Effect of Temperature of Incubation on Performance of Media in the Detection of Enteric Pathogens

The effect of incubation temperatures on the efficacies of both plating media and transport or enrichment broths was determined by the analysis of 391 diarrheal stools for salmonellae and shigellae. Each analysis resulted in 90 observations. Stool specimens were homogenized in saline and used to inoculate eosin methylene blue (EMB), Salmonella-Shigella (SS), and xylose lysine deoxycholate (XLD) agar plates, Amies and Cary-Blair (CB) transport media, and gram-negative (GN) enrichment broth. All media were incubated at 25, 30, and 35 C for 24 and 48 h. In order of efficacy, GN and saline were significantly better than Amies and CB, which were still better than direct streaking for both salmonellae and shigellae. Forty-eight hours was a significant improvement over 24 h only at 25 C on direct streaking for both pathogens. Salmonella detection was also improved at 30 over 25 C on direct streaking. In direct plating, XLD was better than both SS and EMB for both pathogens. After broths, for salmonellae, XLD > SS > EMB, and for shigellae, XLD > EMB > SS, with all differences significant. SS agar was significantly improved for detection of shigellae with 48-h broth inocula versus 24-h broth inocula. The differences thus observed at the various temperatures tested proved to be less important than the media used. The efficient media, GN broth, saline-stool, and XLD were shown to be affected very little by either temperature or time variance of the magnitude tested.     

Isolation of Shigellae: V. Comparison of Enrichment Broths with Stools

Many enteric media are more efficient for the detection of salmonellae than of shigellae. Comparisons of three enrichment broths and three plating media were made during analysis of 1,405 stool specimens to choose a combination of media which would enhance detection of shigellae as well. Gram-Negative (GN), Selenite, and Silliker's Broths were streaked to E M B, Salmonella-Shigella (SS), and xylose lysine deoxycholate (XLD) Agars. The enrichment broths produced a twofold increase in isolations of both salmonellae and shigellae over direct streaking. All three broths performed equally well for Salmonella detection, but GN and Silliker's produced twice as many Shigella isolates as did Selenite. Comparison of the plating media showed that XLD was markedly more efficient than either E M B or SS Agar for the recovery of both genera. SS Agar was superior to E M B for isolation of salmonellae after enrichment, whereas E M B was better for isolation of shigellae by direct streaking. Both E M B and SS were more effective when used after GN and Silliker's than after Selenite. GN Broth and XLD Agar were the most efficient combination of media. During these analyses, 158 salmonellae and 49 shigellae isolates were obtained.     

Isolation of Shigellae. VII. Comparison of Gram-Negative Broth with Rappaport''s Enrichment Broth

Efficacies of Gram Negative Broth (GN) and Rappaport's Enrichment Broth (RE) were compared for detection of enteric pathogens from clinical specimens. Whereas direct streaking on four plating media found 57% of the salmonellae, GN found 80% and RE found 92% of the 157 isolates. By contrast, direct streaking found 87% of the shigellae whereas GN detected 93%, but RE found only 20%. RE produced 35% more Salmonella-positive plates than GN did, which resulted in a 15% increase in isolates. Statistically, RE proved to be significantly better than GN. The unsuitability of RE for shigellae, however, dictates that, if only one enrichment broth is to be used, GN must be that choice, but that maximal isolations of all enteric pathogens should result from the use of both RE and GN. Of the four plating media, Xylose Lysine Deoxycholate Agar detected 90% of the salmonellae and 85% of the shigellae. Salmonella-Shigella Agar detected 72 and 43%, respectively, and Levine Eosin Methylene Blue Agar found 45 and 55%. Bismuth Sulfite Agar detected only 22% of the salmonellae and found no shigellae. The performance of all of the plating media was enhanced by enrichment, but RE was especially effective for salmonellae when compared to GN.     

