Mechanics of channel gating of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) is a key molecule involved in the propagation of signals in the central nervous system and peripheral synapses. Although numerous computational and experimental studies have been performed on this receptor, the structural dynamics of the receptor underlying the gating mechanism is still unclear. To address the mechanical fundamentals of nAChR gating, both conventional molecular dynamics (CMD) and steered rotation molecular dynamics (SRMD) simulations have been conducted on the cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) structure of nAChR embedded in a dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) bilayer and water molecules. A 30-ns CMD simulation revealed a collective motion amongst C-loops, M1, and M2 helices. The inward movement of C-loops accompanying the shrinking of acetylcholine (ACh) binding pockets induced an inward and upward motion of the outer β-sheet composed of β9 and β10 strands, which in turn causes M1 and M2 to undergo anticlockwise motions around the pore axis. Rotational motion of the entire receptor around the pore axis and twisting motions among extracellular (EC), transmembrane (TM), and intracellular MA domains were also detected by the CMD simulation. Moreover, M2 helices undergo a local twisting motion synthesized by their bending vibration and rotation. The hinge of either twisting motion or bending vibration is located at the middle of M2, possibly the gate of the receptor. A complementary twisting-to-open motion throughout the receptor was detected by a normal mode analysis (NMA). To mimic the pulsive action of ACh binding, nonequilibrium MD simulations were performed by using the SRMD method developed in one of our laboratories. The result confirmed all the motions derived from the CMD simulation and NMA. In addition, the SRMD simulation indicated that the channel may undergo an open-close (O ↔ C) motion. The present MD simulations explore the structural dynamics of the receptor under its gating process and provide a new insight into the gating mechanism of nAChR at the atomic level.     

Subunit-selective contribution to channel gating of the M4 domain of the nicotinic receptor

The muscle nicotinic receptor (AChR) is a pentamer of four different subunits, each of which contains four transmembrane domains (M1-M4). We recently showed that channel opening and closing rates of the AChR depend on a hydrogen bond involving a threonine at position 14' of the M4 domain in the alpha-subunit. To determine whether residues in equivalent positions in non-alpha-subunits contribute to channel gating, we mutated deltaT14', betaT14', and epsilonS14' and evaluated changes in the kinetics of acetylcholine-activated currents. The mutation epsilonS14'A profoundly slows the rate of channel closing, an effect opposite to that produced by mutation of alphaT14'. Unlike mutations of alphaT14', epsilonS14'A does not affect the rate of channel opening. Mutations in deltaT14' and betaT14' do not affect channel opening or closing kinetics, showing that conserved residues are not functionally equivalent in all subunits. Whereas alphaT14'A and epsilonS14'A subunits contribute additively to the closing rate, they contribute nonadditively to the opening rate. Substitution of residues preserving the hydrogen bonding ability at position 14' produce nearly normal gating kinetics. Thus, we identify subunit-specific contributions to channel gating of equivalent residues in M4 and elucidate the underlying mechanistic and structural bases.     

Changes in the conductance of the neuronal nicotinic acetylcholine receptor channel induced by magnesium

We have investigated the effect of magnesium on the single-channel conductance of neuronal nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (nAChRs) in nerve growth-factor treated rat pheochromocytoma (PC12) cells. The patch-clamp technique was used to record single-channel currents from cell attached and excised, outside-out patches in the presence of various internal and external Mg2+ concentrations. Mg2+ reduced the single-channel conductance in a concentration-dependent manner with an IC50 of 9.2 mM for external Mg2+ (inward conductance) and 0.69 mM for external Mg2+ (outward conductance). Both estimated and measured conductances for divalent cation-free CsCl solutions were around 60 pS. We also find that divalent cations are not involved in the inward rectification of whole-cell ACh-induced currents in these cells. Our results imply that the amino acids screened by divalent cations sense electric fields only weakly and are presumably outside the lipid bilayer. They also suggest that the density and the number of charges (or both) differ on either side of the ion pore.     

