Screening of Mhc variation in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar): a comparison of restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP), denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) and sequencing

We compared three different molecular methods currently used for screening of Mhc variation in population studies of Atlantic salmon. Restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) of the entire class II gene detected 22 haplotypes. Seventeen exon 2 sequences were obtained from individuals carrying the 22 haplotypes, two of which had not been detected by RFLP. The six alleles (27%) detected by RFLP and not by exon 2 sequencing probably resulted from sequence variation outside exon 2. Within exon 2, RFLP differentiated 88% of the sequences. Alternatively, denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) performed under two run conditions detected 94% of the sequence variation. Both RFLP using different probes, and the two PCR-based methods using three different primer pairs, suggest that there is only a single Mhc class II B gene in the Baltic populations of Atlantic salmon.     

Determining SNP allele frequencies in DNA pools

Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) are among the most common types of polymorphism used for genetic association studies. A method to allow the accurate quantitation of their allele frequencies from DNA pools would both increase throughput and decrease costs for large-scale genotyping. However, to date, most DNA pooling studies have concentrated on the use of microsatellite polymorphisms. In the case of SNPs that are restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs), studies have tended to use methods for the quantitation of allele frequency from pools that rely on densitometric evaluation of bands on an autoradiograph. Radiation-based methods have well-known drawbacks, and we present two alternative methods for the determination of SNP allele frequencies. For RFLPs, we used agarose gel electrophoresis of digested PCR products with ethidium bromide staining combined with densitometric analysis of gel images on a PC. For all types of SNP, we used allele-specific fluorescent probes in the Taqman assay to determine the relative frequencies of two different alleles. Both methods gave accurate and reproducible results, suggesting they are suitable for use in DNA pooling experiments.     

Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE): a rapid and sensitive technique to screen nucleotide sequence variation in populations

We describe a rapid and sensitive method for the detection of nucleotide sequence variation that can be used for large-scale screening of population markers. Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) detects sequence variants of amplified fragments by the differences in their melting behavior. DGGE detects most single-base substitutions when carried out on products amplified with a primer to which a GC clamp has been added. Although DGGE has been primarily used for the detection of limited numbers of single-base mutations in disease studies, it offers great potential for use in population analysis of genetic markers with greater levels of sequence variation. The methodology described was developed to identify the number and distribution of MHC class I alpha 1 alleles among chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) populations. DGGE detects 28 of 31 identified alpha 1 sequences, which differ by between 1 and 16 nucleotides and a two-codon indel. By creating a network of control alleles, 22-23 of the MHC alleles can be resolved rapidly and accurately by a single gel run condition, and 27 alleles can be resolved by two gel run conditions. This techniques has been used in surveys scoring alleles from two MHC markers (class I alpha 1 and alpha 2) in 20,000 individuals of chinook and coho (O. kisutch) salmon. A single person in our laboratory now analyzes 160 salmon from one MHC locus per day with DGGE.     

Allelic polymorphism in MHC class II B in four populations of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar)

We sequenced exon 2 of the MHC class II B gene in Atlantic salmon from the Baltic Sea and identified 17 different exon 2 alleles among 22 different restriction fragment length polymorphism haplotypes. The sequences differed at between 1 and 34 bases. Two different tests were used to estimate the importance of recombination in the generation of new alleles. Recombination events appear to have occurred between three and nine times. Only two pairs of sequences differed by less than five nucleotides, minimizing the importance of point mutations for generating new alleles. Phylogenetic analysis showed that sequences did not cluster according to populations, and genetic distances between populations were small compared to those obtained by allele frequency data. These results, together with the similarity found between exon 2 sequences from Baltic salmon and Norwegian salmon, indicate that all of the identified alleles were present in the ancient salmon population colonizing the Baltic rivers after the last glaciation.     

Application of automated DNA sizing technology for genotyping microsatellite loci.

