Apocytochrome c induces pH-dependent vesicle fusion

The ability of apocytochrome c and the heme containing respiratory chain component, cytochrome c, to induce fusion of phosphatidylcholine (PC) small unilamellar vesicles containing 0-50 mol % negatively charged lipids was examined. Both molecules mediated fusion of phosphatidylserine (PS):PC 1:1 vesicles as measured by energy transfer changes between fluorescent lipid probes in a concentration- and pH-dependent manner, although cytochrome c was less potent and interacted over a more limited pH range than the apocytochrome c. Maximal fusion occurred at pH 3, far below the pKa of the 19 lysine groups contained in the protein (pI = 10.5). A similar pH dependence was observed for vesicles containing 50 mol % cardiolipin (CL), phosphatidylglycerol (PG), and phosphatidylinositol (PI) in PC but the apparent pKa values varied somewhat. In the absence of vesicles, the secondary structure of apocytochrome c was unchanged over this pH range, but in the presence of negatively charged vesicles, the polypeptide underwent a marked conformational change from random coil to alpha-helix. By comparing the pH dependencies of fusion induced by poly-L-lysine and apocytochrome c, we concluded that the pH dependence derived from changes in the net charge on both the vesicles and apocytochrome c. Aggregation could occur under conditions where fusion was imperceptible. Fusion increased with increasing mole ratio of PS. Apocytochrome c did induce some fusion of vesicles composed only of PC with a maximum effect at pH 4. Biosynthesis of cytochrome c involves translocation of apocytochrome c from the cytosol across the outer mitochondrial membrane to the outer mitochondrial space where the heme group is attached. The ability of apocytochrome c to induce fusion of both PS-containing and PC-only vesicles may reflect characteristics of protein/membrane interaction that pertain to its biological translocation.     

Amphitropic proteins: regulation by reversible membrane interactions (Review)

The ability of apocytochrome c and the heme containing respiratory chain component, cytochrome c, to induce fusion of phosphatidylcholine (PC) small unilamellar vesicles containing 0–50 mol% negatively charged lipids was examined. Both molecules mediated fusion of phosphatidylserine (PS):PC 1:1 vesicles as measured by energy transfer changes between fluorescent lipid probes in a concentration- and pH-dependent manner, although cytochrome c was less potent and interacted over a more limited pH range than the apocytochrome c. Maximal fusion occurred at pH 3, far below the pK_a of the 19 lysine groups contained in the protein (pl = 10.5). A similar pH dependence was observed for vesicles containing 50 mol% cardiolipin (CL), phosphatidylglycerol (PG), and phosphatidylinositol (PI) in PC but the apparent pK_a values varied somewhat. In the absence of vesicles, the secondary structure of apocytochrome c was unchanged over this pH range, but in the presence of negatively charged vesicles, the polypeptide underwent a marked conformational change from random coil to α-helix. By comparing the pH dependencies of fusion induced by poly-L-lysine and apocytochrome c, we concluded that the pH dependence derived from changes in the net charge on both the vesicles and apocytochrome c. Aggregation could occur under conditions where fusion was imperceptible. Fusion increased with increasing mole ratio of PS. Apocytochrome c did induce some fusion of vesicles composed only of PC with a maximum effect at pH 4. Biosynthesis of cytochrome c involves translocation of apocytochrome c from the cytosol across the outer mitochondrial membrane to the outer mitochondrial space where the heme group is attached. The ability of apocytochrome c to induce fusion of both PS-containing and PC-only vesicles may reflect characteristics of protein/membrane interaction that pertain to its biological translocation.     

The interaction of Sendai virus with negatively charged liposomes: virus-induced lysis of carboxyfluorescein-loaded small unilamellar vesicles

