A versatile new tool to quantify abasic sites in DNA and inhibit base excision repair

A number of endogenous and exogenous agents, and cellular processes create abasic (AP) sites in DNA. If unrepaired, AP sites cause mutations, strand breaks and cell death. Aldehyde-reactive agent methoxyamine reacts with AP sites and blocks their repair. Another alkoxyamine, ARP, tags AP sites with a biotin and is used to quantify these sites. We have combined both these abilities into one alkoxyamine, AA3, which reacts with AP sites with a better pH profile and reactivity than ARP. Additionally, AA3 contains an alkyne functionality for bioorthogonal click chemistry that can be used to link a wide variety of biochemical tags to AP sites. We used click chemistry to tag AP sites with biotin and a fluorescent molecule without the use of proteins or enzymes. AA3 has a better reactivity profile than ARP and gives much higher product yields at physiological pH than ARP. It is simpler to use than ARP and its use results in lower background and greater sensitivity for AP site detection. We also show that AA3 inhibits the first enzyme in the repair of abasic sites, APE-1, to about the same extent as methoxyamine. Furthermore, AA3 enhances the ability of an alkylating agent, methylmethane sulfonate, to kill human cells and is more effective in such combination chemotherapy than methoxyamine.     

Clustered damages and total lesions induced in DNA by ionizing radiation: oxidized bases and strand breaks

Ionizing radiation induces both isolated DNA lesions and clustered damages-multiple closely spaced lesions (strand breaks, oxidized purines, oxidized pyrimidines, or abasic sites within a few helical turns). Such clusters are postulated to be difficult to repair and thus potentially lethal or mutagenic lesions. Using highly purified enzymes that cleave DNA at specific classes of damage and electrophoretic assays developed for quantifying isolated and clustered damages in high molecular length genomic DNAs, we determined the relative frequencies of total lesions and of clustered damages involving both strands, and the composition and origin of such clusters. The relative frequency of isolated vs clustered damages depends on the identity of the lesion, with approximately 15-18% of oxidized purines, pyrimidines, or abasic sites in clusters recognized by Fpg, Nth, or Nfo proteins, respectively, but only about half that level of frank single strand breaks in double strand breaks. Oxidized base clusters and abasic site clusters constitute about 80% of complex damages, while double strand breaks comprise only approximately 20% of the total. The data also show that each cluster results from a single radiation (track) event, and thus clusters will be formed at low as well as high radiation doses.     

Atypical abasic sites generated by neocarzinostatin at sequence-specific cytidylate residues in oligodeoxynucleotides

Neocarzinostatin chromophore produces alkali-labile, abasic sites at cytidylate residues in AGC sequences in oligonucleotides in their duplex form. Glutathione is the preferred thiol activator of the drug in the formation of these lesions. The phosphodiester linkages on each side of the abasic site are intact, but when treated with alkali, breaks are formed with phosphate moieties at each end. Similar properties are exhibited by the abasic lesions produced at the purine residue to which the C in AGC is base-paired on the complementary strand. The abasic sites at C residues differ from those produced by acid-induced depurination in the much greater lability of the phosphodiester linkages on both sides of the deoxyribose, in the inability of NaBH4 to prevent alkali-induced cleavage, and in the relative resistance to apurinic/apyrimidinic endonucleases. The importance of DNA microstructure in determining attack site specificity in abasic site formation at C residues is shown not only by the requirement for the sequence AGC but also by the findings that substitution of G by I 5' to the C decreases the attack at C, whereas placement of an I opposite the C markedly enhances the reaction. Quantitation of the abstraction of 3H into the drug from C residues in AGC specifically labeled in the deoxyribose at C-5' or C-1',2' suggests that, in contrast to the attack at C-5' in the induction of direct strand breaks at T residues, abasic site formation at C residues may involve attack at C-1'. Each type of lesion may exist on the complementary strands of the same DNA molecule, forming a double-stranded lesion.     

