Rare large scale subdomain motions in prion protein can initiate aggregation

The prion protein is thought to induce prion diseases by changing its conformation from the cellular form, PrP(C), into the infectious Scrapie-form, PrP(Sc). Little is known about the structural and dynamical features of this conformational change. We here introduce a novel concept that involves rare large scale motions between the subdomains beta1-alpha1-beta2 and alpha2-alpha3 in the carboxy-terminal, globular part of PrP. The interface between these two subdomains carries most pathogenic mutations known to be associated with prion diseases. Based on computational simulations as well as experimental results we propose that such a large scale motion subsequently destabilizes large parts of the cellular conformer PrP(C), thus, rendering it prone to structural rearrangements, including aggregation of now partially unfolded parts of the PrP sequence. We hypothesize that such large scale motions occur as a rare event even under equilibrium conditions and that the interaction of such partially destabilized PrP(C)-conformers, which we named PrP(C*), contributes to the formation of pathogenic oligomeric species of the prion protein.     

The highways and byways of prion protein trafficking

Prions are defined as infectious agents that comprise only proteins and are responsible for transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs)--fatal neurodegenerative diseases that affect humans and other mammals and include Creutzfeldt-Jacob disease in humans, scrapie in sheep and bovine spongiform encephalopathy in cattle. Prions have been proposed to arise from the conformational conversion of the cellular prion protein PrP(C) to a misfolded form termed PrP(Sc) that precipitates into aggregates and fibrils. The conversion process might be triggered by interaction of the infectious form with the cellular form or it might result from a mutation in the gene encoding PrP(C). Exactly how and where in the cell the interaction and the conversion of PrP(C) to PrP(Sc) occur, however, remain controversial. Recent studies have shed light on the intracellular trafficking of PrP(C), the role of protein mis-sorting and the cellular factors that are thought to be required for the conformational conversion of prion proteins.     

A protease-resistant protein is a structural component of the scrapie prion

Fractions purified from scrapie-infected hamster brain contain a unique protein, designated PrP. It was labeled with N-succinimidyl 3-(4-hydroxy-5-[125I]-iodophenyl) propionate, which did not alter the titer of the scrapie prion. The concentration of PrP was found to be directly proportional to the titer of the infectious prion. Both PrP and prion infectivity were resistant for 2 hr at 37 degrees C to hydrolysis by proteinase K under nondenaturing conditions. Prolonging the digestion resulted in a concomitant decrease in both PrP and the scrapie prion. When the amino-acid-specific proteases trypsin or SV-8 protease were used instead of proteinase K, no change in either PrP or the prion was detected. The parallel changes between PrP and the prion provide evidence that PrP is a structural component of the infectious prion. Our findings also suggest that the prion contains only one major protein, namely PrP.     

The prion protein and lipid rafts

Prions are the causative agent of the transmissible spongiform encephalopathies, such as Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in humans. In these prion diseases the normal cellular form of the prion protein (PrP(C)) undergoes a post-translational conformational conversion to the infectious form (PrP(Sc)). PrP(C) associates with cholesterol- and glycosphingolipid-rich lipid rafts through association of its glycosyl-phosphatidylinositol (GPI) anchor with saturated raft lipids and through interaction of its N-terminal region with an as yet unidentified raft associated molecule. PrP(C) resides in detergent-resistant domains that have different lipid and protein compositions to the domains occupied by another GPI-anchored protein, Thy-1. In some cells PrP(C) may endocytose through caveolae, but in neuronal cells, upon copper binding to the N-terminal octapeptide repeats, the protein translocates out of rafts into detergent-soluble regions of the plasma membrane prior to endocytosis through clathrin-coated pits. The current data suggest that the polybasic region at its N-terminus is required to engage PrP(C) with a transmembrane adaptor protein which in turn links with the clathrin endocytic machinery. PrP(C) associates in rafts with a variety of signalling molecules, including caveolin-1 and Fyn and Src tyrosine kinases. The clustering of PrP(C) triggers a range of signal transduction processes, including the recruitment of the neural cell adhesion molecule to rafts which in turn promotes neurite outgrowth. Lipid rafts appear to be involved in the conformational conversion of PrP(C) to PrP(Sc), possibly by providing a favourable environment for this process to occur and enabling disease progression.     

