The effect of local bending on gating of MscL using a representative volume element and finite element simulation

Many physiological processes such as cell division, endocytosis and exocytosis cause severe local curvature of the cell membrane. Local curvature has been shown experimentally to modulate numerous mechanosensitive (MS) ion channels. In order to quantify the effects of local curvature we introduced a coarse grain representative volume element for the bacterial mechanosensitive ion channel of large conductance (MscL) using continuum elasticity. Our model is designed to be consistent with the channel conformation in the closed and open states to capture its major continuum rheological behavior in response to the local membrane curvature. Herein we show that change in the local curvature of the lipid bilayer can modulate MscL activity considerably by changing both bilayer thickness and lateral pressure profile. Intriguingly, although bending in any direction results in almost the same free-energy cost, inward (cytoplasmic) bending favors channel opening, whereas outward (periplasmic) bending facilitates closing of the narrowest part of the MscL pore. This quantitative study using MscL as a model channel may have wide reaching consequences for the effect of local curvature on the physiological function of other types of prokaryotic and eukaryotic membrane proteins.     

The effect of local bending on gating of MscL using a representative volume element and finite element simulation

Many physiological processes such as cell division, endocytosis and exocytosis cause severe local curvature of the cell membrane. Local curvature has been shown experimentally to modulate numerous mechanosensitive (MS) ion channels. In order to quantify the effects of local curvature we introduced a coarse grain representative volume element for the bacterial mechanosensitive ion channel of large conductance (MscL) using continuum elasticity. Our model is designed to be consistent with the channel conformation in the closed and open states to capture its major continuum rheological behavior in response to the local membrane curvature. Herein we show that change in the local curvature of the lipid bilayer can modulate MscL activity considerably by changing both bilayer thickness and lateral pressure profile. Intriguingly, although bending in any direction results in almost the same free-energy cost, inward (cytoplasmic) bending favors channel opening, whereas outward (periplasmic) bending facilitates closing of the narrowest part of the MscL pore. This quantitative study using MscL as a model channel may have wide reaching consequences for the effect of local curvature on the physiological function of other types of prokaryotic and eukaryotic membrane proteins.     

The Combined Effect of Hydrophobic Mismatch and Bilayer Local Bending on the Regulation of Mechanosensitive Ion Channels

The hydrophobic mismatch between the lipid bilayer and integral membrane proteins has well-defined effect on mechanosensitive (MS) ion channels. Also, membrane local bending is suggested to modulate MS channel activity. Although a number of studies have already shown the significance of each individual factor, the combined effect of these physical factors on MS channel activity have not been investigated. Here using finite element simulation, we study the combined effect of hydrophobic mismatch and local bending on the archetypal mechanosensitive channel MscL. First we show how the local curvature direction impacts on MS channel modulation. In the case of MscL, we show inward (cytoplasmic) bending can more effectively gate the channel compared to outward bending. Then we indicate that in response to a specific local curvature, MscL inserted in a bilayer with the same hydrophobic length is more expanded in the constriction pore region compared to when there is a protein-lipid hydrophobic mismatch. Interestingly in the presence of a negative mismatch (thicker lipids), MscL constriction pore is more expanded than in the presence of positive mismatch (thinner lipids) in response to an identical membrane curvature. These results were confirmed by a parametric energetic calculation provided for MscL gating. These findings have several biophysical consequences for understanding the function of MS channels in response to two major physical stimuli in mechanobiology, namely hydrophobic mismatch and local membrane curvature.     

Scanning MscL Channels with Targeted Post-Translational Modifications for Functional Alterations

