The comparative specificity of the inner and outer substrate transfer sites in the choline carrier of human erythrocytes

Summary The substrate specificities on the inner and outer surfaces of the cell membrane have been compared by determining the relative affinities, inside and outside, of a series of choline analogs. The results of two different methods were in agreement: (1) the carrier distribution was determined in the presence of a saturating concentration of an equilibrated analog, using N-ethylmaleimide as a probe for the inward-facing carrier; (2) the degree of competition was measured between an equilibrated analog and choline in the external solution. The carrier sites are found to have markedly different specificities: the outer site is more closely complementary to the structure of choline than is the inner, and even a slight enlargement of either the trimethylammonium or hydroxyethyl group gives rise to preferential binding inside. It is also found that a nonpolar binding region, which is adjacent to the outer site, is absent from the inner site. As the transport mechanism involves the exposure of only one site at a time, first on one surface and then the other, it follows that an extensive reorganization of the structure of the substrate site may occur during the carrier-reorientation step, or alternatively that two distinct sites may be present, only one of which is exposed at a time.     

Apparent noncompetitive inhibition of choline transport in erythrocytes by inhibitors bound at the substrate site

Summary According to the conventional carrier model, an inhibitor bound at the substrate transfer site inhibits competitively when on the same side of the membrane as the substrate, but noncompetitively when on the opposite side. This prediction was tested with the nonpenetrating choline analog dimethyl-n-pentyl (2-hydroxyethyl) ammonium ion. In zerotrans entry and infinitetrans entry experiments, where the labeled substrate and the inhibitor occupy the same compartment, the inhibition was competitive, but in zerotrans exit it was noncompetitive, in accord with the model. Similar behavior was seen with dimethyl-n-decyl (2-hydroxyethyl) ammonium ion. With this property of the choline transport system established, it becomes possible to estimate the relative affinity inside and outside of inhibitors present on both sides of the membrane. The tertiary amine, dibutylaminoethanol, which enters the cell by simple diffusion, is such an inhibitor. Here the inhibition kinetics were the reverse of those for nonpenetrating inhibitors; zerotrans and infinitetrans exit was inhibited competitively, and zerotrans entry noncompetitively. It follows that dibutylaminoethanol binds predominantly to the inner carrier form.     

Reaction of internal forms of the choline carrier of erythrocytes with N-ethylmaleimide: Evidence for a carrier conformational change on complex formation

Summary The choline carrier of human erythrocyte membranes exists in distinguishable outward-facing and inward-facing conformations, and previous studies demonstrated that only the latter reacts with N-ethylmaleimide, producing an irreversible inhibition of transport. We now report experiments to determine the individual reaction rates for the two inward-facing forms: the free carrier and the complex. The pseudo-first-order rate constant for the complex with a substrate analog, di-n-butylaminoethanol, is found to be nearlydouble that for the free carrier, showing that the carrier conformation is altered following addition of a ligand (with 1mm N-ethylmaleimide at pH 6.8, 37°C, the constants are 0.57±0.05 min^–1 and 0.33±0.02 min^–1, respectively). Hence three different conformational states have been distinguished by experiment: (1) the inward-facing free carrier; (2) the inward-facing complex; and (3) the outward-facing carrier.     

Evidence for a two-state mobile carrier mechanism in erythrocyte choline transport: Effects of substrate analogs on inactivation of the carrier by N-ethylmaleimide

Summary Choline transport in erythrocytes is irreversibly inhibited by N-ethylmaleimide. The hypothesis that the carrier alternates between outwardfacing and inward-facing forms and that only the latter reacts with the inhibitor (Martin, K. (1971)J. Physiol. (London) 213:647–667; Edwards, P.A. (1973)Biochim. Biophys. Acta 311:123–140) is here subjected to a quantitative test. In this test the effects of a series of substrate analogs upon rates of inactivation and rates of choline exit are compared. By hypothesis the effect of an analog in the external solution on the inactivation rate depends only on how it affects the proportion of the inward-facing carrier. Since¹⁴C-choline efflux is necessarily proportional to the concentration of free carrier in the inward-facing form, the analogs should have related effects on the two rates. In every case the observed effects were identical, whether the analogs accelerated transport or inhibited it. Analysis of the results demonstrates that (1) the transport mechanism depends on the operation of a mobile element; (2) distinguishable inward-facing and outward-facing conformations of the free carrier, carrier-substrate complex, and carrier-inhibitor complex exist, and only the inwardfacing forms react at a significant rate with N-ethylmaleimide; (3) carrier mechanisms involving a single form of free carrier or a single form of carriersubstrate complex are ruled out; and (4) dissociation of the carrier-substrate complex is a rapid step with all substrate analogs.     