Isolation of Shigellae. VII. Comparison of Gram-Negative Broth with Rappaport's Enrichment Broth

Efficacies of Gram Negative Broth (GN) and Rappaport''s Enrichment Broth (RE) were compared for detection of enteric pathogens from clinical specimens. Whereas direct streaking on four plating media found 57% of the salmonellae, GN found 80% and RE found 92% of the 157 isolates. By contrast, direct streaking found 87% of the shigellae whereas GN detected 93%, but RE found only 20%. RE produced 35% more Salmonella-positive plates than GN did, which resulted in a 15% increase in isolates. Statistically, RE proved to be significantly better than GN. The unsuitability of RE for shigellae, however, dictates that, if only one enrichment broth is to be used, GN must be that choice, but that maximal isolations of all enteric pathogens should result from the use of both RE and GN. Of the four plating media, Xylose Lysine Deoxycholate Agar detected 90% of the salmonellae and 85% of the shigellae. Salmonella-Shigella Agar detected 72 and 43%, respectively, and Levine Eosin Methylene Blue Agar found 45 and 55%. Bismuth Sulfite Agar detected only 22% of the salmonellae and found no shigellae. The performance of all of the plating media was enhanced by enrichment, but RE was especially effective for salmonellae when compared to GN.     

Isolation of Shigellae: VI. Performance of Media with Stool Specimens

The efficiencies of three enrichment broths and four plating media for isolation of enteric pathogens were compared from 1,117 stool specimens. Direct streaking proved to be inferior to enrichment, detecting only 50% of the salmonellae and 61% of the shigellae. By contrast, Selenite Broth (SF) found 90% of the total salmonellae isolates and 82% of the shigellae isolates. Gram-Negative Broth (GN) found 82% and 85%, respectively, but Tetrathionate found only 60% and 39%. Thus, SF and GN were comparable for both salmonellae and shigellae and significantly better than Tetrathionate Broth for both. The plating media compared were MacConkey (MAC), deoxycholate citrate (DC), xylose lysine deoxycholate (XLD), and xylose lysine Brilliant Green (XLBG) Agars. Of the total salmonellae isolated, XLD produced 94%; XLBG, 71%; MAC, 55%; and DC, only 35%. Of shigellae, XLD found 89%; MAC, 75%; XLBG, 63%; and DC, but 27%. The efficacy of XLD is observed to be almost threefold that of DC. The most successful combination of media for the detection of fecal pathogens was GN or SF enrichment broths streaked to XLD plates. These analyses resulted in the isolation of 118 strains of salmonellae and 33 of shigellae.     

Clinical Evaluation of Enteric Media in the Primary Isolation of Salmonella and Shigella

Over a 1-year period, media for the isolation of enteric pathogens were compared on 455 stool specimens. Fifty-three pathogens were isolated, of which 56% were Shigella sonnei and 13% were Sh. flexneri. Of these isolates, 90% were found on xylose-lysine-desoxycholate agar, 87% on Hekton enteric agar, and 80% on MacConkey without crystal violet with 2% agar and 0.007% neutral red, but only 28% were recovered on Salmonella-Shigella agar. Less than one-half of the shigellae were recovered after Selenite-F enrichment. On the other hand, enrichment was the most helpful method for isolating salmonellae. Studies on cultures from which mixed isolates were obtained indicated that numbers and chance distribution have an effect on the results obtained. The performance of Salmonella-Shigella agar in the isolation of enteric pathogens was inferior, and the effort involved to obtain those isolates was greater than for Hekton enteric and xylose-lysine-desoxycholate agars.     

Comparison of Media for Direct Isolation and Transport of Shigellae from Fecal Specimens

Xylose-lysine-deoxycholate (XLD) agar, SS agar, and MacConkey agar for isolating shigellae from fecal specimens were compared. XLD agar was superior to both SS agar and MacConkey agar for isolating Shigella sonnei, and both XLD and SS agar were superior to MacConkey agar for isolating S. flexneri. Direct plating of the fecal specimens in the field resulted in a greater yield of shigellae as compared to transporting specimens to the laboratory either in holding media or enrichment broth. Buffered glycerol saline was superior to other transport media evaluated, yielding 83% of shigella isolates when plated within 48 hr as compared to direct plating. The combination of XLD agar and SS agar is recommended for direct isolation of shigellae, and, whenever possible, these solid media should be taken to the bedside and inoculated directly.     

