Mammalian Prion protein expression in yeast; a model for transmembrane insertion

The prion protein (PrP), a GPI-anchored glycoprotein, is inefficiently secreted by mammalian microsomes, 50% being found as transmembrane (TM) proteins with the central TM1 segment spanning the membrane. TM1 hydrophobicity is marginal for lateral membrane insertion, which is primarily driven by hydrophobic interaction between the ER translocon and substrates in transit. Most inserted TM1 has its N-terminus in the ER lumen (Ntm orientation), as expected for arrest of normal secretion. However, 20% is found in inverted Ctm orientation. These are minor species in vivo, presumably a consequence of efficient quality control. PrP mutations that increase TM1 hydrophobicity result in increased Ctm insertion, both in vitro and in mouse brain, and a strong correlation is found between CtmPrP insertion and neuropathology in transgenic mice; a copper-dependent pathogenicity mechanism is suggested. PrP fusions with a C-terminal epitope tag, when expressed in yeast cells at moderate levels, appear to interact efficiently with the translocon, providing a useful model for testing the effects of PrP mutations on TM insertion and orientation. However, secretion of PrP by the mammalian translocon requires the TRAP complex, absent in yeast, where essentially all PrP ends up as TM species, 85–90% Ntm and 10–15% Ctm. Although yeast is, therefore, an incomplete mimic of mammalian PrP trafficking, effects on Ctm insertion of mutations increasing TM1 hydrophobicity closely reflect those seen in vitro. Electrostatic substrate-translocon interactions are a major determinant of TM protein insertion orientation and the yeast model was used to investigate the role of the large negative charge difference across TM1, a likely cause of translocation delay that would favor TM insertion and Ctm orientation. An increase in ΔCh from −5 to −7 caused a marked increase in Ctm insertion, while a decrease to −3 or −1 allowed 35 and about 65% secretion, respectively. Utility of the yeast model and the role of this charge difference in driving PrP membrane insertion are confirmed.     

Combinatorial control of prion protein biogenesis by the signal sequence and transmembrane domain

The prion protein (PrP) is synthesized in three topologic forms at the endoplasmic reticulum. (sec)PrP is fully translocated into the endoplasmic reticulum lumen, whereas (Ntm)PrP and (Ctm)PrP are single-spanning membrane proteins of opposite orientation. Increased generation of (Ctm)PrP in either transgenic mice or humans is associated with the development of neurodegenerative disease. To study the mechanisms by which PrP can achieve three topologic outcomes, we analyzed the translocation of proteins containing mutations introduced into either the N-terminal signal sequence or potential transmembrane domain (TMD) of PrP. Although mutations in either domain were found to affect PrP topogenesis, they did so in qualitatively different ways. In addition to its traditional role in mediating protein targeting, the signal was found to play a surprising role in determining orientation of the PrP N terminus. By contrast, the TMD was found to influence membrane integration. Analysis of various signal and TMD double mutants demonstrated that the topologic consequence of TMD action was directly dependent on the previous, signal-mediated step. Together, these results reveal that PrP topogenesis is controlled at two discrete steps during its translocation and provide a framework for understanding how these steps act coordinately to determine the final topology achieved by PrP.     

A transmembrane form of the prion protein is localized in the Golgi apparatus of neurons

(Ctm)PrP is a transmembrane version of the prion protein that has been proposed to be a neurotoxic intermediate underlying prion-induced pathogenesis. In previous studies, we found that PrP molecules carrying mutations in the N-terminal signal peptide (L9R) and the transmembrane domain (3AV) were synthesized exclusively in the (Ctm)PrP form in transfected cell lines. To characterize the properties of (Ctm)PrP in a neuronal setting, we have utilized cerebellar granule neurons cultured from Tg(L9R-3AV) mice that developed a fatal neurodegenerative illness. We found that about half of the L9R-3AV PrP synthesized in these neurons represents (Ctm)PrP, with the rest being (Sec)PrP, the glycolipid anchored form that does not span the membrane. Both forms contained an uncleaved signal peptide, and they are differentially glycosylated. (Sec)PrP was localized on the surface of neuronal processes. Most surprisingly, (Ctm)PrP was concentrated in the Golgi apparatus, rather in the endoplasmic reticulum as it is in transfected cell lines. Our study is the first to analyze the properties of (Ctm)PrP in a neuronal context, and our results suggest new hypotheses about how this form may exert its neurotoxic effects.     

