Genetic analysis of nonpathogenic Agrobacterium tumefaciens mutants arising in crown gall tumors.

Little is known about the effect of the host on the genetic stability of bacterial plant pathogens. Crown gall, a plant disease caused by Agrobacterium tumefaciens, may represent a useful model to study this effect. Indeed, our previous observations on the natural occurrence and origin of nonpathogenic agrobacteria suggest that the host plant might induce loss of pathogenicity in populations of A. tumefaciens. Here we report that five different A. tumefaciens strains initially isolated from apple tumors produced up to 99% nonpathogenic mutants following their reintroduction into axenic apple plants. Two of these five strains were also found to produce mutants on pear and/or blackberry plants. Generally, the mutants of the apple isolate D10B/87 were altered in the tumor-inducing plasmid, harboring either deletions in this plasmid or point mutations in the regulatory virulence gene virG. Most of the mutants originating from the same tumor appeared to be of clonal origin, implying that the host plants influenced agrobacterial populations by favoring growth of nonpathogenic mutants over that of wild-type cells. This hypothesis was confirmed by coinoculation of apple rootstocks with strain D10B/87 and a nonpathogenic mutant.     

Biological control of crown gall, Agrobacterium tumefaciens

Biological control of crown gall caused by Agrobacteriurn turnefaciens (Smith & Townsend) Conn, pioneered by Dr A. Kerr in South Australia, is effected through the establishment of a high population of the related non-pathogen A. radiobacter (Beijerinck & van Delden) Conn, strain 84 in the rhizosphere of susceptible plants. Strain 84 produces a bacteriocin to which many strains of the pathogen in Australasia, North America and Britain are sensitive. The disease is present in Britain on a variety of hosts including cherry. At East Malling cherry leaf scars, invaluable as an avenue of infection for bacterial canker infectivity titrations, have been used successfully in crown gall studies. Live cells of strain 84, but neither an avirulent strain of the pathogen nor a soil bacterium highly antagonistic to A. tumefaciens in vitro, inhibited gall formation in cherry leaf scars. Heat-killed cells had no effect. In a field experiment at East Malling hardwood cuttings of the new rootstock Colt have been dipped in strain 84 and total inhibition of crown gall is expected to ensue. The results of other experiments where the disease is already established on cherry-rootstock layer-beds and in blackberry plantations are less predictable. In time we hope to solve this problem. Only time will show whether this method of biological control is long lasting or will eventually break down.     

Characterization of Tn904 insertions in octopine Ti plasmid mutants of Agrobacterium tumefaciens.

Seven Tn904 insertion mutants of pTi Ach5 affecting Agrobacterium tumefaciens virulence were studied. The mutant character was shown to be plasmid borne. Four of these mutants were avirulent and carried an insertion in restriction endonuclease HpaI fragment 12, a 3.3-megadalton fragment, which therefore appears to be a Ti plasmid region essential for virulence. Two mutants were attenuated in virulence. The inserts mapped close to HpaI fragment 12. One mutant giving rise to small tumors with excessive adventitious root formation on Kalanchoe daigremontiana carried an insertion in the right side of the common sequence in the deoxyribonucleic acid of the Ti plasmid detected in crown gall tumors. The insertion behavior of Tn904 was studied by analyzing 11 independently isolated and randomly chosen mutants. The Tn904 inserts did not affect oncogenicity, tumor morphology, bacterial transfer functions, octopine catabolism functions, or vital parts of the Ti plasmid, such as the origin of replication. Most of the Tn904 inserts were concentrated in a small part of the map. The size of additional deoxyribonucleic acid as a result of Tn904 inserts varied between 5 and 15 megadaltons. In two cases a Ti plasmid was found with two Tn904 insertions at different positions.     

Methylation of the T-DNA in Agrobacterium tumefaciens and in several crown gall tumors.

Methylation of the T-DNA in Agrobacterium tumefaciens and in four octopine-type (A6S/2, E9, 15955/1, 15955/01) and one nopaline-type (HT37#15) crown gall tumors was investigated using the isoschizomeric restriction endonucleases Msp I and Hpa II. T-DNA in the octopine-type Ti-plasmid pTiB6(806) was not methylated at the sequence 5'CCGG3' in Agrobacterium. With two possible exceptions, neither was the T-DNA of the nopaline-type Ti-plasmid pTiT37 methylated in the bacterium. In all tumor lines investigated, at least one copy of the T-DNA was not methylated. DNA methylation was not detected in the lines A6S/2, 15955/1, HT37#15, and the TL region of E9. DNA methylation of some copies of TR in the E9 tumor line, and possibly in the 15955/01 line, was detected. The methylation of some copies of TR in the E9 line may indicate that not all copies of TR are transcribed in this tumor.     

