Electron spin resonance studies of intact mammalian skeletal muscle

Samples of skeletal muscle from mice, rats and man have been examined by conventional electron spin resonance techniques. One major free-radical signal with g value 2.0036-2.004 was detected in all intact muscle samples and homogenates at 77 K whereas this signal was not seen at room temperature. Other less prominant signals were also detected. Thirty minutes of excessive contractile activity of rat hind limb muscles was found to result in a leakage of intracellular creatine kinase enzyme into the blood plasma and also produced an average 70% increase in the amplitude of the major electron spin resonance signal. These data support the hypothesis that increased free-radical activity may play some role in muscle damage caused by extensive muscular activity.     

Free radical production, catalase and superoxide dismutase activities and membrane integrity during senescence of petals of cut carnations (Dianthus caryophyllus)

There is a sudden increase in free radical levels, measured from the electron spin resonance (ESR) signal, in cut carnation ( Dianthus caryophyllus L. cv. Ember) petal powders between the end of blooming and the onset of withering. There is also an increase in the microsomal generation of superoxide radicals (measured from the ESR-Tiron signal). These increases correspond to a decrease of polar lipids content, a slight increase in peroxides and to the onset of a sudden efflux of electrolytes. A correlation is established between free radical production and the loss of membrane integrity. Catalase (EC 1.11.1.6) activity increases progressively until complete withering and an hypothesis concerning the action of this enzyme is proposed. The changes in superoxide dismutase (EC 1.15.1.1) activity appear to be independent of the amplitude of the ESR-Tiron signal.     

The effect of caffeine on calcium efflux and calcium translocation in skeletal and visceral muscle.

1. KCl-induced depolarization resulted in a large stimulation of the 45Ca efflux from both cockroach skeletal muscle and rat ileal smooth muscle. 2. Caffeine (10 mM) induced a large stimulation of 45Ca efflux from skeletal muscle, but a fall in the efflux from ileal muscle, especially if the efflux was previously stimulated by KCl depolarization. 3. Caffeine inhibited calcium uptake by skeletal muscle mitochondria and sarcoplasmic reticulum, was without effect on ileal muscle mitochondria, but significantly increased caclium binding by ileal muscle membrane vesicular preparations. 4. The induction of contractures and stimulation of 45Ca efflux in skeletal muscle by caffeine are clearly related to inhibition of intracellular calcium binding by the sarcoplasmic reticulum and mitochondria. 5. The relaxation of ileal muscle by caffeine and the inhibition of fibre calcium efflux correlate well with caffeine enhancement of intracellular calcium binding. These experiments suggest that the membrane vesicular compartment may be the main agency centrally involved in fibre calcium regulation in this muscle during the contraction-relaxation cycle.     

Electron paramagnetic resonance evidence that cellular oxygen toxicity is caused by the generation of superoxide and hydroxyl free radicals

Cells require molecular oxygen for the generation of energy through mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation; however, high concentrations of oxygen are toxic and can cause cell death. A number of different mechanisms have been proposed to cause cellular oxygen toxicity. One hypothesis is that reactive oxygen free radicals may be generated; however free radical generation in hyperoxic cells has never been directly measured and the mechanism of this radical generation is unknown. In order to determine if cellular oxygen toxicity is free radical mediated, we applied electron paramagnetic resonance, EPR, spectroscopy using the spin trap 5,5'-dimethyl-1-pyrroline-N-oxide, DMPO, to measure free radical generation in hyperoxic pulmonary endothelial cells. Cells in air did not give rise to any detectable signal. However, cells exposed to 100% O2 for 30 min exhibited a prominent signal of trapped hydroxyl radical, DMPO-OH, while cell free buffer did not give rise to any detectable radical generation. This cellular radical generation was demonstrated to be derived from the superoxide radical since the observed signal was totally quenched by superoxide dismutase, but not by equal concentrations of the denatured enzyme. It was confirmed that the hydroxyl radical was generated since in the presence of ethanol the CH3 CH(OH) radical was formed. Loss of cell viability as measured by uptake of trypan blue dye was observed paralleling the measured free radical generation. Thus, superoxide and hydroxyl radicals are generated in hyperoxic pulmonary endothelial cells and this appears to be an important mechanism of cellular oxygen toxicity.     

