Characterization of lysosomal monoiodotyrosine transport in rat thyroid cells. Evidence for transport by system h

Lysosomal transport of monoiodotyrosine was characterized in countertransport experiments using rat FRTL-5 thyroid cell lysosomes. Monoiodotyrosine carrier activity was temperature-dependent (Ea = 11.65 kcal/mol) and had a pH optimum of 7.5. Carrier activity was minimally inhibited by KCl and NaCl, but unaffected by the presence of other ions or ATP. Monoiodotyrosine transport was unaffected by the presence of carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone, nigericin, or ammonium chloride, indicating that a proton or K+ gradient is not necessary for monoiodotyrosine transport across the lysosomal membrane. Monoiodotyrosine countertransport showed a 6-fold increase in lysosomes from FRTL-5 cells grown in medium containing thyrotropin by comparison to cells grown without this hormone. Thyrotropin responsiveness raised the possibility that monoiodotyrosine was transported by system h, the only known lysosomal carrier whose activity is enhanced by thyrotropin. Consistent with this, monoiodotyrosine-loaded lysosomes exhibited countertransport of [3H]tyrosine, [3H]phenylalanine, and [3H]leucine, three system h ligands, but not [3H]cystine, a nonsystem h ligand. Unlabeled tyrosine, phenylalanine, and leucine, but not cystine or proline, inhibited [125I]monoiodotyrosine countertransport, and leucine inhibition of [3H]tyrosine countertransport and [125I]monoiodotyrosine countertransport yielded virtually identical KI values, 3.5 and 3.2 microM, respectively. Competition studies with monoiodotyrosine analogues showed that system h recognizes a broad range of ligands with an alpha-amino acid configuration at one end and a hydrophobic region at the other. Ring-substituted halogens, regardless of mass or ring position, but not amino, nitro, hydroxy, or methoxy groups, enhanced carrier recognition of system h analogues. It appears that a single system effects the transport of iodinated (e.g. monoiodotyrosine) and noniodinated (e.g. tyrosine) thyroglobulin catabolites into the cytosol for salvage and reutilization by FRTL-5 thyroid cells.     

Na+ -dependent proline transport in isolated membrane vesicles from the L6 muscle cell line. Stimulation of uptake by intravesicular proline

Membrane vesicles of L6 myoblasts were prepared in order to study the amino acid transport system A. The role of the membrane in the adaptive response of transport to amino acid-supplementation was assessed. The membranes, prepared by N2 cavitation, displayed Na+ (but not K+)-dependent L-proline uptake. An overshoot of L-[3H]proline uptake was observed after exposure of the vesicles to an inward Na+ gradient. Isolated membrane vesicles loaded with 50 microM proline displayed countertransport (stimulation of proline uptake). It is concluded that the adaptive decrease of proline uptake observed in amino acid-supplemented cells cannot be accounted for by trans-inhibition of transport.     

Neutral amino acid transport in Leishmania promastigotes

Neutral amino acid transport was investigated in Leishmania promastigotes. Proline and alanine transport occur against their concentration gradient although there is a very rapid (40% at 30 min) conversion of proline to alanine. Uptake of these amino acids occurs by a sodium-independent route which is completely eliminated by addition of CCCP or KCN. $\text{K}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>m</mtext>}}$ values for proline and alanine are 80 μM and 63 μM with $\text{V}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>max</mtext>}}$ values of 6.4 and 7.2 nmol/min per mg dry weight, respectively. Countertransport of proline, alanine and phenylalanine was measured by loading the cells with a variety of neutral amino acids and proline analogs, followed by CCCP addition. The effect of aminooxyacetic acid, an inhibitor of alanine aminotransferase (EC 2.6.1.2), on proline and alanine countertransport was also examined. The results obtained are consistent with the presence of at least two systems for neutral amino acid transport in Leishmania promastigotes.     