An intersubunit hydrogen bond in the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor that contributes to channel gating

The muscle nicotinic acetylcholine receptor is a large, allosteric, ligand-gated ion channel with the subunit composition alpha2betagammadelta. Although much is now known about the structure of the binding site, relatively little is understood about how the binding event is communicated to the channel gate, causing the pore to open. Here we identify a key hydrogen bond near the binding site that is involved in the gating pathway. Using mutant cycle analysis with the novel unnatural residue alpha-hydroxyserine, we find that the backbone N-H of alphaSer-191 in loop C makes a hydrogen bond to an anionic side chain of the complementary subunit upon agonist binding. However, the anionic partner is not the glutamate predicted by the crystal structures of the homologous acetylcholine-binding protein. Instead, the hydrogen-bonding partner is the extensively researched aspartate gammaAsp-174/deltaAsp-180, which had originally been identified as a key binding residue for cationic agonists.     

Mechanosensitive channel gating transitions resolved by functional changes upon pore modification

The mechanosensitive channel of large conductance acts as a biological "emergency release valve" that protects bacterial cells from hypoosmotic stress. Although structural and functional studies and molecular dynamic simulations of this channel have led to several models for the structural transitions that occur in the gating process, inconsistencies linger and details are lacking. A previous study, using a method coined as the "in vivo SCAM", identified several residues in the channel pore that were exposed to the aqueous environment in the closed and opening conformations. Briefly, the sulfhydryl reagent MTSET was allowed to react, in the presence or absence of hypoosmotic shock, with cells expressing mechanosensitive channel of large conductance channels that contained cysteine substitutions; channel dysfunction was assessed solely by cell viability. Here we evaluate the MTSET-induced functional modifications to these mechanosensitive channel activities by measuring single channel recordings. The observed changes in residue availability in different states, as well as channel kinetics and sensitivity, have allowed us to elucidate the microenvironment encountered for a number of pore residues, thus testing many aspects of previous models and giving a higher resolution of the pore domain and the structural transitions it undergoes from the closed to open state.     

Subunit-selective role of the M3 transmembrane domain of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor in channel gating

The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) can be either hetero-pentameric, composed of alpha and non-alpha subunits, or homo-pentameric, composed of alpha7 subunits. To explore the subunit-selective contributions of transmembrane domains to channel gating we analyzed single-channel activity of chimeric muscle AChRs. We exchanged M3 between alpha1 and epsilon or alpha7 subunits. The replacement of M3 in alpha1 by epsilonM3 significantly alters activation properties. Channel activity appears as bursts of openings whose durations are 20-fold longer than those of wild-type AChRs. In contrast, 7-fold briefer openings are observed in AChRs containing the reverse epsilon chimeric subunit. The duration of the open state decreases with the increase in the number of alpha1M3 segments, indicating additive contributions of M3 of all subunits to channel closing. Each alpha1M3 segment decreases the energy barrier of the closing process by approximately 0.8 kcal/mol. Partial chimeric subunits show that small stretches of the M3 segment contribute additively to the open duration. The replacement of alpha1 sequence by alpha7 in M3 leads to 3-fold briefer openings whereas in M1 it leads to 10-fold prolonged openings, revealing that the subunit-selective role is unique to each transmembrane segment.     

Calcium channel current of vascular smooth muscle cells: extracellular protons modulate gating and single channel conductance

Modulation of L-type Ca2+ channel current by extracellular pH (pHo) was studied in vascular smooth muscle cells from bovine pial and porcine coronary arteries. Relative to pH 7.4, alkaline pH reversibly increased and acidic pH reduced ICa. The efficacy of pHo in modulating ICa was reduced when the concentration of the charge carrier was elevated ([Ca2+]o or [Ba2+]o varied between 2 and 110 mM). Analysis of whole cell and single Ca2+ channel currents suggested that more acidic pHo values shift the voltage-dependent gating (approximately 15 mV per pH- unit) and reduce the single Ca2+ channel conductance gCa due to screening of negative surface charges. pHo effects on gCa depended on the pipette [Ba2+] ([Ba2+]p), pK*, the pH providing 50% of saturating conductance, increased with [Ba2+]p according to pK* = 2.7-2.log ([Ba2+]p) suggesting that protons and Ba2+ ions complete for a binding site that modulates gCa. The above mechanisms are discussed in respect to their importance for Ca2+ influx and vasotonus.     

