Glass microspargers as effective frit spargers in single use bioreactors

For multiple-use bench scale and larger bioreactors, sintered stainless steel frit spargers are commonly used as microspargers. For bench-scale single-use bioreactors (SUBs), existing microspargers are sintered plastics, such as polyethylene. However, though plastics are readily sterilized by irradiation making them convenient for single use, these designs overlook surface energy properties of the materials of construction. For these sintered plastic spargers, forces at the water-air-surface interface cause bubble coalescence, leading to lower effective mass transfer, higher gas flow rates, and differing pCO₂ profiles in cell culture. Alternative materials of construction were evaluated based on contact angle information and bubble formation observations. Sintered glass was chosen over thermoplastic polymers for higher surface wettability as described in the glass/water contact angle, its history as a commonly sintered material, and availability at costs suitable for single use applications. Glass sintered spargers and traditional stainless steel frit spargers were compared by porosity, bubble size, and k_La studies. Mass transfer (k_La) and cell culture performance equal or greater than a standard 20 μm stainless steel microsparger mass transfer efficiency was achieved by a glass frit sparger, of international porosity standard “P40” according to ISO 4793-80, which corresponds to a range of 16–40 μm.     

NS0 cell damage by high gas velocity sparging in protein-free and cholesterol-free cultures

Recent developments in high cell density and high productivity fed-batch animal cell cultures have placed a high demand on oxygenation and carbon dioxide removal in bioreactors. The high oxygen demand is often met by increasing agitation and sparging rates of air/O2 in the bioreactors. However, as we demonstrate in this study, an increase of gas sparging can result in cell damage at the sparger site due to high gas entrance velocities. Previous studies have showed that gas bubble breakup at the culture surface was primarily responsible for cell damage in sparged bioreactors. Such cell damage can be reduced by use of surfactants such as Pluronic F-68 in the culture. In our results, where NS0 cells were grown in a protein-free and cholesterol-free medium containing 0.5 g/L Pluronic F-68, high gas entrance velocity at the sparger site was observed as the second mechanism for cell damage. Experiments were performed in scaled-down spinners to model the effect of hydrodynamic force resulting from high gas velocities on antibody-producing NS0 cells. Cell growth and cell death were described by first-order kinetics. Cell death rate constant increased significantly from 0.04 to 0.18 day(-1) with increasing gas entrance velocity from 2.3 to 82.9 m/s at the sparger site. The critical gas entrance velocity for the NS0 cell line studied was found to be approximately 30 m/s; velocities greater than 30 m/s caused cell damage which resulted in reduced viability and consequently reduced antibody production. Observations from a second cholesterol-independent NS0 cell line confirmed the occurrence of cell damage due to high gas velocities. Increasing the concentration of Pluronic F-68 from 0.5 to 2 g/L had no additional protective effect on cell damage associated with high gas velocity at the sparger. The results of gas velocity analysis for cell damage have been applied in two case studies of large-scale antibody manufacturing. The first is a troubleshooting study for antibody production carried out in a 600 L bioreactor, and the second is the development of a gas sparger design for a large bioreactor scale (e.g., 10,000 L) for antibody manufacturing.     

Using CFD simulations and statistical analysis to correlate oxygen mass transfer coefficient to both geometrical parameters and operating conditions in a stirred-tank bioreactor

Optimization of a bioreactor design can be an especially challenging process. For instance, testing different bioreactor vessel geometries and different impeller and sparger types, locations, and dimensions can lead to an exceedingly large number of configurations and necessary experiments. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD), therefore, has been widely used to model multiphase flow in stirred-tank bioreactors to minimize the number of optimization experiments. In this study, a multiphase CFD model with population balance equations are used to model gas–liquid mixing, as well as gas bubble distribution, in a 50 L single-use bioreactor vessel. The vessel is the larger chamber in an early prototype of a multichamber bioreactor for mammalian cell culture. The model results are validated with oxygen mass transfer coefficient (k_La) measurements within the prototype. The validated model is projected to predict the effect of using ring or pipe spargers of different sizes and the effect of varying the impeller diameter on k_La. The simulations show that ring spargers result in a superior k_La compared to pipe spargers, with an optimum sparger-to-impeller diameter ratio of 0.8. In addition, larger impellers are shown to improve k_La. A correlation of k_La is presented as a function of both the reactor geometry (i.e., sparger-to-impeller diameter ratio and impeller-to-vessel diameter ratio) and operating conditions (i.e., Reynolds number and gas flow rate). The resulting correlation can be used to predict k_La in a bioreactor and to optimize its design, geometry, and operating conditions.     

