An in vitro evolved precursor tRNA with aminoacylation activity

A set of catalysts for aminoacyl-tRNA synthesis is an essential component for translation. The RNA world hypothesis postulates that RNA catalysts could have played this role. Here we show an in vitro evolved precursor tRNA consisting of two domains, a catalytic 5'-leader sequence and an aminoacyl-acceptor tRNA. The 5'-leader sequence domain selectively self-charges phenylalanine on the 3'-terminus of the tRNA domain. This cis-acting ribozyme is susceptible to RNase P RNA, generating the corresponding 5'-leader segment and the mature tRNA. Moreover, the 5'-leader segment is able to aminoacylate the mature tRNA in trans. Mutational studies have revealed that C(74) and C(75) at the tRNA aminoacyl-acceptor end form base pairs with G71 and G70 of the trans-acting ribozyme. Such Watson-Crick base pairing with tRNA has been observed in RNase P RNA and 23S rRNA, suggesting that all three ribozymes use a similar mechanism for the recognition of the aminoacyl-acceptor end. Our demonstrations indicate that catalytic precursor tRNAs could have provided the foundations for the genetic coding system in the proto-translation system.     

Ribozyme catalysis of metabolism in the RNA world

In vitro selection has proven to be a useful means of explore the molecules and catalysts that may have existed in a primordial 'RNA world'. By selecting binding species (aptamers) and catalysts (ribozymes) from random sequence pools, the relationship between biopolymer complexity and function can be better understood, and potential evolutionary transitions between functional molecules can be charted. In this review, we have focused on several critical events or transitions in the putative RNA world: RNA self-replication; the synthesis and utilization of nucleotide-based cofactors; acyl-transfer reactions leading to peptide and protein synthesis; and the basic metabolic pathways that are found in modern living systems.     

The Robustness of Naturally and Artificially Selected Nucleic Acid Secondary Structures

Thermodynamic stability and mutational robustness of secondary structure are critical to the function and evolutionary longevity of RNA molecules. We hypothesize that natural and artificial selection for functional molecules favors the formation of structures that are stable to both thermal and mutational perturbation. There is little direct evidence, however, that functional RNA molecules have been selected for their stability. Here we use thermodynamic secondary structure prediction algorithms to compare the thermal and mutational robustness of over 1000 naturally and artificially evolved molecules. Although we find evidence for the evolution of both types of stability in both sets of molecules, the naturally evolved functional RNA molecules were significantly more stable than those selected in vitro, and artificially evolved catalysts (ribozymes) were more stable than artificially evolved binding species (aptamers). The thermostability of RNA molecules bred in the laboratory is probably not constrained by a lack of suitable variation in the sequence pool but, rather, by intrinsic biases in the selection process.     

Ribozymes--why so many, why so few?

The RNA world scenario posits the existence of catalytic and genetic networks whose reactions are catalyzed by RNAs. Substantial progress has been made in recent years in the selection of RNA catalysts by SELEX, thus verifying one prediction of the model. However, many selected catalysts are long molecules, leading to a question of whether they could have been synthesized by a primitive replicator. It is proposed that the efficiency of some small ribozymes may have been augmented by other RNAs acting as transactivators.     

Mechanistic studies on acyl-transferase ribozymes and beyond

In vitro selection has allowed the isolation of many new ribozymes that are able to catalyze an ever-widening array of chemical transformations. Mechanistic studies on these selected ribozymes have provided valuable insight into the methods that RNA can invoke to overcome different catalytic tasks. We focus on the methods employed in these mechanistic studies using the acyl-transferase family of selected ribozymes as well-studied reference systems. Chemical and biochemical techniques have been used in tandem in order to draw conclusions on the various modes of catalysis employed by the different family members. In turn, this type of mechanistic information may provide a means for the redesign and optimization of existing ribozymes or the basis for new selection systems for more powerful RNA catalysts.     

Suppression of BCR-ABL mRNA by various ribozymes in HeLa cells.

