Growth and elimination of nerve terminals at synaptic sites during polyneuronal innervation of muscle cells: a trophic hypothesis

This paper examines the possibility that the elimination of synapses from cells arises from a competition between the nerve terminals for trophic molecules made available by the cells. This idea is applied to the elimination of synapses that occurs during the polyneuronal innervation of muscle cells which accompanies both the development and reinnervation of muscles. In the proposed model, each motorneuron makes the same amount of receptor in its soma for a trophic molecule provided in limited quantities by each muscle cell; this receptor is then distributed to the collateral terminals of the motorneuron in concentrations proportional to the amount of receptor made in the soma by the motorneuron; the more collateral terminals initially possessed by a motorneuron the less will be their concentration of receptor. The receptors in the several collateral terminals on a muscle cell then compete for the trophic molecule provided by the muscle, and terminal growth is proportional to the number of receptor-trophic-molecule bonds formed. An autocatalytic effect has been introduced whereby the increase in size of a terminal accelerates the rate by which the trophic molecule is made available to that terminal for bonding with its receptors. In addition, the affinity between nerve terminal receptors and muscle molecules can be varied in the model. Finally, motorneuron cell death has been analysed as the elimination of neurons that have insufficient terminal area to take up a growth factor in amounts that will allow for the survival of the neuron.     

Activity and synapse elimination at the neuromuscular junction

The neuromuscular junction undergoes a loss of synaptic connections during early development. This loss converts the innervation of each muscle fiber from polyneuronal to single. During this change the number of motor neurons remains constant but the number of muscle fibers innervated by each motor neuron is reduced. Evidence indicates that a local competition among the inputs on each muscle fiber determines which inputs are eliminated. The role of synapse elimination in the development of neuromuscular circuits, other than ensuring a single innervation of each fiber, is unclear. Most evidence suggests that the elimination plays little or no role in correcting for errant connections. Rather, it seems that connections are initially highly specific, in terms of both which motor neurons connect to which muscles and which neurons connect to which particular fibers within these muscles. A number of attempts have been made to determine the importance of neuromuscular activity during early development for this rearrangement of synaptic connections. Experiments reducing neuromuscular activity by muscle tenotomy, deafferentation and spinal cord section, block of nerve impulse conduction with tetrodotoxin, and the use of postsynaptic and presynaptic blocking agents have all shown that normal activity is required for normal synapse elimination. Most experiments in which complete muscle paralysis has been achieved show that activity may be essential for the occurrence of synapse elimination. Furthermore, experiments in which neuromuscular activity has been augmented by external stimulation show that synapse elimination is accelerated. A plausible hypothesis to explain the activity dependence of neuromuscular synapse elimination is that a neuromuscular trophic agent is produced by the muscle fibers and that this production is controlled by muscle-fiber activity. The terminals on each fiber compete for the substance produced by that fiber. Inactive fibers produce large quantities of this substance; on the other hand, muscle activity suppresses the level of synthesis of this agent to the point where only a single synaptic terminal can be maintained. Inactive muscle fibers would be expected to be able to maintain more nerve terminals. The attractiveness of this scheme is that it provides a simple feedback mechanism to ensure that each fiber retains a single effective input.     

Poly- and mononeuronal innervation in a model for the development of neuromuscular connections

In the normal development of connections between motor neurons and muscle fibres, an initial stage of polyneuronal innervation is followed by withdrawal of connections until each muscle fibre is innervated by a single axon. However, polyneuronal innervation has been found to persist after prolonged nerve conduction block, in spite of the resumption of normal neuromuscular activity. Here we analyse in detail a model proposed for the withdrawal of nerve connections in developing muscle, based on competition between nerve terminals. The model combines competition for a pre-synaptic resource with competition for a post-synaptic resource. Using bifurcation and phase space analysis, we show that polyneuronal innervation, as well as mononeuronal innervation, can be stable. The model accounts for the development of mononeuronal innervation and for persistent polyneuronal innervation after prolonged nerve conduction block, which appears as a consequence of the general competitive interactions operating during normal development.     

