Functional differentiation of B lymphocytes in congenital agammaglobulinemia. II. Immunochemical analysis of the in vitro primary immune response.

Cultures of peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) in which specific hemolytic plaque-forming cells (HcPFC) had been induced were labeled with 14C-amino acids. Antigen-specific products in the culture supernatants were characterized by using indirect immune precipitation in conjunction with specific immunoabsorbents and/or gel filtration followed by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. After 5 days of culture with antigen (sheep red blood cells or ovalbumin) newly synthesized IgM and specific IgM antibody were demonstrated in culture supernatants from normal donors and from four out of five patients with congenital agammaglobulinemia (cAgamma). Secreted products bound specifically to antigen and pretreatment of labeled supernatants with anti-mu and anti-L chain antisera, but not with anti-gamma antiserum, prevented binding. Typical mu- and L chains constituted only a proportion of the anigen-binding peptides recognized by the anti-mu reagents. Induction of IgM antibody synthesis was dependent on the presence of antigen and was correlated with the generation of HcPFC. No major differences between the antigen-induced products of cAgamma and normal PBL were observed. These findings suggest that in the absence of terminal B cell differentiation in vivo, certain patients with cAgamma possess precursor cells that can respond to antigen in vitro with the synthesis of specific humoral products, including IgM antibody.     

In vitro immune response of human peripheral lymphocytes. III. Effect of anti-mu or anti-delta antibody on PWM-induced increase of cyclic nucleotides in human B lymphocytes.

Stimulation of human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) with pokeweed mitogen (PWM) induced consistent increases of intracellular levels of cyclic AMP and cyclic GMP within 15 min. Increases of cyclic AMP were observed in both B and T lymphocyte populations, but increase of cyclic GMP was observed only in the B lymphocyte population. The addition of anti-mu antibody to B cells abolished PWM-induced increase of cyclic GMP without any effect on cyclic AMP response. Anti-delta antibody did not show any inhibitory or stimulatory effect on PWM-induced increase of cyclic GMP or cyclic AMP. Pretreatment of B cells with anti-mu antibody at 37 degrees C for 1 hr inhibited PWM-induced increase of cyclic GMP, whereas pretreatment with anti-mu antibody at 4 degrees C did not show any inhibitory effect on PWM-induced increase of cyclic GMP. The effect of anti-mu-pretreatment was reversible and pretreated cells were recovered from the inhibitory effect of anti-mu antibody after 36 hr culture.     

Pokeweed mitogen-induced immunoglobulin secretion by peripheral blood lymphocytes from patients with primary intracranial tumors. Characterization of T helper and B cell function

We have previously demonstrated that patients with primary malignant brain tumors have impaired in vivo and in vitro cell-mediated immunity. The purpose of the present research was to employ pokeweed mitogen (PWM)-induced secretion of immunoglobulin (Ig) by peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) to further investigate impaired lymphocyte function in these patients. The PWM response of PBL from normal individuals averaged 8384 plaque-forming cells (PFC) per 10(6) cells, whereas the response of PBL from patients averaged 1590 PFC/10(6). The decreased PWM response of PBL patients could not be improved by varying the number of PBL placed in culture or employing different concentrations of PWM. Co-culture experiments to detect the presence of suppressor cells in PBL and purified T cell preparations from patients demonstrated that enhanced suppressor cell activity was not evident. Next, experiments were performed to assess the T-helper cell activity present in purified T cell preparations obtained from patients. The results demonstrated that T cells from patients lacked the ability to provide adequate helper activity in the PWM response. Moreover, studies with monoclonal antibodies directed against T cell subsets revealed that PBL from patients have a reduced percentage of T-helper cells (40%) as compared with normal values (55%). In concert with T-helper cell anomalies, B cell function in these patients also is diminished. Thus, these observations indicate that a combined T-helper and B cell defect may contribute to the broad impairment of host immunocompetence observed in patients with primary gliomas.     

Generation of human plaque-forming cells in culture: tissue distribution, antigenic and cellular requirements.