Prion protein contains a second endoplasmic reticulum targeting signal sequence located at its C terminus

Prion protein (PrP) is synthesized at the membrane of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) in three different topological forms as follows: a fully translocated one ((sec)PrP) and two with opposite orientations in the membrane ((Ntm)PrP and (Ctm)PrP). We asked whether other signal sequences exist in the PrP, other than the N-terminal signal sequence, that contribute to its topological diversity. In vitro translocation assays showed that PrP lacking its N-terminal signal sequence could still translocate into ER microsomes, although at reduced efficiency. Deletion of each of the two hydrophobic regions in PrP revealed that the C-terminally located hydrophobic region (TM2) can function as second signal sequence in PrP. Translocation mediated by the TM2 alone can occur post-translationally and yields mainly (Ctm)PrP, which is implicated in some forms of neurodegeneration in prion diseases. We conclude that, in vitro, PrP can insert into ER membranes co- and post-translationally and can use two different signal sequences. We propose that the unusually complex topology of PrP results from the differential utilization of two signal sequences in PrP.     

A transmembrane form of the prion protein contains an uncleaved signal peptide and is retained in the endoplasmic Reticulum

Although there is considerable evidence that PrP(Sc) is the infectious form of the prion protein, it has recently been proposed that a transmembrane variant called (Ctm)PrP is the direct cause of prion-associated neurodegeneration. We report here, using a mutant form of PrP that is synthesized exclusively with the (Ctm)PrP topology, that (Ctm)PrP is retained in the endoplasmic reticulum and is degraded by the proteasome. We also demonstrate that (Ctm)PrP contains an uncleaved, N-terminal signal peptide as well as a C-terminal glycolipid anchor. These results provide insight into general mechanisms that control the topology of membrane proteins during their synthesis in the endoplasmic reticulum, and they also suggest possible cellular pathways by which (Ctm)PrP may cause disease.     

Contact-induced structure transformation in transmembrane prion propagation

Based on recent experimental evidences of the transmission of prion diseases due to a particular transmembrane form (termed (Ctm)PrP), we propose a theoretical model for the molecular mechanism of such conformational diseases, in which a misfolded (Ctm)PrP induces a similar misfolding of another (Ctm)PrP. Computer simulations are performed to investigate the correlation between folding time and the concentration of misfolded PrP in various processes, including dimerization, trimerization, and cooperative dimerization. By comparing with the experimental correlation curve between incubation time and injected dose of scrapie prions, we conclude that cooperative dimerization may play an important role in the pathological mechanism of prion diseases.     

Cotranslational partitioning of nascent prion protein into multiple populations at the translocation channel

The decisive events that direct a single polypeptide such as the prion protein (PrP) to be synthesized at the endoplasmic reticulum in both fully translocated and transmembrane forms are poorly understood. In this study, we demonstrate that the topological heterogeneity of PrP is determined cotranslationally, while at the translocation channel. By evaluating sequential intermediates during PrP topogenesis, we find that signal sequence-mediated initiation of translocation results in an interaction between nascent PrP and endoplasmic reticulum chaperones, committing the N terminus to the lumen. Synthesis of the transmembrane domain before completion of this step allows it to direct the generation of (Ctm)PrP, a transmembrane form with its N terminus in the cytosol. Thus, segregation of nascent PrP into different topological configurations is critically dependent on the precise timing of signal-mediated initiation of N-terminus translocation. Consequently, this step could be experimentally tuned to modify PrP topogenesis, including complete reversal of the elevated (Ctm)PrP caused by disease-associated mutations in the transmembrane domain. These results delineate the sequence of events involved in PrP biogenesis, explain the mechanism of action of (Ctm)PrP-favoring mutations associated with neurodegenerative disease, and more generally, reveal that translocation substrates can be cotranslationally partitioned into multiple populations at the translocon.     

Cell-specific metabolism and pathogenesis of transmembrane prion protein

The C-transmembrane form of prion protein ((Ctm)PrP) has been implicated in prion disease pathogenesis, but the factors underlying its biogenesis and cyotoxic potential remain unclear. Here we show that (Ctm)PrP interferes with cytokinesis in cell lines where it is transported to the plasma membrane. These cells fail to separate following cell division, assume a variety of shapes and sizes, and contain multiple nuclei, some of which are pyknotic. Furthermore, the synthesis and transport of (Ctm)PrP to the plasma membrane are modulated through a complex interaction between cis- and trans-acting factors and the endoplasmic reticulum translocation machinery. Thus, insertion of eight amino acids before or within the N region of the N signal peptide (N-SP) of PrP results in the exclusive synthesis of (Ctm)PrP regardless of the charge conferred to the N region. Subsequent processing and transport of (Ctm)PrP are modulated by specific amino acids in the N region of the N-SP and by the cell line of expression. Although the trigger for (Ctm)PrP upregulation in naturally occurring prion disorders remains elusive, these data highlight the underlying mechanisms of (Ctm)PrP biogenesis and neurotoxicity and reinforce the idea that (Ctm)PrP may serve as the proximate cause of neuronal death in certain prion disorders.     

