Evidence that the adaptive response of human lymphocytes to ionizing radiation acts on lethal damage in nonaberrant cells

In a previous study we found that a cytogenetic adaptive response could lead to increases in survival if there was a sufficient increase in nonaberrant cells (Shadley and Dai, 1992). Since the high challenge doses used produced mainly multiply aberrant cells, we suggested using challenge doses that gave mainly singly aberrant cells in order to improve detection of a survival adaptive response. To test this, human lymphocytes from 6 donors were exposed in the first G₁ phase to 5 cGy of X-rays, followed by 100 cGy 6 h later. Nearly all of the aberrant cells bore only one chromosome aberration with this challenge dose, and in agreement with our proposal, survival adaptive responses were seen in 4 of 6 donors. A near 1:1 relationship between the % nonaberrant cells and % survival was found with 100 cGy, suggesting that the lymphocyte populations scored in the survival and aberration assays were representative of each other. However, the increase in nonaberrant cells was not sufficient to account for the increase in survival. Thus, a large fraction of the increase in survival was due to a decrease in lethal damage in cytologically nonaberrant cells. Such damage could range sub-microscopic lesions, to larger alterations not visible in Giemsa-stained cells. In conjunction with adaptive response studies of others, these results intimate that the adaptive response affects damage at different levels of chromosomal hierarchy (i.e. from the chromosome to DNA). The process(es) responsible for the effects observed in this study may act on lethal, rather than mutagenic lesions.     

On the response of a cell population to low-dose irradiation

The cell composition of a population of human blood lymphocytes was studied after irradiation at doses of 5 cGy, 1.0 Gy and 5 cGy + 1.0 Gy and the use of a cytokinesis block. The frequencies of uni-, bi- and multinucleate lymphocytes with and without micronuclei (MN) were taken into account. By the standard criterion the frequency of binucleate lymphocytes with MN among binucleate lymphocytes--the donors were characterized as follows: in with reduction of radiosensitivity after irradiation with 5 cGy + 1.0 Gy as compared to the values of radiosensitivity after irradiation with 1.0 Gy only (an adaptive response, AR); in with no change of radiosensitivity after exposure to these doses (no AR); and with an increased ofradiosensitivity after exposure to these doses (syndrome of increased radiosensitivity, IRS). It was found that upon exposure to 1.0 Gy and 5 cGy + 1.0 Gy in some donors with AR, without AR and with IRS the total numbers of damaged cells in the population and the number of binucleate cells with MN were equal. This result calls in question the involvement of the repair mechanism in the alteration of radiosensitivity of lymphocytes in these donors. It was also observed that in the same donors a simultaneous increase (or a decrease in the case of IRS) of the portion of undamaged binucleate cells in the population took place. Our results demonstrate the existence of a new, populational, mechanism involved in the alteration of radiosensitivity after exposure to the adaptive and challenge doses.     

Endothelial cell subpopulations in vitro: cell volume, cell cycle, and radiosensitivity

Vascular endothelial cells (EC) are important clinical targets of radiation and other forms of free radical/oxidant stresses. In this study, we found that the extent of endothelial damage may be determined by the different cytotoxic responses of EC subpopulations. The following characteristics of EC subpopulations were examined: 1) cell volume; 2) cell cycle position; and 3) cytotoxic indexes for both acute cell survival and proliferative capacity after irradiation (137Cs, gamma, 0-10 Gy). EC cultured from bovine aortas were separated by centrifugal elutriation into subpopulations of different cell volumes. Through flow cytometry, we found that cell volume was related to the cell cycle phase distribution. The smallest EC were distributed in G1 phase and the larger cells were distributed in either early S, middle S, or late S + G2M phases. Cell cycle phase at the time of irradiation was not associated with acute cell loss. However, distribution in the cell cycle did relate to cell survival based on proliferative capacity (P less than 0.01). The order of increasing radioresistance was cells in G1 (D0 = 110 cGy), early S (135 cGy), middle S (145 cGy), and late S + G2M phases (180 cGy). These findings 1) suggest an age-related response to radiation in a nonmalignant differentiated cell type and 2) demonstrate EC subpopulations in culture.     

