Differential cytotoxicity of activated lymphocytes on allogeneic and xenogeneic target cells. II. Activation by phytohemagglutinin

In the preceding paper it has been shown that human or mouse lymphocytes stimulated by a variety of agents, damaged allogeneic target cells while damage of xenogeneic target cells was weak or absent. In this study, the species specificity of the cytotoxicity of PHA activated lymphocytes has been studied in greater detail. Effector cells were purified lymphocytes either from human peripheral blood, or from spleen or lymph nodes of inbred mice. Target cells were ⁵¹Cr-labeled human Chang liver cells or mouse L cells.PHA stimulated human or mouse lymphocytes were significantly more cytotoxic to allogeneic than to xenogeneic target cells. At low PHA doses at which damage of allogeneic target cells was significant, damage of xenogeneic target cells was very weak or absent. At higher PHA doses, damage of xenogeneic target cells became also significant but always remained at a lower level than that of allogeneic target cells.Prestimulation of human lymphocytes with PHA for 3 days increased their cytotoxic efficiency. Furthermore, damage of human Chang cells by human lymphocytes had a dose-response relationship similar to that valid for stimulation of DNA synthesis. However, damage of mouse L cells by human lymphocytes increased at PHA-doses at which stimulation of DNA-synthesis declined. For mouse lymphocytes, these doseresponse relationships were less clear-cut, probably due to differences in origin and survival of the effector cells. This confirms previous observations that cytotoxicity and DNA-synthesis are different but probably interdependent expressions of lymphocyte activation.     

Differential cytotoxicity of activated lymphocytes on allogeneic and xenogeneic target cells. I. Activation by tuberculin and by Staphylococcus filtrate

Normal lymphocytes activated by mitogens such as phytohemagglutinin (PHA), by Staphylococcus filtrate (SF), or lymphocytes from sensitized individuals stimulated by antigen (PPD, etc.) are cytotoxic to tissue culture cells of different origins. In this and the following paper, the results of a detailed quantitative analysis of the specificity of this cytotoxic reaction are presented. Effector cells were human or mouse lymphocytes, activated by PHA, SF, PPD, or serum factors in the culture medium. Cells from established cell lines of human, mouse, hamster, or rabbit origin, or primary human or rat embryonic fibroblasts were used as target cells. Lysis was quantitated by release of ⁵¹Cr from labeled target cells.Purified human blood lymphocytes, activated by PPD, SF, or otherwise, preferentially damaged allogeneic target cells. Lysis of xenogeneic target cells was weak or did not occur. A close correlation was noted between target cell destruction and blastoid transformation of the lymphocytes, but the slope of the regression lines of xenogeneic cytotoxicity was much smaller than that of allogeneic cytotoxicity when plotted as a function of blastoid transformation.Lymph node or spleen cells from CBA mice were stimulated by PPD to transformation and DNA synthesis. CBA lymphocytes also showed an increased degree of blast transformation in medium containing fetal calf serum or certain batches of fresh human serum. Mouse lymphocytes activated in these ways damaged allogeneic L cells but had no effects on xenogeneic Chang cells.These results indicate that lymphocytes activated by various means preferentially damage target cells from their own species. The recognition mechanisms which determine the specificity of the reactions are not known.     

In vitro allogeneic cytotoxicity in the solitary urochordate Styela clava.

Hemocytes from the solitary urochordate Styela clava can effect allogeneic cytotoxicity in vitro. Spectrophotometric and microscopic quantification of eosin-y dye exclusion revealed significantly greater frequencies of cell death in allogeneic hemocyte cultures when compared to autogeneic controls. This cytotoxic response was characterized by 1) transient activity such that specific cytotoxicity could be detected for only 4 hours of culture though continued specific killing may have been obscured by spontaneous cell death; 2) a necessity for cellular interaction demonstrated by the elimination of allogeneic cytotoxicity in the absence of cell contact; 3) killing of multiple targets by effector cells due to high levels of response at low allogeneic ratios; 4) insensitivity to altered temperature; 5) increased cytotoxicity in the absence of autologous plasma; 6) an absence of xenogeneic reactivity; 7) the presence of three hierarchical levels (low, intermediate, and high) of response. These data reflect events involved in the recognition of allogeneic cellular determinants resulting in specific cytotoxicity effected by immunocompetent cells. Such in vitro recognition and cytotoxic recognition and cytotoxic reactivity may be responsible for adaptive reactions caused by histoincompatibility in solitary tunicates.     