The choline transport system of erythrocytes. Distribution of the free carrier in the membrane

A method is described, based on the kinetics of transport, for determining the equilibrium distribution of the carrier site on the inner and outer surfaces of the cell membrane, and this method is applied to the choline carrier of human erythrocytes. This method depends on measurement of flux ratios for both entry and exit, i.e., the transport rates of a low concentration of labeled substrate into a solution which contains either no substrate or a saturating concentration of unlabeled substrate. The concentrations of inward-facing and outward-facing carrier are found to be nearly equal, and therefore the 5-fold difference in choline affinity on the inner and outer surfaces of the membrane cannot be explained by an unequal carrier distribution. It is also shown that both reorientation and dissociation of the carrier-substrate complex are far more rapid than reorientation of the free carrier.     

The carrier reorientation step in erythrocyte choline transport: pH effects and the involvement of a carrier ionizing group

Summary Under zero-trans conditions, the facilitated transport of choline across the erythrocyte membrane is limited by the rate of reorientation of the free carrier; as a result the pH dependence of this step can be investigated, independent of other steps in transport. It is found that as the pH declines (between 8.0 and 6.0) the rate of inward movement of the free carrier rises and the rate of outward movements falls, so that the partition of the free carrier increasingly favors the inward-facing form. When the pH of the cell interior and of the medium are varied independently, the partition responds to the internal but not the external pH. The membrane potential, which varies somewhat as the pH is altered, has no effect on the carrier partition. The analysis of the results indicates that the carrier mobility is dependent on an ionizing group of pK _a 6.8, which is exposed on the cytoplasmic surface of the membrane in the inward-facing carrier; in the out-ward-facing carrier the ionizing group appears to be masked, in that its pK _a is shifted downward by more than one unit. The observations can be explained by assuming that an ionizing group is located in the wall of a gated channel connecting the substrate site with the cytoplasmic face of the cell membrane.     

Kinetics of irreversible inhibition of choline transport in synaptosomes by ethylcholine mustard aziridinium

Summary Ethylcholine mustard aziridinium (ECMA) inhibits choline transport in synaptosomes at a half-maximal concentration of about 20 m. The rate of inhibition falls off rapidly after 10 min and the concentration dependency reaches a plateau at about 100 m. The inhibition is not removed by washing the synaptosomes, and choline and hemicholinium-3 protect the carrier against attack by the mustard. Choline efflux, particularly that stimulated by choline in the medium (transactivation) is also inhibited by the aziridinium compound. Similarly choline influx activated by preloaded internal choline is inhibited by ECMA. The mustard can enter the synaptosomes in an active form but most of the carrier is alkylated when facing the outside. Prior depolarization of the synaptosomes causes an increase in the rate of inhibition by ECMA which is proportionally about the same as the increase in choline influx also caused by depolarization. At low ECMA concentrations the rate of inhibition is that of a first-order reaction with the carrier but at high ECMA concentrations the translocation of the carrier to the outward-facing conformation controls the rate of inhibition. Using a model of choline transport with some simplifying assumptions it is possible to estimate the amount of carrier; cholinergic synaptosomes carry about six times the concentration of carrier found in noncholinergic ones. In noncholinergic synaptosomes the carrier faces predominately out, the reverse in cholinergic ones. The rate constant of carrier translocation is increased by combination with choline some six- to sevenfold to about 3.5 min^–1. The rate constant of ECMA attack on the carrier is about 440m ^–1 sec^–1.     

