Glucocorticoid ligands specify different interactions with NF-kappaB by allosteric effects on the glucocorticoid receptor DNA binding domain

Glucocorticoids inhibit inflammation by acting through the glucocorticoid receptor (GR) and powerfully repressing NF-kappaB function. Ligand binding to the C-terminal of GR promotes the nuclear translocation of the receptor and binding to NF-kappaB through the GR DNA binding domain. We sought how ligand recognition influences the interaction between NF-kappaB and GR. Both dexamethasone (agonist) and RU486 (antagonist) promote efficient nuclear translocation, and we show occupancy of the same intranuclear compartment as NF-kappaB with both ligands. However, unlike dexamethasone, RU486 had negligible activity to inhibit NF-kappaB transactivation. This failure may stem from altered co-factor recruitment or altered interaction with NF-kappaB. Using both glutathione S-transferase pull-down and bioluminescence resonance energy transfer approaches, we identified a major glucocorticoid ligand effect on interaction between the GR and the p65 component of NF-kappaB, with RU486 inhibiting recruitment compared with dexamethasone. Using the bioluminescence resonance energy transfer assay, we found that RU486 efficiently recruited NCoR to the GR, unlike dexamethasone, which recruited SRC1. Therefore, RU486 promotes differential protein recruitment to both the C-terminal and DNA binding domain of the receptor. Importantly, using chromatin immunoprecipitation, we show that impaired interaction between GR and p65 with RU486 leads to reduced recruitment of the GR to the NF-kappaB-responsive region of the interleukin-8 promoter, again in contrast to dexamethasone that significantly increased GR binding. We demonstrate that ligand-induced conformation of the GR C-terminal has profound effects on the functional surface generated by the DNA binding domain of the GR. This has implications for understanding ligand-dependent interdomain communication.     

Recycling and desensitization of glucocorticoid receptors in v-mos transformed cells depend on the ability of nuclear receptors to modulate gene expression

In v-mos transformed cells, glucocorticoid receptor (GR) proteins that bind hormone agonist are not efficiently retained within nuclei and redistribute to the cytoplasmic compartment. These cytoplasmic desensitized receptors cannot be reutilized and may represent trapped intermediates derived from GR recycling. We have used the glucocorticoid antagonist RU486 to examine whether v-mos effects can be exerted on any ligand-bound GR. In the rat 6m2 cell line that expresses a temperature-sensitive p85gag-mos oncoprotein, RU486 is a complete antagonist and suppresses dexamethasone induction of metallothionein-1 mRNA at equimolar concentrations. Using indirect immunofluorescence, we observe efficient nuclear translocation of GR in response to RU486 treatment in either the presence or absence of v-mos oncoproteins. However, in contrast to the redistribution of agonist-bound nuclear receptors to the cytoplasm of v-mos-transformed cells, RU486-bound GRs are efficiently retained within nuclei. Interestingly, withdrawal of RU486 does not lead to efficient depletion of nuclear GR in either nontransformed or v-mos transformed cells. It is only after the addition of hormone agonist to RU486 withdrawn v-mos-transformed cells that GRs are depleted from nuclei and subsequently redistributed to the cytoplasm. Thus, only nuclear GRs that are agonist-bound and capable of modulating gene activity can be subsequently processed and recycled into the cytoplasm.     

Hepatic glucocorticoid receptor behaves differently when its hormone binding site is occupied by agonist (triamcinolone acetonide) or antagonist (RU486) steroid ligands

We have examined the influence of sulfhydryl (SH)-group modifying agents on the interaction of the rat liver glucocorticoid receptor (GR) with its known agonist triamcinolone acetonide (TA) and the newly synthesized antagonist mifepristone (RU486). In the freshly prepared cytosol, [3H]TA or [3H]RU486 bound to macromolecule(s) which sediment as 8-9 moieties: the binding of either ligand can be competed with radioinert TA or RU486. The presence of 2-10 mM dithiothreitol (DTT), beta-mercaptoethanol (beta-MER), and monothioglycerol (MTG) caused a 2-3 fold increase in the [3H]TA and [3H]RU486 binding to GR. Iodoacetamide (IA) and N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) decreased the agonist binding significantly. In contrast, the [3H]RU486 binding to GR increased by 50 percent in the presence of IA. IA and NEM inhibited the binding of the heat-transformed [3H]TA-receptor complex to DNA-cellulose by 70-90 percent whereas DNA binding of [3H]RU486-bound GR was inhibited only slightly. These results indicate that either a) the interaction of GR with the agonist or antagonist steroid ligands causes differential structural alterations, which are more readily detectable in the presence of SH-modifying agents or b) the agonist and the antagonist interact with distinct steroid binding sites.     