The interaction of Sendai virus with small, unilamellar vesicles, lacking virus receptors and loaded with self-quenched 6-carboxyfluorescein, was studied. Sendai virions induced release of carboxyfluorescein from vesicles composed of negative charged phospholipids, despite the fact that they did not contain virus receptors. Preliminary experiments indicate that the carboxyfluorescein release is accompanied by mixing of the virus and liposome lipids and their entrapped contents, suggesting liposome-virus fusion. No release of carboxyfluorescein was observed with vesicles containing only phosphatidylcholine. The rate of virus-induced carboxyfluorescein release was temperature dependent; the lytic activity of the virus was greatly enhanced above 25 degrees C. This effect was not due to a thermal phase transition of the lipids in either the lipid vesicles or the virions. Virus-induced carboxyfluorescein release was inhibited by the presence of calcium ions in the medium and of cholesterol in the lipid vesicles. It increased with increasing concentrations of either the lipid vesicles or the virions. pretreatment of virions with increasing concentrations of three different proteolytic enzymes (trypsin, chymotrypsin and proteinase) inhibited the virus' ability to cause release of carboxyfluorescein from negatively charged liposomes. Inhibition of the viral lytic activity was also observed after virions were incubated above 56 degrees C.     

Studies on the lipid dependency and mechanism of the translocation of the mitochondrial precursor protein apocytochrome c across model membranes

The lipid dependency of apocytochrome c binding to model membranes and of the translocation of the precursor protein across these membranes was studied by using large unilamellar, trypsin-containing vesicles. These vesicles were improved with respect to those used in a previous article (Rietveld, A., and de Kruijff, B. (1984) J. Biol. Chem. 259, 6704-6706), in the sense that a lower amount of trypsin was enclosed. In mixed egg phosphatidylcholine/bovine brain phosphatidylserine vesicles, both the Kd of apocytochrome c binding (about 20 microM) and the number of phosphatidylserine molecules interacting with the protein was found to be constant. When the phosphatidylserine fraction in the vesicles is more than 15-30% apocytochrome c addition results in the exposure of (a part of) the protein to the internal, trypsin-containing vesicle medium, which process we conceive as a translocation event. Also the interaction of apocytochrome c with vesicles composed of phosphatidylcholine and another acidic phospholipid in a 1:1 ratio, leads to the translocation of the protein across the model membrane. The affinity of this binding was found to be in the order cardiolipin greater than phosphatidylglycerol greater than phosphatidylinositol greater than phosphatidylserine. By varying the lipid composition of the vesicles, it could be demonstrated that the translocation requires a fluid bilayer. In addition, protein specificity was shown for the translocation process. Although apocytochrome c-lipid interaction causes vesicle aggregation, fusion by lipid mixing could not be detected. Due to the apocytochrome c-lipid interaction also, protein aggregates and oligomers have been formed. These results will be discussed in the light of a model for translocation of a precursor protein across a model membrane. The relevance for the mitochondrial system will also be discussed.     

Interaction and fusion of unilamellar vesicles containing cerebrosides and sulfatides induced by myelin basic protein

The effects of myelin basic protein on the aggregation, lipid bilayer merging, intercommunication of aqueous compartments and leakage of small unilamellar vesicles of egg phosphatidylcholine containing different proportions of galactocerebroside and sulfatide were investigated. This was performed employing light scattering, absorbance changes and fluorescence assays (resonance energy transfer, Terbium/dipicolinic acid assay and carboxyfluorescein release). The apposition of membranes rapidly induced by myelin basic protein is enhanced by sulfatide but reduced by galactocerebroside compared to vesicles of egg phosphatidylcholine alone. On the other hand, the presence of either glycosphingolipid in the membrane interferes with the induction by myelin basic protein of lipid bilayer merging, subsequent fusion and changes of the membrane permeability. Our results support an important modulation by sulfatide and galactocerebroside on the interactions among membranes induced by myelin basic protein, depending on the relative proportions of the glycosphingolipids and phosphatidylcholine.     

Fluorescence analysis of size distribution and mode of dye release from carboxyfluorescein-loaded vesicles: application to the study of complement-membrane interactions

We wish to report a novel method for visualizing large unilamellar vesicles loaded with a fluorescent dye and for monitoring changes in the size distribution as well as state of aggregation of such dye-loaded liposomes. In addition, we demonstrate that this method can be used to distinguish between all-or-none release of dye and graded release of dye from individual vesicles. Using this technique, we have characterized complement-mediated release of carboxyfluorescein from large unilamellar vesicles and have found that C5-8 complexes mediate a graded release of dye while C5-9 complexes cause an all-or-none release. Furthermore, complement appears to preferentially attack the medium to larger-sized vesicles in our population of large unilamellar vesicles while smaller vesicles appear to be selectively spared.     

