An antiviral mechanism investigated with ribavirin as an RNA virus mutagen for foot-and-mouth disease virus

To prove whether error catastrophe/lethal mutagenesis is the primary antiviral mechanism of action of ribavirin against foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV). Ribavirin passage experiments were performed and supernatants of Rp1 to Rp5 were harvested. Morphological alterations as well as the levels of viral RNAs, proteins, and infectious particles in the BHK-21 cells infected using the supernatants of Rp1 to Rp5 and control were measured by microscope, real-time RT-PCR, western-blotting and plaque assays, respectively. The mutation frequency was measured by sequencing the complete P1- and 3D-encoding region of FMDV after a single round of virus infection from ribavirin-treated or untreated FMDV-infected cells. Ribavirin treatment for FMDV caused dramatically inhibition of multiplication in cell cultures. The levels of viral RNAs, proteins, and infectious particles in the BHK-21 cells infected were more greatly reduced along with the passage from Rp1 to Rp5, moreover, nucleocapsid protein could not be detected and no recovery of infectious virus in the supernatant or detection of intracellular viral RNA was observed at the Rp5-infected cells. A high mutation rate, giving rise to an 8-and 11-fold increase in mutagenesis and resulting in some amino acid substitutions, was found in viral RNA synthesized at a single round of virus infection in the presence of ribavirin of 1000 microM and caused a 99.7% loss in viral infectivity in contrast with parallel untreated control virus. These results suggest that the antiviral molecular mechanism of ribavirin is based on the lethal mutagenesis/error catastrophe, that is, the ribavirin is not merely an antiviral reagent but also an effective mutagen.     

Preextinction viral RNA can interfere with infectivity

When the error rate during the copying of genetic material exceeds a threshold value, the genetic information cannot be maintained. This concept is the basis of a new antiviral strategy termed lethal mutagenesis or virus entry into error catastrophe. Critical for its success is preventing survival of residual infectious virus or virus mutants that escape the transition into error catastrophe. Here we document that mutated, preextinction foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) RNA can interfere with and delay viral production up to 30 h when cotransfected in BHK-21 cells with standard RNA. Interference depended on the physical integrity of preextinction RNA and was not observed with unrelated RNAs or with nonmutated, defective FMDV RNA. These results suggest that this type of interference requires large size, preextinction FMDV RNA and is mediated neither by small interfering RNAs nor by RNAs that can compete with infectious RNA for host cell factors. A model based on the aberrant expression of mutated RNA as it is expected to occur in the initial stages of the transition into error catastrophe is proposed. Interference mediated by preextinction RNA indicates an advantage of mutagenesis versus inhibition in preventing the survival of virus escape mutants during antiviral treatments.     

A novel protein-RNA binding assay: functional interactions of the foot-and-mouth disease virus internal ribosome entry site with cellular proteins

Translation initiation on foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) RNA occurs by a cap-independent mechanism directed by a highly structured element (approximately 435 nt) termed an internal ribosome entry site (IRES). A functional assay to identify proteins that bind to the FMDV IRES and are necessary for FMDV IRES-mediated translation initiation has been developed. In vitro-transcribed polyadenylated RNAs corresponding to the whole or part of the FMDV IRES were immobilized on oligo-dT Dynabeads and used to deplete rabbit reticulocyte lysate (RRL) of IRES-binding proteins. Translation initiation factors eIF4G, eIF4A, and eIF4B bound to the 3' domain of the FMDV IRES. Depletion of eIF4G from RRL by this region of the FMDV IRES correlated with the loss of translational capacity of the RRL for capped, uncapped, and FMDV IRES-dependent mRNAs. However, this depleted RRL still supported hepatitis C virus IRES-directed translation. Poly (rC) binding protein-2 bound to the central domain of the FMDV IRES, but depletion of RRL with this IRES domain had no effect on FMDV IRES-directed translation initiation.     

Black beetle virus: messenger for protein B is a subgenomic viral RNA

Black beetle virus induces the synthesis of three new proteins, protein A (molecular weight, 104,000), protein α (molecular weight, 47,000), and protein B (molecular weight, 10,000), in infected Drosophila cells. Two of these proteins, A and α, are known to be encoded by black beetle virus RNAs 1 and 2, respectively, extracted from virions. We found that RNA extracted from infected cells directed the synthesis of all three proteins when it was added to a cell-free protein-synthesizing system. When polysomal RNA was fractionated on a sucrose density gradient, the messengers for proteins A and α cosedimented with viral RNAs 1 (22S) and 2 (15S), respectively. However, the messenger for protein B was a 9S RNA (RNA 3) not found in purified virions. Like the synthesis of viral RNAs 1 and 2, intracellular synthesis of RNA 3 was not affected by the drug actinomycin D at concentrations which blocked synthesis of host cell RNA. This indicated that RNA 3 is a virus-specific subgenomic RNA and, therefore, that protein B is a virus-encoded protein.     

