Alternative selectable markers for potato transformation using minimal T-DNA vectors

Alternative selection systems for plant transformation are especially valuable in clonal crops, such as potato (Solanum tuberosum L.), to pyramid transgenes into the same cultivar by successive transformation events. We have modified the pGPTV series of binary vectors to construct pMOA1 to pMOA5, resulting in a series of essentially identical binary vectors except for the presence of different selectable marker genes. These selectable marker genes are tightly inserted between the left and right T-DNA borders and confer resistance to kanamycin (nptII), hygromycin (hpt), methotrexate (dhfr), phosphinothricin (bar), or phleomycin (ble). The T-DNA of all the vectors is based on the minimal features necessary for plant transformation, with no extraneous DNA segments that may be unacceptable to regulatory authorities for general release of transgenic plants. A series of unique restriction sites exists between the right border and each selectable marker gene for subsequent insertion of useful genes. We have also developed improved culture procedures for potato transformation and used the pMOA1 to pMOA5 binary vectors to define stringent selection conditions for each marker gene. Combining these advances improved the frequency of recovering transformed potato plants while maintaining a low frequency of escapes. The relative efficiency of recovering transgenic potato lines with each selectable marker gene can be summarised as: kanamycin resistance>hygromycin resistance>phosphinothricin resistance>phleomycin resistance>methotrexate resistance.     

Developing phosphinothricin-resistant transgenic sunflower (Helianthus?annuus L.) plants

Most investigations on genetic transformations of sunflower have used the neomycin transferase (nptII) gene as the selectable marker. We previously reported a PPT-based selection system for sunflower transformation that uses the bialaphos resistance (bar) gene as the selectable marker and 20 mg/l of phosphinothricin (PPT) as the selective agent. Sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) variety Skorospeliy 87 was genetically transformed via Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain EHA 105 harbouring the binary plasmid vector pBAR. Two-day-old explants from mature embryos competent for direct shooting were used. Southern blot and ELISA experiments confirmed the stability of expression in two generations of transgenic plants. Transformed plants transferred to soil in the greenhouse exhibited resistance to the herbicide Basta^? at 3 l/ha.     

Efficient Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of Arabidopsis thaliana using the bar gene as selectable marker

Summary We have established an efficient Agrobacterium-mediated transformation procedure for Arabidopsis thaliana genotype C24 using the chimeric bialaphos resistance gene (bar) coding for phosphinothricin acetyltransferase (PAT). Hypocotyl explants from young seedlings cocultivated with agrobacteria carrying a bar gene were selected on shoot-inducing media containing different concentrations of phosphinothricin (PPT) which is an active component of bialaphos. We found that 20 mg/l of PPT completely inhibited the control explants from growing whereas the explants transformed with the bar gene gave rise to multiple shoots resistant to PPT after 3 weeks under the same selection conditions. The transformation system could also be applied to root explants. Resulting plantlets could produce viable seeds in vitro within 3 months after preparation of the explants. The stable inheritance of the resistance trait, the integration and expression of the bar gene in the progeny were confirmed by genetic tests, Southern analysis and PAT enzyme assay, respectively. In addition, the mature plants in soil showed tolerance to the herbicide Basta.Abbreviations bar bialaphos resistance gene - CIM callus-inducing medium - DTNB 5,5-dithiobis(2-nitrobenzoic acid) - GM germination medium - HPT hygromycin phosphotransferase - MS Murashige and Skoog salts - NPTII neomycin phosphotransferase II - PAT phosphinothricin acetyltransferase - PPT phosphinothricin - SIM shoot-inducing medium     