Ribozymes are RNA molecules with enzymatic activity that can cleave target RNA molecules in a sequence specific manner. To date, various types of ribozyme have been constructed to cleave other RNAs and such trans-acting ribozymes include hammerhead, hairpin and HDV ribozymes. External guide sequence (EGS) can also induce the suppression of a gene-expression by taking advantage of cellular RNase P. Here we compared the activities of various functional RNA cleavers both in vitro and in vivo. The first purpose of this comparison was intended to determine the best ribozyme motif with the highest activity in cells. The second purpose is to know the correlation between the activities of ribozymes in vitro and in vivo. Our results indicated that the intrinsic cleavage activity of ribozymes is not the sole determinant that is responsible for the activity of a ribozyme in cultured cells.     

Polymerase ribozyme efficiency increased by G/T-rich DNA oligonucleotides

The RNA world hypothesis states that the early evolution of life went through a stage where RNA served as genome and as catalyst. The replication of RNA world organisms would have been facilitated by ribozymes that catalyze RNA polymerization. To recapitulate an RNA world in the laboratory, a series of RNA polymerase ribozymes was developed previously. However, these ribozymes have a polymerization efficiency that is too low for self-replication, and the most efficient ribozymes prefer one specific template sequence. The limiting factor for polymerization efficiency is the weak sequence-independent binding to its primer/template substrate. Most of the known polymerase ribozymes bind an RNA heptanucleotide to form the P2 duplex on the ribozyme. By modifying this heptanucleotide, we were able to significantly increase polymerization efficiency. Truncations at the 3'-terminus of this heptanucleotide increased full-length primer extension by 10-fold, on a specific template sequence. In contrast, polymerization on several different template sequences was improved dramatically by replacing the RNA heptanucleotide with DNA oligomers containing randomized sequences of 15 nt. The presence of G and T in the random sequences was sufficient for this effect, with an optimal composition of 60% G and 40% T. Our results indicate that these DNA sequences function by establishing many weak and nonspecific base-pairing interactions to the single-stranded portion of the template. Such low-specificity interactions could have had important functions in an RNA world.     

The origin of the genetic code: amino acids as cofactors in an RNA world.

The genetic code, understood as the specific assignment of amino acids to nucleotide triplets, might have preceded the existence of translation. Amino acids became utilized as cofactors by ribozymes in a metabolically complex RNA world. Specific charging ribozymes linked amino acids to corresponding RNA handles, which could basepair with different ribozymes, via an anticodon hairpin, and so deliver the cofactor to the ribozyme. Growing of the 'handle' into a presumptive tRNA was possible while function was retained and modified throughout. A stereochemical relation between some amino acids and cognate anticodons/codons is likely to have been important in the earliest assignments. Recent experimental findings, including selection for ribozymes catalyzing peptide-bond formation and those utilizing an amino acid cofactor, hold promise that scenarios of this major transition can be tested.     

Coenzymes as coribozymes

Coenzymes are small organic molecules that supply a varied set of reactive groups to protein enzymes, thereby diversifying catalysis beyond the chemistries of amino acid sidechains. As RNA structures begin with a more limited chemical diversity than proteins, it seems likely that RNA enzymes would also use functional groups from other molecules to support a complex RNA world metabolism. In fact, ribonucleotide moieties in many coenzymes have long been thought to be surviving vestiges of covalently bound coenzymes in an RNA world. The idea of coenzyme utilization by ribozymes can be explored by selection-amplification of coenzyme-binding RNAs and coenzyme-assisted ribozymes. Here, we review coenzyme-RNAs, and discuss their possible significance for RNA-mediated metabolism. In summary, a plausible route from prebiotic chemistry to ribozyme biochemistry exists for CoA, and via similar activities, likely exists for all the nucleotidyl coenzymes.     

Acyl-CoAs from coenzyme ribozymes.

