THE PROLIFERATIVE STATUS OF INTESTINAL EPITHELIAL CLONOGENIC CELLS: SENSITIVITY TO S PHASE SPECIFIC CYTOTOXI CAGENTS

High concentrations of tritiated thymidine and cytosine arabinoside (Ara-C) have been used to selectively kill cells in the crypts of Lieberkuhn that are synthesizing DNA. The effect of these agents on the number of regenerating microcolonies seen 3-J days after a range of radiation doses indicates that a majority of the clono-genic cells are proliferating rapidly and that the slowly proliferating cells at the base of the crypt do not represent the whole clonogenic population.     

Hyperproliferative response of a monoclonal memory CD8 T cell population is characterized by an increased frequency of clonogenic precursors

Strong memory T cell responses result partly from the selection of Ag-specific clones during immunization. In this study, we show that a monoclonal CD8 T cell population expressing a unique TCR is heterogeneous in terms of clonogenic potential following activation under optimal conditions. More importantly, the frequency of clonogenic cells is strongly increased among Ag-experienced cells, indicating that these cells were either generated or selected during the in vivo primary response. Moreover, strong proliferative responses of primed cells result from this enhanced frequency, as proliferating naive and primed cells display the same cycling parameters, i.e., lag time and intermitotic interval. Hence, these results suggest that the clonogenic potential of individual cells is imprinted before Ag encounter and that clonogenic precursors are selected or generated following in vivo activation.     

Research on the factors determining cellular clonogenic capacity following fractional irradiation by the method of computer simulation modelling

Methods of multifactor dispersion analysis of variance of the results of imitation model tests were used to estimate the factors that influence the clonogenic capacity of cells after fractionated irradiation. The "interval between fractions" and "the share of cells at G0" were the major factors at different ratios between radioresistance and efficiency of repair of resting and proliferating cells.     

Delayed reproductive death and ROS levels in the progeny of irradiated melanoma cells

The cell death and survival of proliferating (clonogenic) cells were investigated in two human melanoma cell lines to assess the optimal conditions for preparation of apoptotic bodies from melanoma cells. After 50 J/m2 UVB+UVC the maximal levels of apoptotic cells assayed by Trypan blue staining, nucleosomal DNA fragmentation, MTT, and TUNEL tests were observed within 2-3 d of radiation. In 100 Gy gamma-irradiated cultures these apoptosis indicators were delayed for up to 3 weeks. In addition, clonogenic cells were observed only in exponentially growing cultures irradiated with UV at high cell density but not in gamma-irradiated cultures. The response of melanoma cultures after high UV radiation doses contrasted to the response in lethally gamma-irradiated cultures. UV-irradiated melanoma cultures were recovered within two weeks. Most of the clonogenic cells in the recovered colonies contained micronuclei. ROS levels determined by DCF fluorescence and a modified MTT test were also normalized obviously due to the extensive antioxidant defense system of melanoma cells. UV radiation of tumor cells might be the preferential method for preparation of apoptotic bodies. The presence of clonogenic cells in the suspension of apoptotic bodies from melanoma cells used for pulsing of dendritic cells with tumor antigens might compromise this protocol for preparation of cell vaccines.     

Functional characterization of human thymocytes: a limiting dilution analysis of precursors with proliferative and cytolytic activities

In this report we have analyzed the pool size of human thymocytes capable of proliferating or mediating cytolytic activity. Furthermore, the relationship between these functional capabilities and cell surface antigen expression was studied. Graded numbers of human thymocytes were plated under limiting dilution conditions with irradiated human spleen cells (as a source of feeder cells) and phytohemagglutinin (PHA) in the presence of a saturating concentration of interleukin 2. Cell proliferation, which was evaluated after 20 days of culture, was usually compared with the proliferation of peripheral blood T cell populations cultured under identical conditions. Although essentially all peripheral blood T cells were clonogenic, only 3 to 8% of thymocytes proliferated. Of proliferating microcultures, 48 to 86% showed cytolytic activity in a PHA-dependent assay, whereas 26 to 83% killed the NK-sensitive target cell K-562 in the absence of added lectin. Similar frequency analysis of functional precursors was performed on thymocyte subsets selected according to their expression of T3, T6, T4, and T8 antigens. All precursors of proliferating cells (PTL-P) were found in the T3+ subset. From the comparison of the percentages of total thymocytes capable of proliferation and the proportion of cells brightly stained with anti-T3 antibody, it was evident that only a fraction of T3+ cells was clonogenic. Although the large majority of PTL-P was found in the T6- subpopulation, a small fraction of functional precursors was detected in the T6+ subset. When thymocytes were fractionated according to T4 or T8 antigen expression, it was found that 80 to 90% of the recovered PTL-P were confined to the T4+ fraction, whereas only 20 to 28% of the recovered PTL-P were present in the T8+ subset. Analysis of the precursors of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL-P) in thymocyte populations fractionated according to T4 or T8 antigen expression showed that 70 to 90% of the recovered CTL-P were found in the T4+ fraction and 17 to 30% were in the T8+ subset. Because approximately 80% of proliferating T4+ thymocytes had CTL activity (as compared with less than 5% in peripheral blood T4+ lymphocytes), it appears that the subset distribution of thymic CTL-P differs from that of peripheral blood T cells.     

