed based on cellular viability, the integrity of the plasma membrane, the status of the meiotic spindle/chromosomes, and morphological appearance. For morphologically normal oocytes, the ability to be fertilized and to develop into blastocysts was examined. Morphological assessment revealed 15% of oocytes to be injured by intracellular ice formed during vitrification, and 10% by osmotic swelling during removal of the cryoprotectant. When assessed by the status of spindles/chromosomes, the most sensitive criterion, damage was found in 16% of oocytes without any treatment. This value was similar to the proportion of fresh oocytes that did not cleave after insemination (13%). On exposure to EAFS10/10, the spindles/chromosomes were affected in 33% of oocytes. The exposure reduced the rate of cleavage by 18% points and the rate of development into blastocysts by 19 points. Vitrification reduced these rates by 15% and 36% points, respectively. Although the mechanism responsible for this moderate toxic effect on developmental ability is not known, information obtained in the present study will be useful to develop a practical method for the vitrification of mouse oocytes using straws.     

Effect of warming rate on the survival of vitrified mouse oocytes and on the recrystallization of intracellular ice

Successful cryopreservation demands there be little or no intracellular ice. One procedure is classical slow equilibrium freezing, and it has been successful in many cases. However, for some important cell types, including some mammalian oocytes, it has not. For the latter, there are increasing attempts to cryopreserve them by vitrification. However, even if intracellular ice formation (IIF) is prevented during cooling, it can still occur during the warming of a vitrified sample. Here, we examine two aspects of this occurrence in mouse oocytes. One took place in oocytes that were partly dehydrated by an initial hold for 12 min at -25 degrees C. They were then cooled rapidly to -70 degrees C and warmed slowly, or they were warmed rapidly to intermediate temperatures and held. These oocytes underwent no IIF during cooling but blackened from IIF during warming. The blackening rate increased about 5-fold for each five-degree rise in temperature. Upon thawing, they were dead. The second aspect involved oocytes that had been vitrified by cooling to -196 degrees C while suspended in a concentrated solution of cryoprotectants and warmed at rates ranging from 140 degrees C/min to 3300 degrees C/min. Survivals after warming at 140 degrees C/min and 250 degrees C/min were low (<30%). Survivals after warming at > or =2200 degrees C/min were high (80%). When warmed slowly, they were killed, apparently by the recrystallization of previously formed small internal ice crystals. The similarities and differences in the consequences of the two types of freezing are discussed.     

Reduced survival in utero from transferred mouse blastocysts compared with morulae

Studies on the survival of mouse embryos revealed that fewer offspring were produced when blastocysts, rather than morulae, were transferred to foster mothers. Approximately 8–10 h after fertilization F1 hybrid eggs (C57BL/6J × LT/Sv) were collected and cultured to morulae (day 4) or blastocysts (day 5 ) before transfer into uteri of day 3 foster mothers. A few recipients were killed on day 8 of gestation and deciduae were examined histologically. Embryos developing from transferred morulae were found to lie deep within the deciduae and were surrounded by numerous, large blood islands. Conversely, embryos developing from transferred blastocysts implanted more distally to the maternal blood vessels with only a few blood islands surrounding the embryos. These observations, suggesting abnormal implantation with insufficient embyro nourishment, were confirmed when uteri of foster mothers were examined on day 19 of gestation. Although the proportion of implantations from transferred morulae or blastocysts was similar (42 % and 47%, respectively), significantly more of the implantations were resorbed after transfer of blastocysts (78%) as compared with morulae (15%). These results demonstrate that transfer of day 5 cultured blastocysts into uteri of foster mothers increases embryonic mortality as a consequence of improper implantation.     

Development of vitrified mouse oocytes after in vitro fertilization

Mouse oocytes were cryopreserved by the vitrification method using vitrification solution (VSI) and the effects of dilution methods were examined on the rate of in vitro and in vivo development. Eighty-three percent and 75% of vitrified oocytes exhibited normal morphology when diluted in glycerol + sucrose and sucrose alone, respectively. In contrast, only 35% of the oocytes diluted by a stepwise method exhibited a normal appearance. A high proportion of vitrified oocytes was fertilized in vitro (84-94%), 80 to 87% of which were normal. Of the later embryos, 69 to 78% developed to blastocysts after 4 days of culture. Thirty-six live young (51%) were obtained when vitrified oocytes were transferred to recipient females. The overall rate of development to live young was 25% when vitrified oocytes were diluted with glycerol + sucrose solution. These results indicate that the simple and rapid procedure of vitrification and glycerol + sucrose dilution is suitable for the cryopreservation of mouse oocytes.