Analysis of the glucocorticoid receptor during differentiation of 3T3-F442A preadipocyte cell line in culture

A pure glucocorticoid agonist RU 28362 and the potent antagonist RU 38486 were compared with dexamethasone for the evolution and the molecular nature of the GR during insulin-dependent conversion of 3T3-F442A preadipocytes into mature cells. In the whole cell assay system, the affinity for preadipocyte GR was observed in the order RU 38486 greater than RU 28362 greater than dexamethasone. The GR complex was most stable in presence of dexamethasone followed by the antagonist RU 38486 = the agonist RU 28362. Similar results were obtained in mature adipocytes but the binding of RU 38486 was more equivocal. An insulin-dependent differentiation process did not alter any of these parameters but increased the number of GR nearly fivefold over a 2-week period. Ion-exchange analysis of the cytosolic receptor revealed that the differentiation process was not accompanied by the appearance of any novel or new forms of GR, contrary to the situation in the liver, since both RU 38486 and dexamethasone were bound to identical molecular species of GR. These data provide a defined system for further analysis of cellular receptor as a function of steroid, tissue, and species, contrary to the classical dogma where GR is generally thought to be identical as a passive vehicle for the steroid in all circumstances, and affinity for steroid is generally equated with receptor stability.     

Affinity of interactions between human glucocorticoid receptors and DNA: at physiologic ionic strength, stable binding occurs only with DNAs containing partially symmetric glucocorticoid response elements

Sucrose density gradient shift assays were adapted to permit determination of the affinity of interaction between human glucocorticoid receptors (GR) and DNA under conditions of DNA excess. Saturation analyses were performed to ascertain dissociation constants for the interaction of activated human GR with each of five DNA fragments. Centrifugation of GR-DNA complexes on sucrose gradients under nearly isotonic salt conditions revealed similar affinities with dissociation constants in the range of 2-16 nM for GR interaction with DNA fragments containing glucocorticoid response elements (GREs) exhibiting partial dyad symmetry. By contrast, GR exhibited virtually no affinity for non-GRE-containing DNA or for DNA containing only GRE half-sites. Additionally, GR showed evidence of multiple-site interaction with a DNA fragment containing two partially symmetric GREs, but interacted at only one site of an MMTV LTR DNA fragment containing a single partially symmetric GRE along with a cluster of three half-GREs. Together these data indicate that under physiologically relevant conditions, glucocorticoid receptors have high selectivity and affinity only for DNA containing specific partially symmetric GREs and further suggest that this high affinity for such DNA sites may be sufficient to account for the selective regulation of gene expression observed in glucocorticoid-responsive cells.     

Analysis of the relation between receptor binding affinity and antagonist efficacy of antiglucocorticoids

The biological potencies of four antiglucocorticoids, RU486 (RU), dexamethasone-oxetanone (DOX), R5020, and progesterone have been studied with respect to dexamethasone induction of tyrosine aminotransferase (TAT) in rat hepatoma tissue culture (HTC) cells. Their inhibitory effects in whole-cell competition binding studies (at 37 degrees C) and in TAT induction studies were analyzed by Dixon plots and Schild plots, respectively. We show that: In both cases, there is an actual competition of each antiglucocorticoid with the agonist dexamethasone for the same binding site; the two Kd values derived from the two plots are almost identical for each antiglucocorticoid; RU486 can be distinguished from the three other antiglucocorticoids by its high biological efficacy and its high affinity for the glucocorticoid receptor in whole cells at 37 degrees C (identical to its affinity in cytosol at 0 degree C). These results imply that: There is a linear correlation between the antagonist efficacies of antiglucocorticoids and their affinities for the glucocorticoid receptor in whole cells at 37 degrees C; the antagonistic action is solely mediated by competition with the agonist for the receptor binding site; this is verified by the fact that in all cases, in the presence or absence of antiglucocorticoids, a specific TAT induction level was always related to the same level of receptor saturation by the agonist in whole cells; the phenomena responsible for the high antagonist efficacy of RU486 are also responsible for its high affinity in whole cells at 37 degrees C.     