DNA sequence context as a determinant of the quantity and chemistry of guanine oxidation produced by hydroxyl radicals and one-electron oxidants

DNA sequence context has emerged as a critical determinant of the location and quantity of nucleobase damage caused by many oxidizing agents. However, the complexity of nucleobase and 2-deoxyribose damage caused by strong oxidants such as ionizing radiation and the Fenton chemistry of Fe2+-EDTA/H2O2 poses a challenge to defining the location of nucleobase damage and the effects of sequence context on damage chemistry in DNA. To address this problem, we developed a gel-based method that allows quantification of nucleobase damage in oxidized DNA by exploiting Escherichia coli exonuclease III to remove fragments containing direct strand breaks and abasic sites. The rigor of the method was verified in studies of guanine oxidation by photooxidized riboflavin and nitrosoperoxycarbonate, for which different effects of sequence context have been demonstrated by other approaches (Margolin, Y., Cloutier, J. F., Shafirovich, V., Geacintov, N. E., and Dedon, P. C. (2006) Nat. Chem. Biol. 2, 365-366). Using duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containing all possible three-nucleotide sequence contexts for guanine, the method was used to assess the role of DNA sequence context in hydroxyl radical-induced guanine oxidation associated with gamma-radiation and Fe2+-EDTA/H2O2. The results revealed both differences and similarities for G oxidation by hydroxyl radicals and by one-electron oxidation by riboflavin-mediated photooxidation, which is consistent with the predominance of oxidation pathways for hydroxyl radicals other than one-electron oxidation to form guanine radical cations. Although the relative quantities of G oxidation produced by hydroxyl radicals were more weakly correlated with sequence-specific ionization potential than G oxidation produced by riboflavin, damage produced by both hydroxyl radical generators and riboflavin within two- and three-base runs of G showed biases in location that are consistent with a role for electron transfer in defining the location of the damage products. Furthermore, both gamma-radiation and Fe2+-EDTA/H2O2 showed relatively modest effects of sequence context on the proportions of different damage products sensitive to E. coli formamidopyrimidine DNA glycosylase and hot piperidine, although GT-containing sequence contexts displayed subtle biases in damage chemistry (formamidopyrimidine DNA glycosylase/piperidine ratio). Overall, the results are consistent with the known chemistry of guanine oxidation by hydroxyl radical and demonstrate that charge migration plays a relatively minor role in determining the location and chemistry of hydroxyl radical-mediated oxidative damage to guanine in DNA.     

Base excision repair intermediates as topoisomerase II poisons

Abasic sites are the most commonly formed DNA lesions in the cell and are produced by numerous endogenous and environmental insults. In addition, they are generated by the initial step of base excision repair (BER). When located within a topoisomerase II DNA cleavage site, "intact" abasic sites act as topoisomerase II poisons and dramatically stimulate enzyme-mediated DNA scission. However, most abasic sites in cells are not intact. They exist as processed BER intermediates that contain DNA strand breaks proximal to the damaged residue. When strand breaks are located within a topoisomerase II DNA cleavage site, they create suicide substrates that are not religated readily by the enzyme and can generate permanent double-stranded DNA breaks. Consequently, the effects of processed abasic sites on DNA cleavage by human topoisomerase IIalpha were examined. Unlike substrates with intact abasic sites, model BER intermediates containing 5'- or 3'-nicked abasic sites or deoxyribosephosphate flaps were suicide substrates. Furthermore, abasic sites flanked by 5'- or 3'-nicks were potent topoisomerase II poisons, enhancing DNA scission approximately 10-fold compared with corresponding nicked oligonucleotides that lacked abasic sites. These findings suggest that topoisomerase II is able to convert processed BER intermediates to permanent double-stranded DNA breaks.     