Mechanosensitive channels are present in all living organisms and are thought to underlie the senses of touch and hearing as well as various important physiological functions like osmoregulation and vasoregulation. The mechanosensitive channel of large conductance (MscL) from Escherichia coli was the first protein shown to encode mechanosensitive channel activity and serves as a paradigm for how a channel senses and responds to mechanical stimuli. MscL plays a role in osmoprotection in E. coli, acting as an emergency release valve that is activated by membrane tension due to cell swelling after an osmotic down-shock. Using an osmotically fragile strain in an osmotic down-shock assay, channel functionality can be directly determined in vivo. In addition, using thiol reagents and expressed MscL proteins with a single cysteine substitution, we have shown that targeted post-translational modifications can be performed, and that any alterations that lead to dysfunctional proteins can be identified by this in vivo assay. Here, we present the results of such a scan performed on 113 MscL cysteine mutants using five different sulfhydryl-reacting probes to confer different charges or hydrophobicity to each site. We assessed which of these targeted modifications affected channel function and the top candidates were further studied using patch clamp to directly determine how channel activity was affected. This comprehensive screen has identified many residues that are critical for channel function as well as highlighted MscL domains and residues that undergo the most drastic environmental changes upon gating.     

Functional design of bacterial mechanosensitive channels. Comparisons and contrasts illuminated by random mutagenesis

MscS and MscL are mechanosensitive channels found in bacterial plasma membranes that open large pores in response to membrane tension. These channels function to alleviate excess cell turgor invoked by rapid osmotic downshock. Although much is known of the structure and molecular mechanisms underlying MscL, genes correlating with MscS activity have only recently been identified. Previously, it was shown that eliminating the expression of Escherichia coli yggB removed a major portion of MscS activity. YggB is distinct from MscL by having no obvious structural similarity. Here we have reconstituted purified YggB in proteoliposomes and have successfully detected MscS channel activity, confirming that purified YggB protein encodes MscS activity. Additionally, to define functional regions of the channel protein, we have randomly mutagenized the structural gene and isolated a mutant that evokes a gain-of-function phenotype. Physiological experiments demonstrate that the mutated channel allows leakage of solutes from the cell, suggesting inappropriate channel opening. Interestingly, this mutation is analogous in position and character to mutations yielding a similar phenotype in MscL. Hence, although MscS and MscL mechanosensitive channels are structurally quite distinct, there may be analogies in their gating mechanisms.     

Structure and function of the bacterial mechanosensitive channel of large conductance.

Mechanosensation in bacteria involves transducing membrane stress into an electrochemical response. In Escherichia coli and other bacteria, this function is carried out by a number of proteins including MscL, the mechanosensitive channel of large conductance. MscL is the best characterized of all mechanosensitive channels. It has been the subject of numerous structural and functional investigations. The explosion in experimental data on MscL recently culminated in the solution of the three-dimensional structure of the MscL homologue from Mycobacterium tuberculosis. In this review, much of these data are united and interpreted in terms of the newly published M. tuberculosis MscL crystal structure.     

Multifunctional,Micropipette-based Method for Incorporation And Stimulation of Bacterial Mechanosensitive Ion Channels in Droplet Interface Bilayers

MscL, a large conductance mechanosensitive channel (MSC), is a ubiquitous osmolyte release valve that helps bacteria survive abrupt hypo-osmotic shocks. It has been discovered and rigorously studied using the patch-clamp technique for almost three decades. Its basic role of translating tension applied to the cell membrane into permeability response makes it a strong candidate to function as a mechanoelectrical transducer in artificial membrane-based biomolecular devices. Serving as building blocks to such devices, droplet interface bilayers (DIBs) can be used as a new platform for the incorporation and stimulation of MscL channels. Here, we describe a micropipette-based method to form DIBs and measure the activity of the incorporated MscL channels. This method consists of lipid-encased aqueous droplets anchored to the tips of two opposing (coaxially positioned) borosilicate glass micropipettes. When droplets are brought into contact, a lipid bilayer interface is formed. This technique offers control over the chemical composition and the size of each droplet, as well as the dimensions of the bilayer interface. Having one of the micropipettes attached to a harmonic piezoelectric actuator provides the ability to deliver a desired oscillatory stimulus. Through analysis of the shapes of the droplets during deformation, the tension created at the interface can be estimated. Using this technique, the first activity of MscL channels in a DIB system is reported. Besides MS channels, activities of other types of channels can be studied using this method, proving the multi-functionality of this platform. The method presented here enables the measurement of fundamental membrane properties, provides a greater control over the formation of symmetric and asymmetric membranes, and is an alternative way to stimulate and study mechanosensitive channels.     