Alloantibody-induced cytotoxicity of macrophages.

Alloantibodies substantially alter the in vitro nonspecific cytotoxic effect of macrophages on bystanding allogeneic and xenogeneic target cells. Although the specific IgM alloantibody increased significantly the ability to parental macrophages to damage target cells, IgG alloantibody had an opposite effect and suppressed the macrophage cytotoxicity. Macrophages of F1 hybrid mice were less affected by this treatment unless alloantibodies against both parental strains were added together. Parental macrophages exposed in vitro to the concomitant action of both IgM and IgG alloantibodies exhibited a diminished cytotoxicity toward target cells. It is proposed that IgM and IgG alloantibodies induce different conformational changes of the macrophage surface.     

Graft-versus-host reactivity of mouse thymocytes: effect of in vitro treatment with anti-TL serum.

The lymph ducts efferent from prefemoral nodes of sheep were cannulated and the lymph flow monitored during immune responses to injected allogeneic lymphocytes or xenogeneic murine P815 mastocytoma cells. Changes in the lymph began 5–6 days after injection of allogeneic cells but at 3–4 days after injection of xenogeneic cells, in both systems the number of large cells in the lymph increased to reach peak values of up to 40% of the total. The in vitro cytotoxic activity of lymph cells, cell supernatants, or cell free lymph was determined by measuring the release of ⁵¹Cr from prelabeled target lymphocytes or P815 cells. The cytotoxic mechanisms that were detected in the allogeneic and xenogeneic systems were similar; in both cases the lymph cells were cytotoxic only during the large cell response, and when the immunoblast numbers had returned to normal levels in the lymph no further cell-mediated cytotoxic effects were detected. During the blast response lymphocytes alone caused some target cell damage but their cytotoxic effector function was greatly increased in cultures containing complement or normal blood white cells. It was concluded that the lymph immunoblasts caused some target cell damage by direct action, but the majority of their cytotoxic activity was associated with synthesis and secretion of complement-dependent antibody (C.D.A.) and leukocyte-dependent antibody (L.D.A.).     

LY-2+ effectors cytotoxic for syngeneic tumor cells: generation by allogeneic stimulation and by supernatants from mixed leukocyte cultures

The present study was aimed at gaining insight into means by which stimulation of mouse spleen cells with allogeneic normal cells in mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC) can result in the generation of effector cells cytotoxic for syngeneic tumor or transformed cells. Stimulation of lymphocytes from BALB/c or C3H mice for 5 days with cells from mice of every allogeneic strain tested, in medium containing mouse serum and lacking xenogeneic serum, resulted in the activation of effectors cytotoxic for syngeneic cells transformed spontaneously or by SV40, polyoma or adenovirus. In each experiment, all of the syngeneic transformed cell lines, as well as clones derived from these lines, were lysed to the highest degree by effectors obtained from the same culture, and therefore stimulated with cells from the same allogeneic strain. Although the particular allogeneic sensitizing strain that induced the highest cytolytic activity varied between experiments, effectors obtained from the culture with the highest cell recovery always exhibited the greatest cytotoxicity against all the syngeneic transformed cells and clones. Lysis was mediated predominantly by Ly-2+ effectors; total lytic units of cytotoxicity recovered after treatment with monoclonal anti-Ly-2 antibody and complement (C) were reduced by 85 to 90% compared to cells treated with C alone. Lysis of syngeneic tumor cells by the allosensitized effectors in cytotoxicity assays was not inhibited by the addition of unlabeled "blocking" lymphocytes from the allogeneic strain used for sensitization. In addition, it was found that lymphocytes cultured without stimulating cells for 5 days in medium supplemented with supernatants from secondary MLC that are known to contain high levels of lymphokines, mediated high levels of cytotoxicity on all the transformed cells tested, but lacked detectable cytotoxic activity for syngeneic or allogeneic Con A blasts. The MLC supernatant-activated effectors that lyse the transformed cells are phenotypically CTL, because treatment with anti-Ly-2 and C reduced lytic activity by approximately 75%. Taken together, these findings suggest that the generation in MLC of Ly-2+ effector cells cytotoxic for syngeneic transformed cell lines might not be due, in some cases, to lymphocyte responses to particular alloantigens on the stimulating cells that are cross-reactive with "alien" histocompatibility antigens on transformed cells, but rather is due to effector cell activation by lymphokines produced during allogeneic stimulation.     