The dose dependence of cytogenetic damages and the adaptive response of mammalian cells under the action of ionizing radiation at low doses

The dose-effect dependence of cytogenetic damage after single dose irradiation in the dose range of 0.1-2 Gy and the adaptive response after double-dose irradiation were studied on Chinese hamster and human melanoma cells in culture. The non-linear dose dependencies were found for the induction of chromosome aberrations with decrease in cell radiosensitivity in the definite dose range. This decrease started at 10 and 20 cGy for melanoma and Chinese hamster cells respectively. The maximal adaptive response was induced at 1 cGy for melanoma cells and at 20 cGy for Chinese hamster cells. It can be supposed that the same inducible repair processes are responsible for non-linearity of dose-effect curves and induction of the adaptive response. These processes are similar in mechanisms and different in quantitative proportion for different cell types.     

On the mechanism of adaptive response in human cells

There was investigated one of the mechanisms of adaptive response, related to chromosome aberrations induced by gamma-rays, in lymphocytes of healthy donors and donors with hereditary diseases (Marfan's syndrome and homocystinurea) whose cells are repair-deficient. 3H-thymidine treatment was used as an adaptive dose in G1-period of cell cycle and 8-methoxypsoralen (8-MOP), activated with UV-light, was used as a challenge agents. Cells of healthy donors and cells of patients with Marfan's syndrome had normal adaptive response in relation to gamma-irradiation and photomutagenic action of 8-MOP. There was no induction of adaptive response in realation to gamma-irradiation and 8-MOP photomutagenic action in cells of patients with homocystinurea. The cells from donors characterised with normal repair system and lack of adaptive response 8-MOP photomutagenic action wasn't modified by 3H-thymidine. We have found parallelism of adaptive response protective effect against chromosome aberrations, induced by UV activated 8-MOP and gamma-rays in repair proficient cells of healthy donors and repair deficient cells of patients with Marfan's syndrome. These data lead us to conclusion that mechanism of adaption, at least in some cases has no connection with repair process modification.     

Adaptive response in irradiated human lymphocytes: radiobiological and genetical aspects

The adaptive response (AR) in human lymphocytes in different experimental protocols was investigated. The AR was found to be present in cells pre-exposed to 3 cGy of X-rays in G0, G1 and S phase as well as with tritiated water (4 muCi/ml) when the 'challenge' dose was given in G2. There was no AR after prior exposure of the cells in S phase to secondary irradiation from 70 GeV protons. The AR was not observed after preliminary X-irradiation of the lymphocytes in G0 and G1 and 'challenge' irradiation in G1. Cells from 6 patients with Down's syndrome were tested. At least 5 of them did not show the AR. The AR is considered to be a phenomenon of the antimutagenic aftereffect.     

Protective effects of 5,6,7,8-tetrahydroneopterin against X-ray radiation injury in mice

The protective effects of 5,6,7,8-tetrahydroneopterin (NH4) against radiation injury in mice were studied. (C57BL/6xA/J)F1 (B6A) mice received a single whole-body irradiation dose of 200, 400, 700 or 800 cGy of X-rays. NH4 (30 mg/kg body weight) or phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) was injected intraperitoneally into irradiated mice 10 min before and after the irradiation and again after 6 h. All mice which received the 800 cGy radiation+PBS died between 8 and 11 days after the treatment. In contrast, those which also received NH4 demonstrated a significantly prolonged survival time and 40% lived more than 5 months. Total numbers of thymocytes and spleen cells on day 5 post-irradiation were dramatically reduced in line with the radiation dose. The survival was significantly enhanced by NH4 in treated mice. The proliferation of spleen cells in mice stimulated by concanavalin A (Con A) or lipopolysaccharide (LPS) was also greater in NH4 treated mice. The immune response of survivors 5 months after 800 cGy+NH4 treatments, against Con A, LPS, allogenic mouse, and sheep red blood cells had essentially recovered to the levels of normal mice. These results indicate that NH4 had an important role in modifying radiation injury.     

Cytogenetic effects of low doses of radiation in mammalian cells: analysis of the hypersensitivity phenomenon and induced resistance

The induction of cytogenetic damage after irradiation of chinese hamster cells and human melanoma cells within a dose range 1-200 cGy was studied. The anaphase and metaphase analysis of chromosome damage and micronuclei test were applied. The hypersensitivity (HRS) at doses below 20 cGy and the increased radio-resistence at higher doses (IR) were shown with all cytogenetic critheria for both cell lines. The phenomenon of HRS/IR was reproduced in synchronic as well as in a synchronic population of chinese hamster cells. This fact shows that HRS was caused by high radiosensitivity of all cells and can not be explained by any differential sensitivity of cells in different phase of the cell cycle. So it was supposed that the increasing radio-resistence is determined by the inclusion of the inducible repair processes in all cells. This conclusion consents with the facts, that there was no evidence of HRS on dose-effect curves and that some parts of pre-existent damage was repaired after preliminary irradiation with low doses (1-20 cGy) which induce repair processes. It can be concluded that same inducible repair processes an analogous in mechanisms underlying in the base of HRS/IR phenomenon and adaptive response.     

