Analysis of fine needle aspiration cytology of the breast: a review of 1,297 cases and correlation with histologic diagnoses

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the accuracy of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology of the breast and to ascertain its usefulness. STUDY DESIGN: The authors reviewed 1,297 cases of FNA cytology of the breast which were performed at Chonnam National University Hospital from 1999 to 2002. Cytologic diagnoses were compared with histologic diagnoses in 457 cases that underwent both cytologic and histologic examination. RESULTS: Of 1,297 cases, 1,201 (92.6%) were satisfactory and 96 (7.4%) unsatisfactory. Subsequent histologic examination was performed on 291 cases (29.7%) out of 981 "benign" lesions, 28 (73.7%) of 38 "suspicious," 124 (68.1%) of 182 "malignant" and 14 (14.6%) of 96 "unsatisfactory." FNA cytology revealed 77.7% sensitivity, 99.2% specificity, 98.4% positive predictive value and 88.0% negative predictive value. Diagnostic accuracy was 91.1%. Of the 291 benign cases on cytology, 35 cases were malignancy on histology. Of the 124 cases reported as malignant, 2 were benign. Interpretive error was the leading cause of false positive diagnoses. CONCLUSION: Although FNA cytology is a useful diagnostic procedure for the evaluation of breast lesions, it should be combined with other diagnostic modalities, such as physical examination, ultrasonography and mammography.     

Accuracy and consistency in application of a probabilistic approach to reporting breast fine needle aspiration

OBJECTIVE: To determine the application of a probabilistic/categorical approach for reporting breast fine needle aspiration (FNA) and its dependence on the cytopathologist's level of experience. STUDY DESIGN: All breast surgical specimens that had preoperative breast FNA at our institution during a 3-year period were identified. The cytologic results were reported as 1 of 6 categories: positive, suspicious, atypical, epithelial proliferative, unremarkable and nondiagnostic, according to well-defined criteria. Five cytopathologists were responsible for all cytology sing-out during the study period. The histologic and cytologic diagnoses were correlated. RESULTS: A total of 297 cases were identified. Overall, there were no false positive cases (positive predictive value [PPV] = 100%). Two false negative cases (negative predictive value [NPV] = 96%) were due to sampling error. This indicates that the PPV and NPV for each of the 5 pathologists were also all 100% except for the 1 pathologist who had two false negative cases due to sampling errors. The probability of finding carcinoma on histology for suspicious and atypical cytologic categories ranged from 67% to 100% and 8% to 31%, respectively, for the individual pathologists. Fifteen cases were signed out by > or = 2 pathologists. The involvement of consultants was significantly associated with diagnosis (P = .02). Ten of the 15 cases were in the suspicious (5) or atypical (5) category. CONCLUSION: The probabilistic approach with defined diagnostic criteria is an accurate method and can be consistently applied in reporting breast FNA. Although use of the indeterminate (suspicious and atypical) categories is variable, a definite and considerable difference in the probability of carcinoma between these 2 categories was observed for all pathologists. The involvement of consultants did not move the cases out of these indeterminate categories.     

Ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration cytology of impalpable breast lesions in a rural setting. Comparison of cytology with imaging and final outcome

