The structure of a cytochrome oxidase-lipid model membrane

The structure of “membranous cytochrome oxidase” has been investigated by X-ray diffraction, optical polarization spectroscopy and EPR spectroscopy. These studies indicate that the cytochrome oxidase molecules are oriented asymmetrically in the membrane profile with a significant portion of their mass occurring within the extravesicular surface of the membrane; the oxidase molecultes span the membrane profile; the distribution of the oxidase molecules over the plane of these membranes is non-crystalline; the oxidase molecules contain bundles of α-helical polypeptide chain segments where the average orientation of the helices is normal to the membrane plane; and the average heme orientation within the oxidase molecules is such that the normal to the heme plane lies in the plane of the membrane.     

Studies on the orientations of the mitochondrial redox carriers. II. Orientation of the mitochondrial chromophores with respect to the plane of the membrane in hydrated, oriented mitochondrial multilayers.

Orientations of the active site chromophores of the mitochondrial redox carriers have been investigated in hydrated, oriented multilayers of mitochondrial membranes using optical and EPR spectroscopy. The hemes of cytochrome c oxidase, cytochrome c1, and cytochromes b were found to be oriented in a similar manner, with the normal to their heme planes lying approximately in the plane of the mitochondrial membrane. The heme of cytochrome c was either less oriented in general or was oriented at an angle closer to the plane of the mitochondrial membrane than were the hemes of the "tightly bound" mitochondrial cytochromes. EPR spectra of the azide, sulfide and formate complexes of cytochrome c oxidase in mitochondria in situ obtained as a function of the orientation of the applied magnetic field relative to the planes of the membrane multilayers showed that both hemes of the oxidase were oriented in such a way that the angle between the heme normal and the membrane normal was approx. 90 degrees.     

Studies on the orientations of the mitochondrial redox carriers II. Orientation of the mitochondrial chromophores with respect to the plane of the membrane in hydrated,oriented mitochondrial multilayers

Orientations of the active site chromophores of the mitochondrial redox carriers have been investigated in hydrated, oriented multilayers of mitochondrial membranes using optical and EPR spectroscopy. The hemes of cytochrome c oxidase, cytochrome c₁, and cytochromes b were found to be oriented in a similar manner, with the normal to their heme planes lying approximately in the plane of the mitochondrial membrane. The heme of cytochrome c was either less oriented in general or was oriented at an angle closer to the plane of the mitochondrial membrane than were the hemes of the “tightly bound” mitochondrial cytochromes. EPR spectra of the azide, sulfide and formate complexes of cytochrome c oxidase in mitochondria in situ obtained as a function of the orientation of the applied magnetic field relative to the planes of the membrane multilayers showed that both hemes of the oxidase were oriented in such a way that the angle between the heme normal and the membrane normal was approx. 90°.     

Orientation and lateral mobility of cytochrome c on the surface of ultrathin lipid multilayer films.

We have previously shown that cytochrome c can be electrostatically bound to an ultrathin multilayer film having a negatively charged hydrophilic surface; furthermore, x-ray diffraction and absorption spectroscopy techniques indicated that the cytochrome c was bound to the surface of these ultrathin multilayer films as a molecular monolayer. The ultrathin fatty acid multilayers were formed on alkylated glass, using the Langmuir-Blodgett method. In this study, optical linear dichroism was used to determine the average orientation of the heme group within cytochrome c relative to the multilayer surface plane. The cytochrome c was either electrostatically or covalently bound to the surface of an ultrathin multilayer film. Horse heart cytochrome c was electrostatically bound to the hydrophilic surface of fatty acid multilayer films having an odd number of monolayers. Ultrathin multilayer films having an even number of monolayers would not bind cytochrome c, as expected for such hydrophobic surfaces. Yeast cytochrome c was covalently bound to the surface of a multilayer film having an even number of fatty acid monolayers plus a surface monolayer of thioethyl stearate. After washing extensively with buffer, the multilayer films with either electrostatically or covalently bound cytochrome c were analyzed for bound protein by optical absorption spectroscopy; the orientation of the cytochrome c heme was then investigated via optical linear dichroism. Polarized optical absorption spectra were measured from 450 to 600 nm at angles of 0 degrees, 30 degrees, and 45 degrees between the incident light beam and the normal to the surface plane of the multilayer. The dichroic ratio for the heme alpha-band at 550 nm as a function of incidence angle indicated that the heme of the electrostatically-bound monolayer of cytochrome c lies, on average, nearly parallel to the surface plane of the ultrathin multilayer. Similar results were obtained for the covalently-bound yeast cytochrome c. Furthermore, fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) was used to characterize the lateral mobility of the electrostatically bound cytochrome c over the monolayer plane. The optical linear dichroism and these initial FRAP studies have indicated that cytochrome c electrostatically bound to a lipid surface maintains a well-defined orientation relative to the membrane surface while exhibiting measurable, but highly restricted, lateral motion in the plane of the surface.     