Effects of evoked and spontaneous motoneuronal firing on synapse competition and elimination in skeletal muscle

Synapse elimination is a general feature of the development of neural connections, including the connections of motoneurons to skeletal muscle fibers. Our work addressed two questions: (1) how the action potentials generated in the set of motoneurons innervating an individual muscle (i.e., in a motor pool) are correlated in time during development in vivo; (2) what influence different firing patterns exert on the processes of polyneuronal innervation and synapse elimination which characterize the establishment of muscle innervation. We recorded the spontaneous electromyographic activity of the tibialis anterior and soleus muscles of late embryonic and neonatal rats, identifying the firing of at least two single motor unit signals in each record. We found that a striking switch occurs a few days after birth from a highly synchronous type of firing to an asynchronous one, the first thus characterizing embryonic while the second one adult motoneurons. We also investigated the effects of an evoked synchronous type of discharge on neuromuscular synapse formation, measuring polyneuronal innervation and synapse elimination. This was done in an adult in vivo model of de novo synapse formation, while a chronic TTX nerve conduction block, placed centrally with respect to the stimulating electrodes, eliminated the natural activity of motoneurons. We found that the imposed synchronous activity greatly inhibits synapse elimination, causing polyneuronal innervation to persist. We conclude that the early synchronous firing, favors the establishment of polyneuronal innervation while the subsequent switch to an asynchronous one promotes synapse elimination.     

Synaptic competition and the elimination of polyneuronal innervation follwoing reinnervation of adult frog sartorius muscles

The elimination of polyneuronal innervation (synapse elimination) that occurs following reinnervation was studied in sartorius muscles of adult Rana pipiens. The percentage of neuromuscular junctions that were polyneuronally innervated declined from 47% at 40–80 days after nerve crush to 22% at greater than 250 days after nerve crush. We measured the size, synaptic strength, and position of competing nerve terminals at identified dually innervated neuromuscular junctions at these two different periods of synapse elimination. Our goal was to determine if any of these parameters play a role in the competition between nerve terminals that ultimately results in the elimination of polyneuronal innervation. Our data support the hypothesis that polyneuronal innervation will persist if competing nerve terminals are of similar synaptic efficacies but will be eliminated if the competing terminals are of different synaptic efficacies. We also tested, but failed to find any evidence, that the spatial proximity of competing nerve terminals at the same synaptic site influences the elimination of polyneuronal innervation.     

Synaptic competition and the elimination of polyneuronal innervation following reinnervation of adult frog sartorius muscles

The elimination of polyneuronal innervation (synapse elimination) that occurs following reinnervation was studied in sartorius muscles of adult Rana pipiens. The percentage of neuromuscular junctions that were polyneuronally innervated declined from 47% at 40-80 days after nerve crush to 22% at greater than 250 days after nerve crush. We measured the size, synaptic strength, and position of competing nerve terminals at identified dually innervated neuromuscular junctions at these two different periods of synapse elimination. Our goal was to determine if any of these parameters play a role in the competition between nerve terminals that ultimately results in the elimination of polyneuronal innervation. Our data support the hypothesis that polyneuronal innervation will persist if competing nerve terminals are of similar synaptic efficacies but will be eliminated if the competing terminals are of different synaptic efficacies. We also tested, but failed to find any evidence, that the spatial proximity of competing nerve terminals at the same synaptic site influences the elimination of polyneuronal innervation.     

Postmetamorphic development of neuromuscular junctions and muscle fibers in the frog cutaneous pectoris

Synaptic size, synaptic remodelling, polyneuronal innervation, and synaptic efficacy of neuromuscular junctions were studied as a function of growth in cutaneous pectoris muscles of postmetamorphic Rana pipiens. Recently metamorphosed frogs grew rapidly, and this growth was accompanied by hypertrophy of muscle fibers, myogenesis, and increases in the size and complexity of neuromuscular junctions. There were pronounced gradients in pre- and postsynaptic size across the width of the muscle, with neuromuscular junctions and muscle fibers near the medial edge being smaller than in more lateral regions. The incidence of polyneuronal innervation, measured physiologically and histologically, was also higher near the medial edge. Growth-associated declines in all measures of polyneuronal innervation indicated that synapse elimination occurs throughout life. Electrophysiology also demonstrated regional differences in synaptic efficacy and showed that doubly innervated junctions have lower synaptic efficacy than singly innervated junctions. Repeated, in vivo observations revealed extensive growth and remodelling of motor nerve terminals and confirmed that synapse elimination is a slow process. It was concluded that some processes normally associated with embryonic development persist long into adulthood in frog muscles.     

