Delayed-relaxed response explained by hyperactivation of RelE

Escherichia coli encodes two rel loci, both of which contribute to the control of synthesis of macromolecules during amino acid starvation. The product of relA (ppGpp synthetase I) is responsible for the synthesis of guanosine tetraphosphate, ppGpp, the signal molecule that exerts stringent control of stable RNA synthesis. The second rel locus, relBE, was identified by mutations in relB that confer a so-called 'delayed-relaxed response' characterized by continued RNA synthesis after a lag period of approximately 10 min after the onset of amino acid starvation. We show here that the delayed-relaxed response is a consequence of hyperactivation of RelE. As in wild-type cells, [ppGpp] increased sharply in relB101 relE cells after the onset of starvation, but returned rapidly to the prestarvation level. RelE is a global inhibitor of translation that is neutralized by RelB by direct protein-protein interaction. Lon protease activates RelE during amino acid starvation by degradation of RelB. We found that mutations in relB that conferred the delayed-relaxed phenotype destabilized RelB. Such mutations confer severe RelE-dependent inhibition of translation during amino acid starvation, indicating hyperactivation of RelE. Hyperactivation of RelE during amino acid starvation was shown directly by measurement of RelE-mediated cleavage of tmRNA. The RelE-mediated shutdown of translation terminated amino acid consumption and explains the rapid restoration of the ppGpp level observed in relB mutant cells. Restoration of the prestarvation level of ppGpp, in turn, allows for the resumption of stable RNA synthesis seen during the delayed-relaxed response.     

The bacterial toxin RelE displays codon-specific cleavage of mRNAs in the ribosomal A site

The Escherichia coli relBE operon encodes a toxin-antitoxin pair, RelE-RelB. RelB can reverse inhibition of protein synthesis by RelE in vivo. We have found that although RelE does not degrade free RNA, it cleaves mRNA in the ribosomal A site with high codon specificity. Among stop codons UAG is cleaved with fast, UAA intermediate and UGA slow rate, while UCG and CAG are cleaved most rapidly among sense codons. We suggest that inhibition of protein synthesis by RelE is reversed with the help of tmRNA, and that RelE plays a regulatory role in bacteria during adaptation to poor growth conditions.     

Ribosome rescue by tmRNA requires truncated mRNAs

tmRNA targets ribosomes, stalled either on truncated mRNAs or on mRNAs with slowly read sense or stop codons, tags the newly synthesized peptide chains for degradation and allows for their release by a class-1 release factor. We have studied in vitro how the rate of trans-transfer of a peptide from the P-site tRNA to tmRNA and the efficiency by which tmRNA competes with peptide release factors depend on the length of the mRNA downstream from the P-site. We show that the rate and efficiency of tmRNA action decrease rapidly with increasing down stream length and approach zero when it exceeds 15 bases. We demonstrate that tmRNA action is strongly stimulated by RelE cleavage of mRNA in the A site. We conclude that tmRNA action in vivo must always be preceded by mRNA truncation, and suggest that cleavage of ribosome bound mRNAs is a common element in different bacterial stress responses.     

Translation affects YoeB and MazF messenger RNA interferase activities by different mechanisms

Prokaryotic toxin–antitoxin loci encode mRNA cleaving enzymes that inhibit translation. Two types are known: those that cleave mRNA codons at the ribosomal A site and those that cleave any RNA site specifically. RelE of Escherichia coli cleaves mRNA at the ribosomal A site in vivo and in vitro but does not cleave pure RNA in vitro. RelE exhibits an incomplete RNase fold that may explain why RelE requires its substrate mRNA to presented by the ribosome. In contrast, RelE homologue YoeB has a complete RNase fold and cleaves RNA independently of ribosomes in vitro. Here, we show that YoeB cleavage of mRNA is strictly dependent on translation of the mRNA in vivo. Non-translated model mRNAs were not cleaved whereas the corresponding wild-type mRNAs were cleaved efficiently. Model mRNAs carrying frameshift mutations exhibited a YoeB-mediated cleavage pattern consistent with the reading frameshift thus giving strong evidence that YoeB cleavage specificity was determined by the translational reading frame. In contrast, site-specific mRNA cleavage by MazF occurred independently of translation. In one case, translation seriously influenced MazF cleavage efficiency, thus solving a previous apparent paradox. We propose that translation enhances MazF-mediated cleavage of mRNA by destabilization of the mRNA secondary structure.     