A system for the induction of specific, hemolytic plaque-forming cells from normal human lymphocytes in vitro (HcPFC) has been established and cells from various normal lymphoid tissues have been investigated. Normal values for anti-SRBC HcPFC responses in cultures of 107 Ficoll-Hypaque separated lymphocytes range from 2000 (bone marrow) to 7000 (spleen) and 15,000 (tonsillar and peripheral blood lymphocytes). HcPFC responses to ovalbumin were lower by factor of 2 to 4. Anti-SRBC as well as anti-ovalbumin responses required the cooperation of T lymphocytes and IgM-bearing B lymphocytes and the magnitude of the response was antigen dose dependent. Addition of adherent cells as well as of 2-mercaptoethanol enhanced the response. On the basis of the data obtained in experiments examining the role of B and T lymphocytes, a tentative model of cellular interaction has been postulated, suggesting a major role for antigen concentration in the modulation of the response via reactive T lymphocytes.     

Multiple myeloma: an immunologic profile. I. Peripheral blood studies.

Seventy-four patients with multiple myeloma, 17 untreated and 57 treated, were studied to characterize their peripheral blood lymphocytes. PBL were studied for E, EAC, and EA rosette-forming cells, SIg, and Fc receptor-bearing cells. The responses to HA, Con A, and PWM were assessed as well as their ability to stimulate or to respond in a MLC. Finally, the capacity of mitogen-stimulated lymphocytes to lyse Chang cells, CRBC, and PHA-stimulated lymphoblasts was examined. These results were compared with a group of normals and patients with benign monoclonal gammopathy. In untreated myeloma patients there was a normal percentage of T cells, but an abnormal distribution of B cells as judged by a decrease in SIg-bearing cells, as well as an increase in EAC rosette-forming cells. Subpopulation analysis showed a marked increase in EAC rosette-forming cells without SIg. PHA, Con A, and PWM, and response in MLC were all normal. However, the ability to stimulate in MLC was significantly depressed. Treated myeloma patients had similar findings, except that the response to PWM was significantly depressed. The capacity of PWM-stimulated cells to lyse target cells was depressed in both groups. The results indicate that, in the peripheral blood of myeloma patients, there are populations of lymphocytes characterized by the presence of the EAC receptor without SIg, which are deficient in the capacity to stimulate an MLC response and the ability to be cytotoxic when stimulated by PWM. The results form a baseline for the study of abnormal lymphoid function in human myeloma.     

Expression and function of an early activation marker restricted to human B cells

A B cell-specific monoclonal antibody (anti-Ba) was prepared. In two-color FACS analysis the anti-Ba reacted with a subpopulation of Ig+ or B1+ cells obtained from tonsils, but did not react with most B1+ cells derived from PBL. Activation of B cells from PBL with TPA or anti-mu induced Ba expression and the addition of PHA-conditioned supernatant with anti-mu-enhanced Ba expression. Other B cell activators, such as Staphylococcus aureus Cowan I (Staph-A) or PWM plus T cells, could induce Ba expression. Ba expression was observed 6 hr after stimulation and reached a peak level at 72 hr. Ba expression was strictly restricted to B cells. H-7, a specific inhibitor of protein kinase C (C-kinase), displayed a dose-dependent inhibitory effect on Ba expression, showing dependency on C-kinase for Ba expression. Anti-Ba inhibited B cell proliferation induced by anti-mu and B-BCGF distinct from BSF-1. The results presented in this study suggest that the Ba antigen on B cells may be comparable to the Tac antigen on T cells.     

Isolation and functional analysis of human B cell populations. I. Characterization of the B1+B2+ and B1+B2- subsets

Distinct populations of human B lymphocytes can be identified by their expression and/or co-expression of the B cell-restricted antigens B1 and B2. Dual fluorochrome staining and flow cytometric cell sorting permitted the isolation of the B1+B2+ and B1+B2- cells to homogeneity. In contrast, very few B1-B2+ cells were obtainable from normal lymphoid organs. Virtually all B1+B2+ cells expressed IgM and IgD, but lacked IgG and the plasma cell antigens PCA-1 and PC-1, whereas the B1+B2- cells more frequently expressed IgG, PCA-1 and PC-1. Both populations were noncycling and were composed of similar percentages of small and large cells. The B1+B2+ cells proliferate to anti-mu or to anti-mu + PHA-LCM, but not to PHA-LCM alone. They require both T cells and PWM to produce Ig. In contrast, B1+B2-cells do not significantly proliferate to anti-mu, PHA-LCM, or anti-mu and PHA-LCM. They produce Ig in response to T cells alone without PWM. These phenotypic and functional observations provide preliminary evidence that these populations are distinct and that the B1+B2+ cell may be a "resting" B cell, whereas the B1+B2- cell appears to be more "differentiated." The present studies further suggest that they will also be helpful in characterizing B cells in some human disease states. We believe that the identification and isolation of these and similar subsets of B cells defined by differing cell surface phenotype should aid our understanding both of normal B cell differentiation and of B cell disease states.     