Highly polymorphic microsatellite loci offer great promise for gene mapping studies, but fulfillment of this potential will require substantial improvements in methods for accurate and efficient genotyping. Here, we report a genotyping method based on fluorescently labeled PCR primers and size characterization of PCR products using an automated DNA fragment analyzer. We capitalize on the availability of three distinct fluorescent dyes to label uniquely loci that overlap in size, and this innovation increases by threefold the number of loci that can be analyzed simultaneously. We label size standards with a fourth dye and combine these with the microsatellite PCR products in each gel lane. Computer programs provide very rapid and accurate sizing of microsatellite alleles and efficient data management. In addition, fluorescence signals are linear over a much greater range of intensity than conventional autoradiography. This facilitates multiplexing of loci (since signal intensities often vary greatly) and helps distinguish major peaks from artifacts, thereby improving genotyping accuracy.     

Inorganic pyrophosphatase: a new polymorphic allozyme locus in Pacific salmon

Genetic polymorphism of inorganic pyrophosphatase was investigated in 2799 individuals in four species of Pacific salmon: chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha), coho salmon (O. kisutch), kokanee (O. nerka), and steelhead (O. mykiss), using horizontal starch gel electrophoresis. This enzyme system appears to be an isolocus system with electrophoretically indistinguishable allozymes encoded by two loci (PP-1,2*) expressed in retinal tissue. Mendelian inheritance was observed with a breeding study in three family crosses. Population variability in four species was characterized in 44 populations from the U.S. Pacific coast. Three alleles were found in chinook salmon; two alleles each were found in coho salmon, kokanee, and steelhead. Chinook salmon and kokanee populations differed enough with respect to PP-1,2* frequencies that this isolocus is useful for genetic stock identification in these species.     

Genetic markers of adaptive processes in the Far Eastern pink salmon <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oncorhynchus gorbuscha</Emphasis>: Allelic diversity at the locus of major histocompatibility complex MHC I-<Emphasis Type="Italic">A1</Emphasis>

To clarify allelic diversity at the locus of major histocompatibility complex MHC class I-A1 in the Far Eastern pink salmon Oncorhynchus gorbuscha, sequencing of the electrophoretic alleles isolated from the gel (DGGE alleles) was performed. In 47 individuals, the genotypes of which consisted of ten DGGE alleles, 18 MHC I-A1 nucleotide sequences were revealed, and thus, eight cryptic alleles not detected by electrophoresis were identified. Eleven of these alleles were identified earlier in pink salmon from Hokkaido, Alaska, and British Columbia, and seven, possibly, were unique to the populations from some Far Eastern regions. Six of the previously determined DGGE alleles corresponded to more than one nucleotide sequence. However, the sequences attributed to the same DGGE allele differed on average by less than 1 nucleotide. These findings point to sufficient sensitivity of the DGGE method, although the genetic diversity and differentiation estimates obtained with it will obviously be somewhat underestimated. Considerable predominance of nonsynonymous substitutions over the synonymous ones in the codons of the MHC I-A1 antigen-binding site confirms the presence of positive selection aimed at providing the population resistance to local spectrum of pathogens. Refinement of the allelic composition of the adaptively important MHC genetic marker will contribute to more complete understanding of the adaptive genetic structure of pink salmon as an important element of the overall population structure of the species.     

Single nucleotide polymorphism genotyping by on-line liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry in forensic science of the Y-chromosomal locus M9

A method is described for genotyping alleles of the Y-chromosomal locus M9, incorporating DNA extraction, amplification by polymerase chain reaction (PCR), sample purification by ion-pair reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (IP-RP-HPLC), and allele identification by on-line hyphenation to electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). The alleles G and C were differentiated in 114 base pair amplicons on the basis of intact molecular mass measurements with a mass accuracy between 0.007 and 0.017%. The accuracy of mass determination was significantly reduced to less than 0.0036% upon amplification of a short, 61 bp fragment. The application of steep gradients of acetonitrile in 25 mM butyldimethylammonium bicarbonate not only enabled the efficient separation of non-target components from the PCR product in a monolithic, poly-(styrene-divinylbenzene)-based capillary column, but also allowed the high-throughput analysis of the PCR products with cycle times of 2 min. The new method was compared to a conventional restriction fragment length polymorphism assay with capillary gel electrophoretic analysis. In a blind study, 90 samples of unrelated individuals were genotyped. The high accuracy (<0.004%) and small relative standard deviation (<0.007%, n=20) of mass measurements, which enables even the differentiation of A and T alleles with a mass difference of 9 mass units, make IP-RP-HPLC-ESI-MS a potent tool for the routine characterization of SNPs in forensic science.     