Cytotoxic activities of fish leucocytes

Like mammalian leucocytes, white blood cells of fish are able to kill altered (e.g. virus-infected) and foreign (allogeneic or xenogeneic) cells. The existence of natural killer (NK)-like and specific cytotoxic cells in fish was first shown using allogeneic and xenogeneic effector/target cell systems. In addition to in vivo and ex vivo studies, very important contributions were made by in vitro analysis using a number of different long-term cytotoxic cell lines established from channel catfish. In mammals, specific cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CMC) as part of the adaptive immune response requires a number of key molecules expressed on effector leucocytes and target cells. CD8+ T lymphocytes kill infected cells only, if their antigen receptor (TCR) matches the MHC class I with bound peptide of the target cell. Expression patterns of the fish gene homologues for TCR, CD8 and MHC class I, as well as related genes, are in agreement with similar function. Convenient systems for the analysis of specific CMC have only recently become available for fish with the combination of clonal fish with syngeneic or allogeneic but MHC class I matching cell lines. It was demonstrated that both, NK- and cytotoxic T (Tc) cells are involved in the killing of virus infected MHC class I matching and mismatching target cells. Analysis of these lymphocyte subsets is only starting for fish. There is also evidence that the different viral proteins trigger different subsets of killer cells. This review further discusses findings on fish CMC with regard to temperature/seasons and ontogeny.     

Selective elimination in vitro of alloresponsive T cells to human transplantation antigens by toxin or radionuclide conjugated anti-IL-2 receptor (Tac) monoclonal antibody

The human allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction is the in vitro correlate of graft rejection. Cytotoxic effector cells generated during an allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction were previously shown to express the human p55 IL-2 receptor subunit, whereas resting cells do not express this receptor peptide. In this study, we asked whether Pseudomonas exotoxin or bismuth-212 (an alpha-particle emitting radionuclide) coupled to the anti-IL-2 receptor mAb, anti-Tac, were able to selectively eliminate alloresponsive cells generated during an allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction. After assembly, anti-Tac immunoconjugates retained their binding integrity, specificity, and selectivity. Deletion of alloresponsive cells was shown by the removal of alloproliferating cells as assessed by quantitating cell recovery and by measurement of thymidine incorporation into newly synthesized DNA. Both toxin and radionuclide immunoconjugates eliminated established cytotoxic effector cells generated in an allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction, while leaving intact the PHA-inducible mitogenic response of the nonactivated cells. The addition of excess anti-Tac blocked all of the effects of these cytotoxic reagents. The therapeutic reagents in vitro were most effective when added just prior to the peak of the alloproliferative response, when receptor expression would be close to maximum. Thus, anti-Tac conjugated either with toxin or radionuclide is effective in vitro in specifically eliminating cytotoxic effector cells.     

Induction of preferential cytotoxicity against allogeneic mouse lymphoma cells: in vitro and in vivo studies

