The effect of enhanced alpha-helicity on the activity of a winter flounder antifreeze polypeptide.

The antifreeze polypeptide (AFP) from the winter flounder displays partial alpha-helix formation at lower temperatures. To investigate the relationship between antifreeze activity and alpha-helical structure, we designed and then chemically synthesized an AFP analog with enhanced alpha-helicity, and compared its conformation and antifreeze properties with those of the native AFP. The synthetic analog was more helical than the native AFP; however, the antifreeze activity of both peptides were identical. The antifreeze activity of the peptides displayed a strong pH dependence, which paralleled pH-induced changes in helix content. At pH 8.5, the antifreeze activity of both peptides displayed identical concentration dependences. In addition to antifreeze activity measurements, the effects of the peptides on the rate of ice crystal growth were also measured. While both peptides affected the a- and c-axis growth rates of ice crystals, the highly helical analog was able to exert its effect on ice crystal growth rates at 7-8-fold lower concentrations than the native AFP. These data indicate that there is a direct but complex relationship between alpha-helicity and antifreeze activity.     

A model for binding of an antifreeze polypeptide to ice.

A model is proposed, based on recent peptide analog and ice crystal etching studies, whereby an alanine-rich, alpha-helical antifreeze polypeptide (AFP) from the winter flounder inhibits the growth of ice crystals by hydrogen bonding of Thr, Asn, and Asp side chains in a specific pattern to the [2021] hexagonal bipyramidal planes of ice. It is further suggested that this mode of binding is unidirectional, maximizing opportunities for packing of AFPs on the ice surface, and that ice crystal growth inhibition occurs by a two-step mechanism involving hydrogen bonding and hydrophobic interpeptide interactions.     

Structure-function relationships in an antifreeze polypeptide. The role of neutral, polar amino acids.

An alanine-rich, alpha-helical antifreeze polypeptide (AFP) from the winter flounder and seven analogs with variations in the arrangement of neutral, polar amino acids were synthesized. Circular dichroism studies determined that all of the peptides, except for one containing a proline residue, were essentially 100% alpha-helical. Freezing point depression data, analyzed by three methods, showed that rearrangement of polar residues resulted in moderate to complete loss of anti-freeze activity. It was observed that ice crystals grow as hexagonal bipyramids in dilute solutions, with a constant c to alpha axis ratio of about 3.3. Above a critical threshold concentration, which may depend on the AFP to ice binding constant and reflect the onset of cooperative interactions, growth ceases until the temperature is lowered to the freezing point. We conclude that a specific arrangement of both threonine and asparagine (or aspartic acid) residues is critical for maximal activity and that the AFPs probably bind to the pyramidal faces of ice with a specific orientation. These conclusions are consistent with a recent report (Knight, C. A., Cheng, C. C., and DeVries, A. L. (1991) Biophys. J. 59, 409-418) that a similar AFP adsorbs to the [2021] pyramidal planes of ice in dilute solution.     

Artificial antifreeze polypeptides: alpha-helical peptides with KAAK motifs have antifreeze and ice crystal morphology modifying properties.

Antifreeze polypeptides from fish are generally thought to inhibit ice crystal growth by specific adsorption onto ice surfaces and preventing addition of water molecules to the ice lattice. Recent studies have suggested that this adsorption results from hydrogen bonding through the side chains of polar amino acids as well as hydrophobic interactions between the non-polar domains on the ice-binding side of antifreeze polypeptides and the clathrate-like surfaces of ice. In order to better understand the activity of one of the antifreeze polypeptide families, namely the alpha-helical type I antifreeze polypeptides, four alpha-helical peptides having sequences not directly analogous to those of known antifreeze polypeptides and containing only positively charged and non-polar side chains were synthesized. Two peptides with regularly spaced lysine residues, GAAKAAKAAAAAAAKAAKAAAAAAAKAAKAAGGY-NH2 and GAALKAAKAAAAAALKAAKAAAAAALKAAKAAGGY-NH2, showed antifreeze activity, albeit weaker than seen in natural antifreeze polypeptides, by the criteria of freezing point depression (thermal hysteresis) and ice crystal modification to a hexagonal trapezohedron. Peptides with irregular spacing of Lys residues were completely inactive. Up to now, lysine residues have not been generally associated with antifreeze activity, though they have been implicated in some antifreeze polypeptides. This work also shows that lysine residues in themselves, when properly positioned on an alpha-helical polyalanine scaffold, have all the requisite properties needed for such an activity.     