Mechanisms of elimination, remodeling, and competition at frog neuromuscular junctions

Mechanisms governing synapse elimination, synaptic remodeling, and polyneuronal innervation were examined in anatomical and electrophysiological studies of frog neuromuscular junctions. There was a substantial level of polyneuronal innervation in adult junctions and this varied seasonally. Nerve terminal retraction and synapse elimination occurred during normal growth and following reinnervation. Synapse elimination was not inevitable, however. Repeated in vivo observations of some identified junctions showed that polyneuronal innervation could persist for over a year, while at other junctions it arose de novo by terminal sprouting. We concluded that polyneuronal innervation in adult muscles was governed by an equilibrium between processes of retraction and elimination on one hand, and sprouting and synaptogenesis on the other. Other observations revealed that structural remodeling was a common feature of adult junctions. Most often, remodeling involved the simultaneous growth and retraction of different parts of the same junction. The net result was usually junctional growth that, in small frogs, appeared to provide a good match between synaptic size and the electrical demands of transmission. In larger animals, pre- and postsynaptic sizes were not as well matched, providing morphological evidence for a growth-associated decline in synaptic efficacy. Finally, electrophysiology was used to describe some of the functional correlates and consequences of competitive interactions between the terminals of different axons. These results are explained by a hypothetical mechanism that involves trophic support provided by the muscle to the motoneuron, the overall level of nerve-muscle activity, and the synchrony of pre- and postsynaptic activity.     

Absence of competitive interactions among axon terminals of regenerating motor neurons

Competition among axon terminals is usually considered to contribute to the formation of patterned synaptic connections. During axonal regeneration of motor neurons in the cockroach, leg muscles initially become innervated by appropriate and inappropriate motor neurons. All axon terminals from inappropriate neurons eventually are eliminated, resulting in the reformation of the original innervation pattern. Destruction of an identified motor neuron by the intracellular injection of pronase did not prevent the elimination of inappropriate axon terminals in the muscle normally innervated by that motor neuron. Therefore, competition does not play a role in the reinnervation of the leg muscles. This indicates a major role for specific cell-cell recognition.     

Synaptic competition and the persistence of polyneuronal innervation at frog neuromuscular junctions

Mechanisms governing the elimination of polyneuronal innervation were examined by correlating the morphology and physiology of competing nerve terminals at identified dually innervated neuromuscular junctions in sartorius muscles of adult frogs (Rana pipiens). Synaptic efficacy (endplate potential amplitude per unit nerve terminal length) was presumed to reflect the ability of a terminal to compete for synaptic space. The synaptic efficacies of two terminals at the same synaptic site were found to be surprisingly equal, with a median difference of 33%. Much more variation would be expected if dually innervated junctions were randomly innervated by pairs of terminals having the same range of synaptic efficacy as that found at singly innervated junctions in the same muscle. This finding supports the hypothesis that the weaker input is eliminated from dually innervated junctions when there is a large discrepancy in competitive efficacy, and that both inputs may persist if competitive efficacies are relatively equal. We also tested but failed to find support for the hypothesis that spatial proximity between competing terminals intensifies competition for synaptic space during synapse elimination.     

Dual motor innervation in the axial musculature of fishes

A systematic survey of motor innervation in the myotomal muscle fibres in several groups of fishes was conducted to observe the extent of dual innervation, a phenomenon found within those myotomal muscle fibres with terminal innervation. It is concluded that the dually innervated myotomal muscle fibre is a primitive vertebrate feature. Furthermore, it is suggested that this particular form of polyneuronal innervation is retained in the course of neural evolution within the homogeneous white myotomal muscle fibre region in these fish groups in order to insure synchrony of firing during sudden, rapid locomotion. The findings are examined in light of current ideas regarding the direct adrenergic innervation in addition to cholinergic innervation of striated muscle fibres.     

