Immunologic functions of isolated human lymphocyte subpopulations. IV. Stimulation of MLC and CML by human T cells.

Surface immunoglobulin positive and immunoglobulin negative human lymphocyte populations were obtained by immunoabsorbent column chromatography. Both cell populations were effective as stimulating and target cells in allogeneic MLC and CML reactions. The immunoglobulin negative population was further depleted of both EAC rosette forming cells and nylon wool adherent cells. The resulting highly purified T cell population was also able to stimulate allogeneic cells in MLC, and induce the generation of specifically cytotoxic killer cells in CML.     

Human immunodeficiency disease: impairment of cellular interactions leading to abnormal mediator production in mixed lymphocyte culture reaction.

Leukocyte migration inhibitory factor (LMIF) production in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) reactions is the result of cellular interactions based on two separate phenomena: the capacity of lymphocytes to stimulate in MLC, and the capacity of lymphocytes to respond in MLC. Puromycin-treated lymphocytes are capable of stimulating allogeneic cells for LMIF production, but are unable to respond with synthesis of LMIF (one-way MLC-LMIF test). We have studied the stimulating and responding capacity of lymphocytes from patients with different immunodeficiency syndromes in a one-way MLC-LMIF assay. Lymphocytes from patients known to have qualitative and quantitative defects of T cell or B cell functions (Hodgkin's disease, mycosis fungoides, thymoma, chronic lymphatic leukemia) were found to respond poorly as measured by mediator production although their stimulating fuction was frequently retained. Patients with advanced solid tumors often had both MLC-stimulating and responding functions depressed. There was no apparent correlation between mitogen response and MLC-induced LMIF responses or between MLC proliferative response (as measured by thymidine incorporation) and mediator production. Studying of stimulatory and responding capacity of lymphocytes in the MLC-LMIF assay provides a new tool for assessing immunocompetence and allows for in vitro evaluation of cellular interactions that may play an important role in vivo.     

Isogeneic and allogeneic lymphocyte interactions may be controlled by cell surface immunoglobulin tropism.

A study of allogeneic MLC (mixed lymphocyte culture) and two types of isogeneic MLC has been conducted in which subsets of B-cells were serologically removed from pools prior to using the remainder as stimulator cells. Cellular division in the two types of ILC (isogeneic lymphocyte culture) was found to be triggered by lymphocytes with IgG₁ on their surfaces. In contrast, the stimulator cells in ALC (allogeneic lymphocyte culture) possessed membrane-bound IgG_2A and/or possibly IgG_2B. Splenic T-cells were incapable of stimulating replication of splenic or lymph nodal T-cells in the absence of B-cells. Splenic T-cell preparations served as weak stimulators of other allogeneic T-cells but only when B-cells, either isogeneic or allogeneic to the stimulator T-cells, were present. We propose that stimulation in the MLC occurs in two distinct steps. First, immunoglobulins on cell surfaces may function to bring appropriate subsets of cells together. Next, antigenic recognition occurs that results in blastogenesis. Furthermore, the tropism or attraction that certain immunoglobulins have for some cell types may determine which subsets of cells participate in allogeneic and which take part in isogeneic MLC.     

Human T cell subpopulations defined by a monoclonal antibody. II. Evidence for cell cooperation in the response to alloantigens and generation of cytolytic cells

It has been shown previously that the 5/9 monoclonal antibody defines a small T cell subpopulation in human peripheral blood that includes all the cells responsible for proliferation to tetanus toxoid and to alloantigens as well as the helper cells for B cell differentiation. In the present study, human peripheral blood T cells were fractionated according to their reactivity with the 5/9 monoclonal antibody and stimulated in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC). In spite of a strong proliferative response in MLC, 5/9+ cells generated no cytolytic activity against PHA-activated lymphocytes bearing the stimulating alloantigens (CTL activity) or against the K562 human cell line (NK activity). The precursors of these cytolytic effector cells were present in the 5/9- fraction. However, 5/9+ cells or soluble factors derived from 5/9+ cells were needed to induce 5/9- cells to respond in MLC and develop cytolytic activity. Both 5/9+ and 5/9- cell populations, upon MLC stimulation, were able to lyse L1210 mouse lymphoma cells in the presence of specific antibodies (ADCC).     

Generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in vitro. VII. Suppressive effect of irradiated MLC cells on CTL response.

Irradiated cells obtained from MLC at the peak of the CTL response caused profound suppression of generation of CTL when added in small numbers at the initiation of primary MLC prepared with normal spleen cells. The inhibitory activity of the MLC cells was not affected by irradiation (1000 rads) but was abolished by treatment with anti-theta serum and complement. The suppression was immunologically specific. The response of A (H-2a) spleen cells toward C3H (H-2k) alloantigens was suppressed by irradiated MLC cells obtained from MLC prepared with A spleen cells and irradiated C3H-stimulating cells, whereas the response of A spleen cells toward DBA/2 (H-2d) alloantigens was affected relatively little. However, if irradiated C3H X DBA/2 F1 hybrid spleen cells were used to stimulate A spleen cells in MLC, addition of irradiated MLC cells having cytotoxic activity toward C3H antigens abolished the response to both C3H and DBA/2 antigens. The response to DBA/2 antigens was much less affected when a mixture of irradiated C3H and DBA/2 spleen cells was used as stimulating cells. Thus, the presence of MLC cells having cytotoxic activity toward one alloantigen abolished the response to another non-cross reacting antigen only when both antigens were present on the same F1 hybrid-stimulating cells. This suppression of generation of CTL by irradiated MLC cells apparently involves inactivation of alloantigen-bearing stimulating cells as a result of residual cytotoxic activity of the irradiated MLC cells. This mechanism may be active during the decline in CTL activity noted in the normal immune response in vivo and in vitro.     

Immunologically specific cytolytic activity induced in long-term mixed leukocyte culture cells by concanavalin A.

Stimulation of cells from long-term primary MLC with Con A resulted in the generation of CTL activity comparable in magnitude to that induced by reexposure of the cells to the original stimulating cellular antigen. CTL generated by stimulation of long-term MLC cells with ConA had lytic activity specific for the original stimulating alloantigen used in primary MLC. The pattern of stimulation of long-term MLC cells with Con A differed from that of restimulation with alloantigen in that there was no detectable CTL activity the first 24 hr after Con A stimulation and the peak lytic activity occurred later. Unlike restimulation with alloantigen early lytic activity after Con A stimulation was dependent on DNA synthesis. PHA also proved to be an effective agent for stimulating cytolytic activity in long-term MLC cells. The response to PHA was comparable in magnitude to that generated by Con A. Stimulation of long-term MLC cells with T cell mitogens gave decreased cell recoveries relative to restimulation with alloantigen, however, the lytic activity per cells recovered was generally greater in the mitogen-stimulated cultures.     

Inhibition of stimulation in murine mixed lymphocyte cultures with an alloantiserum directed against a shared Ia determinant.