Effect of type III antifreeze protein dilution and mutation on the growth inhibition of ice.

Mutation of residues at the ice-binding site of type III antifreeze protein (AFP) not only reduced antifreeze activity as indicated by the failure to halt ice crystal growth, but also altered ice crystal morphology to produce elongated hexagonal bipyramids. In general, the c axis to a axis ratio of the ice crystal increased from approximately 2 to over 10 with the severity of the mutation. It also increased during ice crystal growth upon serial dilution of the wild-type AFP. This is in marked contrast to the behavior of the alpha-helical type I AFPs, where neither dilution nor mutation of ice-binding residues increases the c:a axial ratio of the ice crystal above the standard 3.3. We suggest that the ice crystal morphology produced by type III AFP and its mutants can be accounted for by the protein binding to the prism faces of ice and operating by step growth inhibition. In this model a decrease in the affinity of the AFP for ice leads to filling in of individual steps at the prism surfaces, causing the ice crystals to grow with a longer c:a axial ratio.     

Activity of short segments of Type I antifreeze protein

In this work, we present a study on the antifreeze activity of short segments of a Type I antifreeze protein, instead of the whole protein. This approach simplifies the correlation between antifreeze protein characteristics, such as hydrophilicity/hydrophobicity, and the effect of these characteristics on the antifreeze mechanism. Three short polypeptides of Type I AFP have been synthesized. Their antifreeze activity and interactions with water and ice crystals have been analyzed by various techniques such as circular dichroism spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction, differential scanning calorimetry, and osmometry. It is shown that one short segment of Type I AFP has an antifreeze activity of about 60% of the native protein activity. In this work, we demonstrate that short segments of Type I AFPs possess nonzero thermal hysteresis and result in modifications in the growth habits and growth rates of ice. This approach enables the preparation of large quantities of short AFP segments at low cost with high antifreeze activity, and opens the possibility of developing the commercial potential of AFPs.     

Ice-binding mechanism of winter flounder antifreeze proteins

We have studied the winter flounder antifreeze protein (AFP) and two of its mutants using molecular dynamics simulation techniques. The simulations were performed under four conditions: in the gas phase, solvated by water, adsorbed on the ice (2021) crystal plane in the gas phase and in aqueous solution. This study provided details of the ice-binding pattern of the winter flounder AFP. Simulation results indicated that the Asp, Asn, and Thr residues in the AFP are important in ice binding and that Asn and Thr as a group bind cooperatively to the ice surface. These ice-binding residues can be collected into four distinct ice-binding regions: Asp-1/Thr-2/Asp-5, Thr-13/Asn-16, Thr-24/Asn-27, and Thr-35/Arg-37. These four regions are 11 residues apart and the repeat distance between them matches the ice lattice constant along the (1102) direction. This match is crucial to ensure that all four groups can interact with the ice surface simultaneously, thereby, enhancing ice binding. These Asx (x = p or n)/Thr regions each form 5-6 hydrogen bonds with the ice surface: Asn forms about three hydrogen bonds with ice molecules located in the step region while Thr forms one to two hydrogen bonds with the ice molecules in the ridge of the (2021) crystal plane. Both the distance between Thr and Asn and the ordering of the two residues are crucial for effective ice binding. The proper sequence is necessary to generate a binding surface that is compatible with the ice surface topology, thus providing a perfect "host/guest" interaction that simultaneously satisfies both hydrogen bonding and van der Waals interactions. The results also show the relation among binding energy, the number of hydrogen bonds, and the activity. The activity is correlated to the binding energy, and in the case of the mutants we have studied the number of hydrogen bonds. The greater the number of the hydrogen bonds the greater the antifreeze activity. The roles van der Waals interactions and the hydrophobic effect play in ice binding are also highlighted. For the latter it is demonstrated that the surface of ice has a clathratelike structure which favors the partitioning of hydrophobic groups to the surface of ice. It is suggested that mutations that involve the deletion of hydrophobic residues (e.g., the Leu residues) will provide insight into the role the hydrophobic effect plays in partitioning these peptides to the surface of ice.     