Effect of natural selection on the duplicated lysyl oxidase gene in Atlantic salmon

We examined the polymorphism of the lysyl oxidase (LOX) locus, involved in the initiation of muscle collagen cross-linking, in three populations of Atlantic salmon with different life histories and growth rates and compared it with a closely related species (rainbow trout). Up to four alleles were observed per individual, probably as a consequence of the tetraploid origin of the salmonid genome. We found high polymorphism in the LOX locus (16 alleles expressed in total and several low frequency private alleles) in two natural Atlantic salmon populations and extremely reduced diversity in a farmed population (3 alleles) with low density of collagen crosslinks. We also assessed the relative role of selection in maintaining LOX genetic variability in Atlantic salmon. Results from several neutrality tests suggest that selection is playing a role in shaping diversity at the LOX locus. Positive selection was inferred by three different likelihood phylogeny-based methods and one selected site, identified by all three different methods (PAML, FEL and REL) was located within the “copper-talon” characteristic of LOX proteins. We suggest that the retention of four alleles in the salmon LOX locus could be related to its multiple functions.     

Microplate array diagonal gel electrophoresis for cohort studies of microsatellite loci

After PCR amplification, we have achieved precise sizing of trinucleotide and tetranucleotide microsatellite alleles on 96-well open-faced polyacrylamide microplate array diagonal gel electrophoresis (MADGE) gels: two tetranucleotide repeats, HUMTHOI (five alleles 248-263 bp) and DYS390 (eight alleles 200-228 bp), and DYS392, a trinucleotide repeat (eight alleles 210-231 bp). A gel matrix of Duracryl, a high mechanical strength polyacrylamide derivative, and appropriate ionic conditions provide the 1.3%-1.5% band resolution required. No end-labeling of primers is needed, as the sensitive Vistra Green intercalating dye is used for the visualization of bands. Co-run markers bracketing the PCR fragments ensure accurate sizing without inter-lane variability. Electrophoresis of multiple gels in a thermostatically controlled tank allows up to 1000 samples to be run in 90 min. Gel images were analyzed using a Fluorlmager 595 fluorescent scanning system, and alleles were identified using Phoretix software for band migration measurement and Microsoft Excel to compute fragment sizes. Estimated sizes were interpolated precisely to achieve accurate binning. Microsatellite-MADGE represents a utilitarian methodfor high-throughput genotyping in cohort studies, using standard laboratory equipment.     

Restriction data from chloroplast DNA for phylogenetic reconstruction: Is there only one accurate way of scoring?

Information from the same restriction analysis of chloroplast DNA of 33 taxa ofRubiaceae was scored in four different ways, two of which were based on fragments, and two on restriction sites, and they were subsequently analysed with Wagner parsimony. The methods resulted in different phylogenetic trees. The inherent differences between the methods relate to the amount of non-homologous characters and dependent characters, but none of the methods will systematically bias the resulting cladograms. The fragment analyses are much less time-consuming, but probably less accurate, than the site analyses. The choice of method is dependent on a trade-off between accuracy and resources (time). One important recommendation is made: all phylogenetic analyses of chloroplast DNA data should be accompanied by a data matrix and contain information on how the matrix was compiled.     

A method to analyze allele-specific methylation

We have developed a method to analyze the methylation patterns of individual alleles of a gene. The target gene must have alleles identifiable by restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis. The method involves separation of the alleles after digestion by restriction enzyme digestion and electrophoresis, followed by recovery from the gel on ion-exchange paper. Methylation analysis can be done on the separate alleles by Southern blot after digestion by methylation-sensitive enzymes. As an example, we studied human c-Ha-ras-1 and showed that the methylation patterns of different alleles are stable and inherited. The method can be applied to the study of inheritance and methylation in genes where alleles can be identified by restriction fragment length polymorphism.     