We describe in vitro selection of two novel ribozymes that mediate coenzyme reactions. The first is a trans-capping ribozyme that attaches coenzyme A (CoA) at the 5' end of any RNA with the proper short terminal sequence, including RNAs with randomized internal sequences. From such a trans-capped CoA-RNA pool, we derive ribozymes that attack biotinyl-AMP using the SH group of CoA. These ribozymes, selected to acylate CoA with the valeryl side chain of biotin, also produce the crucial metabolic intermediates acetyl-CoA and butyryl-CoA with substantial velocities. Thus, we argue that RNAs might have used the chemical functionality offered by coenzymes to support an RNA world metabolism. In particular, we can combine our results with those of other labs to argue that simple chemistry and RNA catalysis suffice to proceed from simple chemicals to catalysis with acyl-CoAs. The trans-capping method can be generalized for production of varied coenzyme ribozymes using a single catalytic RNA subunit. Finally, the long-suggested RNA origin for CoA itself appears to be chemically feasible.     

New catalytic structures from an existing ribozyme

Although protein enzymes with new catalytic activities can arise from existing scaffolds, less is known about the origin of ribozymes with new activities. Furthermore, mechanisms by which new macromolecular folds arise are not well characterized for either protein or RNA. Here we investigate how readily ribozymes with new catalytic activities and folds can arise from an existing ribozyme scaffold. Using in vitro selection, we isolated 23 distinct kinase ribozymes from a pool of sequence variants of an aminoacylase parent ribozyme. Analysis of these new kinases showed that ribozymes with new folds and biochemical activities can be found within a short mutational distance of a given ribozyme. However, the probability of finding such ribozymes increases considerably as the mutational distance from the parental ribozyme increases, indicating a need to escape the fold of the parent.     

In vitro selection of adenine-dependent hairpin ribozymes

Adenine-dependent hairpin ribozymes were isolated by in vitro selection from a degenerated hairpin ribozyme population. Two new adenine-dependent ribozymes catalyze their own reversible cleavage in the presence of free adenine. Both aptamers have Mg(2+) requirements for adenine-assisted cleavage similar to the wild-type hairpin ribozyme. Cleavage kinetics studies in the presence of various other small molecules were compared. The data suggest that adenine does not induce RNA self-cleavage in the same manner for both aptamers. In addition, investigations of pH effects on catalytic rates show that both adenine-dependent aptamers are more active in basic conditions, suggesting that they use new acid/base catalytic strategies in which adenine could be involved directly. The discovery of hairpin ribozymes dependent on adenine for their reversible self-cleavage presents considerable biochemical and evolutionary interests because we show that RNA is able to use exogenous reactive molecules to enhance its own catalytic activity. Such a mechanism may have been a means by which the ribozymes of the RNA world enlarged their chemical repertoire.     

Acquisition of novel catalytic activity by the M1 RNA ribozyme: the cost of molecular adaptation.

The ribonucleoprotein RNase P is a critical component of metabolism in all known organisms. In Escherichia coli, RNase P processes a vast array of substrates, including precursor-tRNAs and precursor 4. 5S RNA. In order to understand how such catalytic versatility is achieved and how novel catalytic activity can be acquired, we evolve the M1 RNA ribozyme (the catalytic component of E. coli RNase P) in vitro for cleavage of a DNA substrate. In so doing, we probe the consequences of enhancing catalytic activity on a novel substrate and investigate the cost this versatile enzyme pays for molecular adaptation. A total of 25 generations of in vitro evolution yield a population showing more than a 1000-fold increase in DNA substrate cleavage efficiency (kcat/KM) relative to wild-type M1 RNA. This enhancement is accompanied by a significant reduction in the ability of evolved ribozymes to process the ptRNA class of substrates but also a contrasting increase in activity on the p4.5S RNA class of substrates. This change in the catalytic versatility of the evolved ribozymes suggests that the acquired activity comes at the cost of substrate versatility, and indicates that E. coli RNase P catalytic flexibility is maintained in vivo by selection for the processing of multiple substrates. M1 RNA derivatives enhance cleavage of the DNA substrate by accelerating the catalytic step (kcat) of DNA cleavage, although overall processing efficiency is offset by reduced substrate binding. The enhanced ability to cleave a DNA substrate cannot be readily traced to any of the predominant mutations found in the evolved population, and must instead be due to multiple sequence changes dispersed throughout the molecule. This conclusion underscores the difficulty of correlating observed mutations with changes in catalytic behavior, even in simple biological catalysts for which three-dimensional models are available.     