Mutational analysis of topological determinants in prion protein (PrP) and measurement of transmembrane and cytosolic PrP during prion infection

The prion protein (PrP) can adopt multiple membrane topologies, including a fully translocated form (SecPrP), two transmembrane forms (NtmPrP and CtmPrP), and a cytosolic form. It is important to understand the factors that influence production of these species, because two of them, CtmPrP and cytosolic PrP, have been proposed to be key neurotoxic intermediates in certain prion diseases. In this paper, we perform a mutational analysis of PrP synthesized using an in vitro translation system in order to further define sequence elements that influence the formation of CtmPrP. We find that substitution of charged residues in the hydrophobic core of the signal peptide increases synthesis of CtmPrP and also reduces the efficiency of translocation into microsomes. Combining these mutations with substitutions in the transmembrane domain causes the protein to be synthesized exclusively with the CtmPrP topology. Reducing the spacing between the signal peptide and the transmembrane domain also increases CtmPrP. In contrast, topology is not altered by mutations that prevent signal peptide cleavage or by deletion of the C-terminal signal for glycosylphosphatidylinositol anchor addition. Removal of the signal peptide completely blocks translocation. Taken together, our results are consistent with a model in which the signal peptide and transmembrane domain function in distinct ways as determinants of PrP topology. We also present characterization of an antibody that selectively recognizes CtmPrP and cytosolic PrP by virtue of their uncleaved signal peptides. By using this antibody, as well as the distinctive gel mobility of CtmPrP and cytosolic PrP, we show that the amounts of these two forms in cultured cells and rodent brain are not altered by infection with scrapie prions. We conclude that CtmPrP and cytosolic PrP are unlikely to be obligate neurotoxic intermediates in familial or infectiously acquired prion diseases.     

Compartment-restricted biotinylation reveals novel features of prion protein metabolism in vivo

Proteins are often made in more than one form, with alternate versions sometimes residing in different cellular compartments than the primary species. The mammalian prion protein (PrP), a cell surface GPI-anchored protein, is a particularly noteworthy example for which minor cytosolic and transmembrane forms have been implicated in disease pathogenesis. To study these minor species, we used a selective labeling strategy in which spatially restricted expression of a biotinylating enzyme was combined with asymmetric engineering of the cognate acceptor sequence into PrP. Using this method, we could show that even wild-type PrP generates small amounts of the (Ctm)PrP transmembrane form. Selective detection of (Ctm)PrP allowed us to reveal its N-terminal processing, long half-life, residence in both intracellular and cell surface locations, and eventual degradation in the lysosome. Surprisingly, some human disease-causing mutants in PrP selectively stabilized (Ctm)PrP, revealing a previously unanticipated mechanism of (Ctm)PrP up-regulation that may contribute to disease. Thus, spatiotemporal tagging has uncovered novel aspects of normal and mutant PrP metabolism and should be readily applicable to the analysis of minor topologic isoforms of other proteins.     

Cell surface accumulation of a truncated transmembrane prion protein in Gerstmann-Straussler-Scheinker disease P102L

A familial prion disorder with a proline to leucine substitution at residue 102 of the prion protein (PrP(102L)) is typically associated with protease-resistant PrP fragments (PrP(Sc)) in the brain parenchyma that are infectious to recipient animals. When modeled in transgenic mice, a fatal neurodegenerative disease develops, but, unlike the human counterpart, PrP(Sc) is lacking and transmission to recipient animals is questionable. Alternate mice expressing a single copy of PrP(102L) (mouse PrP(101L)) do not develop spontaneous disease, but show dramatic susceptibility to PrP(Sc) isolates from different species. To understand these discrepant results, we studied the biogenesis of human PrP(102L) in a cell model. Here, we report that cells expressing PrP(102L) show decreased expression of the normal 18-kDa fragment on the plasma membrane. Instead, a 20-kDa fragment, probably derived from transmembrane PrP ((Ctm)PrP), accumulates on the cell surface. Because the 20-kDa fragment includes an amyloidogenic region of PrP that is disrupted in the 18-kDa form, increased surface expression of 20-kDa fragment may enhance the susceptibility of these cells to PrP(Sc) infection by providing an optimal substrate, or by amplifying the neurotoxic signal of PrP(Sc). Thus, altered susceptibility of PrP(101L) mice to exogenous PrP(Sc) may be mediated by the 20-kDa (Ctm)PrP fragment, rather than PrP(102L) per se.     