Effect of inhibitors of arachidonic acid metabolism on efflux of intracellular enzymes from skeletal muscle following experimental damage.

The role of arachidonic acid metabolism in the efflux of intracellular enzymes from damaged skeletal muscle has been examined in vitro using inhibitors of cyclo-oxygenase and lipoxygenase enzymes. Damage to skeletal muscle induced by either calcium ionophore A23187 (25 microM) or dinitrophenol (1 mM) caused an increase in the efflux of prostaglandins E2 and F2 alpha together with a large efflux of intracellular creatine kinase. Use of a cyclo-oxygenase inhibitor completely prevented the efflux of prostaglandins, but had no effect on creatine kinase efflux. However, several agents having the ability to inhibit lipoxygenase enzymes dramatically reduced creatine kinase efflux following damage. These data suggest that a product or products of lipoxygenase enzymes may be mediators of the changes in plasma membrane integrity which permit efflux of intracellular enzymes as a consequence of skeletal muscle damage.     

Differential effect of dopamine catabolism and uptake inhibition on dopamine-induced calcium dysregulation and viability loss

The present study was aimed at evaluating of the effects of dopamine (DA) toxicity on PC12 cells' calcium homeostasis, cellular viability, and free radical levels. Moreover, the effect of receptor inhibition, and DA metabolism and reuptake antagonism on all parameters was also evaluated. Acute treatment with DA impaired the ability of PC12 cells to buffer excess calcium after K+-depolarization, decreased cellular viability by approximately 35%, and increased free radical levels by about 10% in a dose dependent manner. Pretreatment with both active and inactive pargyl monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOi) protected PC12 cells from DA toxicity on cellular viability and free radical levels, regardless of the presence or absence of their target enzymes in PC12 cells. These results suggest a lack of specific involvement of DA metabolism by MAO in dopamine's effects on cellular viability and production of free radicals. However, DA-induced dysregulation of calcium homeostasis seems to be more specifically mediated by DA metabolism by MAO. Results indicate that, in order for toxicity to occur the DA must be taken up into the cells. DA receptors do not mediate dopamine cytoxicity, and the D2 receptor plays a modest role in DA-induced calcium dysregulation and generation of free radicals. Moreover, DA-induced cell viability loss is not mediated by calcium, nor by caspase-3 enzyme, but is prevented by inhibition of mitochondrial permeability transition pores.     

Ischemia and reperfusion of skeletal muscle lead to the appearance of a stable lipid free radical in the circulation

Both ischemia and reperfusion injury and contractile activity are associated with the generation of reactive oxygen species and free radicals by skeletal muscle. In addition, exercise has been reported to lead to the formation of a circulating free radical species that is detectable in the blood by spin trapping before analysis by electron-spin resonance (ESR) techniques. Previous analysis of the ESR signal indicated that the circulating species is either a carbon- or oxygen-centered lipid-derived free radical. The current data indicate that this species is present in the blood of anesthetized rats after 4-h ischemia and 1 h of reperfusion of a single hindlimb. During 4 h of ischemia, the species was also present in microdialysates from the tibialis anterior muscle but was unchanged in magnitude compared with control tissue. During 1 h of reperfusion, the signal intensity increased by a mean of 420% (P < 0.05, n = 4). Hydroxyl radical activity in the interstitial fluid also significantly increased during ischemia and further increased by a mean of 210% (P < 0.05, n = 4) during reperfusion. No changes in interstitial superoxide levels were seen, but interstitial PGE(2) content also increased during reperfusion. A significant positive correlation was found between the magnitude of the ESR signal and both the hydroxyl radical activity and PGE(2) content of microdialysis fluids. These data support the hypothesis that the circulating free radical species is formed in the interstitial fluid by hydroxyl radical interaction with a lipid that may be released from reperfused tissue with a similar pattern to prostanoids.     