Determination of Genetic Sex in Chinook Salmon (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Oncorhynchus tshawytscha</Emphasis>) Using the Male-Linked Growth Hormone Pseudogene by Real-Time PCR

This study used a real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) method based on the growth hormone pseudogene (GHp) in chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) to determine genetic sex. The GHp is present as a single copy in the genome of the male chinook salmon but is absent in the female, providing a means of using this real-time qPCR method to discriminate genetic sex. Comparisons between genomic DNA samples from 2 geographically distinct populations of chinook salmon (Columbia River, Washington, and Yukon River, Alaska) showed, within each population examined, that the males were clearly differentiated from the females. There were no interpopulation differences between males or females. The advantages of this real-time qPCR method are that it is rapid, is amenable to high sample throughput, and provides an accurate numerical value that allows comparisons between samples by statistical methods.     

Inheritance of liver isocitrate dehydrogenase in the humpback salmon Oncorhynchus gorbuscha (Walb.)

Genetic variants of NADP+-dependent soluble isocitrate dehydrogenase (sIDH) expressed in pink salmon liver have been studied. The progeny of 16 individual crossings has been analysed. It is shown that sIDH in the liver of pink salmon is a dimer and is coded for by two duplicated loci, one of which is represented by 3 alleles (82, 100 and 124) and the other, probably by two (100 and 124). The products of the most frequently occurring alleles of these loci are almost similar in their electrophoretic mobility. Polypeptides coded for by the alleles of both loci combine freely, generating heterodimers.     

Genetic comparison of salmon from the White Sea and north-western Atlantic Ocean

Samples of salmon Salmo salar from the River Kachkovka and the River Nilma in northern Russia were analysed by starch gel electrophoresis and compared to three Norwegian stocks, the Neiden river in northern Norway and Øyreselv and Hopselv rivers on the west coast. The comparison included the following polymorphic loci: AAT-4 *, IDDH-2 *, IDHP-3 *, MDH- 3,4 *, MEP-2 *, ESTD * as well as the newly discovered polymorphic loci FBALD-3 * and TPI-3 *. Samples were run side by side on gels, and the alleles found in the Russian stocks were the same as those found in the Norwegian stocks, although the electrophoretic methods used lead to differences in designations of alleles. A polymorphism in ESTD * which involves a slow allele was commonly observed in the three northern populations of the Nilma, Kachkovka and Neiden rivers. This allele was absent in the other Norwegian stocks and in a major brood stock of farmed salmon in Norway. The IDHP-3 * 116 allele was found in unusually high frequencies in the northern populations. Thus, the variability observed at these two loci indicates a barrier to gene flow between the northern salmon stocks and the more southern stocks in the East Atlantic area.     

Comparison of three microsatellite analysis methods for detecting genetic diversity in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Phytophthora sojae</Emphasis> (Stramenopila: Oomycete)

Analysis of an organism’s genetic diversity requires a method that gives reliable, reproducible results. Microsatellites are robust markers, however, detection of allele sizes can be difficult with some systems as well as consistency among laboratories. In this study, our two laboratories used 219 isolates of Phytophthora sojae to compare three microsatellite methods. Two capillary electrophoresis methods, the Applied Biosystems 3730 Genetic Analyzer and the CEQ 8000 Genetic Analysis system, detected an average of 2.4-fold more alleles compared to gel electrophoresis with a mean of 8.8 and 3.6 alleles per locus using capillary and gel methods, respectively. The two capillary methods were comparable, although allele sizes differed consistently by an average of 3.2 bp across isolates. Differences between capillary methods could be overcome if reference standard DNA genotypes are shared between collaborating laboratories.     