Comparison of Media for Isolation of Salmonellae and Shigellae from Fecal Specimens

Five transport media, eight plating media, and three enrichment broth media for the isolation of salmonellae and shigellae were evaluated. Eight laboratories in widely separated regions of the United States participated in this evaluation by submitting 490 fecal specimens in the transport media provided. The results suggest that the newer transport media may not offer any advantage over the use of buffered glycerol-saline in the isolation of these enteric pathogens. Shigellae were best isolated by direct inoculation, whereas salmonellae were isolated in greater numbers after tetrathionate (without Brilliant Green) enrichment with subsequent culturing on the plating medium. The use of a variety of plating media is recommended for the recovery of a larger number of these enteric pathogens.     

Isolation of Salmonellae and Shigellae from an Artificial Mixture of Fecal Bacteria

Numerous selective media, available commercially, act by suppressing "normal" bacterial inhabitants of the intestine while permitting the growth of so-called pathogenic representatives of the family Enterobacteriaceae. This investigation attempts to evaluate the action of Salmonella-Shigella (SS) agar, xylose lysine desoxycholate (XLD) agar, and hektoen enteric (HE) agar. Salmonellae and shigellae, isolated from clinical material, were mixed in various ratios with escherichiae, Klebsiella-Enterobacter-Serratia group bacteria, and members of the tribe Proteeae, also of clinical origin. Several of the mixtures were plated in multiple dilutions on the three media. Stools in preservative were also used for evaluation of the media after the addition of definite numbers of the pathogenic bacteria. Results indicate that SS agar suppresses the shigellae along with the autochthonous members of Enterobacteriaceae. XLD and HE agars readily permit the recovery of shigellae as well as salmonellae. This recovery is not obscured by the higher yield of other species obtained with these media.     

Comparison of Brilliant Green Agar and Hektoen Enteric Agar Media in the Isolation of Salmonellae from Food Products

Brilliant Green (BG) agar and Hektoen enteric (HE) agar media were compared for their efficiency in isolating salmonellae from various food products. Of the 11,226 food specimens examined, 1,662 (or 14.9%) yielded salmonellae. Of this number, 1,475 (88.7%) were recovered from BG agar and 1,315 (79.1%) were recovered from HE agar media. The results indicate that BG agar is more effective in isolating salmonellae from food products. A smaller subsidiary study showed HE agar to be more selective than BG agar. Four hundred ten specimens yielded 92 nonlactose-fermenting isolants other than salmonellae on BG agar and only 11 such isolants on HE agar.     

Comparison of Four Agar Plating Media with and Without Added Novobiocin for Isolation of Salmonellae from Beef and Deboned Poultry Meat

Four plating media, Hektoen enteric (HE), xylose-lysine deoxycholate (XLD), tryptic soy-xylose-lysine (TSXL), and tryptic soy-brillant green (TSBG) agars with and without 10 mg of added novobiocin per ml, were evaluated for recovery of Salmonella from roast beef and deboned turkey. Colonies producing a reaction typical of H₂S-positive salmonellae (alkaline with black centers) were picked. On the media without novobiocin, from 109 determinations on 75 samples, number of salmonellae found and false-positives were, respectively: HE—13, 58; XLD—17, 18; TSXL—23, 0; TSBG—22, 7. When novobiocin was present the corresponding results were: HE—17, 24; XLD—21, 2; TSXL—23, 3; TSBG—20, 7. A total of 25 determinations were positive on one or more agars. False-positives on HE and XLD without novobiocin were predominantly Proteus, which were almost totally eliminated by addition of 10 mg of novobiocin per liter. If alkaline H₂S-negative colonies had been considered, many more false-positives would have been found on HE and XLD but not on TSBG or TSXL. Addition of novobiocin markedly improved isolations of salmonellae from XLD and HE and reduced the number of false-positives. Addition of novobiocin did not improve performance of TSXL and slightly impaired differentiation of salmonellae from Citrobacter on TSBG. XLD with novobiocin and TSXL are highly specific for H₂S-positive salmonellae, and the appearance of Salmonella-like colonies on these media can be considered a presumptive test for H₂S-positive salmonellae.     