Synapse elimination by fiber type and maturational state in rabbit soleus muscle

We have compared the development of fast and slow motor innervation in the neonatal rabbit soleus, a muscle which contains two distinct motor unit types during the early period of polyneuronal innervation. The innervation state of individual muscle fibers was ascertained using an intracellular electrode; a fluorescent dye was then injected into particular fibers to permit subsequent identification of histochemical type. We found no significant difference in the time course of synapse elimination for fast and slow motor units as judged by the percentage of fibers remaining polyneuronally innervated at two ages: 7-8 days, when most fibers are multiply innervated, and 10-11 days, when the level of polyinnervation is low. In a second experiment, we examined a phenomenon in which compound end-plate potentials were occasionally seen in muscle fibers at an age (17-23 days) well past the major episode of synapse elimination. We present evidence that this apparent polyinnervation in fact derives from an electrode-induced electrical coupling artifact and that genuinely polyinnervated fibers are very rare at this stage, if present at all.     

Elevated levels of polyneuronal innervation persist for as long as two years in reinnervated frog neuromuscular junctions

When the nerve to an adult frog sartorius muscle is crushed, and axons are allowed to regenerate, the level of polyneuronal innervation at reinnervated neuromuscular junctions is higher than normal. With time, much of this polyneuronal innervation is reduced by the process of synapse elimination (Werle and Herrera, 1988). Using intracellular recording, we estimated the level of polyneuronal innervation in adult frog (Rana pipiens) sartorius muscles 2 years (range: 1.7-2.4 years) after crushing the sartorius nerve. We found that 27% (S.E. = 1.4%) of the junctions in muscles 2 years after reinnervation were polyneuronally innervated, whereas only 10% (S.E. = 1.2%) of the junctions in normal frog muscles were polyneuronally innervated. Thus, the synapse elimination that occurs following reinnervation does not restore the normal level of polyneuronal innervation. Histological comparisons of junctional structure between muscles 2 years after reinnervation and normal muscles revealed substantial differences. Reinnervated junctions had a greater length of synaptic gutter apposed by nerve terminal processes, more axonal inputs, more empty synaptic gutter, more instances of single synaptic gutters innervated by more than one axon, and longer lengths of nerve terminal processes that connect synaptic gutters within a junction. On the basis of this physiological and anatomical evidence, we conclude that nerve injury causes persistent changes in the pattern of muscle innervation.     

Glial cell-line derived neurotrophic factor-dependent fusimotor neuron survival during development

Glial cell-line derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) is a potent survival factor for motor neurons. Previous studies have shown that some motor neurons depend upon GDNF during development but this GDNF-dependent motor neuron subpopulation has not been characterized. We examined GDNF expression patterns in muscle and the impact of altered GDNF expression on the development of subtypes of motor neurons. In GDNF hemizygous mice, motor neuron innervation to muscle spindle stretch receptors (fusimotor neuron innervation) was decreased, whereas in transgenic mice that overexpress GDNF in muscle, fusimotor innervation to muscle spindles was increased. Facial motor neurons, which do not contain fusimotor neurons, were not changed in number when GDNF was over expressed by facial muscles during their development. Taken together, these data indicate that fusimotor neurons depend upon GDNF for survival during development. Since the fraction of cervical and lumbar motor neurons lost in GDNF-deficient mice at birth closely approximates the size of the fusimotor neuron pool, these data suggest that motor neuron loss in GDNF-deficient mice may be primarily of fusimotor neuron origin.     