Subunit-selective role of the M3 transmembrane domain of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor in channel gating

The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) can be either hetero-pentameric, composed of α and non-α subunits, or homo-pentameric, composed of α7 subunits. To explore the subunit-selective contributions of transmembrane domains to channel gating we analyzed single-channel activity of chimeric muscle AChRs. We exchanged M3 between α1 and ? or α7 subunits. The replacement of M3 in α1 by ?M3 significantly alters activation properties. Channel activity appears as bursts of openings whose durations are 20-fold longer than those of wild-type AChRs. In contrast, 7-fold briefer openings are observed in AChRs containing the reverse ? chimeric subunit. The duration of the open state decreases with the increase in the number of α1M3 segments, indicating additive contributions of M3 of all subunits to channel closing. Each α1M3 segment decreases the energy barrier of the closing process by ∼ 0.8 kcal/mol. Partial chimeric subunits show that small stretches of the M3 segment contribute additively to the open duration. The replacement of α1 sequence by α7 in M3 leads to 3-fold briefer openings whereas in M1 it leads to 10-fold prolonged openings, revealing that the subunit-selective role is unique to each transmembrane segment.     

Initial coupling of binding to gating mediated by conserved residues in the muscle nicotinic receptor

We examined functional consequences of intrasubunit contacts in the nicotinic receptor alpha subunit using single channel kinetic analysis, site-directed mutagenesis, and structural modeling. At the periphery of the ACh binding site, our structural model shows that side chains of the conserved residues alphaK145, alphaD200, and alphaY190 converge to form putative electrostatic interactions. Structurally conservative mutations of each residue profoundly impair gating of the receptor channel, primarily by slowing the rate of channel opening. The combined mutations alphaD200N and alphaK145Q impair channel gating to the same extent as either single mutation, while alphaK145E counteracts the impaired gating due to alphaD200K, further suggesting electrostatic interaction between these residues. Interpreted in light of the crystal structure of acetylcholine binding protein (AChBP) with bound carbamylcholine (CCh), the results suggest in the absence of ACh, alphaK145 and alphaD200 form a salt bridge associated with the closed state of the channel. When ACh binds, alphaY190 moves toward the center of the binding cleft to stabilize the agonist, and its aromatic hydroxyl group approaches alphaK145, which in turn loosens its contact with alphaD200. The positional changes of alphaK145 and alphaD200 are proposed to initiate the cascade of perturbations that opens the receptor channel: the first perturbation is of beta-strand 7, which harbors alphaK145 and is part of the signature Cys-loop, and the second is of beta-strand 10, which harbors alphaD200 and connects to the M1 domain. Thus, interplay between these three conserved residues relays the initial conformational change from the ACh binding site toward the ion channel.     

Kinetics of unliganded acetylcholine receptor channel gating.

Open- and closed-state lifetimes of unliganded acetylcholine receptor channel activity were analyzed by the method of likelihood maximazation. For both open times and closed times, the best-fitting density is most often a sum of two exponentials. These multiple open states cannot depend on the number of receptor binding sites occupied since they are observed in the absence of ligand. The rate of spontaneous opening and the faster decay constant of closing increased as the membrane was hyperpolarized. The voltage dependence of the rate of spontaneous opening is stronger than that for curare-liganded channels. Evidence that the acetylcholine receptor channel can open spontaneously in the absence of ligand has been presented previously (Sanchez et al, 1983; Brehm et al, 1984; Jackson, 1984). To add to this evidence, alpha-bungarotoxin was added to the patch electrode, causing the frequency of openings to decay with time. The rate constant determined from this decay is similar to rate constants reported for the binding of iodinated alpha-bungarotoxin to the acetylcholine receptor. The frequency of unliganded channel opening has been estimated as 2 X 10(-3) s-1 per receptor. A comparison of carbamylcholine-liganded and spontaneous gating transition rates suggests that ligand binding increases the rate of opening by a factor of 1.4 X 10(7). Carbamylcholine binding increases the mean open time by a factor of 5. Thus, a cholinergic agonist activates the acetylcholine receptor by destabilizing the closed state. The liganded and unliganded channel gating rates were used to analyze the energetics of ligand activation of the acetylcholine receptor channel, and to relate the open channel dissociation constant to the closed channel dissociation constant.     