Low-dose radiation hypersensitivity is associated with p53-dependent apoptosis

Exposure to environmental radiation and the application of new clinical modalities, such as radioimmunotherapy, have heightened the need to understand cellular responses to low dose and low-dose rate ionizing radiation. Many tumor cell lines have been observed to exhibit a hypersensitivity to radiation doses <50 cGy, which manifests as a significant deviation from the clonogenic survival response predicted by a linear-quadratic fit to higher doses. However, the underlying processes for this phenomenon remain unclear. Using a gel microdrop/flow cytometry assay to monitor single cell proliferation at early times postirradiation, we examined the response of human A549 lung carcinoma, T98G glioma, and MCF7 breast carcinoma cell lines exposed to gamma radiation doses from 0 to 200 cGy delivered at 0.18 and 22 cGy/min. The A549 and T98G cells, but not MCF7 cells, showed the marked hypersensitivity at doses <50 cGy. To further characterize the low-dose hypersensitivity, we examined the influence of low-dose radiation on cell cycle status and apoptosis by assays for active caspase-3 and phosphatidylserine translocation (Annexin V binding). We observed that caspase-3 activation and Annexin V binding mirrored the proliferation curves for the cell lines. Furthermore, the low-dose hypersensitivity and Annexin V binding to irradiated A549 and T98G cells were eliminated by treating the cells with pifithrin, an inhibitor of p53. When p53-inactive cell lines (2800T skin fibroblasts and HCT116 colorectal carcinoma cells) were examined for similar patterns, we found that there was no hyperradiosensitivity and apoptosis was not detectable by Annexin V or caspase-3 assays. Our data therefore suggest that low-dose hypersensitivity is associated with p53-dependent apoptosis.     

Absence of radiation-induced adaptive response in lymphocytes of patients with Down's syndrome]

The adaptive syndrome and response (AR) in lymphocytes from 6 patients with Down syndrome (DS) were investigated. No AR was found to occur in all cases in DS cells pre-exposed to 3 rad of X-rays in S phase of cell cycle and then irradiated with 150 rad of gamma rays in G2 whereas the chromosome aberrations yield in cells from control donors was decreased twice under such conditions of the experiment.     

Differential Th1 and Th2 cell responses in male and female BALB/c mice infected with coxsackievirus group B type 3.

Male and female BALB/c mice differ dramatically in susceptibility to myocarditis subsequent to coxsackievirus B3 (CVB3) infection. CVB3 infection of male mice results in substantial inflammatory cell infiltration of the myocardium, and virus-immune lymphocytes from these animals give predominantly a Th1 cell phenotypic response, as determined by predominant immunoglobulin G2a isotypic antibody production and elevated numbers of gamma interferon and interleukin-2 (IL-2)-producing CD4+ T lymphocytes. Females infected with the same virus give predominantly a Th2 cell phenotypic response, as determined by preferential immunoglobulin G1 antibody isotypic responses and increased precursor frequencies of IL-4- and IL-5-producing CD4+ T cells. Treatment of females with testosterone or males with estradiol prior to infection alters subsequent Th subset differentiation, suggesting that the sex-associated hormones have either a direct or indirect effect on CD4+ lymphocyte responses in this model. Treatment of females with 0.1 mg of monoclonal antibody to IL-4 reduces precursor frequencies of IL-4-producing CD4+ T cells and increases frequencies of gamma interferon-producing cells. This treatment also enhances myocardial inflammation, indicating a correlation between Th1-like cell responses and pathogenicity in CVB3 infection. The Th2-like cell may regulate Th1 cell activation. Adoptive transfer of T lymphocytes from CVB3-infected female mice into male animals suppresses the development of myocarditis in the recipients. Treatment of the female donors with monoclonal antibodies to either CD3, CD4, or IL-4 molecules abrogates suppression.     