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the effectiveness of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology in a multidisciplinary setting in rural Australia and to compare the imaging (mammographic and ultrasound) appearances and cytomorphologic findings with the final outcome. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective analysis of ultrasound-guided FNA cytology results from 426 women, aged 40-86 years, with screening-detected mammographic abnormalities. Cases of microcalcification, assessed mainly by stereotactatic core biopsy, were not included in the study. The FNAs were performed at a rural breast screening and assessment program in New South Wales, Australia, over a three-year period between May 1993 and May 1996. RESULTS: Imaging, FNA and combined imaging and FNA results from 426 women were as follows. The imaging diagnoses included 176 (41%) benign, 34 (8%) probably benign, 17 (4%) equivocal, 104 (24%) suspicious and 95 (23%) malignant cases. The FNA findings showed 59 (14%) no epithelial cells seen (nondiagnostic), 175 (41%) benign, 36 (8%) atypical, 41 (10%) suspicious and 115 (27%) malignant. Combined imaging and cytologic results comprised 224 (52.6%) benign, 10 (2.3%) atypical/equivocal, 59 (13.9%) suspicious and 133 (31.2%) malignant cases. All the malignant cases, by combined assessment, had malignant histology, and all the benign cases behaved in a benign fashion. In 80% of the suspicious lesions, the histologic diagnosis was malignant, but only 10% of the atypical/equivocal lesions had malignant histology. The positive predictive value of diagnosis of malignancy by combined imaging and FNA was 100%, and the false negative rate was 0%. CONCLUSION: Despite the recent surge in the popularity of core biopsy, FNA cytology of impalpable, mammographically detected lesions, when practiced in a multidisciplinary setting, is an extremely accurate test with high sensitivity, specificity, predictive values and efficacy. FNA cytology of the breast is a well-tolerated, relatively noninvasive test with a very low risk of complications. The sensitivity and positive predictive values for malignant and suspicious mammographic categories are also very high.     

Value of fine needle aspiration cytology of the breast, with an emphasis on the cytodiagnosis of colloid carcinoma.

The fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytologic evaluation of 6,941 lesions of the breast was reviewed, with an emphasis on the cytodiagnosis of colloid carcinoma. The most common benign breast diseases in this series were fibroadenomas, cysts and fibrocystic conditions. All cases with an FNA diagnosis of suspicious were biopsied; a number of these were found to be carcinoma of the breast. In cases with an FNA diagnosis of carcinoma of the breast, a plan of management was immediately adopted on the basis of that diagnosis. Thirteen cases of colloid (mucinous) carcinoma of the breast were diagnosed by FNA cytology; in all, the cytodiagnosis was confirmed by the subsequent histologic diagnosis. The distinctive cytologic criteria that may be useful for making an FNA diagnosis of colloid carcinoma of the breast are discussed, and the FNA differences between the pure and mixed types of colloid carcinoma are noted.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology in the management of palpable benign and malignant breast disease. Correlation with clinical and mammographic findings

Two surgeons in a health maintenance organization group practice performed 280 fine needle aspirations (FNAs) on 257 palpable breast lesions in 200 patients. The cytology was interpreted by four pathologists at a community hospital. FNA cytology had a sensitivity of 96% and a specificity of 94% in these cases; there were no false-positive diagnoses of cancer. FNA cytology improved the identification of benign disease and decreased the risk of missing cancers. FNA cytology also improved the predictive value of mammographic information and was more helpful than mammography in demonstrating the need for biopsy of small palpable lesions that turned out to be "minimal" breast cancers.     

Fine needle aspiration of breast lesions in women aged 30 and under

Fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsies of 1,598 breast masses were performed between 1983 and 1989, and of them, 48 were from women aged 30 and under for whom a cytologic diagnosis was made by FNA and histologic follow-up was available. In 37 (77%) of the cases, both the cytologic and histologic diagnoses were benign. Fibroadenoma (20/37) and fibrocystic changes (14/37) were the most common benign lesions aspirated. Eight (17%) FNAs showed cytologic atypia. Four of these atypical lesions proved to be benign (two fibroadenomas, two fibrocystic changes). Epithelial proliferation in fibroadenomas and fibrocystic changes and cellular stroma in a fibroadenoma mimicking phylloides tumor were the causes of atypia in these biopsies. Four of the eight atypical lesions were shown to be carcinoma at biopsy (three infiltrating duct, one atypical medullary). Low cellularity, epithelial cohesiveness mimicking a fibroadenoma and background lactational changes in a pregnant patient were the causes of the atypical, rather than unequivocally malignant, diagnoses in these cases. In three patients (6%), a diagnosis of carcinoma was made by FNA and confirmed histologically (all were infiltrating duct carcinoma). Although most breast masses in women aged 30 and under are benign, cytologic atypia in a breast fine needle aspirate in this age group warrants a surgical biopsy. Clinical follow-up alone may be appropriate for young women with clinically nonsuspicious breast masses without cytologic atypia.     