Estimates of the number of clonogenic cells in crypts of murine small intestine

There is a proliferative cell hierarchy in the mouse intestinal crypt with ancestral stem cells which can regenerate all components of the lineage after injury (clonogenic cells). The number of these clonogenic or regenerative cells per crypt can be estimated from radiobiological experiments where doses of radiation are used to kill cells and ablate crypts. Various approaches can be adopted which provide different estimates of this number of cells. One of the conventional approaches used in the past provided estimates of about 70-80 clonogenic cells per crypt (i.e. about 50% of the proliferative or 30% of all crypt cells). A technically simpler approach has recently been suggested. This has been used here to provide many independent estimates of the number of crypt clonogenic cells. These suggest about 32 clonogenic cells exist per crypt i.e. about half the previous estimate and about twice the number of putative "functional" stem cells (those which operate as stem cells in the normal steady-state crypt). The reasons for the differences are discussed. The new estimates are compatible with the hypothesis that the crypt contains a ring of about 16 functional stem cells which are expected to be clonogenic, besides which there is a second ring of 16 clonogenic cells which represent early transit cells (the immediate daughters of the stem cells) which can act as clonogenic cells if required after radiation injury.     

A clonogenic survival assay of neural stem cells in rat spinal cord after exposure to ionizing radiation

Neural stem cells play an important role in neurogenesis of the adult central nervous system (CNS). Inhibition of neurogenesis has been suggested to be an underlying mechanism of radiation-induced CNS damage. Here we developed an in vivo/ in vitro clonogenic assay to characterize the survival of neural stem cells after exposure to ionizing radiation. Cells were isolated from the rat cervical spinal cord and plated as single cell suspensions in defined medium containing epidermal growth factor and basic fibroblast growth factor. The survival of the proliferating cells was determined by their ability to form neurosphere colonies. The number and size of neurospheres were analyzed quantitatively at day 10, 12, 14 and 16 after plating. Plating cells from 5, 10 and 15 mm of the cervical spinal cord resulted in a linear increase in the number of neurospheres from day 10-16. Compared to the nonirradiated spinal cord, there was a significant decrease in the number and size of neurosphere colonies cultured from a 10-mm length of the rat spinal cord after a single dose of 5 Gy. When dissociated neurospheres derived from a spinal cord that had been irradiated with 5 Gy were allowed to differentiate, the percentages of neurons, oligodendrocytes and astrocytes as determined by immunocytohistochemistry were not altered compared to those from the nonirradiated spinal cord. Secondary neurospheres could be obtained from cells dissociated from primary neurospheres that had been cultured from the irradiated spinal cord. In conclusion, exposure to ionizing radiation reduces the clonogenic survival of neural stem cells cultured from the rat spinal cord. However, neural stem cells retain their pluripotent and self-renewing properties after irradiation. A neurosphere-based assay may provide a quantitative measure of the clonogenic survival of neural stem cells in the adult CNS after irradiation.     