Rare Large Scale Subdomain Motions in Prion Protein can Initiate Aggregation

Abstract

The prion protein is thought to induce prion diseases by changing its conformation from the cellular form, PrP^c, into the infectious Scrapie-form, PrP^Sc. Little is known about the structural and dynamical features of this conformational change. We here introduce a novel concept that involves rare large scale motions between the subdomains βl-αl-β2 and α2-α3 in the carboxy-terminal, globular part of PrP. The interface between these two subdomains carries most pathogenic mutations known to be associated with prion diseases. Based on computational simulations as well as experimental results we propose that such a large scale motion subsequently destabilizes large parts of the cellular conformer PrP^c, thus, rendering it prone to structural rearrangements, including aggregation of now partially unfolded parts of the PrP sequence. We hypothesize that such large scale motions occur as a rare event even under equilibrium conditions and that the interaction of such partially destabilized PrP^c-conformers, which we named PrP^c*, contributes to the formation of pathogenic oligomeric species of the prion protein.     

Possible role for Ca2+ in the pathophysiology of the prion protein?

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies, or prion diseases, are lethal neurodegenerative disorders caused by the infectious agent named prion, whose main constituent is an aberrant conformational isoform of the cellular prion protein, PrP(C) . The mechanisms of prion-associated neurodegeneration and the physiologic function of PrP(C) are still unclear, although it is now increasingly acknowledged that PrP(C) plays a role in cell differentiation and survival. PrP(C) thus exhibits dichotomic attributes, as it can switch from a benign function under normal conditions to the triggering of neuronal death during disease. By reviewing data from models of prion infection and PrP-knockout paradigms, here we discuss the possibility that Ca(2+) is the hidden factor behind the multifaceted behavior of PrP(C) . By featuring in almost all processes of cell signaling, Ca(2+) might explain diverse aspects of PrP(C) pathophysiology, including the recently proposed one in which PrP(C) acts as a mediator of synaptic degeneration in Alzheimer's disease.     

Locally disordered conformer of the hamster prion protein: a crucial intermediate to PrPSc?

A crucial step for transformation of the normal cellular isoform of the prion protein (PrP(C)) to the infectious prion protein (PrP(Sc)) is thought to entail a previously uncharacterized intermediate conformer, PrP*, which interacts with a template PrP(Sc) molecule in the conversion process. By carrying out (15)N-(1)H two-dimensional NMR measurements under variable pressure on Syrian hamster prion protein rPrP(90-231), we found a metastable conformer of PrP(C) coexisting at a population of approximately 1% at pH 5.2 and 30 degrees C, in which helices B and C are preferentially disordered. While the identity is still unproven, this observed metastable conformer is most logically PrP* or a closely related precursor. The structural characteristics of this metastable conformer are consistent with available immunological and pathological information about the prion protein.     

Comparative computational analysis of prion proteins reveals two fragments with unusual structural properties and a pattern of increase in hydrophobicity associated with disease-promoting mutations