Renal fine needle aspiration cytology

OBJECTIVE: To audit and evaluate the pitfalls in renal fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective analysis of 180 renal FNAs from 163 patients, encountered at Canberra Hospital, Australian Capital Territory, between June 1989 and July 1997 was undertaken. The FNA procedures had been performed by radiologists under computed tomography (CT) or ultrasound (US) guidance. The study correlated the FNA results with biopsy findings and clinical outcome. RESULTS: The initial cytologic diagnoses included 84 (47%) benign, 6 (3%) atypical, 7 (4%) suspicious, 70 (39%) malignant and 13 (7%) inadequate. Six of the 13 cytologically inadequate group, on further investigation, had malignant histology. The benign cytologic categories contained 79 benign conditions and 5 cases with a malignant outcome. The atypical cytologic group contained 5 benign and 1 malignant case. All nine cytologically suspicious cases had malignant histology. The cytologically malignant group contained 62 malignant, 7 benign and 1 patient lost to follow-up. The sensitivity was 92.5%, specificity was 91.9%, positive predictive value was 89.9%, negative predictive value was 94.0%, and efficacy of the test was 92.2%. CONCLUSION: Renal FNA can provide an accurate diagnosis in most instances; however, aspiration cytology of the kidney has limitations and pitfalls. Low grade renal cell carcinoma has to be differentiated from oncocytoma, angiomyolipoma, renal infarct and reactive conditions. Renal FNA has a high negative predictive value, which is useful in reassuring patients with radiologically and cytologically benign lesions. Negative FNA does not exclude malignancy in the presence of a radiologic suspicion.     

An audit of 'equivocal' (C3) and 'suspicious' (C4) categories in fine needle aspiration cytology of the breast

An audit of 'equivocal' (C3) and 'suspicious' (C4) categories in fine needle aspiration cytology of the breast
We have audited the frequency of use and outcome of the 'equivocal/atypia probably benign' (C3) and 'suspicious of malignancy' (C4) category for breast cytology in our Unit. A total of 14 935 cytological specimens were reported by at least one of the three pathologists with a special interest in breast pathology, according to five categories of the NHSBSP guidelines for cytology reporting, 1992; 3.7% (555 cases) and 3.9% (587 cases) of cases were classified as equivocal (C3) and suspicious (C4), respectively, giving a total rate (C3 + C4) of 7.6%. Of the C3 cases, 68% were subsequently benign and 32% were malignant. Of the C4 cases, 19% were subsequently benign and 81% malignant. The commonest benign lesions in both categories were fibroadenomas (7.6% of C3 and 19.8% of C4), fibrocystic change (14.3% of C3 and 12.5% of C4), radial scars (6.2% of C3 and 10.4% of C4) and papillomas (6.2% of C3 and 6.3% of C4). Of the malignant lesions (particularly those classified as C3), a high proportion were low grade or special type cancers. The categories of atypia probably benign (C3) and suspicious of malignancy (C4) in breast cytology provide a strategy for classification of problematic or uncertain cases; this maintains the predictive value of the benign (C2) and malignant (C5) categories, and allows separation of these difficult cases into clinically useful groups with differing probabilities of malignancy.     

Stereotaxic fine needle aspiration cytology of clinically occult malignant and premalignant breast lesions