Biochemistry of fish antifreeze proteins

Four distinct macromolecular antifreezes have been isolated and characterized from different marine fish. These include the glycoprotein antifreezes (Mr 2.5-33 K), which are made up of a repeating tripeptide (Ala-Ala-Thr)n with a disaccharide attached to the threonyl residues, and three antifreeze protein (AFP) types. Type I is an alanine-rich, amphiphilic, alpha-helix (Mr 3-5 K); type II is a larger protein (Mr 14 K) with a high content of reverse turns and five disulfide bridges; and type III is intermediate in size (Mr 6-7 K) with no distinguishing features of secondary structure or amino acid composition. Despite their marked structural differences, all four antifreeze types appear to function in the same way by binding to the prism faces of ice crystals and inhibiting growth along the a-axes. It is suggested that type I AFP binds preferentially to the prism faces as a result of interactions between the helix macrodipole and the dipoles on the water molecules in the ice lattice. Binding is stabilized by hydrogen bonding, and the amphiphilic character of the helix results in the hydrophobic phase of the helix being exposed to the solvent. When the solution temperature is lowered further, ice crystal growth occurs primarily on the uncoated, unordered basal plane resulting in bipyramidal-shaped crystals. The structural features of type I AFP that could contribute to this mechanism of action are reviewed. Current challenges lie in solving the other antifreeze structures and interpreting them in light of what appears to be a common mechanism of action.     

A serendipitous discovery of antifreeze protein-specific activity in C-linked antifreeze glycoprotein analogs

Structurally diverse carbon-linked (C-linked) analogs of antifreeze glycoprotein (AFGP) have been prepared via linear or convergent solid phase synthesis. These analogs range in molecular weight from approx 1.5–4.1 KDa and do not possess the β-d-galactose-1,3-α-d-N-acetylgalactosamine carbohydrate moiety or the l-threonine-l-alanine-l-alanine polypeptide backbone native to the AFGP wild-type. Despite these dramatic structural modifications, the 2.7-KDa and 4.1-KDa analogs possess antifreeze protein-specific activity as determined by recrystallization-inhibition (RI) and thermal hysteresis (TH) assays. These analogs are weaker than the wild-type in their activity, but nanoliter osmometry indicates that these compounds are binding to ice and affecting a localized freezing point depression. This is the first example of a C-linked AFGP analog that possesses TH and RI activity and suggests that the rational design and synthesis of chemically and biologically stable AFGP analogs is a feasible and worthwhile endeavor. Given the low degree of TH activity, these compounds may prove useful for the protection of cells during freezing and thawing cycles.     

Energy-optimized structure of antifreeze protein and its binding mechanism.

A combination of Monte Carlo simulated annealing and energy minimization was utilized to determine the conformation of the antifreeze protein from the fish winter flounder. It was found from the energy-optimized structure that the hydroxyl groups of its four threonine residues, i.e. Thr2, Thr13, Thr24, Thr35, are aligned on almost the same line parallel to the helix axis and separated successively by 16.1, 16.0 and 16.2 A, respectively, very close to the 16.6 A repeat spacing along [0112] in ice. Based on such a space match, a zipper-like model is proposed to elucidate the binding mechanism of the antifreeze protein to ice crystals. According to the current model, the antifreeze protein may bind to an ice nucleation structure in a zipper-like fashion through hydrogen bonding of the hydroxyl groups of these four Thr residues to the oxygen atoms along the [0112] direction in ice lattice, subsequently stopping or retarding the growth of ice pyramidal planes so as to depress the freeze point. The calculated results and the binding mechanism thus derived accord with recent experimental observations. The mechanistic implications derived from such a special antifreeze molecule might be generally applied to elucidate the structure-function relationship of other antifreeze proteins with the following two common features: (1) recurrence of a Thr residue (or any other polar amino acid residue whose side-chain can form a hydrogen bond with water) in an 11-amino-acid period along the sequence concerned; and (2) a high percentage of Ala residue component therein. Further experiments are suggested to test the ice binding model.     