Prion diseases are a group of neurodegenerative disorders associated with conversion of a normal prion protein, PrPC, into a pathogenic conformation, PrPSc. The PrPSc is thought to promote the conversion of PrPC. The structure and stability of PrPC are well characterized, whereas little is known about the structure of PrPSc, what parts of PrPC undergo conformational transition, or how mutations facilitate this transition. We use a computational knowledge-based approach to analyze the intrinsic structural propensities of the C-terminal domain of PrP and gain insights into possible mechanisms of structural conversion. We compare the properties of PrP sequences to those of a PrP paralog, Doppel, and to the distributions of structural propensities observed in known protein structures from the Protein Data Bank. We show that the prion protein contains at least two sequence fragments with highly unusual intrinsic propensities, PrP(114-125) and helix B. No segments with unusual properties were found in Doppel protein, which is topologically identical to PrP but does not undergo structural rearrangements. Known disease-promoting PrP mutations form a statistically significant cluster in the region comprising helices B and C. Due to their unusual properties, PrP(114-125) and the C terminus of helix B may be considered as primary candidates for sites involved in conformational transition from PrPC to PrPSc. The results of our study also show that most PrP mutations associated with neurodegenerative disorders increase local hydrophobicity. We suggest that the observed increase in hydrophobicity may facilitate PrP-to-PrP or/and PrP-to-cofactor interactions, and thus promote structural conversion.     

Local structural plasticity of the prion protein. Analysis of NMR relaxation dynamics

A template-assisted conformational change of the cellular prion protein (PrP(C)) from a predominantly helical structure to an amyloid-type structure with a higher proportion of beta-sheet is thought to be the causative factor in prion diseases. Since flexibility of the polypeptide is likely to contribute to the ability of PrP(C) to undergo the conformational change that leads to the infective state, we have undertaken a comprehensive examination of the dynamics of two recombinant Syrian hamster PrP fragments, PrP(29-231) and PrP(90-231), using (15)N NMR relaxation measurements. The molecular motions of these PrP fragments have been studied in solution using (15)N longitudinal (T(1)) and transverse relaxation (T(2)) measurements as well as [(1)H]-(15)N nuclear Overhauser effects (NOE). These data have been analyzed using both reduced spectral density mapping and the Lipari-Szabo model free formalism. The relaxation properties of the common regions of PrP(29-231) and PrP(90-231) are very similar; both have a relatively inflexible globular domain (residues 128-227) with a highly flexible and largely unstructured N-terminal domain. Residues 29-89 of PrP(29-231), which include the copper-binding octarepeat sequences, are also highly flexible. Analysis of the spectral densities at each residue indicates that even within the structured core of PrP(C), a markedly diverse range of motions is observed, consistent with the inherent plasticity of the protein. The central portions of helices B and C form a relatively rigid core, which is stabilized by the presence of an interhelix disulfide bond. Of the remainder of the globular domain, the parts that are not in direct contact with the rigid region, including helix A, are more flexible. Most significantly, slow conformational fluctuations on a millisecond to microsecond time scale are observed for the small beta-sheet. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that the infectious, scrapie form of the protein PrP(Sc) could contain a helical core consisting of helices B and C, similar in structure to the cellular form PrP(C). Our results indicate that residues 90-140, which are required for prion infectivity, are relatively flexible in PrP(C), consistent with a lowered thermodynamic barrier to a template-assisted conformational change to the infectious beta-sheet-rich scrapie isoform.     

The role of the 132-160 region in prion protein conformational transitions

The native conformation of host-encoded cellular prion protein (PrP(C)) is metastable. As a result of a post-translational event, PrP(C) can convert to the scrapie form (PrP(Sc)), which emerges as the essential constituent of infectious prions. Despite thorough research, the mechanism underlying this conformational transition remains unknown. However, several studies have highlighted the importance of the N-terminal region spanning residues 90-154 in PrP folding. In order to understand why PrP folds into two different conformational states exhibiting distinct secondary and tertiary structure, and to gain insight into the involvement of this particular region in PrP transconformation, we studied the pressure-induced unfolding/ refolding of recombinant Syrian hamster PrP expanding from residues 90-231, and compared it with heat unfolding. By using two intrinsic fluorescent variants of this protein (Y150W and F141W), conformational changes confined to the 132-160 segment were monitored. Multiple conformational states of the Trp variants, characterized by their spectroscopic properties (fluorescence and UV absorbance in the fourth derivative mode), were achieved by tuning the experimental conditions of pressure and temperature. Further insight into unexplored conformational states of the prion protein, likely to mimic the in vivo structural change, was obtained from pressure-assisted cold unfolding. Furthermore, salt-induced conformational changes suggested a structural stabilizing role of Tyr150 and Phe141 residues, slowing down the conversion to a beta-sheet form.     