Stereotaxic fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology was used to study clinically occult (nonpalpable) breast lesions in 114 consecutive patients with mammographically suspicious findings prior to excisional biopsy. The aspirate contained insufficient material for cytologic evaluation in 15 cases (13.2%), which were histologically diagnosed as benign (7 cases), atypical hyperplasia (7 cases) or carcinoma in situ (1 case). The cytologic findings indicated a benign lesion in 77 cases (67.5%), which were histologically diagnosed as benign (71 cases) or atypical ductal hyperplasia (6 cases). The cytologic sample showed atypia in eight cases (7.0%), which were histologically diagnosed as severe atypical ductal hyperplasia (three cases), carcinoma in situ (one case) or proliferative fibrocystic disease (four cases). In the eight cases (7.0%) cytologically interpreted as probably malignant, histology confirmed six invasive carcinomas, one carcinoma in situ and one fibrocystic disease. Of six cases (4.4%) cytologically reported as malignant, five were histologically diagnosed as invasive carcinoma and one as carcinoma in situ. Overall, stereotaxic FNA cytology reported as malignant or probably malignant 14 of the 15 cases with a histologic confirmation of malignancy, for a sensitivity of 93.3%. Cytology correctly identified 78 of the 83 histologically negative cases, for a specificity of 94.0%. The 16 cases histologically diagnosed as ductal hyperplasia, which carries a high risk for subsequent malignancy, were studied in detail in an effort to define histologic and cytologic criteria for this entity. Using selected histologic criteria, 11 of these cases were graded as showing mild-to-moderate atypical hyperplasia and 5 as showing severe atypical hyperplasia. Three of the latter cases were similarly identified by an analogous cytologic grading; the other two cases had insufficient cytologic samples. The total results in this series of 114 cases support the use of stereotaxic FNA cytology in the diagnosis of these nonpalpable breast lesions, examples of which are illustrated. In particular, it may help to raise the low specificity yielded by mammography alone, which would represent a significant advance for the patient in terms of the accuracy, expediency and reduced cost of diagnosing these lesions.     

Statistical analysis of fine needle aspiration cytology of the breast. A review of 678 cases plus 4,265 cases from the literature

Between 1979 and 1984, 678 breast fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytologic specimens were received in our laboratory; tissue follow-up was available for 159 cases (23%). The diagnoses rendered in cases with subsequent tissue study were benign (41%), insufficient (10.5%), atypical and/or suspicious for carcinoma (10.5%) and malignant (38%). Using the tissue diagnosis as the standard, there were four false-negative cytologic results and one false-positive result. Considering only cases with a definitive diagnosis of benign or malignant, the sensitivity of cytologic interpretation for diagnosing malignancy on adequate material was 94% while the specificity was 98%; the overall efficiency of the test was thus 96%. The predictive values were 98% for a positive test and 94% for a negative test. Of the total number of submitted cases, a correct and definitive diagnosis was rendered 76% of the time. Calculation of similar statistics from six other series in which the FNA cytologic diagnoses were compared with the histologic diagnoses yielded data almost identical to our findings. The high degree of uniformity in the data indicates that these statistical parameters can be used as standards for evaluating the efficiency of breast FNA cytology.     

Papillary breast lesions diagnosed on cytology. Profile of 65 cases

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the cytologic features of nipple discharge and fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytologic smears from breast lesions reported as showing papillary features and to correlate them with histopathologic features. STUDY DESIGN: The study group consisted of FNA smears and/or nipple discharge smears from 65 breast lesions diagnosed on cytology as duct papilloma, papillary lesion, fibrocystic condition, fibroadenoma, papillary neoplasm or papillary carcinoma. Cytomorphologic features assessed included cellularity, cell pattern (clusters, papillary, 3-dimensionality, etc.) and cell characteristics (monomorphism, pleomorphism, apocrine change, plasmacytoid features). Histological material was available for review and cytohistologic correlation in all cases. RESULTS: Forty-six specimens were FNA smears, and 16 were nipple discharge smears; in 3 cases FNA and nipple discharge cytologic smears were available for review. Cytologic study could predict the presence of a papillary pattern in all neoplasms with pure or focal papillary differentiation. There was an overlap in cytomorphologic features between papillary and nonpapillary benign lesions as well as between benign and malignant papillary neoplasms. Frank blood in the aspirate, cell dissociation and atypia, however, were more frequent in the last. CONCLUSION: Overlap of cytologic features in nonneoplastic and neoplastic benign papillary lesions and between benign and malignant papillary neoplasms necessitates histologic evaluation in all cases diagnosed as papillary on cytology. Since 49.2% of lesions showing papillary features on cytology prove to be malignant, all cases reported as papillary on cytology should be excised urgently for histologic assessment.     