Studies of the orientation of the mitochondrial redox carriers. III. Orientation of the gx and gy axes of the hemes of cytochrome oxidase with respect to the plane of the membrane in oriented membrane multilayers.

The EPR absorption properties of the hemes of cytochrome oxidase and their liganded derivatives were examined in oriented multilayers from isolated oxidase, mitochondrial membranes and membrane fragments of a bacterium, Paracoccus denitrificans. The hemes of the oxidase in all the systems investigated were oriented normal to the plane of the multilayers. The directions of the g signals corresponding to the gx and gy axes of the g tensor were found to be different in low-spin ferric heme in fully oxidized oxidase and in half-reduced liganded oxidase. It is suggested that this different orientation of gx and gy in fully oxidized oxidase and half-reduced liganded oxidase arises because the respective EPR signals belong to two different hemes, those of cytochrome a and a3.     

Orientations of the retinyl and the heme chromophores in the brown membrane of Halobacterium halobium

The orientations of the retinyl and heme chromophores of bacteriorhodopsin and cytochrome b-561 of the brown membrane of Halobacterium halobium have been determined by linear dichroic spectroscopy of oriented brown membrane films. Both chromophores exhibit cylindrical symmetry with respect to the membrane normal. However, the retinyl transition dipole moment is polarized at an angle of 20 to 24 ° with respect to the plane of the membrane while the plane of the heme is oriented nearly perpendicular to the membrane plane. Therefore, the orientation of retinal bound to bacterio-opsin in the brown membrane is approximately the same as in the purple membrane. This is supportive of our previous conclusions that the fine structures of the bacteriorhodopsins of these membranes are very similar in spite of differences in the composition and structure of the two membranes. The orientation of the heme plane of the membrane-bound cytochrome b-561 is very similar to orientations of several membrane-bound heme proteins that are involved in electron transfer processes and may be suggestive of its function in the brown membrane. Analysis of the linear dichroic spectrum over the entire bacteriorhodopsin band using an exciton formalism is in accord with the energy separation of the in-plane and out-of-plane excitonic transitions being less than 5 nm. Since a similar energy separation was reported for the purple membrane, the relative positions of the retinals must be approximately the same in both membranes. A similar analysis of the Soret region, based on the existence of two degenerate mutually perpendicular porphyrin transitions, indicates that the energy separation should be from 5 to 20 nm. However, the smaller value is unlikely for it would imply very large circular dichroic bands not yet encountered in any heme proteins.     

Symmetry, orientation and rotational mobility in the a3 heme of cytochrome c oxidase in the inner membrane of mitochondria.

The photoinduced linear dichroism of absorption changes resulting from photolysis of the complex between heme a3 of the cytochrome oxidase and CO is studied. The experiments started from isotropic solutions or suspensions of the enzyme both in its isolated form and in mitochondria. The anisotropy responsible for the linear dichroism was induced by excitation with a flash of linearly polarized light. The dichroic ratios observed with various systems; polymerized enzyme in solution, enzyme in mitochondria and in submitochondrial particles (at 20 degrees C as well as at liquid N2-temperature) all approached a value of 4/3 which characterizes a chromophore which is circularly degenerate. Therefrom we conclude that the interaction of heme a3 with its microenvironment within the protein does not break its four-fold symmetry. The experiments with mitochondria and submitochondrial particles suspended in aqueous buffer revealed similarly high dichoric ratios without any dichroic relaxation other than a rather slow one which could be attributed to the rotation of the whole organelle in the suspending medium. Therefrom we conclude that the cytochrome oxidase either is totally immobilized in the membrane, or that it carries out only limited rotational diffusion around a single axis coinciding with the symmetry axis of heme a3. In the light of independent evidence for a transmembrane arrangement of the oxidase and for the general fluidity of the inner mitochondrial membrane we consider anisotropic mobility of the cytochrome oxidase around an axis normal to the plane of the membrane as the most likely interpretation. Then our experimental results imply that the plane of heme a3 is coplanar to the membrane.     