The density of clonogenic cells in human solid tumors

Considering that tumors are maintained by clonogenic cells, and that the primary target in the therapy of cancer is the clonogenic cell, the density of clonogens in a tumor could become an important parameter in quantitating the response to therapy. Indirect methods for determining the density of clonogenic cells in human tumors based on the response of tumors to radiation suggest there are circa 1 X 10(5) clonogens per gram with a large range. Direct methods, based on the measurement of cloning efficiency of enzymatically disaggregated biopsies of human tumors in soft agar, suggest a clonogen density of approximately 1,500 clonogens per gram. As this value is inconsistent with the prior data, we chose to determine the density of clonogenic cells in human tumors by assaying the enzyme digest of biopsies of human tumors for clonogenic cells using an enriched monolayer clonogenic assay. We determined the average clonogen density to be 1.12 x 10(5) clonogens per gram with a large range. The agreement with the indirect method suggests that the enriched monolayer clonogenic assay supports the proliferation of the cell population responsible for maintaining the tumor.     

Tumor cells can escape DNA-damaging cisplatin through DNA endoreduplication and reversible polyploidy

Cancer chemotherapy can induce tumor regression followed, in many cases, by relapse in the long-term. Thus this study was performed to assess the determinants of such phenomenon using an in vivo cancer model and in vitro approaches. When animals bearing an established tumor are treated by cisplatin, the tumor initially undergoes a dramatic shrinkage and is characterized by giant tumor cells that do not proliferate but maintain DNA synthesis. After several weeks of latency, the tumor resumes its progression and consists of small proliferating cells. Similarly, when tumor cells are exposed in vitro to pharmacological concentrations of cisplatin, mitotic activity stops initially but cells maintain DNA duplication. This DNA endoreduplication generates giant polyploid cells that then initiate abortive mitoses and can die through mitotic catastrophe. However, many polyploid cells survive for weeks as non-proliferating mono- or multi-nucleated giant cells which acquire a senescence phenotype. Prolonged observation of these cells sheds light on the delayed emergence of a limited number of extensive colonies which originate from polyploid cells, as demonstrated by cell sorting analysis. Theses colonies are made of small diploid cells which differ from parental cells by stereotyped chromosomal aberrations and an increased resistance to cytotoxic drugs. These data suggest that a multistep pathway, including DNA endoreduplication, polyploidy, then depolyploidization and generation of clonogenic escape cells can account for tumor relapse after initial efficient chemotherapy.     

Regrowth kinetics of cells from different regions of multicellular spheroids of four cell lines

A basic understanding of the recruitment of quiescent tumor cells into the cell cycle would be an important contribution to tumor biology and therapy. As a first step in pursuing this goal, we have investigated the regrowth kinetics of cells from different regions in multicellular spheroids of rodent and human origin. Cells were isolated from four different depths within the spheroids using a selective dissociation technique. The outer cells were proliferating and resumed growth after replating with a 0-8-hour lag period, similar to cells from exponentially growing monolayers. With increasing depth of origin, the lag periods prior to regrowth increased to 2-3 times the monolayer doubling time; cells from plateau-phase monolayers showed a lag period of 1-1.5 times the doubling period. After resuming growth, all cells of a given cell line grew with the same doubling time and achieved the same confluency level. The inner spheroid cells and cells from plateau-phase monolayers had reduced clonogenic efficiencies. The inner cells were initially 1.5-3 times smaller than the outer cells, but began to increase in volume within 4 hours of replating. The fractions of S-phase cells were greatly decreased with increasing depth of origin in the spheroids; there were long delays prior to S-phase recovery after plating, to a maximum of 1-1.5 times the normal doubling time. These results suggest that those quiescent cells from spheroids and monolayers which are able to reenter the cell cycle are predominantly in the G1-phase. However, quiescent cells from the innermost spheroid region require approximately twice as long to enter normal cell cycle traverse as cells from plateau-phase monolayers. The selective dissociation method can isolate very pure populations of proliferating and quiescent cells in a rapid and nonperturbing manner; this system will be valuable in further characterizing quiescent cells from spheroids.     

Circadian rhythms in the incidence of apoptotic cells and number of clonogenic cells in intestinal crypts after radiation using normal and reversed light conditions