Pools of high titered alloantisera were raised by immunizing (B10.A/SgSn X A/WySn)F1 mice with C57BL/10Sn(B10) spleen cells. This serum (F1 anti-B10), when added to one-way mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC), inhibited stimulation of B10.A splenic responders by both B10 and B10.D2/nSn irradiated, splenic stimulators. The B10 stimulation was suppressed approximately 85% whereas the mean suppression of B10.D2 stimulation was approximately 60%. In the ofrmer case, the serum contained antibodies reactive with multiple major histocompatibility complex determinants on the stimulator cells. In the latter case, the cytoxic reactivity of the serum was directed principally against an I region-associated determinant Ia.8) shared by B10 and B10.D2 and coded for by a gene(s) in the I-A subregion. The magnitude of the suppression of the response to B10.D2 cells (60%) was similar to the reduction in stimulation observed when the Ia.8 difference was eliminated genetically by using (B10 X B10.A)F1 responder cells against irradiated B10.D2 stimulators. Ihhibition of MLC by this antiserum was a function of reactivity with stimulator and not responder cells. Although some pools of F1 anti-B10 antiserum produced partial inhibition of the responder cell in a B10.D2 vs B10.Ax MLC combination, the results were inconsistent and not correlated with the anti-Ia.8 cytotoxicity titers. In addition, an F1 anti-B10 antiserum pool, which consistently failed to inhibit the responder cell, nevertheless inhibited both irradiated B10.D2 and (B10.A X B10.D2)F1 cells from stimulating B10.A responder cells. However, this same antiserum did not inhibit stimulation of B10.D2 responder cells by the (B10.A X B10.D2)F1 stimulators. Thus, the binding of antibodies to the non-stimulating antigens on the F1 stimulator cell did not interfere with the capacity of the appropriate stimulating antigens to cause stimulation. All of these results are consistent with the hypothesis that Ia allo-antigens are the major stimulating determinants of I region-associated MLC reactions.     

Specific inhibition of human lymphocyte responses by primed autologous lymphocytes. I. Evaluation of MLR inhibition as a model for suppression.

Human lymphocytes from person A, primed for 10 to 14 days in MLC against lymphocytes from person B, inhibit specifically the proliferative response to B by fresh (i.e., unprimed) lymphocytes of A. Gamma-irradiated (2000 R) primed lymphocytes likewise inhibit specifically, although less strongly. Cells of A, primed with cells of B and then irradiated, usually can inhibit the response of A to cells of any individual sharing HLA-D antigens with B, and the effect tends to be independent of the number of stimulating cells. We also often see inhibition of responses to cells sharing HLA-A and -B antigens with person B, but this effect tends to be lost when the number of stimulating cells is increased. Similarly, at low doses, cells primed for HLA-D antigen a appear not to inhibit the response to an irrelevant HLA-D antigen b on the same stimulating cell. At higher doses of primed cells, even the response to the irrelevant antigen is inhibited. These data suggest to us that at least two mechnaisms may be involved: one directed at the stimulating cell (most likely cell-mediated cytolysis), and predominant at high ratios of primed cells to stimulating cells; the other directed at specific clones of responding cells, and predominant at low ratios.     

Nonspecific suppressor T cells cause decreased mixed lymphocyte culture reactivity in bone marrow transplant patients

Decreased reactivity in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) was observed in patients within 1 yr after allogeneic and autologous bone marrow transplantation. Suppressor activity of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from transplant patients was studied by adding these cells as modulator cells to a bidirectional MLC with cells from normal individuals. PBMC from transplant patients markedly suppressed MLC reactivity in a dose-dependent manner. Suppressor activity was present in cells forming rosettes with sheep erythrocytes. Treatment of modulator cells with monoclonal antibodies against T cell differentiation antigens (OKT8, OKIa1) and complement completely abolished suppression of MLC. Suppressor activity was unaffected by 30 Gy irradiation. Suppressor activity declined gradually after transplantation and was inversely correlated with MLC reactivity of each patient at a significant level (p less than 0.01). These observations suggest that OKT8+ Ia+ radioresistant suppressor T cells play a role in the development of decreased MLC reactivity observed during the early post-transplant period.     

Cellular immunity in the mouse. I. In vitro lymphocyte reactivity

The mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) and antigen-mediated proliferative response represent important correlates to the in vivo phenomena of allograft rejection and delayed hypersensitivity. This study defines an in vitro model to measure mouse lymphocyte responsiveness to allogeneic cells, antigen (tuberculoprotein), and nonspecific mitogens. Results describe optimal cells concentration, time and conditions of culture. Optimal conditions include the use of high cell concentration, flat-bottomed vials, RPMI-1640 medium, and fresh human serum. Peripheral blood lymphocytes demonstrated greater proliferation than lymph node lymphocytes, which in turn demonstrated greater activity than splenic lymphocytes. Significant proliferation occurred in serum-free media, dialyzed against fresh serum and supplemented with hydrocortisone and carrier protein. The MLC response in the mouse appears dependent on multiple subpopulations of cells and on soluble substances produced by them.     