The role of rafts in the fibrillization and aggregation of prions

A key molecular event in prion diseases is the conversion of the prion protein (PrP) from its normal cellular form (PrP(C)) to the disease-specific form (PrP(Sc)). The transition from PrP(C) to PrP(Sc) involves a major conformational change, resulting in amorphous aggregates and/or fibrillar amyloid deposits. Here several lines of evidence implicating membranes in the conversion of PrP are reviewed with a particular emphasis on the role of lipid rafts in the conformational transition of prion proteins. New correlations between in vitro biophysical studies and findings from cell biology work on the role of rafts in prion conversion are highlighted and a mechanism for the role of rafts in prion conversion is proposed.     

Molecular distinction between pathogenic and infectious properties of the prion protein

Tg(PG14) mice express a prion protein (PrP) with a nine-octapeptide insertion associated with a human familial prion disease. These animals spontaneously develop a fatal neurodegenerative disorder characterized by ataxia, neuronal apoptosis, and accumulation in the brain of an aggregated and weakly protease-resistant form of mutant PrP (designated PG14(spon)). Brain homogenates from Tg(PG14) mice fail to transmit disease after intracerebral inoculation into recipient mice, indicating that PG14(spon), although pathogenic, is distinct from PrP(Sc), the infectious form of PrP. In contrast, inoculation of Tg(PG14) mice with exogenous prions of the RML strain induces accumulation of PG14(RML), a PrP(Sc) form of the mutant protein that is infectious and highly protease resistant. Like PrP(Sc), both PG14(spon) and PG14(RML) display conformationally masked epitopes in the central and octapeptide repeat regions. However, these two forms differ profoundly in their oligomeric states, with PG14(RML) aggregates being much larger and more resistant to dissociation. Our analysis provides new molecular insight into an emerging puzzle in prion biology, the discrepancy between the infectious and neurotoxic properties of PrP.     

Multiple biochemical similarities between infectious and non-infectious aggregates of a prion protein carrying an octapeptide insertion

A nine-octapeptide insertion in the prion protein (PrP) gene is associated with an inherited form of human prion disease. Transgenic (Tg) mice that express the mouse homolog of this mutation (designated PG14) spontaneously accumulate in their brains an insoluble and weakly protease-resistant form of the mutant protein. This form (designated PG14(Spon)) is highly neurotoxic, but is not infectious in animal bioassays. In contrast, when Tg(PG14) mice are inoculated with the Rocky Mountain Laboratory (RML) strain of prions, they accumulate a different form of PG14 PrP (designated PG14(RML)) that is highly protease resistant and infectious in animal transmission experiments. We have been interested in characterizing the molecular properties of PG14(Spon) and PG14(RML), with a view to identifying features that determine two, apparently distinct properties of PrP aggregates: their infectivity and their pathogenicity. In this paper, we have subjected PG14(Spon) and PG14(RML) to a panel of assays commonly used to distinguish infectious PrP (PrP(Sc)) from cellular PrP (PrP(C)), including immobilized metal affinity chromatography, precipitation with sodium phosphotungstate, and immunoprecipitation with PrP(C)- and PrP(Sc)-specific antibodies. Surprisingly, we found that aggregates of PG14(Spon) and PG14(RML) behave identically to each other, and to authentic PrP(Sc), in each of these biochemical assays. PG14(Spon) however, in contrast to PG14(RML) and PrP(Sc), was unable to seed the misfolding of PrP(C) in an in vitro protein misfolding cyclic amplification reaction. Collectively, these results suggest that infectious and non-infectious aggregates of PrP share common structural features accounting for their toxicity, and that self-propagation of PrP involves more subtle molecular differences.     