Thyroid Cytology and Risk of Thyroid Cancer: Differences Among Indeterminate Specimens

ObjectiveTo assess the potential for stratification of indeterminate cytologic findings on fine-needle aspiration (FNA) of thyroid nodules in an effort to improve therapeutic strategies.MethodsWe attempted to determine the malignant risk associated with various indeterminate FNA cytologic patterns by correlation of specimens with the final histologic diagnosis. For this analysis, we identified 294 computerized medical records of surgically treated thyroid nodules during a 5-year period at our institution with the corresponding FNA cytology reports available.ResultsOf the 294 surgical cases, 162 with a positive or indeterminate cytologic report were selected, reviewed, and classified. Of 52 patients with positive cytologic findings on FNA, 51 (98%) had a final histologic report of a malignant thyroid nodule. Of 110 patients with indeterminate specimens, 30 (27%) had a final histologic diagnosis of thyroid carcinoma. The presence of nuclear atypia was predictive of thyroid carcinoma in 75% of patients, a Hürthle cell cytologic pattern was associated with a malignant thyroid nodule in 33%, and a hypercellular smear was suggestive of malignant involvement in 26% of cases. The lowest rate of malignant potential was associated with cytologic microfollicular and scant colloid alone subtype (6%).ConclusionThe results of this study show that indeterminate thyroid cytologic specimens can be subdivided into groups with different malignant risks. A microfollicular cytologic pattern in the absence of a hypercellular smear or nuclear atypia does not support a recommendation of surgical treatment. A malignant cytologic diagnosis has a high positive predictive value for detection of thyroid cancer. (Endocr Pract. 2004;10:330-334)     

Preoperative aspiration cytology of breast tumors

During a ten-year period, 1,942 aspirations of 1,906 mammary tumors in 1,874 patients were performed before excisional biopsy or mastectomy. The cytology findings were categorized as positive (1,107 cases), suspicious (152 cases), atypical (183 cases), benign (166 cases) and unsatisfactory (298 cases). All cytologically positive cases with follow-up were confirmed histologically or by clinical observation. Follow-up showed that 96% of the cases in the suspicious category, 86% of the cases in the atypical category, 51% of the cases in the benign category and 72% of the cases in the unsatisfactory category had malignant neoplasms. Aspiration cytology diagnosed 1,031 of 1,539 primary malignant mammary neoplasms (67%) and 19 of 28 neoplasms (68%) metastatic to the breast; if unsatisfactory cases are excluded, these figures become 1,031 of 1,365 cases (75%) and 19 of 25 (76%), respectively. If those cases reported as suspicious are included with the positive cases and those reported as atypical are included with the negative cases, aspiration cytology would have a sensitivity of 84% for the presence of carcinoma, a specificity of 97% for the absence of carcinoma, a predictive value of 99% for a positive diagnosis and a predictive value of 56% for a negative diagnosis; the diagnostic efficiency would be 86%. Our findings reaffirmed that the cytologic diagnosis of mammary carcinomas is reliable but that negative or inconclusive cytologic findings should not be regarded as a definitive diagnosis if there is clinical suspicion of a malignant neoplasm.     

Interpretation of fine needle aspiration cytology of the breast: a comparison of cytological, frozen section, and final histological diagnoses

This study examines the performance of the preliminary, on-site interpretation by the pathologist of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology smears compared to the final cytology report, the frozen section diagnosis and the final histopathological report. We found that both the preliminary and the final cytology reports gave satisfactory results over the minimum standards for quality assurance required by both the Norwegian breast screening programme and the NHS BSP in the UK with the exception of the 'suspicious' rate. We noted that the preliminary report had fewer false negatives (2.1%) than the final report (4.3%). We show that an unequivocal cytological diagnosis of malignancy is a reliable diagnosis, and in cases where mammography/ultrasonography and clinical examination are in agreement with FNA, frozen section examination is unnecessary. However, cases with a suspicious or equivocal FNA should be considered for frozen section analysis.     