Purification of the RelB and RelE proteins of Escherichia coli: RelE binds to RelB and to ribosomes

The direct interaction of the Escherichia coli cytotoxin RelE with its specific antidote, RelB, was demonstrated in two ways: (i) copurification of the two proteins and (ii) a positive yeast two-hybrid assay involving the relB and relE genes. In addition, the purified RelE protein exhibited ribosome-binding activity in an in vitro assay, supporting previous observations suggesting that it is an inhibitor of translation.     

Structure probing of tmRNA in distinct stages of trans-translation

Ribosomes stalled on problematic mRNAs in bacterial cells can be rescued by transfer-messenger RNA (tmRNA), its helper protein (small protein B, SmpB), and elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) through a mechanism called trans-translation. In this work we used lead(II) footprinting to probe the interactions of tmRNA with SmpB and other components of the translation machinery at different steps of the trans-translation cycle. Ribosomes with a short nascent peptide stalled on a truncated mRNA were reacted with Ala-tmRNA*EF-Tu*GTP, SmpB, and other translation components to initiate and execute trans-translation. Free tmRNA was probed with lead(II) acetate with and without SmpB, and ribosome bound tmRNA was probed in one of four different trans-translation states stabilized by antibiotic addition or selective exclusion of translation components. For comparison, we also analyzed lead(II) cleavage patterns of tmRNA in vivo in a wild-type as well as in an SmpB-deficient Escherichia coli strain. We observed some specific cleavages/protections in tmRNA for the individual steps of trans-translation, but the overall tmRNA conformation appeared to be similar in the stages analyzed. Our findings suggest that, in vivo, a dominant fraction of tmRNA is in complex with SmpB and that, in vitro, SmpB remains tmRNA bound at the initial steps of trans-translation.     

Ribosome stalling during translation elongation induces cleavage of mRNA being translated in Escherichia coli

Recently, it has been found that ribosome pausing at stop codons caused by certain nascent peptides induces cleavage of mRNA in Escherichia coli cells (1, 2). The question we addressed in the present study is whether mRNA cleavage occurs when translation elongation is prevented. We focused on a specific peptide sequence (AS17), derived from SecM, that is known to cause elongation arrest. When the crp-crr fusion gene encoding CRP-AS17-IIA(Glc) was expressed, cAMP receptor protein (CRP) proteins truncated around the arrest sequence were efficiently produced, and they were tagged by the transfer-messenger RNA (tmRNA) system. Northern blot analysis revealed that both truncated upstream crp and downstream crr mRNAs were generated along with reduced amounts of the full-length crp-crr mRNA. The truncated crp mRNA dramatically decreased in the presence of tmRNA due to rapid degradation. The 3' ends of truncated crp mRNA correspond well to the C termini of the truncated CRP proteins. We conclude that ribosome stalling by the arrest sequence induces mRNA cleavage near the arrest point, resulting in nonstop mRNAs that are recognized by tmRNA. We propose that the mRNA cleavage induced by ribosome stalling acts in concert with the tmRNA system as a way to ensure quality control of protein synthesis and possibly to regulate the expression of certain genes.     