The aim of this study was to activate, in mixed leukocyte/tumor cell cultures (MLTC), cytotoxic lymphocytes exhibiting preferential activity in vitro and in vivo towards allogeneic mouse lymphoma cells. Whereas the lymphoma target cells were readily lysed by the MLTC-derived lymphocytes, the cytotoxicity against the corresponding allogeneic concanavalin-A(ConA)-induced lymphoblasts was more than tenfold lower. Both activities were mediated by CD3⁺, TCR⁺, CD8⁺, CD4⁻ cytotoxic T cells (CTL). ConA-induced lymphoblasts were readily lysed by anti-Thy1.2 antibodies and complement, by CTL derived from mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC) and by the MLTC-derived CTL in the presence of ConA, indicating that the lymphoblasts are not merely less lysable than the lymphoma cells but that the latter are specifically recognized by the CTL. Lymphoblasts poorly competed with ⁵¹Cr-labeled lymphoma cells in a “cold”-target competition assay, suggesting that the MLTC-derived CTL largely recognize epitopes expressed only by the lymphoma cells. Furthermore, analysis of the cytotoxic activity of more than 500 MLTC-derived CTL oligoclones and over 30 clones revealed that one-third of them were cytotoxic only against the allogeneic lymphoma cells, one-third were reactive against both the lymphoma and the allogeneic lymphoblast target cells and the remainder were not cytotoxic at all. Upon injection into sublethally irradiated, lymphoma-bearing allogeneic mice, the MLTC-derived CTL cured 56% of the recipients and caused graft versus host disease (GVHD) is only 22%, whereas CTL activated in MLC against allogeneic splenocytes were therapeutically ineffective and caused lethal GVHD in 89% of the recipients. Although the therapeutic efficacy of the in vitro-generated antitumor CTL was demonstrated against experimental lymphoma lines, this strategy might prove effective in tumor immunotherapy in conjunction with other modalities. Received: 24 December 1998 / Accepted: 5 April 1999     

Endocytosis in cytotoxic T-lymphocytes

Endocytosis in T lymphocytes was analyzed during their differentiation into cytotoxic effector cells in allogeneic mixed lymphocyte cultures. We found that endocytic activity increases from a very low value to reach a peak at Day 5, at which time the cytotoxic titer is highest in these cell cultures. Thereafter it decreases, as does cytotoxicity. Upon restimulation the T cells again exhibit markedly increased endocytic activity. The possible role of endocytosis in cytotoxic T cells is briefly discussed with regard to their differentiation and their interaction with target cells.     

Effects of in vivo priming on in vitro induction of cytotoxicity. I. Non-specific augmentation by in vivo presensitization with allogeneic or xenogeneic cells.

In vivo presensitization of donor mice of responding cells with third party cellular antigens augmented in vitro generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in allogeneic and xenogeneic combinations. In vitro induction of detectable cytotoxicity in presensitized responding cells required the incubation period needed for in vitro primary response. However, such cytotoxic T lymphocytes were generated after in vitro stimulation with monolayers of methylcholanthrene-induced tumor cells, UV-irradiated or heated spleen cells which had proved to be effective in secondary but not in primary response. Presensitized responding cells exposed to 600R-irradiation did not augment in vitro induction of cytotoxicity in normal responding cells. The augmenting effect of presensitized responding cells may be attributable to radiosensitive T cells which are in a transitional state in differentiation from typical unprimed cells to typical primed cells.     

Nonspecific cytotoxic effects of antigen-transformed lymphocytes. III. Relationship to specific cytotoxicity.

Human peripheral blood lymphocytes, cultured either with PPD or in one-way mixed leucocyte reactions, develop a nonspecific cytotoxic potential which can be expressed on autologous as well as on unrelated xenogeneic target cells. This nonspecific cytotoxicity develops at an early stage in the mixed leucocyte reaction, before specific cytotoxic effects are demonstrable, and decreases as specific cytotoxicity increases.     

Killer cells induced by stimulation with allogeneic tumor cells and subsequent culture with recombinant interleukin-2

Summary Peripheral blood lymphocytes were cultured for 5 days with allogeneic tumor cells (allogeneic mixed lymphocyte/tumor cell culture), and subsequently cultured with recombinant interleukin-2 for 12 days. These cultured cells were found to be cytotoxic to autologous tumor cells. Results of two-color analysis using monoclonal antibodies to cell markers showed that more than 80% of their cultured cells were CD3⁺ cells, and CD4⁺ cells showed a higher distribution than CD8⁺ cells. However, CD8⁺ cells had a much higher killing activity with autologous tumor than did CD4⁺ cells, when estimated by an elimination study using monoclonal antibodies to T cell phenotypes and complement. The cold-target inhibition test showed that the cytotoxicity of these cells for autologous tumor cells was inhibited by unlabeled autologous tumor cells but not by unlabeled stimulator cells. Furthermore, about 40% of the cytotoxicity was suppressed by blocking of HLA class I antigen with a monoclonal antibody on autologous tumor cells. Thus, cytotoxic activity of lymphocytes to autologous tumor restricted by target cell HLA class I antigen is possibly induced by allogeneic tumor-stimulation.     