Diagnostic use of mean nuclear area and nuclear DNA content in preoperative breast cancer cytology

OBJECTIVE: Fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology of breast lumps is a routine procedure, and the diagnostic accuracy can be 95%. Occasional discrepancies arise, and it would be valuable to have additional parameters for accurate diagnosis. We evaluated nuclear DNA content and mean nuclear area (MNA) using image cytometry in the diagnosis of preoperative breast cancers by FNA in those with a discrepancy between clinical, radiologic and cytologic diagnoses. STUDY DESIGN: One hundred eighteen consecutive preoperative FNA samples were evaluated for nuclear DNA and MNA and were compared to cytologic and postoperative histologic diagnoses. RESULTS: Sensitivity, accuracy and positive predictive value of routine cytology were 95%, 90%, 95% as compared to nuclear DNA (66%, 66%, 96%) and MNA (61%, 61%, 97%). Combining these 3 parameters gave a sensitivity of 97%, accuracy of 94% and positive predictive value of 99%. CONCLUSION: These results demonstrate that nuclear DNA and MNA combined with routine cytology may be useful adjuncts in preoperative breast cancer cytologic diagnosis when discrepancies arise. This may lead to better and more accurate planning of treatment regimens in preoperative breast cancer patients.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of breast fibroadenoma. A cytohistologic correlation study of 405 cases.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the cytohistologic correlation of breast fibroadenoma (FA) in order to assess the value of cytology in the conservative management of this lesion. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective analysis of all aspirates diagnosed as FA or fibroadenomatous lesion (n = 1,549) for which a histologic follow-up study was available (n = 362). Forty-three aspirates, including 14 nonrepresentative smears, from histologically proven FAs with a different cytologic report were also included in the study. RESULTS: Cytohistologic agreement was present in 287 of the 362 cytodiagnoses. Lack of correlation was observed in 75 cases. Most diagnostic errors accumulated in the older patient group. The sensitivity of the cytologic diagnosis of FA was 86.9% (90.8% excluding nonrepresentative cases), with a positive predictive value of 79.3%. In 43 cases a histologic diagnosis of FA was given after previous erroneous (n = 29) or nonrepresentative cytodiagnoses (n = 14). The specificity of the cytologic diagnosis of FA reached 93.8%, with a negative predictive value of 96.3% (97.5% excluding nonrepresentative cases). Regarding malignancy, five tumors were diagnosed as FA and were malignant. No false positive diagnoses of malignancy were given, but nine aspirates were included in the category "suspicious for carcinoma." CONCLUSION: FA of the breast remains a diagnostic challenge for the cytopathologist. A considerable amount of benign breast lesions can mimic FA on cytology, and such diagnostic categories as "fibroadenomatous lesion" or "consistent with FA" are associated with low diagnostic accuracy. While the cytologic requisites for entering a program of conservative management of FA are established, it seems that strict diagnostic criteria should be applied even at the expense of diminishing sensitivity.     

Application of the probabilistic approach to reporting breast fine needle aspiration in males

OBJECTIVE: To apply the probabilistic approach to a series offine needle aspiration (FNA) samples of male breast lesions and determine the accuracy and reproducibility of this method of reporting in men. STUDY DESIGN: All male breast surgical specimens with a preoperative breast FNA at our institution from 1994 to 2005 were identified. The FNAs were blindly reviewed by 2 groups of observers and classified in 1 of 5 categories using published reporting guidelines: positive, suspicious, atypical, proliferative without atypia and unremarkable. The histologic and cytologic diagnoses were correlated. The interobserver variation was determined. RESULTS: A total of 138 FNAs were performed for 123 male patients. Histologic correlation was available for 23 satisfactory FNAs. A total of 11 of 11 carcinomas (100%) were classified as positive, suspicious or atypical. Of 12 benign masses, 11 (91.6%) were classified as proliferative without atypia or unremarkable. One case of gynecomastia was classified as atypical by 1 observer but deemed not atypical with consensus review. The kappa statistic for benign and atypical/suspicious/malignant categories was 0.90. CONCLUSION: Based on this series, the probabilistic approach can be applied to the reporting of FNAs of male breast lesions. Gynecomastia may result in an atypical cytologic diagnosis.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of mammary duct ectasia: report of a case with novel cytologic and immunocytochemical findings.

