Variability of the immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region locus: a population study

The Immunoglobulin Heavy chain Constant region (IGHC) locus is a multigene family composed of highly homologous segments often involved in unequal crossings over that lead to deleted and duplicated haplotypes. The frequencies of these haplotypes in 558 individuals from Lombardy, Veneto, Puglia and Sardinia were determined by Pulsed Field Gel Electrophoresis (PFGE), followed by Southern blotting with four IGHC probes, and compared with those observed in 110 subjects from Piedmont. Twenty deletions and 60 duplications were characterized, all in heterozygous individuals except for 2 homozygous deletions. The differences in frequency between the five populations were not significant. The deletions/duplications involved one or more genes: GP-A2, A1-E and G4 duplications, and A1-E and GP-A2 deletions were the most common. Four new duplications are described: three, involving the genes from GP to A2, from G2 to G4, and G4, are counterparts of known deletions. The fourth duplication spans from GP to G2. A G1 deleted heterozygous individual never previously described in Italy is reported. All the rearranged haplotypes seem to be the result of unequal crossing over. The difference between the number of duplications and deletions was significant in Sardinia, Lombardy, Puglia and in the total of 668 subjects (P < 0.001). This may be due to selection or genetic drift.     

Familial clustering of IGHC deletions and duplications: functional and molecular analysis

The human immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region locus (IGHC) comprises nine genes and two pseudogenes clustered in a 350 kilobase (kb) region on chromosome 14q32. Several IGHC haplotypes with single or multiple gene deletions and duplications have been characterized. The most likely mechanism accounting for these unusual haplotypes is the unequal crossing-over between homologous regions within the locus. Here we report the analysis of an unusual case of familial clustering of deletions/duplications. In the two branches of the BON family, three duplicated and two deleted haplotypes, all probably independent in origin, have been characterized. The structure of the haplotypes, one of which is described here for the first time, supports the hypothesis of homologous unequal crossing-over as the origin of recombinant haplotypes. The analysis of serological markers in a subject carrying one deleted and one duplicated haplotype allowed us the first direct inferences concerning the functions of the duplicated IGHC haplotypes.     

A recurrent breakpoint in the most common deletion of the Ig heavy chain locus (del A1-GP-G2-G4-E).

Human Ig heavy chain constant regions are encoded by a cluster of genes, the IGHC locus, on 14q32.3. Several forms of IGHC deletions and duplications spanning one to five genes have been described in different populations, with frequencies of 1.5-3.5% and 4.5-44%, respectively. Despite the common occurrence of these gene rearrangements, little is known about the breakpoint sites; evidence obtained from deletions in the IGHC locus and in other regions of the human genome suggests that they preferentially occur in highly homologous regions and might be favored by a variety of recombinogenic signals. We present here a detailed study of three homozygotes for the most common type of IGHC multiple gene deletion, spanning the A1-GP-G2-G4-E genes. Using a combination of Southern blotting, long-range PCR, and automated sequencing, the unequal crossover events of all of the six studied haplotypes have been mapped to a region of approximately 2 kb with almost complete homology between EP1-A1 and E-A2, flanked by two minisatellites. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that segments of complete homology may be required for efficient homologous recombination in humans. The possible role of minisatellites as recombination signals is inferred, in agreement with current knowledge.     

On the evolution of multigene families

Multigene families are classified into three groups: small families as exemplified by hemoglobin genes of mammals; middlesize multigene families, by genes of mammalian histocompatibility antigens; and large multigene families, by variable region genes of immunoglobulins. Facts and theories on these evolving multigene families are reviewed, with special reference to the population genetics of their concerted evolution. It is shown that multigene families are evolving under continued occurrence of unequal (but homologous) crossing-over and gene conversion, and that mechanisms for maintaining genetic variability are totally different from the conventional models of population genetics. Thus, in view of widespread occurrence of multigene families in genomes of higher organisms, the evolutionary theory based mainly on change of gene frequency at each locus would appear to need considerable revision.     

Multiple levels of analysis of an IGHG4 gene deletion

Summary Human immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region (IGHC) genes constitute a typical multigene family, usually comprising eleven genes on the telomere of chromosome 14 (14q32). In this region, deleted and duplicated haplotypes have been reported to exist with considerable frequency. Their origin is the result of either unequal crossing-over or looping out excision. In this paper, we report the characterization of a new type of deletion, involving the IGHG4 gene, in a subject who also carries a larger deletion of a previously described type on the second chromosome. Employment of several methods (polymerase chain reaction, standard Southern blot, pulsed field gel electrophoresis, serological techniques) to analyze these deleted haplotypes has resulted in a level of accuracy in their characterization that has not been achieved in previous cases. The site of recombination responsible for the IGHG4 deletion was restricted to a 2.5-kb region 3 of the G4 gene; this rules out any possible involvement of the S regions in the recombination process. The usefulness of the various techniques in the characterization of the deletions is also discussed, together with possible future applications in the field.     