Hydrodynamics and mass transfer in miniaturized bubble column bioreactors

Miniaturized bubble columns (MBCs) have different hydrodynamics in comparison with the larger ones, but there is a lack of scientific data on MBCs. Hence, in this study, the effect of gas hold-up, flow regimes, bubble size distribution on volumetric oxygen mass transfer coefficient at different pore size spargers and gas flow rates in MBCs in the presence and absence of microorganisms were investigated. It was found that flow regime transition occurred around low gas flow rates of 1.18 and 0.85 cm/s for small (16–40 µm) and large (40–100 µm) pore size spargers, respectively. Gas hold-up and K_La in MBC with small size sparger were higher than those with larger one, with an increasing effect in the presence of microorganisms. A comparison revealed that the wall effect on the flow regime and gas hold-up in MBCs was greater than bench-scale bubble columns. The K_La values significantly increased up to tenfold using small pore size sparger. In the MBC and stirred tank bioreactors, the maximum obtained cell concentrations were OD₆₀₀ of 41.5 and 43.0, respectively. Furthermore, it was shown that in MBCs, higher K_La and lower turbulency could be achieved at the end of bubbly flow regime.

     

A novel scale-up method for mammalian cell culture in packed-bed bioreactor

A novel method for the scale-up culture of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells in a packed-bed bioreactor is developed wherein microcarriers, attached with CHO cells in a microcarrier culture system, are inoculated directly into the packed-bed bioreactor. Cells continue to grow after inoculation and the maximum cell density reaches about 2×10⁷ cells ml^–1. The method provides a new technique for the scale-up of a packed-bed culture while decreasing the labour cost and ensuring the safety of operation.     

机械搅拌式动物细胞反应器不同桨型组合的CFD数值模拟与优化

生物反应器已成为哺乳动物细胞生产治疗性抗体药物和疫苗的核心。文中采用CFD数值模拟方法对目前常用的机械搅拌式生物反应器在不同的搅拌形式下的流场进行了分析,获得了5种搅拌桨型组合条件下的速率矢量、持气率、含气率和剪切力分布的特征。通过构建的重组CHO细胞在不同搅拌形式条件下的流加分批培养发现,细胞密度和抗体表达水平与反应器内的最大剪切率直接相关,在FBMI3搅拌形式下细胞密度和抗体表达水平均最高。结果表明该CHO细胞在悬浮培养时对剪切环境比较敏感,且最大剪切力是工业规模放大的关键因素。     

The influence of polymeric membrane gas spargers on hydrodynamics and mass transfer in bubble column bioreactors

Gas sparging performances of a flat sheet and tubular polymeric membranes were investigated in 3.1 m bubble column bioreactor operated in a semi batch mode. Air–water and air–CMC (Carboxymethyl cellulose) solutions of 0.5, 0.75 and 1.0 % w/w were used as interacting gas–liquid mediums. CMC solutions were employed in the study to simulate rheological properties of bioreactor broth. Gas holdup, bubble size distribution, interfacial area and gas–liquid mass transfer were studied in the homogeneous bubbly flow hydrodynamic regime with superficial gas velocity (U _G) range of 0.0004–0.0025 m/s. The study indicated that the tubular membrane sparger produced the highest gas holdup and densely populated fine bubbles with narrow size distribution. An increase in liquid viscosity promoted a shift in bubble size distribution to large stable bubbles and smaller specific interfacial area. The tubular membrane sparger achieved greater interfacial area and an enhanced overall mass transfer coefficient (K _La) by a factor of 1.2–1.9 compared to the flat sheet membrane.     