Aspects of the adaptive response to very low doses of radiation and other agents

When human lymphocytes and other cells are pre-exposed to very low doses of ionizing radiation and subsequently exposed to a high dose, less genetic damage, i.e., fewer chromosome aberrations, is found than is observed in cells that had not been pre-exposed. This has been termed the adaptive response and has been attributed to the induction of a repair mechanism by the low dose exposure. Several experiments have now been carried out on this adaptive response to better characterize the phenomenon. (A) Experiments with differential display of mRNAs indicate that human lymphocytes exposed to 2 cGy of X-rays have somewhat different mRNAs expressed than do unexposed cells. This is providing access to DNA that might be involved in adaptation. (B) Other experiments with embryonic cells from transgenic mice that are deficient in superoxide dismutase (SOD) have shown that the adaptive response is unrelated to the amount of SOD in the cells, and thus is independent of superoxide radicals. (C) Experiments in which very low doses of various restriction enzymes were electroporated into human lymphocytes have shown that low levels of double-strand DNA breaks alone are able to induce the adaptive response. (D) Experiments in which human male lymphocytes (XY chromosome constitution) and human female lymphocytes (XX chromosome constitution) were cocultivated have shown that adaptation is not caused by a change in the rate of cell progression to mitosis after a challenge dose, and is a further indication that cell stage sensitivity is not a factor in the adaptive response.     

Chromosome studies of in vitro senescent lymphocytes: nonrandom trisomy 2

Chromosome studies were carried out in long-term (142 and 184 d) human lymphocyte in vitro cultures in order to investigate the cytogenetic status of aging lymphocytes. The female donors were subdivided into three subgroups according to their age: 20-40 year-old (three individuals), 70-90 year-old (five persons), and centenarians (three persons). Besides some aneuploidy and structural abnormalities, telomere fusions were detected in all donor cells, and associations of acrocentric chromosomes were found in six persons in the three age-groups. Clonal trisomy 2 was present in three individuals (two from the 70-90 year-group and one centenarian with a clone +2, +8). While telomeric fusions and acrocentric associations seem to be more related to in vitro aging, trisomy 2 also appears dependent on the age of the cell donors.     

The mechanisms of adaptive response. Estimation of capacity of human blood lymphocytes to radiation adaptive response using different criteria

Blood lymphocytes of 15 healthy donors have been investigated for the ability to decrease their radiosensitivity after treatment with low dose irradiation named radioinduced adaptive response (AR). The unstable chromosome aberrations were used to evaluate the radiosensitivity change after irradiation of cells with low adaptive dose (5 cGy) and subsequent high challenge dose (1.0 Gy) in comparison with the effect of challenge irradiation only. Three indexes were used: the frequency of cells with aberrations in all analyzed cells (A), the number of chromosome aberrations per cell (B) and the number of chromosome aberrations per one aberrant cell (C). It has been discovered that all donors examined can be divided into four groups: 1--individuals which cells did not show AR by all indexes used; 2--individuals which cells showed AR by indexes A and B, but not C; 3--AR was demonstrated by indexes B and C; 4--AR was confirmed by all three indexes. Generally accepted repair model for AR formation explains only the case of donor groups 3 and 4, but can not explain the mechanism leading to the case of group 2. For understanding this mechanism, the distribution of metaphases by the number of chromosome aberrations per cell was analyzes for each donor. It was shown that the part of cells without aberrations in group 2 donors increased significantly after treatment with the adaptive and challenge irradiation in comparison with that after irradiation with challenge dose only. The conclusion is that in this case AR is formed as a result of change in the frequency 0 cell class--population shift. The analogous shift was observed in the distributions of metaphases for all donors of the group 4, but was absent in the group 3 donors. The data obtained suggest that AR of blood lymphocytes might be a result of several processes: activation of submutational genome damage repair; population shifts manifested by the change in the part of undamaged cells; and, possibly, activation of apoptotic cell death. The complex nature of AR affects each of radiosensitivity evaluation criteria to a different extent.     

Sister-chromatid exchanges induced by mitomycin C after acute or chronic exposure of human lymphocytes to a low dose of X-rays

Human peripheral blood lymphocytes from 10 male donors were exposed to mitomycin C with and without prior irradiation with 0.01 Gy X-rays. Acute or chronic irradiation of lymphocytes in G1 resulted in a decrease in the subsequent level of mitomycin C-induced sister-chromatid exchange aberrations. The effect was small (approximately 10%) with evidence of some variability between donors. By contrast no adaptive response was observed if the cells were treated in G0.     