Bacterial mechanosensitive channels as a paradigm for mechanosensory transduction

Research on bacterial mechanosensitive (MS) channels has since their discovery been at the forefront of the MS channel field due to extensive studies of the structure and function of MscL and MscS, two of the several different types of MS channels found in bacteria. Just a few years after these two MS channels were cloned their 3D structure was solved by X-ray crystallography. Today, the repertoire of multidisciplinary approaches used in experimental and theoretical studies following the cloning and crystallographic determination of the MscL and MscS structure has expanded by including electronparamagnetic resonance (EPR) and F?rster resonance energy transfer (FRET) spectroscopy aided by computational modelling employing molecular dynamics as well as Brownian dynamics simulations, which significantly advanced the understanding of structural determinants of the gating and conduction properties of these two MS channels. These extensive multidisciplinary studies of MscL and MscS have greatly contributed to elucidation of the basic physical principles of MS channel gating by mechanical force. This review summarizes briefly the major experimental and conceptual advancements, which helped in establishing MscL and MscS as a major paradigm of mechanosensory transduction in living cells.     

Correlating a protein structure with function of a bacterial mechanosensitive channel

MscL, a mechanosensitive channel found in many bacteria, protects cells from hypotonic shock by reducing intracellular pressure through release of cytoplasmic osmolytes. First isolated from Escherichia coli, this protein has served as a model for how a protein senses and responds to membrane tension. Recently the structure of a functionally uncharacterized MscL homologue from Mycobacterium tuberculosis was solved by x-ray diffraction to a resolution of 3.5 A. Here we demonstrate that the protein forms a functional MscL-like mechanosensitive channel in E. coli membranes and azolectin proteoliposomes. Furthermore, we show that M. tuberculosis MscL crystals, when re-solubilized and reconstituted, yield wild-type channel currents in patch clamp, demonstrating that the protein does not irreversibly change conformation upon crystallization. Finally, we apply functional clues acquired from the E. coli MscL to the M. tuberculosis channel and show a mechanistic correlation between these channels. However, the inability of the M. tuberculosis channel to gate at physiological membrane tensions, demonstrated by in vivo E. coli expression and in vitro reconstitution, suggests that the membrane environment or other additional factors influence the gating of this channel.     

Bacterial mechanosensitive channels: Experiment and theory

Since their discovery in Escherichia coli some 20 years ago, studies of bacterial mechanosensitive (MS) ion channels have been at the forefront of the MS channel research field. Two major events greatly advanced the research on bacterial MS channels: (i) cloning of MscL and MscS, the MS channels of Large and Small conductance, and (ii) solving their 3D crystal structure. These events enabled further experimental studies employing EPR and FRET spectroscopy in addition to patch clamp and molecular biological techniques that have successfully been used in characterization of the structure and function of bacterial MS channels. In parallel with the experimental studies computational modelling has been applied to elucidate the molecular dynamics of MscL and MscS, which has significantly contributed to our understanding of basic physical principles of the mechanosensory transduction in living organisms.     

Mechanosensitive channels of bacteria and archaea share a common ancestral origin