Polymyxin resistance in Agrobacterium tumefaciens and its effect on crown gall tumor induction.

Polymyxin-resistant (PBLr) mutants of Agrobacterium tumefaciens A6, B6, and B6M were isolated from polymyxin-sensitive (PBLs) parent strains in a defined medium containing 600 microgram of polymyxin B sulfate per millilitre. The weight and number of tumors induced by PBLr mutants on a variety of host plants such as carrot, potato, and pinto bean were 45--75% less than those induced by PBLs wild types. The crude cell envelopes (CCE) prepared from both PBLs and PBLr bacteria were inhibitory for tumor initiation when they were applied before or during the inoculation of viable tumorigenic bacteria, but not when they were applied 30 min after the inoculation of infectious bacteria. The potency to inhibit the tumor initiation by the CCE prepared from PBLs cells was approximately 50% higher than that by the equal amount of the CCE prepared from PBLr cells. The concentration of CCE preparations required to reduce tumor induction 50% in carrot and pinto bean was determined to be 2.6 mg/mL and 4.0--6.2 mg/mL for the CCE derived from PBLs and PBLr cells, respectively. These data suggest that the envelope structure or composition of PBLs and PBLr cells is distinct, and that the acquisition of resistance to polymyxin by agrobacteria modifies envelope structure or components which are essential for tumor initiation.     

Interactions between octopine and nopaline plasmids in Agrobacterium tumefaciens.

Transfer of octopine Ti plasmids to strains already carrying an octopine Ti plasmid was found to occur at the same (high) frequency as transfer to Ti plasmid lacking recipients, showing that resident Ti plasmids do not exhibit entry exclusion towards incoming Ti plasmids. The resident octopine Ti plasmid was lost by the recipient after the entrance of the incoming Ti plasmid, which is indicative of the incompatibility between the Ti plasmids. Octopine Ti plasmids were found to become established only infrequently in recipients with a nopaline Ti plasmid and, vice versa, nopaline Ti plasmids were only rarely established in recipients with an octopine Ti plasmid. Rare clones in which the incoming octopine (nopaline) Ti plasmid had been established despite the presence of a nopaline (octopine) Ti plasmid appeared to harbor cointegrates consisting of the entire incoming Ti plasmid and the entire resident Ti plasmid. The integration event invariably had occurred in a region of the plasmids that is highly conserved in evolution and that is essential for oncogenicity. These results show that octopine and nopaline Ti plasmids cannot be maintained as separate replicons by one and the same cell. Therefore, be definition, these plasmids belong to the same incompatibility group, which has been names inc Rh-1. Agrobacterial non-Ti octopine and nopaline plasmids were found to belong to another incompatibility group. The tumorigenic properties of strains harboring two different Ti plasmids, in a cointegrate structure, were indicative of the virulence genes of both of them being expressed. The agrobacterial non-Ti octopine and nopaline plasmids did not influence the virulence properties encoded by the Ti plasmid.     

Highly tumorigenic Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain from crown gall tumors of chrysanthemum

A wild-type Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain CNI5 isolated from crown gall of chrysanthemum (Dendranthema grandiflora Tzvelev) was characterized. Strain CNI5 was classified into biovar 1, based on physiological and biochemical characteristics, and was resistant to ampicillin. Strain CNI5 induced tumors at a higher frequency and on a larger area of explants in most tested plant species, especially in chrysanthemum cultivars, than the octopine-type strain C58C1cmr (pTiB6S3). Agropine and mannopine were detected in tumors induced by strain CNI5 and were specifically catabolized by this strain. Strain CNI5 harbored five plasmids including one plasmid that shared sequence similarity to TL-DNA of the octopine-type Ti plasmid and four cryptic plasmids.     

Growth of Agrobacterium tumefaciens under octopine limitation in chemostats.