Modulation of natural killer-mediated lysis by red blood cells

Natural killer (NK)-mediated cytotoxicity is significantly enhanced in the presence of red blood cells (RBC). The enhancement is dose dependent on the number of RBC present and can be induced by autochthonous, allogeneic, or xenogeneic RBC. The enhancement was demonstrated in cytotoxicity against two different NK-sensitive tumor target cell lines, K562 and U937, and by three different assay systems, chromium release, lactate dehydrogenase release, and inhibition of thymidine incorporation. RBC directly enhance the cytotoxic activity of NKH-1/Leu19+ large granular lymphocyte NK cells. Intact RBC have to be present during the cytotoxicity assay to induce the enhancement, which probably occurs at a postbinding, preprogramming phase. The anti-CD2 antibody Leu5 cannot block the enhancement at a concentration inhibitory to lymphocyte rosetting with sheep RBC, suggesting that the enhancement is not induced by interaction through the CD2 antigen. These results indicate that RBC are a potent modulator of NK cytotoxicity and suggest that in vitro NK studies using purified lymphocytes may not always truly reflect NK activity in the blood stream.     

Cytotoxic and proliferative lymphocyte responses to allogeneic and xenogeneic antigens in vitro.

In vitro lymphoproliferative responses to foreign histocompatibility antigens are phylogenetically restricted. Responses occur most readily to allogeneic or closely related xenogeneic leucocytes, but not to unrelated xenogeneic cells. Specific cytotoxic T cell responses to foreign histocompatibility antigens show the same phylogenetic restriction. This lack of xenoreactivity is not due to a lack of precursor cells for the xenoantigens; guinea-pig lymphocytes, although normally unresponsive to mouse antigens, have a similar precursor frequency for these antigens as do lymphocytes of allogeneic mouse strains. Specific cytotoxic responses of guinea-pig lymphocytes to mouse antigens can be generated if a factor released from con A stimulated guinea-pig spleen cells is added to the culture medium. The factor produced by con A-activated spleen cells (CS) is also phylogenetically restricted in its action; CS must be obtained from animals homologous with the donor of the responding lymphocytes.     

H-2 antigen requirements in the in vitro induction of SV40-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes

T cytotoxic cells generated to syngeneic SV40 virus transformants lyse only SV40 target cells that are syngeneic at the H-2 locus. In contrast, SV40-specific tumor transplantation immunity shows no requirements for syngeneic H-2. Inoculation of allogeneic or even xenogeneic transformants will confer immunity to a challenge of syngeneic SV40 tumor cells. The experiments described here represent an attempt to reconcile these apparently conflicting observations. In our hands, generation of SV40-specific T cytotoxic cells in vitro requires both in vivo priming and secondary in vitro sensitization. We have found that priming for a secondary syngeneic-restricted response requires only that the cell employed be SV40 transformed. That is, priming may be accomplished with syngeneic, allogeneic, or xenogeneic SV40 transformants. Thus, the apparent lack of H-2 restriction in vivo immunity does not eliminate a role for the H-2-restricted cytotoxic T cell in tumor transplantation immunity.     

Continuously proliferating T killer cells specific for H-2b targets: selection and characterization.

BALB/c (H-2d) thymus-derived lymphocytes sensitized to C57BL/6 (H-2b) alloantigens have been propagated in vitro for over 9 months. These T lymphocytes are specifically cytotoxic to H-2b target cells but are stimulated to proliferate by both H-2b and H-2k spleen cells. This indicates that for these selected cells the antigen requirements for cell proliferation are different from those for cell-mediated cytotoxicity. If not continuously stimulated with allogeneic spleen cells, the cytotoxic cultures fail to divide and rapidly lose their cytotoxic activity. Allogeneic erythrocytes do not stimulate cell proliferation in "quiescent" cell cultures and allogeneic tumor cells do so only in the presence of spleen cells. However, "quiescent" cell cultures display cytotoxicity in the presence of phytohemagglutinin A as do cell cultures which have lost their cytotoxic activity although they proliferate upon allogeneic stimulation. The significance of these findings is discussed.     