New genes originated via multiple recombinational pathways in the beta-globin gene family of rodents

Species differences in the size or membership composition of multigene families can be attributed to lineage-specific additions of new genes via duplication, losses of genes via deletion or inactivation, and the creation of chimeric genes via domain shuffling or gene fusion. In principle, it should be possible to infer the recombinational pathways responsible for each of these different types of genomic change by conducting detailed comparative analyses of genomic sequence data. Here, we report an attempt to unravel the complex evolutionary history of the beta-globin gene family in a taxonomically diverse set of rodent species. The main objectives were: 1) to characterize the genomic structure of the beta-globin gene cluster of rodents; 2) to assign orthologous and paralogous relationships among duplicate copies of beta-like globin genes; and 3) to infer the specific recombinational pathways responsible for gene duplications, gene deletions, and the creation of chimeric fusion genes. Results of our comparative genomic analyses revealed that variation in gene family size among rodent species is mainly attributable to the differential gain and loss of later expressed beta-globin genes via unequal crossing-over. However, two distinct recombinational mechanisms were implicated in the creation of chimeric fusion genes. In muroid rodents, a chimeric gamma/epsilon fusion gene was created by unequal crossing-over between the embryonic epsilon- and gamma-globin genes. Interestingly, this gamma/epsilon fusion gene was generated in the same fashion as the "anti-Lepore" 5'-delta-(beta/delta)-beta-3' duplication mutant in humans (the reciprocal exchange product of the pathological hemoglobin Lepore deletion mutant). By contrast, in the house mouse, Mus musculus, a chimeric beta/delta fusion pseudogene was created by a beta-globin --> delta-globin gene conversion event. Although the gamma/epsilon and beta/delta fusion genes share a similar chimeric gene structure, they originated via completely different recombinational pathways.     

Illegitimate recombination is a major evolutionary mechanism for initiating size variation in plant resistance genes

Current models for the evolution of plant disease resistance (R) genes are based on mechanisms such as unequal crossing-over, gene conversion and point mutations as sources for genetic variability and the generation of new specificities. Size variation in leucine-rich repeat (LRR) domains was previously mainly attributed to unequal crossing-over or template slippage between LRR units. Our analysis of 112 R genes and R gene analogs (RGAs) from 16 different gene lineages from monocots and dicots showed that individual LRR units are mostly too divergent to allow unequal crossing-over. We found that illegitimate recombination (IR) is the major mechanism that generates quasi-random duplications within the LRR domain. These initial duplications are required as seeds for subsequent unequal crossing-over events which cause the observed rapid increase or decrease in LRR repeat numbers. Ten of the 16 gene lineages studied contained such duplications, and in four of them the duplications served as a template for subsequent repeat amplification. Our analysis of Pm3-like genes from rice and three wheat species showed that such events can be traced back more than 50 million years. Thus, IR represents a major new evolutionary mechanism that is essential for the generation of molecular diversity in evolution of RGAs.     

Williams-Beuren syndrome: a model of recurrent genomic mutation

Williams-Beuren syndrome is a segmental aneusomy syndrome with manifestations affecting the vascular, connective tissue, endocrine and central nervous systems. Most patients show a similar heterozygous approximately 1.5 Mb deletion at 7q11.23 that contains a number of reported genes. Deletion mapping in the few atypical patients with smaller deletions suggested that additive effects of haploinsufficiency for two or more genes might be necessary for the phenotype. Vascular stenoses are caused by haploinsufficiency at the elastin gene, while the genes responsible for the cognitive deficits are likely located at the telomeric edge of the deletion, including CYLN2 and GTF2I. Large region-specific segmental duplications predispose to misalignment and inter- or intrachromosomal unequal crossing-over causing the deletions. Atypical alleles at 7q11.23 such as inversions and deletions/insertions of large repeats, also generated through aberrant recombination between the local segmental duplications, are found in approximately 35% of transmitting parents. Genomic instability at 7q11.23 is directly related to the genomic structure of the region.     