用填充床生物反应器大规模培养表达重组人红细胞生成素的细胞株

目的：用填充床生物反应器培养表达重组人红细胞生成素的工程细胞株C2W,使其达到高密度高表达。方法：将工程细胞株用含5％小牛血清的DF培养基复苏放大培养,当细胞达到10^9时,接种到5L生物反应器中,先用含血清培养基生长培养,再换为无血清培养基表达培养;在整个培养过程中,采用流加方式连续培养,每日采样测定培养上清中葡萄糖浓度,隔日测定细胞的表达水平。结果：接种量约为10^9细胞;细胞罐培养57d,包括含血清生长培养6d,无血清表达培养51d：重组人红细胞生成素平均表达水平为5636U／mL,最高时达7880U／mL;收集无血清培养上清476L,平均每日灌流量8.3L,最高时达12L／日。结论：在适当的条件下,利用填充床生物反应器可使工程细胞株的培养达到长时间、高表达。     

Membrane sparger in bubble column,airlift, and combined membrane–ring sparger bioreactors

The bubble column and the two internal loop airlift reactors (riser/downcomer area ratios of 0.11 and 0.58) characterized in this study were equipped with a rubber membrane sparger, which produced small bubbles, giving high mass transfer coefficients. The low mixing intensity in the bubble column was increased by an order of magnitude in the airlift reactors. We designed a novel aeration and mixing system by adding a ring sparger to the membrane sparger in the bubble column and maintained the advantages of both airlift configuration (good mixing properties) and bubble column configuration (efficient aeration, without any internal constructions). The combined membrane–ring sparger system has unique features with respect to the efficiency of utilization of substrate gasses and energy. Model experiments showed that the small bubbles from the membrane sparger do not coalesce with the large bubbles from the ring sparger. If different gases were added through the two spargers it was possible to transfer a hazardous or expensive gas quantitatively to the liquid through the membrane sparger (dual sparging mode). In the combined membrane–ring sparger system the energy input for mixing and mass transfer is divided. Therefore, the energy consumption can be minimized if the flow distribution of air through the membrane and ring sparger is controlled by the oxygen demand and the inhomogeneity of the culture, respectively (split sparging mode). The dual sparging mode was used for mass production of the alga Rhodomonas sp. as the first step in aquatic food chains. Avoiding mechanical parts removes an important risk of malfunction, and a continuous culture could be maintained for more than 8 months. © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biotechnol Bioeng 64: 452–458, 1999.     

Influence of sparger on energy dissipation, shear rate, and mass transfer to sea water in a concentric-tube airlift bioreactor

Data on volumetric mass-transfer coefficient, K_La_L, in a 12 × 10⁻³ m³ airlift bioreactor are reported. Measurements were made in sea water. The superficial gas velocity ranged up to 0.21 m/s. Four cylindrical spargers (60–1000 μm pore size) were tested. In bubbly flow, the sparger pore size strongly influenced the K_La_L; the highest K_La_L values were obtained with the smallest pore size. In contrast, in the transition and heterogeneous flow regimes, the pore size had little influence on K_La_L. The best correlation of the mass transfer data was obtained when both gas holdup and liquid superficial velocity were taken as independent variables. Shear rates were estimated in the different zones of the reactor. The highest values were found in the bottom zone of the reactor and in the gas-liquid separator. The penetration and isotropic turbulence models were used to develop a semi-theoretical equation relating the volumetric mass-transfer coefficient to shear rate; hence providing a better understanding of how the operational variables may be manipulated to attain a moderate shear rate and an appropriate level of mass transfer, two extremely important parameters for the growth of sensible microorganisms as those used in marine biotechnology.     

CFD simulation coupled with population balance equations for aerated stirred bioreactors

Mammalian cells have been widely used to produce therapeutic proteins in stirred bioreactors in suspension culture. Local hydrodynamics can have a great impact on cell proliferation and protein synthesis, but there are few reports on spatial heterogeneity of nutrients, gas bubbles, and mass transfer coefficients. We have employed computational fluid dynamics (CFD) coupled with population balance equations to study local hydrodynamics in a 20 L stirred bioreactor. The flow patterns, energy dissipation rates, gas volume fraction, gas bubble size distribution and local mass transfer coefficient have been displayed throughout the whole bioreactor. Their implications for mammalian cell culture have been discussed. This study provides an insight into rational design and optimum operation conditions in a stirred bioreactor for mammalian cell cultivation.     