DNA cleavage induced by antitumor antibiotic leinamycin and its biological consequences

The natural product leinamycin has been found to produce abasic sites in duplex DNA through the hydrolysis of the glycosidic bond of guanine residues modified by this drug. In the present study, using a synthetic oligonucleotide duplex, we demonstrate spontaneous DNA strand cleavage at leinamycin-induced abasic sites through a β-elimination reaction. However, methoxyamine modification of leinamycin-induced abasic sites was found to be refractory to the spontaneous β-elimination reaction. Furthermore, this complex was even resistant to the δ-elimination reaction with hot piperidine treatment. Bleomycin and methyl methanesulfonate also induced strand cleavage in a synthetic oligonucleotide duplex even without thermal treatment. However, methoxyamine has a negligible effect on DNA strand cleavage induced by both drugs, suggesting that the mechanism of DNA cleavage induced by leinamycin might be different from those induced by bleomycin or methyl methanesulfonate. In this study, we also assessed the cytotoxicity of leinamycin against a collection of mammalian cell lines defective in various repair pathways. The mammalian cell line defective in the nucleotide excision repair (NER) or base excision repair (BER) pathways was about 3 to 5 times more sensitive to leinamycin as compared to the parental cell line. In contrast, the radiosensitive mutant xrs-5 cell line deficient in V(D)J recombination showed similar sensitivity towards leinamycin compared to the parental cell line. Collectively, our findings suggest that both NER and BER pathways play an important role in the repair of DNA damage caused by leinamycin.     

Role for DNA polymerase beta in response to ionizing radiation

Evidence for a role of DNA polymerase beta in determining radiosensitivity is conflicting. In vitro assays show an involvement of DNA polymerase beta in single strand break repair and base excision repair of oxidative damages, both products of ionizing radiation. Nevertheless the lack of DNA polymerase beta has been shown to have no effect on radiosensitivity. Here we show that mouse embryonic fibroblasts deficient in DNA polymerase beta are considerably more sensitive to ionizing radiation than wild-type cells, but only when confluent. The inhibitor methoxyamine renders abasic sites refractory to the dRP lyase activity of DNA polymerase beta. Methoxyamine did not significantly change radiosensitivity of wild-type fibroblasts in log phase. However, DNA polymerase beta deficient cells in log phase were radiosensitized by methoxyamine. Alkaline comet assays confirmed repair inhibition of ionizing radiation induced damage by methoxyamine in these cells, indicating both the existence of a polymerase beta-dependent long patch pathway and the involvement of another methoxyamine sensitive process, implying the participation of a second short patch polymerase(s) other than DNA polymerase beta. This is the first evidence of a role for DNA polymerase beta in radiosensitivity in vivo.     

C-1' hydrogen abstraction of deoxyribose in DNA strand scission by dynemicin A.

Dynemicin A, which is a hybrid antitumor antibiotic containing anthraquinone and enediyne cores, abstracts the C-1' hydrogen of DNA deoxyribose and then the damaged DNA leads to strand breaks with the formation of 5'- and 3'-phosphate termini. The lesions of C-4' hydrogen also occur at 3' side of G.C base pairs (i. e., 5'-CT and 5'-GA), leading to 5'-phosphate and 3'-phosphoglycolate termini or 4'-hydroxylated abasic sites. The C-1' hydrogen abstraction by dynemicin A is distinct from the preferential C-5' hydrogen abstraction of calicheamicin and neocarzinostatin.     

Reaction of apurinic/apyrimidinic sites with [14C]methoxyamine. A method for the quantitative assay of AP sites in DNA

A simple and rapid method is described for the determination of AP (apurinic/apyrimidinic) sites in DNA. The method involves the reaction of [14C]methoxyamine with the aldehyde group present in the deoxyribose moiety after a base loss. Studies with alkylated-depurinated DNA and with uracil-containing polydeoxyribonucleotides depyrimidinated by uracil-DNA glycosylase show that methoxyamine reacts with both apurinic and apyrimidinic sites in a rapid and exhaustive way. Under standard conditions (30-min incubation with 5 mM methoxyamine at 37 degrees C, pH 7.2) untreated DNA is almost unreactive and the [14C]methoxyamine incorporation in DNA is proportional to the number of AP sites. Since the methoxyamine reaction is free from any degradative effect on DNA, AP sites may be estimated from a simple determination of the acid-insoluble radioactivity.     