Substitution of choline by related compounds in the diet of Argyrotaenia velutinana and Heliothis virescens

Argyrotaenia velutinana, the red-banded leaf roller, and Heliothis virescens, the tobacco budworm, both require choline for growth and development when reared on semisynthetic diets. The optimum level for A. velutinana is $\text{50 mg}\text{100 g}$ of diet whereas that for H. virescens exceeds $\text{100 mg}\text{100 g}$ of diet.No choline analog tested can adequately replace choline in the diet. One compound, dimethylethylcholine, will permit some adut emergence but development is slower and mortality is greater than on the corresponding diet containing choline. This is in sharp contrast to a number of Diptera in which mary choline analogs can not only replace choline in the diet but are also incorporated into phospholipids analogous to phosphatidylcholine.In A. velutinana, dimethylisopropylcholine and β-methylcholine, although inadequate as choline replacements, can spare the dietary choline requirement, Isopropylethanolamine is a growth inhibitor for A. velutinana but not for H. virescens.     

Reconstitution of carrier-mediated choline transport in proteoliposomes prepared from presynaptic membranes oftorpedo electric organ,and its internal and external ionic requirements

Summary Proteoliposomes made by a butanol-sonication technique from electric organ presynaptic membranes showed choline transport activity. In contrast to intact nerve terminals, the uptake of choline was dissociated from its conversion to acetylcholine in this preparation. The kinetics of choline uptake by proteoliposomes was best described by two Michaelis-Menten components. At a low concentration of choline, uptake was inhibited by hemicholinium-3 and required external Na⁺ and, thus, closely resembled high-affinity choline uptake by intact cholinergic nerve terminals. Choline transport could be driven by the Na⁺ gradient and by the transmembrane potential (inside negative) but did not directly require ATP. External Cl^–, but not a Cl^– gradient, was needed for choline transport activity. It is suggested that internal K⁺ plays a role in the retention of choline inside the proteoliposome. Proteoliposomes should prove a useful tool for both biochemical and functional studies of the highaffinity choline carrier.Abbreviations ACh acetylcholine - HC-3 hemicholinium-3 - ChAT choline acetyltransferase     

The choline carrier of erythrocytes: Location of the NEM-reactive thiol group in the inner gated channel

Summary Choline transport across the human erythrocyte membrane is irreversibly inhibited when N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) reacts with a carrier SH group which is located outside the substrate site, and which is exposed in the inward-facing form of the carrier but prevented from reacting in the outward-facing form. The location of the SH group with respect to the membrane has now been determined by studying the dependence of the NEM-alkylation rate on the intracellular and extracellular pH. The results show that the reactive SH group equilibrates with hydrogen ions in the cytoplasm, but is completely isolated from hydrogen ions in the external medium. With this added evidence it becomes possible to conclude that the SH group is located in the inner gated channel of the choline carrier.     

The binding and translocation steps in transport as related to substrate structure. A study of the choline carrier of erythrocytes

The relationships between structure, affinity and transport activity in the choline transport system of erythrocytes have been investigated in order to (i) explore the nature of the carrier site and its surroundings, and (ii) determine the dependence of the carrier reorientation process on binding energies and steric restraints due to the substrate molecule. Affinity constants and maximum transport rates for a series of trialkyl derivatives of ethanolamine were obtained by a method that involves measuring the trans effect of unlabeled analogs upon the movement of radioactive choline. The main conclusions are as follows: (1) An analysis of transport kinetics shows that the affinity constants determined experimentally differ from the actual dissociation constants in a predictable way. The better the substrate, the higher the apparent affinity relative to the true value, whereas the affinity of non-transported inhibitors is underestimated by a constant factor. (2) The carrier-choline complex undergoes far more rapid reorientation (translocation) than the free carrier. (3) The carrier imposes a strict upper limit upon the size of a substrate molecule that can participate in the carrier reorientation process; this limit corresponds to the choline structure. A smaller substrate such as tetramethylammonium, despite relatively weak binding forces, is unhindered in its translocation, suggesting that a carrier conformational change, dependent upon substrate binding energy, is not required for transport. (4) Small increases in the size of the quaternary ammonium head, as in triethylcholine, sharply lower affinity, consistent with a high degree of specificity for the trimethylammonium group. (5) Lengthening the alkyl substituent in derivatives of dimethyl- and diethylaminoethanol causes a regular increase in affinity, suggestive of unspecific hydrophobic bonding in a region very near the substrate site.     