Atomic force microscopy analysis of icosahedral virus RNA

Single-stranded genomic RNAs from four icosahedral viruses (poliovirus, turnip yellow mosaic virus (TYMV), brome mosaic virus (BMV), and satellite tobacco mosaic virus (STMV)) along with the RNA from the helical tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) were extracted using phenol/chloroform. The RNAs were imaged using atomic force microscopy (AFM) under dynamic conditions in which the RNA was observed to unfold. RNAs from the four icosahedral viruses initially exhibited highly condensed, uniform spherical shapes with diameters consistent with those expected from the interiors of their respective capsids. Upon incubation at 26 degrees C, poliovirus RNA gradually transformed into chains of globular domains having the appearance of thick, irregularly segmented fibers. These ultimately unwound further to reveal segmented portions of the fibers connected by single strands of RNA of 0.5-1 nm thickness. Virtually the same transformations were shown by TYMV and BMV RNA, and with heating, the RNA from STMV. Upon cooling, the chains of domains of poliovirus RNA and STMV RNA condensed and re-formed their original spherical shapes. TMV RNAs initially appeared as single-stranded threads of 0.5-1.0 nm diameter but took on the structure of the multidomain chains upon further incubation at room temperature. These ultimately condensed into short, thick chains of larger domains. Our observations suggest that classical extraction of RNA from icosahedral virions produces little effect on overall conformation. As tertiary structure is lost however, it is evident that secondary structural elements are arranged in a sequential, linear fashion along the polynucleotide chain. At least in the case of poliovirus and STMV, the process of tertiary structure re-formation from the linear chain of secondary structural domains proceeds in the absence of protein. RNA base sequence, therefore, may be sufficient to encode the conformation of the encapsidated RNA even in the absence of coat proteins.     

Nucleotide sequence heterogeneity of the RNA from a natural population of foot-and-mouth-disease virus

The genomic RNA from isolates of foot-and-mouth-disease virus (FMDV) of serological types O or C obtained during epizootic outbreaks have been analysed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of the T1 RNase-generated oligonucleotides (T1 fingerprinting). Among virus isolates that are closely related serologically, 4-12 oligonucleotide changes were detected constitute the genome, the variations affect 0.7%-2.2% positions in FMDV RNA. Higher nucleotide-sequence divergence exists between the genomic RNAs from serologically unrelated viruses, while a 100-fold lower RNA sequence heterogeneity has been detected by analysis of individual clones derived from one viral isolate. Oligonucleotide mapping indicates that the variant oligonucleotides are scattered throughout the FMDV genome. We suggest that extensive genetic variability at many RNA sites is the basis for the antigenic diversity of FMDV.     

A circular dichroism study of the Turnip yellow mosaic virus-RNA

We examined the circular dichroism spectra of intact Turnip yellow mosaic virus, freezed/thawed virus, empty capsid particles, and phenol extracted RNA. The circular dichroism signal of the empty capsid was found to contribute for less than 1% to the circular dichroism of the virus. Differences in the circular dichroism spectra indicate that TYMV-RNA exhibits different conformations when it is in situ in the virus, when it has been ejected by freezing/thawing and when it has been phenol extracted. Increase of the ionic strength up to 0.1 M NaCl led to conformational change of the RNA either freezed/thawed ejected or phenol extracted but not in situ in the capsid. Addition of spermidine (3 mM) induced a conformational change only for the phenol extracted RNA. These results are discussed with respect to the origin of the various conformational states of viral RNA.     

Riboproteomic analysis of polypeptides interacting with the internal ribosome-entry site element of foot-and-mouth disease viral RNA

Initiation of translation driven by internal ribosome entry site (IRES) elements depends upon the structural organization of this mRNA region. Besides translation initiation factors (eIFs), auxiliary proteins can also affect IRES activity. With the aim to identify proteins interacting with two unrelated IRESs present in the genome of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) and hepatitis C virus (HCV) we have used a proteomic approach. This procedure allowed the identification of 21 RNA-binding proteins interacting with discrete regions of the FMDV IRES, domains 3 and 5, and 16 interacting with domain III of the HCV IRES. In support of the binding specificity, the factors interacting with domain 3 differed from those interacting with domain 5, and included three poly(rC)-binding protein (PCBP) members, besides proliferation-associated 2G4 (PA2G4) and deleted-azoospermia 1 (DAZ1) protein. Around 71% of the identified factors associated with the FMDV IRES differ from those interacting with the HCV IRES. The group of proteins interacting with the FMDV or the HCV IRES includes eIF4B and 5 subunits of eIF3, respectively, known to interact with each of these RNAs, validating the results of this approach. According to the function of the identified proteins, 55% are involved in translation control, whereas 35% play a role in different aspects of RNA lifespan. Compilation of factors preferentially associated with FMDV or HCV IRES provides a basis for examining the strategies used by IRESs to recruit the translation machinery.     