Evaluation of the role of ligand and thermal activation of specific DNA binding by in vitro synthesized human glucocorticoid receptor

We have used a DNA-binding/immunoprecipitation assay to analyze the capacity of human glucocorticoid receptor (hGR), generated in rabbit reticulocyte lysates, to bind DNA. In vitro translated hGR was indistinguishable from native hGR, as determined by migration on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels, sedimentation on sucrose density gradients, and reactivity with antipeptide antibodies generated against hGR. In addition, cell-free synthesized hGR was capable of specific binding to glucocorticoid response element (GRE)-containing DNA fragments. Using this assay system, we have evaluated the contributions of ligand binding and heat activation to DNA binding by these glucocorticoid receptors. In vitro translated hGR was capable of selective DNA binding even in the absence of glucocorticoid. Treatment with dexamethasone or the antiglucocorticoid RU486 had no additional effect on the DNA-binding capacity when receptor preparations were maintained at 0 C (no activation). In contrast, addition of either ligand or antagonist in combination with a heat activation step promoted DNA binding by approximately 3-fold over that of heat-activated unliganded receptors. Agonist (dexamethasone) was slightly more effective in supporting specific DNA binding than antagonist (RU486). DNA binding by in vitro synthesized GR was blocked by the addition of sodium molybdate to the receptor preparations before steroid addition and thermal activation. Addition of KCl resulted in less DNA binding either due to blockage of DNA-receptor complex formation or disruption of the complexes. The specificity of DNA binding by cell-free synthesized hGR was analyzed further by examining the abilities of various DNAs to compete for binding to a naturally occurring GRE found in the mouse mammary tumor virus-long terminal repeat. Oligonucleotides containing the consensus GRE were the most efficient competitors, and fragments containing regulatory sequences from glucocorticoid-repressible genes were somewhat competitive, whereas single stranded oligonucleotides were unable to compete for mouse mammary tumor virus-long terminal repeat DNA binding, except when competitor was present at extremely high concentrations. Together these studies indicate that hGR synthesized in rabbit reticulocyte lysates displays many of the same properties, including GRE-specific DNA binding, observed for glucocorticoid receptor present in cytosolic extracts of mammalian cells and tissues. Similarities between the effects of dexamethasone and RU486 suggest that the antiglucocorticoid properties of RU486 do not occur at the level of specific DNA binding.     

Inhibition of the production of mediators of inflammation by corticosteroids is a glucocorticoid receptor-mediated process

In order to find an explanation for corticosteroid resistance we assessed whether inhibition by dexamethasone (DEX) of the stimulated production of TNF- proportional, variant, IL-6, PGE(2) and LTB(4) by peripheral blood mononuclear cells (MNC) depends on binding to the glucocorticoid receptor (GR), and whether it is determined by the number or the affinity of the GR of these cells. GR number and affinity of MNC were determined by means of a whole cell DEX binding assay. MNC were incubated with DEX and LPS or A23187 in the absence or presence of RU486, a potent steroid antagonist. DEX caused a concentration dependent inhibition of TNF- proportional, variant, IL-6 and PGE(2) production but had no effect on LTB(4) production. RU486 significantly blocked the effect of DEX, but no correlations were found between the inhibition of mediator release and the K(d) or receptor number.     

Role of activation function domain-1, DNA binding, and coactivator GRIP1 in the expression of partial agonist activity of glucocorticoid receptor-antagonist complexes

The determinants of the partial agonist activity of most antisteroids complexed with steroid receptors are not well understood. We now examine the role of the N-terminal half of the glucocorticoid receptor (GR) including the activation domain (AF-1), the DNA binding site sequence, receptor contact with DNA, and coactivator binding on the expression of partial agonist activity in two cell lines for GRs bound by five antiglucocorticoids: dexamethasone mesylate (Dex-Mes), dexamethasone oxetanone (Dex-Ox), progesterone (Prog), deoxycorticosterone (DOC), and RU486. Using truncated GRs, we find that the N-terminal half of GR and the AF-1 domain are dispensable for the partial agonist activity of antiglucocorticoids. This contrasts with the AF-1 domain being required for the partial agonist activity of antisteroids with most steroid receptors. DNA sequence (MMTV vs a simple GRE enhancer) and cell-specific factors (CV-1 vs Cos-7) exert minor effects on the level of partial agonist activity. Small activity differences for some complexes of GAL4/GR chimeras with GR- vs GAL-responsive reporters suggest a contribution of DNA-induced conformational changes. A role for steroid-regulated coactivator binding to GRs is compatible with the progressively smaller increase in partial agonist activity of Dex-Mes > Prog > RU486 with added GRIP1 in CV-1 cells. This hypothesis is consistent with titration experiments, where low concentrations of GRIP1 more effectively increase the partial agonist activity of Dex-Mes than Prog complexes. Furthermore, ligand-dependent GRIP1 binding to DNA-bound GR complexes decreases in the order of Dex > Dex-Mes > Prog > RU486. Thus, the partial agonist activity of a given GR-steroid complex in CV-1 cells correlates with its cell-free binding of GRIP1. The ability to modify the levels of partial agonist activity through changes in steroid structure, DNA sequence, specific DNA-induced conformational changes, and coactivator binding suggests that useful variations in endocrine therapies may be possible by the judicious selection of these parameters to afford gene and tissue selective results.     