Major histocompatibility complex and kin discrimination in Atlantic salmon and brook trout

Many species of salmonids can discriminate kin from unrelated conspecifics using olfactory cues. In this study, we determined the role of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) in kin discrimination by juvenile Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) and brook trout (Salvelinus fontinalis). Genetic variation at the highly polymorphic exon coding for peptide-binding region of an MHC class II gene was studied using polymerase chain reaction and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis. Experiments compared discrimination ability based on MHC haplotypes both within and among kin and non-kin groups. Juveniles chose kin sharing both alleles over kin sharing no alleles. Juveniles also preferred non-kin sharing both alleles to non-kin sharing no alleles. These data suggest that the MHC class II gene influence kin discrimination in juvenile Atlantic salmon and brook trout. The influence of additional genes was also apparent in trials where juveniles were able to recognize kin sharing no alleles over non-kin sharing no alleles. However, the inability of juveniles to discriminate between kin sharing no alleles and non-kin sharing either one or both alleles indicates that MHC is as potent as the rest of the genome in producing distinguishable odours.     

Population structure of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.): a range-wide perspective from microsatellite DNA variation

Atlantic salmon (n = 1682) from 27 anadromous river populations and two nonanadromous strains ranging from south-central Maine, USA to northern Spain were genotyped at 12 microsatellite DNA loci. This suite of moderate to highly polymorphic loci revealed 266 alleles (5-37/locus) range-wide. Statistically significant allelic and genotypic heterogeneity was observed across loci between all but one pairwise comparison. Significant isolation by distance was found within and between North American and European populations, indicating reduced gene flow at all geographical scales examined. North American Atlantic salmon populations had fewer alleles, fewer unique alleles (though at a higher frequency) and a shallower phylogenetic structure than European Atlantic salmon populations. We believe these characteristics result from the differing glacial histories of the two continents, as the North American range of Atlantic salmon was glaciated more recently and more uniformly than the European range. Genotypic assignment tests based on maximum-likelihood provided 100% correct classification to continent of origin and averaged nearly 83% correct classification to province of origin across continents. This multilocus method, which may be enhanced with additional polymorphic loci, provides fishery managers the highest degree of correct assignment to management unit of any technique currently available.     

PCR‐based markers detect genetic variation at growth and immune function‐related loci in chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)

We developed seven polymerase chain reaction (PCR) based markers that detect genetic variation at loci related to growth (four) and immune function (three) in chinook salmon. One assay shows a length polymorphism following PCR; the others show restriction fragment length polymorphisms (PCR‐RFLP). Two alleles were detected in each assay, and the common alleles were found at frequencies of 0.67–0.95 in seven wild populations in British Columbia, Canada. These loci also amplified in other salmonid species. These markers, by detecting variation linked to genes with high fitness relevance, are expected to be useful in a range of theoretical and applied studies.     

Molecular evolution at Mhc genes in two populations of chinook salmon Oncorhynchus tshawytscha

The DNA sequences of four exons of the MHC (major histocompatibilty complex) were examined in chinook salmon ( Oncorhynchus tshawytscha ) from an interior (Nechako River) and a coastal (Harrison River) population in the Fraser River drainage of British Columbia. Mhc class I A1, A2 and A3 sequences and a class II B1 sequence were obtained by PCR from each of 16–20 salmon from each population. The class I A1 and a pair of linked A2–A3 exons were derived from two different classical salmonid class I genes, Sasa-A and Onmy-UA , respectively. Allelic variation for B1, A1 and A2 was characterized by the high levels of nonsynonymous substitution indicative of the effects of natural selection on Mhc domains that contain peptide binding regions. The number of alleles detected at each of the four exons ranged from three ( B1 ) to 22 ( A1 ), but levels of nucleotide sequence divergence at all four exons were low relative to classical mammalian Mhc genes. The nucleotide similarity among alleles ranged between 89 and 99% over all exons, and all four domains possessed only two major sequence motifs. Allelic distributions at B1, A1 and A3 confirmed the genetic distinctiveness of the Harrison and Nechako chinook salmon populations revealed in previous studies. The two major allelic motifs of B1 and A1 segregated strongly between the populations. In spite of evidence that allelic diversity at these chinook salmon Mhc exons has been generated by selection, the level and distribution of diversity in the two salmon populations strongly reflected the demographic history of the species, which has been characterized by repeated bottlenecks and isolation-by-distance in glacial refugia.