Strategies for developing marker-free transgenic plants

The development of marker-free transgenic plants has responded to public concerns over the safety of biotechnology crops. It seems that continued work in this area will soon remove the question of unwanted marker genes from the debate concerning the public acceptability of transgenic crop plants. Selectable marker genes are co-introduced with genes of interest to identify those cells that have integrated the DNA into their genome. Despite the large number of different selection systems, marker genes that confer resistance to the antibiotics, hygromycin (hpt) and kanamycin (nptII) or herbicide phosphinothricin (bar), have been used in most transgenic research and crop development techniques. The techniques that remove marker gene are under development and will eventually facilitate more precise and subtle engineering of the plant genome, with widespread applications in both fundamental research and biotechnology. In addition to allaying public concerns, the absence of resistance genes in transgenic plants could reduce the costs of developing biotechnology crops and lessen the need for time-consuming safety evaluations, thereby speeding up the commercial production of biotechnology crops. Many research results and various techniques have been developed to produce marker-free transgenic plants. This review describes the strategies for eliminating selectable marker genes to generate marker-free transgenic plants, focusing on the three significant marker-free technologies, co-transformation, site-specific recombinase-mediated excision, and non-selected transformation.     

Characterization of the herbicide-resistance gene bar from Streptomyces hygroscopicus

A gene which confers resistance to the herbicide bialaphos (bar) has been characterized. The bar gene was originally cloned from Streptomyces hygroscopicus, an organism which produces the tripeptide bialaphos as a secondary metabolite. Bialaphos contains phosphinothricin, an analogue of glutamate which is an inhibitor of glutamine synthetase. The bar gene product was purified and shown to be a modifying enzyme which acetylates phosphinothricin or demethylphosphinothricin but not bialaphos or glutamate. The bar gene was subcloned and its nucleotide sequence was determined. Interspecific transfer of this Streptomyces gene into Escherichia coli showed that it could be used as a selectable marker in other bacteria. In the accompanying paper, bar has been used to engineer herbicide-resistant plants.     

Hygromycin resistance as an efficient selectable marker for wheat stable transformation

Summary A highly efficient method for stable wheat transformation using hygromycin resistance as a selectable marker is described. Young embryogenic calli growing from immature wheat embryos were transformed using a gunpowder-driven microparticle accelerator. Transgenic wheat plants were determined by PCR amplification of transgene fragments and confirmed by Southern hybridization, activity of the transgene expression and by analysis of the progeny. The hpt gene was as good as or a better selectable marker than the bar gene with an average efficiency (number of transgenic plants relative to the number of bombarded calli) of 5.5% compared with 2.6% for the bar gene.     

Bialaphos selection of stable transformants from maize cell culture

Summary Stable transformed Black Mexican Sweet (BMS) maize callus was recovered from suspension culture cells bombarded with plasmid DNA that conferred resistance to the herbicide bialaphos. Suspension culture cells were bombarded with a mixture of two plasmids. One plasmid contained a selectable marker gene, bar, which encoded phosphinothricin acetyl transferase (PAT), and the other plasmid encoded a screenable marker for -glucuronidase (GUS). Bombarded cells were selected on medium containing the herbicide bialaphos, which is cleaved in plant cells to yield phosphinothricin (PPT), an inhibitor of glutamine synthetase. The bialaphos-resistant callus contained the bar gene and expressed PAT as assayed by PPT inactivation. Transformants that expressed high levels of PAT grew more rapidly on increasing concentrations of bialaphos than transformants expressing low levels of PAT. Fifty percent of the bialaphos-resistant transformants tested (8 of 16) expressed the nonselected gene encoding GUS.     

Using green fluorescent protein sheds light on <Emphasis Type="Italic">Lupinus angustifolius</Emphasis> L. transgenic shoot development

Narrow-leaf lupin (NLL) is the main legume crop grown in rotation with wheat and other cereals in Western Australia. Efforts to improve NLL germplasm by use of genetic technologies have been hampered by the lack of an efficient genetic transformation method, an issue that is in common with dominant crop legumes globally. Prior research has primarily used the bar gene for phosphinothricin (PPT) resistance. The aim of recent research has been to investigate alternative selection methodologies, in order to determine whether the limitations of low frequency of transgenic shoots, combined with chimerism at T0 could be overcome. Investigation of hygromycin resistance as a selectable marker compared to PPT is reported here. The results suggested that hygromycin resistance was a more suitable selectable marker for NLL transformation than PPT. Surprisingly, from investigation of transformation using the GUS reporter gene, it was also observed that transformation frequency was greater when selection treatment was reduced or delayed, compared to the existing protocols. To further investigate this observation, an eGFP expressing construct was prepared. Observations within the first week after Agrobacterium exposure of lupin explants demonstrated that transformation of NLL explant cells was not a rate-limiting step. Instead, the results indicated that the current selection methodology was killing the cells that were competent to regenerate into transgenic shoots. It was concluded that further research on the development of the treated explants should focus on delayed selection and exposure to Agrobacterium of cells below the apical meristem.     