EPR spin trapping evaluation of ROS production in human fibroblasts exposed to cerium oxide nanoparticles: Evidence for NADPH oxidase and mitochondrial stimulation

To better understand the antioxidant (enzyme mimetic, free radical scavenger) versus oxidant and cytotoxic properties of the industrially used cerium oxide nanoparticles (nano-CeO(2)), we investigated their effects on reactive oxygen species formation and changes in the antioxidant pool of human dermal and murine 3T3 fibroblasts at doses relevant to chronic inhalation or contact with skin. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spin trapping with the nitrone DEPMPO showed that pretreatment of the cells with the nanoparticles dose-dependently triggered the release in the culture medium of superoxide dismutase- and catalase-inhibitable DEPMPO/hydroxyl radical adducts (DEPMPO-OH) and ascorbyl radical, a marker of ascorbate depletion. This DEPMPO-OH formation occurred 2 to 24h following removal of the particles from the medium and paralleled with an increase of cell lipid peroxidation. These effects of internalized nano-CeO(2) on spin adduct formation were then investigated at the cellular level by using specific NADPH oxidase inhibitors, transfection techniques and a mitochondria-targeted antioxidant. When micromolar doses of nano-CeO(2) were used, weak DEPMPO-OH levels but no loss of cell viability were observed, suggesting that cell signaling mechanisms through protein synthesis and membrane NADPH oxidase activation occurred. Incubation of the cells with higher millimolar doses provoked a 25-60-fold higher DEPMPO-OH formation together with a decrease in cell viability, early apoptosis induction and antioxidant depletion. These cytotoxic effects could be due to activation of both the mitochondrial source and Nox2 and Nox4 dependent NADPH oxidase complex. Regarding possible mechanisms of nano-CeO(2)-induced free radical formation in cells, in vitro EPR and spectrophotometric studies suggest that, contrary to Fe(2+) ions, the Ce(3+) redox state at the surface of the particles is probably not an efficient catalyst of hydroxyl radical formation by a Fenton-like reaction in vivo.     

Ryanodine receptor oxidation causes intracellular calcium leak and muscle weakness in aging

Age-related loss of muscle mass and force (sarcopenia) contributes to disability and increased mortality. Ryanodine receptor 1 (RyR1) is the skeletal muscle sarcoplasmic reticulum calcium release channel required for muscle contraction. RyR1 from aged (24?months) rodents was oxidized, cysteine-nitrosylated, and depleted of the channel-stabilizing subunit calstabin1, compared to RyR1 from younger (3-6?months) adults. This RyR1 channel complex remodeling resulted in "leaky" channels with increased open probability, leading to intracellular calcium leak in skeletal muscle. Similarly, 6-month-old mice harboring leaky RyR1-S2844D mutant channels exhibited skeletal muscle defects comparable to 24-month-old wild-type mice. Treating aged mice with S107 stabilized binding of calstabin1 to RyR1, reduced intracellular calcium leak, decreased reactive oxygen species (ROS), and enhanced tetanic Ca(2+) release, muscle-specific force, and exercise capacity. Taken together, these data indicate that leaky RyR1 contributes to age-related loss of muscle function.     

Synthetic diacylglycerols trigger an increase of intracellular free calcium in promyelocytic HL60 cells

Phosphoinositide turnover is known to play an important role in intracellular free calcium homeostasis through the inositol trisphophate-mediated release of calcium from intracellular stores. We find that the other product of phosphoinositide turnover, 1,2-diacylglycerol, elicits an increase in intracellular free calcium in HL60 cells which is due, at least in part, to release of calcium from intracellular stores. This effect is specific for calcium, since intracellular sodium and potassium levels and cellular volume were unaffected. Concomitant with the intracellular calcium increase, we find an increase in cellular inositol trisphosphate levels, suggesting that the effect of diacylglycerol on calcium may be mediated by inositol trisphosphate. Diacylglycerols also stimulate calcium efflux. This stimulation is not simply due to the increase in intracellular calcium. These effects appear not to be mediated through stimulation of a phorbol ester-activatable protein kinase C (Ca2+/phospholipid-dependent enzyme) since phorbol esters do not elicit an increase in cytoplasmic free calcium or an increase in calcium efflux.     