Cleavage of mRNAs and role of tmRNA system under amino acid starvation in Escherichia coli

We have shown previously that ribosome stalling during translation caused by various reasons leads to mRNA cleavage, resulting in non-stop mRNAs that are eliminated in a tmRNA-dependent manner. Amino acid starvation is a physiological condition in which ribosome stalling is expected to occur more frequently. Here we demonstrate that mRNA cleavage is induced by amino acid starvation, resulting in accumulation of truncated mRNAs in cells lacking tmRNA. The truncated mRNAs are eliminated in wild-type cells, indicating that the tmRNA system rapidly degrade the truncated mRNAs. The cleavage pattern of model mRNAs in which serine codons were replaced with threonine codons indicated that mRNA cleavage occurs near serine codons in response to serine starvation. Cells lacking all of the five known toxin loci were proficient in mRNA cleavage, showing that toxin–antitoxin systems are not responsible for the cleavage. A mild serine starvation caused a significant growth inhibition in cells lacking tmRNA but not in wild-type cells. The ribosome-mediated mRNA cleavage along with the tmRNA system is an important mechanism that enables cells to adapt to amino acid starvation conditions.     

The bacterial toxin RelE induces specific mRNA cleavage in the A site of the eukaryote ribosome

RelE/RelB is a well-characterized toxin-anti-toxin pair involved in nutritional stress responses in Bacteria and Archae. RelE lacks any eukaryote homolog, but we demonstrate here that it efficiently and specifically cleaves mRNA in the A site of the eukaryote ribosome. The cleavage mechanism is similar to that in bacteria, showing the feasibility of A-site cleavage of mRNA for regulatory purposes also in eukaryotes. RelE cleavage in the A-site codon of a stalled eukaryote ribosome is precise and easily monitored, making "RelE printing" a useful complement to toeprinting to determine the exact mRNA location on the eukaryote ribosome and to probe the occupancy of its A site.     

Structural and thermodynamic characterization of the Escherichia coli RelBE toxin-antitoxin system: indication for a functional role of differential stability

The RelE and RelB proteins constitute the RNA interferase (toxin) and its cognate inhibitor (antitoxin) components of the Escherichia coli relBE toxin-antitoxin system. Despite the well-described functionality and physiological activity of this system in E. coli, no structural study was performed on the folding and stability of the protein pair in solution. Here we structurally and thermodynamically characterize the RelBE system components from E. coli in solution, both separately and in their complexed state. The RelB antitoxin, an alpha-helical protein according to circular dichroism and infrared spectroscopy, forms oligomers in solution, exhibits high thermostability with a TM of 58.5 degrees C, has a considerable heat resistance, and has high unfolding reversibility. In contrast, the RelE toxin includes a large portion of antiparallel beta-sheets, displays lower thermostability with a TM of 52.5 degrees C, and exhibits exceptional sensitivity to heat. Complex formation, accompanied by a structural transition, leads to a 12 degrees C increase in the TM and substantial heat resistance. Moreover, in vivo interaction and protein footprint experiments indicate that the C-terminal part of RelB is responsible for RelB-RelE interaction, being protease sensitive in its free state, while it becomes protected from proteolysis when complexed with RelE. Overall, our findings support the notion that RelB lacks a well-organized hydrophobic core in solution whereas RelE is a well-folded protein. Furthermore, our results support that RelB protein from E. coli is similar to ParD and CcdA antitoxins in both fold and thermodynamic properties. The differential folding state of the proteins is discussed in the context of their physiological activities.     

Overproduction of the Lon protease triggers inhibition of translation in Escherichia coli: involvement of the yefM-yoeB toxin-antitoxin system

In Escherichia coli, the Lon ATP-dependent protease is responsible for degradation of several regulatory proteins and for the elimination of abnormal proteins. Previous studies have shown that the overproduction of Lon is lethal. Here, we showed that Lon overproduction specifically inhibits translation through at least two different pathways. We have identified one of the pathways as being the chromosomal yefM-yoeB toxin-antitoxin system. The existence of a second pathway is demonstrated by the observation that the deletion of the yefM-yoeB system did not completely suppress lethality and translation inhibition. We also showed that the YoeB toxin induces cleavage of translated mRNAs and that Lon overproduction specifically activates YoeB-dependent mRNAs cleavage. Indeed, none of the other identified chromosomal toxin-antitoxin systems (relBE, mazEF, chpB and dinJ-yafQ) was involved in Lon-dependent lethality, translation inhibition and mRNA cleavage even though the RelB and MazE antitoxins are known to be Lon substrates. Based on our results and other studies, translation inhibition appears to be the key element that triggers chromosomal toxin-antitoxin systems. We propose that under Lon overproduction conditions, translation inhibition is mediated by Lon degradation of a component of the YoeB-independent pathway, in turn activating the YoeB toxin by preventing synthesis of its unstable YefM antidote.     