Establishment of neomycin phosphotransferase II (<Emphasis Type="Italic">nptII</Emphasis>) selection for transformation of soybean somatic embryogenic cultures

Soybean transformation is limited by the lack of multiple efficient selectable marker systems. Biolistic transformation of somatic proliferative embryogenic cultures, one of the commonly used soybean transformation methods, relies largely on hygromycin phosphotransferase II (hptII) selection. The purpose of the present study was to establish another efficient selectable marker system to facilitate multiple gene transformations of soybean. We tested neomycin phosphotransferase II (nptII) that has been used successfully in cotyledonary node transformation, but with limited success in transformation of embryogenic cultures. Transgenic events were obtained using nptII with improved G418 selection without generating escapes. G418 selection required longer recovery and selection periods, and resulted in a lower efficiency of initial transformants compared to hygromycin selection. Six independent fertile transgenic plants were recovered using nptII and G418, a frequency similar to that obtained with hygromycin selection. Soybean embryogenic cultures co-transformed with the hptII and nptII markers showed resistance to both hygromycin B and G418, while regeneration and plant fertility were not adversely affected. The nptII will be useful as a second selectable marker for multiple gene transformations in basic and applied soybean research.     

Engineering herbicide resistance in plants by expression of a detoxifying enzyme

Phosphinothricin (PPT) is a potent inhibitor of glutamine synthetase in plants and is used as a non-selective herbicide. The bar gene which confers resistance in Streptomyces hygroscopicus to bialaphos, a tripeptide containing PPT, encodes a phosphinothricin acetyltransferase (PAT) (see accompanying paper). The bar gene was placed under control of the 35S promoter of the cauliflower mosaic virus and transferred to plant cells using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. PAT was used as a selectable marker in protoplast co-cultivation. The chimeric bar gene was expressed in tobacco, potato and tomato plants. Transgenic plants showed complete resistance towards high doses of the commercial formulations of phosphinothricin and bialaphos. These data present a successful approach to obtain herbicide-resistant plants by detoxification of the herbicide.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">ptxD</Emphasis> gene in combination with phosphite serves as a highly effective selection system to generate transgenic cotton (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Gossypium hirsutum</Emphasis> L.)

Key message

This report demonstrates the usefulness of ptxD/phosphite as a selection system that not only provides a highly efficient and simple means to generate transgenic cotton plants, but also helps address many of the concerns related to the use of antibiotic and herbicide resistance genes in the production of transgenic crops.

Abstract

Two of the most popular dominant selectable marker systems for plant transformation are based on either antibiotic or herbicide resistance genes. Due to concerns regarding their safety and in order to stack multiple traits in a single plant, there is a need for alternative selectable marker genes. The ptxD gene, derived from Pseudomonas stutzeri WM88, that confers to cells the ability to convert phosphite (Phi) into orthophosphate (Pi) offers an alternative selectable marker gene as demonstrated for tobacco and maize. Here, we show that the ptxD gene in combination with a protocol based on selection medium containing Phi, as the sole source of phosphorus (P), can serve as an effective and efficient system to select for transformed cells and generate transgenic cotton plants. Fluorescence microscopy examination of the cultures under selection and molecular analyses on the regenerated plants demonstrate the efficacy of the system in recovering cotton transformants following Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Under the ptxD/Phi selection, an average of 3.43 transgenic events per 100 infected explants were recovered as opposed to only 0.41% recovery when bar/phosphinothricin (PPT) selection was used. The event recovery rates for nptII/kanamycin and hpt/hygromycin systems were 2.88 and 2.47%, respectively. Molecular analysis on regenerated events showed a selection efficiency of ~?97% under the ptxD/Phi system. Thus, ptxD/Phi has proven to be a very efficient, positive selection system for the generation of transgenic cotton plants with equal or higher transformation efficiencies compared to the commonly used, negative selection systems.