Measurement of myocardial free radical production during exercise using EPR spectroscopy

Exercise is associated with an increase in oxygen flux through the mitochondrial electron transport chain that has recently been demonstrated to increase the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in skeletal muscle. This study examined whether exercise also causes free radical production in the heart. We measured ROS production in seven chronically instrumented dogs during rest and treadmill exercise (6.4 km/h at 10 degrees grade; and heart rate, 204 +/- 3 beats/min) using electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy in conjunction with the spin trap alpha-phenyl-tert-butylnitrone (PBN) (0.14 mol/l) in blood collected from the aorta and coronary sinus (CS). To improve signal detection, the free radical adducts were deoxygenated over a nitrogen stream for 15 min and extracted with toluene. The hyperfine splitting constants of the radicals were alpha(N) = 13.7 G and alpha(H) = 1.0 G, consistent with an alkoxyl or carbon-centered radical. Resting aortic and CS PBN adduct concentrations were 6.7 and 6.3 x 10(8) arbitrary units (P = not significant). Both aortic and CS adduct concentrations increased during exercise, but there was no significant difference between the aortic and CS concentrations. Thus, in contrast to skeletal muscle, submaximal treadmill exercise did not result in detectable free radical production by the heart.     

Calcium homeostasis and cell death in Sol8 dystrophin-deficient cell line in culture

Abnormalities of calcium homeostasis are involved in the process of cell injuries such as Duchenne muscular dystrophy characterized by the absence of the protein dystrophin. But how the absence of dystrophin leads to cytosolic calcium overload is as yet poorly understood. This question has been addressed with skeletal muscle cells from human DMD muscles or mdx mice. Although easier to obtain than human muscles, mdx muscle cells have provided controversial data concerning the resting intracellular calcium level ([Ca2+](i)). This work describes the culture of Sol8 cell line that expresses neither dystrophin nor adhalin, a dystrophin-associated protein. The [Ca2+](i)and intracellular calcium transients induced by different stimuli (acetylcholine, caffeine and high potassium) are normal during the first days of culture. At later stages, calcium homeostasis exhibits drastic alterations with a breaking down of the calcium responses and a large [Ca2+](i)elevation. Concomitantly, Sol8 cells exhibit morphological signs of cell death like cytoplasmic shrinkage and incorporation of propidium iodide. Cell death could be significantly reduced by blocking the activity of calpains, a type of calcium-regulated proteases. These results suggest that Sol8 cell line provides an alternative model of dystrophin-deficient skeletal muscle cells for which a clear disturbance of the calcium homeostasis is observed in culture in association with calpain-dependent cell death. It is shown that transfection with a plasmid cDNA permits the forced expression of dystrophin in Sol8 myotubes as well as a correct sorting of the protein. This approach could be used to explore possible interactions between dystrophin deficiency, calcium homeostasis alteration, and dystrophic cell death.     

Inositol-1,4,5-triphosphate receptors mediate activity-induced synaptic Ca2+ signals in muscle fibers and Ca2+ overload in slow-channel syndrome

Strict control of calcium entry through excitatory synaptic receptors is important for shaping synaptic responses, gene expression, and cell survival. Disruption of this control may lead to pathological accumulation of Ca2+. The slow-channel congenital myasthenic syndrome (SCS), due to mutations in muscle acetylcholine receptor (AChR), perturbs the kinetics of synaptic currents, leading to post-synaptic Ca2+ accumulation. To understand the regulation of calcium signaling at the neuromuscular junction (NMJ) and the etiology of Ca2+ overload in SCS we studied the role of sarcoplasmic Ca2+ stores in SCS. Using fura-2 loaded dissociated fibers activated with acetylcholine puffs, we confirmed that Ca2+ accumulates around wild type NMJ and discovered that Ca2+ accumulates significantly faster around the NMJ of SCS transgenic dissociated muscle fibers. Additionally, we determined that this process is dependant on the activation, altered kinetics, and movement of Ca2+ ions through the AChR, although, surprisingly, depletion of intracellular stores also prevents the accumulation of this cation around the NMJ. Finally, we concluded that the sarcoplasmic reticulum is the main source of Ca2+ and that inositol-1,4,5-triphosphate receptors (IP3R), and to a lesser degree L-type voltage gated Ca2+ channels, are responsible for the efflux of this cation from intracellular stores. These results suggest that a signaling system mediated by the activation of AChR, Ca2+, and IP3R is responsible for localized Ca2+ signals observed in muscle fibers and the Ca2+ overload observed in SCS.     