Antiserum inhibition of the mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) interaction. Inhibitory effect of antibodies reactive with HLA-D-associated determinants.

Two antisera, procured by immunization within HLA-A- and HLA-B-identical and HLA-D-incompatible unrelated combinations, were cytotoxic to B lymphocytes from the immunizing donor and from persons sharing his HLA-D-incompatible phenotype(s). The sera strongly and specifically inhibited lymphocytes from these donors when used as stimulating cells in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) reactions, while specific responding cell inhibition was less evident. The inhibitory effect was retained in the immunoglobulin G (IgG) and the F (ab)′₂ fractions of these antisera. Inhibition was observed when the antisera were added within 48 hr after initiating the MLC. We conclude that these antisera contain antibodies reactive with structures closely associated with HLA-D determinants and that these may be human analogs of the mouse Ia antigens.     

Generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in vitro. VI. Effect of cell density on response in mixed leukocyte cultures.

Reexposure of day 14 murine mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) populations to the original irradiated allogeneic stimulating spleen cells has previously been found to result in the ratpid generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) associated with a net increase in cultured cell number. Under the experimental conditions used, day 5 MLC cells appeared unable to respond to the allogeneic stimulus. In order to characterize further the development of the potential for anamnestic reactivity during the course of MLC, C57BL/6 spleen cells were incubated with irradiated (1000 rads) DBA/2 spleen cells (primary MLC) for up to 3 weeks. At various time intervals after the onset of the primary MLC, the surviving cells were collected and reexposed, at varying cell concentrations, to irradiated DBA/2 spleen cells (secondary MLC). At daily intervals thereafter, CTL activity was assessed using a quantitative 51Cr-release assay system. A paradoxic effect of responding cell concentration on generation of CTL activity was observed; relatively greater increase in CTL activity was observed as the concentration of responding cells was decreased over a 100-fold range. This effect was more pronounced with responding cells reexposed to antigen after primary MLC for 20 days, but was observed even with normal cells. The apparent unresponsiveness of day 5 MLC cells to alloantigen restimulation could be overcome by simple dilution of responding cells. Cytotoxic activity at the time of restimulation with antigen seems to be a major factor determining the magnitude of the secondary response. Since intact cells bearing alloantigens are required for the generation of CTL in MLC, residual cytotoxic cells reduce the effective antigenic stimulus by destroying stimulating cells. This effect of concentration of responding cells on generation of CTL in MLC complicates interpretation of experiments investigating the role of "inhibitor" and "helper" cell in cell-mediated immune responses occurring in vitro. Under optimal conditions, the highest CTL activity and the largest increase in total cell number was observed 4 days after restimulation of day 10 MLC cells. On a per cell basis, the lytic activity was up to 4 times greater than that observed at the peak of a primary response, and the number of viable cells recovered was nearly 20 times higher than that at the onset. Such secondary MLC are thus a convenient source of lymphoid cells selected primarily on the basis of proliferation induced by alloantigens.     

Generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes in mixed lymphocyte reactions II. Importance of private and publicH-2 alloantigens on the expression of cytotoxicity

MLC were established to test for the generation of specific cytotoxic effector cells in CML. The target cell used to assay for CML in the five combinations tested was of a differentH-2 haplotype from the stimulating cell population. Cytotoxicity was observed against this target only when it shared private alloantigens (antigens that are specific for theH-2D andH-2K region of differentH-2 haplotypes) with the stimulating cell population. Very weak or no Cytotoxicity was found when such alloantigens were not shared, although cross-reactive publicH-2 specificities were. These findings indicate that T cells display a cytotoxic potential against privateH-2 antigens in a primary response in vitro and are not capable of responding to publicH-2 specificities to the same level.BSS balanced salt solution - CML cell-mediated lympholysis - GPC guinea pig complement - ¹²⁵IUdR ¹²⁵I-iodo-deoxyuridine - MLC mixed lymphocyte culture - SE standard error     

Cell-mediated immune response in vitro. I. The development of suppressor cells and cytotoxic lymphocytes in mixed lymphocyte cultures.

