Metabolomic profiling of wild‐type and mutant soybean root nodules using laser‐ablation electrospray ionization mass spectrometry reveals altered metabolism

The establishment of the nitrogen‐fixing symbiosis between soybean and Bradyrhizobium japonicum is a complex process. To document the changes in plant metabolism as a result of symbiosis, we utilized laser ablation electrospray ionization‐mass spectrometry (LAESI‐MS) for in situ metabolic profiling of wild‐type nodules, nodules infected with a B. japonicum nifH mutant unable to fix nitrogen, nodules doubly infected by both strains, and nodules formed on plants mutated in the stearoyl‐acyl carrier protein desaturase (sacpd‐c) gene, which were previously shown to have an altered nodule ultrastructure. The results showed that the relative abundance of fatty acids, purines, and lipids was significantly changed in response to the symbiosis. The nifH mutant nodules had elevated levels of jasmonic acid, correlating with signs of nitrogen deprivation. Nodules resulting from the mixed inoculant displayed similar, overlapping metabolic distributions within the sectors of effective (fix⁺) and ineffective (nifH mutant, fix^?) endosymbionts. These data are inconsistent with the notion that plant sanctioning is cell autonomous. Nodules lacking sacpd‐c displayed an elevation of soyasaponins and organic acids in the central necrotic regions. The present study demonstrates the utility of LAESI‐MS for high‐throughput screening of plant phenotypes. Overall, nodules disrupted in the symbiosis were elevated in metabolites related to plant defense.     

Exclusion of inefficient Bradyrhizobium japonicum serogroups by soybean genotypes

Soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] forms a symbiosis with serogroups of Bradyrhizobium japonicum that differ in their dinitrogen fixing abilities. The objectives of this study were to identify soybean genotypes that would restrict nodulation by relatively inefficient serogroups indigenous to a large portion of the southeastern USA, and then characterize the nodulation responses of selected genotypes with specific bradyrhizobial strains under controlled conditions. From field screening trials followed by controlled single and competitive inoculations of serogroups USDA 31, 76 and 110, twelve soybean genotypes out of 382 tested were identified with varying levels of exclusion abilities. Soybean nodule occupancies and nodulation characteristics were influenced by plant genotype, environment (i.e. field or greenhouse), bradyrhizobial serogroup, and location of nodules (i.e. tap or lateral root). The cultivar Centennial sustains high seed yields even though it nodulates to a high degree with the inefficient serogroup USDA 31. In contrast, data from the released cultivars Braxton, Centennial and Coker 368 indicate that they may have been selected to exclude the inefficient serogroup USDA 76 from their tap root nodules, possibly contributing to high seed yield.     

MALDI mass spectrometry‐assisted molecular imaging of metabolites during nitrogen fixation in the Medicago truncatula–Sinorhizobium meliloti symbiosis

Symbiotic associations between leguminous plants and nitrogen‐fixing rhizobia culminate in the formation of specialized organs called root nodules, in which the rhizobia fix atmospheric nitrogen and transfer it to the plant. Efficient biological nitrogen fixation depends on metabolites produced by and exchanged between both partners. The Medicago truncatula–Sinorhizobium meliloti association is an excellent model for dissecting this nitrogen‐fixing symbiosis because of the availability of genetic information for both symbiotic partners. Here, we employed a powerful imaging technique – matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI)/mass spectrometric imaging (MSI) – to study metabolite distribution in roots and root nodules of M. truncatula during nitrogen fixation. The combination of an efficient, novel MALDI matrix [1,8–bis(dimethyl‐amino) naphthalene, DMAN] with a conventional matrix 2,5–dihydroxybenzoic acid (DHB) allowed detection of a large array of organic acids, amino acids, sugars, lipids, flavonoids and their conjugates with improved coverage. Ion density maps of representative metabolites are presented and correlated with the nitrogen fixation process. We demonstrate differences in metabolite distribution between roots and nodules, and also between fixing and non‐fixing nodules produced by plant and bacterial mutants. Our study highlights the benefits of using MSI for detecting differences in metabolite distributions in plant biology.     