Structure and function of antifreeze proteins

High-resolution three-dimensional structures are now available for four of seven non-homologous fish and insect antifreeze proteins (AFPs). For each of these structures, the ice-binding site of the AFP has been defined by site-directed mutagenesis, and ice etching has indicated that the ice surface is bound by the AFP. A comparison of these extremely diverse ice-binding proteins shows that they have the following attributes in common. The binding sites are relatively flat and engage a substantial proportion of the protein's surface area in ice binding. They are also somewhat hydrophobic -- more so than that portion of the protein exposed to the solvent. Surface-surface complementarity appears to be the key to tight binding in which the contribution of hydrogen bonding seems to be secondary to van der Waals contacts.     

Understanding the mechanism of ice binding by type III antifreeze proteins

Type III antifreeze proteins (AFPs) are present in the body fluids of some polar fishes where they inhibit ice growth at subzero temperatures. Previous studies of the structure of type III AFP by NMR and X-ray identified a remarkably flat surface on the protein containing amino acids that were demonstrated to be important for interaction with ice by mutational studies. It was proposed that this protein surface binds onto the (1 0 [\bar 1] 0) plane of ice with the key amino acids interacting directly with the water molecules in the ice crystal. Here, we show that the mechanism of type III AFP interaction with ice crystals is more complex than that proposed previously. We report a high-resolution X-ray structure of type III AFP refined at 1.15 A resolution with individual anisotropic temperature factors. We report the results of ice-etching experiments that show a broad surface coverage, suggesting that type III AFP binds to a set of planes that are parallel with or inclined at a small angle to the crystallographic c-axis of the ice crystal. Our modelling studies, performed with the refined structure, confirm that type III AFP can make energetically favourable interactions with several ice surfaces.     

Calorimetric analysis of antifreeze glycoproteins of the polar fish, Dissostichus mawsoni

Solutions of antifreeze glycoproteins 1 through 5 and 8 were analyzed for activity by differential scanning calorimetry. With a scan rate of 1 degree C min-1, antifreeze glycoproteins 1-5 (20 mg/ml) revealed antifreeze activity with a delay in the freeze exotherm during cooling in the presence of ice. Antifreeze glycoprotein 8 (60 mg/ml), however, did not reveal antifreeze activity. When a 0.1 degree C min-1 scan rate was used, glycoproteins 1-5 again yielded a delay in the freeze onset, but the exotherm consisted of multiple events. At the slower scan glycoprotein 8 revealed an initial freeze followed by multiple exothermic events resembling those of glycoproteins 1-5. Thermograms exhibiting antifreeze activity had an initial shoulder in the exotherm direction upon cooling followed by a delay before the exotherm. The shoulders were correlated with c-axis ice growth observed in visual methods. The glycoprotein antifreezes had a linear increase in activity with decreased ice content.     

Structure-function relationship in the globular type III antifreeze protein: identification of a cluster of surface residues required for binding to ice.

Antifreeze proteins (AFPs) depress the freezing point of aqueous solutions by binding to and inhibiting the growth of ice. Whereas the ice-binding surface of some fish AFPs is suggested by their linear, repetitive, hydrogen bonding motifs, the 66-amino-acid-long Type III AFP has a compact, globular fold without any obvious periodicity. In the structure, 9 beta-strands are paired to form 2 triple-stranded antiparallel sheets and 1 double-stranded antiparallel sheet, with the 2 triple sheets arranged as an orthogonal beta-sandwich (Sönnichsen FD, Sykes BD, Chao H, Davies PL, 1993, Science 259:1154-1157). Based on its structure and an alignment of Type III AFP isoform sequences, a cluster of conserved, polar, surface-accessible amino acids (N14, T18, Q44, and N46) was noted on and around the triple-stranded sheet near the C-terminus. At 3 of these sites, mutations that switched amide and hydroxyl groups caused a large decrease in antifreeze activity, but amide to carboxylic acid changes produced AFPs that were fully active at pH 3 and pH 6. This is consistent with the observation that Type III AFP is optimally active from pH 2 to pH 11. At a concentration of 1 mg/mL, Q44T, N14S, and T18N had 50%, 25%, and 10% of the activity of wild-type antifreeze, respectively. The effects of the mutations were cumulative, such that the double mutant N14S/Q44T had 10% of the wild-type activity and the triple mutant N14S/T18N/Q44T had no activity. All mutants with reduced activity were shown to be correctly folded by NMR spectroscopy. Moreover, a complete characterization of the triple mutant by 2-dimensional NMR spectroscopy indicated that the individual and combined mutations did not significantly alter the structure of these proteins. These results suggest that the C-terminal beta-sheet of Type III AFP is primarily responsible for antifreeze activity, and they identify N14, T18, and Q44 as key residues for the AFP-ice interaction.     