The glucocorticoid receptor is increased in Atm-/- thymocytes and in Atm-/- thymic lymphoma cells, and its nuclear translocation counteracts c-myc expression

We have previously demonstrated that spontaneous DNA synthesis in immature thymocytes of Atm-/- mice is elevated, and that treatment with the glucocorticoid dexamethasone (Dex) attenuates this increased DNA synthesis and prevents the development of thymic lymphomas. Deregulation of c-myc may drive the uncontrolled proliferation of Atm-/- thymocytes, since upregulation of c-myc parallels the elevated DNA synthesis in the cells. In this study, we show that the glucocorticoid receptor (GR) is expressed at high levels in Atm-/- thymocytes and in Atm-/- thymic lymphoma cells, although serum glucocorticoid (GC) levels in Atm-/- mice are similar to those in Atm+/+ mice. In cultured Atm-/- thymic lymphoma cells treated with Dex, GR nuclear translocation occurs, resulting in suppression of DNA synthesis and c-myc expression at both the mRNA and protein levels. Interestingly, the GR antagonist RU486 also causes GR nuclear translocation, but does not affect DNA synthesis and c-myc expression in Atm-/- thymic lymphoma cells. As expected, RU486 reverses the suppressive effects of Dex on DNA synthesis and c-myc expression. Administration of Dex to Atm-/- mice decreases the elevated c-Myc protein levels in their thymocytes. These findings suggest that GC/GR signaling plays an important role in regulating c-myc expression in Atm-/- thymocytes and thymic lymphoma cells.     

Trifluoromethyl group as a pharmacophore: effect of replacing a CF3 group on binding and agonist activity of a glucocorticoid receptor ligand

Compound 1, a potent glucocorticoid receptor ligand, contains a quaternary carbon bearing trifluoromethyl and hydroxyl groups. This paper describes the effect of replacing the trifluoromethyl group on binding and agonist activity of the GR ligand 1. The results illustrate that replacing the CF3 group with a cyclohexylmethyl or benzyl group maintains the GR binding potency. These substitutions alter the functional behavior of the GR ligands from agonists to antagonists. Docking studies suggest that the benzyl analog 19 binds in a similar fashion as the GR antagonist, RU486. The central benzyl group of 19 and the C-11 dimethylaniline moiety of RU486 overlay. Binding of compound 19 is believed to force helix 12 to adopt an open conformation and this leads to the antagonist properties of the non-CF3 ligands carrying a large group at the center of the molecule.     

Evidence from pulse-chase labeling studies that the antiglucocorticoid hormone RU486 stabilizes the nonactivated form of the glucocorticoid receptor in mouse lymphoma cells

A pulse-chase labeling technique was used to determine the properties of glucocorticoid receptors occupied by the antiglucocorticoid hormone RU486 in S49.1 mouse lymphoma cells. Cells were pulse-labeled with [35S]methionine and then at the beginning of the chase, either no hormone (control), dexamethasone, or RU486 was added to cells. At 4 h into the chase, cytosol was prepared and receptors were immunoadsorbed to protein A-Sepharose using the BuGR2 antireceptor antibody. Immunoadsorbed proteins were resolved by gel electrophoresis and analyzed by autoradiography. The 90 kDa heat shock protein (hsp90) coimmunoadsorbed with receptors from control cells when protein A-Sepharose pellets were washed with 250 mM NaCl but not when protein A-Sepharose pellets were washed with 500 mM NaCl, indicating that hsp90-receptor complexes are disrupted by a high concentration of salt in the absence of molybdate. hsp90 coimmunoadsorbed with receptors from RU486-treated cells even when protein A-Sepharose pellets were washed with 500 mM NaCl, indicating that RU486 stabilizes the association of hsp90 with the glucocorticoid receptor. In contrast, hsp90 did not coimmunoadsorb with receptors from dexamethasone-treated cells, consistent with earlier evidence that hsp90 dissociates from the receptor when the receptor binds glucocorticoid hormone. Dexamethasone induced a rapid quantum decrease in the amount of normal receptor recovered from cytosol but did not induce a decrease in the amount of nuclear transfer deficient receptor recovered from cytosol, consistent with tight nuclear binding of normal receptors occupied by dexamethasone. In contrast, RU486 did not induce a quantum decrease in the recovery of normal receptors from cytosol, indicating that receptors occupied by RU486 are not tightly bound in the nuclear fraction. We conclude that the antiglucocorticoid hormone RU486, in contrast to the glucocorticoid hormone dexamethasone, stabilizes the association between the glucocorticoid receptor and hsp90. The decreased affinity of receptors occupied by RU486 for the nuclear fraction may be due to their association with hsp90 and may account for the failure of RU486 to exert agonist activity.