During the in vitro development of cytotoxic lymphocytes (CL), suppressor cells also develop. Spleen cells or lymph node cells harvested from mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) on day 2 (day-2 MLC) and added to a fresh MLC suppressed the development of CL. This suppressive effect was sensitive to treatment with anti-theta and C. The suppressive effect of day-2 MLC was not due to cytotoxic effects nor to altered kinetics of the development of both suppressor cells and CL. Although CL develop from hydrocortisone-treated spleen cells, day-2 MLC of hydrocortisone-treated spleen cells did not suppress the development of CL. These studies suggest that suppressor cells and CL are derived from different T cell subpopulations.     

Human lymphocyte responses are enhanced by culture at 40 degrees C.

In vitro responses of human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) were found to be markedly enhanced by culture at 40 degrees C rather than at the conventional temperature of 37 degrees C. We studied proliferative responses of lymphocytes by activation by phytohemagglutinin (PHA) concanavalin A (Con A), pokeweed mitogen (PWM), and allogeneic lymphocytes in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) and found enhancement of DNA synthesis at the higher temperature. Cytotoxic T cell responses to allogeneic cells were also enhanced when MLC was done at 40 degrees C. These enhanced immune responses appear to be due in part to increased numbers of participating cells. If in vitro lymphocyte responses correlate with in vivo responses, then fever associated with infection or tumor may be beneficial whereas that associated with autoimmune disorders may have a detrimental effect.     

HLA class l specific t lymphocyte clones with dual alloreactive functions

Four human T lymphocyte clones exhibiting proliferative responses to class I HLA antigens were isolated from an in vitro mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC). Three clones expressed the Leu-2⁺3^– phenotype and demonstrated proliferation in response to HLA-B8, while the fourth clone expressed the Leu-2^–3⁺ phenotype and proliferated in response to HLA-A2. These clones were also cytotoxic towards cells bearing the same target antigens. Blocking studies utilizing monoclonal antibodies demonstrated that proliferation was triggered by determinants on the class I molecule itself, and these determinants appear to be spatially close to those which determine serologic allospecificity. These findings support the concept that the class I molecules themselves are the weak MLC stimulating determinants previously mapped to the HLA-A and B regions of the major histocompatibility complex.Abbreviations used in this paper B-LCL B-lymphoblastoid cell line - cpm counts per minute - FCS fetal calf serum - HS human serum - ³H-TdR tritiated thymidine - IL-2 interleukin-2 - IL2-CM interleukin-2 containing conditioned medium - MHC major histocompatibility complex - MLC mixed lymphocyte culture - MoAb monoclonal antibody - PBL peripheral blood mononuclear leukocytes - PLT primed lymphocyte test     

Generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes in the autologous mixed lymphocyte culture.

We have studied the ability of purified B lymphocytes to generate cytotoxic T lymphocytes in autologous mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC). Cytotoxic lymphocytes were produced but only autologous mononuclear cells stimulated by lipopolysaccharide (LPS) were susceptible target cells. Unstimulated mononuclear cells and purified B cells were not susceptible to killing by cytotoxic cells generated in the autologous MLC. This suggests that the target antigen may be expressed on stimulated or dividing B lymphocytes in a way that renders the cells more susceptible to cytolysis. Autologously stimulated cytotoxic effector cells were found to exhibit specificity. Cy totoxicity for autologous LPS-stimulated target cells occurred but not for an allogeneic, B cell, histiocytic lymphoma cell line. It is postulated that cytotoxic T cells generated in the autologous MLC may play a role in immune surveillance or in regulation of the immune system.     