Batch, fed-batch, and microcarrier cultures with CHO cell lines in a pressure-cycle driven miniaturized bioreactor

Miniaturized bioreactors for suspension cultures of animal cells, such as Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) cells, could improve bioprocess development through the ability to cheaply explore a wide range of bioprocess operating conditions. A miniaturized pressure-cycled bioreactor for animal cell cultures, described previously (Diao et al., 2008), was tested with a suspension CHO cell line producing commercially relevant quantities of human IgG. Results from the suspended CHO cell line showed that the cell growth was comparable to conventional flask controls and the target protein production was enhanced in the minibioreactor, which may be due to the relatively high oxygen transfer rate and the moderate shear stress, measured and simulated previously. Microcarrier culture using an anchorage-dependent CHO cell line and Cytodex 3 also showed a similar result: comparable growth and enhanced production of a model protein (secreted alkaline phosphatase or SEAP). Various fed-batch schemes were applied to the CHO cells producing human IgG, yielding cell numbers (1.1 × 10(7) /mL) at day 8 and titers of human IgG (2.3 g/L) at day 14 that are typical industrial values for CHO cell fed-batch cultures. The alteration of the volumetric oxygen transfer coefficient is a key parameter for viability of the CHO cell line producing human IgG. We conclude that the minibioreactor can provide favorable cell culture environments; oxygen transfer coefficient and mixing time can be altered to mimic values in a larger scale system allowing for potential prediction of response during scale-up.     

Comparison of the hydrodynamics and mass transfer characteristics in internal-loop airlift bioreactors utilizing either a novel membrane-tube sparger or perforated plate sparger

Two gas spargers, a novel membrane-tube sparger and a perforated plate sparger, were compared in terms of hydrodynamics and mass transfer (or oxygen transfer) performance in an internal-loop airlift bioreactor. The overall gas holdup ε _T, downcomer liquid velocity V _d, and volumetric mass transfer coefficient K _L a were examined depending on superficial gas velocity U _G increased in Newtonian and non-Newtonian fluids for the both spargers. Compared with the perforated plate sparger, the bioreactor with the membrane-tube sparger increased the values of ε _T by 4.9–48.8 % in air–water system when the U _G was from 0.004 to 0.04 m/s, and by 65.1–512.6 % in air–CMC solution system. The V _d value for the membrane-tube sparger was improved by 40.0–86.3 %. The value of K _L a was increased by 52.8–84.4 % in air–water system, and by 63.3–836.3 % in air–CMC solution system. Empirical correlations of ε _T, V _d, and K _L a were proposed, and well corresponding with the experimental data with the deviation of 10 %.     

Production of extracellular protease from crude substrates with dregs in an external-loop airlift bioreactor with lower ratio of height to diameter

Bacillus subtilis AS1.398 was cultivated in a 11.5-L total volume external-loop airlift bioreactor with a low height-to-diameter ratio of 2.9 and a riser-to-downcomer diameter ratio of 6.6 for the production of protease from crude substrates with dregs. The influence of aeration rate, liquid volume, and sparger hole diameter on protease production was investigated. An average of 8197 u/mL protease activity was obtained after a total fermentation time of 32 h in the external-loop airlift bioreactor with a liquid volume of 8.5 L, air flow rate of 1.5 vvm, and sparger hole diameter of 1.5 mm. The addition of one stainless steel sieve plate in the riser of the airlift bioreactor increased productivity of protease. After 32 h of fermentation, an average of 8718 u/mL protease activity was achieved in the external-loop airlift bioreactor with one sieve plate and an air flow rate of 1.2 vvm, liquid volume of 8.5 L, and gas sparger hole diameter of 1.5 mm. This was 9.0% higher than the typical averages of about 8000 u/mL protease activity in the mechanically stirred tank bioreactors of the enzyme factory using the same microorganism. It is possible to make a scale-up of the external-loop airlift bioreactor and feasible to operate it for production of protease from crude substrate with dregs.     