Analysis of foot-and-mouth disease virus internalization events in cultured cells

It has been demonstrated that foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) can utilize at least four members of the alpha(V) subgroup of the integrin family of receptors in vitro. The virus interacts with these receptors via a highly conserved arginine-glycine-aspartic acid amino acid sequence motif located within the betaG-betaH loop of VP1. While there have been extensive studies of virus-receptor interactions at the cell surface, our understanding of the events during viral entry into the infected cell is still not clear. We have utilized confocal microscopy to analyze the entry of two FMDV serotypes (types A and O) after interaction with integrin receptors at the cell surface. In cell cultures expressing both the alphaVbeta3 and alphaVbeta6 integrins, virus adsorbed to the cells at 4 degrees C appears to colocalize almost exclusively with the alphaVbeta6 integrin. Upon shifting the infected cells to 37 degrees C, FMDV capsid proteins were detected within 15 min after the temperature shift, in association with the integrin in vesicular structures that were positive for a marker of clathrin-mediated endocytosis. In contrast, virus did not colocalize with a marker for caveola-mediated endocytosis. Virus remained associated with the integrin until about 1 h after the temperature shift, when viral proteins appeared around the perinuclear region of the cell. By 15 min after the temperature shift, viral proteins were seen colocalizing with a marker for early endosomes, while no colocalization with late endosomal markers was observed. In the presence of monensin, which raises the pH of endocytic vesicles and has been shown to inhibit FMDV replication, viral proteins were not released from the recycling endosome structures. Viral proteins were not observed associated with the endoplasmic reticulum or the Golgi. These data indicate that FMDV utilizes the clathrin-mediated endocytosis pathway to infect the cells and that viral replication begins due to acidification of endocytic vesicles, causing the breakdown of the viral capsid structure and release of the genome by an as-yet-unidentified mechanism.     

The virulent satellite RNA of turnip crinkle virus has a major domain homologous to the 3' end of the helper virus genome

RNA C (355 bases), RNA D (194 bases) and RNA F (230 bases) are small, linear satellite RNAs of turnip crinkle virus (TCV) which have been cloned as cDNAs and sequenced in this study. These RNAs produce dramatically different disease symptoms in infected plants. RNA C is a virulent satellite that intensifies virus symptoms when co-inoculated with its helper virus in turnip plants, while RNA D and RNA F are avirulent. RNA D and RNA F, the avirulent satellites, are closely related to each other except that RNA F has a 36-base insert near its 3' end, not found in RNA D. The 189 bases at the 5' end of RNA C, the virulent satellite, are homologous to the entire sequence of RNA D. However, the 3' half of RNA C, is composed of 166 bases which are nearly identical to two regions at the 3' end of the TCV helper virus genome. Hence, the virulent satellite is a composite molecule with one domain at its 5' end homologous to the other avirulent satellites and another domain at its 3' end homologous to the helper virus genome. All four TCV RNAs, RNAs C, D and F and the helper virus genome have identical 7 bases at their 3' ends. The secondary structure of RNA C deduced from the sequence can be folded into two separate domains — the domain of helper virus genome homology and the domain homologous to other TCV satellite RNAs. Comparative sequences of several different RNA C clones reveal that this satellite is a population of molecules with sequence and length heterogeneity.     

RD-114, baboon, and woolly monkey viral RNA's compared in size and structure.