Cleavage of the A site mRNA codon during ribosome pausing provides a mechanism for translational quality control

Cells employ many mechanisms to ensure quality control during protein biosynthesis. Here, we show that, during the pausing of a bacterial ribosome, the mRNA being translated is cleaved at a site within or immediately adjacent to the A site codon. The extent of this A site mRNA cleavage is correlated with the extent of ribosome pausing as assayed by tmRNA-mediated tagging of the nascent polypeptide. Cleavage does not require tmRNA, the ribosomal alarmone (p)ppGpp, or bacterial toxins such as RelE which have been shown to stimulate a similar activity. Translation is required for cleavage, suggesting that the ribosome participates in the reaction in some fashion. When normal protein synthesis is compromised, A site mRNA cleavage and the tmRNA system provide a mechanism for reducing translational errors and the production of aberrant and potentially harmful polypeptides.     

Protein tagging at rare codons is caused by tmRNA action at the 3' end of nonstop mRNA generated in response to ribosome stalling

It has been believed that protein tagging caused by consecutive rare codons involves tmRNA action at the internal mRNA site. We demonstrated previously that ribosome stalling either at sense or stop codons caused by certain arrest sequences could induce mRNA cleavage near the arrest site, resulting in nonstop mRNAs that are recognized by tmRNA. These findings prompted us to re-examine the mechanism of tmRNA tagging at a run of rare codons. We report here that either AGG or CGA but not AGA arginine rare-codon clusters inserted into a model crp mRNA encoding cAMP receptor protein (CRP) could cause an efficient protein tagging. We demonstrate that more than three consecutive AGG codons are needed to induce an efficient ribosome stalling therefore tmRNA tagging in our system. The tmRNA tagging was eliminated by overproduction of tRNAs corresponding to rare codons, indicating that a scarcity of the corresponding tRNA caused by the rare-codon cluster is an important factor for tmRNA tagging. Mass spectrometry analyses of proteins generated in cells lacking or possessing tmRNA encoding a protease-resistant tag sequence indicated that the truncation and tmRNA tagging occur within the cluster of rare codons. Northern and S1 analyses demonstrated that nonstop mRNAs truncated within the rare-codon clusters are detected in cells lacking tmRNA but not in cells expressing tmRNA. We conclude that a ribosome stalled by the rare codon induces mRNA cleavage, resulting in nonstop mRNAs that are recognized by tmRNA.     

Novel factor rescues ribosomes trapped on non-stop mRNAs

Ribosomes are trapped at the 3′ ends of mRNAs that lack a natural stop codon. In bacteria, a reaction called trans-translation recycles ribosomes entrapped at such ‘non-stop’ mRNAs. The main player in trans-translation is tmRNA (SsrA-RNA), a bi-functional RNA that acts as both a tRNA and an mRNA. In the trans-translation reaction, alanine-charged tmRNA loads at the ribosomal A-site and translation shifts to the resume codon in tmRNA. Translation of tmRNA stops at a natural stop codon at the end of the small reading frame of tmRNA. In this way, the reaction simultaneously adds a peptide tag to the end of the nascent, incomplete polypeptide and recycles the stalled ribosomes. The peptide tag is recognized by cellular proteases that rapidly degrade the incomplete, potentially harmful polypeptides. The trans-translation reaction is not essential in most bacteria, raising the possibility that ribosomes stalled at non-stop mRNAs can be rescued by alternative routes. In this issue of Molecular Microbiology, Chadani et al. show that a novel translation factor, ArfA, can recycle a ribosome trapped at the 3′ end of a non-stop mRNA in the absence of trans-translation. AfrA is essential in the absence of tmRNA, showing that the two systems work in parallel to resolve stalled ribosomes.