Effects of bubble–liquid two‐phase turbulent hydrodynamics on cell damage in sparged bioreactor

According to recent experimental studies on sparged bioreactors, significant cell damage may occur at the gas inlet region near the sparger. Although shear stress was proposed to be one of the potential causes for cell damage, detailed hydrodynamic studies at the gas inlet region of gas–liquid bioreactors have not been performed to date. In this work, a second‐order moment (SOM) bubble–liquid two‐phase turbulent model based on the two‐fluid continuum approach is used to investigate the gas–liquid hydrodynamics in the bubble column reactor and their potential impacts on cell viability, especially at the gas inlet region. By establishing fluctuation velocity and bubble–liquid two‐phase fluctuation velocities correlation transport equations, the anisotropy of two‐phase stresses and the bubble–liquid interactions are fully considered. Simulation results from the SOM model indicate that shear and normal stresses, turbulent energy dissipation rate, and the turbulent kinetic energy are generally smaller at the gas inlet region when compared with those in the fully developed region. In comparison, a newly proposed correlation expression, stress‐induced turbulent energy production (STEP), is found to correlate well with the unusually high cell death rate at the gas inlet region. Therefore, STEP, which represents turbulent energy transfer to a controlled volume induced by a combination of shear and normal stresses, has the potential to provide better explanation for increased cell death at the sparger region. © 2013 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 30:48–58, 2014     

Scale-up of virus-like particles production: effects of sparging, agitation and bioreactor scale on cell growth, infection kinetics and productivity

The baculovirus-insect cells expression system was used for the production of self-forming Porcine parvovirus (PPV) like particles (virus-like particles, VLPs) in serum-free medium. At 2l bioreactor scale an efficient production was achieved by infecting the culture at a concentration of 1.5 x 10(6)cells/ml using a low multiplicity of infection of 0.05 pfu per cell. In a continuous bioreactor, it was shown that the uninfected insect cells were not sensitive to local shear stress values up to 2.25 N/m2 at high Reynolds numbers (1.5 x 10(4)) in sparging conditions. Uninfected insect cells can be grown at scaled-up bioreactor at high agitation and sparging rates as long as vortex formation is avoided and bubble entrapment is minimized. An efficient process scale-up to 25 l bioreactor was made using constant shear stress criteria for scale-up. The kinetics of baculovirus infection at low multiplicity of infection, either at different cell concentration or at different scales, are very reproducible, despite the different turbulence conditions present in the bioreactor milieu. The results suggest that the infection kinetics is controlled by the rate of baculovirus-cell receptor attachment and is independent of the bioreactor hydrodynamic conditions. Furthermore, the achieved specific and volumetric productivities were higher at the 25 l scale when compared to the smaller scale bioreactor. Different rates of cell lysis after infection were observed and seem to fully explain both the shift in optimal harvest time and the increase in cell specific productivity. The results emphasize the importance of integrated strategies and engineering concepts in process development at bioreactor stage with the baculovirus insect cell system.     

Experimental study of a ceramic microsparging aeration system in a pilot-scale animal cell culture

The oxygen supply of cell cultures with the aid of free gas bubbles is an efficient process strategy in pharmaceutical production. If the cell-damaging impact of gas bubbles is reduced, direct aeration becomes a practical solution with scale-up potential and comparatively high oxygen transfer rates. In this paper a microsparging aeration system made of porous ceramic was compared with bubble-free membrane aeration. The sparging system was used for the long-term cultivation of mammalian cells in 2- to 100-L scale bioreactors and produced bubble sizes of 100-500 microm in diameter. Using a scale of 2.5 and 30 L, a cell density of 2.6 x 10(6) cells/mL was attained. When a 100-L scale was used, a density of 1.1 x 10(6) cells/mL was achieved, whereas a comparable membrane-aerated system showed a cell density of 2.2 x 10(6) cells/mL. At relatively low agitation rates of less than 70 rpm in the sparged bioreactors, a homogeneous and constant oxygen concentration was kept in the medium. As a result of the different foam-forming tendency caused by the lower gas flow of the ceramic sparger compared to that of the standard aeration systems, we were able to develop an appropriate process control strategy. Furthermore, oxygen transfer measurements for the common stainless steel sparger and the ceramic sparger showed a 3-fold higher oxygen transfer coefficient for the ceramic sparger.     