Interferon acts directly on human B lymphocytes to modulate immunoglobulin synthesis

At different times of exposure, interferon (IFN) enhanced and suppressed pokeweed mitogen- (PWM) induced IgG synthesis by human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL). Pretreatment of PBL and IFN frequently increased antibody production by more than 100% when compared with that by untreated PBL. Results of experiments in which PBL were separated into T and B subpopulations indicated that IFN preparations acted directly on B cells. Thus, mixtures of IFN-treated B cells and untreated T cells from 5 of 7 persons tested produced 81% to 500% more IgG than untreated, matched control cells. However, IFN-treated monocytes mixed with untreated B and T cells or IFN-treated T cells mixed with untreated B cells failed to enhance IgG production significantly in similar assays. In contrast to the pretreatment protocol, when IFN was present in the incubation mixture throughout the PWM assay, IgG production decreased. Sephadex chromatography of the IFN and tests of the resulting fractions indicated that the IgG production-enhancing activity was located in the fraction carrying the antiviral activity.     

Regulation of immunoglobulin production in human peripheral bood leukocytes: cellular interactions.

The intercellular influences regulating immunoglobulin (Ig) synthesis by normal human peripheral blood leukocytes (PBL) were investigated in cells stimulated by pokeweed mitogen (PWM). This system was shown to be totally T lymphocyte dependent as purified B lymphocytes (less than or equal to 1% T lymphocytes) failed to make significant amounts of Ig. No evidence was obtained for an Ig class switch as all classes of Ig (IgM, IgG, IgA) were shown to be produced in increasing amounts over a 6-day time period. T lymphocytes demonstrated maximum helper effect when mixed with equal numbers of B cells. This helper effect was mediated through the dual mechanisms of increasing the number of B lymphocytes containing cytoplasmic Ig and by increasing the maturity of these B lymphocytes as demonstrated by an increasing Ig production per B lymphocyte. When present in higher numbers, T lymphocytes were also capable of suppressing Ig production. This T-mediated suppression was first evident as a decrease in the Ig produced per B lymphocyte (decreased maturity). With maximum T suppression Ig-containing B lymphocyte numbers were also diminished. T lymphocyte help was relatively independent of macrophages (phagocytic cells) and did not require DNA synthesis for expression. Both T help and suppression were shown to cross allogeneic barriers. Immature T lymphocytes (thymocytes) were incapable of mediating either activity. Normal human PBL contain T lymphocytes campable of mediating both T help and suppression and the Ig produced by PBL was shown to be the balance of these activities. This balance probably represent the participation of distinct T lymphocyte subpopulations analogous to the T helper (Ly 1+) and T suppressor (Ly 2+, 3+) populations in the mouse.     

Pregnancy-associated growth factor. II. A T-dependent polyclonal activator of human adult peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL)

This study examined the ability of pregnancy-associated growth factor (PAGF), a substance found in crude human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG), to induce plaque-forming cells (PFC) in cultured human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL). PAGF, 0.25 to 1 mg/ml, induced maximal PFC at 6 to 7 days as measured by the staphylococcal protein A-coupled SRBC reverse hemolytic plaque assay with a rabbit anti-human Ig antiserum. PAGF-induced PFC/culture ranged from 1800 to 39,000 with a mean of 11,524 in unfractionated PBL (N = 24), as compared to 540 to 77,840 with a mean of 17,303 for pokeweed (PWM) (N = 22). Comparison of PAGF- and PWM-induced PFC showed that both induced specific IgG, IgA, and IgM PFC. In most individuals, PAGF induced more IgM and PWM more IgG PFC. The kappa: lambda ratio was 1.5 for unstimulated PBL, and approximately 3.5 for PAGF and PWM. To see if PAGF was a T-dependent polyclonal activator of B cells, T and non-T populations were obtained by SRBC rosettes and negatively selected T4 and T8 cells by complement-mediated lysis of SRBC+(T) cells. Only the recombined subsets which included T4 cells and non-T cells supported PAGF- and PWM-induced PFC. These data indicate that PAGF, a substance derived from commercial extracts of pregnancy urine, is a T4-dependent polyclonal activator of normal human B cells.     