Effect of ice fraction and dilution factor on the antifreeze activity in the hemolymph of the cerambycid beetle Rhagium inquisitor

The freezing-melting hysteresis in a given volume of hemolymph from the cerambycid beetle Rhagium inquisitor was linearly and negatively related to the logarithm of the mass fraction of ice in the sample. When the ice fraction dropped by a factor of 10, the hysteresis activity increased by about 2 degrees C. When the hemolymph was diluted, the hysteresis activity was linearly and negatively related to the logarithm of the dilution factor. Dilution of the hemolymph by a factor of 2 led to a 1 degree C reduction in hysteresis activity. In the diluted samples, the ice growth took place along the a-axes, implying that the antifreeze peptides of insects block ice growth along the c-axis, in addition to the a-axis.     

Raman spectra of a solid antifreeze glycoprotein and its liquid and frozen aqueous solutions.

Raman spectroscopy was used to study the anomalous decrease in the freezing temperature of water produced by an antifreeze glycoprotein obtained from the sera of an Antarctic fish. An active fraction of this glycoprotein has a molecular weight of approximately 18,000 by equilibrium sedimentation compared to an apparent weight of 20 by freezing temperature depression. The Raman spectra of water present in a 1% antifreeze glycoprotein solution and of ice frozen from this solution were indistinguishable from the spectra of pure water and ice, respectively. These results indicate that the bulk properties of water and ice are unaffected by the presence of the antifreeze glycoprotein. Raman measurements on ice grown slowly, using as seed an oriented single crystal of ice in contact with 1% glycoprotein solutions, showed that the active glycoprotein was not excluded from the ice phase. On the other hand, we found that a smaller, inactive glycoprotein was excluded. Comparison of the Raman spectra of active and inactive glycoprotein components as solids, in 5% solutions, and rapidly frozen 5% solutions, showed that the two components differ in conformation and possibly in the environment of their carbohydrate hydroxyls. These observations suggest that hydrogen bonding of the carbohydrate hydroxyls of the active glycoprotein at the ice-solution interface may physically prevent growth of the ice lattice.     

A natural variant of type I antifreeze protein with four ice-binding repeats is a particularly potent antifreeze.

A 4.3-kDa variant of Type I antifreeze protein (AFP9) was purified from winter flounder serum by size exclusion chromatography and reversed-phase HPLC. By the criteria of mass, amino acid composition, and N-terminal sequences of tryptic peptides, this variant is the posttranslationally modified product of the previously characterized AFP gene 21a. It has 52 amino acids and contains four 11-amino acid repeats, one more than the major serum AFP components. The larger protein is completely alpha-helical at 0 degree C, with a melting temperature of 18 degrees C. It is considerably more active as an antifreeze than the three-repeat winter flounder AFP and the four-repeat yellowtail flounder AFP, both on a molar and a mg/mL basis. Several structural features of the four-repeat winter flounder AFP, including its larger size, additional ice-binding residues, and differences in ice-binding motifs might contribute to its greater activity. Its abundance in flounder serum, together with its potency as an antifreeze, suggest that AFP9 makes a significant contribution to the overall freezing point depression of the host.     

Cloning and expression of afpA, a gene encoding an antifreeze protein from the arctic plant growth-promoting rhizobacterium Pseudomonas putida GR12-2