Quantification of power consumption and oxygen transfer characteristics of a stirred miniature bioreactor for predictive fermentation scale-up

Miniature parallel bioreactors are becoming increasingly important as tools to facilitate rapid bioprocess design. Once the most promising strain and culture conditions have been identified a suitable scale-up basis needs to be established in order that the cell growth rates and product yields achieved in small scale optimization studies are maintained at larger scales. Recently we have reported on the design of a miniature stirred bioreactor system capable of parallel operation [Gill et al. (2008); Biochem Eng J 39:164-176]. In order to enable the predictive scale-up of miniature bioreactor results the current study describes a more detailed investigation of the bioreactor mixing and oxygen mass transfer characteristics and the creation of predictive engineering correlations useful for scale-up studies. A Power number of 3.5 for the miniature turbine impeller was first established based on experimental ungassed power consumption measurements. The variation of the measured gassed to ungassed power ratio, P(g)/P(ug), was then shown to be adequately predicted by existing correlations proposed by Cui et al. [Cui et al. (1996); Chem Eng Sci 51:2631-2636] and Mockel et al. [Mockel et al. (1990); Acta Biotechnol 10:215-224]. A correlation relating the measured oxygen mass transfer coefficient, k(L)a, to the gassed power per unit volume and superficial gas velocity was also established for the miniature bioreactor. Based on these correlations a series of scale-up studies at matched k(L)a (0.06-0.11 s(-1)) and P(g)/V (657-2,960 W m(-3)) were performed for the batch growth of Escherichia coli TOP10 pQR239 using glycerol as a carbon source. Constant k(L)a was shown to be the most reliable basis for predictive scale-up of miniature bioreactor results to conventional laboratory scale. This gave good agreement in both cell growth and oxygen utilization kinetics over the range of k(L)a values investigated. The work described here thus gives further insight into the performance of the miniature bioreactor design and will aid its use as a tool for rapid fermentation process development.     

Effect of sparger design on hydrodynamics of a gas recirculation anaerobic bioreactor

The effects of sparger design and gas flow rate on, gas holdup distribution and liquid (slurry) recirculation velocity have been studied in a surrogate anaerobic bioreactor used for treating bovine waste with a conical bottom mixed by gas recirculation. A single orifice sparger (SOS) and a multi-orifice ring sparger (MORS) with the same orifice open area and gas flow rates (hence the same process power input) are compared in this study. The advanced non-invasive techniques of computer automated tomography (CT) and computer automated radioactive particle tracking (CARPT) were employed to determine gas holdup, liquid recirculation velocity, and the poorly mixed zones. Gas flows (Q(g)) ranging of 0.017 x 10(-3) m(3)/s to 0.083 x 10(-3) m(3)/s were used which correspond to draft tube superficial gas velocities ranging from 1.46 x 10(-2) m/s to 7.35 x 10(-2) m/s (based on draft tube diameter). Air was used for the gas, as the molecular weights of air and biogas (consisting mainly of CH(4) and CO(2)) are in the same range (biogas: 28.32-26.08 kg/kmol and air: 28.58 kg/kmol). When compared to the SOS for a given gas flow rate, the MORS gave better gas holdup distribution in the draft tube, enhanced the liquid (slurry) recirculation, and reduced the fraction of the poorly mixed zones. The improved gas holdup distribution in the draft tube was found to have increased the overall liquid velocity. Hence, for the same process power input the MORS system performed better by enhancing the liquid recirculation and reducing the poorly mixed zones.     

Interaction of cell culture process parameters for modulating mAb afucosylation

The extent of afucosylation, which refers to the absence of core fucose on Fc glycans, can correlate positively with the antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) activity of a monoclonal antibody (mAb). Therefore, it is important to maintain consistent afucosylation during cell culture process scale-up in bioreactors for a mAb with ADCC activity. However, there is currently a lack of understanding about the impact of partial pressure of carbon dioxide (pCO₂)—a parameter that can vary with bioreactor scale—on afucosylation. Using a small-scale (3 L) bioreactor model that can modulate pCO ₂ levels through modified configurations and gassing strategies, we identified three cell culture process parameters that influence afucosylation of a mAb produced by a recombinant Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) cell line: pCO ₂, media hold duration (at 37°C), and manganese. These three-independent parameters demonstrated a synergistic effect on mAb afucosylation; increase in pCO ₂, media hold duration, and manganese consistently increased afucosylation. Our investigations into the underlying mechanisms through proteomic analysis indicated that the synergistic interactions downregulated pathways related to guanosine diphosphate-fucose synthesis and fucosylation, and upregulated manganese transport into the CHO cells. These new findings highlight the importance of considering potential differences in culture environment and operations across bioreactor scales, and understanding the impact of their interactions on product quality.