The ubiquity of mechanosensitive (MS) ion channels set off a search for their functional homologues in archaea, the third domain of life. A new MS channel was identified in the archaeon Methanococcus jannaschii by using the TM1 transmembrane domain of the bacterial MS channel of large conductance, MscL, as a genetic probe to search the archaeal genomic database for MS channel homologues. The hypothetical protein MJ0170 (MscMJ) was found to harbor two MscL-like TM1 structural motifs and showed a high degree of se quence and secondary structure conservation with MscS (YggB) homologues. The alignment of sequences of MscL, MscS and MscMJ homologues further revealed that bacterial and archaeal channels form a phylogenetic tree composed of three main branches and share a common ancestral origin. This suggests the evolution of prokaryotic MS channels via gene duplication of a MscL-like progenitor gene followed by divergence, fur ther indicating that the common ancestor of the prokaryotic MS channels most likely resembled MscL. When expressed in E. coli and functionally examined by the patch clamp, the MscMJ protein behaved as a MS channel with a conductance of 270 pS in 200 mM KCl and a cation selectivity (PK/PC]) of approximately 6. The structural and functional homologue of MscMJ, MscMJLR, was identified as a second type of MS channel in M. jannaschii. The channel has a conductance of approximately 2 nS, rectifies with voltage and shares cation selectivity with MscMJ. The stoichiometry of both types of MS channels revealed that the free energy of activation, deltaG0 approximately 7kT, obtained for MscMJ matches the one calculated for MscS, deltaG0 approximately 5kT, whereas the free energy of activation approximately deltaG0 approximately 18kT of MscMJLR resembles more the deltaG0 = 14-19kT reported for MscL. The presence of two types of MS channels discovered in the cell envelope of M. jannaschii indicates that multiplicity of MS channels in prokaryotes is a necessary element for their survival in the habitats frequently challenged by sudden changes in osmolarity. Further functional and phylogenetic study of MS channels from all three domains of the universal phylogenetic tree may help to understand the evolution and common biophysical principles that govern mechanosensory transduction.     

Nanomechanical properties of MscL α helices: A steered molecular dynamics study

Gating of mechanosensitive (MS) channels is driven by a hierarchical cascade of movements and deformations of transmembrane helices in response to bilayer tension. Determining the intrinsic mechanical properties of the individual transmembrane helices is therefore central to understanding the intricacies of the gating mechanism of MS channels. We used a constant-force steered molecular dynamics (SMD) approach to perform unidirectional pulling tests on all the helices of MscL in M. tuberculosis and E. coli homologs. Using this method, we could overcome the issues encountered with the commonly used constant-velocity SMD simulations, such as low mechanical stability of the helix during stretching and high dependency of the elastic properties on the pulling rate. We estimated Young's moduli of the α-helices of MscL to vary between 0.2 and 12.5 GPa with TM2 helix being the stiffest. We also studied the effect of water on the properties of the pore-lining TM1 helix. In the absence of water, this helix exhibited a much stiffer response. By monitoring the number of hydrogen bonds, it appears that water acts like a ‘lubricant’ (softener) during TM1 helix elongation. These data shed light on another physical aspect underlying hydrophobic gating of MS channels, in particular MscL.     

Modulation of channel activity and gadolinium block of MscL by static magnetic fields

The magnetic field of the Earth has for long been known to influence the behaviour and orientation of a variety of living organisms. Experimental studies of the magnetic sense have, however, been impaired by the lack of a plausible cellular and/or molecular mechanism providing meaningful explanation for detection of magnetic fields by these organisms. Recently, mechanosensitive (MS) ion channels have been implied to play a role in magnetoreception. In this study we have investigated the effect of static magnetic fields (SMFs) of moderate intensity on the activity and gadolinium block of MscL, the bacterial MS channel of large conductance, which has served as a model channel to study the basic physical principles of mechanosensory transduction in living cells. In addition to showing that direct application of the magnetic field decreased the activity of the MscL channel, our study demonstrates for the first time that SMFs can reverse the effect of gadolinium, a well-known blocker of MS channels. The results of our study are consistent with a notion that (1) the effects of SMFs on the MscL channels may result from changes in physical properties of the lipid bilayer due to diamagnetic anisotropy of phospholipid molecules and consequently (2) cooperative superdiamagnetism of phospholipid molecules under influence of SMFs could cause displacement of Gd³⁺ ions from the membrane bilayer and thus remove the MscL channel block.     

Bilayer-mediated clustering and functional interaction of MscL channels

Mechanosensitive channels allow bacteria to respond to osmotic stress by opening a nanometer-sized pore in the cellular membrane. Although the underlying mechanism has been thoroughly studied on the basis of individual channels, the behavior of channel ensembles has yet to be elucidated. This work reveals that mechanosensitive channels of large conductance (MscL) exhibit a tendency to spatially cluster, and demonstrates the functional relevance of clustering. We evaluated the spatial distribution of channels in a lipid bilayer using patch-clamp electrophysiology, fluorescence and atomic force microscopy, and neutron scattering and reflection techniques, coupled with mathematical modeling of the mechanics of a membrane crowded with proteins. The results indicate that MscL forms clusters under a wide range of conditions. MscL is closely packed within each cluster but is still active and mechanosensitive. However, the channel activity is modulated by the presence of neighboring proteins, indicating membrane-mediated protein-protein interactions. Collectively, these results suggest that MscL self-assembly into channel clusters plays an osmoregulatory functional role in the membrane.     