Cytosolic prion protein is the predominant anti-Bax prion protein form: exclusion of transmembrane and secreted prion protein forms in the anti-Bax function

Prion protein (PrP) prevents Bax-mediated cell death by inhibiting the initial Bax conformational change that converts cytosolic Bax into a pro-apoptotic protein. PrP is mostly a glycophosphatidylinositol-anchored cell surface protein but it is also retrotranslocated into cytosolic PrP (CyPrP) or can become a type 1 or type 2 transmembrane protein. To determine the form and subcellular location of the PrP that has anti-Bax function, we co-expressed various Syrian hamster PrP (SHaPrP) mutants that favour specific PrP topologies and subcellular localization with N-terminally green fluorescent protein tagged pro-apoptotic Bax (EGFP-Bax) in MCF-7 cells and primary human neurons. Mutants that generate both CyPrP and secreted PrP ((Sec)PrP) or only CyPrP have anti-Bax activity. Mutants that produce (Ctm)PrP or (Ntm)PrP lose the anti-Bax activity, despite their ability to also make (Sec)PrP. Transmembrane-generating mutants do not produce CyPrP and both normal and cognate mutant forms of CyPrP rescue against the loss of anti-Bax activity. (Sec)PrP-generating constructs also produce non-membrane attached (Sec)PrP. However, this form of PrP has minimal anti-Bax activity. We conclude that CyPrP is the predominant form of PrP with anti-Bax function. These results imply that the retrotranslocation of PrP encompasses a survival function and is not merely a pathway for the proteasomal degradation of misfolded protein.     

Interactions between the conserved hydrophobic region of the prion protein and dodecylphosphocholine micelles

The three-dimensional structure of PrP110-136, a peptide encompassing the conserved hydrophobic region of the human prion protein, has been determined at high resolution in dodecylphosphocholine micelles by NMR. The results support the conclusion that the (Ctm)PrP, a transmembrane form of the prion protein, adopts a different conformation than the reported structures of the normal prion protein determined in solution. Paramagnetic relaxation enhancement studies with gadolinium-diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid indicated that the conserved hydrophobic region peptide is not inserted symmetrically in the micelle, thus suggesting the presence of a guanidium-phosphate ion pair involving the side chain of the terminal arginine and the detergent headgroup. Titration of dodecylphosphocholine into a solution of PrP110-136 revealed the presence of a surface-bound species. In addition, paramagnetic probes located the surface-bound peptide somewhere below the micelle-water interface when using the inserted helix as a positional reference. This localization of the unknown population would allow a similar ion pair interaction.     

Mutant prion proteins are partially retained in the endoplasmic reticulum

Familial prion diseases are linked to point and insertional mutations in the prion protein (PrP) gene that are presumed to favor conversion of the cellular isoform of PrP to the infectious isoform. In this report, we have investigated the subcellular localization of PrP molecules carrying pathogenic mutations using immunofluorescence staining, immunogold labeling, and PrP-green fluorescent protein chimeras. To facilitate visualization of the mutant proteins, we have utilized a novel Sindbis viral replicon engineered to produce high protein levels without cytopathology. We demonstrate that several different pathogenic mutations have a common effect on the trafficking of PrP, impairing delivery of the molecules to the cell surface and causing a portion of them to accumulate in the endoplasmic reticulum. These observations suggest that protein quality control in the endoplasmic reticulum may play an important role in prion diseases, as it does in some other inherited human disorders. Our experiments also show that chimeric PrP molecules with the sequence of green fluorescent protein inserted adjacent to the glycolipidation site are post-translationally modified and localized normally, thus documenting the utility of these constructs in cell biological studies of PrP.     

Evidence for a secretory form of the cellular prion protein

The biogenesis of hamster brain prion protein (PrP) has been studied by expression of RNA transcribed from a full-length PrP cDNA in Xenopus oocytes and cell-free systems. Earlier studies in the wheat germ cell-free system showed that one form of PrP is a transmembrane protein that spans the bilayer at least twice [Hay, B., Barry, R. A., Lieberburg, I., Prusiner, S. B., & Lingappa, V. R. (1987) Mol. Cell. Biol. 7, 914-920]. We now report that PrP can also exist as a secreted protein. SP6 PrP RNA microinjected into Xenopus oocytes produced two forms of PrP: one that remained in the cell and another that was secreted into the medium. Cell-free translation studies in rabbit reticulocyte lysates supplemented with microsomal membranes gave similar results: while one form of PrP was found as an integral membrane protein spanning the membrane at least twice, another form of PrP was found to be completely translocated to the microsomal membrane vesicle lumen. Both the membrane and secretory forms of PrP appear to be generated from the same pool of nascent chains. The mechanism governing the alternative fates of nascent PrP remains to be elucidated but may have significance for understanding the pathogenesis of scrapie and other prion diseases.     