Identification of “nodule-specific” host proteins (nodulins) involved in the development of Rhizobium-Legume symbiosis

Infection of legume roots with Rhizobium species results in the development of a root nodule structure in which the bacteria form an intracellular symbiosis with the plant. We report here that the infection of soybean (Glycine max L.) roots with Rhizobium japonicum results in the synthesis by the plant of at least 18–20 polypeptides other than leghemoglobin during the development of root nodules. Identification of these “nodule-specific” host polypeptides (referred to as nodulins) was accomplished by two-dimensional gel analysis of the immunoprecipitates formed by a “nodule-specific” antiserum with in vitro translation products of root-nodule polysomes that are free of bacteroidal contaminations. Nodulins account for 7–11% of the total ³⁵S-methionine-labeled protein synthesized in the host cell cytoplasm, and the majority of them are of 12,000–20,000 molecular weight. These proteins are absent from the uninfected roots, bacteroids and free-living Rhizobium, and appear to be coded for by the plant genes that may be obligatory for the development of symbiosis in the legume root nodules. Analysis of nodulins in ineffective (unable to fix nitrogen) nodules developed due to Rhizobium strains SM5 and 61A24 showed that their synthesis is reduced and their expression differentially influenced by mutations in rhizobia. Two polypeptides of bacterial origin were also found to be cross-reactive with the “nodule-specific” antiserum, suggesting that they are secreted by Rhizobium into the host cell cytoplasm during symbiotic nitrogen fixation.     

Inhibition of ornithine decarboxylase activity reduces polyamine levels and growth ofAgrobacterium tumefaciens

Flavins in different compartments of effective nodules fromGlycine max cv Maple Arrow xBradyrhizobium japonicum strains were studied by spectrophotometry and chromatographic techniques. Flavins in the peribacteroid space were riboflavin (80%) and FMN (20%), as identified by TLC and HPLC. Flavin concentrations in the soybean root nodule cytoplasm, in the symbiosome space (PBS) and in the cytosol of bacteroids were monitored between 20 and 40 days post infection (d.p.i.) Between the 20th and 29th d.p.i. an at least four times higher flavin/protein ratio was found in PBS of effective nodules compared with the nodule cytoplasm. Between nitrogenase activity in the free-living state and bacterial flavin accumulation, no correlation could be observed. Flavin accumulation is not restricted to an effective symbiosis, as indicated by the analysis of ineffective nodules with strainB. japonicum RH-31 Marburg. Flavin accumulation is absent in uninfected soybean root tissue and in free-living rhizobia, thus indicating that flavin accumulation is a result of symbiotic interaction. Flavin accumulation is also missing in nodules with a hypersensitive response against the bacteria.     

Soybean ureide transporters play a critical role in nodule development,function and nitrogen export

Legumes can access atmospheric nitrogen through a symbiotic relationship with nitrogen‐fixing bacteroids that reside in root nodules. In soybean, the products of fixation are the ureides allantoin and allantoic acid, which are also the dominant long‐distance transport forms of nitrogen from nodules to the shoot. Movement of nitrogen assimilates out of the nodules occurs via the nodule vasculature; however, the molecular mechanisms for ureide export and the importance of nitrogen transport processes for nodule physiology have not been resolved. Here, we demonstrate the function of two soybean proteins – GmUPS1‐1 (XP_003516366) and GmUPS1‐2 (XP_003518768) – in allantoin and allantoic acid transport out of the nodule. Localization studies revealed the presence of both transporters in the plasma membrane, and expression in nodule cortex cells and vascular endodermis. Functional analysis in soybean showed that repression of GmUPS1‐1 and GmUPS1‐2 in nodules leads to an accumulation of ureides and decreased nitrogen partitioning to roots and shoot. It was further demonstrated that nodule development, nitrogen fixation and nodule metabolism were negatively affected in RNAi UPS1 plants. Together, we conclude that export of ureides from nodules is mediated by UPS1 proteins, and that activity of the transporters is not only essential for shoot nitrogen supply but also for nodule development and function.     