Characterization with dithiothreitol (DTT) of IgM auto-lymphocytotoxic antibodies in dialyzed patients awaiting kidney transplants

A group of 42 sensitized dialysis patients showing high reactivity (81%-100%) against a random panel of peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL), were analyzed for the presence of autoreactive lymphocytotoxic antibodies. The test was performed at different temperatures (4 degrees C, 22 degrees C, 37 degrees C) with dithiothreitol (DTT) against autologous PBL, EBV-induced autologous B lymphoblasts (A-BCL), K562 cells and T lymphocytes. Thirteen of 42 patients had IgM auto-lymphocytotoxic antibodies. The broadly reactive IgM autoantibodies could be inactivated by treatment with DTT 5 mM and allowed the identification of the presence of autoantibodies alone or in combination with anti-IgG alloantibodies.     

B lymphocyte differentiation induced by lipopolysaccharide. III. Suppression of B cell maturation by anti-mouse immunoglobulin antibodies.

Lipopolysaccharide-(LPS) induced differentiation of mouse B lymphocytes to cells synthesizing large amounts of cytoplasmic IgM and IgG2 could be suppressed by antibodies to mu-chains. Maximal inhibition of LPS-induced differentiation was associated with increased cellular proliferation as measured by incorporation of 3H-thymidine, whereas treatment with anti-mu alone over a wide dosage range did not stimulate cellular proliferation. Spleen cells from newborn mice were suppressed by concentrations of anti-mu several hundred-fold lower than required for adult spleen cells; the adult pattern of susceptibility to suppression was acquired by 1 week of age. No significant differences in susceptibility to anti-mu were found in comparisons of adult spleen, lymph node, bone marrow, and Peyer's patch lymphocytes.     

Differential effects of the stimulation of complement receptors CR1 (CD35) and CR2 (CD21) on cell proliferation and intracellular Ca2+ mobilization of chronic lymphocytic leukemia B cells.

The regulatory role of CR1 and CR2 on B cell activation and proliferation has been investigated by using B cells from patients with chronic lymphocytic leukemia. The chronic lymphocytic leukemia B cells are clonal expansions of B lymphocytes frozen at specific stages of activation. They displayed two patterns of response upon surface Ig (sIg) cross-linking in terms of in vitro proliferation and intracellular free Ca2+ mobilization: cells from patient F (first pattern) proliferated in the presence of mitogenic anti-mu antibodies, whereas cells from patient A (second pattern) did not respond to sIg cross-linking but proliferated in the presence of low m.w. B cell growth factor and IL-2. Coculture of A or F cells with C3b-bearing SRBC led to a two- to four-fold increase in thymidine incorporation in cultures containing low m.w. B cell growth factor but not in cultures containing rIL-2. This enhanced proliferation was inhibited by F(ab')2 polyclonal rabbit antihuman CR1 antibodies. Only cells which proliferated in the presence of anti-mu (cells F) responded to cross-linking of sIg with a rise in intracellular Ca2+. No increase in calcium mobilization was observed after co-cross-linking of CR1 and sIg on A and F cells with mAb or polyclonal anti-CR1 antibodies. Co-cross-linking of CR2 with sIg only led to an enhanced intracellular Ca2+ rise in F cells but not in A cells. The lack of CR2-mediated synergy in Ca2+ rise in A cells indicates that the synergy occurs only if there is a proper coupling of sIg to phospholipase C. CR1-induced proliferation of B cells does not involve the signaling pathways of sIg. These results provide additional evidences for the role of C3 fragments in modulation of human B cell activation.     