A System for Detecting Salmonellae in Meat and Meat Products

Leifson's selenite F broth was more selective for salmonellae when incubated at 43° instead of the traditional 37°. Different selective agar media produced different numbers of colonies from similar inocula of salmonella cells, but Difco brilliant green agar consistently gave the highest recoveries when tested in this way. Combined with 43° selenite broth enrichment it provided a useful system for isolating salmonellae from foods. In a short comparative test this system compared favourably with more classical techniques employing enrichment of each sample at 37° in two different enrichment broths, followed by streaking on two selective agars.     

A New Plating Medium for the Isolation of Enteric Pathogens: I. Hektoen Enteric Agar

A new agar plating medium for the isolation of enteric pathogens is described. This medium contains greater quantities of peptone to offset the inhibitory effects of bile salts. Additional carbohydrates and larger quantities of those previously used have also been incorporated into the medium to differentiate pathogens from some of the slow lactose fermenters. The use of an indicator system never used before in a differential plating medium opens new possibilities for improvement over traditional and newer selective media. Known strains from the various genera of Enterobacteriaceae have been tested for colonial differentiation as well as for possible inhibitory effects. The results show the medium to be highly selective for the shigellae as well as for other enteric pathogens.     

Comparison of four agar plating media with and without added novobiocin for isolation of salmonellae from beef and deboned poultry meat

Four plating media, Hektoen enteric (HE), xylose-lysine deoxycholate (XLD), tryptic soy-xylose-lysine (TSXL), and tryptic soy-brillant green (TSBG) agars with and without 10 mg of added novobiocin per ml, were evaluated for recovery of Salmonella from roast beef and deboned turkey. Colonies producing a reaction typical of H(2)S-positive salmonellae (alkaline with black centers) were picked. On the media without novobiocin, from 109 determinations on 75 samples, number of salmonellae found and false-positives were, respectively: HE-13, 58; XLD-17, 18; TSXL-23, 0; TSBG-22, 7. When novobiocin was present the corresponding results were: HE-17, 24; XLD-21, 2; TSXL-23, 3; TSBG-20, 7. A total of 25 determinations were positive on one or more agars. False-positives on HE and XLD without novobiocin were predominantly Proteus, which were almost totally eliminated by addition of 10 mg of novobiocin per liter. If alkaline H(2)S-negative colonies had been considered, many more false-positives would have been found on HE and XLD but not on TSBG or TSXL. Addition of novobiocin markedly improved isolations of salmonellae from XLD and HE and reduced the number of false-positives. Addition of novobiocin did not improve performance of TSXL and slightly impaired differentiation of salmonellae from Citrobacter on TSBG. XLD with novobiocin and TSXL are highly specific for H(2)S-positive salmonellae, and the appearance of Salmonella-like colonies on these media can be considered a presumptive test for H(2)S-positive salmonellae.     

Isolation of Salmonellae from Foods Samples: V. Determination of the Method of Choice for Enumeration of Salmonella

Comparison of three methods by which salmonellae may be isolated and enumerated from dried albumen, direct inoculation of enrichment media, centrifugation of samples, and pre-enrichment in noninhibitory media, reveals pre-enrichment to be the method of choice.

The superiority of pre-enrichment manifests itself in replicate aliquots of the same sample by producing a statistically significant increase in numbers of isolations of salmonellae and in empirical use with various albumen samples by consistently higher values of most probable numbers (MPN).

The primary factor involved in this superiority appears to be the greater ability of small numbers of salmonellae to initiate growth in the nonselective mannitol purple sugar broth than in the inhibitory enrichment media.

The method of analysis recommended entails inoculation of mannitol broth pre-enrichment medium, transfer of 24-hr culture aliquots to tetrathionate broth, and streaking on brilliant green agar for isolation of salmonellae.

     

Effects of Varying Concentrations of Novobiocin Incorporated into Two Salmonella Plating Media on the Recovery of Four Enterobacteriaceae

Hydrogen sulfide-producing strains of salmonellae, Escherichia coli, Citrobacter freundii, and Proteus mirabilis were isolated from fresh pork sausage. All the strains produced black-centered colonies on Hektoen enteric agar (HE). On xylose lysine deoxycholate agar (XLD), C. freundii produced yellow colonies, and the strains of the other three genera formed black-centered colonies. The selectivity of HE and XLD for salmonellae was improved by the addition of novobiocin to both media. With increasing concentrations of novobiocin, the degree of growth inhibition for the four genera was less on HE than on XLD. Novobiocin concentrations of 80 μg/ml in HE and 5 μg/ml in XLD did not affect the growth or colonial morphology of salmonellae. When 80 μg of novobiocin per ml was incorporated into HE, P. mirabilis strains were not recovered, 40% of C. freundii strains failed to form black-centered colonies, and growth of E. coli strains was not affected but colonies were altered without eliminating the black centers. When novobiocin at 5 μg/ml was incorporated into XLD, colonies of P. mirabilis strains were not recovered, C. freundii formed yellow colonies, and the colonies of the H₂S-producing E. coli strains were unaffected.     