The Arctic plant growth-promoting rhizobacterium Pseudomonas putida GR12-2 secretes an antifreeze protein (AFP) that promotes survival at subzero temperatures. The AFP is unusual in that it also exhibits a low level of ice nucleation activity. A DNA fragment with an open reading frame encoding 473 amino acids was cloned by PCR and inverse PCR using primers designed from partial amino acid sequences of the isolated AFP. The predicted gene product, AfpA, had a molecular mass of 47.3 kDa, a pI of 3.51, and no previously known function. Although AfpA is a secreted protein, it lacked an N-terminal signal peptide and was shown by sequence analysis to have two possible secretion systems: a hemolysin-like, calcium-binding secretion domain and a type V autotransporter domain found in gram-negative bacteria. Expression of afpA in Escherichia coli yielded an intracellular 72-kDa protein modified with both sugars and lipids that exhibited lower levels of antifreeze and ice nucleation activities than the native protein. The 164-kDa AFP previously purified from P. putida GR12-2 was a lipoglycoprotein, and the carbohydrate was required for ice nucleation activity. Therefore, the recombinant protein may not have been properly posttranslationally modified. The AfpA sequence was most similar to cell wall-associated proteins and less similar to ice nucleation proteins (INPs). Hydropathy plots revealed that the amino acid sequence of AfpA was more hydrophobic than those of the INPs in the domain that forms the ice template, thus suggesting that AFPs and INPs interact differently with ice. To our knowledge, this is the first gene encoding a protein with both antifreeze and ice nucleation activities to be isolated and characterized.     

Structure of an antifreeze polypeptide from the sea raven. Disulfide bonds and similarity to lectin-binding proteins.

The antifreeze polypeptide (AFP) from the sea raven, Hemitripterus americanus, is a member of the cystine-rich class of blood antifreeze proteins which enable survival of certain fishes at sub-zero temperatures. Sea raven AFP contains 129 residues with 10 half-cystine residues. We have analyzed these half-cystine residues and established that all 10 of the half-cystine residues appeared to be involved in disulfide bond formation and that disulfide bonds linked Cys7 to Cys18, Cys35 to Cys125, and Cys89 to Cys117. These assignments were established by extensive proteolytic digestions of native AFP using pepsin and thermolysin and purification of the peptides by Sephadex G-15 gel filtration chromatography, anion exchange chromatography, and C18 reverse-phase high performance liquid chromatography. Cystine-containing peptides were detected by a colorimetric assay using nitrothiosulfobenzoate. Disulfide-containing peptides were reduced and alkylated, purified, and analyzed by amino acid analysis. The unreduced disulfide-linked peptides were sequenced directly by automated Edman degradations to confirm the disulfide assignments. Possible arrangements of the two remaining disulfide bonds include linkages Cys69/111 to Cys100/101. The sea raven AFP shares structural similarity with pancreatic stone protein and several lectin-binding proteins, especially with respect to half-cystines, glycines, and bulky aromatic residues. Two of the disulfide linkages we determined for sea raven AFP: Cys7-Cys18 and Cys35-Cys125, are conserved in these proteins. These similarities in covalent structure suggest that the sea raven AFP, pancreatic stone protein, and several lectin-binding proteins comprise a family of proteins which may possess a common fold.     

Structure-function relationships in a winter flounder antifreeze polypeptide. I. Stabilization of an alpha-helical antifreeze polypeptide by charged-group and hydrophobic interactions

The major antifreeze polypeptide (AFP) from winter flounder (37 amino acid residues) is a single alpha-helix. Aspartic acid and arginine are found, respectively, at the amino and carboxyl-termini. These charged amino acids are ideally located for stabilizing the alpha-helical conformation of this AFP by means of charge-dipole interaction (Shoemaker, K. R., Kim, P.S., York, E.J., Stewart, J. M., and Baldwin, R. L. (1987) Nature 326, 563-567). In order to understand these and other molecular interactions that maintain the AFP structure, we have carried out the chemical synthesis of AFP analogs and evaluated their conformations by circular dichroism spectroscopy. We synthesized the entire AFP molecule (37-mer) and six COOH-terminal peptide fragments (36-, 33-, 27-, 26-, 16-, and 15-mers). Peptides containing acidic NH2-terminal residues displayed greater helix formation and thermal stability compared to those peptides of similar size, but with neutral NH2-terminal residues. Helix formation was maximum above pH 9.2. The peptide conformations also displayed a pH-dependent sensitivity to changes in ionic strength. Helix formation was reduced in the presence of acetonitrile. We conclude that the AFP helix is most likely stabilized by: charge-dipole interactions between charged terminal amino acids and the helix dipole, a charge interaction between Lys18 and Glu22 (either a salt bridge or a hydrogen bond), and hydrophobic interactions.