Erythrocyte Lii-Nao countertransport system. Inhibition by N-ethylmaleimide probes for a conformational change of the transport system

Human erythrocytes were treated by a series of SH-reagents, including maleimides, iodo compounds, mercurials and oxidizing agents. Rates of Li efflux into Na-rich medium, Li leak and Lii-Nao countertransport were then determined. Of the 13 different reagents studied, only N-ethylmaleimide, iodoacetamide and iodoacetate inhibited selectively the countertransport activity. The effect of the various reagents indicates that the sensitive SH-groups of the countertransport system are not externally exposed. N-Ethylmaleimide was used to probe for changes elicited by substrate cations in Lii-Nao countertransport. In Na- and Li-free medium, inhibition of Lii-Nao countertransport by N-ethylmaleimide of 35% was reached within 2 s. In Na or Li medium, maximal inhibition was twice as great, but was attained much more slowly, within 10 min. Kinetic data and Hill plot analysis indicate the involvement of two classes of SH-groups: one expressed in the various media with and without substrate cations, and an additional one, which becomes specifically available to N-ethylmaleimide in the presence of external Na or Li. The affinity of Na to the site promoting inhibition by N-ethylmaleimide (apparent Km = 12 mM) is higher than the affinity of Na to its external countertransport site (apparent Km = 25 mM, as reported by Sarakadi, B., Alifimoff, J.K., Gunn, R.B. and Tosteson, D.C. (1978) J. Gen. Physiol. 72, 249-265). Reactivity of N-ethyl[14C]maleimide was not modified by the media tested. It is concluded that external Na and Li cause a conformational change in the protein(s) of the countertransport system in human erythrocytes.     

Erythrocyte Lii-Nao countertransport system Inhibition by N-ethylmaleimide probes for a conformational change of the transport system

Human erythrocytes were treated by a series of SH-reagents, including maleimides, iodo compounds, mercurials and oxidizing agents. Rates of Li efflux into Na-rich medium, Li leak and Li_i-Na_o countertransport were then determined. Of the 13 different reagents studied, only N-ethylmaleimide, iodoacetamide and iodoacetate inhibited selectively the countertransport activity. The effect of the various reagents indicates that the sensitive SH-groups of the countertransport system are not externally exposed. N-Ethylmaleimide was used to probe for changes elicited by substrate cations in Li_i-Na_o countertransport. In Na- and Li-free medium, inhibition of Li_i-Na_o countertransport by N-ethylmaleimide of 35% was reached within 2 s. In Na or Li medium, maximal inhibition was twice as great, but was attained much more slowly, within 10 min. Kinetic data and Hill plot analysis indicate the involvement of two classes of SH-groups: one expressed in the various media with and without substrate cations, and an additional one, which becomes specifically available to N-ethylmaleimide in the presence of external Na or Li. The affinity of Na to the site promoting inhibition by N-ethylmaleimide (apparent K_m  12 mM) is higher than the affinity of Na to its external countertransport site (apparent K_m  25 mM), as reported by Sarakadi, B., Alifimoff, J.K., Gunn, R.B. and Tosteson, D.C. (1978) J. Gen. Physiol. 72, 249–265). Reactivity of $\text{N-}\text{ethyl}\text{[}{}^{14}\text{C}\text{]}\text{maleimide}$ was not modified by the media tested. It is concluded that external Na and Li cause a conformational change in the protein(s) of the countertransport system in human erythrocytes.     

Intracellular sodium concentration and transport in red cells in essential hypertension, hyperthyroidism, pregnancy and hypokalemia

Intracellular sodium content ([Nai]), ouabain-sensitive ('Na-K ATPase') and ouabain-insensitive ('passive permeability') sodium efflux, Na-K cotransport and Na-Li ('Na-Na') countertransport were estimated in erythrocytes in 39 control subjects, 20 patients with essential hypertension, 14 patients with hypokalemia of renal or unknown etiology, 13 hyperthyroid patients and 19 pregnant women. In normokalemic essential hypertension there was only a moderate, but significant elevation of the activity of the Na-Li countertransport system. In the group of patients with hypokalemia, there was a significant increase of [Nai], ouabain-insensitive sodium efflux and Na-Li countertransport. In hyperthyroidism, a marked decrease of Na-Li countertransport was associated with a marked elevation of [Nai], in pregnancy an elevation of the Na-Li countertransport with a [Nai] 43% lower than the control values. The ouabain-sensitive sodium efflux was elevated in hyperthyroidism and hypokalemia, in which [Nai] was increased. In the control subjects there was a positive linear correlation between ouabain-sensitive sodium efflux and [Nai]. The sodium component of the Na-K cotransport was decreased to about one third of the unchanged furosemide-sensitive potassium component during pregnancy. Conclusions: The changes of cellular sodium metabolism in essential hypertension are of minor degree as compared to those in the other conditions studied. Cellular sodium metabolism in blood cells is influenced by thyroid hormones and metabolic disorders. Na-Li countertransport, i.e. Na-Na countertransport, seems to be involved in the regulation of [Nai]: an increase of its activity diminishes [Nai] (pregnancy); a decrease elevates [Nai] (hyperthyroidism). Ouabain-sensitive sodium efflux, i.e. 'Na-K ATPase', is mainly regulated by its substrate, [Nai].     