Differences between the prion protein and its homolog Doppel: a partially structured state with implications for scrapie formation

The key event in the pathogenesis of prion diseases is a conformational change in the prion protein (PrP). Models for conversion of PrP(C) into PrP(Sc) typically implicate an, as yet, unidentified intermediate. In an attempt to identify such an intermediate, we used native-state hydrogen exchange monitored with NMR. Although we were unable to detect an intermediate directly, we observed substantial protection above that expected based upon measurements of the global stability of PrP (>2 kcal mol(-1) super protection). This super protection implicates either structure in the denatured state or the presence of an intermediate. Similar experiments with Doppel, a homolog of PrP that does not form infectious prions, failed to demonstrate such super protection. This suggests that the partially structured state of PrP encompassing portions of the B and C helices, may be a significant factor in the ability of PrP to convert from PrP(C) to PrP(Sc).     

The role of PrP in health and disease

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) such as scrapie in sheep, bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) in cattle or Creutzfeldt-Jacob disease (CJD) and Gerstmann-Str?ussler-Scheinker syndrome (GSS) in humans, are caused by an infectious agent designated prion. The "protein only" hypothesis states that the prion consists partly or entirely of a conformational isoform of the normal host protein PrPc and that the abnormal conformer, when introduced into the organism, causes the conversion of PrPc into a likeness of itself. Since the proposal of the "protein only" hypothesis more than three decades ago, cloning of the PrP gene, studies on PrP knockout mice and on mice transgenic for mutant PrP genes allowed deep insights into prion biology. Reverse genetics on PrP knockout mice containing modified PrP transgenes was used to address a variety of problems: mapping PrP regions required for prion replication, studying PrP mutations affecting the species barrier, modeling familial forms of human prion disease, analysing the cell specificity of prion propagation and investigating the physiological role of PrP by structure-function studies. Many questions regarding the role of PrP in susceptibility to prions have been elucidated, however the physiological role of PrP and the pathological mechanisms of neurodegeneration in prion diseases are still elusive.     

Optimized overproduction,purification, characterization and high-pressure sensitivity of the prion protein in the native (PrP(C)-like) or amyloid (PrP(Sc)-like) conformation

Overproduction and purification of the prion protein is a major concern for biological or biophysical analysis as are the structural specificities of this protein in relation to infectivity. We have developed a method for the effective cloning, overexpression in Escherichia coli and purification to homogeneity of Syrian golden hamster prion protein (SHaPrP(90-231)). A high level of overexpression, resulting in the formation of inclusion bodies, was obtained under the control of the T7-inducible promoter of the pET15b plasmid. The protein required denaturation, reduction and refolding steps to become soluble and attain its native conformation. Purification was carried out by differential centrifugation, gel filtration and reverse phase chromatography. An improved cysteine oxidation protocol using oxidized glutathione under denaturing conditions, resulted in the recovery of a higher yield of chromatographically pure protein. About 10 mg of PrP protein per liter of bacterial culture was obtained. The recombinant protein was identified by monoclonal antibodies and its integrity was confirmed by electrospray mass spectrometry (ES/MS), whereas correct folding was assessed by circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. This protein had the structural characteristics of PrP(C) and could be converted to an amyloid structure sharing biophysical and biochemical properties of the pathologic form (PrP(Sc)). The sensitivity of these two forms to high pressure was investigated. We demonstrate the potential of using pressure as a thermodynamic parameter to rescue trapped aggregated prion conformations into a soluble state, and to explore new conformational coordinates of the prion protein conformational landscape.     