The molecular weights, subunit compositions, and secondary structure patterns of the RNAs from an endogenous baboon virus and from a woolly monkey sarcoma virus were examined and compared to the properties of the RNA of RD-114, an endogenous feline virus. The high molecular weight RNA extracted from each of these three viruses has a sedimentation coefficient of 52S, and a molecular length, measured by electron microscopy, of 16-20 kb (kb=kilobase, 1000 nucleotides). Each such RNA is a dimer, containing two monomer subunits of 8-10 kb in length (molecular weight 3 X 10(6) daltons). The two monomer subunits are joined at their non-poly(A) ends in a structure called the dimer linkage structure. The appearance of this structure is somewhat different for the different viruses. The dimer linkage dissociates at temperature estimated to be 87 degrees C in aqueous 0.1M Na+ for RD-114 and baboon viral RNAs, but at the lower temperature of 66 degrees C for woolly monkey RNA. All three viral RNAs have two large loops of similar size and position symmetrically placed on either side of the dimer linkage structure. Since the baboon virus is partially related to RD-114, and the woolly monkey virus is unrelated to either of the other two, the dimer linkage and symmetrical loops are surprisingly similar and may well be common features of type C virus RNAs.     

Characterization of synthetic foot-and-mouth disease virus provirions separates acid-mediated disassembly from infectivity.

One of the final steps in the maturation of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) is cleavage of the VP0 protein to produce VP4 and VP2. The mechanism of this cleavage is unknown, but it is thought to function in stabilizing the virus particle and priming it for infecting cells. To investigate the cleavage process and to understand its role in virion maturation, we engineered synthetic FMDV RNAs with mutations at Ala-85 (A85) and Asp-86 (D86) of VP0, which border the cleavage site. BHK cells transfected with synthetic RNAs containing substitutions at position 85 (A85N or A85H) or at position 86 (D86N) yielded particles indistinguishable from wild-type (WT) virus in sedimentation and electrophoretic profiles. Viruses derived from these transfected cells were infectious and maintained their mutant sequences upon passage. However, BHK cells transfected with synthetic RNAs encoding Phe and Lys at these positions (A85F/D86K) or a Cys at position 86 (D86C) produced noninfectious provirions with uncleaved VP0 molecules. Despite their lack of infectivity, the A85F/D86K provirions displayed cell binding and acid sensitivity similar to those of WT virus. However, acid breakdown products of the A85F/D86K provirions differed in hydrophobicity from the comparable WT virion products, which lack VP4. Taken together, these studies are consistent with a role for soluble VP4 molecules in release of the viral genome from the endosomal compartment of susceptible cells.     

Analysis of extracellular West Nile virus particles produced by cell cultures from genetically resistant and susceptible mice indicates enhanced amplification of defective interfering particles by resistant cultures

[3H]uridine-labeled extracellular West Nile virus (WNV) particles produced by cell cultures obtained from genetically resistant C3H/RV and congenic susceptible C3H/HE mice were compared by sucrose density gradient centrifugation as well as by analysis of the particle RNA. Defective interfering (DI) WNV particles were observed among progeny produced during acute infections in both C3H/RV and C3H/HE cells. Although only a partial separation of standard and DI particles was achieved, the DI particles were found to be more dense than the standard virions. Particles containing several species of small RNAs consistently constituted a major proportion of the total population of virus progeny produced by C3H/RV cells, but a minor proportion of the population produced by C3H/HE cells. Decreasing the multiplicity of infection or extensive plaque purification of the WNV inoculum decreased the proportion of small RNAs found in the progeny virus. The ratio of DI particles to standard virus observed in progeny virus was determined by the cell type used to grow the virus. The ratio could be shifted by passaging virus from one cell type to the other. Homologous interference could be demonstrated with WNV produced by C3H/RV cells but not with virus produced by C3H/HE cells. Continued passage of WNV in C3H/HE cells resulted in a cycling of infectivity. However, passage in C3H/RV cells resulted in the complete loss of infectious virus. Four size classes of small viral RNA, with sedimentation coefficients of about 8, 15, 26, and 34S, were observed in the extracellular particles. A preliminary analysis of these RNAs by oligonucleotide fingerprinting indicated that the smaller RNAs were less complex than the 40S RNA and differed from each other. The data are consistent with the conclusion that WNV DI particles interfere more effectively with standard virus replication and are amplified more efficiently in C3H/RV cells than in congenic C3H/HE cells. The relevance of these findings to the further understanding of genetically controlled resistance to flaviviruses is discussed.     