Improved measurement of dibenzo[a,l]pyrene-induced abasic sites by the aldehyde-reactive probe assay

Dibenzo[a,l]pyrene (DB[a,l]P) induces abundant amounts of depurinating adducts that spontaneously dissociate to form abasic sites in DNA. However, several previous studies that used the aldehyde-reactive probe (ARP) assay, could not verify abasic site formation by DB[a,l]P. Therefore, we examined whether a modification of the ARP assay would allow greater quantification of abasic sites. A previous study indicated that the abasic site quantification is improved by letting ARP trap the nascent abasic sites in cells, before extracting DNA for the assay. To test whether the addition of ARP to the DB[a,l]P-DNA adduct-forming reaction would improve abasic site quantification, we treated calf thymus DNA (0.625 mg/mL) with DB[a,l]P (80 microM) and 3-methylcholanthrene-treated rat liver microsomes with or without ARP (3 mM). The inclusion of ARP in the adduct-forming reaction resulted in significantly greater detection of abasic sites (62 lesions/10(6) bp versus 3.7 lesions/10(6) bp). DB[a,l]P also induces DNA strand breaks. The strand breaks may occur at abasic sites and by other mechanisms, such as oxidative damage. ARP/O-methoxyamine-abasic site conjugates are refractory to strand breakage, however, ARP or O-methoxyamine (3-10 mM) could only partially protect DB[a,l]P-induced DNA degradation, presumably by protecting the abasic sites, but not the other strand breaks. These results suggest that if DNA strand breakages occur at the abasic sites or at bases flanking them, and the fragments are lost during DNA extraction, abasic site estimation could be compromised. To obtain an independent line of evidence for abasic site formation in DB[a,l]P-treated cells, mouse Mbeta16 fibroblasts were treated with DB[a,l]P and O-methoxyamine. O-Methoxyamine is known to potentiate cytotoxicity of abasic site-inducing chemicals by forming abasic site conjugates, which partially inhibits their repair. O-Methoxyamine was found to increase DB[a,l]P cytotoxicity in these cells, supporting the idea that DB[a,l]P formed abasic sites. In summary, the inclusion of ARP in the DB[a,l]P-DNA adduct-forming reaction traps and protects the nascent abasic sites, allowing an improved quantification of abasic sites.     

Solution structure of an oligonucleotide containing an abasic site: evidence for an unusual deoxyribose conformation

The antitumor antibiotic bleomycin causes two major lesions in the deoxyribose backbone of DNA: formation of 4′-keto abasic sites and formation of strand breaks with 3′-phosphoglycolate and 5′-phosphate ends. As a model for the 4′-keto abasic site, we have characterized an abasic site (X) in d(CCAAAGXACTGGG)·d(CCCAGTACTTTGG) by two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy. A total of 475 NOEs and 101 dihedral angles provided the restraints for molecular modeling. Four unusual NOEs were observed between each anomer of the abasic site and the neighboring bases. In addition, four coupling constants for adjacent protons of the deoxyribose of both the α and β anomers of the abasic site were observed. The modeling suggests that for both anomers the abasic site is extrahelical, without significant distortion of the backbone opposite the lesion. The coupling constants further allowed assignment of an unusual sugar pucker for each anomer. The unique position of the abasic site in our structural model for each anomer is discussed in terms of repair of such lesions in vivo.     

The determination of the DNA sequence specificity of bleomycin-induced abasic sites

The DNA sequence specificity of the cancer chemotherapeutic agent, bleomycin, was determined with high precision in purified plasmid DNA using an improved technique. This improved technique involved the labelling of the 5′- and 3′-ends of DNA with different fluorescent tags, followed by simultaneous cleavage by bleomycin and capillary electrophoresis with laser-induced fluorescence. This permitted the determination of bleomycin cleavage specificity with high accuracy since end-label bias was greatly reduced. Bleomycin produces single- and double-strand breaks, abasic sites and other base damage in DNA. This high-precision method was utilised to elucidate, for the first time, the DNA sequence specificity of bleomycin-induced DNA damage at abasic sites. This was accomplished using endonuclease IV that cleaves DNA at abasic sites after bleomycin damage. It was found that bleomycin-induced abasic sites formed at 5′-GC and 5′-GT sites while bleomycin-induced phosphodiester strand breaks formed mainly at 5′-GT dinucleotides. Since bleomycin-induced abasic sites are produced in the absence of molecular oxygen, this difference in DNA sequence specificity could be important in hypoxic tumour cells.     