Characteristics of a lysosomal membrane transport system for tyrosine and other neutral amino acids in rat thyroid cells

Tyrosine countertransport was used to demonstrate the existence of a carrier system for neutral amino acids in the lysosomal membrane of FRTL-5 thyroid cells. In addition to tyrosine, the carrier system recognized the neutral amino acids leucine, histidine, phenylalanine, and tryptophan. Cystine and lysine, amino acids for which a lysosomal carrier system has been demonstrated, showed no competition with tyrosine for countertransport. The tyrosine system showed stereospecificity and cation independence. It did not require an acidic lysosome or the availability of free thiols. The apparent Km for tyrosine was approximately 100 microM; the energy of activation of the system was approximately 9.7 kcal/mol. This new lysosomal membrane carrier system for neutral amino acids resembles the plasma membrane L system in 3T3 Chinese hamster ovary cells and melanoma B-16 cells.     

Mechanism of proline transport in Escherichia coli K12. I. Effect of a membrane potential on the kinetics of 2H+/proline symport in cytoplasmic membrane vesicles

The stoichiometric coupling mechanism of the membrane potential (delta psi) in the reaction of H+/proline symport was investigated kinetically, using cytoplasmic membrane vesicles of the proline carrier-overproducing strain of Escherichia coli MinS/ pLC4 -45. When a delta psi was imposed across the cytoplasmic membrane by respiration, the Michaelis constant of transport (Kt) was lowered to about 1 microM, which was 2 orders of magnitude smaller than that of passive influx and efflux, and the maximum velocity (Vmax) was concomitantly enhanced as an exponential function of delta psi. Thermodynamically, the carrier translocated proline with a stoichiometry of 2 mol of protons versus 1 mol of substrate when driven by a delta psi at pH 8.0. Data on the delta psi dependence of Vmax of proline transport could be explained quantitatively by the Geck-Heinz hypothesis (Geck, P., and Heinz, E. (1976) Biochim, Biophys. Acta 443, 49-63). A symmetrical model of the 2H+/proline symport via formation of a carrier/H+/substrate (CH+H+S) intermediate is proposed. In this model, the effect of delta psi on the Kt was resolved as stimulation of formation of a transport intermediate, whereas the effect of delta psi on the Vmax was explained by enhancement of translocation of loaded carriers between the two sides of the membrane.     

A novel type of coupling between proline and galactoside transport in Escherichia coli.

Exit of thiomethylgalactoside (TMG) from preloaded cells induced the accumulation of proline. Likewise, proline exit stimulated TMG accumulation. Since a proton ionophore (carbonylcyanide-m-chlorophenylhydrazone) abolished these effects, a protonmotive force was implicated as the "intermediate" in the coupling reaction. The evidence suggests that the exit of TMG resulted in proton exit, which produced either a membrane potential (inside negative or a pH gradient (outside acid) or both. This inwardly directed protonmotive force provided the energy for proline entry and accumulation. Thus the energy coupling was not via a common transport protein but by proton movements which coupled the two separate H+-dependent transport processes.     

Energetics of alanine, lysine, and proline transport in cytoplasmic membranes of the polyphosphate-accumulating Acinetobacter johnsonii strain 210A.