Specificity of the interaction of amino- and carboxy-terminal fragments of the mitochondrial precursor protein apocytochrome c with negatively charged phospholipids. A spin-label electron spin resonance study

The contribution of the various regions of the mitochondrial precursor protein apocytochrome c to the interaction of the protein with phosphatidylserine dispersions has been studied with chemically and enzymatically prepared fragments of horse heart apocytochrome c and phospholipids spin-labeled at different positions of the sn-2 chain. Three amino-terminal heme-less peptides, two heme-containing amino-terminal fragments, one central fragment, and three carboxy-terminal fragments were studied. The electron spin resonance spectra of phospholipids spin-labeled at the C5 position of the fatty acid chain indicate that both amino-terminal and carboxy-terminal fragments of the apocytochrome c molecule cause a restriction of motion of the lipids, whereas the heme-containing peptides and protein have less effect. In addition, a second motionally more restricted lipid component, which is observed for apocytochrome c interacting with phosphatidylserine dispersions containing lipids spin-labeled at the C12 or C14 position [G?rrissen, H., Marsh, D., Rietveld, A., & de Kruijff, B. (1986) Biochemistry 25, 2904-2910], was observed both on binding the carboxy-terminal fragments and on binding of the amino-terminal fragments of the precursor protein. Interestingly, even a small water-soluble peptide consisting of the 24 carboxy-terminal residues gave rise to a two-component spectrum, with an outer hyperfine splitting of the restricted lipid component of 59 G, indicating a considerable restriction of the chain motion. This suggests that both the carboxy- and amino-terminal parts of the protein penetrate into the center of the bilayer and cause a strong perturbation of the fatty acyl chain motion. The implications of these findings for the mechanism of apocytochrome c translocation across membranes are discussed.     

Effect of triorganotin compounds on membrane permeability

Organotin compounds are widely distributed toxicants. They are membrane-active molecules with broad biological toxicity. In this contribution, we study the effect of triorganotin compounds on membrane permeability using phospholipid model membranes and human erythrocytes. Tribultyltin and triphenyltin are able to induce the release of entrapped carboxyfluorescein from large unilamellar vesicles. The rate of release is similar for phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylserine systems and the presence of equimolar cholesterol decreases the rate of the process. Release of carboxyfluorescein is almost abolished when a non-diffusible anion like gluconate is present in the external medium, and it is restored by addition of chloride. Tributyltin is able to cause hemolysis of human erythrocytes in a dose-dependent manner. Relative kinetics determination shows that potassium leakage occurs simultaneously with hemoglobin release. Hemolysis is reduced when erythrocytes are suspended in a gluconate medium. These results indicate that triorganotin compounds are able to transport organic anions like carboxyfluorescein across phospholipids bilayers by exchange diffusion with chloride and suggest that anion exchange through erythrocyte membrane could be related to the process of hemolysis.     

Is the mitochondrial precursor protein apocytochrome c able to pass a lipid barrier?

To obtain insight into the role of lipids in the translocation of extramitochondrially synthesized proteins, we studied the ability of apocytochrome c to pass lipid bilayers. With polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, the digestion of externally added apocytochrome c by trypsin, enclosed in lipid vesicles, was followed. The experiments demonstrate that apocytochrome c is able to pass a lipid barrier and this process shows both a lipid- and protein specificity. The most probable molecular mechanisms involved in this phenomenon are discussed.     

Preferential lipid association and mode of penetration of apocytochrome c in mixed model membranes as monitored by tryptophanyl fluorescence quenching using brominated phospholipids

The fluorescence of the single tryptophan residue at position 59 in apocytochrome c, the biosynthetic precursor of the inner mitochondrial membrane protein cytochrome c, was studied in small unilamellar vesicles composed of phosphatidylserine (PS) and phosphatidylcholine (PC) with or without specifically Br-labelled acyl chains at the sn-2 position. The protein has a very high affinity for PS-containing vesicles (dissociation constant Kd less than 1 microM). From the relative quenching efficiency by the brominated phospholipids, it could be concluded that the protein specifically associates with the PS component in mixed vesicles and that maximal quenching occurred with phospholipids in which the bromine was present at the 6,7-position of the 2-acyl chain suggesting that (part of) the bound protein penetrates 7-8 A deep into the hydrophobic core of the bilayer.     