The G4 gene is duplicated in 44% of human immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region haplotypes

The structure of the human immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region (IGHC), on chromosome 14q32, comprises nine CH genes and two pseudogenes, all originating from multiple duplication events. Continuing evolution of the region is demonstrated by the finding of various types of duplicated and deleted haplotypes, which together add up to 6%. Here we provide molecular and genetic evidence that the G4 gene is duplicated in 44% of IGHC haplotypes in the Italian population. The duplication spans about 20 kb of genomic DNA and probably originated through unequal crossing over. Refined characterisation of the genomic region downstream from the G4 gene improves our knowledge of the evolutionary history of CH genes. Received: 4 December 1996 / Accepted: 10 February 1997     

Unequal crossing-over in Escherichia coli

Unequal crossing-over between sister chromosomes in the process of DNA replication in Escherichia coli leads to the formation of tandem duplications, thus enhancing the activity of certain genes. In conjugational matings between genetically marked E. coli strains, unequal crossing-over leads to the formation of heterozygous tandem duplications. Studying these duplications as model systems allowed the conclusion that unequal crossing-over between direct DNA repeats of sister chromosomes is the main pathway of the formation of selected recombinants in E. coli strains carrying duplications. This was inferred from the data on the segregation of homozygous diploid recombinants by heterozygous duplications. Unequal crossing-over between sister chromosomes occurs as adaptive exchange providing the survival of the greater part of bacterial cells on a selective medium. The known phenomenon of adaptive mutagenesis may also be a consequence of unequal exchanges at the level of DNA mononucleotide repeats.     

Haplotype Phasing and Inheritance of Copy Number Variants in Nuclear Families

DNA copy number variants (CNVs) that alter the copy number of a particular DNA segment in the genome play an important role in human phenotypic variability and disease susceptibility. A number of CNVs overlapping with genes have been shown to confer risk to a variety of human diseases thus highlighting the relevance of addressing the variability of CNVs at a higher resolution. So far, it has not been possible to deterministically infer the allelic composition of different haplotypes present within the CNV regions. We have developed a novel computational method, called PiCNV, which enables to resolve the haplotype sequence composition within CNV regions in nuclear families based on SNP genotyping microarray data. The algorithm allows to i) phase normal and CNV-carrying haplotypes in the copy number variable regions, ii) resolve the allelic copies of rearranged DNA sequence within the haplotypes and iii) infer the heritability of identified haplotypes in trios or larger nuclear families. To our knowledge this is the first program available that can deterministically phase null, mono-, di-, tri- and tetraploid genotypes in CNV loci. We applied our method to study the composition and inheritance of haplotypes in CNV regions of 30 HapMap Yoruban trios and 34 Estonian families. For 93.6% of the CNV loci, PiCNV enabled to unambiguously phase normal and CNV-carrying haplotypes and follow their transmission in the corresponding families. Furthermore, allelic composition analysis identified the co-occurrence of alternative allelic copies within 66.7% of haplotypes carrying copy number gains. We also observed less frequent transmission of CNV-carrying haplotypes from parents to children compared to normal haplotypes and identified an emergence of several de novo deletions and duplications in the offspring.     

Population genetics theory of concerted evolution and its application to the immunoglobulin V gene tree

Summary The previous simple model for treating concerted evolution of multigene families has been revised to be compatible with various new observations on the immunoglobulin variable region family and other families. In the previous model, gene conversion and unequal crossing-over were considered, and it was assumed that genes are randomly arranged on the chromosome; neither subdivision nor correlation of gene identity and chromosomal distance were considered. Although this model satisfactorily explains the observed amino acid diversity within and between species, it fails to predict the very ancient branching of the mouse immunoglobulin heavy chain V-gene family. By incorporating subdivided structure and genetic correlation with chromosomal distance into the simple model, the data of divergence may be satisfactorily explained, as well as the rate of nucleotide substitution and the amino acid diversity. The rate at which a V-gene is duplicated or deleted by conversion or by unequal crossing-over is estimated by the new model to be on the order of 10^–6 per year. The model may be applicable to other multigene families, such as those coding for silkmoth chorion or mammalian kallikrein.Contribution no. 1560 from the National Institute of Genetics, Mishima, 411 Japan     

Unstable chromosome rearrangements associated with male recombination in Drosophila melanogaster

The male recombination second chromosome 23.5 MRF isolated from the same Greek natural population with the second chromosome 31.1 MRF induced high frequencies of chromosome rearrangements, including specific deletions and duplications. A number of the duplications recovered were found to be highly unstable. The duplicated chromosome segments of the unstable duplications had been either completely or partially lost. The loss occurred most probably by excision of the corresponding segments and not by unequal crossing-over involving sister chromatids. As regards the unstable deletions, they became either shorter or longer or they showed complete restoration. Hypotheses explaining the high frequencies of the unstable chromosome mutations detected are discussed.     