The metabolism of halothane by hepatocytes: a comparison between free radical spin trapping and lipid peroxidation in relation to cell damage

The technique of free radical spin trapping has been applied to demonstrate the formation of free radicals produced during the metabolism of halothane by rat liver hepatocytes under hypoxic conditions. The results obtained support previous findings that reported sex differences in the metabolic activation of halothane by rats in vivo. Cell viability under hypoxic conditions, as judged by trypan blue staining and lactate dehydrogenase release, shows a correlation with the extent of metabolism of halothane as measured by electron spin resonance spectroscopy. The extent of lipid peroxidation was measured by diene conjugation, malondialdehyde production and chemiluminescence. The latter technique allowed the demonstration of lipid peroxidation during incubations of hepatocytes under aerobic conditions. The magnitude of the aerobic chemiluminescence showed a similar sex dependency to the extent of free radical formation under hypoxic conditions. Cell viability measurements show that halothane metabolism in both hypoxic and aerobic conditions can lead to cell death. Consequently, oxidative lipid damage could be a cause of cell damage, as judged by cell viability, additional to covalent binding.     

Erythrocytes reduce extracellular ascorbate free radicals using intracellular ascorbate as an electron donor

Ascorbate is readily oxidized in aqueous solution by ascorbate oxidase. Ascorbate radicals are formed, which disproportionate to ascorbate and dehydroascorbic acid. Addition of erythrocytes with increasing intracellular ascorbate concentrations decreased the oxidation of ascorbate in a concentration-dependent manner. Concurrently, it was found, utilizing electron spin resonance spectroscopy, that extracellular ascorbate radical levels were decreased. Control experiments showed that these results could not be explained by leakage of ascorbate from the cells, inactivation of ascorbate oxidase, or oxygen depletion. Thus, this means that intracellular ascorbate is directly responsible for the decreased oxidation of extracellular ascorbate. Exposure of ascorbate-loaded erythrocytes to higher levels of extracellular ascorbate radicals resulted in the detection of intracellular ascorbate radicals. Moreover, efflux of dehydroascorbic acid was observed under these conditions. These data confirm the view that intracellular ascorbate donates electrons to extracellular ascorbate free radical via a plasma membrane redox system. Such a redox system enables the cells to effectively counteract oxidative processes and thereby prevent depletion of extracellular ascorbate.     

Decreased carbon centered and hydrogen radicals in skeletal muscle of vitamin E supplemented rats.

Carbon centered and hydrogen radicals were examined using electron spin resonance techniques with 5,5 dimethyl-2-pyrroline-1-oxide in the skeletal muscle of rats fed with a control diet and a vitamin E supplemented diet containing alpha tocopherol. Carbon centered and hydrogen radical levels in the white and red muscles and the soleus of these vitamin E treated muscle fibers were decreased. These results suggest that vitamin E directly quenches these free radicals.     

Mobilization of intracellular calcium and stimulation of calcium fluxes by endothelin-2 in cultured mouse swiss 3T3 fibroblasts

Specific receptor-induced signal transduction mechanisms for the endothelin-2 isoform (ET-2), a potent vasoconstrictor of vascular smooth muscle, were examined in Swiss 3T3 cells. Half-maximal binding (EC₅₀) and maximal, saturable binding (B_max) were estimated from Scatchard analyses and were found to be 24.2 ± 3.3 pM and 56500 ± 1700 sites/cells, respectively. A saturating concentration of ET-2 (100 nM) increased intracellular free calcium (measured by Fura-2 fluorescence) from a resting level of 100 nM to a peak level of 600–800 nM. The initial increase in intracellular free calcium was transitory and was followed by a smaller maintained elevation (250 nM). In the absence of extracellular calcium, ET-2 induced a transitory response equal in size to the peak in the presence of extracellular calcium, but the maintained response was absent. ET-2 increased intracellular free calcium in a concentration-dependent manner with an EC₅₀ of 1 nM. In calcium free solution (2 mM EGTA), ET-2 increased the efflux of ⁴⁵Ca from cells loaded to isotopic equilibrium (3 h) with ⁴⁵Ca. The intracellular second messenger, IP₃, also increased the calcium efflux from saponin permeabilized 3T3 cells loaded with ⁴⁵Ca (pCa 6) in the presence of MgATP. In the presence of extracellular calcium, ET-2 significantly increased calcium uptake into 3T3 cells by 92 ± 36.6 pmoles/million cells/2 min (n = 8). It is suggested that ET-2 binds to specific, high affinity receptors in 3T3 cells and that this receptor interaction increases the intracellular free calcium by IP₃-induced mobilization of calcium from cellular stores and by increasing influx of extracellular calcium.     