Symmetry, orientation and rotational mobility in the a3 heme of cytochrome c oxidase in the inner membrane of mitochondria

The photoinduced linear dichroism of absorption changes resulting from photolysis of the complex between heme a₃ of the cytochrome oxidase and CO is studied. The experiments started from isotropic solutions or suspensions of the enzyme both in its isolated form and in mitochondria. The anisotropy responsible for the linear dichroism was induced by excitation with a flash of linearly polarized light. The dichroic ratios observed with various systems; polymerized enzyme in solution, enzyme in mitochondria and in submitochondrial particles (at 20 °C as well as at liquid N₂-temperature) all approached a value of 4/3 which characterizes a chromophore which is circularly degenerate. Therefrom we conclude that the interaction of heme a₃ with its microenvironment within the protein does not break its four-fold symmetry.

The experiments with mitochondria and submitochondrial particles suspended in aqueous buffer revealed similarly high dichroic ratios without any dichroic relaxation other than a rather slow one which could be attributed to the rotation of the whole organelle in the suspending medium. Therefrom we conclude that the cytochrome oxidase either is totally immobilized in the membrane, or that it carries out only limited rotational diffusion around a single axis coinciding with the symmetry axis of heme a₃. In the light of independent evidence for a transmembrane arrangement of the oxidase and for the general fluidity of the inner mitochondrial membrane we consider anisotropic mobility of the cytochrome oxidase around an axis normal to the plane of the membrane as the most likely interpretation. Then our experimental results imply that the plane of heme a₃ is coplanar to the membrane.     

EPR signals and orientation of cytochromes in the spinach chloroplast thylakoid membrane

The cytochromes in spinach chloroplasts were studied using EPR spectroscopy. In addition to the low-spin heme signals previously assigned, cytochrome f (g_z 3.51), high-potential cytochrome b-559 (g_z 3.08) and cytochrome b-559 converted to a low-potential form (g_z 2.94), a high-spin heme signal was induced by 2,3-dichloro-5,6-dicyano-1,4-benzoquinone (DDQ). However, this signal cannot be due to cytochrome b-563 in its native form. The orientation of the cytochromes in the thylakoid membrane was studied in magnetically oriented chloroplasts. Cytochrome b-559 in the native state and in the low-potential form was found to have its heme plane perpendicular to the membrane plane. The orientation was the same for cytochrome b-559 oxidized by low-temperature illumination, which suggests that also the reduced heme is oriented perpendicular to the membrane.     

The orientation of cytochromes in membrane multilayers prepared from aerobically grown Escherichia coli K12

Centrifugation of membrane vesicles, prepared from ultrasonically disrupted Escherichia coli K12, on to a planar surface followed by slow, partial dehydration results in a high degree of parallel orientation of the membrane planes with respect to each other and the supporting surface. Rotation of such membrane multilayers about a single axis parallel with the membrane planes within the magnetic field of an electron paramagnetic resonance (e.p.r.) spectrometer allows the orientation of anisotropic paramagnetic centres to be deduced. Computer simulations of the angular dependence of cytochrome e.p.r. spectra show two, or perhaps three, cytochromes, well-oriented with respect to the membrane plane. A low-spin cytochrome is oriented with the normal to its haem plane lying in the membrane plane. One (or perhaps two) high-spin cytochrome(s) lies with its haem plane making an angle of 45 degrees with the membrane plane. The orientation of the low-spin cytochrome haem is thus the same as that of haems in b-type cytochromes and cytochrome oxidases of the a type found in the mitochondria of higher animal and microbial cells and the bacterium Paracoccus denitrificans (Erecińska et al., 1979). The possible identity of this low-spin component as the terminal oxidase, cytochrome o, is discussed.     

Studies on the orientations of the mitochondrial redox carriers. I. Orientation of the hemes of cytochrome c oxidase with respect to the plane of a cytochrome oxidase-lipid model membrane.

The liganded derivatives of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase have been prepared in hydrated oriented multilayers of membranous cytochrome c oxidase. The optical spectra of the liganded derivatives recorded at an angle of 45 degrees between the incident light beam and the normal to the planes of the membranes in the multilayers show dichroic ratios of almost 2 in the visible region and 1.2-1.4 in the Soret region. The dichroic ratios were found to be similar for both cytochromes a and a3. Electron paramagnetic resonance spectra of the azide, sulfide, and formate complexes of cytochrome c oxidase obtained as a function of the orientation of the applied magnetic field relative to the planes of the membranes in the multilayer confirm the optical data and demonstrate that both hemes of cytochrome c oxidase are oriented such that the angle between the heme normal and the membrane normal is approximately 90 degrees.     

Metal-free and metal-substituted cytochromes c. Use in characterization of the cytochrome c binding site.