Variations in the number of radiation-induced morphologically dead or dying cells (apoptotic cells) in the crypts in the small intestine of the mouse have been studied throughout a 24-h period under a normal light regimen (light on, 07.00-19.00 h; light off, 19.00-07.00 h). A clear circadian rhythm was displayed in the apoptotic incidence 3 or 6 h after irradiation for each gamma-ray dose studied (range 0.14-9.0 Gy). The most prominent circadian rhythm was obtained after 0.5 Gy. The peak time of day for inducing apoptosis was 06.00-09.00 h, and the trough occurred at 18.00-21.00 h. Some mice were also transferred to a room with the light cycle reversed, and were irradiated on different days after the transfer. The apoptosis induced by 0.5 Gy or 9.0 Gy, or the number of surviving crypts (microcolonies) after 11.0 Gy or 13.0 Gy was examined. The transition point for reversal (i.e. the switch time from the normal-light pattern to the reversed-light pattern) of the circadian rhythm in apoptosis (after 0.5 Gy) occurred 7 days after the transfer and the rhythm was reversed by 14 days. The rhythm for crypt survival (i.e. for clonogenic cell radiosensitivity) was disturbed on 1 day and the transition point for reversal occurred 3 days after the transfer. The rhythm became reversed by 7 days. These observations are discussed in relation to the identity of clonogenic cells, (functional) stem cells, proliferating transit cells and the cells sensitive to small doses of radiation (i.e. hypersensitive cells) in the crypt.     

In vitro holding and PLD repair

Summary The Stationary or Plateau-Phase of commonly used rodent cell lines like the V79 are often assumed to be quiescent (non-mitotic). An analysis of cell turnover in V79 plateau-phase cultures through BrUdR-incorporation combined with FUdR-block and light exposure (S-phase cytocide) revealed such cultures to be in a state of kinetic equilibrium. Even when the state of maximal permissible density was acquired, at least 50% of the population of cells were cycling within the time for one population doubling. Attempts at holding the cells from cycling (through nutrient-depletion and serum-privation) were unsuccessful, although the turnover-rate was reduced. Our assays for X-irradiated clonogenic survivors after attempted holding combined with delayed plating (DP) showed differences in the survival curves for exponentially growing and confluent cultures. Elimination of cycling cells by S-phase cytocide removed these differences. Since a significant fraction of plateau-phase cells are not mitotically quiescent (Q), one must eliminate the proliferating (P) fraction if one wishes to examine the PLDR of the Q cells. For V79 cells, removal of the P cells eliminates the higher survival (usually interpreted as Q cell PLDR) of plateau-phase cells.     

Effects of radiation on normal tissues: Hypothetical mechanisms and limitations of in situ assays of clonogenicity

Summary It is argued that proliferating normal tissues fall into two categories. In type H (for hierarchical) tissues, cells either multiply or perform tissue-specific functions. Sterilizing doses of radiation immediately initiate a gradual depopulation of irreversibly postmitotic, mature cells. The constant rate of functional cell depletion is given by physiological longevity of the cells. Consequently the onset of maximal depopulation is dose-independent and, after a range of radiation doses, the peak of milder damage is seen earlier than that of a more severe one. In type F (for flexible) tissues all cells are assumed to have the potential for proliferation and are also engaged in tissue-specific functions. Radiation leads to dose-dependent loss of the functional cells through their mitotic death, both immediately after exposure and during the next phase of increased compensatory proliferation resulting in accelerated expression of radiation damage (avalanche). Consequently the more severe damage following larger doses of radiation is seen earlier than the milder one produced with smaller doses.Assays of cell clonogenicity in vivo concern almost exclusively type H populations. The large radiation/drug/heat doses administered in these assays serve both to dilute the clonogenic cells by at least two orders of magnitude, and to produce a measurable response. When comparing two agents or interpreting their combined action it is advisable to ensure that the dilution step yields qualitatively comparable samples of clonogenic cells to be then characterized in terms of dose-survival curve parameters.Read at the Fifteenth Annual Meeting of the European Society for Radiation Biology (Rotterdam, 25th–29th August, 1980)     

Ionizing Irradiation Not Only Inactivates Clonogenic Potential in Primary Normal Human Diploid Lens Epithelial Cells but Also Stimulates Cell Proliferation in a Subset of This Population