Immunodominant T-cell epitope on the F protein of respiratory syncytial virus recognized by human lymphocytes.

The lymphocyte proliferative responses to respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) were evaluated for 10 healthy adult donors and compared with proliferative responses to a chimeric glycoprotein (FG glycoprotein) which consists of the extracellular domains of both the F and G proteins of RSV and which is produced from a recombinant baculovirus. The lymphocytes of all 10 donors responded to RSV, and the proliferative responses to the whole virus were highly correlated with the responses to the FG glycoprotein. These data suggested that one or both of these glycoproteins of RSV were major target structures for stimulation of the human lymphocyte proliferative response among virus-specific memory T cells. The lymphocytes of four donors were evaluated further for their proliferative responses to a nested set of overlapping peptides modeled on the extracellular and cytoplasmic domains of the F protein of RSV. Strikingly, the lymphocytes of all 4 donors responded primarily to a region defined by a single peptide spanning residues 338 to 355, and the lymphocytes of 2 donors responded to an overlapping peptide spanning residues 328 to 342 also, thus defining a region of the F1 subunit within residues 328 to 355 that may circumscribe an immunodominant site for stimulation of human T cells from a variety of individuals. This region of the F protein is highly conserved among A and B subgroup viruses. As revealed by monoclonal antibody blocking studies, the lymphocytes responding to this antigenic site had characteristics consistent with T helper cells. Similar epitope mapping studies were performed with BALB/c mice immunized with the FG protein in which a relatively hydrophobic peptide spanning residues 51 to 65 within the F2 subunit appeared to be the major T cell recognition determinant. The data are discussed with respect to an antigenic map of the F protein and the potential construction of a synthetic vaccine for RSV.     

Mechanism of adaptive response: Estimation of human lymphocyte adaptive response to radiation using various criteria

Blood lymphocytes of 15 healthy donors have been investigated for their ability to reduce radiosensitivity after low-dose irradiation-radio-induced adaptive response (AR). The frequency of unstable chromosome aberrations was used to evaluate cell radiosensitivity after the irradiation of cells in low adaptive (5 cGy) and high challenge (1 Gy) doses in comparison with the effect of challenge irradiation only. Three indexes have been used, i.e., (A) the frequency of cells with aberrations per total analyzed cell, (B) the number of chromosome aberrations per one cell, (C) and the number of chromosome aberrations per one aberrant cell. It was found that the donors can be divided in the four following groups: 1. AR was not estimated any of the indexes used; 2. AR was estimated with indexes A and B, but not C; 3. AR was shown by indexes B and C; 4. AR was evident with all three indexes. The generally accepted AR repair model only explains the appearance of group-3 and-4 donors, but not group-2. For the purpose of understanding the AR mechanisms and the difference in AR estimations with various criteria, the metaphase distribution by the number of chromosome aberrations has been analyzed for each donor. It was shown that, in group-2 donors, the number of cells without aberrations after adaptive and challenge irradiations was significantly higher than after irradiation with a challenge dose only. Thus, in this group, AR is formed as a result of the changed frequency of cells in the 0 class (population shift). A similar shift is observed in the metaphase distribution in the donors of group 4, but not in group 3. The data obtained show that AR is probably a result of several processes, including the activation of the reparation of premutational genome damages, population shifts evident in the frequency of undamaged cells, and, possibly, the activation of apoptotic cell death. The complex character of AR is reflected to different degrees in each criterion of radiosensitivity.     

Transposition of chromosome loci in bystander cells upon exposure to an adaptive dose of ionizing radiation

During the process of the realization of the bystander effect the trans of the Signal from irradiated cells to the intact cell (bystander cells) happens. So both type of cells (irradiated and intact cells) have the same damages and reactions. There are new data about bystander effect as the transduction mechanism of the adaptive response and we have investigated this phenomenon. There are an incubation of the intact (bystander cells) and the exposed (X-radiation of 10 cGy) human lymphocytes and we analyze the location of the centromeric loci of the first chromosome. We observed hat for the first time that after X-ray exposition of the adaptive doses the transposition of the chromosome loci from the peripheral to the central parts of the nucleus in intact (bystander cell) G0-lymphocytes which were incubated in the growth environment cells with irradiated cells removal. We support that the starting states of the adaptive response is the loci extrication of the matrix, the transposition and the approach homologous chromosomes. This process is necessary for the DNA double strand breaks reparation (in the case of injured dose X-radiation) with the participation of the homologous recombination.