Amino acid transport in right-side-out membrane vesicles of Acinetobacter johnsonii 210A was studied. L-Alanine, L-lysine, and L-proline were actively transported when a proton motive force of -76 mV was generated by the oxidation of glucose via the membrane-bound glucose dehydrogenase. Kinetic analysis of amino acid uptake at concentrations of up to 80 microM revealed the presence of a single transport system for each of these amino acids with a Kt of less than 4 microM. The mode of energy coupling to solute uptake was analyzed by imposition of artificial ion diffusion gradients. The uptake of alanine and lysine was driven by a membrane potential and a transmembrane pH gradient. In contrast, the uptake of proline was driven by a membrane potential and a transmembrane chemical gradient of sodium ions. The mechanistic stoichiometry for the solute and the coupling ion was close to unity for all three amino acids. The Na+ dependence of the proline carrier was studied in greater detail. Membrane potential-driven uptake of proline was stimulated by Na+, with a half-maximal Na+ concentration of 26 microM. At Na+ concentrations above 250 microM, proline uptake was strongly inhibited. Generation of a sodium motive force and maintenance of a low internal Na+ concentration are most likely mediated by a sodium/proton antiporter, the presence of which was suggested by the Na(+)-dependent alkalinization of the intravesicular pH in inside-out membrane vesicles. The results show that both H+ and Na+ can function as coupling ions in amino acid transport in Acinetobacter spp.     

Proline transport in Staphylococcus aureus: a high-affinity system and a low-affinity system involved in osmoregulation.

L-Proline enhanced the growth of Staphylococcus aureus in high-osmotic-strength medium, i.e., it acted as an osmoprotectant. Study of the kinetics of L-[14C]proline uptake by S. aureus NCTC 8325 revealed high-affinity (Km = 1.7 microM; maximum rate of transport [Vmax] = 1.1 nmol/min/mg [dry weight]) and low-affinity (Km = 132 microM; Vmax = 22 nmol/min/mg [dry weight]) transport systems. Both systems were present in a proline prototrophic variant grown in the absence of proline, although the Vmax of the high-affinity system was three to five times higher than that of the high-affinity system in strain 8325. Both systems were dependent on Na+ for activity, and the high-affinity system was stimulated by lower concentrations of Na+ more than the low-affinity system. The proline transport activity of the low-affinity system was stimulated by increased osmotic strength. The high-affinity system was highly specific for L-proline, whereas the low-affinity system showed a broader substrate specificity. Glycine betaine did not compete with proline for uptake through either system. Inhibitor studies confirmed that proline uptake occurred via Na(+)-dependent systems and suggested the involvement of the proton motive force in creating an Na+ gradient. Hyperosmotic stress (upshock) of growing cultures led to a rapid and large uptake of L-[14C]proline that was not dependent on new protein synthesis. It is suggested that the low-affinity system is involved in adjusting to increased environmental osmolarity and that the high-affinity system may be involved in scavenging low concentrations of proline.     

Thyrotropin stimulation of lysosomal tyrosine transport in rat FRTL-5 thyroid cells

Tyrosine countertransport was used to demonstrate the hormonal stimulation of neutral amino acid transport across the lysosomal membrane of FRTL-5 cells. Cells grown with thyrotropin (1 X 10(-10) M) had 7-fold (+/- S.E.) higher tyrosine countertransport activity in their lysosomes than cells grown without thyrotropin. Thyrotropin also stimulated the uptake into tyrosine-loaded lysosomes of other neutral amino acids recognized by the tyrosine carrier, namely, phenylalanine (3-fold) and leucine (6-fold). In contrast lysosomal cystine countertransport was not affected by thyrotropin. Addition of thyrotropin to cells grown without thyrotropin showed that the stimulation of tyrosine counter-transport (a) required at least 48 h to reach the level of the thyrotropin-supplemented cells, (b) depended upon protein synthesis, since cycloheximide (20 microM) was inhibitory, and (c) depended upon RNA synthesis, since actinomycin D (1 nM) was inhibitory. Cells grown without thyrotropin but with dibutyryl cyclic AMP (1 mM) or cholera toxin (1 nM) exhibited enhanced lysosomal countertransport of tyrosine, suggesting that cyclic AMP may act as a messenger. This represents the first demonstration of hormonal responsiveness in a lysosomal transport system and may reflect the importance of salvage and reutilization of lysosomal degradation products for the thyroid epithelial cell.     

Stimulatory effect of lithium ion on proline transport by whole cells of Escherichia coli.