Mechanistic contributions of residues in the M1 transmembrane domain of the nicotinic receptor to channel gating

The nicotinic receptor (AChR) is a pentamer of homologous subunits with an alpha(2)betaepsilondelta composition in adult muscle. Each subunit contains four transmembrane domains (M1-M4). Position 15' of the M1 domain is phenylalanine in alpha subunits while it is isoleucine in non-alpha subunits. Given this peculiar conservation pattern, we studied its contribution to muscle AChR activation by combining mutagenesis with single-channel kinetic analysis. AChRs containing the mutant alpha subunit (alphaF15'I) as well as those containing the reverse mutations in the non-alpha subunits (betaI15'F, deltaI15'F, and epsilonI15'F) show prolonged lifetimes of the diliganded open channel resulting from a slower closing rate with respect to wild-type AChRs. The kinetic changes are not equivalent among subunits, the beta subunit, being the one that produces the most significant stabilization of the open state. Kinetic analysis of betaI15'F of AChR channels activated by the low-efficacious agonist choline revealed a 10-fold decrease in the closing rate, a 2.5-fold increase in the opening rate, a 28-fold increase in the gating equilibrium constant in the diliganded receptor, and a significant increase opening in the absence of agonist. Mutations at betaI15' showed that the structural bases of its contribution to gating is complex. Rate-equilibrium linear free-energy relationships suggest an approximately 70% closed-state-like environment for the beta15' position at the transition state of gating. The overall results identify position 15' as a subunit-selective determinant of channel gating and add new experimental evidence that gives support to the involvement of the M1 domain in the operation of the channel gating apparatus.     

Fundamental gating mechanism of nicotinic receptor channel revealed by mutation causing a congenital myasthenic syndrome

We describe the genetic and kinetic defects in a congenital myasthenic syndrome due to the mutation epsilonA411P in the amphipathic helix of the acetylcholine receptor (AChR) epsilon subunit. Myasthenic patients from three unrelated families are either homozygous for epsilonA411P or are heterozygous and harbor a null mutation in the second epsilon allele, indicating that epsilonA411P is recessive. We expressed human AChRs containing wild-type or A411P epsilon subunits in 293HEK cells, recorded single channel currents at high bandwidth, and determined microscopic rate constants for individual channels using hidden Markov modeling. For individual wild-type and mutant channels, each rate constant distributes as a Gaussian function, but the spread in the distributions for channel opening and closing rate constants is greatly expanded by epsilonA411P. Prolines engineered into positions flanking residue 411 of the epsilon subunit greatly increase the range of activation kinetics similar to epsilonA411P, whereas prolines engineered into positions equivalent to epsilonA411 in beta and delta subunits are without effect. Thus, the amphipathic helix of the epsilon subunit stabilizes the channel, minimizing the number and range of kinetic modes accessible to individual AChRs. The findings suggest that analogous stabilizing structures are present in other ion channels, and possibly allosteric proteins in general, and that they evolved to maintain uniformity of activation episodes. The findings further suggest that the fundamental gating mechanism of the AChR channel can be explained by a corrugated energy landscape superimposed on a steeply sloped energy well.     

Voltage-dependent gating of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator Cl- channel

When excised inside-out membrane patches are bathed in symmetrical Cl--rich solutions, the current-voltage (I-V) relationship of macroscopic cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) Cl- currents inwardly rectifies at large positive voltages. To investigate the mechanism of inward rectification, we studied CFTR Cl- channels in excised inside-out membrane patches from cells expressing wild-type human and murine CFTR using voltage-ramp and -step protocols. Using a voltage-ramp protocol, the magnitude of human CFTR Cl- current at +100 mV was 74 +/- 2% (n = 10) of that at -100 mV. This rectification of macroscopic CFTR Cl- current was reproduced in full by ensemble currents generated by averaging single-channel currents elicited by an identical voltage-ramp protocol. However, using a voltage-step protocol the single-channel current amplitude (i) of human CFTR at +100 mV was 88 +/- 2% (n = 10) of that at -100 mV. Based on these data, we hypothesized that voltage might alter the gating behavior of human CFTR. Using linear three-state kinetic schemes, we demonstrated that voltage has marked effects on channel gating. Membrane depolarization decreased both the duration of bursts and the interburst interval, but increased the duration of gaps within bursts. However, because the voltage dependencies of the different rate constants were in opposite directions, voltage was without large effect on the open probability (Po) of human CFTR. In contrast, the Po of murine CFTR was decreased markedly at positive voltages, suggesting that the rectification of murine CFTR is stronger than that of human CFTR. We conclude that inward rectification of CFTR is caused by a reduction in i and changes in gating kinetics. We suggest that inward rectification is an intrinsic property of the CFTR Cl- channel and not the result of pore block.     