Intermittent Hypothermia Is Neuroprotective in an in vitro Model of Ischemic Stroke

Objective: To investigate whether the intermittent hypothermia (IH) protects neurons against ischemic insult and the potential molecular targets using an in vitro ischemic model of oxygen glucose deprivation (OGD).Methods: Fetal rat cortical neurons isolated from Day E18 rat embryos were subjected to 90-min OGD and hypothermia treatments during reoxygenation before examining the changes in microscopic morphology, cell viability, microtubule- associated protein 2 (MAP-2) release, intracellular pH value and calcium, reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation, mitochondrial membrane potential (△Ψm) and neuronal death using cell counting kit (CCK-8), enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), BCECF AM, Fluo-3 AM, DCFH-DA and dihydroethidium (DHE), JC-1 staining and terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nick-end labeling (TUNEL), respectively.Results: 90-min OGD induced morphologic abnormalities, cell viability decline, MAP-2 release, intracellular acidosis, calcium overload, increased ROS generation, △Ψm decrease and cell death in primary neurons, which was partially inhibited by continuous hypothermia (CH) and intermittent hypothermia (IH). Interestingly, 6-h CH was insufficient to reduce intracellular calcium overload and stabilize mitochondrial membrane potential (△Ψm), while 12-h CH was effective in reversing the above changes. All IH treatments (6×1 h, 4×1.5 h or 3×2 h) effectively attenuated intracellular free calcium overload, inhibited ROS production, stabilized mitochondrial membrane potential (△Ψm) and reduced delayed cell death in OGD-treated cells. However, only IH intervals longer than 1.5 h appeared to be effective in preventing cell viability loss and intracellular pH decline.Conclusion: Both CH and IH were neuroprotective in an in vitro model of ischemic stroke, and in spite of shorter hypothermia duration, IH could provide a comparable neuroprotection to CH.     

Ca2+ signals and death programmes in neurons

Cell death programmes are generally defined by biochemical/genetic routines that are linked to their execution and by the appearance of more or less typical morphological features. However, in pathological settings death signals may engage complex and interacting lethal pathways, some of which are common to different cells, whereas others are linked to a specific tissue and differentiation pattern. In neurons, death programmes can be spatially and temporally segregated. Most importantly physiological Ca2+ signals are essential for cell function and survival. On the other hand, Ca2+ overload or perturbations of intracellular Ca2+ compartmentalization can activate or enhance mechanisms leading to cell death. An imbalance between Ca2+ influx and efflux from cells is the initial signal leading to Ca2+ overload and death of ischaemic neurons or cardiomyocytes. Alterations of intracellular Ca2+ storage can integrate with death signals that do not initially require Ca2+, to promote processing of cellular components and death by apoptosis or necrosis. Finally, Ca2+ can directly activate catabolic enzymes such as proteases, phospholipases and nucleases that directly cause cell demise and tissue damage.     

Free radical activity following contraction-induced injury to the extensor digitorum longus muscles of rats.

The purpose of the study was to investigate the role of free radicals in the injury induced by a protocol of repeated pliometric (lengthening) contractions to the extensor digitorum longus (EDL) muscle in situ in rats. Previous data have indicated that prior treatment with the antioxidant polyethylene glycol-superoxide dismutase reduced the damage that was apparent at 3 days following this type of exercise. Three hours and 3 days following the protocol, the magnitude of the semiquinone-derived free radical signal observed by electron spin resonance spectroscopy (ESR) was not different for exercised and non-exercised skeletal muscles. A reduction in the protein thiol content of muscle was evident at 3 h, and was still apparent at 3 days. Three hours after the protocol, the total muscle glutathione content and the percentage in the oxidized form were unchanged, but by 3 days the percentage of muscle glutathione present in the oxidized form was elevated. The susceptibility of muscle to lipid peroxidation in vitro was reduced 3 days after the pliometric contractions. These data indicate that oxidation of protein thiols and glutathione may be involved in the secondary damage following pliometric contractions, but provide no evidence that the species involved were derived from mitochondrial semiquinone radicals.