The effect of monovalent cations on proline transport in whole cells of Escherichia coli K-12 has been examined. Lithium ion added to the uptake medium stimulated proline transport severalfold and K+ and Na+ were slightly effective, whereas Rb+, Cs+, and NH4+ were completely without effect. The stimulatory effect of Li+ on proline transport was not due to an increase in osmolarity of the uptake medium, and d 5 mM p-chloromercuribenzene sulfonic acid completely blocked this effect of Li+ without having any effect on the basal rate of proline transport. The Arrhenius plots for Li+-stimulated transport showed a clear transition point at 35 degrees C in addition to 20 degrees C which was also detectable in the basal transport. Lithium ion stimulated proline transport synergistically in the presence of glucose and succinate as a carbon source. The addition of 2.5 mM KCN or 0.5 mM arsenate did not inhibit this synergistic effect, although the presence of these inhibitors inhibited completely the stimulation of proline transport induced by the addition of carbon source. Carbonylcyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone and 2,4-dinitrophenol blocked both the basal and Li+-stimulated proline transport. When membrane potential of E. coli cells was measured by the dibenzyldimethylammonium uptake method, the incubation of Li+ with the cells did not affect the preexisting membrane potential. These results suggest that Li+ stimulates proline transport by intact cells of E. coli in a manner somewhat affecting membrane component(s) different from the transport carrier of proline. It is uncertain whether the effect of Li+ is directly involved in the mechanisms of energy coupling of proline transport.     

Effect of phospholipase A on active transport of amino acids with membrane vesicles of Mycobacterium phlei.

Active transport of proline remained unaffected in phospholipase A-treated electron transport particles from Mycobacterium phlei. However, the steady state level of proline was reduced 50 to 60% in phospholipase A-treated depleted electron transport particles that were devoid of membrane-bound coupling factor-latent ATPase activity. The decrease in the uptake of proline in the phospholipase A-treated depleted electron transport particles was not due to a change in the apparent K-m for proline, but it was related to the amount of phospholipid cleaved from the membranes. Restoration in the level of proline transport in phospholipase A-treated depleted electron transport particles was achieved by reconstituting these vesicles with diphosphatidylglycerol and phosphatidylethanolamine liposomes. Diphosphatidylglycerol was found to be most effective in the restoration of proline uptake. In contrast to the effect of phospholipase A treatment on proline transport, similar treatement of the electron transport particles or depleted electron transport particles failed to inhibit the active transport of either glutamine or glutamic acid. Studies with phospholipase A-treated membrane vesicles confirmed earlier findings that a proton gradient is not required for active transport of amino acids.     

Ordered binding model as a general mechanistic mechanism for secondary active transport systems.

The mechanistic mechanism of secondary active transport processes has not been fully elucidated. Based on substrate binding studies dependent on coupling cation concentrations of the glutamate, melibiose, lactose and proline transport carriers in Escherichia coli, the ordered binding mechanism was proposed as the energy coupling mechanism of the transport systems. This ordered binding mechanism satisfactorily explained the properties of the secondary active transport systems. Thus, this mechanism as the general energy coupling mechanism for the transport systems is discussed.     

Cysteine transport in melanosomes from murine melanocytes

The synthesis of pheomelanin requires the incorporation of thiol-containing compound(s) during the process of mammalian melanogenesis. Since melanins are produced only in specialized, membrane-bound organelles, known as melanosomes, such thiol donor(s) must cross the membrane barrier from the cytosol to the melanosome interior. Cysteine and/or glutathione (GSH) were proposed as suitable thiol donors, although uptake of these compounds into melanosomes was not previously characterized. In this study, we show that cysteine is transported, in a temperature- and concentration-dependent manner, across membranes of melanosomes derived from murine melanocytes. Additional proof that cysteine uptake results from a carrier-mediated process and is not due to simple diffusion or to a membrane channel, was obtained in countertransport experiments, in which melanosomes preloaded with cysteine methyl ester took up significantly more [35S]cysteine than did unloaded controls. In contrast, we were unable to detect any significant uptake of [35S]GSH over a wide concentration range, in the presence or in the absence of reducing agent. This study is the first demonstration of melanosomal membrane transport of cysteine, and it strongly suggests that free cysteine is the thiol source utilized for pheomelanin synthesis in mammalian melanocytes.     

Activation of a new proline transport system in Salmonella typhimurium.