Ribosomal RNA on the surfaces of nonleukemic mouse ascites tumor cells

RNAs on the cell surfaces of two nonleukemic and two leukemic strains of mouse ascites tumor cells were studied by fractionating the RNAs released from the cell surface by gentle pronase treatment after sucrose density gradient centrifugation, by indirect membrane immunofluorescence that used anti-RNA antibody and by cell electrophoresis. RNA was extracted from the cell supernatants of Ehrlich ascites tumor and sarcoma 180 cells (nonleukemic) that had been treated or not treated with pronase (1 microgram/ml, 37 degrees C, 20 min) followed by sucrose density gradient centrifugation. It was clearly demonstrated that the amounts of ribosomal RNA (18S and 28S) released after pronase treatment were approximately 80% greater than that of nonpronase-treated cells. Ehrlich ascites tumor cells that had been treated with actinomycin D (100 micrograms/kg body weight of mouse, 16 h) in vivo released an amount of ribosomal RNA after pronase treatment only 20% greater than the value for untreated cells. Actinomycin D treatment greatly reduced both the cell surface negative charge and the cell surface immunofluorescence when rabbit anti-RNA antibody was used. Under the same experimental conditions with actinomycin D, only ribosomal RNA synthesis showed preferential inhibition, not the syntheses of poly A-containing messenger RNA, 4S or other small-size RNAs. In contrast, L1210 and C1498 cells (leukemic) showed no change in the amounts of ribosomal RNA released after pronase treatment. L1210 cells also showed no change in the surface negative charge after being treated with actinomycin D.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Heparan sulfate-binding foot-and-mouth disease virus enters cells via caveola-mediated endocytosis

Foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) utilizes different cell surface macromolecules to facilitate infection of cultured cells. Virus, which is virulent for susceptible animals, infects cells via four members of the alpha(V) subclass of cellular integrins. In contrast, tissue culture adaptation of some FMDV serotypes results in the loss of viral virulence in the animal, accompanied by the loss of virus' ability to use integrins as receptors. These avirulent viral variants acquire positively charged amino acids on surface-exposed structural proteins, resulting in the utilization of cell surface heparan sulfate (HS) molecules as receptors. We have recently shown that FMDV serotypes utilizing integrin receptors enter cells via a clathrin-mediated mechanism into early endosomes. Acidification within the endosome results in a breakdown of the viral capsid, releasing the RNA, which enters the cytoplasm by a still undefined mechanism. Since there is evidence that HS internalizes bound ligands via a caveola-mediated mechanism, it was of interest to analyze the entry of FMDV by cell-surface HS. Using a genetically engineered variant of type O(1)Campos (O(1)C3056R) which can utilize both integrins and HS as receptors and a second variant (O(1)C3056R-KGE) which can utilize only HS as a receptor, we followed viral entry using confocal microscopy. After virus bound to cells at 4 degrees C, followed by a temperature shift to 37 degrees C, type O(1)C3056R-KGE colocalized with caveolin-1, while O(1)C3056R colocalized with both clathrin and caveolin-1. Compounds which either disrupt or inhibit the formation of lipid rafts inhibited the replication of O(1)C3056R-KGE. Furthermore, a caveolin-1 knockdown by RNA interference also considerably reduced the efficiency of O(1)C3056R-KGE infection. These results indicate that HS-binding FMDV enters the cells via the caveola-mediated endocytosis pathway and that caveolae can associate and traffic with endosomes. In addition, these results further suggest that the route of FMDV entry into cells is a function solely of the viral receptor.     

Subcellular localization of low-molecular RNA in the cells of chick embryos

The subcellular distribution of chick embryo low molecular weight RNAs has been studied by the thermal phenol fractionation procedure. The major part of 8SII RNA, earlier discovered in some oncornaviruses and normal cells, was extracted by phenol at 4%. Our results thus give evidence of the cytoplasmic localization of this RNA. Another part of 8SII RNA, which has been extracted at 65 degrees, is thought to consist of newly synthesized molecules located in the nuclei. A similarity in subcellular distribution of low molecular weight RNAs from chick embryo and rat liver has been obtained, i. e. such a distribution may be of universal nature.     

Removal of the genome-linked protein of foot-and-mouth disease virus by rabbit reticulocyte lysate.

Rabbit reticulocyte lysate cleaves the genome-linked protein VPg from foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) RNA. This activity could be reliably monitored since removal of the protein resulted in a change in migration in polyacrylamide gels of the small specific 5' and fragment of the RNA (S fragment). The unlinking activity cleaved the bond between the tyrosine residue of VPg and the RNA to leave a 5' phosphate on the RNA. The 5' sequence of the RNA from which VPg had been removed by rabbit reticulocyte lysate was the same as that of FMDV mRNA isolated from infected cells. VPg released from the RNA was rapidly degraded by the rabbit reticulocyte lysate to material which eluted with the inclusion volume of a Sepharose 6B column and partitioned to the aqueous phase during phenol extraction. The unlinking activity was inhibited by heating the lysate to 56 degrees C, by sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), EDTA, and Zn2+ ions but was unaffected by reducing agents, a translation inhibitor, and a number of protease and RNase inhibitors.