Interaction of phenylisothiocyanates with the mitochondrial phosphate carrier. I. Covalent modification and inhibition of phosphate transport

The effects of phenylisothiocyanate (PITC) and of the polar analogue p-sulfophenylisothiocyanate (p-sulfoPITC) on the phosphate carrier of bovine heart mitochondria have been investigated. Incubation of mitochondria with the two phenylisothiocyanates leads to inhibition of the phosphate carrier protein. The inhibition of phosphate transport by PITC is unaffected by the addition of dithioerythritol (DTE) or by variation of the pH. The inhibition by p-sulfoPITC is in part removed by DTE; the remaining inactivation of the phosphate carrier, which can be attributed to the reaction with NH₂ groups, is temperature and pH-dependent. Inhibition of phosphate transport by both p-sulfoPITC and PITC depends on the time of incubation and the concentration of the inhibitor. Preincubation with mersalyl protects the carrier protein against the inactivation by p-sulfoPITC but not against PITC. Other SH reagents tested do not show any protective effect. It can thus be concluded that two types of lysine residues are essential for the activity of the phosphate carrier. Lysine(s) of the former type are located at the surface of the membrane and are topologically related to the functional SH groups of the protein. Lysine residue(s) of the latter type are buried in the hydrophobic phase of the membrane.     

Effects of chronic (dietary) choline availability on the transport of choline across the blood-brain barrier

The effects of dietary choline availability on the transport of choline across the blood-brain barrier (BBB) were investigated using the intracarotid injection technique. Maintenance of rats on choline-deficient, basal choline, or choline-supplemented diets for 28-32 days led to respective increases in blood levels of choline and correlative increases in the velocity of transport of choline measured using a buffer injectate. When serum from these rats was included in the injectate and transport determined in control animals, there was a marked inhibition of choline transport that was related to the concentration of choline in the diets. Results suggest that the activity of the choline carrier at the BBB is antagonized by an inhibitory substance in serum whose concentration or activity may be modified by chronic alterations in circulating levels of choline and whose presence may normally regulate the velocity of choline transport.     

Citrate uniport by the mitochondrial tricarboxylate carrier: a basis for a new hypothesis for the transport mechanism

The tricarboxylate transport system located in the inner mitochondrial membrane was studied as an isolated protein reconstituted in proteoliposomes. The effects on the transport of citrate by various reagents, specific for different aminoacid residues, were analyzed. In the group of SH reagents, it was found that N-ethylmaleimide is an irreversible inhibitor of the citrate–citrate exchange, while HgCl₂ and the mercurial mersalyl cause a rapid unidirectional efflux of citrate from liposomes. It was demonstrated that NEM and mercurials act on different SH groups. Dithioerythritol is not able to reverse the effect of mersalyl unless another reagent, pyridoxalphosphate, is present. Pyridoxalphosphate itself, a reagent specific for NH₂ residues, is an effective inhibitor of citrate exchange transport, as measured in both influx and efflux, but it has no effect on the mercurial-induced efflux. The same behavior was observed with diethylpyrocarbonate, a reagent specific for histidine and tyrosine residues. Interestingly, a slow basic efflux of internal citrate, in the absence of countersubstrate, was observed in proteoliposomes. Because it is inhibited by the same reagents acting on the exchange process, it is deduced that it is catalyzed by the tricarboxylate carrier. The ability of the carrier to perform a uniport of the substrate suggests the presence of a single substrate binding site on the carrier protein. A preliminary kinetic approach indicates that such a transport model is compatible with this theory.     

Differential inhibition of soluble and membrane-bound acetylcholinesterase forms from mouse brain by choline esters with an acyl moiety of an intermediate size

Differential inhibitions of soluble and membrane-bound acetylcholinesterase forms purified from mouse brain were examined by the comparison of kinetic constants such as a K _m value, a K_ss value (substrate inhibition constant), and IC₅₀ values of active site-selective ligands including choline esters. Membrane-bound acetylcholinesterase form (solubilized only in the presence of detergent) showed lower K_m and K_ss values than soluble acetylcholinesterase form (easily solubilized without detergent). Edrophonium expressed a slightly but significantly (p<0.01) higher inhibition of detergent-soluble acetylcholinesterase form than aqueous-soluble acetylcholinesterase form, while physostigmine inhibited both forms with a similar potency. A remarkable difference in inhibition was observed using choline esters; although choline esters with acyl chain of a short size (acetyl-to butyrylcholine) or a long size (heptanoyl- to decanoylcholine) showed a similar inhibitory potency for two forms of acetylcholinesterase, pentanoylcholine and hexanoylcholine inhibited more strongly aqueous-soluble acetylcholinesterase than detergent-soluble acetylcholinesterase. Thus, it is suggested that the two forms of AChE may be distinguished kinetically by pentanoyl- or hexanoylcholine.This work was supported in part by Agency for Defense Development.     