Proline uptake can be mediated by three different transport systems in wild-type Salmonella typhimurium: a high-affinity proline transport system encoded by the putP gene and two glycine-betaine transport systems with a low affinity for proline encoded by the proP and proU genes. However, only the PutP permease transports proline well enough t allow growth on proline as a sole carbon or nitrogen source. By selecting for mutations that allow a putP mutant to grow on proline as a sole nitrogen source, we isolated mutants (designated proZ) that appeared to activate a cryptic proline transport system. These mutants enhanced the transport of proline and proline analogs but did not require the function of any of the known proline transport genes. The mutations mapped between 75 and 77.5 min on the S. typhimurium linkage map. Proline transport by the proZ mutants was competitively inhibited by isoleucine and leucine, which suggests that the ProZ phenotype may be due to unusual mutations that alter the substrate specificity of the branched-chain amino acid transport system encoded by the liv genes.     

Evaluation of ouabain-insensitive red blood cell cation transport in uremic patients

The authors present the results of a simultaneous assay of: intracellular Na+ and K+ concentrations, Na+ and K+ outward bumetanide-sensitive effluxes (Na+, K+ cotransport), Na+ efflux stimulated by extracellular Li+ (Na+, Li+ countertransport), and ouabain- and bumetanide-resistant Na+ and K+ effluxes (passive membrane permeability) performed in red blood cells from 15 uremic patients an regular hemodialysis and from 12 normal subjects, with an established flux assay. Na+ and K+ effluxes by the Na+, K+ cotransport system were significantly (p less than 0.01) lower in uremic patients then in normals (219 +/- 37 vs 82 +/- 17 mumol/l RBC/h and 251 +/- 29 vs 139 +/- 14 mumol/l RBC/h respectively). In normal subjects the bumetanide sensitive Na+ and K+ effluxes were strongly (r = 0.89; p less than 0.01) intercorrelated; and the intracellular Na+ concentration was related to the outward Na+ cotransport flux (r = 0.53; p approximately 0.05). Among uremic patients these correlations were not found. Na+ and K+ intracellular concentrations, passive Na+ and K+ permeability, and Na+, Li+ countertransport activity were not different among uremic patients and normal controls. In conclusion, in uremic dialyzed patients, red blood cell Na+, K+ cotransport activity is quite uniformly suppressed. The possible pathogenesis of this disfunction is still speculative and deserves further studies.     

Formation and stability of the enolates of N-protonated proline methyl ester and proline zwitterion in aqueous solution: a nonenzymatic model for the first step in the racemization of proline catalyzed by proline racemase

Rate constants for the hydrolysis of L-proline methyl ester to form proline and methanol in D(2)O buffered at neutral pD and 25 degrees C and the deuterium enrichment of the proline product determined by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry are reported. The data give k(DO) = 5.3 +/- 0.5 M(-1) s(-1) as the second-order rate constant for carbon deprotonation of N-protonated proline methyl ester by deuterioxide ion in D(2)O at 25 degrees C and I = 1.0 (KCl). The data provide good estimates of carbon acidities of pK(a) = 21 for N-protonated proline methyl ester and pK(a) = 29 for proline zwitterion in water and of the second-order rate constant k(HO) = 4.5 x 10(-5) M(-1) s(-1) for carbon deprotonation of proline zwitterion by hydroxide ion at 25 degrees C. There is no detectable acceleration of the deprotonation of N-protonated proline methyl ester by the Br?nsted base 3-quinuclidinone in water, and it is not clear that such Br?nsted catalysis would make a significant contribution to the rate acceleration for deprotonation of bound proline at proline racemase. A comparison of the first-order rate constants k(HO)[HO(-)] = 4.5 x 10(-11) s(-1) for deprotonation of free proline zwitterion in water at pH 8 and k(cat) = 2600 s(-1) for deprotonation of proline bound to the active site of proline racemase at pH 8 shows that the enzymatic rate acceleration for proline racemase is ca. 10(13)-fold. This corresponds to a 19 kcal/mol stabilization of the transition state for deprotonation of the enzyme-bound carbon acid substrate by interaction with the protein catalyst. It is suggested that (1) much of the rate acceleration of the enzymatic over the nonenzymatic reaction in water may result from transfer of the substrate proline zwitterion from the polar solvent water to a nonpolar enzyme active site and (2) the use of thiol anions rather than oxygen anions as Br?nsted bases at this putative nonpolar enzyme active site may be favored, because of the smaller energetic price for desolvation of thiol anions than for desolvation of the more strongly solvated oxygen anions.