In vitro generation of effector cells cytotoxic to autologous targets from chronic myeloid leukemia patients in remission

Summary Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) patients in remission were stimulated in vitro, in a 3-cell assay with autologous leukemic cells or autologous bone marrow (BM) cells alone, or each in combination with allogeneic PBL. The responder cells were used as effectors in a 4-h ⁵¹Cr release cytotoxicity assay using autologous targets such as leukemic cells, BM cells, phytohemagglutinin-induced lymphoblasts, and allogeneic K562 (erythroblastoid leukemic cell line) target cells. Sensitization of lymphocytes from CML patients with either autologous leukemic cells or BM cells generated cytotoxic cells (CTCs) capable of killing both the targets. These results suggested that in CML, the PBL may have been sensitized to myeloid maturation-related antigens in vivo, which, on secondary stimulation in vitro, may result in differentiation of CTCs cytotoxic to immature myeloid cells, either from autologous leukemic cells or autologous BM. The inability of PBL from patients with oral cancers to lyse autologous BM cells upon in vitro stimulation, supported this possibility. Clonogenic assays conducted to assess the colony forming potential of BM cells which had interacted with CTCs indicated that there was about 37% reduction in committed granulocyte stem cell colony formation without an appreciable change in committed granulocyte/monocyte stem cell units and clusters. Therefore, since the BM toxicity of the CTCs is not very high, these cells may have a potential clinical use in CML.     

Suppressive Effect by Cooperation of Splenic and Peritoneal Adherent Cells on Generation of Cytotoxic T Lymphocytes

When spleen cells primed in vivo against allogeneic lymphoid cells were used as responder cells in secondary mixed lymphocyte cultures, a high degree of cytotoxicity was generated even in the absence of splenic adherent cells. However, removal of adherent cells from such primed responder spleen cells reduced the cytotoxicity to some extent. On the other hand, when these responder cells were transferred into the peritoneal cavity of irradiated syngeneic mice together with antigenic cells, unseparated responder cells generated a lower degree of cytotoxicity than did adherent cell-depleted responder cells. In an in vitro system, peritoneal adherent cells also suppressed the generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes by unseparated responders; however they augmented the cytotoxic T lymphocyte generation by adherent cell-depleted responders. These adherent cell populations with augmenting activity became inhibitory when they coexisted. The mechanism of this inhibitory action remains unclear.     

Cellular therapy by allogeneic macrophages against visceral leishmaniasis: Role of TNF-α

Tumor necrosis factor α (TNF-α) is an essential player in infection with Leishmania, controlling inflammatory lesion and parasite killing. We recently have shown the leishmanicidal activity of transmembrane form of TNF (mTNF) derived from allogeneic natural killer (NK) cells in experimental visceral leishmaniasis. Allogeneic macrophages and human monocytes derived mTNF has significantly higher antileishmanial activity compared to allogeneic NK cells. Unlike NK cells, syngeneic macrophages also possess antileishmanial activity, although degree of activity is significantly less compared to allogeneic macrophages. Cellular therapy by intravenous transfer of allogeneic macrophages enhances leishmanicidal effect against the established infection in susceptible animal by reducing the splenic parasite burden to 28.3 ± 4.71 × 10⁵ compared to 256.00 ± 17.36 × 10⁵ in control group. In vivo treatment with anti-mouse TNF-α reduces the therapeutic efficacy of the allogeneic macrophages by increasing the parasite load in spleen of infected mice. These results demonstrated that allogeneic and xenogeneic macrophages induce cytokine mediated protective mechanism against infected macrophages via TNF-α in vitro and, possibly in vivo. The macrophage mediated protective role in absence of T cell help demonstrate an unique property of the mononuclear phagocytes in controlling infection and inflammation in visceral leishmaniasis, despite being acts as a host cell for the same parasite.