Effects of variation of ion and methylation of carrier on the rate constants of macrotetralide-mediated ion transport in lipid bilayers

Summary The effects of methylation on the rate constants of carrier-mediated ion transport have been studied on monooleindecane bilayers with K⁺, Rb⁺, NH ₄ ⁺ , and TI⁺ ions, using the series of homologue carriers, nonactin, monactin, dinactin, trinactin, and tetranactin, each member of the series differing from the previous one by only one methyl group. Measurements of the amplitude and time constant of the current relaxation after a voltage jump over a large domain of voltage and permeant ion concentration, together with a computer curve-fitting procedure, have allowed us, without the help of steady-state current-voltage data, to deduce and compare the values of the various rate constants for ion transport: formation (k _Ri) and dissociation (k _Di) of the ion-carrier complex at the interface, translocation across the membrane interior of the carrier (k _s) and the complex (k _is). With the additional information from steady-state low-voltage conductance measurements, we have obtained the value of the aqueous phase-membrane and torus-membrane partition coefficient of the carrier ({ie191-1} and {ie191-2}). From nonactin to tetranactin with the NH ₄ ⁺ ion,k _is, and {ie191-3} are found to increase by factors of 5 and 3, respectively,k _Di and {ie191-4} to decrease respectively by factors 8 and 2, whilek _Ri andk _s are practically invariant. Nearly identical results are found for K⁺, Rb⁺, and Tl⁺ ions.k _Ri,k _s andk _is are quite invariant from one ion to the other except for Tl⁺ wherek _Ri is about five times larger. On the other hand,k _Di depends strongly on the ion, indicating that dissociation is the determining step of the ionic selectivity of a given carrier. The systematic variations in the values of the rate constants with increasing methylation are interpreted in terms of modifications of energy barriers induced by the carrier increasing size. Within this framework, we have been able to establish and verify a fundamental relationship between the variations ofk _is andk _Di with methylation.     

On the mechanism of proton transport by the neuronal excitatory amino acid carrier 1

Uptake of glutamate from the synaptic cleft is mediated by high affinity transporters and is driven by Na(+), K(+), and H(+) concentration gradients across the membrane. Here, we characterize the molecular mechanism of the intracellular pH change associated with glutamate transport by combining current recordings from excitatory amino acid carrier 1 (EAAC1)-expressing HEK293 cells with a rapid kinetic technique with a 100-micros time resolution. Under conditions of steady state transport, the affinity of EAAC1 for glutamate in both the forward and reverse modes is strongly dependent on the pH on the cis-side of the membrane, whereas the currents at saturating glutamate concentrations are hardly affected by the pH. Consistent with this, the kinetics of the pre-steady state currents, measured after saturating glutamate concentration jumps, are not a function of the pH. In addition, we determined the deuterium isotope effect on EAAC1 kinetics, which is in agreement with proton cotransport but not OH(-) countertransport. The results can be quantitatively explained with an ordered binding model that includes a rapid proton binding step to the empty transporter followed by glutamate binding and translocation of the proton-glutamate-transporter complex. The apparent pK of the extracellular proton binding site is approximately 8. This value is shifted to approximately 6.5 when the substrate binding site is exposed to the cytoplasm.     

The hydrolysis of glycerophosphocholine by rat brain microsomes: Activation and inhibition

Experiments with glycerophosphocholine phosphodiesterase (GPC diesterase, EC 3.1.4.2.) in rat brain microsomes suggest that, although its activity is inhibited by low concentrations of calmidazolium, its dependence on Ca²⁺ ions is not modulated by calmoulin. The activity of glycerophosphocholine choline phosphodiesterase (choline phosphohydrolase, EC 3.1.4.38) was much lower than that of the GPC diesterase. A relatively inexpensive method for the preparation ofsn-glycero-3-phospho [Me-¹⁴C]choline is described.Special Issue Dedicated to Dr. Abel Lajtha.