Visualisation of the mechanosensitive channel of large conductance in bacteria using confocal microscopy

The mechanosensitive channel of large conductance (MscL) plays an important role in the survival of bacterial cells to hypo-osmotic shock. This channel has been extensively studied and its sequence, structure and electrophysiological characteristics are well known. Here we present a method to visualise MscL in living bacteria using confocal microscopy. By creating a gene fusion between mscl and the gene encoding the green fluorescent protein (GFP) we were able to express the fusion protein MscL-GFP in bacteria. We show that MscL-GFP is present in the cytoplasmic membrane and forms functional channels. These channels have the same characteristics as wild-type MscL, except that they require more pressure to open. This method could prove an interesting, non-invasive, tool to study the localisation and the regulation of expression of MscL in bacteria.     

Mechanosensitive channel of Thermoplasma, the cell wall-less archaea

By using a functional approach of reconstituting detergent-solubilized membrane proteins into liposomes and following their function in patch-clamp experiments, we identified a novel mechanosensitive (MS) channel in the thermophilic cell wall-less archaeon Thermoplasma volcanium. Sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) of the enriched protein fractions revealed a band of approx 15 kDa comparable to MscL, the bacterial MS channel of large conductance. 20 N-terminal residues determined by protein microsequencing, matched the sequence to an unknown open reading frame in the genome of a related species Thermoplasma acidophilum. The protein encoded by the T. acidophilum gene was cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli and reconstituted into liposomes. When examined for function, the reconstituted protein exhibited properties typical of an MS ion channel: 1) activation by negative pressure applied to the patch-clamp pipet, 2) blockage by gadolinium, and 3) activation by the anionic amphipath trinitrophenol. In analogy to the nomenclature used for bacterial MS channels, the MS channel of T. acidophilum was termed MscTA. Secondary structural analysis indicated that similar to MscL, the T. acidophilum MS protein may have two transmembrane domains, suggesting that MS channels of thermophilic Archaea belong to a family of structurally related MscL-like ion channels with two membrane-spanning regions. When the mscTA gene was expressed in the mscL ⁻ knockout strain and the MscTA protein reconstituted into liposomes, the gating of MscTA was charaterized by very brief openings of variable conductance. In contrast, when the mscTA gene was expressed in the wild-type mscL ⁺ strain of E. coli, the gating properties of the channel resembled MscL. However, the channel had reduced conductance and differed from MscL in its kinetics and in the free energy of activation, suggesting that MscTA and MscL can form functional complexes and/or modulate each other activity. Similar to MscL, MscTA exhibited an increase in activity in liposomes made of phospholipids having shorter acyl chain, suggesting a role of hydrophobic mismatch in the function of prokaryotic MS channels.     

Physical principles underlying the transduction of bilayer deformation forces during mechanosensitive channel gating

In mechanosensitive (MS) channels, gating is initiated by changes in intra-bilayer pressure profiles originating from bilayer deformation. Here we evaluated two physical mechanisms as triggers of MS channel gating: the energetic cost of protein-bilayer hydrophobic mismatches and the geometric consequences of bilayer intrinsic curvature. Structural changes in the Escherichia coli large MS channel (MscL) were studied under nominally zero transbilayer pressures using both patch clamp and EPR spectroscopic approaches. Changes in membrane intrinsic curvature induced by the external addition of lysophosphatidylcholine (LPC) generated massive spectroscopic changes in the narrow constriction that forms the channel 'gate', trapping the channel in the fully open state. Hydrophobic mismatch alone was unable to open the channel, but decreasing bilayer thickness lowered MscL activation energy, stabilizing a structurally distinct closed channel intermediate. We propose that the mechanism of mechanotransduction in MS channels is defined by both local and global asymmetries in the transbilayer pressure profile at the lipid-protein interface.     