Differential interactions of apo- and holocytochrome c with acidic membrane lipids in model systems and the implications for their import into mitochondria

Monomolecular layers of lipid extracts of microsomal, mitochondrial outer and inner membranes, and pure lipid species have been used to measure their interaction with apo- and holocytochrome c. Large differences were observed both with respect to the nature and the lipid specificity of the interaction. The initial electrostatic interaction of the hemefree precursor apocytochrome c with anionic phospholipids is followed by penetration of the protein in between the acyl chains. Apocytochrome c shows similar interactions for all anionic lipids tested. In strong contrast the holoprotein discriminates enormously between cardiolipin for which it has a high affinity and phosphatidylserine and phosphatidylinositol for which it has a much lower affinity. For these latter lipids the interaction with cytochrome c is primarily electrostatic. The cytochrome c-cardiolipin interaction shows several unique features which suggest the formation of a specific complex between the two molecules. These properties account for the preference in interaction of the apoprotein with the lipid extract of the outer mitochondrial membrane over that of the endoplasmic reticulum and the large preference of cytochrome c for the inner over that of the outer mitochondrial membrane lipid extract. Only apocytochrome c was able to induce close contacts between monolayers of the mitochondrial outer membrane lipids and vesicles of mitochondrial inner membrane lipids. Experiments with fragments of both protein and unfolding experiments with cytochrome c revealed that the differences in interaction between the two proteins are mainly due to differences in their tertiary structure and not the presence of the heme group itself. The initial unfolded structure of apocytochrome c is responsible for the high penetrative power of the protein and its ability to induce close membrane contact, whereas the folded structure of cytochrome c is responsible for the specific interaction with cardiolipin. The results are discussed in the light of the apocytochrome c import process in mitochondria and suggest that lipid-protein interactions contribute to targeting the precursor toward mitochondria and are important for its translocation across the outer mitochondrial membrane and the final localization of cytochrome c toward the outside of the inner mitochondrial membrane.     

Topography of the C terminus of cytochrome b5 tightly bound to dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine vesicles

Cytochrome b5 holoenzyme was bound asymmetrically in the tightly bound form to small unilamellar dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine vesicles. [3H]Taurine, a membrane-impermeant nucleophile, was added to the external medium and was then cross-linked to cytochrome carboxyl residues by the addition of a water-soluble carbodiimide. Nonpolar peptide was isolated after trypsin digestion of taurine-labeled apocytochrome b5 and contained 1.7-1.9 residues of taurine. The C-terminal tetrapeptide containing residues Thr130-Asn133 was generated by chymotryptic hydrolysis of radiolabeled nonpolar peptide and was purified by gel filtration and ion exchange chromatography. Amino acid analysis of the C-terminal tetrapeptide showed that about 1.6 mol of taurine was cross-linked per mol of peptide. When the experiment was performed with taurine trapped inside the vesicles, no cross-linking was observed. The results suggest that when cytochrome b5 holoenzyme is bound to vesicles in the tight binding form, the C terminus is located on the external surface of the vesicles.     

On the size-dependent disintegration of small unilamellar phosphatidylcholine vesicles in rat plasma. Evidence of complete loss of vesicle structure.

The destruction of small unilamellar egg phosphatidylcholine vesicles in rat plasma was monitored by measuring release of encapsulated 125I-poly(vinylpyrrolidone) or carboxyfluorescein and by determining transfer of radiolabelled phosphatidylcholine to plasma lipoproteins by means of gel filtration. The susceptibility of the vesicles to the destructive action of plasma increased with decreasing vesicle size, as observed by incubating plasma with individual fractions constituting the small-vesicle peak on Sepharose CL-2B. This results in selective destruction of small vesicles when heterogeneous vesicle populations are incubated with plasma. Samples of homogeneous vesicle populations were incubated with a wide range of plasma concentrations, which resulted in extents of solute and phospholipid release ranging from 10 to 90%. When the extents of solute release were plotted against the extents of lipid release a linear, virtually 1:1, relationship was found, for both carboxyfluorescein and poly(vinylpyrrolidone) as the solute. This suggests that the release of solutes from small unilamellar phosphatidylcholine vesicles as a result of their interaction with plasma (lipo)proteins involves the total destruction of a fraction of the vesicles, the magnitude of which is determined by the vesicle: plasma ratio. Our results argue against a previously presented view suggesting that the interaction between such vesicles and plasma results in the formation of pores through which encapsulated solutes diffuse at Mr-dependent rates [Kirby & Gregoriadis (1981) Biochem. J. 199, 251-254]. The discrepancies between the two studies in observations as well as in interpretation are discussed.     