The luminescent properties of metal-free, tin(IV) and zinc(II) cytochromes c have been used to characterize the interaction of cytochrome c with mitochondria and cytochrome oxidase. Diminution in the fluorescence yields of tin and zinc cytochrome c occur when these derivates bind to cytochrome oxidase or mitochondria. Based upon spectral overlap and quantum yield, the distance between the porphyrin rings of cytochrome a and cytochrome c is estimated according to Forster theory to be in the neighborhood of 3.5 nm. Measurements of the polarized emission of metal-free 'porphyrin' cytochrome c when bound to oriented layers of cytochrome c oxidase indicate that the porphyrin is bound obliquely to the plane of the oxidase layers with an angle of about 70 degrees C from heme plane to membrane plane. It is proposed that these data have significance for elucidation of electron transfer mechanisms.     

Studies of the orientation of the mitochondrial redox carriers III. Orientation of the gx and gy axes of the hemes of cytochrome oxidase with respect to the plane of the membrane in oriented membrane multilayers

The EPR absorption properties of the hemes of cytochrome oxidase and their liganded derivatives were examined in oriented multilayers from isolated oxidase, mitochondrial membranes and membrane fragments of a bacterium, Paracoccus denitrificans. The hemes of the oxidase in all the systems investigated were oriented normal to the plane of the multilayers. The directions of the g signals corresponding to the g_x and g_y axes of the g tensor were found to be different in low-spin ferric heme in fully oxidized oxidase and in half-reduced liganded oxidase. It is suggested that this different orientation of g_x and g_y in fully oxidized oxidase and half-reduced liganded oxidase arises because the respective EPR signals belong to two different hemes, those of cytochrome a and a₃.     

Charge transfer in the K proton pathway linked to electron transfer to the catalytic site in cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase couples electron transfer from cytochrome c to O 2 to proton pumping across the membrane. In the initial part of the reaction of the reduced cytochrome c oxidase with O 2, an electron is transferred from heme a to the catalytic site, parallel to the membrane surface. Even though this electron transfer is not linked to proton uptake from solution, recently Belevich et al. [(2006) Nature 440, 829] showed that it is linked to transfer of charge perpendicular to the membrane surface (electrogenic reaction). This electrogenic reaction was attributed to internal transfer of a proton from Glu286, in the D proton pathway, to an unidentified protonatable site "above" the heme groups. The proton transfer was proposed to initiate the sequence of events leading to proton pumping. In this study, we have investigated electrogenic reactions in structural variants of cytochrome c oxidase in which residues in the second, K proton pathway of cytochrome c oxidase were modified. The results indicate that the electrogenic reaction linked to electron transfer to the catalytic site originates from charge transfer within the K pathway, which presumably facilitates reduction of the site.     

The effect of mitochondrial energization on cytochrome c oxidase kinetics as measured at low temperatures. I. The reaction with carbon monoxide.

The kinetics of CO binding by the cytochrome c oxidase of pigeon heart mitochondria were studied as a function of membrane energization at temperatures from 180 to 280 degrees K in an ethylene glycol/water medium. Samples energized by ATP showed acceleration of CO binding compared to those untreated or uncoupled by carbonylcyanide p-trifluoromethyoxyphenylhydrazone but only at relatively low temperatures and high CO concentrations. Experiments using samples in a "mixed valency" (partially oxidized) state showed that the acceleration of ligand binding is not due to the formation of a partially oxidized state via reverse electron transport. It is concluded that in the deenergized state one CO molecule can be closely associated with the cytochrome a3 heme site without actually being bound to the heme iron; in the energized state, two or more ligand molecules can occupy this intermediate position. The change in the apparent ligand capacity of a region near the heme iron in response to energization is evidence for an interaction between cytochrome oxidase and the ATPase system. Furthermore, these results suggest a control mechanism for O2 binding.     

Studies on the orientations of the mitochondrial redox carriers I. Orientation of the hemes of cytochrome c oxidase with respect to the plane of a cytochrome oxidase-lipid model membrane

The liganded derivatives of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase have been prepared in hydrated oriented multilayers of membranous cytochrome c oxidase. The optical spectra of the liganded derivatives recorded at an angle of 45° between the incident light beam and the normal to the planes of the membranes in the multilayers show dichroic ratios of almost 2 in the visible region and 1.2–1.4 in the Soret region. The dichroic ratios were found to be similar for both cytochromes a and a₃. Electron paramagnetic resonance spectra of the azide, sulfide, and formate complexes of cytochrome c oxidase obtained as a function of the orientation of the applied magnetic field relative to the planes of the membranes in the multilayer confirm the optical data and demonstrate that both hemes of cytochrome c oxidase are oriented such that the angle between the heme normal and the membrane normal is approximately 90°.     