Recombinant interferon-alpha, -beta, and -gamma enhance the proliferative response of human B cells

Recombinant interferons (IFN-alpha, -beta, and -gamma) were examined for their effects on B cell activation. Relatively small IgM+ B cells from human blood samples were isolated by fluorescence-activated cell sorting and were used as target cells. Although the interferons themselves were nonmitogenic, each enhanced the proliferative response induced by a mitogenic anti-mu monoclonal antibody, with IFN-beta usually showing the greatest enhancement and IFN-gamma the least. Pretreatment with the interferons primed resting B cells to undergo enhanced DNA synthesis in response to the anti-mu antibody DA4. Conversely, anti-mu pretreatment, followed by IFN treatment, did not induce B cells to enter the S phase. Time-course analysis revealed that IFN could augment the anti-mu response even when added as late as the final 24 hr of a 3-day culture interval. Combinations of IFN-gamma plus IFN-alpha or -beta were synergistic in the anti-mu response, whereas the IFN-alpha plus IFN-beta combination was not. The data suggest that interferons produced by both lymphocytes (IFN-gamma) and nonlymphoid inflammatory cells (IFN-alpha and -beta) can enhance B cell growth via different mechanisms.     

Use of human leukocyte antigen-mismatched allogeneic lymphokine-activated killer cells and interleukin-2 in the adoptive immunotherapy of patients with malignancies

Clinical effects and side effects were studied in the adoptive immunotherapy of patients bearing malignant diseases using human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-mismatched allogeneic lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells. Allogeneic LAK cells were induced from peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of normal donors by means of initial stimulation with pokeweed mitogen (PWM). Six of 15 patients applied in the adoptive immunotherapy showed clinical effects such as partial or complete regression of pulmonary metastasis, pleural effusion and primary tumor. All pulmonary metastatic lesions were eliminated in one case by this adoptive immunotherapy combined with chemotherapy. Generally toxic effects were chillness, fever and general fatigue which were reversible, and no allergic side effects occurred even though allogeneic LAK cells were injected frequently except one patient who showed preshock like symptom accompanied with leukocytopenia and continuous hypotension immediately after infusion but was finally rescued. In the patients who received more than 10¹¹ of allogeneic LAK cells, anti-HLA class I antibodies appeared without any evidence of autoantibody. However, immunological side effects were never experienced after injection of allogeneic LAK cells even when the anti-HLA class I antibodies appeared in the patients. Taken together, allogeneic LAK cells could be considered as alternative therapy for patients with malignancies who could not supply sufficient materials of autologous LAK cells.Abbreviations PWM pokeweed mitogen - LAK lymphokine-activated killer - IL-2 interleukin 2 - PEL peripheral blood lymphocytes - TIL tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes - GVHD graft-versus-host disease - HLA human leukocyte antigen     

Pre-B cells: bone marrow persistence in anti-mu-suppressed mice, conversion to B lymphocytes, and recovery after destruction by cyclophosphamide.

Chronic treatment of mice from birth with anti-mu antibodies aborts development of B lymphocytes and plasma cells. In these studies we show that bone marrow from anti-mu-treated mice contains a population of cells with cytoplasmic IgM, but which lack detectable cell-surface IgM. These cells are analogous to pre-B cells, defined in ontogenetic studies as the immediate precursors of B lymphocytes. Pre-B cells from bone marrow of anti-mu treated mice retain their functional integrity, as evidenced by their ability to give rise to sIgM+, LPS-responsive lymphocytes in culture. We also show that cyclophosphamide treatment destroys pre-B cells and that recovery of pre-B cells in bone marrow precedes the regeneration of sIgM+ B lymphocytes. Generation of B lymphocytes in adult mice apparently occurs exclusively in the bone marrow because induction of extramedullary hemopoiesis in spleen was not accompanied by the appearance of pre-B cells in that organ.     

Influence of human thymocytes on B-lymphocyte differentiation in man.

Human thymocytes from children less than 6 years of age were tested for their influence on differentiation of normal B cells. The addition of either thymocytes or a culture supernatant from thymocytes to normal peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) enhanced pokeweed mitogen-induced B-cell differentiation as tested in a plaque-forming assay for antibody to sheep red blood cells. The thymocytes, however, could not substitute for T lymphocytes in cultures of PBL which had been previously depleted of T lymphocytes. Further, prior treatment of thymocytes with concanavalin A did not result in generation of suppressor cells for either B-cell differentiation or for the responses of PBL to mitogens. Thus, although thymocytes were functionally immature by these assays as compared to mature T lymphocytes they exerted an influence on B-cell differentiation in cultures of normal peripheral blood lymphocytes.     