Unequal crossing-over in Escherichia coli

Unequal crossing-over between sister chromosomes in the process of DNA replication in Escherichia coli leads to the formation of tandem duplications, thus enhancing the activity of certain genes. In conjugational matings between genetically marked E. coli strains, unequal crossing-over leads to the formation of heterozygous tandem duplications. Studying these duplications as model systems allowed the conclusion that unequal crossing-over between direct DNA repeats of sister chromosomes is the main pathway of the formation of selected recombinants in E. coli strains carrying duplications. This was inferred from the data on the segregation of homozygous diploid recombinants by heterozygous duplications. Unequal crossing-over between sister chromosomes occurs as adaptive exchange providing the survival of the greater part of bacterial cells on a selective medium. The known phenomenon of adaptive mutagenesis may also be a consequence of unequal exchanges at the level of DNA mononucleotide repeats.     

Neutral mutations and repetitive DNA

We have previously shown that computer simulations of processes that generate selectively advantageous changes together with random duplications and deletions give rise to genomes with many different genes embedded in a large amount of dispensable DNA sequence. We now explore the consequences of neutral changes on the evolution of genomes. We follow the consequences of sequence divergences that are neutral when they occur in dispensable sequences or extra copies of genes present in multigene families. We find that when divergence occurs at about the same frequency as duplication/deletion events, genomes carry repetitive sequences in proportion to their size. Inspection of the genomes as they evolved showed that multigene families were generated by relatively recent duplications of single genes and so would be expected to be highly homogeneous.     

Copy-number fluctuation by unequal crossing-over in the chicken avidin gene family

The chicken avidin gene (AVD) forms a closely clustered gene family together with several avidin-related genes (AVRs). In this study, we used fluorescence in situ hybridization on extended DNA fibers (fiber-FISH) to show that the number of the AVD and AVR genes differs between individuals. Furthermore, the gene copy-number showed wide somatic variation in white blood cells of the individuals. The molecular mechanism underlying the fluctuation is most probably unequal crossing-over and/or unequal sister chromatid exchange, as judged by the Gaussian distribution of the gene counts. By definition, an increase in gene number on one locus should be accompanied by a decrease on the other locus in unequal sequence exchange. The results suggest that copy-number lability may be more common among gene families than previously thought. The chicken avidin gene family also provides an excellent model for studying the mechanisms of recombination and gene conversion.     

Role of gene duplication in evolution

It is now known that many multigene and supergene families exist in eukaryote genomes: multigene families with uniform copy members like genes for ribosomal RNA, those with variable members like immunoglobulin genes, and supergene families such as those for various growth factor and hormone receptors. Many such examples indicate that gene duplication and subsequent differentiation are extremely important for organismal evolution. In particular, gene duplication could well have been the primary mechanism for the evolution of complexity in higher organisms. Population genetic models for the origin of gene families with diverse functions are presented, in which natural selection favors those genomes with more useful mutants in duplicated genes. Since any gene has a certain probability of degenerating by mutation, success versus failure in acquiring a new gene by duplication may be expressed as the ratio of probabilities of spreading of useful versus detrimental mutations in redundant gene copies. Also examined are the effects of gene duplication on evolution by compensatory advantageous mutations. Results of the analyses show that both natural selection and random drift are important for the origin of gene families. In addition, interaction between molecular mechanisms such as unequal crossing-over and gene conversion, and selection or drift is found to have a large effect on evolution by gene duplication.     

How gene families evolve

Theories and facts of gene family evolution are reviewed. Concerted evolution is commonly observed for gene families which originated a long time ago, however there are many different types of multigene families, from uniform to diverse. The rate of homogenization by unequal crossing-over, gene conversion, etc. has been evolutionarily adjusted for each gene family. When new functions are needed by organisms, gene families may evolve into superfamilies, in which no further concerted evolution takes place, and each member of the family may acquire an indispensable function. The homeobox-containing gene family is a most exciting example of such superfamily.     

Ig H chain variable and C region genes in common variable immunodeficiency. Characterization of two new deletion haplotypes.

Common variable immunodeficiency, a disorder characterized by diminished antibody production, manifests clinically as an increased susceptibility to bacterial infections. We have investigated the Ig H chain V and C region gene segments in 33 patients with common variable immunodeficiency, to identify the possible role these genes may have in the molecular basis of the defect. No major deletions were recognized for the VH gene segments of the VH2, VH5, and VH6 families, nor were there any differences in the RFLP patterns of mu- or alpha- switch regions or of C gamma genes. Two new deletion haplotypes were identified for the C region genes, the first encompassing C gamma 1 on a different haplotype from the C gamma 1 deletion described previously, and the second a novel deletion encompassing both C gamma 2 and C gamma 4. Based on these and previously described deletions in the IGHC region, we postulate that homologous regions are involved in the deletion process and that other new deletions likely exist in the population.