Reaction of apurinic/apyrimidinic sites with [C]methoxyamine: A method for the quantitative assay of AP sites in DNA

A simple and rapid method is described for the determination of AP (apurinic/apyrimidinic) sites in DNA. The method involves the reaction of [¹⁴C]methoxyamine with the aldehyde group present in the deoxyribose moiety after a base loss. Studies with alkylated-depurinated DNA and with uracil-containing polydeoxyribonucleotides depyrimidinated by uracil-DNA glycosylase show that methoxyamine reacts with both apurinic and apyrimidinic sites in a rapid and exhaustive way. Under standard conditions (30-min incubation with 5 mM methoxyamine at 37°C, pH 7.2) untreated DNA is almost unreactive and the [¹⁴C]methoxyamine incorporation in DNA is proportional to the number of AP sites. Since the methoxyamine reaction is free from any degradative effect on DNA, AP sites may be estimated from a simple determination of the acid-insoluble radioactivity.     

Comparison of human plasma low- and high-density lipoproteins as substrates for lecithin: cholesterol acyltransferase

The interstrand crosslinks that appear in stored depurinated DNA interfere with the counting of apurinic sites and strand breaks by sucrose gradient analysis. They could not be cleaved at acid or alkaline pH, or by treatment with methoxyamine.     

Condensation of DNA—A putative obstruction for repair process in abasic clustered DNA damage

Clustered DNA damages are defined as two or more closely located DNA damage lesions that may be present within a few helical turns of the DNA double strand. These damages are potential signatures of ionizing radiation and are often found to be repair resistant. Types of damaged lesions frequently found inside clustered DNA damage sites include oxidized bases, abasic sites, nucleotide dimers, strand breaks or their complex combinations. In this study, we used a bistranded two-lesion abasic cluster DNA damage model to access the repair process of DNA in condensate form.Oligomer DNA duplexes (47 bp) were designed to have two deoxyuridine in the middle of the sequences, three bases apart in opposite strands. The deoxyuridine residues were converted into abasic sites by treatment with UDG enzyme creating an abasic clustered damage site in a precise position in each of the single strand of the DNA duplex. This oligomer duplex having compatible cohesive ends was ligated to pUC19 plasmid, linearized with HindIII restriction endonuclease. The plasmid–oligomer conjugate was transformed into condensates by treating them with spermidine. The efficiency of strand cleavage action of ApeI enzyme on the abasic sites was determined by denaturing PAGE after timed incubation of the oligomer duplex and the oligomer–plasmid conjugate in presence and absence of spermidine. The efficiency of double strand breaks was determined similarly by native PAGE. Quantitative gel analysis revealed that rate of abasic site cleavage is reduced in the DNA condensates as compared to the oligomer DNA duplex or the linear ligated oligomer–plasmid conjugates. Generation of double strand break is significantly reduced also, suggesting that their creation is not proportionate to the number of abasic sites cleaved in the condensate model. All these suggest that the ApeI enzyme have difficulty to access the abasic sites located deep into the condensates leading to repair refractivity of the damages. In addition, we found that presence of a polyamine such as spermidine has no notable effect in the incision activity of ApeI enzyme in linear oligomer DNA duplexes in our experimental concentration.     

Ku antigen interacts with abasic sites

One of the most abundant lesions in DNA is the abasic (AP) sites arising spontaneously or as an intermediate in base excision repair. Certain proteins participating in the processing of these lesions form a Schiff base with the deoxyribose of the AP site. This intermediate can be stabilized by NaBH(4) treatment. By this method, DNA duplexes with AP sites were used to trap proteins in cell extracts. In HeLa cell extract, along with a prevalent trap product with an apparent molecular mass of 95 kDa, less intensive low-molecular-weight products were observed. The major one was identified as the p80-subunit of Ku antigen (Ku). Ku antigen, a DNA binding component of DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK), participates in double-stranded break repair and is responsible for the resistance of cells to ionizing radiation. The specificity of Ku interaction with AP sites was proven by more efficient competition of DNA duplexes with an analogue of abasic site than non-AP DNA. Ku80 was cross-linked to AP DNAs with different efficiencies depending on the size and position of strand interruptions opposite to AP sites. Ku antigen as a part of DNA-PK was shown to inhibit AP site cleavage by apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease 1.     