Studies on the molecular organization of cytochromes P-450 and b5 in the microsomal membrane.

1. The relative orientations of the heme groups of cytochromes P-450 and b5 in the microsomal membrane have been studied by the technique of electron paramagnetic resonance. The results show that the heme plane of cytochrome P-450 lies in the same plane as the membrane surface, whereas the cytochrome b5 heme plane has a random orientation. 2. No significant broadening or change in relaxation properties of the gz component of low spin cytochrome P-450 occurred when cytochrome b5 was reduced by redox poising. It is concluded that there is little or no paramagnetic coupling between the heme groups of the two species. 3. The results favor a model in which no tight complex between cytochromes P-450 and b5 is present, the species being independent and interacting only by random molecular collisions or via other intermediate species.     

Effects of chronic alcohol consumption on the steady-state kinetics properties of cytochrome oxidase in rat liver

The effect of chronic alcohol consumption on steady-state kinetic characteristics of cytochrome oxidase in rat liver was studied using submitochondrial particles prepared from ethanol-fed and control rats. Preparations from both control and alcoholic rats had equivalent apparent Km values for cytochrome c of 13 microM in the presence of phenazine methosulfate or 19 microM with N,N,N',N'-tetramethylphenylene diamine as oxidation-reduction mediators at physiological ionic strength. Both preparations showed comparable stimulation (approx. 3-fold) of oxidase activity following detergent solubilization of the membrane and similar temperature dependence for oxidase activity. Under all conditions, preparations from alcohol-fed rats displayed 30 to 50% lower rats of cytochrome oxidase activity per unit membrane protein than those from control rats. The diminution in specific activity per mg protein was accompanied by a similar decline in heme aa3 content, as has been noted in previous studies. When expressed on a turnover number basis, the molecular activity of cytochrome oxidase (natoms O/min per nmol heme a) was equivalent in both alcoholic and control preparations. The results indicate that the intrinsic kinetic characteristics of cytochrome oxidase are not changed by alcohol consumption. The data suggest that the characteristic decline in heme aa3 content and cytochrome oxidase specific activity seen in ethanol-fed rats does not arise from alterations in the accessibility of the oxidase towards cytochrome c, or from changes in bulk phase lipid composition or physical properties. The results support the conclusion that ethanol consumption decreases the membrane content of functionally active oxidase molecules, but does not change the catalytic properties of these oxidase molecules.     

The orientation of bovine adrenal cortex cytochrome P-450 in submitochondrial particle multilayers.

Angular electron paramagnetic resonance spectra of cytochrome P-450 in oriented multilayers from bovine adrenal cortex Submitochondrial particles have been obtained. Both high- and low-spin forms are present. Analysis of the spectra allows the orientation of the cytochrome P-450 to be determined relative to the membrane plane. The quality of the orientation of the cytochrome P-450 is estimated by use of a computer simulation program. Cytochrome P-450, unlike other cytochromes and porphyrins previously studied, has its heme plane parallel to the membrane plane.     

Raman spectra of heme a, cytochrome oxidase-ligand complexes, and alkaline denatured oxidase.

We report 441.6 nm excitation resonance Raman spectra of oxidized and reduced monomeric heme a-imidazole, cytochrome oxidase-exogenous ligand complexes in various redox states, and alkaline denatured oxidase. These data show that, in reduced oxidase, the cytochrome a3 Raman spectrum has bands at 215, 364, 1230, and 1670 cm-1 not observed in the cytochrome a spectrum. The appearance of these bands in the reduced cytochrome a3 spectrum is due to interactions between the heme a of cytochrome a3 and its protein environment and not to intrinsic properties of heme a. These interactions are pH sensitive and strongly influence the vibrational spectra of both heme a groups. We assign the 1670-cm-1 band to the heme a formyl substituent and propose that the intensity of the 1670 cm-1 is high for reduced cytochrome a3 because the C==O lies in the porphyrin plane and is very weak for oxidized and reduced cytochrome a, oxidized cytochrome a3, and oxidized and reduced heme a-imidazole because the C==O lies out of the plane. We suggest that movement of the C==O in and out of the plane explains the ligand induced spectral shift in the optical absorption spectrum of reduced cytochrome a3. Finally, we confirm the observation of Adar & Yonetani (private communication) that, under laser illumination, resting oxidase is photoreactive.