Molecular evolution of the mammalian prion protein

Prion protein (PrP) sequences are until now available for only six of the 18 orders of placental mammals. A broader comparison of mammalian prions might help to understand the enigmatic functional and pathogenic properties of this protein. We therefore determined PrP coding sequences in 26 mammalian species to include all placental orders and major subordinal groups. Glycosylation sites, cysteines forming a disulfide bridge, and a hydrophobic transmembrane region are perfectly conserved. Also, the sequences responsible for secondary structure elements, for N- and C-terminal processing of the precursor protein, and for attachment of the glycosyl-phosphatidylinositol membrane anchor are well conserved. The N-terminal region of PrP generally contains five or six repeats of the sequence P(Q/H)GGG(G/-)WGQ, but alleles with two, four, and seven repeats were observed in some species. This suggests, together with the pattern of amino acid replacements in these repeats, the regular occurrence of repeat expansion and contraction. Histidines implicated in copper ion binding and a proline involved in 4-hydroxylation are lacking in some species, which questions their importance for normal functioning of cellular PrP. The finding in certain species of two or seven repeats, and of amino acid substitutions that have been related to human prion diseases, challenges the relevance of such mutations for prion pathology. The gene tree deduced from the PrP sequences largely agrees with the species tree, indicating that no major deviations occurred in the evolution of the prion gene in different placental lineages. In one species, the anteater, a prion pseudogene was present in addition to the active gene.     

Failure of Prion Protein Oxidative Folding Guides the Formation of Toxic Transmembrane Forms

The mechanism by which pathogenic mutations in the globular domain of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) increase the likelihood of misfolding and predispose to diseases is not yet known. Differences in the evidences provided by structural and metabolic studies of these mutants suggest that in vivo folding could be playing an essential role in their pathogenesis. To address this role, here we use the single or combined M206S and M213S artificial mutants causing labile folds and express them in cells. We find that these mutants are highly toxic, fold as transmembrane PrP, and lack the intramolecular disulfide bond. When the mutations are placed in a chain with impeded transmembrane PrP formation, toxicity is rescued. These results suggest that oxidative folding impairment, as on aging, can be fundamental for the genesis of intracellular neurotoxic intermediates key in prion neurodegenerations.     

Glycosylation deficiency at either one of the two glycan attachment sites of cellular prion protein preserves susceptibility to bovine spongiform encephalopathy and scrapie infections

The conversion into abnormally folded prion protein (PrP) plays a key role in prion diseases. PrP(C) carries two N-linked glycan chains at amino acid residues 180 and 196 (mouse). Previous in vitro data indicated that the conversion process may not require glycosylation of PrP. However, it is conceivable that these glycans function as intermolecular binding sites during the de novo infection of cells on susceptible organisms and/or play a role for the interaction of both PrP isoforms. Such receptor-like properties could contribute to the formation of specific prion strains. However, in earlier studies, mutations at the glycosylation sites of PrP led to intracellular trafficking abnormalities, which made it impossible to generate PrP glycosylation-deficient mice that were susceptible to bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) or scrapie. We have now tested more than 25 different mutations at both consensus sites and found one nonglycosylated (T182N/T198A) and two monoglycosylated (T182N and T198A) mutants that rather retained authentic cellular trafficking properties. In vitro all three mutants were converted into PrP(res). PrP mutant T182N/T198A also provoked a strong dominant-negative inhibition on the endogenous wild type PrP conversion reaction. By using the two monoglycosylated mutants, we generated transgenic mice overexpressing PrP(C) in their brains at levels of 2-4 times that of nontransgenic mice. Most interestingly, such mice proved readily susceptible to a challenge with either scrapie (Chandler and Me7) or with BSE. Incubation times were comparable or in some instances even significantly shorter than those of nontransgenic mice. These data indicate that diglycosylation of PrP(C) is not mandatory for prion infection in vivo.     

Topics in prion cell biology.

Recent studies of a transmembrane form of the prion protein (PrP) have indicated its importance for neuropathogenesis in certain contexts, and have analysed the transacting factors at the endoplasmic reticulum and the mutations within PrP that regulate its appearance. A significant focus for our understanding of the normal role of PrP has emerged from its interaction with copper ions. Studies on two yeast prions have analysed the structure and phenotype of the aggregated conformers underlying the prion state, as well as the interactions regulating their formation and turnover within a dividing cell.