Agrobacterium tumefaciens B6 and ATCC 15955 were grown under octopine or glutamate limitation in chemostats. Examination of the maximum specific growth rate (mu max) and substrate affinity (KS) for each strain indicated that strain B6 was highly inefficient in its use of octopine as either a nitrogen or carbon source compared with strain ATCC 15955. Examination of the yield coefficients showed that in both strains octopine was used more efficiently as a nitrogen source than as a carbon source. The data permitted predictions to be made concerning the outcome of competition for a single limiting substrate. Under octopine limitation, strain ATCC 15955 should dominate; under glutamate limitation, strain B6 should dominate. The results of an observed competition with glutamate as the limiting substrate confirmed the latter prediction, although B6 did dominate at a rate faster than was predicted from simple competition theory. B6 displayed higher growth rates and substrate affinities than ATCC 15955 on all concentrations of glutamate. The yield of B6 on octopine was also considerably higher. This latter attribute could provide an ecological advantage to B6 because of the importance of yield in the fate of competitions under multisubstrate regimens. These will be the most prevalent regimens in the area around the tumor (tumorosphere) or the rhizosphere. The increased performance on glutamate could provide an advantage in an opine-free environment when B6 is growing as a saprophyte.     

Double infection of tobacco plants by two complementing octopine T-region mutants of Agrobacterium tumefaciens

The molecular basis of complementation by a mixture of two different types of octopine T-region mutants (LBA4060 and LBA4210) was studied. Six randomly chosen cellular clones derived from a tumor obtained after mixed infection were analyzed for their T-DNA content via Southern blot hybridization. The clones appeared to contain T-DNA that originated from each of both mutants, indicating that they developed from doubly infected single cells. Genetic complementation, therefore, might explain at least in part the observed complementation phenomenon. However, complementation as a result of cross-feeding between separately transformed cells could not be excluded. Following protoplast isolation, small aggregates might have formed that developed into the clones analyzed.     

Growth of Agrobacterium tumefaciens under octopine limitation in chemostats

Agrobacterium tumefaciens B6 and ATCC 15955 were grown under octopine or glutamate limitation in chemostats. Examination of the maximum specific growth rate (mu max) and substrate affinity (KS) for each strain indicated that strain B6 was highly inefficient in its use of octopine as either a nitrogen or carbon source compared with strain ATCC 15955. Examination of the yield coefficients showed that in both strains octopine was used more efficiently as a nitrogen source than as a carbon source. The data permitted predictions to be made concerning the outcome of competition for a single limiting substrate. Under octopine limitation, strain ATCC 15955 should dominate; under glutamate limitation, strain B6 should dominate. The results of an observed competition with glutamate as the limiting substrate confirmed the latter prediction, although B6 did dominate at a rate faster than was predicted from simple competition theory. B6 displayed higher growth rates and substrate affinities than ATCC 15955 on all concentrations of glutamate. The yield of B6 on octopine was also considerably higher. This latter attribute could provide an ecological advantage to B6 because of the importance of yield in the fate of competitions under multisubstrate regimens. These will be the most prevalent regimens in the area around the tumor (tumorosphere) or the rhizosphere. The increased performance on glutamate could provide an advantage in an opine-free environment when B6 is growing as a saprophyte.     

Unusual plasmid DNA organization in an octopine crown gall tumor.

A cloned tobacco crown gall tumor, 1595501, incited by A. tumefaciens strain 15955 was studied. Molecular analysis of the organization of the T-DNA by means of Southern transfer and hybridization techniques indicated that the 1595501 tumor has about 10 copies of TL DNA, five of which are complete TL DNA, whereas most octopine tumors have only one to two copies of complete TL DNA. Hybridization studies and genomic cloning indicated that some segments of the T-DNA have undergone deletions. One of the clones contained two copies of T-DNA which were inverted in orientation with respect to each other. Two left ends of TL DNA from the 1595501 tumor line and the corresponding region of the octopine plasmid were sequenced. Comparison of the various cloned T-DNA sequences with Ti-plasmid sequence indicated that while there is an association with a 25 base pair direct repeat, there is no specific set of base pairs in the T-DNA at which divergence from Ti-plasmid sequences occurred.     

Strain-dependent temperature-sensitive phase in crown gall tumorigenesis

The effect of high temperature treatments on the early stages of crown gall tumorigenesis in sunflowers was investigated. Treatments of 32 C initiated at various times during the first ten days after infection had a similar effect on tumors induced by Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains B₆ and C58. Tumor growth was sensitive to 32 C until 60 to 72 hours after infection and was stimulated by 32 C after that time. Therefore, the “inception phase” for both C58 and B₆-induced tumors ends between 60 to 72 hours after infection. In contrast, B₆ and C58 tumors varied in their response to 37 C treatments during the first 168 hours after infection. Both C58 and B₆ tumors were sensitive to 37 C during the first 72 hours; however, B₆ tumors became resistant to 37 C after 96 hours, whereas C58-induced tumors remained sensitive until 144 to 168 hours after infection.