Trophic interrelations at the neuromuscular junction as revealed by the use of botulinal neurotoxins

1. From denervation studies the trophic influence of the motor nerve on the muscle cell is well documented while little is known about the influence of the muscle on the nerve. Sectioning the axon invariably destroys the nerve terminals and produces nerve degeneration products which themselves may affect nerve and muscle properties. With regard to those difficulties we believe that the botulinal neurotoxins (BoTx) are valuable complements to denervation since they selectively interrupt impulse transmission across the synapse without damaging its morphology. 2. Paralysis of mouse or rat skeletal muscle in vivo with BoTx type A causes marked growth of motor nerve terminals. The sprouting terminals are rich in large dense-core synaptic vesicles containing various neuropeptides and they spontaneously release large quanta of ACh. Thus, it appears that paralysis by BoTx is a strong stimulus for motor nerve growth and the delivery of "trophic" substances to the nerve terminals. 3. Postsynaptically, in extrajunctional areas, paralysis by BoTx induces all the changes observed following denervation, i.e. atrophy, appearance of extra-junctional ACh receptors, TTX-resistant action potentials, a fall of resting membrane potential, fibrillation potentials and the disappearance of extrajunctional acetylcholinesterase activity. Endplate properties are, however, largely maintained. 4. BoTx blockade delays and prevents the retraction of polyneuronal innervation and motoneurone death during development. This supports the suggestion that the paralysed muscle secretes factors essential for growth and for the survival of motoneurones. 5. Like denervated muscle, BoTx paralysed ones, express a high endocytotic activity restricted to a segment in the endplate region.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Selective stabilization of muscle innervation during development: A mathematical model

The biochemical model presented concerns a critical step of the development of skeletal muscle innervation. After invasion of the muscle by exploratory motor axons, several nerve terminals converge from different motoneurons onto each muscle fibre at a single endplate. During the folloing weeks the redundant innervation disappears: a single nerve ending per muscle fibre becomes stabilized. The model is based on the assumption that the numbers of motoneurons and of muscle fibres remain constant during this evolution and that the selective stabilization of the adult connectivity results from the competition of the active nerve terminals for a postsynaptic retrograde factor μ. At the peak of the multiple innervation, the synthesis of μ by the muscle fiber stops, possibly as a consequence of muscle electrical and/or mechanical activity. The stock of μ becomes limited; a retrograde trans-synaptic diffusion of μ from the muscle to the nerve endings takes place. Within each nerve ending, μ enters into a chemical autocatalytic reaction which results in the production of a presynaptic stabilization factor s. The nerve impulses reaching the nerve terminal initiate this reaction. Any given nerve terminal become stabilized when the concentration of s reaches a threshold value. The mathematical analysis of the model shows that there exists a unique solution which is physically acceptable. Its application and computer simulation predict that only one nerve terminal becomes stabilized per muscle fibre. The model accounts for the experimental observations that the reduction in size of the motor units is not necessarily accompanied by a reduction in the variability of their size. The model also accounts for the acceleration or delay in regression which follows modifications of the chronic activity of the nerve endings and for the variability of the pattern of innervation observed in isogenic organisms. Plausible biochemical hypotheses concerning the factors engaged in the “selective stabilization” of the nerve-endings are discussed.     

Transplantation of Xenopus laevis Tissues to Determine the Ability of Motor Neurons to Acquire a Novel Target

The evolutionary origin of novelties is a central problem in biology. At a cellular level this requires, for example, molecularly resolving how brainstem motor neurons change their innervation target from muscle fibers (branchial motor neurons) to neural crest-derived ganglia (visceral motor neurons) or ear-derived hair cells (inner ear and lateral line efferent neurons). Transplantation of various tissues into the path of motor neuron axons could determine the ability of any motor neuron to innervate a novel target. Several tissues that receive direct, indirect, or no motor innervation were transplanted into the path of different motor neuron populations in Xenopus laevis embryos. Ears, somites, hearts, and lungs were transplanted to the orbit, replacing the eye. Jaw and eye muscle were transplanted to the trunk, replacing a somite. Applications of lipophilic dyes and immunohistochemistry to reveal motor neuron axon terminals were used. The ear, but not somite-derived muscle, heart, or liver, received motor neuron axons via the oculomotor or trochlear nerves. Somite-derived muscle tissue was innervated, likely by the hypoglossal nerve, when replacing the ear. In contrast to our previous report on ear innervation by spinal motor neurons, none of the tissues (eye or jaw muscle) was innervated when transplanted to the trunk. Taken together, these results suggest that there is some plasticity inherent to motor innervation, but not every motor neuron can become an efferent to any target that normally receives motor input. The only tissue among our samples that can be innervated by all motor neurons tested is the ear. We suggest some possible, testable molecular suggestions for this apparent uniqueness.     