Arabinogalactan proteins during the development of soybean root nodules

In soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr.) root nodules the level of hydroxyproline-containing molecules is developmentally regulated. Hydroxyproline accumulates in both nodule cortex and medulla. In the cortex, the hydroxyproline is mainly localized in the cell wall, presumably as extensin, but in the medulla it is mainly in the soluble fraction as an arabinogalactan protein (AGP). Nodule-specific AGPs are present at early nodulation. The highest concentration of AGP is in the nodule medulla, followed by nodule cortex, uninfected roots, leaves, flowers, pods and seeds. Root nodules and all organs of the soybean plant that were tested were found to express a tissue-specific set of arabinogalactan proteins.Abbreviation AGP Arabinogalactan protein     

A small heat shock protein,GmHSP17.9, from nodule confers symbiotic nitrogen fixation and seed yield in soybean

Legume–rhizobia symbiosis enables biological nitrogen fixation to improve crop production for sustainable agriculture. Small heat shock proteins (sHSPs) are involved in multiple environmental stresses and plant development processes. However, the role of sHSPs in nodule development in soybean remains largely unknown. In the present study, we identified a nodule-localized sHSP, called GmHSP17.9, in soybean, which was markedly up-regulated during nodule development. GmHSP17.9 was specifically expressed in the infected regions of the nodules. GmHSP17.9 overexpression and RNAi in transgenic composite plants and loss of function in CRISPR-Cas9 gene-editing mutant plants in soybean resulted in remarkable alterations in nodule number, nodule fresh weight, nitrogenase activity, contents of poly β-hydroxybutyrate bodies (PHBs), ureide and total nitrogen content, which caused significant changes in plant growth and seed yield. GmHSP17.9 was also found to act as a chaperone for its interacting partner, GmNOD100, a sucrose synthase in soybean nodules which was also preferentially expressed in the infected zone of nodules, similar to GmHSP17.9. Functional analysis of GmNOD100 in composite transgenic plants revealed that GmNOD100 played an essential role in soybean nodulation. The hsp17.9 lines showed markedly more reduced sucrose synthase activity, lower contents of UDP-glucose and acetyl coenzyme A (acetyl-CoA), and decreased activity of succinic dehydrogenase (SDH) in the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle in nodules due to the missing interaction with GmNOD100. Our findings reveal an important role and an unprecedented molecular mechanism of sHSPs in nodule development and nitrogen fixation in soybean.     

Nodulins and nodulin genes of Glycine max

Summary Nodulins are organ-specific plant proteins induced during symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Nodulins play both metabolic and structural roles within infected and uninfected nodule cells. In soybean, several nodulin genes, coding for abundant nodulins, have been identified and isolated. Structural analysis of some of these genes has revealed their possible mode of regulation and the subcellar location of the protein product. Studies of ineffective symbiosis based on cultivar-strain genotype differences suggested that both partners influence the expression of nodulin genes. Concomitant with nodule organogenesis, the Rhizobium undergoes substantial differentiation leading to the accumulation of nodule-specific bacterial proteins, bacteroidins. The major structural alteration occuring in the infected cell is the formation of a membrane enclosing the bacteroid (peribacteroid membrane). A number of nodulins are specifically targetted to this membrane during endosymbiosis. The induction of nodulins and bacteroidins leads to the formation of an effective nodule. Nodulin genes can be induced in vitro by factors derived from nodules suggesting that trans-activators may be involved in derepression of the host genes necessary for Rhizobium-legume symbiosis.     

Localization of a protease in protoplast preparations in infected cells of French bean nodules

Protoplasts from infected and uninfected cells were isolated from the central nitrogen fixing tissue of French bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L. cv Contender) root nodules. Successive filtrations allowed the separation of the infected cells, whereas the small uninfected cells were isolated on a discontinuous Percoll gradient. Higher yields of intact protoplasts were obtained from young (4-week-old) nodules whereas no protoplasts could be isolated from the oldest nodules. When proteolysis was determined in the cytosolic fraction of both infected and uninfected cells, at pH 5.0 and 8.0, with leghemoglobin or azocasein as substrate, activity was present only in infected cell protoplasts and increased with nodule age. A protease with an acidic pH optimum, mainly responsible for this increasing activity, was highly purified from senescing nodules by electro-elution after nondenaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and used to produce polyclonal antibodies. Western blots of nodule protein separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and probed with purified anti-protease immunoglobulin G showed the molecular mass of the protease to be 58 kilodaltons. Blots also confirmed that protease protein was located in infected cell protoplasts only, regardless of nodule age.     