Conformational changes in a pore-lining helix coupled to cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator channel gating

Cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR), the protein dysfunctional in cystic fibrosis, is unique among ATP-binding cassette transporters in that it functions as an ion channel. In CFTR, ATP binding opens the channel, and its subsequent hydrolysis causes channel closure. We studied the conformational changes in the pore-lining sixth transmembrane segment upon ATP binding by measuring state-dependent changes in accessibility of substituted cysteines to methanethiosulfonate reagents. Modification rates of three residues (resides 331, 333, and 335) near the extracellular side were 10-1000-fold slower in the open state than in the closed state. Introduction of a charged residue by chemical modification at two of these positions (resides 331 and 333) affected CFTR single-channel gating. In contrast, modifications of pore-lining residues 334 and 338 were not state-dependent. Our results suggest that ATP binding induces a modest conformational change in the sixth transmembrane segment, and this conformational change is coupled to the gating mechanism that regulates ion conduction. These results may establish a structural basis of gating involving the dynamic rearrangement of transmembrane domains necessary for vectorial transport of substrates in ATP-binding cassette transporters.     

Role of pairwise interactions between M1 and M2 domains of the nicotinic receptor in channel gating

The adult form of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) consists of five subunits (alpha(2)betaepsilondelta), each having four transmembrane domains (M1-M4). The atomic model of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor shows that the pore-lining M2 domains make no extensive contacts with the rest of the transmembrane domains. However, there are several sites where close appositions between segments occur. It has been suggested that the pair alphaM1-F15' and alphaM2-L11' is one of the potential interactions between segments. To determine experimentally if these residues are interacting and to explore if this interhelical interaction is essential for channel gating, we combined mutagenesis with single-channel kinetic analysis. Mutations in alphaM1-F15' lead to profound changes in the opening rate and slighter changes in the closing rate. Channel gating is impaired as the volume of the residue increases. Rate-equilibrium linear free-energy relationship analysis reveals an approximately 70% open-state-like environment for alphaM1-F15' at the transition state of the gating reaction, suggesting that it moves early during the gating process. Replacing the residue at alphaM1-15' by that at alphaM2-11' and vice versa profoundly alters gating, but the combination of the two mutations restores gating to near normal, indicating that alphaM1-F15' and alphaM2-L11' are interchangeable. Double-mutant cycle analysis shows that these residues are energetically coupled. Thus, the interaction between M1 and M2 plays a key role in channel gating.     

Novel kinetics in the sodium conductance system predicted by the aggregation model of channel gating.

Special voltage-clamp pulse protocols are given that make differential predictions for the kinetics of models based on a simple sequential, simple cyclic, and an aggregation scheme. Detailed kinetic time-courses for the discriminating pulse protocols are numerically derived from the differential equation system that describes the aggregation model.     

Structure and gating mechanism of the α7 nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

1. Download : Download high-res image (358KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor: from molecular model to single-channel conductance

The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) is the archetypal ligand-gated ion channel. A model of the α7 homopentameric nAChR is described in which the pore-lining M2 helix bundle is treated atomistically and the remainder of the molecule is treated as a “low resolution” cylinder. The surface charge on the cylinder is derived from the distribution of charged amino acids in the amino acid sequence (excluding the M2 segments). This model is explored in terms of its predicted single-channel properties. Based on electrostatic potential profiles derived from the model, the one-dimensional Poisson-Nernst-Planck equation is used to calculate single-channel current/voltage curves. The predicted single-channel conductance is three times higher (ca. 150 pS) than that measured experimentally, and the predicted ion selectivity agrees with the observed cation selectivity of nAChR. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are used to estimate the self-diffusion coefficients (D) of water molecules within the channel. In the narrowest region of the pore, D is reduced ca. threefold relative to that of bulk water. Assuming that the diffusion of ions scales with that of water, this yields a revised prediction of the single-channel conductance (ca. 50 pS) in good agreement with the experimental value. We conclude that combining atomistic (MD) and continuum electrostatics calculations is a promising approach to bridging the gap between structure and physiology of ion channels. Received: 2 August 1999 / Revised version: 5 November 1999 / Accepted: 9 November 1999