BACKGROUND: Mammary duct ectasia (MDE), or periductal mastitis, is a well-defined clinical entity with a characteristic histopathologic appearance on breast biopsy specimens. However, the cytologic features of MDE have been described only recently in the cytopathology literature, and fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytologic findings are based mainly on a small number of case reports in the English-language literature. Therefore, awareness of this entity and recognition of its cytomorphologic features could aid in a more accurate diagnosis. We report the novel cytologic and immunocytochemical findings on a case of MDE that was confirmed by histologic examination on a subsequent biopsy. CASE: We report the findings of breast FNA cytology in a 50-year-old female with a mammographically and clinically suspicious lesion. Cytology displayed a paucicellular aspirate, typified by a few scattered, cohesive clusters of ductal epithelial cells with mild nuclear atypia and distinct, peripherally located myoepithelial cells. Intermingled within the ductal elements were numerous polygonal cells with abundant, finely vacuolated cytoplasm that were immunoreactive for macrophage-specific antibody, CD68. The background consisted of a variable number of foam cells and negligible amount of blood. CONCLUSION: The current case of MDE demonstrates cytomorphologic features that may pose diagnostic problems, particularly as a consequence of variable cytologic atypia this entity may present on FNA cytology. This diagnostic difficulty is compounded because of the abnormal mammographic and suspicious clinical findings that may be associated with MDE. CD68 immunoreactivity is a useful ancillary tool to verify the histiocytic, rather than epithelial and potentially neoplastic, nature of multivacuolated cells. To the best of our knowledge, there has been no prior reported case of MDE in the English-language literature studied utilizing CD68 antibody. This case report emphasizes that MDE is a heterogeneous entity with diverse cytomorphologic features. FNA cytology in conjunction with immunocytochemistry might permit accurate classification in the proper clinical setting.     

Fine Needle Aspiration Cytodiagnosis As A Pre-Requisite For Primary Medical Treatment of Breast Cancer

The accurate non-surgical diagnosis of breast lumps allows assessment of breast cancer patients for conservation or neoadjuvant primary treatment before surgical intervention. We have analysed the accuracy of clinical assessment, fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC), and mammography in over 868 women seen in a symptomatic breast clinic. Clinical examination by an experienced breast physician, together with FNAC, detected over 99% of the cancers with a 12% false positive rate. A cytological diagnosis of definite carcinoma was obtained in 69% of women with breast cancer with no false positive result from the women with benign conditions producing a 100% positive predictive value. These results indicate that it would be acceptable to give pre-surgical systemic endocrine or chemotherapy to women with positive cytology which is therefore a prerequisite for a neoadjuvant therapy programme.     

Value of fine needle aspiration in the diagnosis of breast lesions.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the accuracy values of 276 fine needle aspriations (FNA) of breast lesions with a subsequent excisional biopsy diagnosis and to make a comparison between 25 studies of the literature using the same criteria to calculate those values. STUDY DESIGN: Cytologic findings were compared with the histologic diagnosis of each mass. The correlation of results was analyzed by a decision-analysis approach, and the following values concerning diagnostic accuracy were calculated in the present study and in 25 other reports: sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value, false positive fraction and false negative fraction. To calculate those values, we eliminated unsatisfactory results and assumed that suspicious and positive cytologic findings represented carcinoma of the breast. RESULTS: Comparing our results with the means in the literature (numbers in parenthesis), FNA detected cancer with a sensitivity of 92.1% (87.7%), specificity of 98.6% (94.7%), positive predictive value of 99.4% (92.8%), negative predictive value of 82.1% (90.7%), false positive fraction of 0.6% (7.1%) and false negative fraction of 17.9% (13.4%); in 6.2% of cases the material was unsatisfactory (13.4%). CONCLUSION: All the rates varied enormously between the studies and during the past 13 years. It seems that false positive and false negative fractions tended to diminish and stabilize in more recent years, and specificity and sensitivity underwent a slight increase. The differences between the rates of those studies suggest that FNA of the breast has some unavoidable limitations.