The Lotus japonicus ndxgene family is involved in nodule function and maintenance

To elucidate the function of the ndx homeobox genes during the Rhizobium-legume symbiosis, two Lotus japonicus ndxgenes were expressed in the antisense orientation under the control of the nodule-expressed promoter Psenod12 in transgenic Lotus japonicus plants. Many of the transformants obtained segregated into plants that failed to sustain proper development and maintenance of root nodules concomitant with down-regulation of the two ndx genes. The root nodules were actively fixing nitrogen 3 weeks after inoculation, but the plants exhibited a stunted growth phenotype. The nodules on such antisense plants had under-developed vasculature and lenticels when grown on medium lacking nitrogen sources. These nodules furthermore entered senescence earlier than the wild-type nodules. Normal plant growth was resumed upon external addition of nitrogen. This suggests that assimilated nitrogen is not properly supplied to the plants in which the two ndx genes are down-regulated. The results presented here, indicate that the ndx genes play a role in the development of structural nodule features, required for proper gas diffusion into the nodule and/or transport of the assimilated nitrogen to the plant.     

Visualization of symbiotic tissue in intact root nodules of Vicia tetrasperma using GFP-marked Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae

In rhizobial symbiosis with legume plant hosts, the symbiotic tissue in the root nodules of indeterminate type is localized to the basal part of the nodule where the symbiotic zones contain infected cells (IC) interspersed with uninfected cells (UC) that are devoid of rhizobia. Although IC are easily distinguished in nodule sections using standard histochemical techniques, their observation in intact nodules is hampered by nodule tissue characteristics. Tagging of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae strain 128C30 with a constitutively expressed gene for green fluorescent protein (nonshifted mutant form cycle3) in combination with the advantages of the tiny nodules formed by Vicia tetrasperma (L.) SCHREB: . allowed for vital observation of symbiotic tissue using fluorescence microscopy. Separation of a red-shifted background channel and digital image stacking along z-axis enabled us to construct a nodule image in a classical fluorescence microscopy of nodules exceeding 1 mm in diameter. In parallel, visualization of nodule bacteria inside the symbiotic tissue by confocal microscopy at the excitation wavelength 488 nm clearly distinguished IC/UC pattern in the nodule virtual sections and revealed red-shifted fluorescence of nonrhizobial origin. This signal was located on the periphery of IC and increased with their degradation, thus suggesting accumulation of secondary metabolites, presumably flavonoids. The simultaneous detection of bacteria and secondary metabolites can be used for monitoring changes to intact nodule physiology in the model legumes. The advantage of V. tetrasperma as a suggested laboratory model for pea cross-inoculation group has been demonstrated.     

The occurrence of leghemoglobin protein in the uninfected interstitial cells of soybean root nodules

The distribution of leghemoglobin (Lb) in resin-embedded root nodules of soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr.) was investigated using immunogold labeling. Using anti-Lb immunoglobulin G and protein A-gold, Lb or its apoprotein was detected both in cells infected by Bradyrhizobium japonicum and in uninfected interstitial cells. Leghemoglobin was present in the cytoplasm, exclusive of the organelles, and in the nuclei of both cell types. In a comparison of the density of labeling in adjacent pairs of infected and uninfected cells, Lb was found to be about four times more concentrated in infected cells. This is the first report of Lb in uninfected cells of any legume nodule; it raises the possibility that this important nodule-specific protein may participate in mediating oxygen flow to host plant organelles throughout the infected region of the nodule.Abbreviations BSA bovine serum albumin - IgG immunoglobulin G - kDA kilodalton - Lb leghemoglobin - TBST Tris-buffered saline plus Tween 20