Induction of double-strand breaks by S1 nuclease, mung bean nuclease and nuclease P1 in DNA containing abasic sites and nicks.

Defined DNA substrates containing discrete abasic sites or paired abasic sites set 1, 3, 5 and 7 bases apart on opposite strands were constructed to examine the reactivity of S1, mung bean and P1 nucleases towards abasic sites. None of the enzymes acted on the substrate containing discrete abasic sites. Under conditions where little or no non-specific DNA degradation was observed, all three nucleases were able to generate double-strand breaks when the bistranded abasic sites were 1 and 3 base pairs apart. However, when the abasic sites were further apart, the enzymes again failed to cleave the DNA. These results indicate that single abasic sites do not cause sufficient denaturation of the DNA to allow incision by these single-strand specific endonucleases. The reactivity of these enzymes was also investigated on DNA substrates that were nicked by DNasel or more site-specifically by endonuclease III incision at the discrete abasic sites. The three nucleases readily induced a strand break opposite such nicks.     

Some properties of the interstrand crosslinks in depurinated DNA

The interstrand crosslinks that appear in stored depurinated DNA interfere with the counting of apurinic sites and strand breaks by sucrose gradient analysis. They could not be cleaved at acid or alkaline pH, or by treatment with methoxyamine.     

Improved measurement of dibenzo[a,l]pyrene-induced abasic sites by the aldehyde-reactive probe assay

Dibenzo[a,l]pyrene (DB[a,l]P) induces abundant amounts of depurinating adducts that spontaneously dissociate to form abasic sites in DNA. However, several previous studies that used the aldehyde-reactive probe (ARP) assay, could not verify abasic site formation by DB[a,l]P. Therefore, we examined whether a modification of the ARP assay would allow greater quantification of abasic sites. A previous study indicated that the abasic site quantification is improved by letting ARP trap the nascent abasic sites in cells, before extracting DNA for the assay. To test whether the addition of ARP to the DB[a,l]P–DNA adduct-forming reaction would improve abasic site quantification, we treated calf thymus DNA (0.625 mg/mL) with DB[a,l]P (80 μM) and 3-methylcholanthrene-treated rat liver microsomes with or without ARP (3 mM). The inclusion of ARP in the adduct-forming reaction resulted in significantly greater detection of abasic sites (62 lesions/10⁶ bp versus 3.7 lesions/10⁶ bp). DB[a,l]P also induces DNA strand breaks. The strand breaks may occur at abasic sites and by other mechanisms, such as oxidative damage. ARP/O-methoxyamine-abasic site conjugates are refractory to strand breakage, however, ARP or O-methoxyamine (3–10 mM) could only partially protect DB[a,l]P-induced DNA degradation, presumably by protecting the abasic sites, but not the other strand breaks. These results suggest that if DNA strand breakages occur at the abasic sites or at bases flanking them, and the fragments are lost during DNA extraction, abasic site estimation could be compromised. To obtain an independent line of evidence for abasic site formation in DB[a,l]P-treated cells, mouse Mβ16 fibroblasts were treated with DB[a,l]P and O-methoxyamine. O-Methoxyamine is known to potentiate cytotoxicity of abasic site-inducing chemicals by forming abasic site conjugates, which partially inhibits their repair. O-Methoxyamine was found to increase DB[a,l]P cytotoxicity in these cells, supporting the idea that DB[a,l]P formed abasic sites. In summary, the inclusion of ARP in the DB[a,l]P–DNA adduct-forming reaction traps and protects the nascent abasic sites, allowing an improved quantification of abasic sites.