Misfolding of the prion protein at the plasma membrane induces endocytosis, intracellular retention and degradation

Suramin induces misfolding of the cellular prion protein (PrP(C)) and interferes with the propagation of infectious scrapie prions. A mechanistic analysis of this effect revealed that suramin-induced misfolding occurs at the plasma membrane and is dependent on the proximal region of the C-terminal domain (aa 90-158) of PrP(C). The conformational transition induces rapid internalization, mediated by the unstructured N-terminal domain, and subsequent intracellular degradation of PrP(C). As a consequence, PrP Delta N adopts a misfolded conformation at the plasma membrane; however, internalization is significantly delayed. We also found that misfolding and intracellular retention of PrP(C) can be induced by copper and that, moreover, copper interferes with the propagation of the pathogenic prion protein (PrP(Sc)) in scrapie-infected N2a cells. Our study revealed a quality control pathway for aberrant PrP conformers present at the plasma membrane and identified distinct PrP domains involved.     

Prion protein amyloid formation under native-like conditions involves refolding of the C-terminal alpha-helical domain

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies are associated with conformational conversion of the cellular prion protein, PrP(C), into a proteinase K-resistant, amyloid-like aggregate, PrP(Sc). Although the structure of PrP(Sc) remains enigmatic, recent studies have afforded increasingly detailed characterization of recombinant PrP amyloid. However, all previous studies were performed using amyloid fibrils formed in the presence of denaturing agents that significantly alter the folding state(s) of the precursor monomer. Here we report that PrP amyloid can also be generated under physiologically relevant conditions, where the monomeric protein is natively folded. Remarkably, site-directed spin labeling studies reveal that these fibrils possess a beta-core structure nearly indistinguishable from that of amyloid grown under denaturing conditions, where the C-terminal alpha-helical domain of the PrP monomer undergoes major refolding to a parallel and in-register beta-structure upon conversion. The structural similarity of fibrils formed under drastically different conditions strongly suggests that the common beta-sheet architecture within the approximately 160-220 core region represents a distinct global minimum in the PrP conversion free energy landscape. We also show that the N-terminal region of fibrillar PrP displays conformational plasticity, undergoing a reversible structural transition with an apparent pK(a) of approximately 5.3. The C-terminal region, on the other hand, retains its beta-structure over the pH range 1-11, whereas more alkaline buffer conditions denature the fibrils into constituent PrP monomers. This profile of pH-dependent stability is reminiscent of the behavior of brain-derived PrP(Sc), suggesting a substantial degree of structural similarity within the beta-core region of these PrP aggregates.     

Aggregation and fibrillization of prions in lipid membranes

A key molecular event in prion diseases is the conversion of PrP (prion protein) from its normal cellular form (PrP(c)) into the disease-specific form (PrP(Sc)). The transition from PrP(c) to PrP(Sc) involves a major conformational change, resulting in amorphous aggregates and/or fibrillar amyloid deposits. Here, we review several lines of evidence implicating membranes in the conversion of PrP, and summarize recent results from our own work on the role of lipid membranes in conformational transitions of prion proteins. By establishing new correlations between in vivo biological findings with in vitro biophysical results, we propose a role for lipid rafts in prion conversion, which takes into account the structural heterogeneity of PrP in different lipid environments.     

Solution structure of the E200K variant of human prion protein. Implications for the mechanism of pathogenesis in familial prion diseases

Prion propagation in transmissible spongiform encephalopathies involves the conversion of cellular prion protein, PrP(C), into a pathogenic conformer, PrP(Sc). Hereditary forms of the disease are linked to specific mutations in the gene coding for the prion protein. To gain insight into the molecular basis of these disorders, the solution structure of the familial Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease-related E200K variant of human prion protein was determined by multi-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Remarkably, apart from minor differences in flexible regions, the backbone tertiary structure of the E200K variant is nearly identical to that reported for the wild-type human prion protein. The only major consequence of the mutation is the perturbation of surface electrostatic potential. The present structural data strongly suggest that protein surface defects leading to abnormalities in the interaction of prion protein with auxiliary proteins/chaperones or cellular membranes should be considered key determinants of a spontaneous PrP(C) --> PrP(Sc) conversion in the E200K form of hereditary prion disease.