     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">Agrobacterium</Emphasis>-mediated transformation of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Cry1C,Cry2A</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Cry9C</Emphasis> genes into <Emphasis Type="Italic">Gossypium hirsutum</Emphasis> and plant regeneration

Three constructs harbouring novel Bacillus thuringiensis genes (Cry1C, Cry2A, Cry9C) and bar gene were transformed into four upland cotton cultivars, Ekangmian10, Emian22, Coker201 and YZ1 via Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. With the bar gene as a selectable marker, about 84.8 % of resistant calli have been confirmed positive by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) tests, and totally 50 transgenic plants were regenerated. The insertions were verified by means of Southern blotting. Bioassay showed 80 % of the transgenic plantlets generated resistance to both herbicide and insect. We optimized conditions for improving the transformation efficiency. A modified in vitro shoot-tip grafting technique was introduced to help entire transplantation. This result showed that bar gene can replace antibiotic marker genes (ex. npt II gene) used in cotton transformation.     

Transgenic fertile Scoparia dulcis L., a folk medicinal plant, conferred with a herbicide-resistant trait using an Ri binary vector

Summary Transgenic herbicide-resistant Scoparia dulcis plants were obtained by using an Ri binary vector system. The chimeric bar gene encoding phosphinothricin acetyltransferase flanked by the promoter for cauliflower mosaic virus 35S RNA and the terminal sequence for nopaline synthase was introduced in the plant genome by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation by means of scratching young plants. Hairy roots resistant to bialaphos were selected and plantlets (R0) were regenerated. Progenies (S1) were obtained by self-fertilization. The transgenic state was confirmed by DNA-blot hybridization and assaying of neomycin phosphotransferase II. Expression of the bar gene in the transgenic R0 and S1 progenies was indicated by the activity of phosphinothricin acetyltransferase. Transgenic plants accumulated scopadulcic acid B, a specific secondary metabolite of S. dulcis, in amounts of 15–60% compared with that in normal plants. The transgenic plants and progenies showed resistant trait towards bialaphos and phosphinothricin. These results suggest that an Ri binary system is one of the useful tools for the transformation of medicinal plants for which a regeneration protocol has not been established.Abbreviations CaMV cauliflower mosaic virus - NPT-II neomycin phosphotransferase - PAT phosphinothricin acetyltransferase - PPT phosphinothricin     

Expression of a cholera toxin B subunit in transgenic lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation system

To increase expression level of cholera toxin B subunit (CTB) in lettuce plants, synthetic CTB (sCTB) gene based on the optimized codon usage was fused with an endoplasmic reticulum retention signal, KDEL. The sCTB gene was introduced into a plant expression vector and transformed to lettuce plants using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation system. As a selection marker, a bialaphos resistance (bar) gene that encodes phosphinothricin acetyltransferase (PAT), conferring tolerance to the herbicide phosphinothricin (PPT), was used. PCR amplification of genomic DNA confirmed the presence of the sCTB gene in the transgenic lettuce plants. Expressions of mRNA and protein of sCTB were observed by Northern and Western blot analyses, respectively. The sCTB synthesized in the transgenic lettuce showed strong affinity for GM₁-ganglioside suggesting that the sCTB conserved the antigenic sites for binding and proper folding of pentameric CTB structure. The expression level of CTB was relatively high, reaching total soluble protein (TSP) levels of 0.24% in transgenic lettuce.     