Muscles in a mouse model of spinal muscular atrophy show profound defects in neuromuscular development even in the absence of failure in neuromuscular transmission or loss of motor neurons

A mouse model of the devastating human disease "spinal muscular atrophy" (SMA) was used to investigate the severe muscle weakness and spasticity that precede the death of these animals near the end of the 2nd postnatal week. Counts of motor units to the soleus muscle as well as of axons in the soleus muscle nerve showed no loss of motor neurons. Similarly, neither immunostaining of neuromuscular junctions nor the measurement of the tension generated by nerve stimulation gave evidence of any significant impairment in neuromuscular transmission, even when animals were maintained up to 5days longer via a supplementary diet. However, the muscles were clearly weaker, generating less than half their normal tension. Weakness in 3 muscles examined in the study appears due to a severe but uniform reduction in muscle fiber size. The size reduction results from a failure of muscle fibers to grow during early postnatal development and, in soleus, to a reduction in number of fibers generated. Neuromuscular development is severely delayed in these mutant animals: expression of myosin heavy chain isoforms, the elimination of polyneuronal innervation, the maturation in the shape of the AChR plaque, the arrival of SCs at the junctions and their coverage of the nerve terminal, the development of junctional folds. Thus, if SMA in this particular mouse is a disease of motor neurons, it can act in a manner that does not result in their death or disconnection from their targets but nonetheless alters many aspects of neuromuscular development.     

Gap junctional communication among motor and other neurons shapes patterns of neural activity and synaptic connectivity during development

We are studying the functional roles of neuronal gap junctional coupling during development, using motor neurons and their synapses with muscle fibers as a model system. At neuromuscular synapses, several studies have shown that the relative pattern of activity among motor inputs competing for innervation of the same target muscle fiber determines how patterns of innervation are sculpted during the first weeks after birth. We asked whether gap junctional coupling among motor neurons modulates the relative timing of motor neuron activity in awake, behaving neonatal mice. We found that the activity of motor neurons innervating the same muscle is temporally correlated perinatally, during the same period that gap junction-mediated electrical and dye coupling are present. In vivo blockade of gap junctions abolished temporal correlations in motor neuron activity, without changing overall motor behavior, motor neuron activity patterns or firing frequency. Together with preliminary studies in mice lacking gap junction protein Cx40, our data suggest that developmentally regulated gap junctional coupling among motor and other neurons affects the activity in nascent neural circuits and thus in turn affects synaptic connectivity. Dynamic monitoring of dye coupling can be used to explore this possibility in normal mice and in mice lacking gap junction proteins during embryonic and neonatal development.     

Synapse elimination occurs late in the hormone-sensitive levator ani muscle of the rat

Using tetranitroblue tetrazolium (TNBT) to stain neuromuscular synapses, we compared the development of the adult pattern of innervation in two fast-twitch muscles in the rat: the androgen-sensitive levator ani (LA) and the extensor digitorum longus (EDL), which is not thought to be androgen sensitive. We found that about 18% of adult LA muscle fibers, but only about 2% of adult EDL fibers, are multiply innervated. Moreover, synapse elimination occurs substantially later in the LA compared with the EDL. At 2 weeks after birth, the EDL is already predominantly singly innervated, whereas the LA is still predominantly multiply innervated. The apparent delay in the normal time course of synapse elimination in the LA corresponds to a similar delay in other aspects of neuromuscular development (the time course of appearance of axonal retraction bulbs, the growth of fibers, and the development of adult motor terminal morphology). Finally, motor terminals change during synapse elimination from morphologies resembling growth cones to the adult form of neuromuscular synapses. Because the period of synapse elimination is significantly different for muscles that differ in their androgen sensitivity, hormonal sensitivity may represent an important property of motoneurons or muscle fibers influencing the normal time course of neuromuscular synapse elimination in rats. Thus, androgen might regulate the normal ontogenetic process of synapse elimination.