Comparative study on Salmonella isolation from sewage—contaminated natural waters

A lcaide , E., M artinez , J.P. & G aray , E. 1984. Comparative study on Salmonella isolation from sewage contaminated natural waters. Journal of Applied Bacteriology 56 , 365–371.
A comparative study of five factors influencing the isolation of salmonellas from sewage-contaminated natural waters was carried out. The effect of pre-enrichment in buffered peptone water was compared with single-step enrichment in NR10 broth incubated at 43C. A modification of NR10 has been compared with the original composition. Bismuth sulphite agar (BSA), Hektoen enteric agar (HE) and brilliant green agar (BGA) have been used as plating media. Other factors considered have been temperature of the water and sampling site. A total of 759 salmonella strains belonging to 36 different serotypes has been recovered in a two-year study. All five factors considered in the study have shown a significant effect on the recovery of salmonellas. The combination of direct enrichment in NR10, followed by BSA or HE as plating media was most effective for the isolation of Salmonella . The influence of water temperature and characteristics of the sampling sites have also been discussed.     

Lysine-Iron Agar in the Detection of Arizona Cultures

A lysine-iron agar is described and recommended for the detection of Arizona strains which ferment lactose rapidly. Black colonies which appear on bismuth sulfite agar should be transferred to the medium. Salmonellae and Arizona cultures produce a distinctive reaction since they are the only recognized groups of enteric bacteria which regularly produce lysine decarboxylase rapidly and form large amounts of hydrogen sulfide. Use of the medium is particularly recommended in the examination of specimens from enteric infections in which shigellae and salmonellae are not detected.     

Optimising recovery of Campylobacter spp. from the lower porcine gastrointestinal tract

To determine the incidence of campylobacters in Northern Ireland pigs, ileal contents and anal swabs were taken shortly after death. Direct streaking onto Preston agar, and modified charcoal cefoperazone desoxycholate agar (mCCDA), were compared, as was enrichment in selective broths prior to streaking onto the corresponding solid medium. For anal swabs direct plating on mCCDA was most efficient, with 100% of samples positive, whilst for ileal contents enrichment in mCCD broth was best with 86% of samples positive. Although only 34% of ileal samples enriched in Preston broths were positive they yielded three species not isolated from mCCD broth, and hence indicated that some pigs were infected by at least two species of Campylobacter. Overall, the number of samples found to contain campylobacters, and the range of species isolated, was seen to be markedly affected by both the choice of selective medium and the isolation procedures.     

Lysine mannitol glycerol agar (LMG) and LMG with sulphamandelate for isolation of Salmonella spp. from clinical specimens

Lysine mannitol glycerol agar (LMG) was compared to xylose lysine deoxycholate agar (XLD), bismuth sulphite agar (BS), and Salmonella-Shigella agar (SS) for the ability to detect Salmonella spp. in clinical specimens, primarily faeces samples. During an 8-month period, 15 salmonellae were isolated from 940 faeces on LMG, while 14 strains were obtained on XLD, 11 on SS and only 3 strains on BS. Salmonella typhi was recovered from two blood cultures in 24 h on LMG, compared to 48 h on BS. LMG was augmented by addition of a sulphacetamide/mandelic acid (sulphamandelate) selective supplement (LMGS). During a 20-month period, 43 salmonellae were isolated from 2622 faeces on LMG and LMGS. The selectivity of LMGS was superior to that of LMG with no decrease in sensitivity of detection; all salmonellae isolated on LMG were isolated on LMGS. Both LMG and LMGS were suitable for routine use in the isolation of Salmonella spp. from clinical specimens.