Introduction and constitutive expression of a rice chitinase gene in bread wheat using biolistic bombardment and the bar gene as a selectable marker

 Our long-term goal is to control wheat diseases through the enhancement of host plant resistance. The constitutive expression of plant defense genes to control fungal diseases can be engineered by genetic transformation. Our experimental strategy was to biolistically transform wheat with a vector DNA containing a rice chitinase gene under the control of the CaMV 35 S promoter and the bar gene under control of the ubiquitin promoter as a selectable marker. Immature embryos of wheat cv ‘Bobwhite’ were bombarded with plasmid pAHG11 containing the rice chitinase gene chi11 and the bar gene. The embryos were subcultured on MS2 medium containing the herbicide bialaphos. Calli were then transferred to a regeneration medium, also containing bialaphos. Seventeen herbicide-resistant putative transformants (T₀) were selected after spraying with 0.2% Liberty, of which 16 showed bar gene expression as determined by the phosphinothricin acetyltransferase (PAT) assay. Of the 17 plants, 12 showed the expected 35-kDa rice chitinase as revealed by Western blot analysis. The majority of transgenic plants were morphologically normal and self-fertile. The integration, inheritance and expression of the chi11 and bar genes were confirmed by Southern hybridization, PAT and Western blot analysis of T₀ and T₁ transgenic plants. Mendelian segregation of herbicide resistance was observed in some T₁ progenies. Interestingly, a majority of the T₁ progeny had very little or no chitinase expression even though the chitinase transgene was intact. Because PAT gene expression under control of the ubiquitin promoter was unaffected, we conclude that the CaMV 35 S promoter is selectively inactivated in T₁ transgenic wheat plants. Received: 12 May 1998 / Accepted: 15 May 1998     

Herbicide resistant transgenic papaya plants produced by an efficient particle bombardment transformation method

A system for the production of transgenic papaya (Carica papaya L.) plants using zygotic embryos and embryogenic callus as target cells for particle bombardment is described. Phosphinothricin (bar ) and kanamycin (npt II) resistance genes were used as selectable markers, and the gus gene (uidA) as a reporter gene. Selection with 100 mg/l kanamycin and 4 mg/l phosphinothricin (PPT) yielded a total of over 90 resistant embryogenic colonies from three independent experiments using embryogenic callus as a target tissue. This represents an efficiency of 60 transgenic clones per gram of fresh weight callus bombarded. The efficiency of genetic transformation using zygotic embryos was lower, as only 8 independent resistant clones were recovered out of 645 bombarded zygotic embryos, giving a efficiency of 1.24%. Subsequent subculture of transgenic somatic embryos both from zygotic embryos and embryogenic callus led to the development of plants with apparently normal morphology. Histological, fluorimetric assay for GUS, NPT II assay and DNA analysis (Southern hybridization) showed that kanamycin /PPT resistant plants carried and expressed the transgenes.Abbreviations Gus -glucuronidase - NPTII neomycin phophotransferase II - bar phophinothricin acetyl transferase gene - Pat phosphinothricin acetyl transferase - PPT phosphinothricin - Km kanamycin - 2,4-D 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - K kinetin - BAP benzylaminopurine - IBA indolbutyric acid     

Green fluorescent protein as a visual selection marker for coffee transformation

The green fluorescent protein (GFP) was used as a visual selectable marker to produce transgenic coffee (Coffea canephora) plants following Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. The binary vector pBECKS 2000.7 containing synthetic gene for GFP (sgfp) S65T and the hygromycin phosphotransferase gene hph both controlled by 35S cauliflower mosaic virus CaMV35S promoters was used for transformation. Embryogenic cultures were initiated from hypocotyls and cotyledon leaves of in vitro grown seedlings and used as target material. Selection of transformed tissue was carried out using GFP visual selection as the sole screen or in combination with a low level of antibiotics (hygromycin 10 mg/L), and the efficiency was compared with antibiotics selection alone (hygromycin 30 mg/L). GFP selection reduced the time for transformed somatic embryos formation from 18 weeks on a hygromycin (30 mg/L) antibiotics containing medium to 8 weeks. Moreover, visual selection of GFP combined with low level of antibiotics selection improved the transformation efficiency and increased the number of transformed coffee plants compared to selection in the presence of antibiotics. Molecular analysis confirmed the presence of the sgfp-S65T coding region in the regenerated plants. Visual screening of transformed cells using GFP by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation techniques was found to be efficient and therefore has the potential for development of selectable marker-free transgenic coffee plants.