Direct selection of trans-acting ligase ribozymes by in vitro compartmentalization

We have used a compartmentalized in vitro selection method to directly select for ligase ribozymes that are capable of acting on and turning over separable oligonucleotide substrates. Starting from a degenerate pool, we selected a trans-acting variant of the Bartel class I ligase which statistically may have been the only active variant in the starting pool. The isolation of this sequence from the population suggests that this selection method is extremely robust at selecting optimal ribozymes and should, therefore, prove useful for the selection and optimization of other trans-acting nucleic acid catalysts capable of multiple turnover catalysis.     

Fixation and Accumulation of Thermotolerant Catalytic Competence of a Pair of Ligase Ribozymes Through Complex Formation and Cross Ligation

In the early stages of the hypothetical RNA world, some primitive RNA catalysts (ribozymes) may have emerged through self-assembly of short RNA oligomers. Although they may be unstable against temperature fluctuations and other environmental changes, ligase ribozymes (ribozymes with RNA strand-joining activity) may resolve structural instability of self-assembling RNAs by converting them to the corresponding unimolecular formats. To investigate this possibility, we constructed a model system using a cross-ligation system composed of a pair of self-assembling ligase ribozymes. Their abilities to act as catalysts, substrates, and a cross-ligation system were analyzed with or without thermal pretreatment before the reactions. A pair of self-assembling ligase ribozymes, each of which can form multiple conformations, demonstrated that thermotolerance was acquired and accumulated through complex-formation that stabilized the active forms of the bimolecular ribozymes and also cross-ligation that produced the unimolecular ribozymes.     

The importance of prebiotic chemistry in the RNA world

In vitro selection experiments have clearly demonstrated that RNA can perform many of the functions necessary to support an RNA world. Moreover, it appears that novel functions could have readily evolved from existing functional RNA molecules. Therefore, diverse molecular ecosystems could potentially have arisen from an initial, small population of functional replicators. These findings suggest that the sequences of living systems may have been determined in part by chance occurrences at origins. Any extrapolations linking sequences (as opposed to functions) obtained in the laboratory to what may have occurred ca. 4 billion years ago are tenuous at best. Thus, perhaps the best way to understand origins is not by examining relatively unconstrained sequence information, but by examining the inherent constraints imposed by prebiotic chemistry.     

Ribozymes: Flexible molecular devices at work

The discovery of ribozymes, RNAs with catalytic activity, revealed the extraordinary characteristic of this molecule, and corroborated the idea that RNA was the first informative polymer. The “RNA world” hypothesis asserts that the DNA/RNA/PROTEIN world arose from an earlier RNA world in which were present only RNA molecules able to perform both of the two functions performed separately by DNA and proteins in the present-day cells: the ability to transfer genetic information and to carry out catalytic activity.The catalytic properties of ribozymes are exclusively due to the capacity of RNA molecules to assume particular structures. Moreover, the structural versatility of RNA can allow to a single RNA sequence to fold in more than one structure, able to perform more than one function. In the first part of this work we will discuss the RNA plasticity, focusing on “bifunctional” ribozymes isolated by in vitro selection experiments, and on the consequences of this plasticity in the prospective of the emergence of new specific functions.The possibility that one sequence could have more than one structure/function, greatly increase the evolutionary potential of RNA, and the capacity of RNA to switch from a structure/function to another is probably one of the reasons of the evolutionary success also in modern-day cells. Naturally occurring ribozymes discovered in contemporary cells, demonstrate the crucial role that ribozymes still have in the modern protein world. In the second part of this paper we will discuss the capacity of natural ribozymes to modulate gene expression making use of their exclusive catalytic properties. Moreover, we will consider the possibility of their ancient origin.