The Zeamine Antibiotics Affect the Integrity of Bacterial Membranes

The zeamines (zeamine, zeamine I, and zeamine II) constitute an unusual class of cationic polyamine-polyketide-nonribosomal peptide antibiotics produced by Serratia plymuthica RVH1. They exhibit potent bactericidal activity, killing a broad range of Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria, including multidrug-resistant pathogens. Examination of their specific mode of action and molecular target revealed that the zeamines affect the integrity of cell membranes. The zeamines provoke rapid release of carboxyfluorescein from unilamellar vesicles with different phospholipid compositions, demonstrating that they can interact directly with the lipid bilayer in the absence of a specific target. DNA, RNA, fatty acid, and protein biosynthetic processes ceased simultaneously at subinhibitory levels of the antibiotics, presumably as a direct consequence of membrane disruption. The zeamine antibiotics also facilitated the uptake of small molecules, such as 1-N-phenylnaphtylamine, indicating their ability to permeabilize the Gram-negative outer membrane (OM). The valine-linked polyketide moiety present in zeamine and zeamine I was found to increase the efficiency of this process. In contrast, translocation of the large hydrophilic fluorescent peptidoglycan binding protein PBD_KZ-GFP was not facilitated, suggesting that the zeamines cause subtle perturbation of the OM rather than drastic alterations or defined pore formation. At zeamine concentrations above those required for growth inhibition, membrane lysis occurred as indicated by time-lapse microscopy. Together, these findings show that the bactericidal activity of the zeamines derives from generalized membrane permeabilization, which likely is initiated by electrostatic interactions with negatively charged membrane components.     

Thermodynamic parameters of the binding of retinol to binding proteins and to membranes

Retinol (vitamin A alcohol) is a hydrophobic compound and distributes in vivo mainly between binding proteins and cellular membranes. To better clarify the nature of the interactions of retinol with these phases which have a high affinity for it, the thermodynamic parameters of these interactions were studied. The temperature-dependence profiles of the binding of retinol to bovine retinol binding protein, bovine serum albumin, unilamellar vesicles of dioleoylphosphatidylcholine, and plasma membranes from rat liver were determined. It was found that binding of retinol to retinol binding protein is characterized by a large increase in entropy (T delta S degrees = +10.32 kcal/mol) and no change in enthalpy. Binding to albumin is driven by enthalpy (delta H degrees = -8.34 kcal/mol) and is accompanied by a decrease in entropy (T delta S degrees = -2.88 kcal/mol). Partitioning of retinal into unilamellar vesicles and into plasma membranes is stabilized both by enthalpic (delta H degrees was -3.3 and -5.5 kcal/mol, respectively) and by entropic (T delta S degrees was +4.44 and +2.91 kcal/mol, respectively) components. The implications of these finding are discussed.     

Interaction between corneocytes and stratum corneum lipid liposomes in vitro

Small unilamellar vesicles were made from a mixture of epidermal ceramides (45%), cholesterol (35%), free fatty acids (15%) and cholesteryl sulfate (5%). Isolated corneocytes prepared from pig epidermis were added to the liposomes and the interaction between corneocytes and liposomes was studied by (1) thin-section electron microscopy and (2) monitoring the release of aqueous contents of the vesicles by following the fluorescence intensity of carboxyfluorescein entrapped in the vesicles. The vesicles adsorbed readily onto the corneocytes and slowly transformed into lamellar sheets. Enhanced fluorescence intensity indicated a corneocyte-induced membrane fusion process that resulted in the release of aqueous contents of the vesicles. The results suggest a cohesive role for the corneocyte cell envelope, which consists of a monomolecular layer of lipids covalently bound to the outside of a cross-linked protein envelope. This may be one of the major factors in the reassembly of extruded membranous disks into lamellar sheets which occurs during the final stages of epidermal differentiation.     