Detection of lymphotoxin produced in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC): variation in target cell sensitivity

In an attempt to resolve some of the uncertainty as to whether soluble cytotoxin—lymphotoxin (LT)—is produced in mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC), we established one-way MLC between the lymphocytes of normal individuals and two lines of lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL). Cell-free culture fluid harvested after 5 days was tested for LT employing not only the stimulating LCL cells as targets, but also two lines of cells known to be sensitive to LT. The LCL cells—RPMI 8866 and NHDL-2—were found to be completely resistant to LT under the conditions of our assay. By contrast, when the sensitive cells were used in the cytotoxicity assay, LT was readily detected. These results emphasize the importance of intrinsic target cell sensitivity in the study of lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxic phenomena and raise questions as to the mechanism whereby cells may be resistant to LT.     

Studies on cytotoxicity generated in human mixed lymphocyte cultures. III. Natural killer-like cytotoxicity mediated by human lymphocytes with receptors for IgM

Stimulation of human peripheral blood lymphocytes with allogeneic cells in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) results in increased NK-like cytotoxicity against K562 targets. The effector cells of this cytotoxicity were shown to include both Fcμ+ and Fcμ? cells, as shown by EAμ rosette separation and by combined rosette formation and single-cell analysis. Peak cytotoxic activity of Fcμ+ cells was found after 3 days of MLC stimulation. The Cytotoxicity against KS62 targets mediated by Fcμ+ cells could not be inhibited at all with alloantigen-bearing cells and could only be partially inhibited with another NK-sensitive target (MOLT- 4). This cytotoxicity could be generated from either Fcγ+ or FCγ? cells. These results indicate considerable heterogeneity of NK-like effectors and their precursors.     

Lymphocyte responses to syngeneic antigens. I. Enhancement of the murine autologous mixed lymphocyte response by polyethylene glycol

The normally weak murine T-cell proliferative response against autologous non-T stimulator cells (the autologous mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) was enhanced markedly by inclusion of the hydrophilic polymer, polyethylene glycol (PEG), into the culture medium. Potentiation of the autologous MLC was indicated on the basis of increased [³H]TdR incorporation by responding cells, as well as by the numbers of viable cells recovered from mixed cell cultures. PEG is not a polyclonal activator of T and/or B lymphocytes, since nylon wool nonadherent lymphoid cells (T cell-enriched fraction), nylon wool adherent cells (B cell-enriched fraction) and T cell-deficient “nude” spleen cells were not stimulated into DNA synthesis when cultured separately with PEG. Inclusion of 4% PEG into the culture medium was found to optimally enhance autologous MLC, although concentrations between 2 and 5% also significantly elevated responsiveness. At a responder/stimulator ratio of 1:2, autologous MLC yielded peak [³H]TdR incorporation after 5 days of culture. At lower ratios (1:1 and 2:1), however, Δ cpm of autologous MLC continued to increase over a culture period of 7 days. Enhanced responsiveness in the presence of PEG was observed in strains of mice representing a variety of H-2 haplotypes, indicating that at least the potential for autoreactivity of this type is a naturally occurring and widespread characteristic of murine species. An absolute requirement for purified T responder cells was necessary in the autologous MLC, since unseparated lymphoid cell responder LN or spleen cells demonstrated marked proliferation when cultured alone in medium containing PEG. The proliferation of T cells to autologous non-T cells within the same unseparated lymphoid cell preparation appears to be responsible for this phenomenon. Ia antigens expressed by the stimulator cells are involved in the induction of T-cell response, since anti-Ia sera added directly to the cultures inhibited the autologous MLC, but did not affect other T-cell responses to alloantigens or mitogens. Despite the marked proliferation observed in the autologous MLC performed in the presence of PEG, there was no generation of cytotoxic effector cells. Thus, PEG does not appear to add, or alter determinants on stimulator cells to an extent that they are recognized as foreign by precursor cytotoxic T cells. Although the mechanism of enhancement of autologous MLC by PEG is not totally defined, it appears, at least functionally, to promote cellular interactions that occur normally between T cells, B cells, and macrophages. In this respect, PEG will be a powerful and useful probe to dissect the cellular interactions that take place in autologous responses.