Structural and functional differences between two homologous mechanosensitive channels of Methanococcus jannaschii

We report the molecular cloning and characterization of MscMJLR, a second type of mechanosensitive (MS) channel found in the archaeon Methanococcus jannaschii. MscMJLR is structurally very similar to MscMJ, the MS channel of M.jannaschii that was identified and cloned first by using the TM1 domain of Escherichia coli MscL as a genetic probe. Although it shares 44% amino acid sequence identity and similar cation selectivity with MscMJ, MscMJLR exhibits other major functional differences. The conductance of MscMJLR of approximately 2 nS is approximately 7-fold larger than the conductance of MscMJ and rectifies with voltage. The channel requires approximately 18 kT for activation, which is three times the amount of energy required to activate MscMJ, but is comparable to the activation energy of Eco-MSCL: Our study indicates that a multiplicity of conductance-wise and energetically well-tuned MS channels in microbial cell membranes may provide for cell survival by the sequential opening of the channels upon challenge with different osmotic cues.     

Mechanical Activation of MscL Revealed by a Locally Distributed Tension Molecular Dynamics Approach

Membrane tension perceived by mechanosensitive (MS) proteins mediates cellular responses to mechanical stimuli and osmotic stresses, and it also guides multiple biological functions including cardiovascular control and development. In bacteria, MS channels function as tension-activated pores limiting excessive turgor pressure, with MS channel of large conductance (MscL) acting as an emergency release valve preventing cell lysis. Previous attempts to simulate gating transitions in MscL by either directly applying steering forces to the protein or by increasing the whole-system tension were not fully successful and often disrupted the integrity of the system. We present a novel, to our knowledge, locally distributed tension molecular dynamics (LDT-MD) simulation method that allows application of forces continuously distributed among lipids surrounding the channel using a specially constructed collective variable. We report reproducible and reversible transitions of MscL to the open state with measured parameters of lateral expansion and conductivity that exactly satisfy experimental values. The LDT-MD method enables exploration of the MscL-gating process with different pulling velocities and variable tension asymmetry between the inner and outer membrane leaflets. We use LDT-MD in combination with well-tempered metadynamics to reconstruct the tension-dependent free-energy landscape for the opening transition in MscL. The flexible definition of the LDT collective variable allows general application of our method to study mechanical activation of any membrane-embedded protein.     

The gating mechanism of the bacterial mechanosensitive channel MscL revealed by molecular dynamics simulations

One of the ultimate goals of the study on mechanosensitive (MS) channels is to understand the biophysical mechanisms of how the MS channel protein senses forces and how the sensed force induces channel gating. The bacterial MS channel MscL is an ideal subject to reach this goal owing to its resolved 3D protein structure in the closed state on the atomic scale and large amounts of electrophysiological data on its gating kinetics. However, the structural basis of the dynamic process from the closed to open states in MscL is not fully understood. In this study, we performed molecular dynamics (MD) simulations on the initial process of MscL opening in response to a tension increase in the lipid bilayer. To identify the tension-sensing site(s) in the channel protein, we calculated interaction energy between membrane lipids and candidate amino acids (AAs) facing the lipids. We found that Phe78 has a conspicuous interaction with the lipids, suggesting that Phe78 is the primary tension sensor of MscL. Increased membrane tension by membrane stretch dragged radially the inner (TM1) and outer (TM2) helices of MscL at Phe78, and the force was transmitted to the pentagon-shaped gate that is formed by the crossing of the neighboring TM1 helices in the inner leaflet of the bilayer. The radial dragging force induced radial sliding of the crossing portions, leading to a gate expansion. Calculated energy for this expansion is comparable to an experimentally estimated energy difference between the closed and the first subconductance state, suggesting that our model simulates the initial step toward the full opening of MscL. The model also successfully mimicked the behaviors of a gain of function mutant (G22N) and a loss of function mutant (F78N), strongly supporting that our MD model did simulate some essential biophysical aspects of the mechano-gating in MscL.