Over the past century, ionizing radiation has been known to induce cataracts in the crystalline lens of the eye, but its mechanistic underpinnings remain incompletely understood. This study is the first to report the clonogenic survival of irradiated primary normal human lens epithelial cells and stimulation of its proliferation. Here we used two primary normal human cell strains: HLEC1 lens epithelial cells and WI-38 lung fibroblasts. Both strains were diploid, and a replicative lifespan was shorter in HLEC1 cells. The colony formation assay demonstrated that the clonogenic survival of both strains decreases similarly with increasing doses of X-rays. A difference in the survival between two strains was actually insignificant, although HLEC1 cells had the lower plating efficiency. This indicates that the same dose inactivates the same fraction of clonogenic cells in both strains. Intriguingly, irradiation enlarged the size of clonogenic colonies arising from HLEC1 cells in marked contrast to those from WI-38 cells. Such enhanced proliferation of clonogenic HLEC1 cells was significant at ≥2 Gy, and manifested as increments of ≤2.6 population doublings besides sham-irradiated controls. These results suggest that irradiation of HLEC1 cells not only inactivates clonogenic potential but also stimulates proliferation of surviving uniactivated clonogenic cells. Given that the lens is a closed system, the stimulated proliferation of lens epithelial cells may not be a homeostatic mechanism to compensate for their cell loss, but rather should be regarded as abnormal. This is because these findings are consistent with the early in vivo evidence documenting that irradiation induces excessive proliferation of rabbit lens epithelial cells and that suppression of lens epithelial cell divisions inhibits radiation cataractogenesis in frogs and rats. Thus, our in vitro model will be useful to evaluate the excessive proliferation of primary normal human lens epithelial cells that may underlie radiation cataractogenesis, warranting further investigations.     

The influence of cellular proliferative history on the susceptibility to oncogenic transformation

C3H mouse 10T½ clone 8 cells were serially transferred from passage 11 to 15 with 5 × 10⁴ cells seeded per 60-mm dish at each passage. One group of cells was passaged as soon as confluence was reached. Two other groups were kept for 3 or 6 days in confluence at each passage before subculture. Cloning efficiency was found to increase progressively with passage of all three groups. At the 15th passage, cells from all three groups were harvested just prior to confluence, irradiated with ultraviolet light, and assayed for clonogenic survival and malignant transformation. Survival response was the same for all three groups, but cells which were kept constantly proliferating in previous passages were found to be much more susceptible to transformation. These results suggest that the susceptibility of these cells to transformation is influenced by their proliferative history; in particular, intermittent growth quiescence in previous passages decreased this susceptibility.     

Terminally differentiated postmitotic tumor cells in a rat rhabdomyosarcoma cell line

A permanent rat rhabdomyosarcoma cell line (BA-HAN-1C) has been established, the phenotype of which is characterized by the coexistence of undifferentiated mononuclear cells and differentiated multinuclear myotube-like giant cells. The failure of attempts to separate these two cell types by repeated recloning procedures indicates their close histogenetic relationship and suggests that differentiation in this tumor proceeds in a similar manner to that in normal striated muscle where postmitotic myotubes arise from mononuclear myoblasts by fusion. The morphologically undifferentiated mononuclear tumor cells were shown to be actively proliferating and to incorporate thymidine methyl-3H(3H-TdR). The myotube-like giant cells neither incorporated 3H-TdR nor underwent mitosis or exhibited any clonogenic potential. After retransplantation into syngenic rats, tumor growth was markedly retarded when the tumor cell inoculum contained a high percentage of myotube-like giant cells. These data show that proliferative activity in this rhabdomyosarcoma cell line is confined to the mononuclear tumor cell compartment, the multinuclear myotube-like giant cells having withdrawn from the cell cycle and represent terminally differentiated postmitotic cells. This cell line should provide a valuable tool for further investigation of coherent aspects of proliferation and differentiation using various differentiation inducers.     

The Proliferative Status of Microcolony-Forming Cells In Mouse Small Intestine

Abstract The technique of thymidine (TdR) suicide has been used with the intestinal microcolony assay to demonstrate that in the middle of the light cycle, nearly all intestinal clonogenic cells, in the B6D2F₁ mice used in these experiments, were not in S phase. Doses of tritiated thymidine [³H]TdR up to 1 mCi/mouse did not kill a significant fraction of those clonogenic cells which survived a test dose of 12 Gy γ-rays. This finding supports some data in the literature, but conflicts with others. However, the suicide technique was found in the studies reported here to be very efficient in sterilizing clonogenic cells in the middle of the dark cycle, and also in a regenerating epithelium at day 3 after a dose of 9 Gy. This implies that the technique can discriminate well between populations of clonogenic cells which differ in their content of cells in S phase. the lack of a suicide effect in the middle of the light cycle indicates that the majority of proliferative epithelial cells are not clonogenic.