Regulation of antibody release by naturally occurring anti-immunoglobulins in cultures of pokeweed mitogen-stimulated human peripheral blood lymphocytes

Immunoregulatory influences of human anti-immunoglobulins (anti-Ig) were studied in cultures of peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from 11 normal donors. Pokeweed mitogen (PWM)-stimulated PBL released anti-Ig specific for Fab or Fc fragments of IgG, often within the first 24 to 72 hr in vitro. PBL that released more than 1 ng/ml IgM anti-Fab during the first 72 hr in vitro ultimately produced significantly less antibody (Ab) by the 12th day than PBL that released no detectable IgM anti-Fab during the first 3 days in culture. Adding affinity-purified human anti-Fab to PWM-stimulated PBL also suppressed the later Ab release by these cells. Suppression was polyclonal, affecting IgM anti-Fc, IgM anti-Fab, and IgM anti-tetanus toxoid Ab, and was directly dependent on the quantity of anti-Fab added. Anti-Fab Ab, isolated from single donor sera, were more suppressive, nanogram for nanogram, than were equal quantities of IgG anti-Fab obtained from Cohn Fraction II, when added to autologous donor PBL in vitro. Affinity-purified IgM anti-Fc, from pooled rheumatoid arthritis patient sera, also suppressed Ab release by PWM-stimulated PBL in a dose-dependent manner. These observations suggest that anti-Ig may exert a significant immunoregulatory role in man that can override to some extent the T cell-dependent stimulus for polyclonal B cell activation provided by PWM.     

Human B cell differentiation. II. Suppression by T cells of T-dependent and T-independent plasma cell maturation.

In vitro human plasma cell generation induced by both T-dependent (PWM) and T-independent (NWSM) mitogens was found to be suppressed by peripheral blood lymphocytes preincubated with human aggregated IgG. T cells, but not B lymphocytes, were able to mediate the suppressive activity; since aggregated (Fab)'2 fragments were found unable to generate suppressor cells, it was concluded that the suppressor cell was a T lymphocyte bearing Fcgamma receptors. These cells appeared to be largely radiosensitive. In most cases the proliferative responses remained unchanged. Since NWSM-induced activation is not dependent on the presence of T cells, these results show that, at least in this case, T cells exert their suppressor function directly on B lymphocytes. Whether PWM-induced B cell differentiation is suppressed by the same mechanism or/and by inactivation of T helper lymphocytes remains under investigation.     

Interactions between B lymphocyte subpopulations. Augmentation of the responses of resting B lymphocytes by activated B lymphocytes

Mouse B lymphocytes were fractionated from normal T lymphocyte-depleted spleen cell populations using discontinuous percoll gradients and were stimulated with rabbit F(ab')2 anti-mouse mu-specific antibodies (anti-mu) plus the supernatant of Con A-stimulated rat spleen cells (SN) as a source of lymphokines. The responses of small (mean volume 120 mu 3), dense (greater than 1.087 specific gravity), resting (least spontaneous thymidine incorporation) B lymphocytes were augmented by irradiated (4000 rad), larger (mean volume greater than 170 mu 3), less dense (less than 1.081 specific gravity), activated (greater spontaneous thymidine incorporation) B lymphocytes. Proliferation was augmented 2- to 4-fold and polyclonal antibody-forming cell responses three- to sixfold. Maximal augmentation of the responses of 5 X 10(4) resting B cells was obtained with 10(4) activated B cells. Augmenting activity was specific for activated B lymphocytes in that responses were not augmented by irradiated thymocytes, T lymphoblasts, macrophages, or additional supernatant. B lymphocytes activated in vitro by LPS or anti-mu also had augmenting activity. Augmentation of responses was maximal only when activated B lymphocytes were added simultaneously with anti-mu. The interaction between activated and resting B lymphocytes did not appear to be genetically restricted. Interestingly, the augmenting activity of activated B cells could be reconstituted by a combination of supernatant and cell membranes from these cells but not by either alone, suggesting that two components are required, one soluble and the other membrane-bound. Thus, a functional interaction has been demonstrated between B lymphocyte subpopulations which differ in their state of activation, and this interaction appears to involve a novel mechanism of action.