Insertion of apocytochrome c into lipid vesicles

Apocytochrome c (cytochrome c without the heme) is synthesized in the cell cytoplasm without a cleaved signal sequence, then transported across the outer mitochondrial membrane. We have studied the interaction of apocytochrome c with lipid vesicles as a model for understanding protein translocation across membranes. Apocytochrome c (but not holocytochrome c) that has been incubated with vesicles at 37 degrees C in 0.2 M NaCl binds to the vesicles. Under these conditions, as well as upon incubation with detergent or at high protein concentrations, all the added protein remains partly accessible to externally added protease, but a COOH-terminal fragment of some of the protein molecules becomes protected against digestion. When apocytochrome c is added to azolectin vesicles with internally trapped proteases, most of the added protein can be digested, even in the presence of a large excess of protease inhibitor external to the vesicles. Thus, in spite of a lack of nonpolar stretches in its amino acid sequence, apocytochrome c is capable of binding to and inserting into lipid membranes. In this model system, transport may be driven by trapping of protease-digested apocytochrome c on one side of the membrane.     

Permeability studies on liposomes formed from polymerizable diacetylenic phospholipids and their potential applications as drug delivery systems

We have investigated the permeability and entrapment characteristics of liposomes formed from a group of polymerizable phospholipids, containing diacetylenic groups in one or both of their acyl chains. Permeability was assessed by the release of an entrapped dye, 6-carboxyfluorescein. Diacetylenic phosphatidylcholine (PC) liposomes were found to exhibit a wide range of permeability properties, depending on: the nature of the diacetylenic lipid, i.e. mixed-chain (mc) or identical-chain (id), the extent of polymerisation, vesicle size, and cholesterol content. Ultraviolet-initiated polymerisation affected a significant decrease in the permeability of C25idPC liposomes. The increase in permeability of liposomes formed from four other diacetylenic lipids (C25mcPC, C23idPC, C23mcPC and C20idPC) after polymerisation was attributed to disturbances in the packing of lipid molecules, and/or the limited ability of small unilamellar vesicles to accommodate long polymers. The C20idPC lipid is atypical, forming irregular monomeric and polymeric vesicles. The permeability of C25idPC liposomes was also assessed by the release of [3H]inulin. C25idPC liposomes exhibited low permeabilities to [3H]inulin in their monomeric and polymeric states. Incubation of C25idPC liposomes in human plasma caused a substantial increase in the permeability of monomeric vesicles to both carboxyfluorescein and [3H]inulin. The permeability of polymerised C25idPC liposomes, however, was unaffected in the presence of plasma, with vesicles retaining most of their entrapped [3H]inulin after 50 h. These findings demonstrate that polymeric C25idPC liposomes exhibit high resistance to the destructive actions of plasma components, such as high-density lipoproteins (HDLs). Polymeric C25idPC liposomes may have an application in drug delivery systems.     

Structural studies on reconstituted reaction center-phosphatidylcholine membranes.

Reaction center protein, isolated from the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R26 mutant, was incorporated into phosphatidylcholine bilayers forming a homogeneous population of unilamellar vesicles. Cytochrome c, added to preformed reaction center-phosphatidylcholine vesicles, rapidly reduced up to 90% of the laser-generated (BChl)2+ of the reaction center (with kinetics of electron transfer similar to those in the chromatophore membrane) which suggests that the portion of the reaction center which accommodates functional cytochrome c binding sites is exposed predominantly on the exterior of the vesicles. Unit cell electron density profiles were derived from lamellar X-ray diffraction from oriented reaction center-phosphatidylcholine membrane multilayers at varying lipid/protein ratios. The analysis of these profiles showed that the reaction center protein incorporates into the phosphatidylcholine membrane with unique sidedness and that the profile of the reaction center protein itself is asymmetric and spans the membrane.     

Proton currents and protein motion in membranes

A specific interaction between purified liver transglutaminase and small unilamellar phospholipid vesicles at the lipid phase transition have been revealed. The enzyme-induced perturbation of the bilayer is sufficient for phase transition release of encapsulated carboxyfluorescein from the vesicles. The size of the enzyme-phospholipid recombinants depends upon the protein-phospholipid ratio as shown on Sepharose 4B elution profile. The activity of transglutaminase inserted into the bilayer is greatly reduced. The interaction does not occur when the phospholipid vesicle are in the solid or liquid phase and it requires the structural integrity of the enzyme.